2. Theory of Public Debt
What is Public Debt?
money or credit owed by any level of government
indirect debt of taxpayers
INTERNAL DEBT
EXTERNAL DEBT
3. Theory of Public Debt
What are the origins of Public Borrowing?
European economists between 1500 and 1750
Mercantilist Period are considered mercantilists.
Era of merchant capital, dependent on
connections between social and productive
systems
One of the greatest critics of
mercantilism. He was strong in
emphasizing the disadvantages of
Adam Smith borrowing and expostulated on the
advantages of the balanced budget
during the years of capitalism.
4. Theory of Public Debt
Keynesian Theory
of Deficit Financing
It was during the time of John Maynard Keynes that
the idea of public borrowing was introduced during
the Great Depression, mainly as a compensatory tool
in times of economic stability.
“In order to keep people fully
employed, governments have to run deficits
when the economy is slowing.”
Borrowing for capital generation purposes is
necessary like setting up public enterprises
which will contribute to a productive output.
5. Theory of Public Debt
Keynesian Theory
of Deficit Financing
WHY IT CANNOT WORK IN LDC’S
1) Instabilities of LDC‟s are of external origin like oil crisis, inflation, and
recession in the industrialized countries.
2) Keynes‟ theories are based on the assumption of fully developed
economies undergoing cyclical difficulties. In LDC‟s productive
capacity is not yet fully developed.
3) An example cited by fiscal administrators in the 60‟s was the
Emergency Employment Administration during the Macapagal era where
deficit financing was resorted to.
6. Theory of Public Debt
What are the origins of Public Borrowing?
Development Finance
Predicated on Foreign Borrowing.
The expenditure demands of development are
expensive and urgent. The only immediate
option recommended by experts is
borrowing, specifically foreign borrowing.
Musgrave and Musgrave point out that in development finance, foreign
borrowing is preferable.
“Public investment which is financed by (local) borrowing does not
add to capital formation if it merely diverts funds otherwise available
for private investment. If borrowing is from abroad, additional
resources become available as borrowing is accompanied by
increased imports.”
7. Theory of Public Debt
What are the origins of Public Borrowing?
Development Finance
Why Foreign Borrowing is preferred:
1. results in inflow of additional resources
2. covers up foreign exchange deficiencies due to
development spending
3. facilitates the inflow of technical and managerial
expertise
Significant events during the development decades:
1. the sharp rise in borrowing activities of the LDCs
2. the emergence of the World Bank and
International Monetary Fund as the dominant
figures in development
8. Theory of Public Debt
What are the origins of Public Borrowing?
Development Finance
International
Monetary Fund
An international organization of
Surveillance
184 member countries. It was
1)Abolition or liberalization of
established to promote foreign exchange and import
international monetary controls
Financing
cooperation, exchange 2)Devaluation of the exchange
stability, and orderly exchange rate
arrangements; to foster 3)Domestic anti-inflationary
economic growth and high levels programmes
Technical Assistance provide
of employment; and to 4)Greater hospitality to foreign
temporary financial assistance to
investment
countries to help ease balance of
payments adjustment.
9. Theory of Public Debt
What are the origins of Public Borrowing?
Development Finance
The World Bank
By 1949, the bank shifted
Originated from IBRD
from reconstruction to
(International Bank of
development lending, with
Reconstruction and
focus on LDC‟s.
Development)
During the 1950‟s, loans to
the goal was to assist in the LDC‟s were infrastructure
recovery and reconstruction of related. Later on, it widened its
countries devastated by WWII. scope to include
By the end of the 90‟s, total loans and
By the end of 1980, total loans and credits mining, agriculture, water, educ
credits to amounted to $80 billion.
to LDC‟s LDC‟s amounted to $2 trillion. ation, etc.
10. Theory of Public Debt
What are the origins of Public Borrowing?
The International
Structuralist Models
Dependency Theory/
Theory of Imperialism/ Neo-Marxist
Neo-colonialism
Dos Santos defines dependence as a
Views the relationships conditioning situation where the economies of
one group of countries are conditioned by the
among LDC‟s, advanced
development and expansion of others
countries, and the WB-IMF as
that of an imperialism. Conditions of dependency:common historical
background; initial dependence on imports for
The colonial relationship is manufacturing requirements; heavy dependence on
evident through political and imports of foreign technology; deep penetration by
economic dominance, or foreign capital in the guise of transnational
what is called „neo-colonial‟. corporations; condition of
cultural, psychological, social, and political
independence.
11. Theory of Public Debt
What are the origins of Public Borrowing?
