2. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
2
Outline
Soft/softer handover
– HO between cells using same UMTS carrier frequency
IRAT handover/cell change
– HO/cell changes between UMTS and GSM
Inter-frequency handover
– HO between different UMTS carrier frequencies
4. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
4
Concept of Soft/Softer Handover
Cell A
Cell B
Cell C
Single Link
The UE measured the CPICH Signal strenght (RSCP) and quality (Ec/No) to
determine which cell to add in the active set
Add and remove from active set is based on relative measurments
Softer handover
-two cells of same RBS in Active Set
Soft handover
-two cells of different RBS in Active Set
Soft/softer handover
-three cells in Active Set
5. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
5
Active set and monitored set
Combining the monitored set Active set (AS)
max 32 cells
Monitored set – the union of neighbours from all cells in the active set
Duplicate cells
are removed
6. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
6
cell A31
cell B31
cell C31
Detected cells
Monitored cell list truncation
If too many neighbours are
defined, the monitored set will
be truncated.
The truncated cells are not
measured by all UE
– Calls may be dropped
If UE reports unmonitored set
the RNC will use this
information for active set
update procedure
If undefined neighbour is
reported the RNC cannot take
action
max 32 cells
cellx
celly
cellz
Detected
cells
Truncated cells- ”unmonitored set”
Undefined neighbors
7. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
7
Safeguard against rogue UE
If a UE moves far into a
cell not belonging to the
active set it will be
released.
This situation may e.g.
occur due to
– truncation
– missing neighbour
relations
– congestion in target
cell
releaseConnOffset [12 dB]
best server
cell not in active set
Pilot Ec/No UE released
8. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
8
Benefit of soft handover
HHO: Excessive
interference prior
to handover
SHO: UE power
controlled by both
source and target
cell to avoid
excessive
interference.
Lowest required
power used.
power control:
power control: power control:
9. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
9
CN
Good block
Block in error
RNC selection
combining
RBS maximum
ratio combining
Diversity Gain
Maximum and selection ration combining
10. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
10
Event triggered measurement
reporting
1. Measure
2. Filter
3. Apply quality offsets to cells individualOffset [0 dB]
4. Compare with measurement criterion
5. Send measurement report with EVENT (if occurred)
f1 f1
4 events associated with soft (or
softer) handover: UE view
• 1a Add
• 1b Remove
• 1c Replace
• 1d Change of best cell
Unlike GSM:
Measurement reports are only
sent when something exciting
happens.
“Event based reporting”
11. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
11
RNC
Example of event triggered reporting
Adding a new cell in the Active set
CPICH in
Active Set
CPICH in
Monitored Set
Cell A Cell B
UE measures all cells in the monitored set including cell B
12. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
12
Example of event triggered reporting
Adding a new cell in the Active set
RNC
CPICH in
Monitored Set
1- CPICH event 1a
Cell A Cell B
Cell B bcomes strong enough (compared to cell A) to trigger a 1a report (add cell B in active set)
CPICH in
Active Set
13. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
13
Example of event triggered reporting
Adding a new cell in the Active set
RNC
2- Report
...meas report..
......
......
CPICH in
Monitored Set
1- CPICH event 1a
Cell A Cell B
A measurment report is sent to the RNC
CPICH in
Active Set
14. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
14
Example of event triggered reporting
Adding a new cell in the Active set
RNC
2- Report
CPICH in
Monitored Set
1- CPICH event 1a
3- New RL
Cell A Cell B
The RNC sets up a new RL in cell B
CPICH in
Active Set
15. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
15
Example of event triggered reporting
Adding a new cell in the Active set
3- New RL
4- Add
RNC
2- Report
1- CPICH event 1a
CPICH in
Active Set
Cell A Cell B
A message s sent to the UE to add cell B in the active set
CPICH in
Active Set
16. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
16
Supported UTRAN Events
Add, remove, replace and change of best cell
Radio Link addition (event 1a)
– If neighbour cell is within
reportingRange1a to the
strongest cell it is added
to the Active set
Radio Link deletion (event 1b)
– If cell in active set is
reportingRange1b below
the strongest cell it is
removed from active set
Radio Link replacement
(event 1c)
– If neighbour cell is within
reportingRange1c to the
weakest cell it replaces
the weakest cell in the
Active set
Change of best cell (event 1d)
– If any cell in the
monitored set becomes
stronger than the current
cell best cell in the active
set
17. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
17
Delete
threshold
CELL A
CELL B
CELL C
Time
Quality
Add
threshold
Supported UTRAN events
Illustration of add, delete, replace and change of best cell
Handover events - Add, replace and delete a cell in the Active Set
To stabilize decisions - Hysteresis and timers
ASmax = 2 CELL A in AS CELL A & B in AS
CELL B&C
in AS
CELL B in AS
TTT
replace
TTT
delete
Events
1a add
1b delete
1c replace
1d change of
best cell
Change of best cell
TTT
add
TTT Time To Trigger
18. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
18
Soft/softer handover area
Soft handover area
Remove:ReportingRange1b
Add:ReportingRange1a
By adjusting the add and remove
threshold its possible to control
handover area
19. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
19
Effect of different handover settings
Distribution of soft and softer handover in commercial
networks
Single Link
35%
Softer
10%
3-way Softer
1%
Soft
24%
Soft/Softer
10%
3-way Soft
20%
Single Link
48%
Softer
17%
3-way Softer
2%
Soft/Softer
10%
Soft
16%
3-way Soft
7%
Alternative
Add: 4 dB
Remove: 7 dB
Ericsson
Recommended
Add: 3 dB
Remove: 5 dB
Larger handover area (+3 dB)
Higher transmission and power usage (+20%)
Same drop rate performance ~1% average
Larger soft handover areas cost more
resources (Transmission and HW)
20. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
20
Summary soft/softer handover
The monitored set is created as the union of the
neighbour lists of the active set
Soft handover needed to prevent excessive
interference
Diversity gain can be achieved in handover area
Measurement reporting are event based
– Four events: add, remove, replace, change of best cell 1c
22. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
22
Using GSM as fall back from
UMTS
UMTS
GSM
IRAT Handover/
Cell change
Poor UMTS
coverage
By allowing WCDMA to switch to GSM it is
possible to extend the service coverage
23. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
23
Compressed mode measurements
• To be able to measure on GSM, a gap in the continuous
transmission must be created.
