SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 10
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Word count: 2497


                       SKIP?




                       SKIP?




                      SCiP!


Critical Reflexivity; smoke and mirrors or philosophy?
             Justin Moseley; 201162717.
        Professor T. Mullen and Miss C. Reid
CONTENTS
Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 2
Adaptation .............................................................................................................................................. 2
   Reflex action........................................................................................................................................ 2
   Reflection in action ............................................................................................................................. 3
   Reflection on action ............................................................................................................................ 3
Application .............................................................................................................................................. 4
   Reflex Action ....................................................................................................................................... 4
   Reflection in action ............................................................................................................................. 4
   Reflection on action ............................................................................................................................ 4
Anticipation ............................................................................................................................................. 5
   Reflex Action ....................................................................................................................................... 5
   Reflection in action ............................................................................................................................. 5
   Reflection on action ............................................................................................................................ 5
Learning outcomes - Bridging the gap; Reflexive methodologies .......................................................... 6
   Reflex action........................................................................................................................................ 6
       Emotion ........................................................................................................................................... 6
       Preconceived rationality ................................................................................................................. 7
   Reflection on Action............................................................................................................................ 7
       Journals ........................................................................................................................................... 7
Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................... 8
Bibliography ............................................................................................................................................ 9




TABLE OF FIGURES
FIGURE 1; SITUATIONAL COMMUNICATION (MOSELEY, 2012)                                                                                                        6
FIGURE 2; PHILOSOPHY OF REFLEXIVE REFLECTION (MOSELEY, 2012)                                                                                               7




                                                                                                                                                         1
Critical Reflexivity; smoke and mirrors or philosophy?

Introduction
My life has been primarily spent within institutions. I attended boarding school and then spent
twenty years working in the Merchant Navy. Three years ago I came ashore to work on a large
offshore construction project. During this latter tenure I met two MBA’s, both of whom were
instrumental in my attendance of this course. Furthermore, they gave me pause for thought in two
varying different ways.

I discovered John had an MBA. Through our discussions I began to form an idea of what it was and
what it meant to achieve this qualification. However, one aspect I did not “get” during our
conversation was that he stated how incredibly frustrating it was working on the project. This was
due to his cognizance of how things should be done, as opposed to how things were done.

I now have an altered view of the project from time and spatial perspectives. I also have a
perception of strategic tools and best practices, which prior to attending Strathclyde I did not even
know existed. Through this insight I understand John’s frustration. Furthermore, I now see how
issues could have been ameliorated or avoided if the project personnel were more open minded and
not involved in poor management practices which, in retrospect, were pervasive.

My challenge is that I am not a naturally reflective person. Moreover, due to the nature of my action
orientated employment I was the quintessential “energetic problem solver” (Van Der Heijden et al.,
2002, p.230). My challenge is how, or can, I transit through the managerial spectrum in order to
become a reflective practitioner (Schön, 2007)?



Adaptation

Reflex action
On the initial morning of SCiP I was a little nervous about whom my team would be. My concern was
due to my perception of some individuals within the cohort and the feeling that that they would not
match my standards. However, my reflex thinking was counterproductive; sometimes as a manager
you may be placed within an unknown group and have to ensure high performance regardless of
composition. Ultimately the team was formed from two self-selected groups, and a part time
student. My reaction to this was satisfaction; I had not worked with the other full timers, though I
was aware of their high performing reputation. I was however, concerned about the unknown
qualities of the part time member. The irony of this misperception is not lost on me, as Andrew

                                                                                                  2
performed very well. A salutary lesson is to be consistently open minded and to embrace the
unknown.

Initially in the syndicate room, I noticed that the two self-select teams reflexively sat together at
opposite ends of the table. Using Bolman and Deals (2008) frames I was conscious of potential
conflict arising if we did not integrate. I altered my seating and sat with the other group thus
reducing the potential of factionalisation.

Reflection in action
Through the course of the next few days it became apparent that the group created a richness of
discussion and were adroit at avoiding groupthink (Whyte, 1952). However, the counterpoint of this
richness was that we were affected with “paralysis by analysis.” On one occasion Andrew, stepped in
and “broke the fame” (Bolman and Deal, 2008, p.13) suggesting that we split into sub sets and we
worked more successfully this way. This ability to reflect whilst in action suggested by Schön (2007)
gives the practitioner an aptitude to manage ambiguous and unique situations. This was an excellent
learning process; sometimes I become entrenched in a feedback loop of non-optimal decision
making, where I am unable or not open to seeing better solutions.

Reflection on action
My tenure in the Merchant Navy training developed my leadership ability. This is not what would be
considered a democracy due to the explicit hierarchy; it lies within the “structural” leadership frame
(Bolman and Deal, 2008). My challenge is that I am no longer at sea and requirements ashore differ.
Due to my training, background and strength of character there is a reflexive propensity for me to
dominate groups. Mckenna and Beech (2008) suggest it would be beneficial to utilise
“tranformational leadership,” whereby I lead by example and empower others. However, due to my
force of character, leading by example can be detrimental as I can seem overbearing. Moreover,
what I consider to be empowering people may be perceived as giving orders. I have developed
strategies to ensure all group members have an opportunity to give their input. For example, one
method I applied was ensuring the group gave their opinion first. I found if I gave my perspective
initially, I felt people just agreed with me (or otherwise I am right, A LOT).

On joining a new group for SCiP, I decided to take a step back and see how the group developed.
This gave me a new perspective; I began to comprehend different types of leadership, the explicit
where you lead from the front, or the leader who stands aloof from the action, but is more adroit at
seeing holistically. Using Hersey’s (1984) situational leadership model, the SCiP group was generally
within the “leadership through delegation” aspect. We were all self-starters driving towards the
same goal. However, after the inadequate trial presentation, the model had to be changed to
“leadership through directing.” I pointed out that while we had excellent ideas, if we did not
                                                                                                   3
capitalise on them we would not achieve our goals. Specialised tasks were duly delegated to the
group (Weber, 1947) which remotivated and refocused us and resulted in a much improved
presentation.



Application

Reflex Action
I have noticed during SCiP and previous modules that there is a reflex action of bounded limitations
which some of the cohort place around themselves. I have lost count of the amount of times I have
been asked or overheard “are we allowed to do this?” The difficulty arises when this fear of failure
creeps into the group and stifles the innovative use of tools resulting in “satisficing” (Simon, 1957);
whereby outcomes and behaviours are diluted (Cropper et al., 2009) resulting in mediocrity.