The International
Structuralist Models
Cheryl Payer, writer of the
“Debt Trap”, cited that “the The Philippines in the early 80s was one of
World Bank has used its the top seven debtor countries and had a
financial power to promote Balance of Payment (BOP) deficit of $1.135
the interests of billion, a trade deficit of $2.805 billion, and a
private, international capital cash deficit of P14.4 billion.
in its expansion to every Negotiations with IMF were formidable, such
corner of the as, reduction of cash deficit to P9
„underdeveloped‟ world.” billion, further restructuring of tariff rates
and further devaluation of the peso.
12. Structure of Philippine Public
Debt
CROSS-
SECTION
Creditor Debtor Maturity
Medium-Term
Official Private Public Central Bank Private Short-term
Long-Term
Multilateral Banks
Bilateral Suppliers credit
Financial
Institutions
Others
13. Structure of Philippine Public
Debt
TIME-SERIES ANALYSIS
external debt accumulation in the Philippines is
Growth Trend characterized by an accelerating trend.
public sector which includes mainly the National
Debtor trend Government, GOCCs, and the Central Bank; and the
private sector.
Philippine major creditors-private commercial
Creditor trend banks, financial institutions, and the official creditors
consisting of multilateral and bilateral agencies.
Debt-service interest payments alone on debts had
trend continually risen.
Net Resource measures the net flow of resources in a
Transfer debtor-creditor relationship.
24. Interest Payments & Debt Service to GDP
Foreign Interest For. Debt
Year Payments to Service to
GDP GDP
1998 7.82
1999 old
8.70
concept
1999 new Debt service
This translates 8.64 savings of
to a net concept $10.1bn
resource 2000 4.2 8.25
savings of
US$4.1bn in 2001 4.1 9.17
2008 to finance
import content 2002 3.4 10.10
of capex 2003 3.2 9.98
needed for
growth! 2004 2.7 8.30
2005 2.8 7.71
2006 2.8 6.88
2007 2.5 5.33
2008 1.9 4.41
24
Source: BSP-SEFI
25. Tensile Strength
300.0 70%
65%
250.0
60%
200.0
55%
50%
150.0 45%
40%
100.0
35%
30%
50.0
25%
0.0 20%
1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 Feb 09 Apr 09 Jun 09 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Jun
09
NPLs Total Loans to GDP Ratio
18.0 1.00
16.0 0.95
14.0
0.90
12.0
0.85
10.0
0.80
8.0
0.75
6.0
0.70
4.0
2.0 0.65
0.0 0.60
Ma Se Ma Se Ma Se Ma Se Ma Se Ma Se Ma Se Ma Se Ma Se Ma Se Ma
1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 Feb 09 Apr 09 Jun 09
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
NPL to Total Loans Ratio Loans to Deposit Ratio
Source: BSP
25
26. Monetary Policy- mostly
countercyclical
8.50 8.5%
8.00
7.50 7.5%
7.00
6.50 6.5%
6.00
5.50 5.5%
5.00
4.50 4.5%
4.00
3.50 3.5%
Jan May Sep Jan May Sep Jan May Sep Jan May Sep Jan May Sep Jan May Sep
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
RRP GDP Growth Rate
Source: BSP and NSCB 26
28. System for Public Debt Management
Background on Public Debt
This desire to borrow in order to spend
Fiscal deficits (the gap between more is usually justified by the
government revenues and total following:
expenditures) are prerequisites to 1) development finance
accumulating debt. 2) cheap credit
The gap represents the difference 3) financing current expenditure
between government revenue
generation and the desired level of
spending of government . Ways on financing expenditure gaps:
The absence of money to fully 1) raising taxes
finance its desired spending prompts 2) tapping domestic savings
a government to borrow. 3) monetary expansion
4) foreign borrowing
29. System for Public Debt Management
Four Stages of Public Debt (Angel Yoingco)
Borrowing the Funds
Spending the Funds
Raising revenue for
repayments
Actual debt repayment
30. System for Public Debt Management
What is Public Debt Management and Why is it Important?
It is the process of establishing and Governments should ensure that both the
executing a strategy for managing level and rate of growth in their public
the government's debt in order to: debt is fundamentally sustainable, and
-raise the required amount of funding can be serviced under a wide range of
-achieve its risk and cost objectives circumstances while meeting cost and
-meet any other sovereign debt risk objectives.
management goals the government
may have set
Poorly structured debt in terms of
maturity, currency, or interest rate
composition and large and unfunded
contingent liabilities have been
important factors in inducing or
propagating economic crises in many
countries throughout history.
31. System for Public Debt Management
What is Public Debt Management and Why is it Important?
Sound debt structures help Several debt market crises have
governments reduce their highlighted the importance of
exposure to interest rate, currency sound debt management
and other risks. practices and the need for an
efficient and sound capital
market.
Risky debt structures are often the
consequence of inappropriate
economic policies--fiscal, monetary
and exchange rate--but the feedback
effects undoubtedly go in both
directions.