Transmission Gap (TG) for inter-RAT measurements
HLS
SF/2
Frame
Higher Layer Scheduling (HLS)
-temporarily stop of data flow
on interactive bearers (only PS64 for
for IRAT) and multi-RAB SF/2: preserves bit rate
on CS and streaming
bearers by temporarily decreasing
the spreading factor
SF
SF
24. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
24
Truncation/unmonitored set
IRAT and IFHO only measure the monitored set
If too many neighbours are
defined, the monitored set will
be truncated
For IRAT (and IFHO) only the
monitored list is measured
Truncated cells may
cause dropped calls
max 32 cells
cell x
cell y
cell z
Unmonitored
set
25. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
25
Three types of events
Start compressed mode measurements
– Ec/No below a threshold (event 2d, cell level) OR
- RSCP below a threshold (event 2d, cell level) OR
– UE TX power above a threshold (event 6a, RNC level)
All evaluated in parallel
Stop compressed mode measurements
– Ec/No above a threshold (event 2f, relative to 2d) AND
– RSCP above a threshold (event 2f, relative to 2d) AND
– UE TX power below a threshold (event 6b, RNC level)
All evaluated in parallel
Trigger IRAT handover/cell change
– Ec/No/RSCP(depending on the what triggered 2d) below a
threshold (relative to 2d) AND
– GSM RSSI above a threshold (event 3a, RNC level)
28. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
29
Need for Inter-frequency Handover
Inter Frequency
handover
UMTS 1st carrier
UMTS 2nd carrier
GSM
Poor UMTS
coverage (2nd
carrier)
29. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
30
Three types of events
Start compressed mode measurements
– Ec/No below a threshold (event 2d, cell level) OR
- RSCP below a threshold (event 2d, cell level) OR
– UE TX power above a threshold (event 6a, RNC level)
All evaluated in parallell
Stop compressed mode measurements
– Ec/No above a threshold (event 2f, relative to 2d) AND
– RSCP above a threshold (event 2f, relative to 2d) AND
– UE TX power below a threshold (event 6b, RNC level)
All evaluated in parallell
Trigger inter-frequency handover
– Ec/No/RSCP(depending on the what triggered 2d) below a
threshold (relative to 2d) AND
– non-used frequency RSCP AND non-used frequency Ec/No above
a threshold (event 2b, RNC level)
Identical to
IRAT
Identical to IRAT
30. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
31
Compressed mode pattern, IRAT,
IFHO
Frame # 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
GSM carrier RSSI
Initial BSIC indentification
BSIC re-confirmation
Frame # 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
IFHO
IRAT HO/CC (pattern repetition = 8 frames)
IFHO (pattern repetition = 4 frames)
Note: These patterns is not possible to combine. I.e not possible to
measure GSM cells and WCDMA interfrequency cells at the same time.
31. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
32
IRAT or IFHO?
GSM
will start if hoType =
[IFHO_preferred] for at
least one cell in AS
?
IFHO measurements
will start if hoType =
[GSM_preferred] for at least 1
cell in AS AND no cell in AS
has hoType = [IFHO_preferred]
IRAT measurements
UMTS 2nd carrier
UMTS 2nd carrier
32. Commercial in confidence Handover 2005-09-26
33
Summary
IRAT and Inter-frequency measurements are done in compressed
mode.
Parameter hoType decides which type of measurements and HO
evaluation (IRAT or IFHO) to perform
Three event types to control handover
– starting measurement
– stopping measurement
– trigger handover
The events can be triggered by RSCP, Ec/No, UE TX power (used
freq) and RSCP, Ec/No, GSM RSSI (non-used freq)