Reflection in action
Our SCiP group had an older demographic, we had confidence in ourselves and each other to forge
ahead and not follow instructions explicitly. For example, during the option wind tunnelling, rather
than follow the process unequivocally we “self-wind tunnelled” using procedural rationality (Cropper
et al., 2009). To achieve this we discussed whether the generated options were feasible and fitted
the client’s requirement, thus refining the options in a less structured manner, but with excellent
results.

On one occasion however, the group became lost as we were “free styling.” Due to not following the
instructions we had missed a critical aspect of the tool and therefore had to reiterate the process.

Reflection on action
Weick, (1998) suggests that a balance is required to ensure that the bounds of rationality do not
stifle innovation. From the aforementioned examples it can be seen that dependent upon group
composition, the use of tools may vary; there is no “right” way (Weick, 1995). Creativity should be
nurtured wherever possible (Drucker, 1954) and mistakes which occur should not be dwelt upon. If a
team member is lambasted for errors, they are unlikely to engage and propose ideas again.

Whilst there are benefits from being creative, cognizance should be given to the inherent pitfalls of
not explicitly following procedures, as demonstrated by our free styling efforts. Utilisation of
reflection within double loop learning (Argyris, 1991) means that whilst mistakes may be made, the
next time the cycle is completed there should be no reoccurrence of that particular mistake and
creativity is able to flow unimpeded.



                                                                                                       4
Anticipation

Reflex Action
Prior to the client interview, the group reflexively decided to don business attire, style the room in a
particular way and offer coffee and biscuits. This decision felt like the right thing to do, as it gave a
statement of intent; that we were serious and committed. It was refreshing when the client arrived
in a hoody and was relaxed. This however, shows that our perception of the situation may not have
matched the clients.

Reflection in action
Andrew, (the warm blanket) was the spokesman for the team. His style of communication was
something unique, if in my opinion, a little too acquiescent (which I did tell him). His ability to talk
gently in an amenable manner was very different to the forthright and possibly abrasive
communication I use, this challenged my perception of what I consider normal.

Reflection on action
On my last project there were huge issues between us (the principle contractors) and the client. I
have wondered whether cultural differences were at fault as the organisations were American and
Scottish respectively. In retrospect, I think it may have been something more fundamental; the
inability to communicate in a reasonable manner throughout the organisation. I remember the
Project Director commenting that this type of project commenced well, but once the contract was
signed, the client and contractor were at loggerheads. If this was the communiqué that the Director
was sending, it is unsurprising that at the contracts termination there is still a three hundred million
pound legal claim between the organisations (Blackwell, 2012).

One of my favourite paradigms is “communication is key.” Seeing how different methods of
interaction were utilised to advocate varied perspectives in this module struck me (Wittgenstein,
1980). Referring to situational leadership theory (Hersey, 1984), the model could also be utilised for
communication. Whereby the practitioner changes their voice, pitch and language dependent upon
who their audience is. In the Navy, instructions were issued in a clear, concise and unambiguous
manner. Whilst this method has its practicalities in certain forums, I have seen people wince at my
tone or directness. Observing Andrew allowed me to understand how I could ameliorate my
communications to suit the audience. I have utilised the quintessential MBA two by two below to
demonstrate this.




                                                                                                      5
Figure 1; Situational Communication (Moseley, 2012)



Learning outcomes - Bridging the gap; Reflexive methodologies
Throughout this year, we have been told that we should be more reflective, have a sense of being
and that we should embrace new ways of practicing. However, no one elucidates on how to achieve
this. Cunliffe (2004) suggests that reflexivity is a philosophy, Gray (2007, p.496) states reflexivity is
“more than learning,” while Argyris (1991) highlights the challenge “smart people” find in being
critically reflexive. How then can I, an action orientated practititioner, moderate reflex, engender
reflection, thus becoming a practitioner of reflective philosophy?

Following a review of methodologies, I have composed a subjective model of reflective philosophy.
This considers the aspects of reflex and reflection previously discussed, with additional internal and
external trigger points.

Reflex action

Emotion
Goleman (2004) suggests that humans are driven by emotional reflex due to the evolution of the
human brain; layers of intelligence and rationality overlay primal strata. Due to this composition the
primal can overpower the rational (Goleman, 2004). Luft and Ingham (1950) suggest that
appreciation of feedback ensures the pratitioner’s cognition of how their actions are percieved
externally.

Knowing oneself, internally and externally, enables the practitioner to be cogent of emotional
manifestation and rationalise it, thereby reducing the negative, whilst            enhancing    positive
responses.
                                                                                                      6
Preconceived rationality
Schön, (2007) discusses tacit knowledge and Weick, (1993) suggests contextual reality. Both terms
suggest a preconception of rationality, whereby the practitioner has situational knowledge and
reacts reflexively. This preconception may mask contextual reality, the practitioners reaction
becomes routine, reality is not percieved and over learning occurs (Schön, 2007). Weick, (1993)
suggests that intersubjectivity allows for synthesis of opinions and minimising subjective errors.

Being open to intersubjectivity will not only strengthen groups I am part of, but also the decision
making process – thereby engendering a rationalised synthesis of reality.

Reflection on Action

Journals
Cunliffe (2004) and Gray, (2007) advocate the use of journals as a tool for reflection on action. From
a personal perspective I forsee two challenges arising from this. The first being I am overly self
critical, this aspect of my character can be destructive. To alleviate this, I should use the “cognition
of emotion” facet of my model, allowing objective self evaluation. Secondly, thought should be given
to writing in a critically reflexive manner, (Cunliffe, 2004, p. 415). This leads to evaluating oneself in a
subjectively critical style, which, due to defensive reasoning (Argyris, 1991) could be challenging to
the holistic nature of the reflexive philosophy. However, since I have precognizance of these
potential downfalls, I should now be capable of avoiding these negative processural aspects.
Furthermore, journal use should enable me to differentiate the reality of my actions against my own
subjectivity, thus promoting self awareness and a reconceptualisation of reality.




                            Figure 2; Philosophy of Reflexivity (Moseley, 2012)
                                                                                                         7
Conclusion
The final MBA vignette;

During my previous role the second person I met with an MBA was the Chief Executive of a port. From
him I gained understanding of the time and energy commitment required to complete an MBA. On
one occasion I asked him what aspects he used from the MBA, he paused, looked stricken, turned to
me and said quietly “nothing.”

This is my biggest fear; I spend this year absorbing strategies and skills, then do not use the tools,
knowledge or best practices, due to either my own non-reflective personality, or perhaps exigencies
of work. This meeting has been at the forefront of my mind throughout this year and its negativity
and potential occurrence still concerns me.

