The Lower Lackawanna Watershed near Scranton, PA, is polluted by the largest abandoned mine drain (AMD) in the eastern US. The Old Forge Borehole spews 100 cubic feet per second of iron laden water into the Lackawanna River decimating the aquatic habitat and fish populations for miles downstream and into the Susquehanna River. This assessment was completed in 2012 and the plan recommends cleaning up this discharged and a related discharge, the Duryea Breach, in order to remove approximately 5 tons of iron per day using an active treatment plant. The plant could also have many other beneficial effects besides producing clean water, like hydroelectric power, geothermal heating, iron oxide resource recovery. With these added benefits, the initial ~$15 million investment in a plant could be paid off over and over again.
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Lower Lackawanna Watershed Restoration and Assessment Plan Meeting
1. Lower Lackawanna Watershed
Restoration and Assessment Plan
The Lower Lackawanna Watershed Stakeholders Group Meeting
August 21, 2012 at Council Chambers Duryea Borough
2.
3. Lower Lackawanna River
Mine Drainage
Impairment
• Old Forge Borehole – Union Street
• ~100 CFS (~45,000 GPM)
• ~15 mg/l of iron (4 tons/day)
• net (-) acidity
• no other major pollution
constituents
• Duryea Breach
• ~24 CFS (11,000 GPM)
• ~20 mg/l of iron (1ton/day)
• net (-) acidity
• no other major pollution
constituents
8. Past Studies
• Historical studies researched
– Dodge (1904)
– Ash (1940s-1950s)
– Gannet Fleming (1967)
– PADEP TMDL (2005) exceeds maximum load by
1000%
– SRBC (2011) Old Forge and Duryea contribute 25%
of iron loading to the Susquehanna River.
16. Old Forge/Duryea Quality and Loading
• Since highly (-) net acidic, no alkaline (lime) cost.
• Large flows could be harnessed for electrical needs.
• Since no alkaline material needed, iron sludge
should be attractive to business/industry.
Discharge Ave Flow
CFS
Ave Fe
mg/l
Ave Mn
mg/l
Ave Al
mg/l
Ave Net Acid
mg/l
Ave Fe Load
tons/day
Ave Mn Load
tons/day
Ave Al Load
tons/day
Ave Net Acid Load
tons/day
Old Forge 100 15.0 2.0 0.1 -69.0 4.0 0.5 ~0.0 -18.6
Duryea 24 17.0 2.3 0.1 -60.0 1.1 0.7 ~0.0 -3.9
Combined OF&D 124 5.1 1.2 ~0.0 -22.5
Lancashire #15 11 200.0 na 40 na (pH 2.7) 5.9 na 1.2 na (24 tons/day
hydrated lime)
17. LLR-WRAP Purpose
• To promote the development of an AMD treatment
plant to treat both the OFBH and Duryea Breach.
• To engender a community stakeholder’s partnership to
advance the treatment plant development.
• To advance a comprehensive plan for the larger 2000
acre confluence area in parts of Luzerne and
Lackawanna Counties in Duryea and Old Forge
Boroughs, the City of Pittston and Ransom Township.
18. SMCRA Reauthorization
• Reauthorized in 2007
• PA could receive >$2 billion in restoration
funding. Up to 30% of treat AMD.
• Fund will expire in 2022
• Funds administered by PADEP Bureau of
Conservation and Restoration.
• Need Qualified Hydrologic Unit Plan to be
eligible for funding.
19. LLR-WRAP Goal
• Completion of QHUP by LRCA, EPCAMR and
SRBC.
• PADEP BC&R approve QHUP.
• Initiate AMD treatment plant feasibility study.
• If feasibly, construction of system.
• Stakeholders collaborate to create an entity to
fund and operate the Lower Lackawanna AMD
treatment facility on a perpetual basis.
21. Industrial Site Potential
• Service facilities to help manage Marcellus Industry.
• Investment sites for a variety of sustainable and/or
“green” industries.
– Geothermal
– Hydroelectric
– Fe Hydroxide Sludge Reprocessing
– Passive solar
– Wind turbines
• Large buffer areas of wetlands and natural habitats
that could be managed for conservation and recreation
surrounding industrial and commercial sites.