32. EXTERNAL DEBT MANAGEMENT
IN THE PHILIPPINES
DEBT MANAGEMENT
FROM A MACRO PERSPECTIVE
Identification of priority areas for foreign
financing
Determination of project viability and
borrower’s capacity to pay
Assessment of country’s debt servicing
capability
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
33. EXTERNAL DEBT MANAGEMENT
IN THE PHILIPPINES
INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS
FOR DEBT MANAGEMENT
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
Department of Finance
Investment Coordination Committee
Inter-agency Committee for Review of Foreign
Loan Documents
National Economic Development Authority
Development Budget Coordination Committee
Board of Investments
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
34. EXTERNAL DEBT MANAGEMENT
IN THE PHILIPPINES
LEGAL BASES
The Philippine Constitution – 15 October 1986
Letter of Instructions No. 158 – 21 January 1974
Foreign Borrowings Act (Republic Act 4860)
– 8 September 1966
New Central Bank Act (Republic Act 7653)
– 10 June 1993
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
35. EXTERNAL DEBT MANAGEMENT
IN THE PHILIPPINES
BSP DEBT MANAGEMENT
RESPONSIBILITIES
Monitoring the level of external debt
Keeping outstanding debt and debt burden
at manageable levels
Obtaining the best available terms and conditions
for foreign financing and avoid bunching of
maturities
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
36. EXTERNAL DEBT MANAGEMENT
IN THE PHILIPPINES
BSP DEBT MANAGEMENT TOOLS
Regulatory issuances (policies and procedures)
Administrative mechanisms (approval and
registration process; reporting system)
Observance of ceilings on new commercial MLT
loans and outstanding ST public sector debt
Debt Strategies
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
37. EXTERNAL DEBT MANAGEMENT
IN THE PHILIPPINES
DEBT MONITORING SYSTEM
The Philippine external debt monitoring system covers
all data categories such as:
by borrower
(public, private, bank and non-bank);
by original and residual maturity
(short-term, medium- and long-term);
by creditor type;
by currency; and
by country
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
38. EXTERNAL DEBT MANAGEMENT
IN THE PHILIPPINES
DEBT MONITORING SYSTEM
The Philippine external debt monitoring system covers
all data categories such as:
by borrower
(public, private, bank and non-bank);
by original and residual maturity
(short-term, medium- and long-term);
by creditor type;
by currency; and
by country
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
39. Issues and Problems
• Aquino inherited a government with a budget deficit of
P298.5 billion in 2009 or 3.9 percent of gross
domestic product (GDP). For 2010, the government
has set a fiscal deficit of P300 billion or 3.6 percent of
GDP. Actual collection in January to June 2010
indicates that tax revenues will likely fall short of
target by P74 billion (about 0.9 percent of the GDP
while non-tax revenues will likely fall short of target by
0.4 percent of GDP, according to Dr. Rosario
Manasan, fiscal expert of the Philippine Institute for
Development Studies.
40. The current fiscal situation
The Arroyo government almost achieved a balanced
budget in 2007, which is on track with its Medium-Term
Philippine Development Plan target. Congress passed
landmark laws like value-added tax, excise tax and lateral
attrition to increase revenue collection. But it fell through
with the onset of the global crisis in the latter part of 2008
and early part of 2009.
As percent of gross domestic product (GDP), fiscal deficit
surged from less than 1 percent in 2007 and 2008 to 3.9
percent of GDP in 2009.
As the fiscal deficit soared, so is the national government
debt. Debt-to-GDP ratio went up from 56 percent of GDP
in 2007 to 57 percent of GDP in 2008 and 2009. Although
compared to the 78-percent debt-to-GDP ration in 2004
when the country had a fiscal crisis, the 57-percent debt-
to-GDP ratio is still much lower.
41. The current fiscal situation ..
The Arroyo government’s economic team proposed to
the Aquino administration to balance the budget within
three to six years but it was received thumbs
down. According to the new Department of Finance
Cesar Purisima, the Aquino government does not
intend to balance the budget in the next six years as
President Aquino intends to focus on social services
during his term.
But according to DOF Undersecretary Gil
Beltran, delaying the date of achieving a balanced
budget may negatively affect the country’s
creditworthiness. On the other hand, he said that
pushing to wipe out the budget deficit ahead of the
2013 goal may also be too much for the country’s
fragile fiscal position.
42. The current fiscal situation ..
For 2010, debt-to-GDP is projected to go down to
53.4 percent to 46 percent in 2013. The year 2013
will be a good time to the budget but a more
realistic will be 2015.
The Development Budget Coordination Committee
(DBCC), the interagency committee that advises
the President on macroeconomic targets, increased
the budget deficit target this year to P325 billion or
3.9 percent of GDP instead of P293 billion or 3.5
percent of GDP. The DBCC is composed of the
Department of Budget and Management, National
Economic and Development Authority, Department
of Finance and Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas.