SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 11
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Citizens' Appeal: Ensuring expeditious and
timely justice to all
Establishing an effective criminal justice system
with emphasis on Under-trial prisoners
TEAM
Group Coordinator: Arpita Mitra
Members: Quratulain Mushtaque, Aishwarya Khanna,
Deepali Dutta, Navdeep Kaur
It is a matter of deep concern that the bulk of cases pending (nearly 60 to 65
percent), relate to criminal matters, with a staggering proportion of 64.7 percent
of under-trials cases, resultant issue of overcrowded prisons and human rights
violation at multiple levels.
As per prison statistics of National
Crime Bureau, total capacity of Jails in
the country: 3,32,782; Total Number
of Jail Inmates as on 31.12.2011 :
3,72,926. The number of under-trial
prisoners has increased by 0.5% in
2011 (2,41,200) over 2010 (2,40,098).
However, a staggering number of
under-trials are imprisoned for a
longer term than even the most
rigorous sentence would have ever
been.
Source: http://ncrb.gov.in/PSI-2011/Graphs-2011.pdf
In our attempt to hypothesize, these crucial issues within the ambit of
criminal justice finds focus and emphasis of the subsequent analysis
Ineffective identification and lack of adequate institutional arrangement of/for under-trial prisoners:
Pertaining to classification of under-trial prisoners from previously existing hardened criminals,
especially in the case of juvenile delinquents and other categories of prisoners to appropriate
channelize prison reforms.
Infrastructural inadequacy and lack of institutionalization to promote demarcation of various
categories of prisoners, considering a backlog of 35,000 cases with the Supreme Court of India,
350,000 with the high courts and over 25 million with the subordinate courts.
2. Inapplicability of archaic provisions as part of Prison Manuals without adequate revisions as per
the subject to present circumstances
- Understanding the context in which the crime takes place, the larger sociological parameters and
trends of nature of crime to be recognized before law can be formulated and implemented.
Concept of Human rights violation and lack of recognition of the inalienable rights of prisoners; in
relation to implementation to various welfare schemes pertaining to them (such as pre-natal, post-
natal care for pregnant prisoners), together with denial of Acts and Constitutional Provisions. For
instance Section 437(6) is to be enacted to prevent this and makes it mandatory for a person to be
released on bail where the trial has not concluded within 60 days from the first date fixed for taking
evidence. Section 436-A20 which spells out the right of an under-trial prisoner to apply for bail once
she/he has served one half of the maximum term of sentence she/he would have served had she/he
been convicted.
4.
Inadequacies and
underutilization in/of Bail
Provisions:
Inaccessibility due to
monetary-financial crisis.
they are found to rot in
prisons due to exorbitantly
high bail amount. The
hierarchy of courts and with
appeals after appeal have
led to a situation where the
poor cannot reach the
temple of justice due to
heavy cost of its access. In
other words one can state
that granting justice at a
higher cost indirectly means
the denial of justice. Such
circumstances lead to a clear
violation of the Supreme
Court judgment which held,
legal aid to a poor is a
constitutional mandate not
only by virtue of Article 39A
but also Articles 14, 19, 21
which cannot be denied by
the government
5.
Lack of Accountability and
Objective criteria for
Prison Management
In terms of the debate
between concern of Prison
and Prisoners as a State
subject vs the prerogative
of the Centre to ensure
accountability on a larger
level.
In terms of Prison
administration: Prison
authorities and their
responsibility to ensure
decentralization of work
and responsibility to
ensure justice even inside
the prisons, undermining
which promote physical
abuse and custodial
violence and death for the
under-trial prisoners- who
are subjected to a form of
brutality that the law
doesn’t recognize as
‘being deserved’.
6.
Objective/ Outlook of
Prison and Judicial
provisions in criminal
cases
Faulty understanding of
emphasis on ‘punitive’
aspect, and not the
concept of rehabilitation
and reformation of the
prisoner
Denies existence of a
prisoner as a human being
“A huge majority of under-trial prisoners are poor, who have no lawyers, access to
adequate medical care and thereby subjected to torture and exploitation”
Proposed suggestions
•Pertaining to
involvement of
the prisoner in
her/his
concerned
case
•Suggestive
element as to
how to ensure
speedy justice
procedurally
Logistical and
Procedural
• Awareness/Knowledge of the
prisoner about the welfare
schemes s/he is eligible to
avail, specially pertaining to
women prisoners and
juvenile delinquents
• Rights of the Prisoner, for the
contestation and deliberation
happens over her/his crime,
which should be delinked
with the person’s
individualistic identity in
relation to the social- as a
human being having the right
to access their inalienable
rights- especially right to Life.
• Clarity in institutional
structures dealing directly
with under-trial pending
cases.
• Resolving debate
concerning Prisons as a
State subject vs Centre’s
concern. Ultimately these
indivuals can determine
both favourable and
unfavourable situations for
the community as a whole.
• Proper registration and
record-keeping in regard to
under-trial prisoners: seek
transparency
• Ensuring legal rights of
prisoners and Right to Plea
Bargaining.
• Court proceedings, video-
conferencing facility to be
introduced.
•Community
awareness and
community
involvement
•Understanding
context of crime
•Under-trial prisoners
be offered with
stimulating activities
and vocational
training- role of NGOs
have been crucial.
Administration and
accountability
Identification and Access
to Legal-social rights
Coping mechanism
and change in outlook
Logistical and Procedural Approach to modifying the present setup for under-
trial prisoners (Identification)
1.
•Ensure separation of the following categories of prisoners: a) Women (b) Young offenders (c) Under-trials (d)
Convicts (e) Civil prisoners (f) Detenues (g) high security prisoners, for more systematic processes to avail
