Are you interested in patenting your invention but don’t know where to start? Then come to Milwaukee Public Library’s free monthly Patent Searching 101 program. Patent searching is the first step in the patent application process; it ensures your invention is new and thus eligible for a patent. Business librarians will explain the seven-step search process and talk about changes in patent law due to the America Invents Act.
2. What is a Patent?
A patent is...
• a property right granted by the Government of the
United States of America to an inventor,
• “to exclude others from making, using, offering for
sale, or selling the invention throughout the United
States or importing the invention into the United
States,”
• for a limited time,
• in exchange for public disclosure of the invention when
the patent is granted.
2
4. 3 Types of Patents
• Utility Patents – granted
for a useful process or method,
machine, manufactured article
or composition of matter.
• Term: 20 years from filing
date
4
5. 3 Types of Patents
• Design Patents – granted for new, original
and ornamental design for an article of
manufacture: the appearance is protected.
• Term: 14 years from the date the
patent is granted
• Plant Patents – granted for a new,
asexually reproduced plant.
• Term: 20 years from filing date
5
6. What CANNOT be Patented?
• Inventions which are NOT NEW
• Inventions which are OBVIOUS
variations of known technology (obvious
to one familiar with technology)
• ABSTRACT ideas
6
7. What Cannot Be Patented?
Changes from the Patent Reform Act
(S.23)
• Inventions MADE PUBLIC more than one year
prior to patent application filing date OR made
public by other independent inventor before the
first inventor files an application.
7
10. Why Are Patent Searches
Necessary?
• To make sure your idea is new, to search
for prior art
• To increase awareness of the product
field
• To prepare for consulting an attorney
• To reduce patent attorney/agent fees
• To prepare for the application process
10
11. Ways to Search for Patents
on USPTO Databases
• By Patent Number or Publication
Number
• By Keyword (full text or selected fields)
• Some problems: only from 1976 forward;
inconsistent terminology; obsolete names;
synonyms (e.g. rodent extermination
device); British spellings; spelling errors
• By U.S. Patent Classification
• Recommended; Classification systems
categorizes things based on
characteristics and relationships
11
12. U.S. Patent Classification
• There are currently
450 classes and
150,000 subclasses
in the U.S. Patent
Classification
System (USPC).
• Use the online
index to navigate
USPC
12
13. 7 Step Preliminary Patent
Search Overview
• USPTO has developed a 7 Step Patent
Search Strategy to increase the
likelihood a novice searcher will do a
thorough job of a preliminary patent
search.
• Remember: all it takes is one patent to
refute the “novelty” of one’s invention.
13
15. Patent Search Example
A dog harness that
carries a water pouch
and has an attached
water dispenser.
15
16. Step 1: Description of
Invention
What does it do?
• Essential function of the invention
What is the end result?
• Essential effect or basic product resulting from
the invention
What is it made out of?
• Physical structure of the invention
What is it used for?
• Intended use for the invention
16
17. Step 1: Description of Example,
cont.
What does it do?
• An animal vest/harness that carries water and
dispenses water for the animal
What is the end result?
• Water is stored in the vest/harness and is
expelled through a connected dispenser
What is it made of?
• Polyester, plastic tubing, etc.
What is it used for?
• Used to spray water into dog’s (or other animal’s)
mouth, or to spray dog’s paws.
17
18. Step 1: Description of Example,
cont.
Consider Synonyms
• Dog, pet, animal, etc.
• Vest, harness, pouch, dispenser etc.
• Liquid, water, etc.
18
19. Step 2: Determine Classification
Using the Index to U.S. Patent
Classification
• Use the Index to find potential class(es) and
subclass(es).
• Look up each term that describes the invention,
e.g. function, composition, etc.
http://www.uspto.gov/web/patents/classification/uspcindex/indextouspc.h
19
23. Step 2 Continued: Determine
Classification
Use the HTML Index and click on “A”
for animal. Is it also under “D” for dog?
23
24. Step 2 Continued: Determine
Classification
A - Animal
W - Watering devices
24
25. Step 3: Class Schedule in
Manual Of Classification
Online
Click on the Class/Subclass number in
the Index to U.S. Patent Classification – it
will bring you immediately into the Class
Schedule for your invention at the
subclass level.
+ Indicates the subclass is further broken
down
• 119/72+
• 224/148.2
25
26. Step 4: Classification
Definitions
Click on subclass number or title to view and read
the definition. Also includes a “SEE” section that
will point to additional classes and subclasses to
search. Dots show subclass relationships.
26
27. Step 5: Search U.S. Patents
& Published Patent
Applications
You have the class/subclass, now search!
USPTO has two searchable patent publication
databases:
• PatFT (Patents Full-Text)
• Patents back to 1976 accessible by
keyword searching and class/subclass
• All U.S. patents back to 1790 by
class/subclass or patent number.
• AppFT (Published Patent Applications
Full-Text)
27
28. Step 5: Search Each
Database Separately Using
A & P Buttons
Clicking on the P button next to subclass 72
will run the search for all patents within
that class/subclass (119/72) in the PatFT
database.
Clicking on the A button will run the search
for all published patent applications
within that class/subclass in the AppFT
database.
