SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 28
Download to read offline
TWC
Exploratory visualization of earth science
    data in a semantic web context

          Xiaogang (Marshall) Ma, Peter Fox


             Tetherless World Constellation
            Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
                       AGU Fall Meeting 2012, San Francisco,
    Session IN53D. Semantics and Cyberinfrastructures for Next Generation Science II
                                    12/07/2012
TWC
                 What is exploratory visualization

• “the process that involves a discipline
  expert creating maps and other
  graphics while dealing with relatively
  unknown geographic data”
                               (Kraak, 2008)


• “Visualization too often becomes an
  end product of scientific analysis,
  rather than an exploration tool that
  scientists can use throughout the
  research life cycle.”
                     (Fox and Hendler, 2011)
                                               2
• (Big) Motivation
                         TWC
                         Motivation & Objective


  – Online services of earth science data have been
    increasingly built in recent years.
  – Tools and services supporting information retrieval with
    those data services are still underdeveloped.

                                                           …

• (Small) Objective
  – A pilot study: Annotation, visualization, and filtration of
    rock age (geologic time) information from online
    geological map services
                                                             3
TWC           Idea



                            Experience


   Data     Information    Knowledge



Creation    Presentation   Integration
Gathering   Organization   Conversation




                      Context             4
Geological
                       TWC           Idea

                      Exploratory
      map                                              Ontology
  services           Visualization
                                      Experience


             Data    Information     Knowledge



         Creation     Presentation   Integration
         Gathering    Organization   Conversation




                                Context            Semantic Web
                                                            5
• Data source:
                     TWC     Actions

                 reuse available services

• Annotation:    build and reuse ontologies

• Visualization: a channel between rock age data
                 services and annotation and
                 filtration operations

• Filtration:    a sample of exploratory
                 visualization
                                               6
TWC     Data source

• Web Map Service (WMS) of British Geological
  Survey
  – WMS: a HTTP interface for requesting geo-registered
    map images from distributed geospatial databases
    (http://www.opengeospatial.org/standards/wms)


• WMS operations
  – GetCapabilities (mandatory), GetMap (mandatory),
    GetFeatureInfo (optional)
  – SLD WMS only: DescribeLayer, GetLegendGraphic,
    GetStyles, PutStyles, etc.
    SLD: Styled Layer Descriptor - an XML schema     7
TWC
A sample of ‘GetFeatureInfo’




                                                  Output format:
                                                  • Text/xml
                                                  • Text/html
                                                  • Text/plain
                                                  …

           1) Click a feature   2) Information returned


                                                            8
TWC
                        Annotation: build and reuse
                                ontologies

• An ontology of geologic time scale (GTS)
  – Ordinal hierarchical structure
     A 7-level hierarchy
     Ordinal arrangement of concepts at each level
  – 175 concepts
     e.g., Triassic, Middle Triassic, Induan, etc.
  – Definition of concepts
     Reuse existing works
  – Encoding
     SKOS, RDFS, OWL


                                                     9
TWC
“Lower Triassic” in the hierarchy



                                           RDF triples




                     Series        Middle_Triassic

                      isA
                                    gts:lowerThan                  Olenekian

                          gts:                          gts:
         Triassic                  Lower_Triassic                 gts:lowerThan
                        subsetOf                     supersetOf


                                   gts:upperThan                    Induan


                                     Lopingian

                                                                       10
                    Ordinal hierarchical structure
TWC
Refer to and reuse existing works for definitions



Global Boundary Stratotype Section
and Point (GSSP) information



                                                    Multilingual labels



                                RGB codes of geological time concepts
Definitions of
geological time
concepts


    Learn ideas and
  take lessons from
                                                                 11
      existing works                                                  11
Annotation
  function
                           TWC

Map: 1:625k bed
 rock age of UK




             1) Get a concept (e.g., Triassic)   2) Retrieve its annotation
                                                                    12
             by clicking a feature               from the ontology
TWC
• Based on the GTS ontology
                               Visualization


  – ordinal hierarchical structure, labels, color codes


• Linked to WMS map layers and the GTS ontology
  for annotation and filtration operations

• Tools: ActionScript and Flare library
  – Result: Flash animations



                                                          13
TWC
    Flash animations
                       Radial tree
                         (“Pie”)




Rooted tree                          14
TWC      Filtration

• Show legend of a WMS map layer in the
  animation

• Use the legend as a control panel to show spatial
  features of certain GTS concept(s)