welfare schemes.
2.
•Use of Technology: For first time offenders especially, and under-trial prisoners who await their case to be
deliberated in the continuous Court proceedings, video-conferencing facility to be introduced. Already
experimented in Tihar/ Rohini Jails, it seeks to strengthen prison security, save manpower-equipment-and
transportation.
3.
•Recommending application and implementation of ‘Committee on Rationalization of Classification of
Prisoners’ (1997), suggesting a set of categories by which prisoners should be segregated: Gender, Convicts,
Under-trials, Age, Nature of Crime, Previous history, Prison term, Kind of sentence awarded and so on
4.
•Instituting the Mulla Committee Report to avoid redundancy in existing Prison Manual provisions, and
update provisions as per the change in context. Under-trial prisoners should be lodged in separate
institutions away from convicted prisoners. There should be proper and classification even among under-
trial prisoners to ensure that contamination of first time and petty offenders into full fledged and hardened
criminals does not take place
5.
• Bail Amount Management: Systematic implementation of Sections 107-10 of the Criminal
Procedure Code, whereby it states how a prohibitive bail amount should be replaced by a token
bail amount, accounting for poverty as an impediment to seek justice
Prison Administrative System
Prison Administrative System
Examining people who administer
prisons
Need for implementation of an
already existing law: to create a
Board which is expected to meet a
certain number of times a year, to
facilitate inspection of a certain
number of cases and ensure
submission of report to the
concerned Minister and the
Parliament, which in effect fails to
be implemented
Need for adequate shelter homes and
correctional institutions
Inadequate provisions for juvenile
delinquents, together with reflection
on lack of adequate mechanisms to
record details about the prisoner. A
database is to be framed with specific
focus on children, mentally-challenged
prisoners with special provisions
The executive personnel in
prison i.e. the Superintendents,
Additional Superintendents,
Deputy Superintendents,
Assistant Superintendents and
the guards staff are entrusted
with the primary responsibility
to ensure that the human rights
which the prisoners are entitled
to are not impinged upon and
restricted beyond the limit
inherent in the process of
incarceration itself.
Administration and Accountability (Judiciary,
Organizations and the Community)
Alternatives to Imprisonment: Anger management and counseling strategies to be introduced
by courts. Support from Community involvement in relation to organizations and NGOs is
significant in devising coping mechanisms. Special emphasis also remain on non-custodial
strategies to be implemented for women during pregnancy.
Addressing Prisoner’s concerns and complaints through the Prison Grievance Box where they
can write in their issues which must be systematically addressed, even if be on an anonymous
level- due to sensitivity of the content shared.
Change in Outlook- from focus on punitive aspects and punishment to prisoners to prisoner
rehabilitation. This can be combined with incorporation of ideas from models of dealing with
criminal justice, especially in Singapore- The Yellow Ribbon Project takes in account the social
stigma faced by individuals in prisons and employing community involvement to deal with it
Instituting the Mulla Committee Report. Also promoting implementation of some of the
crucial clauses of the Model Prison Manual, with important guarantees essential for
safeguarding the rights of the prisoners: Right to Bail, Institutionalized Mechanism to address
Grievances, Right to living accommodation, hygiene, food-clothing.
Emphasis on legal rights of prisoners and right to Plea Bargaining procedure.
Possibilities and hindrances
A major factor determining the potential of this framework
is the establishment of a well-connected, well-networked
system. Financial strains and technological efficiency can
pose a risk to the effective implementation of these ideas.
Also the systematic procedure to even debate upon the
unanimous and obligatory implementation of some of the
modules and Manuals can acquire a lot of time duration and
resources.
However, considering the Judicial system’s attempt to work
on the prospects of increasing efficiency in the arena of
Criminal Justice and Legal reform, the framework proposed
is a plausible option. It takes 15 years on average to conduct
disposition of one case, which is conceived to be reduced to
3 years by 2030.
On an overall understanding, the attempt has been to weave a broader definition of
Justice for the under-trial prisoners.
This looks into timely justice and expeditious form of justice- which is routinely and
systematically denied to the under-trial prisoners at multiple levels. The emphasis
remains on not a fast-track court, but fast manner of conducting proceedings that do
not exert pressure on existing institutional structures of the Judiciary, yet at the
same time does not result in overcrowding of prisons with inadequate provisions
together with an observance of denial and ignorance of human inalienable rights.
The approach therefore attempts to identify the importance of a well-coordinated
system and approach to deal with layers of hidden abuse /exploitation alongwith
delayed investigation and delayed trials, Ultimately viewing the issue from multiple
angle and dimensions , specially from the perspective of a prisoner and her/his
experience assist us in the process of establishing an effective criminal system.
Sources:
http://www.humanrights.asia/resources/journals-magazines/article2/0204/indias-
graduate-schools-of-crime
http://archive.tehelka.com/story_main46.asp?filename=Ne310710undertrial.asp
http://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/article/the-problems-of-undertrials-1280-
1.html
http://www.infochangeindia.org/human-rights/news/50000-undertrials-could-be-
freed-under-indias-new-criminal-laws.html
http://www.amnesty.org.au/news/comments/32192/
http://www.humanrightsinitiative.org/new/2010/undertrial_prisoners_&_criminal_ju
stice_system.pdf
Report on the National Consultation on Prison Reforms- HRLN 2010
© Google Images