28
31. Step 6: Review Your Search
Results
• Front Page; drawing sheets
• Specification
• Background of the invention
• Summary of the invention
• Detailed description of the invention
31
32. Step 6: Review Your Search
Results: CLAIMS
• Legal
boundaries of
intellectual
property
• Located at the
end of the
patent document
32
33. Step 7: Review Reference
Cited
Referenced By:
links patents that
cite the displayed
patent.
References Cited: shows
the other established
patents viewed by
examiners to determine
the newness or novelty of
the patent that was
granted.
33
34. Step 7: Current U.S.
Classification & Field of
Classification Search
The field of search can provide valuable clues to
other classifications that the patent examiner
searched
34
35. 7 Step Patent Search
Review
• Brainstorm keywords to describe the invention.
• Use these keywords to find initial class/subclass
in the Index to the U.S. Patent Classification.
• Verify the relevancy of class/subclasses using the
Classification Schedule.
• Confirm scope of subclass in Classification
Definitions.
• Access patent documents and published patent
applications using classification in PatFT & AppFT.
• Review the claims, specifications, and drawings
of documents retrieved.
• Retrieve and review cited references and “Field
of Classification Search” in documents retrieved.
35
36. Patent Attorney or Agents
USPTO recommends hiring an attorney or
agent for assistance in preparing a patent.
Patent preparation in legal language is a
challenge.
Registered attorneys and agents are listed
on the upsto.gov website:
https://oedci.uspto.gov/OEDCI/GeoRegion.jsp
36
37. Patents 101: Final Notes
• Document your searches! Write down what
classifications you’ve searched, the
databases you used, keep a list of patents
and applications reviewed.
• Use the U.S. Patent Classification Suggestion
form (included in packet)
• Explore the USPTO website
• Milwaukee Public Library has numerous
books to help in the patent process.
37
38. Contacts
• USPTO Contact Center:
(800) PTO-9199
• Patent Electronic Business Center:
(866) 217-9197
• Milwaukee Public Library Business and
Technology: (414) 286-3051
38
Hinweis der Redaktion
Welcome to Patents 101: How to Do a Patent Search! This program will explain the procedure for conducting a preliminary patent search; a process recommended by the U.S. Patent Office as the first part of preparing your patent application. Obtaining a patent is a long and costly process and you can really benefit by taking advantage of the resources available at the Milwaukee Public Library. Milwaukee Public Library is a Patent and Trademark Resource Center, this means we have a complete collection of historic patents as well as a wide variety of print resources to help with the patent application process. One important thing to note is that as librarians we are unable to conduct patent searches for patrons OR make search suggestions but we can direct you to resources and explain the patent search process. It’s an exciting time for inventors in the U.S. Congress just passed the America Invents Act of 2011 which will result it the biggest change in the U.S. patent system since 1952. The major difference between the new law and the old, is the shift in focus from First to Invent rule to a First Inventor to File, this means patent rights are granted based on the application filing date and not on proving who invented something first. I’ll share some other changes from the America Invents Act with you at different points in the presentation. Look through folder content: Copy of today’s presentation, space to take notes Sample granted patent Process for Obtaining a Utility Patent A form letter requesting suggestions from the USPTO Business card Other flyers with information on offices to contact, scam prevention, help centers
READ SLIDE For those not familiar with how patents are granted; once applications are received at the USPTO in Alexandria, VA, they are examined by patent examiners who are experts in their fields. The examiners determine whether the patent meets all the set requirements and then either issue or deny the patent application. This process can take up to three years depending on the backlog at USPTO. There is an option for a prioritized examination, that is, for a fee the USPTO will prioritize your patent application. As I mentioned, the U.S. patent granting process will be undergoing changes in the coming years. The current way patents are granted is called First to Invent and includes a 1 year grace period. This means an inventor can publish information about an invention, OR can produce and sell a product and have 1 year to apply for a patent on that item. After the first year is over the inventor can no longer apply for a patent because the item is considered no longer new and falls into the category of prior art. This means anyone else can produce and sell the item. If another party submits a patent application within the first year, the initial inventor can request an interference proceeding with the USPTO which will legally determine who is the first inventor. This process is going to change starting in 2013. The America Invents Act moves the U.S. into a First Inventor to File process, which is currently used by Europe and Japan. Beginning in 2013, the first party to file a patent application on their invention will be entitled to a patent regardless of the actual date of invention (as long as all the other requirements are met). So what are the requirement of a patent?
READ SLIDE w/ DEFINITIONS New: some aspect of the invention needs to be substantially different and never before patented. There must be new features, or claims, made in the patent application. Useful – useful here meaning operative or able to serve a useful purpose. Unobvious: the invention must not be obvious to someone knowledgeable in the field of your invention. This judgment is made at the patent office by the patent examiners (who, remember, have expert knowledge in the field of your invention. They will know if your idea is just an obvious progressions or a totally new concept which means it clearly has not been done before. This is why the importance of the language you use to describe your invention is important and why the USPTO advises you hire a patent attorney. Fully disclosed – the patent office must have all the information used in creating your invention. You can’t leave out any details.
Utility Patents serve a useful or functional purpose. Granted for 20 years, afterwards there is no patent protection.
Design patents protect the ornamental appearance of a physical object and are granted for 14 years. Plant patents are for new scientifically created plants and are patented for 20 years. The plant patents are still printed in paper because the color of the plant can be what is its unique and new feature.
READ SLIDE then Text It’s important to note one of the changes coming from the America Invents Act’s shift to First Inventor to File rule. Remember you have 1 year to file a patent application once you make your invention public. If you wait more than 1 year you cannot obtain a patent. You also will not be able to obtain a patent if another (independent) inventor publishes information describing the invention/makes the invention public in some way before you file your patent application, even if it’s within the one year period. This change goes into effect in 2013.
Review Handout (yellow)
READ SLIDE A comprehensive patent search is going to save you time and money. In 2010, over 460,000 patent applications were received by the U.S. Patent Office. Typically only 60% of those get approved. Keep in mind there is no refund for application fees.
READ this The recommended way to conduct your patent search is using the U.S. Patent Classification system. There are currently 450 classes and 150,000 subclasses in the U.S. Patent Classification system. Think of classes and subclasses as the way the USPTO organizes inventions into categories. There is an online index to navigate the classes/subclasses.
Read This Before we begin our search, lets look at a sample granted patent so you have an idea what exactly we are searching. WHITE HANDOUT. Every number you see in parentheses is used for a specific field. For example, field 54 will always have the patent title , no matter what country the patent was issued in or the language. Go through: Inventors, U.S. Classification (52) and Field of Classification (58). On the bottom right of the first page is listed the number of claims made by the applicant along with an abstract. The claims form the basis of the patent grant. The last page of the patent provides the full claims made by the applicant in legal language.
Lets start our example patent search. I want to patent an invention for pets that I think dog owners will love. It’s a dog harness that carries water and has a water dispenser attached to the vest.
Read This (then slide) Step 1: Describe your invention! Ask yourself these questions and keep detailed notes. You will be using these words or terms in Step 2. Using a dictionary and thesaurus is very helpful.
The link on the slide takes you directly to the index. The next three slides show how to get to the index from homepage (http://www.uspto.gov/), I’ll show you the process on the website. [Show process from USPTO homepage]
(your view is from the website) USPTO Home page changed 12/20/11, the slide handouts have a screenshot of the old homepage, none of the other content/steps have changed.
(your view is from the website)
(your view is from the website)
(your view is from the website) You’ll want to use the HTML version of the index since it’s easier to read and doesn’t require you to download any pdfs. The index lists common and technical terms and links them to classifications. Click on the letter to search. You’ll want to try the words you wrote down during Step 1. I’m going to start with letter A for Animal, but I may also want to try D for Dog.
(your view is from the website) Once I find ANIMAL, I’m going to scroll until I find the next words that best fits my invention. In this case it’s WATERING DEVICES. The number listed is the class/subclass to all inventions falling into “Animal – Watering Devices” category.
(your view is from the website) Step 3 moves us from the INDEX into the Class Schedule. The Class Schedule is where we can view the official definition of a class/subclass and access patents and patent applications. To get to the Class Schedules CLICK on the class/subclass number in the INDEX.
(your view is from the website) Once you are in the Class Schedules in the Manual of Classification online, you can read the classification definitions by clicking on the subclass number or title. Read the definitions carefully to determine if they fit your invention; if it does not accurately describe your invention then you’ll have to explore different classes/subclasses. In addition to the definition there is a SEE section that will point to relating classes and subclasses. Shift F5 back to slideshow
Now that I’m confident my invention fits the description of class/subclass 119/72 I can search for issued patents and patent applications. USPTO has two patent publication databases to search: PatFT and AppFT.
READ SLIDE Return to USPTO Results to search PatFT and AppFT
(your view is from the website) Click on and open the titles of patents found in your search and compare them with your invention.
(your view is from the website)
(your view is from the website) Step 6: Review your search results closely. Side note: Some computers do not have the required software to view patent images in the TIFF format. The software is free and available to download on the USPTO websites. There are also websites that let you view patents as pdfs: 1.) pat2pdf.org 2.)Google patents Both are on the Patent Websites half sheet in the folder.
(your view is from the website) Pay special attention to the CLAIMS section of the patent publication. Remember from earlier that claims are words that describe the invention in legal language and form the basis on which the patent was granted. Be sure to ask yourself whether any of the patents you found in your search disclose an invention with claims similar to your invention? Always remember a patent cannot be granted if the invention is not new.
(your view is from the website) The final step of the search process is to search the references cited within the patents that you’ve opened in viewed. The references show the search history of other established patents that were viewed to determine the newness or novelty of the patent that was granted.
(your view is from the website) Shift F5 to return to slideshow
This program only covers a small portion of the much larger patent application process. It is strongly recommended you hire a patent attorney as it may provide the best chance to obtain a patent.
It can take anywhere from 12-48 months for your patent to reach an examiner. If there are questions about your patent an examiner will contact you. Milwaukee Public Library is a Patent and Trademark Resource Center (PTRC) and has a collection of books to help in the patent process. [Bring books to show]