• Tools: JavaScript, OpenLayers and SLD
  – SLD: an XML schema describing the appearance of
    map layers

                                                      15
Show Legend: SLD from WMS
                           TWC
                             1) WMS operation:
                                GetStyles




                                2) Get a list of geologic
3) Generate a Legend for          time concepts from the
  the WMS map layer               SLD document
                                                    16
More examples                    TWC
                                  Germany
Surface rock age (1 : 1M)




          Courtesy OneGeology-Europe
TWC   Norway

Surface rock age (1 : 1M)




          Courtesy OneGeology-Europe
TWC
Maps of participants in OneGeology-Europe
Denmark
               TWC
Maps of participants in OneGeology-Europe

      Surface rock age (1 : 1M)
Show features: SLD to WMS
                              TWC       4) Get features of
                                        “Upper Cretaceous”
1) Click “Upper Cretaceous”
  in the legend




2) Generate an SLD document
  for “Upper Cretaceous”, by
  referring the GTS ontology   3) Send the SLD to WMS server
                                                        21
TWC
Filter & generalize geological time features using the legend
TWC
  More examples of generalization




Generalization at System level      Generalization at Erathem level




Generalization at Eonothem level   “Precambrian” and “Phanerozoic”
TWC        Demo


WMS + Flash Viz + Vocabulary file + JavaScript

http://goo.gl/tyDKL



                                                 24
TWC           Current work

• Collaborate with GeoSciML group to refine the
  geologic time ontology
  – http://resource.geosciml.org/vocabulary/timescale/
  – Dr. Simon Cox (CSIRO), Dr. Steve Richard (AZGS)


• Use d3.js to rebuild the visualization
• Use triple store to hold the ontology, and SPARQL
  for query
• Reuse Linked Data resources for annotation
  – DBpedia, SISSVoc
                                                         25
TWC    New Demo


WMS + Flash + Ontology file + JavaScript

http://goo.gl/tyDKL
WMS + D3.js Viz + Ontology in triple store + JavaScript

http://goo.gl/WghdY
                                                     26
TWC       Wrap up

• Exploratory visualization provides a intuitive way to show
  patterns of ontologies and data

• Ontology is a powerful aid for conducting exploratory
  visualization

• Semantic Web provides a space for retrieving more data
  and, hopefully, more information

• Further efforts are needed to deploy exploratory
  visualization in earth science works
                                                          27
TWC
Thank you!
                             Acknowledgements:



       Demos:                More information:
       http://goo.gl/tyDKL   Marshall X Ma
       http://goo.gl/WghdY   max7@rpi.edu

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Ontology spectrum for geological data interoperability (PhD defense nov 2011)
Ontology spectrum for geological data interoperability (PhD defense nov 2011)Ontology spectrum for geological data interoperability (PhD defense nov 2011)
Ontology spectrum for geological data interoperability (PhD defense nov 2011)Xiaogang (Marshall) Ma
 
A short story of geologic time ontologies and vocabularies
A short story of geologic time ontologies and vocabulariesA short story of geologic time ontologies and vocabularies
A short story of geologic time ontologies and vocabulariesXiaogang (Marshall) Ma
 
A use case-driven iterative method for building a provenance-aware GCIS onto...
A use case-driven iterative method for building a provenance-aware GCIS onto...A use case-driven iterative method for building a provenance-aware GCIS onto...
A use case-driven iterative method for building a provenance-aware GCIS onto...Xiaogang (Marshall) Ma
 
Why data science matters and what we can do with it
Why data science matters and what we can do with itWhy data science matters and what we can do with it
Why data science matters and what we can do with itXiaogang (Marshall) Ma
 
A short review of Connected China: A visualization of elite social networks i...
A short review of Connected China: A visualization of elite social networks i...A short review of Connected China: A visualization of elite social networks i...
A short review of Connected China: A visualization of elite social networks i...Xiaogang (Marshall) Ma
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Ontology spectrum for geological data interoperability (PhD defense nov 2011)
Ontology spectrum for geological data interoperability (PhD defense nov 2011)Ontology spectrum for geological data interoperability (PhD defense nov 2011)
Ontology spectrum for geological data interoperability (PhD defense nov 2011)
 
A short story of geologic time ontologies and vocabularies
A short story of geologic time ontologies and vocabulariesA short story of geologic time ontologies and vocabularies
A short story of geologic time ontologies and vocabularies
 
A use case-driven iterative method for building a provenance-aware GCIS onto...
A use case-driven iterative method for building a provenance-aware GCIS onto...A use case-driven iterative method for building a provenance-aware GCIS onto...
A use case-driven iterative method for building a provenance-aware GCIS onto...
 