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Andere mochten auch (19)

Queen’s day
Queen’s dayQueen’s day
Queen’s day
 
SKITIANS
SKITIANSSKITIANS
SKITIANS
 
Wasted
WastedWasted
Wasted
 
Women enpowerment.pptx11111111111
Women enpowerment.pptx11111111111Women enpowerment.pptx11111111111
Women enpowerment.pptx11111111111
 
Royal family
Royal familyRoyal family
Royal family
 
Digital Beauty Presentation, April. 2015
Digital Beauty Presentation, April. 2015Digital Beauty Presentation, April. 2015
Digital Beauty Presentation, April. 2015
 
GERUNDS AND INFINITIVES
GERUNDS AND INFINITIVESGERUNDS AND INFINITIVES
GERUNDS AND INFINITIVES
 
Social Media + Beauty Brands Trend Report
Social Media + Beauty Brands Trend ReportSocial Media + Beauty Brands Trend Report
Social Media + Beauty Brands Trend Report
 
Only5
Only5Only5
Only5
 
The cosmeceutical market - current and future outlook.
The cosmeceutical market - current and future outlook.The cosmeceutical market - current and future outlook.
The cosmeceutical market - current and future outlook.
 
Phobia ; what are you afraid of ?
Phobia ; what are you afraid of ?Phobia ; what are you afraid of ?
Phobia ; what are you afraid of ?
 
Phobia disorder
Phobia disorderPhobia disorder
Phobia disorder
 
Phobia.
Phobia. Phobia.
Phobia.
 