It is perhaps ironic then, that over the last two weeks whilst having no modules or assignments to
complete (save this one) I have enjoyed writing this reflection. I found myself walking around
Brighton contemplating this essay and as I looked at particular things I decomposed them into MBA
terms; the queue at airport security became a normal distribution curve, advertisements became
market strategies, my thoughts on my actions during the day were reflective and critical rather than
a stick to beat myself with. They acknowledged my failings, but saw positives and how I
could/should/would improve.

Finally, utilisation of the trigger points and acceptance of external inputs within the philosophy
model will, I hope, further open my personality and allow for more collaborative working. Embracing
the rational will, in turn, make me a better manager and person.

Perhaps there is a new trick in the old sea dog?




                                                                                                   8
Bibliography
                                                          nd
Ackermann, F. and Eden, C. (2011) making Strategy, 2 edition, London: SAGE.

Argyris, C. (1991) 'Teachingsmart people how to think', Havard Business Review, vol. 69, no. 3.

Blackwell, B. (2012) Greater Gabbard dispute rolls on as project nears finish, 17 March, [Online], Available:
http://www.rechargenews.com/energy/wind/article313762.ece [1 June 2012].
                                                               th
Bolman, L. and Deal, T. (2008) Reframing Organisations, 4 edition, San Francisco: John Wiley and Sons.

Cropper, S., Eden, C., Gunn, L. and K, v.d.H. (2009) 'Principles of Rationality', in Managing, Glasgow: University
of Strathclyde.

Cuncliffe, A. (2004) 'On becoming a critically reflexive practitioner', Journal of Management Education, vol. 28,
no. 4, August, pp. 407-426.

Drucker, P. (1954) The Practice of Managment, Harper and Row.
                                              st
Goleman, D. (2004) Emotional Intelligence, 1 edition, London: Bloomsbury.

Gray, D. (2007) 'Facilitating Management Learning: Developing Critical Reflection Through Reflective Tools',
Management Learning, vol. 38, no. 5, November, pp. 495-517.

Hersey, P. (1984) The Situational Leader, New York: Warner.

Jun, J. (1994) Philosophy of administration, Seoul: Daeyoung Moonhwa International.

Lindblom, C.E. (1959) 'The Science of Muddling Through', Public Administration Review, pp. 79-88.

Luft, J. and Ingham, H. (1950) Proceedings of the western training laboratory in group development, Los
Angeles: UCLA.
                                                                                           nd
Mckenna, E. and Beech, N. (2008) Human Resource Management: A Conscise Analysis, 2 edition, Harlow:
Pearson Education.
                                             st
Schon, D. (2007) The Reflective Practioner, 1 edition, London: Ashgate.
                                                     nd
Simon, H. (1957) Administrative Decision Making, 2 edition, Macmillan.
                                                                                                st
Van Der Heijden, K., Bradfield, R., Burt, G., Cairns, G. and Wright, G. (2002) The Sixth Sense, 1 edition,
Chichester: John Wiley and Sons.

Weber, M. (1947) The Theory of Social and Econmic Oganization, New York: Free Press.

Weick, K. (1993) 'The collapse of sensemaking in organizations: the Mann Gulch disaster', Administrative
Science Quarterly, vol. 38, no. 4, December, pp. 628-652.

Weick, K. (1995) Sensemaking in Organizations, Sage.

Weick, K. (1998) 'Improvisation as a mindest for organisational analysis', Organizational Science, vol. 9, no. 5,
pp. 543-555.

Whyte, W.H. (1952) Groupthink, Fortune Magazine.

Wittgenstein, L. (1980) Remarks on the philosophy of psychology, Oxford: Blackwell.



                                                                                                                9

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Basic Chemistry of Life PPT
Basic Chemistry of Life PPT Basic Chemistry of Life PPT
Basic Chemistry of Life PPT mszeron
 
1 بحث مشروع التخرج
1 بحث مشروع التخرج1 بحث مشروع التخرج
1 بحث مشروع التخرجZaid Alsahagi
 
الويب 1 2-3
الويب 1 2-3الويب 1 2-3
الويب 1 2-3fatimah991
 
Nanosensors in food safety
Nanosensors in food safetyNanosensors in food safety
Nanosensors in food safetyMelih Erdem
 
Dewey arabic tabels
Dewey arabic tabelsDewey arabic tabels
Dewey arabic tabelsmarym_hany
 
Lecture#01 (Cell structure and function).pptx
Lecture#01 (Cell structure and function).pptxLecture#01 (Cell structure and function).pptx
Lecture#01 (Cell structure and function).pptxSabaMahmood22
 
أنواع-مناهج-البحث-العلمي
أنواع-مناهج-البحث-العلميأنواع-مناهج-البحث-العلمي
أنواع-مناهج-البحث-العلميHassan Hamed
 
Applications of nanobiotechnology in medicine
Applications of nanobiotechnology in medicineApplications of nanobiotechnology in medicine
Applications of nanobiotechnology in medicineRameshPandi4
 
أنواع البحث العلمى
أنواع البحث العلمىأنواع البحث العلمى
أنواع البحث العلمىSohib AlQuran
 
الباب الأول - كيمياء اولى ثانوى - مصر– الكيمياء مع د.حسن الجزار
الباب الأول - كيمياء اولى ثانوى - مصر– الكيمياء مع د.حسن الجزارالباب الأول - كيمياء اولى ثانوى - مصر– الكيمياء مع د.حسن الجزار
الباب الأول - كيمياء اولى ثانوى - مصر– الكيمياء مع د.حسن الجزارDrHassan El-gazer
 
Chapter 2 : Cell Structure and Functions
Chapter 2 : Cell Structure and FunctionsChapter 2 : Cell Structure and Functions
Chapter 2 : Cell Structure and FunctionsSimple ABbieC
 
Biological molecules
Biological moleculesBiological molecules
Biological moleculesjpochne
 
الدرس الخامس : تصنيف ديوي العشري
الدرس الخامس : تصنيف ديوي العشريالدرس الخامس : تصنيف ديوي العشري
الدرس الخامس : تصنيف ديوي العشريHamad Alhinai
 

Was ist angesagt? (18)

DNA TO PROTEIN
DNA TO PROTEINDNA TO PROTEIN
DNA TO PROTEIN
 
Basic Chemistry of Life PPT
Basic Chemistry of Life PPT Basic Chemistry of Life PPT
Basic Chemistry of Life PPT
 
1 بحث مشروع التخرج
1 بحث مشروع التخرج1 بحث مشروع التخرج
1 بحث مشروع التخرج
 
الويب 1 2-3
الويب 1 2-3الويب 1 2-3
الويب 1 2-3
 
Nanosensors in food safety
Nanosensors in food safetyNanosensors in food safety
Nanosensors in food safety
 