Why data science matters and what we can do with it
Why data science matters and what we can do with itWhy data science matters and what we can do with it
Why data science matters and what we can do with it
 
A short review of Connected China: A visualization of elite social networks i...
A short review of Connected China: A visualization of elite social networks i...A short review of Connected China: A visualization of elite social networks i...
A short review of Connected China: A visualization of elite social networks i...
 
A short introduction to GIS
A short introduction to GISA short introduction to GIS
A short introduction to GIS
 

Similar to Exploratory visualization of earth science data in a Semantic Web context

Deep Learning on Aerial Imagery: What does it look like on a map?
Deep Learning on Aerial Imagery: What does it look like on a map?Deep Learning on Aerial Imagery: What does it look like on a map?
Deep Learning on Aerial Imagery: What does it look like on a map?Rob Emanuele
 
Archaeology, Informatics and Knowledge Representation
Archaeology, Informatics and Knowledge RepresentationArchaeology, Informatics and Knowledge Representation
Archaeology, Informatics and Knowledge RepresentationDART Project
 
Astronomical Data Processing on the LSST Scale with Apache Spark
Astronomical Data Processing on the LSST Scale with Apache SparkAstronomical Data Processing on the LSST Scale with Apache Spark
Astronomical Data Processing on the LSST Scale with Apache SparkDatabricks
 
Technologies For Appraising and Managing Electronic Records
Technologies For Appraising and Managing Electronic RecordsTechnologies For Appraising and Managing Electronic Records
Technologies For Appraising and Managing Electronic Recordspbajcsy
 
20160818 Semantics and Linkage of Archived Catalogs
20160818 Semantics and Linkage of Archived Catalogs20160818 Semantics and Linkage of Archived Catalogs
20160818 Semantics and Linkage of Archived Catalogsandrea huang
 
Scaling Out With Hadoop And HBase
Scaling Out With Hadoop And HBaseScaling Out With Hadoop And HBase
Scaling Out With Hadoop And HBaseAge Mooij
 
Semantic Sensor Network Ontology: Description et usage
Semantic Sensor Network Ontology: Description et usageSemantic Sensor Network Ontology: Description et usage
Semantic Sensor Network Ontology: Description et usagecatherine roussey
 
"Navigating the Database Universe" by Dr. Michael Stonebraker and Scott Jarr,...
"Navigating the Database Universe" by Dr. Michael Stonebraker and Scott Jarr,..."Navigating the Database Universe" by Dr. Michael Stonebraker and Scott Jarr,...
"Navigating the Database Universe" by Dr. Michael Stonebraker and Scott Jarr,...lisapaglia
 
TeraGrid and Physics Research
TeraGrid and Physics ResearchTeraGrid and Physics Research
TeraGrid and Physics Researchshandra_psc
 
Ceph Day Melbourne - Scale and performance: Servicing the Fabric and the Work...
Ceph Day Melbourne - Scale and performance: Servicing the Fabric and the Work...Ceph Day Melbourne - Scale and performance: Servicing the Fabric and the Work...
Ceph Day Melbourne - Scale and performance: Servicing the Fabric and the Work...Ceph Community
 
Big Data Cloud Meetup - Jan 29 2013 - Mike Stonebraker & Scott Jarr of VoltDB
Big Data Cloud Meetup - Jan 29 2013 - Mike Stonebraker & Scott Jarr of VoltDBBig Data Cloud Meetup - Jan 29 2013 - Mike Stonebraker & Scott Jarr of VoltDB
Big Data Cloud Meetup - Jan 29 2013 - Mike Stonebraker & Scott Jarr of VoltDBBigDataCloud
 
Collaborative Similarity Measure for Intra-Graph Clustering
Collaborative Similarity Measure for Intra-Graph ClusteringCollaborative Similarity Measure for Intra-Graph Clustering
Collaborative Similarity Measure for Intra-Graph ClusteringWaqas Nawaz
 