Self confidence presentation
Self confidence presentationSelf confidence presentation
Self confidence presentation
 
Personality development presentation
Personality development presentationPersonality development presentation
Personality development presentation
 
Personality Development
Personality DevelopmentPersonality Development
Personality Development
 
Building self confidence
Building self confidenceBuilding self confidence
Building self confidence
 
Presentation On Personality
Presentation On PersonalityPresentation On Personality
Presentation On Personality
 
PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT
PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENTPERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT
PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT
 

Ähnlich wie rebirth

Incarceration Of The United States
Incarceration Of The United StatesIncarceration Of The United States
Incarceration Of The United StatesMiz Hester
 
prison rules.pdf
prison rules.pdfprison rules.pdf
prison rules.pdfRKSKR
 
250 words each QuestionQuestion 1.  Fundamentally jails and pr.docx
250 words each QuestionQuestion 1.  Fundamentally jails and pr.docx250 words each QuestionQuestion 1.  Fundamentally jails and pr.docx
250 words each QuestionQuestion 1.  Fundamentally jails and pr.docxvickeryr87
 
United States Parole Program Compared To Australia And
United States Parole Program Compared To Australia AndUnited States Parole Program Compared To Australia And
United States Parole Program Compared To Australia AndChelsea Porter
 
CA2-LECTURE-MIDTERMNOTES FOR CRIMINOLOGY_104617.pdf
CA2-LECTURE-MIDTERMNOTES FOR CRIMINOLOGY_104617.pdfCA2-LECTURE-MIDTERMNOTES FOR CRIMINOLOGY_104617.pdf
CA2-LECTURE-MIDTERMNOTES FOR CRIMINOLOGY_104617.pdfGrena1
 
Pre-trial Detention in Zimbabwe
Pre-trial Detention in ZimbabwePre-trial Detention in Zimbabwe
Pre-trial Detention in ZimbabweDr Lendy Spires
 
_Correction Research Paper and Evaluation.docx
_Correction Research Paper and Evaluation.docx_Correction Research Paper and Evaluation.docx
_Correction Research Paper and Evaluation.docxAndrewClark295760
 
Unlocking Human Dignity: A plan to transform the US Immigrant Detention System
Unlocking Human Dignity: A plan to transform the US Immigrant Detention SystemUnlocking Human Dignity: A plan to transform the US Immigrant Detention System
Unlocking Human Dignity: A plan to transform the US Immigrant Detention SystemMarcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 
The Value Of Prison And Public Prisons
The Value Of Prison And Public PrisonsThe Value Of Prison And Public Prisons
The Value Of Prison And Public PrisonsJulie Potts
 
BCJ 2002, Theory and Practices of Corrections 1 Cour.docx
BCJ 2002, Theory and Practices of Corrections  1  Cour.docxBCJ 2002, Theory and Practices of Corrections  1  Cour.docx
BCJ 2002, Theory and Practices of Corrections 1 Cour.docxJASS44
 
Community Supervision Is Not A New Concept
Community Supervision Is Not A New ConceptCommunity Supervision Is Not A New Concept
Community Supervision Is Not A New ConceptMelissa Dudas
 
United Nations Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners and.docx
United Nations Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners and.docxUnited Nations Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners and.docx
United Nations Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners and.docxwrite5
 
Introduction to Jail Diversion
Introduction to Jail DiversionIntroduction to Jail Diversion
Introduction to Jail DiversionGilbert Gonzales
 
Prisoners, Their Rights and Reformation
Prisoners, Their Rights and ReformationPrisoners, Their Rights and Reformation
Prisoners, Their Rights and ReformationDr. Amarjeet Singh
 
Pros And Cons Of Parole Programs
Pros And Cons Of Parole ProgramsPros And Cons Of Parole Programs
Pros And Cons Of Parole ProgramsAmber Carter
 

Ähnlich wie rebirth (20)

Incarceration Of The United States
Incarceration Of The United StatesIncarceration Of The United States
Incarceration Of The United States
 
prison rules.pdf
prison rules.pdfprison rules.pdf
prison rules.pdf
 
250 words each QuestionQuestion 1.  Fundamentally jails and pr.docx
250 words each QuestionQuestion 1.  Fundamentally jails and pr.docx250 words each QuestionQuestion 1.  Fundamentally jails and pr.docx
250 words each QuestionQuestion 1.  Fundamentally jails and pr.docx
 
Parole preview
Parole previewParole preview
Parole preview
 
United States Parole Program Compared To Australia And
United States Parole Program Compared To Australia AndUnited States Parole Program Compared To Australia And
United States Parole Program Compared To Australia And
 
CA2-LECTURE-MIDTERMNOTES FOR CRIMINOLOGY_104617.pdf
CA2-LECTURE-MIDTERMNOTES FOR CRIMINOLOGY_104617.pdfCA2-LECTURE-MIDTERMNOTES FOR CRIMINOLOGY_104617.pdf
CA2-LECTURE-MIDTERMNOTES FOR CRIMINOLOGY_104617.pdf
 