Dewey arabic tabels
Dewey arabic tabelsDewey arabic tabels
Dewey arabic tabels
 
Lecture#01 (Cell structure and function).pptx
Lecture#01 (Cell structure and function).pptxLecture#01 (Cell structure and function).pptx
Lecture#01 (Cell structure and function).pptx
 
atomism.pptx
atomism.pptxatomism.pptx
atomism.pptx
 
Biology ppt
Biology pptBiology ppt
Biology ppt
 
أنواع-مناهج-البحث-العلمي
أنواع-مناهج-البحث-العلميأنواع-مناهج-البحث-العلمي
أنواع-مناهج-البحث-العلمي
 
Applications of nanobiotechnology in medicine
Applications of nanobiotechnology in medicineApplications of nanobiotechnology in medicine
Applications of nanobiotechnology in medicine
 
معايير تصميم صفحات الويب
معايير تصميم صفحات الويبمعايير تصميم صفحات الويب
معايير تصميم صفحات الويب
 
أنواع البحث العلمى
أنواع البحث العلمىأنواع البحث العلمى
أنواع البحث العلمى
 
الباب الأول - كيمياء اولى ثانوى - مصر– الكيمياء مع د.حسن الجزار
الباب الأول - كيمياء اولى ثانوى - مصر– الكيمياء مع د.حسن الجزارالباب الأول - كيمياء اولى ثانوى - مصر– الكيمياء مع د.حسن الجزار
الباب الأول - كيمياء اولى ثانوى - مصر– الكيمياء مع د.حسن الجزار
 
Chapter 2 : Cell Structure and Functions
Chapter 2 : Cell Structure and FunctionsChapter 2 : Cell Structure and Functions
Chapter 2 : Cell Structure and Functions
 
Biological molecules
Biological moleculesBiological molecules
Biological molecules
 
Intro to cells
Intro to cellsIntro to cells
Intro to cells
 
الدرس الخامس : تصنيف ديوي العشري
الدرس الخامس : تصنيف ديوي العشريالدرس الخامس : تصنيف ديوي العشري
الدرس الخامس : تصنيف ديوي العشري
 

Andere mochten auch

First Presentation
First PresentationFirst Presentation
First Presentationkevintr
 
Ehrlich-Geiger-Presentation
Ehrlich-Geiger-PresentationEhrlich-Geiger-Presentation
Ehrlich-Geiger-Presentationjulietgeiger
 
2 tarih icinde turk edebiyatı
2   tarih icinde turk edebiyatı2   tarih icinde turk edebiyatı
2 tarih icinde turk edebiyatıUmut Açıkgöz
 
Coronado Real Estate - Distinctive Homes Magazine - Gerri-Lynn Fives
Coronado Real Estate - Distinctive Homes Magazine - Gerri-Lynn FivesCoronado Real Estate - Distinctive Homes Magazine - Gerri-Lynn Fives
Coronado Real Estate - Distinctive Homes Magazine - Gerri-Lynn Fivescoronado4sale
 
Marketing on Facebook - Best Practice Guide
Marketing on Facebook - Best Practice GuideMarketing on Facebook - Best Practice Guide
Marketing on Facebook - Best Practice GuideTrần Đình Khánh
 
Finance and Financial Management.
Finance and Financial Management.Finance and Financial Management.
Finance and Financial Management.Justin Moseley
 
Waste management & M-commerce in Bangladesh
Waste management & M-commerce in BangladeshWaste management & M-commerce in Bangladesh
Waste management & M-commerce in BangladeshSabrina Ferdousi
 
Strategy Analysis and Evaluation
Strategy Analysis and EvaluationStrategy Analysis and Evaluation
Strategy Analysis and EvaluationJustin Moseley
 
Strategic consulting services
Strategic consulting servicesStrategic consulting services
Strategic consulting servicesAmit Gupte
 

Andere mochten auch (19)

Betonarme yapilar
Betonarme yapilarBetonarme yapilar
Betonarme yapilar
 
Itc presentation sabrina
Itc presentation sabrinaItc presentation sabrina
Itc presentation sabrina
 
First Presentation
First PresentationFirst Presentation
First Presentation
 
My baby book
My baby bookMy baby book
My baby book
 
Ehrlich-Geiger-Presentation
Ehrlich-Geiger-PresentationEhrlich-Geiger-Presentation
Ehrlich-Geiger-Presentation
 
2 tarih icinde turk edebiyatı
2   tarih icinde turk edebiyatı2   tarih icinde turk edebiyatı
2 tarih icinde turk edebiyatı
 
2009 mat 4
2009  mat 42009  mat 4
2009 mat 4
 
Coronado Real Estate - Distinctive Homes Magazine - Gerri-Lynn Fives
Coronado Real Estate - Distinctive Homes Magazine - Gerri-Lynn FivesCoronado Real Estate - Distinctive Homes Magazine - Gerri-Lynn Fives
Coronado Real Estate - Distinctive Homes Magazine - Gerri-Lynn Fives
 
Making Strategy.
Making Strategy. Making Strategy.
Making Strategy.
 
Marketing on Facebook - Best Practice Guide
Marketing on Facebook - Best Practice GuideMarketing on Facebook - Best Practice Guide
Marketing on Facebook - Best Practice Guide
 
Edebi sanatlar
Edebi sanatlarEdebi sanatlar
Edebi sanatlar
 
Finance and Financial Management.
Finance and Financial Management.Finance and Financial Management.
Finance and Financial Management.
 
Imla kurallari
Imla kurallariImla kurallari
Imla kurallari
 
Waste management & M-commerce in Bangladesh
Waste management & M-commerce in BangladeshWaste management & M-commerce in Bangladesh
Waste management & M-commerce in Bangladesh
 
Strategy Analysis and Evaluation
Strategy Analysis and EvaluationStrategy Analysis and Evaluation
Strategy Analysis and Evaluation
 
New zealand
New zealandNew zealand
New zealand
 
Marketing Managment.
Marketing Managment. Marketing Managment.
Marketing Managment.
 