Round Table Introduction: Analytics on 100 TB+ catalogs
Round Table Introduction: Analytics on 100 TB+ catalogsRound Table Introduction: Analytics on 100 TB+ catalogs
Round Table Introduction: Analytics on 100 TB+ catalogsMario Juric
 
Deep Learning AtoC with Image Perspective
Deep Learning AtoC with Image PerspectiveDeep Learning AtoC with Image Perspective
Deep Learning AtoC with Image PerspectiveDong Heon Cho
 
Ontologies introduction - ecoOnto meeting
Ontologies introduction - ecoOnto meetingOntologies introduction - ecoOnto meeting
Ontologies introduction - ecoOnto meetingjchabalier
 
Frossie Economou & Angelo Fausti [Vera C. Rubin Observatory] | How InfluxDB H...
Frossie Economou & Angelo Fausti [Vera C. Rubin Observatory] | How InfluxDB H...Frossie Economou & Angelo Fausti [Vera C. Rubin Observatory] | How InfluxDB H...
Frossie Economou & Angelo Fausti [Vera C. Rubin Observatory] | How InfluxDB H...InfluxData
 
Pittaro open stackloganalysis_20130416
Pittaro open stackloganalysis_20130416Pittaro open stackloganalysis_20130416
Pittaro open stackloganalysis_20130416OpenStack Foundation
 
Provenance for Data Munging Environments
Provenance for Data Munging EnvironmentsProvenance for Data Munging Environments
Provenance for Data Munging EnvironmentsPaul Groth
 
Q4 2016 GeoTrellis Presentation
Q4 2016 GeoTrellis PresentationQ4 2016 GeoTrellis Presentation
Q4 2016 GeoTrellis PresentationRob Emanuele
 

Similar to Exploratory visualization of earth science data in a Semantic Web context (20)

Deep Learning on Aerial Imagery: What does it look like on a map?
Deep Learning on Aerial Imagery: What does it look like on a map?Deep Learning on Aerial Imagery: What does it look like on a map?
Deep Learning on Aerial Imagery: What does it look like on a map?
 
Archaeology, Informatics and Knowledge Representation
Archaeology, Informatics and Knowledge RepresentationArchaeology, Informatics and Knowledge Representation
Archaeology, Informatics and Knowledge Representation
 
Astronomical Data Processing on the LSST Scale with Apache Spark
Astronomical Data Processing on the LSST Scale with Apache SparkAstronomical Data Processing on the LSST Scale with Apache Spark
Astronomical Data Processing on the LSST Scale with Apache Spark
 
Technologies For Appraising and Managing Electronic Records
Technologies For Appraising and Managing Electronic RecordsTechnologies For Appraising and Managing Electronic Records
Technologies For Appraising and Managing Electronic Records
 
20160818 Semantics and Linkage of Archived Catalogs
20160818 Semantics and Linkage of Archived Catalogs20160818 Semantics and Linkage of Archived Catalogs
20160818 Semantics and Linkage of Archived Catalogs
 
Scaling Out With Hadoop And HBase
Scaling Out With Hadoop And HBaseScaling Out With Hadoop And HBase
Scaling Out With Hadoop And HBase
 
Semantic Sensor Network Ontology: Description et usage
Semantic Sensor Network Ontology: Description et usageSemantic Sensor Network Ontology: Description et usage
Semantic Sensor Network Ontology: Description et usage
 
"Navigating the Database Universe" by Dr. Michael Stonebraker and Scott Jarr,...
"Navigating the Database Universe" by Dr. Michael Stonebraker and Scott Jarr,..."Navigating the Database Universe" by Dr. Michael Stonebraker and Scott Jarr,...
"Navigating the Database Universe" by Dr. Michael Stonebraker and Scott Jarr,...
 
TeraGrid and Physics Research
TeraGrid and Physics ResearchTeraGrid and Physics Research
TeraGrid and Physics Research
 
Ceph Day Melbourne - Scale and performance: Servicing the Fabric and the Work...
Ceph Day Melbourne - Scale and performance: Servicing the Fabric and the Work...Ceph Day Melbourne - Scale and performance: Servicing the Fabric and the Work...
Ceph Day Melbourne - Scale and performance: Servicing the Fabric and the Work...
 