• Good railroad access
23. Other LLR-WRAP Issues
• Flood Control
• Transportation planning and expansion to
support Confluence site development
• Water quality as related to MS4 and CSO
systems
• Stream corridor management related to water
loss to the mine pool and degraded habitats
• Upland surface mine reclamation needs
24.
25. Lets Revitalize the Lackawanna Valley!
LRCA, EPCAMR and SRBC are asking the
community to join with us as the “Lower
Lackawanna Coalition” to ADVANCE this plan to
restore the Lower Lackawanna River Confluence
area and develop a mine drainage treatment
plant and create opportunities for additional
public and private investment for
commercial, industrial, conservation and
residential uses of the lands and waters of the
Confluence area.
26. Outcomes
• PA DEP is requested to advance the OFBH and Duryea Breach QHUPs through the approval
process, initiate feasibility studies and develop construction and operations and management
program for a treatment plant.
• Duryea Borough, Old Forge Borough, Ransom Township and the City of Pittston will consider
collaboration on a comprehensive plan to address the Confluence area and the river corridor
up through Old Forge.
• This planning work will examine the need for and interest in the establishment of a Lower
Lackawanna Development entity as a public or private agency with a long term mission to
develop industrial commercial and residential opportunities and manage a mine drainage
facility.
• Duryea Borough, West Pittston Borough, County, State and Federal agencies will consider
multiple objectives and the needs of Mine Drainage treatment and conservation
management at the confluence with the design and development of new flood control
programs.
• Conservation and protection and appropriate management of the confluence areas natural
and cultural resources will be integrated into all future planning and development programs.
• Recreation and public open space management will be integrated into all planning and
development programs in the Confluence area.
27. What are your recommendations,
ideas, questions and concerns?
Please direct your comments to
Bernie McGurl, Executive Director,
Lackawanna River Corridor Association
at 570-347-6311 or to director@lrca.org
The Lower Lackawanna Watershed covers about 40 square miles in parts of 10 municipalities in Lackawanna and Luzerne Counties. The main focus of this study area is a 2000 acre post-industrial landscape mid-way between Scranton and Wilkes-Barre.
The mine pumping system that had kept the mines under the Lackawanna Valley dewatered was terminated on November 1, 1961. During the winter of 1961-62 the mine voids became flooded and surcharged out any available outlet to the surface such as boreholes, entry shafts and slopes, air shafts and surface subsidence fractures. Mine drainage flows caused damages to both public and private properties and threatened human health and safety. A subsurface anticlinal feature called the Moosic Anticline helps to define the Lackawanna Basin of the Northern Anthracite Field. Rock ledges reveal its crest in the bed of the Lackawanna River at Old Forge and Jermyn.
The flooded mine complex under the Lower and Middle Lackawanna Valley is now referred to as the Metropolitan Scranton Mine Pool (MSMP). It contains an estimated seventy (70) billion gallons of water, which is a water body about 3/4 the size of Lake Wallenpaupack. The smaller Upper Lackawanna Mine Pool (ULMP) lies under the vicinity of Carbondale. It contains approximately forty (40) billion gallons of water and flows into the river through the Jermyn Mine Tunnel. In order to relieve flooding mine drainage problems, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania directed the installation of the Old Forge Bore Hole (OFBH). It became operational in September 1962, fifty years ago. Recent flow measurements have ranged from: 85 to 120 CFS (55 to 77.5 MGD). Yielding an average flow of 99 CFS or 64 MGD. These flows indicate that OFBH is the largest Abandoned Mine Drain (AMD) the Anthracite region and perhaps the largest AMD in the eastern United States.
The Lower Lackawanna is also impacted by AMD flows from the Duryea Breach. This is a subsidence fracture caused by the collapse of the Phoenix Shaft at Canal Street in Duryea. Following the shaft collapse the mine pool surcharged and broke open the ground about 1000 feet south of the shaft into the remnants of the Duryea Canal Boat Basin. From there it eroded a channel for 800 feet to flow into the Lackawanna River just above the Coxton Road Bridge.
The Confluence of the Lackawanna and Susquehanna Rivers hosts a strategic junction of road, rail and utility infrastructure. The rivers, mine pool discharges, and a topography of flooded soil and gravel quarry pits along the flood plain create a unique and un tapped water resource management area that can have significant economic and conservation benefits for the entire region. We recommend that a comprehensive plan be developed involving multiple partners to address these opportunities and address the myriad of constraints to the highest and best sustainable use of this resource area.