Strategic thinking
Strategic thinkingStrategic thinking
Strategic thinking
 
Strategic consulting services
Strategic consulting servicesStrategic consulting services
Strategic consulting services
 

Ähnlich wie Strategic Consulting in Practice

Mohamed s leadership_style
Mohamed s leadership_styleMohamed s leadership_style
Mohamed s leadership_styleResultsUK
 
Leading Effective Change
Leading Effective ChangeLeading Effective Change
Leading Effective ChangeKate Loge
 
Managing Oneself And Reflective Practise Drucker Hackett
Managing Oneself And Reflective Practise Drucker   HackettManaging Oneself And Reflective Practise Drucker   Hackett
Managing Oneself And Reflective Practise Drucker HackettNaomi Smith
 
Emergent Practices_Masters Literature Review_Theory of Practice
Emergent Practices_Masters Literature Review_Theory of PracticeEmergent Practices_Masters Literature Review_Theory of Practice
Emergent Practices_Masters Literature Review_Theory of PracticeRae Stacy
 
Thought Leadership International Journal
Thought Leadership International JournalThought Leadership International Journal
Thought Leadership International Journalrobinryde
 
Managing Transition Workshop
Managing Transition WorkshopManaging Transition Workshop
Managing Transition WorkshopAnil Saxena
 
School Of Engineering And Digital Arts
School Of Engineering And Digital ArtsSchool Of Engineering And Digital Arts
School Of Engineering And Digital ArtsLisa Kennedy
 
Embracing the paradoxes of leadership
Embracing the paradoxes of leadershipEmbracing the paradoxes of leadership
Embracing the paradoxes of leadershipAlex Clapson
 
Vision--A MUST - Final Paper
Vision--A MUST - Final PaperVision--A MUST - Final Paper
Vision--A MUST - Final PaperLori S. Jacobson
 
HRM3120Individual and Organisati.docx
HRM3120Individual and Organisati.docxHRM3120Individual and Organisati.docx
HRM3120Individual and Organisati.docxwellesleyterresa
 
The Use Of Supervision To Develop Reflective Practice
The Use Of Supervision  To Develop  Reflective PracticeThe Use Of Supervision  To Develop  Reflective Practice
The Use Of Supervision To Develop Reflective Practicegaz12000
 
Deloitte inclusive leadership__march 2012 v2.0
Deloitte inclusive leadership__march 2012 v2.0Deloitte inclusive leadership__march 2012 v2.0
Deloitte inclusive leadership__march 2012 v2.0Megha Gupta
 
Persuaive Essay. School essay: Persuasive essay topis
Persuaive Essay. School essay: Persuasive essay topisPersuaive Essay. School essay: Persuasive essay topis
Persuaive Essay. School essay: Persuasive essay topisElizabeth Pardue
 
Respond to PeersReview several of your classmates’ posts, and.docx
Respond to PeersReview several of your classmates’ posts, and.docxRespond to PeersReview several of your classmates’ posts, and.docx
Respond to PeersReview several of your classmates’ posts, and.docxcarlstromcurtis
 
EXTRA CREDITWe just finished watching 12 Angry Men, a movie which .docx
EXTRA CREDITWe just finished watching 12 Angry Men, a movie which .docxEXTRA CREDITWe just finished watching 12 Angry Men, a movie which .docx
EXTRA CREDITWe just finished watching 12 Angry Men, a movie which .docxssuser454af01
 

Ähnlich wie Strategic Consulting in Practice (20)

Mohamed s leadership_style
Mohamed s leadership_styleMohamed s leadership_style
Mohamed s leadership_style
 
Leading Effective Change
Leading Effective ChangeLeading Effective Change
Leading Effective Change
 
Managing Oneself And Reflective Practise Drucker Hackett
Managing Oneself And Reflective Practise Drucker   HackettManaging Oneself And Reflective Practise Drucker   Hackett
Managing Oneself And Reflective Practise Drucker Hackett
 
Barriers to leadership
Barriers to leadershipBarriers to leadership
Barriers to leadership
 
Emergent Practices_Masters Literature Review_Theory of Practice
Emergent Practices_Masters Literature Review_Theory of PracticeEmergent Practices_Masters Literature Review_Theory of Practice
Emergent Practices_Masters Literature Review_Theory of Practice
 
Thought Leadership International Journal
Thought Leadership International JournalThought Leadership International Journal
Thought Leadership International Journal
 
Managing Transition Workshop
Managing Transition WorkshopManaging Transition Workshop
Managing Transition Workshop
 
School Of Engineering And Digital Arts
School Of Engineering And Digital ArtsSchool Of Engineering And Digital Arts
School Of Engineering And Digital Arts
 
Embracing the paradoxes of leadership
Embracing the paradoxes of leadershipEmbracing the paradoxes of leadership
Embracing the paradoxes of leadership
 
Vision--A MUST - Final Paper
Vision--A MUST - Final PaperVision--A MUST - Final Paper
Vision--A MUST - Final Paper
 
HRM3120Individual and Organisati.docx
HRM3120Individual and Organisati.docxHRM3120Individual and Organisati.docx
HRM3120Individual and Organisati.docx
 
681 Capstone Paper Final- Michael Vega
681 Capstone Paper Final- Michael Vega681 Capstone Paper Final- Michael Vega
681 Capstone Paper Final- Michael Vega
 
The Use Of Supervision To Develop Reflective Practice
The Use Of Supervision  To Develop  Reflective PracticeThe Use Of Supervision  To Develop  Reflective Practice
The Use Of Supervision To Develop Reflective Practice
 
INTS3350_ME_DPA
INTS3350_ME_DPAINTS3350_ME_DPA
INTS3350_ME_DPA
 
Deloitte inclusive leadership__march 2012 v2.0
Deloitte inclusive leadership__march 2012 v2.0Deloitte inclusive leadership__march 2012 v2.0
Deloitte inclusive leadership__march 2012 v2.0
 
Persuaive Essay. School essay: Persuasive essay topis
Persuaive Essay. School essay: Persuasive essay topisPersuaive Essay. School essay: Persuasive essay topis
Persuaive Essay. School essay: Persuasive essay topis
 
Respond to PeersReview several of your classmates’ posts, and.docx
Respond to PeersReview several of your classmates’ posts, and.docxRespond to PeersReview several of your classmates’ posts, and.docx
Respond to PeersReview several of your classmates’ posts, and.docx
 
朝邦對話新訊息 August cpyf dialogue newsletter
朝邦對話新訊息 August cpyf dialogue newsletter朝邦對話新訊息 August cpyf dialogue newsletter
朝邦對話新訊息 August cpyf dialogue newsletter
 
EXTRA CREDITWe just finished watching 12 Angry Men, a movie which .docx
EXTRA CREDITWe just finished watching 12 Angry Men, a movie which .docxEXTRA CREDITWe just finished watching 12 Angry Men, a movie which .docx
EXTRA CREDITWe just finished watching 12 Angry Men, a movie which .docx
 
RPL Masterclass(v2)
RPL Masterclass(v2)RPL Masterclass(v2)
RPL Masterclass(v2)
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...meghakumariji156
 
joint cost.pptx COST ACCOUNTING Sixteenth Edition ...
joint cost.pptx  COST ACCOUNTING  Sixteenth Edition                          ...joint cost.pptx  COST ACCOUNTING  Sixteenth Edition                          ...
joint cost.pptx COST ACCOUNTING Sixteenth Edition ...NadhimTaha
 