Big Data Cloud Meetup - Jan 29 2013 - Mike Stonebraker & Scott Jarr of VoltDB
Big Data Cloud Meetup - Jan 29 2013 - Mike Stonebraker & Scott Jarr of VoltDBBig Data Cloud Meetup - Jan 29 2013 - Mike Stonebraker & Scott Jarr of VoltDB
Big Data Cloud Meetup - Jan 29 2013 - Mike Stonebraker & Scott Jarr of VoltDB
 
Collaborative Similarity Measure for Intra-Graph Clustering
Collaborative Similarity Measure for Intra-Graph ClusteringCollaborative Similarity Measure for Intra-Graph Clustering
Collaborative Similarity Measure for Intra-Graph Clustering
 
Round Table Introduction: Analytics on 100 TB+ catalogs
Round Table Introduction: Analytics on 100 TB+ catalogsRound Table Introduction: Analytics on 100 TB+ catalogs
Round Table Introduction: Analytics on 100 TB+ catalogs
 
Deep Learning AtoC with Image Perspective
Deep Learning AtoC with Image PerspectiveDeep Learning AtoC with Image Perspective
Deep Learning AtoC with Image Perspective
 
Ontologies introduction - ecoOnto meeting
Ontologies introduction - ecoOnto meetingOntologies introduction - ecoOnto meeting
Ontologies introduction - ecoOnto meeting
 
Frossie Economou & Angelo Fausti [Vera C. Rubin Observatory] | How InfluxDB H...
Frossie Economou & Angelo Fausti [Vera C. Rubin Observatory] | How InfluxDB H...Frossie Economou & Angelo Fausti [Vera C. Rubin Observatory] | How InfluxDB H...
Frossie Economou & Angelo Fausti [Vera C. Rubin Observatory] | How InfluxDB H...
 
Hadoop For OpenStack Log Analysis
Hadoop For OpenStack Log AnalysisHadoop For OpenStack Log Analysis
Hadoop For OpenStack Log Analysis
 
Pittaro open stackloganalysis_20130416
Pittaro open stackloganalysis_20130416Pittaro open stackloganalysis_20130416
Pittaro open stackloganalysis_20130416
 
Provenance for Data Munging Environments
Provenance for Data Munging EnvironmentsProvenance for Data Munging Environments
Provenance for Data Munging Environments
 
Q4 2016 GeoTrellis Presentation
Q4 2016 GeoTrellis PresentationQ4 2016 GeoTrellis Presentation
Q4 2016 GeoTrellis Presentation
 