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGParadip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGpr788182
 
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al MizharAl Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizharallensay1
 
GUWAHATI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in Escort service book now
GUWAHATI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in  Escort service book nowGUWAHATI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in  Escort service book now
GUWAHATI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in Escort service book nowkapoorjyoti4444
 
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai KuwaitThe Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwaitdaisycvs
 
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR ESCORTS
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR  ESCORTSJAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR  ESCORTS
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR ESCORTSkajalroy875762
 
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableBerhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Availablepr788182
 
Marel Q1 2024 Investor Presentation from May 8, 2024
Marel Q1 2024 Investor Presentation from May 8, 2024Marel Q1 2024 Investor Presentation from May 8, 2024
Marel Q1 2024 Investor Presentation from May 8, 2024Marel
 
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60% in 6 Months
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60%  in 6 MonthsSEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60%  in 6 Months
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60% in 6 MonthsIndeedSEO
 
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for ViewingMckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for ViewingNauman Safdar
 
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165meghakumariji156
 
Kalyan Call Girl 98350*37198 Call Girls in Escort service book now
Kalyan Call Girl 98350*37198 Call Girls in Escort service book nowKalyan Call Girl 98350*37198 Call Girls in Escort service book now
Kalyan Call Girl 98350*37198 Call Girls in Escort service book nowranineha57744
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business PotentialFalcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business PotentialFalcon investment
 
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAIGetting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAITim Wilson
 
CROSS CULTURAL NEGOTIATION BY PANMISEM NS
CROSS CULTURAL NEGOTIATION BY PANMISEM NSCROSS CULTURAL NEGOTIATION BY PANMISEM NS
CROSS CULTURAL NEGOTIATION BY PANMISEM NSpanmisemningshen123
 
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityHow to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityEric T. Tung
 
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration PresentationUneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentationuneakwhite
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
 
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond InsightsWheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
 
joint cost.pptx COST ACCOUNTING Sixteenth Edition ...
joint cost.pptx  COST ACCOUNTING  Sixteenth Edition                          ...joint cost.pptx  COST ACCOUNTING  Sixteenth Edition                          ...
joint cost.pptx COST ACCOUNTING Sixteenth Edition ...
 
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGParadip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
 
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al MizharAl Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
 
GUWAHATI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in Escort service book now
GUWAHATI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in  Escort service book nowGUWAHATI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in  Escort service book now
GUWAHATI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in Escort service book now
 
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai KuwaitThe Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
 
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR ESCORTS
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR  ESCORTSJAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR  ESCORTS
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR ESCORTS
 
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableBerhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Marel Q1 2024 Investor Presentation from May 8, 2024
Marel Q1 2024 Investor Presentation from May 8, 2024Marel Q1 2024 Investor Presentation from May 8, 2024
Marel Q1 2024 Investor Presentation from May 8, 2024
 
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60% in 6 Months
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60%  in 6 MonthsSEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60%  in 6 Months
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60% in 6 Months
 
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for ViewingMckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
 
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
 
Kalyan Call Girl 98350*37198 Call Girls in Escort service book now
Kalyan Call Girl 98350*37198 Call Girls in Escort service book nowKalyan Call Girl 98350*37198 Call Girls in Escort service book now
Kalyan Call Girl 98350*37198 Call Girls in Escort service book now
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business PotentialFalcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
 
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAIGetting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
 
CROSS CULTURAL NEGOTIATION BY PANMISEM NS
CROSS CULTURAL NEGOTIATION BY PANMISEM NSCROSS CULTURAL NEGOTIATION BY PANMISEM NS
CROSS CULTURAL NEGOTIATION BY PANMISEM NS
 
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityHow to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
 
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration PresentationUneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
 

Strategic Consulting in Practice

  • 1. Word count: 2497 SKIP? SKIP? SCiP! Critical Reflexivity; smoke and mirrors or philosophy? Justin Moseley; 201162717. Professor T. Mullen and Miss C. Reid
  • 2. CONTENTS Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 2 Adaptation .............................................................................................................................................. 2 Reflex action........................................................................................................................................ 2 Reflection in action ............................................................................................................................. 3 Reflection on action ............................................................................................................................ 3 Application .............................................................................................................................................. 4 Reflex Action ....................................................................................................................................... 4 Reflection in action ............................................................................................................................. 4 Reflection on action ............................................................................................................................ 4 Anticipation ............................................................................................................................................. 5 Reflex Action ....................................................................................................................................... 5 Reflection in action ............................................................................................................................. 5 Reflection on action ............................................................................................................................ 5 Learning outcomes - Bridging the gap; Reflexive methodologies .......................................................... 6 Reflex action........................................................................................................................................ 6 Emotion ........................................................................................................................................... 6 Preconceived rationality ................................................................................................................. 7 Reflection on Action............................................................................................................................ 7 Journals ........................................................................................................................................... 7 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................... 8 Bibliography ............................................................................................................................................ 9 TABLE OF FIGURES FIGURE 1; SITUATIONAL COMMUNICATION (MOSELEY, 2012) 6 FIGURE 2; PHILOSOPHY OF REFLEXIVE REFLECTION (MOSELEY, 2012) 7 1
  • 3. Critical Reflexivity; smoke and mirrors or philosophy? Introduction My life has been primarily spent within institutions. I attended boarding school and then spent twenty years working in the Merchant Navy. Three years ago I came ashore to work on a large offshore construction project. During this latter tenure I met two MBA’s, both of whom were instrumental in my attendance of this course. Furthermore, they gave me pause for thought in two varying different ways. I discovered John had an MBA. Through our discussions I began to form an idea of what it was and what it meant to achieve this qualification. However, one aspect I did not “get” during our conversation was that he stated how incredibly frustrating it was working on the project. This was due to his cognizance of how things should be done, as opposed to how things were done. I now have an altered view of the project from time and spatial perspectives. I also have a perception of strategic tools and best practices, which prior to attending Strathclyde I did not even know existed. Through this insight I understand John’s frustration. Furthermore, I now see how issues could have been ameliorated or avoided if the project personnel were more open minded and not involved in poor management practices which, in retrospect, were pervasive. My challenge is that I am not a naturally reflective person. Moreover, due to the nature of my action orientated employment I was the quintessential “energetic problem solver” (Van Der Heijden et al., 2002, p.230). My challenge is how, or can, I transit through the managerial spectrum in order to become a reflective practitioner (Schön, 2007)? Adaptation Reflex action On the initial morning of SCiP I was a little nervous about whom my team would be. My concern was due to my perception of some individuals within the cohort and the feeling that that they would not match my standards. However, my reflex thinking was counterproductive; sometimes as a manager you may be placed within an unknown group and have to ensure high performance regardless of composition. Ultimately the team was formed from two self-selected groups, and a part time student. My reaction to this was satisfaction; I had not worked with the other full timers, though I was aware of their high performing reputation. I was however, concerned about the unknown qualities of the part time member. The irony of this misperception is not lost on me, as Andrew 2
  • 4. performed very well. A salutary lesson is to be consistently open minded and to embrace the unknown. Initially in the syndicate room, I noticed that the two self-select teams reflexively sat together at opposite ends of the table. Using Bolman and Deals (2008) frames I was conscious of potential conflict arising if we did not integrate. I altered my seating and sat with the other group thus reducing the potential of factionalisation. Reflection in action Through the course of the next few days it became apparent that the group created a richness of discussion and were adroit at avoiding groupthink (Whyte, 1952). However, the counterpoint of this richness was that we were affected with “paralysis by analysis.” On one occasion Andrew, stepped in and “broke the fame” (Bolman and Deal, 2008, p.13) suggesting that we split into sub sets and we worked more successfully this way. This ability to reflect whilst in action suggested by Schön (2007) gives the practitioner an aptitude to manage ambiguous and unique situations. This was an excellent learning process; sometimes I become entrenched in a feedback loop of non-optimal decision making, where I am unable or not open to seeing better solutions. Reflection on action My tenure in the Merchant Navy training developed my leadership ability. This is not what would be considered a democracy due to the explicit hierarchy; it lies within the “structural” leadership frame (Bolman and Deal, 2008). My challenge is that I am no longer at sea and requirements ashore differ. Due to my training, background and strength of character there is a reflexive propensity for me to dominate groups. Mckenna and Beech (2008) suggest it would be beneficial to utilise “tranformational leadership,” whereby I lead by example and empower others. However, due to my force of character, leading by example can be detrimental as I can seem overbearing. Moreover, what I consider to be empowering people may be perceived as giving orders. I have developed strategies to ensure all group members have an opportunity to give their input. For example, one method I applied was ensuring the group gave their opinion first. I found if I gave my perspective initially, I felt people just agreed with me (or otherwise I am right, A LOT). On joining a new group for SCiP, I decided to take a step back and see how the group developed. This gave me a new perspective; I began to comprehend different types of leadership, the explicit where you lead from the front, or the leader who stands aloof from the action, but is more adroit at seeing holistically. Using Hersey’s (1984) situational leadership model, the SCiP group was generally within the “leadership through delegation” aspect. We were all self-starters driving towards the same goal. However, after the inadequate trial presentation, the model had to be changed to “leadership through directing.” I pointed out that while we had excellent ideas, if we did not 3
  • 5. capitalise on them we would not achieve our goals. Specialised tasks were duly delegated to the group (Weber, 1947) which remotivated and refocused us and resulted in a much improved presentation. Application Reflex Action I have noticed during SCiP and previous modules that there is a reflex action of bounded limitations which some of the cohort place around themselves. I have lost count of the amount of times I have been asked or overheard “are we allowed to do this?” The difficulty arises when this fear of failure creeps into the group and stifles the innovative use of tools resulting in “satisficing” (Simon, 1957); whereby outcomes and behaviours are diluted (Cropper et al., 2009) resulting in mediocrity. Reflection in action Our SCiP group had an older demographic, we had confidence in ourselves and each other to forge ahead and not follow instructions explicitly. For example, during the option wind tunnelling, rather than follow the process unequivocally we “self-wind tunnelled” using procedural rationality (Cropper et al., 2009). To achieve this we discussed whether the generated options were feasible and fitted the client’s requirement, thus refining the options in a less structured manner, but with excellent results. On one occasion however, the group became lost as we were “free styling.” Due to not following the instructions we had missed a critical aspect of the tool and therefore had to reiterate the process. Reflection on action Weick, (1998) suggests that a balance is required to ensure that the bounds of rationality do not stifle innovation. From the aforementioned examples it can be seen that dependent upon group composition, the use of tools may vary; there is no “right” way (Weick, 1995). Creativity should be nurtured wherever possible (Drucker, 1954) and mistakes which occur should not be dwelt upon. If a team member is lambasted for errors, they are unlikely to engage and propose ideas again. Whilst there are benefits from being creative, cognizance should be given to the inherent pitfalls of not explicitly following procedures, as demonstrated by our free styling efforts. Utilisation of reflection within double loop learning (Argyris, 1991) means that whilst mistakes may be made, the next time the cycle is completed there should be no reoccurrence of that particular mistake and creativity is able to flow unimpeded. 4