Exploratory visualization of earth science data in a Semantic Web context

  • 1. TWC Exploratory visualization of earth science data in a semantic web context Xiaogang (Marshall) Ma, Peter Fox Tetherless World Constellation Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute AGU Fall Meeting 2012, San Francisco, Session IN53D. Semantics and Cyberinfrastructures for Next Generation Science II 12/07/2012
  • 2. TWC What is exploratory visualization • “the process that involves a discipline expert creating maps and other graphics while dealing with relatively unknown geographic data” (Kraak, 2008) • “Visualization too often becomes an end product of scientific analysis, rather than an exploration tool that scientists can use throughout the research life cycle.” (Fox and Hendler, 2011) 2
  • 3. • (Big) Motivation TWC Motivation & Objective – Online services of earth science data have been increasingly built in recent years. – Tools and services supporting information retrieval with those data services are still underdeveloped. … • (Small) Objective – A pilot study: Annotation, visualization, and filtration of rock age (geologic time) information from online geological map services 3
  • 4. TWC Idea Experience Data Information Knowledge Creation Presentation Integration Gathering Organization Conversation Context 4
  • 5. Geological TWC Idea Exploratory map Ontology services Visualization Experience Data Information Knowledge Creation Presentation Integration Gathering Organization Conversation Context Semantic Web 5
  • 6. • Data source: TWC Actions reuse available services • Annotation: build and reuse ontologies • Visualization: a channel between rock age data services and annotation and filtration operations • Filtration: a sample of exploratory visualization 6
  • 7. TWC Data source • Web Map Service (WMS) of British Geological Survey – WMS: a HTTP interface for requesting geo-registered map images from distributed geospatial databases (http://www.opengeospatial.org/standards/wms) • WMS operations – GetCapabilities (mandatory), GetMap (mandatory), GetFeatureInfo (optional) – SLD WMS only: DescribeLayer, GetLegendGraphic, GetStyles, PutStyles, etc. SLD: Styled Layer Descriptor - an XML schema 7
  • 8. TWC A sample of ‘GetFeatureInfo’ Output format: • Text/xml • Text/html • Text/plain … 1) Click a feature 2) Information returned 8
  • 9. TWC Annotation: build and reuse ontologies • An ontology of geologic time scale (GTS) – Ordinal hierarchical structure A 7-level hierarchy Ordinal arrangement of concepts at each level – 175 concepts e.g., Triassic, Middle Triassic, Induan, etc. – Definition of concepts Reuse existing works – Encoding SKOS, RDFS, OWL 9
  • 10. TWC “Lower Triassic” in the hierarchy RDF triples Series Middle_Triassic isA gts:lowerThan Olenekian gts: gts: Triassic Lower_Triassic gts:lowerThan subsetOf supersetOf gts:upperThan Induan Lopingian 10 Ordinal hierarchical structure
  • 11. TWC Refer to and reuse existing works for definitions Global Boundary Stratotype Section and Point (GSSP) information Multilingual labels RGB codes of geological time concepts Definitions of geological time concepts Learn ideas and take lessons from 11 existing works 11
  • 12. Annotation function TWC Map: 1:625k bed rock age of UK 1) Get a concept (e.g., Triassic) 2) Retrieve its annotation 12 by clicking a feature from the ontology
  • 13. TWC • Based on the GTS ontology Visualization – ordinal hierarchical structure, labels, color codes • Linked to WMS map layers and the GTS ontology for annotation and filtration operations • Tools: ActionScript and Flare library – Result: Flash animations 13
  • 14. TWC Flash animations Radial tree (“Pie”) Rooted tree 14
  • 15. TWC Filtration • Show legend of a WMS map layer in the animation • Use the legend as a control panel to show spatial features of certain GTS concept(s) • Tools: JavaScript, OpenLayers and SLD – SLD: an XML schema describing the appearance of map layers 15
  • 16. Show Legend: SLD from WMS TWC 1) WMS operation: GetStyles 2) Get a list of geologic 3) Generate a Legend for time concepts from the the WMS map layer SLD document 16
  • 17. More examples TWC Germany Surface rock age (1 : 1M) Courtesy OneGeology-Europe
  • 18. TWC Norway Surface rock age (1 : 1M) Courtesy OneGeology-Europe
  • 19. TWC Maps of participants in OneGeology-Europe
  • 20. Denmark TWC Maps of participants in OneGeology-Europe Surface rock age (1 : 1M)
  • 21. Show features: SLD to WMS TWC 4) Get features of “Upper Cretaceous” 1) Click “Upper Cretaceous” in the legend 2) Generate an SLD document for “Upper Cretaceous”, by referring the GTS ontology 3) Send the SLD to WMS server 21
  • 22. TWC Filter & generalize geological time features using the legend
  • 23. TWC More examples of generalization Generalization at System level Generalization at Erathem level Generalization at Eonothem level “Precambrian” and “Phanerozoic”
  • 24. TWC Demo WMS + Flash Viz + Vocabulary file + JavaScript http://goo.gl/tyDKL 24
  • 25. TWC Current work • Collaborate with GeoSciML group to refine the geologic time ontology – http://resource.geosciml.org/vocabulary/timescale/ – Dr. Simon Cox (CSIRO), Dr. Steve Richard (AZGS) • Use d3.js to rebuild the visualization • Use triple store to hold the ontology, and SPARQL for query • Reuse Linked Data resources for annotation – DBpedia, SISSVoc 25
  • 26. TWC New Demo WMS + Flash + Ontology file + JavaScript http://goo.gl/tyDKL WMS + D3.js Viz + Ontology in triple store + JavaScript http://goo.gl/WghdY 26
  • 27. TWC Wrap up • Exploratory visualization provides a intuitive way to show patterns of ontologies and data • Ontology is a powerful aid for conducting exploratory visualization • Semantic Web provides a space for retrieving more data and, hopefully, more information • Further efforts are needed to deploy exploratory visualization in earth science works 27
  • 28. TWC Thank you! Acknowledgements: Demos: More information: http://goo.gl/tyDKL Marshall X Ma http://goo.gl/WghdY max7@rpi.edu