  • 6. Anticipation Reflex Action Prior to the client interview, the group reflexively decided to don business attire, style the room in a particular way and offer coffee and biscuits. This decision felt like the right thing to do, as it gave a statement of intent; that we were serious and committed. It was refreshing when the client arrived in a hoody and was relaxed. This however, shows that our perception of the situation may not have matched the clients. Reflection in action Andrew, (the warm blanket) was the spokesman for the team. His style of communication was something unique, if in my opinion, a little too acquiescent (which I did tell him). His ability to talk gently in an amenable manner was very different to the forthright and possibly abrasive communication I use, this challenged my perception of what I consider normal. Reflection on action On my last project there were huge issues between us (the principle contractors) and the client. I have wondered whether cultural differences were at fault as the organisations were American and Scottish respectively. In retrospect, I think it may have been something more fundamental; the inability to communicate in a reasonable manner throughout the organisation. I remember the Project Director commenting that this type of project commenced well, but once the contract was signed, the client and contractor were at loggerheads. If this was the communiqué that the Director was sending, it is unsurprising that at the contracts termination there is still a three hundred million pound legal claim between the organisations (Blackwell, 2012). One of my favourite paradigms is “communication is key.” Seeing how different methods of interaction were utilised to advocate varied perspectives in this module struck me (Wittgenstein, 1980). Referring to situational leadership theory (Hersey, 1984), the model could also be utilised for communication. Whereby the practitioner changes their voice, pitch and language dependent upon who their audience is. In the Navy, instructions were issued in a clear, concise and unambiguous manner. Whilst this method has its practicalities in certain forums, I have seen people wince at my tone or directness. Observing Andrew allowed me to understand how I could ameliorate my communications to suit the audience. I have utilised the quintessential MBA two by two below to demonstrate this. 5
  • 7. Figure 1; Situational Communication (Moseley, 2012) Learning outcomes - Bridging the gap; Reflexive methodologies Throughout this year, we have been told that we should be more reflective, have a sense of being and that we should embrace new ways of practicing. However, no one elucidates on how to achieve this. Cunliffe (2004) suggests that reflexivity is a philosophy, Gray (2007, p.496) states reflexivity is “more than learning,” while Argyris (1991) highlights the challenge “smart people” find in being critically reflexive. How then can I, an action orientated practititioner, moderate reflex, engender reflection, thus becoming a practitioner of reflective philosophy? Following a review of methodologies, I have composed a subjective model of reflective philosophy. This considers the aspects of reflex and reflection previously discussed, with additional internal and external trigger points. Reflex action Emotion Goleman (2004) suggests that humans are driven by emotional reflex due to the evolution of the human brain; layers of intelligence and rationality overlay primal strata. Due to this composition the primal can overpower the rational (Goleman, 2004). Luft and Ingham (1950) suggest that appreciation of feedback ensures the pratitioner’s cognition of how their actions are percieved externally. Knowing oneself, internally and externally, enables the practitioner to be cogent of emotional manifestation and rationalise it, thereby reducing the negative, whilst enhancing positive responses. 6
  • 8. Preconceived rationality Schön, (2007) discusses tacit knowledge and Weick, (1993) suggests contextual reality. Both terms suggest a preconception of rationality, whereby the practitioner has situational knowledge and reacts reflexively. This preconception may mask contextual reality, the practitioners reaction becomes routine, reality is not percieved and over learning occurs (Schön, 2007). Weick, (1993) suggests that intersubjectivity allows for synthesis of opinions and minimising subjective errors. Being open to intersubjectivity will not only strengthen groups I am part of, but also the decision making process – thereby engendering a rationalised synthesis of reality. Reflection on Action Journals Cunliffe (2004) and Gray, (2007) advocate the use of journals as a tool for reflection on action. From a personal perspective I forsee two challenges arising from this. The first being I am overly self critical, this aspect of my character can be destructive. To alleviate this, I should use the “cognition of emotion” facet of my model, allowing objective self evaluation. Secondly, thought should be given to writing in a critically reflexive manner, (Cunliffe, 2004, p. 415). This leads to evaluating oneself in a subjectively critical style, which, due to defensive reasoning (Argyris, 1991) could be challenging to the holistic nature of the reflexive philosophy. However, since I have precognizance of these potential downfalls, I should now be capable of avoiding these negative processural aspects. Furthermore, journal use should enable me to differentiate the reality of my actions against my own subjectivity, thus promoting self awareness and a reconceptualisation of reality. Figure 2; Philosophy of Reflexivity (Moseley, 2012) 7
  • 9. Conclusion The final MBA vignette; During my previous role the second person I met with an MBA was the Chief Executive of a port. From him I gained understanding of the time and energy commitment required to complete an MBA. On one occasion I asked him what aspects he used from the MBA, he paused, looked stricken, turned to me and said quietly “nothing.” This is my biggest fear; I spend this year absorbing strategies and skills, then do not use the tools, knowledge or best practices, due to either my own non-reflective personality, or perhaps exigencies of work. This meeting has been at the forefront of my mind throughout this year and its negativity and potential occurrence still concerns me. It is perhaps ironic then, that over the last two weeks whilst having no modules or assignments to complete (save this one) I have enjoyed writing this reflection. I found myself walking around Brighton contemplating this essay and as I looked at particular things I decomposed them into MBA terms; the queue at airport security became a normal distribution curve, advertisements became market strategies, my thoughts on my actions during the day were reflective and critical rather than a stick to beat myself with. They acknowledged my failings, but saw positives and how I could/should/would improve. Finally, utilisation of the trigger points and acceptance of external inputs within the philosophy model will, I hope, further open my personality and allow for more collaborative working. Embracing the rational will, in turn, make me a better manager and person. Perhaps there is a new trick in the old sea dog? 8
  • 10. Bibliography nd Ackermann, F. and Eden, C. (2011) making Strategy, 2 edition, London: SAGE. Argyris, C. (1991) 'Teachingsmart people how to think', Havard Business Review, vol. 69, no. 3. Blackwell, B. (2012) Greater Gabbard dispute rolls on as project nears finish, 17 March, [Online], Available: http://www.rechargenews.com/energy/wind/article313762.ece [1 June 2012]. th Bolman, L. and Deal, T. (2008) Reframing Organisations, 4 edition, San Francisco: John Wiley and Sons. Cropper, S., Eden, C., Gunn, L. and K, v.d.H. (2009) 'Principles of Rationality', in Managing, Glasgow: University of Strathclyde. Cuncliffe, A. (2004) 'On becoming a critically reflexive practitioner', Journal of Management Education, vol. 28, no. 4, August, pp. 407-426. Drucker, P. (1954) The Practice of Managment, Harper and Row. st Goleman, D. (2004) Emotional Intelligence, 1 edition, London: Bloomsbury. Gray, D. (2007) 'Facilitating Management Learning: Developing Critical Reflection Through Reflective Tools', Management Learning, vol. 38, no. 5, November, pp. 495-517. Hersey, P. (1984) The Situational Leader, New York: Warner. Jun, J. (1994) Philosophy of administration, Seoul: Daeyoung Moonhwa International. Lindblom, C.E. (1959) 'The Science of Muddling Through', Public Administration Review, pp. 79-88. Luft, J. and Ingham, H. (1950) Proceedings of the western training laboratory in group development, Los Angeles: UCLA. nd Mckenna, E. and Beech, N. (2008) Human Resource Management: A Conscise Analysis, 2 edition, Harlow: Pearson Education. st Schon, D. (2007) The Reflective Practioner, 1 edition, London: Ashgate. nd Simon, H. (1957) Administrative Decision Making, 2 edition, Macmillan. st Van Der Heijden, K., Bradfield, R., Burt, G., Cairns, G. and Wright, G. (2002) The Sixth Sense, 1 edition, Chichester: John Wiley and Sons. Weber, M. (1947) The Theory of Social and Econmic Oganization, New York: Free Press. Weick, K. (1993) 'The collapse of sensemaking in organizations: the Mann Gulch disaster', Administrative Science Quarterly, vol. 38, no. 4, December, pp. 628-652. Weick, K. (1995) Sensemaking in Organizations, Sage. Weick, K. (1998) 'Improvisation as a mindest for organisational analysis', Organizational Science, vol. 9, no. 5, pp. 543-555. Whyte, W.H. (1952) Groupthink, Fortune Magazine. Wittgenstein, L. (1980) Remarks on the philosophy of psychology, Oxford: Blackwell. 9