Pre-trial Detention in Zimbabwe
Pre-trial Detention in ZimbabwePre-trial Detention in Zimbabwe
Pre-trial Detention in Zimbabwe
 
_Correction Research Paper and Evaluation.docx
_Correction Research Paper and Evaluation.docx_Correction Research Paper and Evaluation.docx
_Correction Research Paper and Evaluation.docx
 
RDP Chapter 6
RDP Chapter 6RDP Chapter 6
RDP Chapter 6
 
Unlocking Human Dignity: A plan to transform the US Immigrant Detention System
Unlocking Human Dignity: A plan to transform the US Immigrant Detention SystemUnlocking Human Dignity: A plan to transform the US Immigrant Detention System
Unlocking Human Dignity: A plan to transform the US Immigrant Detention System
 
Prison Over Crowding Research Paper
Prison Over Crowding Research PaperPrison Over Crowding Research Paper
Prison Over Crowding Research Paper
 
The Value Of Prison And Public Prisons
The Value Of Prison And Public PrisonsThe Value Of Prison And Public Prisons
The Value Of Prison And Public Prisons
 
BCJ 2002, Theory and Practices of Corrections 1 Cour.docx
BCJ 2002, Theory and Practices of Corrections  1  Cour.docxBCJ 2002, Theory and Practices of Corrections  1  Cour.docx
BCJ 2002, Theory and Practices of Corrections 1 Cour.docx
 
Community Supervision Is Not A New Concept
Community Supervision Is Not A New ConceptCommunity Supervision Is Not A New Concept
Community Supervision Is Not A New Concept
 
United Nations Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners and.docx
United Nations Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners and.docxUnited Nations Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners and.docx
United Nations Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners and.docx
 
Introduction to Jail Diversion
Introduction to Jail DiversionIntroduction to Jail Diversion
Introduction to Jail Diversion
 
Prison Essay
Prison EssayPrison Essay
Prison Essay
 
Prisoners, Their Rights and Reformation
Prisoners, Their Rights and ReformationPrisoners, Their Rights and Reformation
Prisoners, Their Rights and Reformation
 
Prison Overcrowding Essay
Prison Overcrowding EssayPrison Overcrowding Essay
Prison Overcrowding Essay
 
Pros And Cons Of Parole Programs
Pros And Cons Of Parole ProgramsPros And Cons Of Parole Programs
Pros And Cons Of Parole Programs
 

Mehr von Citizens for Accountable Governance (20)

Pegasus
PegasusPegasus
Pegasus
 
Boosting_skillsetsteamnbd
Boosting_skillsetsteamnbdBoosting_skillsetsteamnbd
Boosting_skillsetsteamnbd
 
Manthan iitm team
Manthan iitm teamManthan iitm team
Manthan iitm team
 
Christite2_2
Christite2_2Christite2_2
Christite2_2
 
Christite1 1
Christite1 1Christite1 1
Christite1 1
 
Vision transparent india
Vision transparent indiaVision transparent india
Vision transparent india
 
Manthan
ManthanManthan
Manthan
 
Sanitation pdf
Sanitation pdfSanitation pdf
Sanitation pdf
 
TechFidos
TechFidosTechFidos
TechFidos
 
samanvaya
samanvayasamanvaya
samanvaya
 
Women_ppt
Women_pptWomen_ppt
Women_ppt
 
Tourism_and_Border_Trade
Tourism_and_Border_TradeTourism_and_Border_Trade
Tourism_and_Border_Trade
 
Striving_towards_a_cleaner_nation
Striving_towards_a_cleaner_nationStriving_towards_a_cleaner_nation
Striving_towards_a_cleaner_nation
 
Stri_Shakti
Stri_ShaktiStri_Shakti
Stri_Shakti
 
sahas1
sahas1sahas1
sahas1
 
REIN
REINREIN
REIN
 
Reducing_malnutrition
Reducing_malnutritionReducing_malnutrition
Reducing_malnutrition
 
Pahal
PahalPahal
Pahal
 
public_distribution_system
public_distribution_systempublic_distribution_system
public_distribution_system
 
ojas1
ojas1ojas1
ojas1
 

rebirth

  • 1. Citizens' Appeal: Ensuring expeditious and timely justice to all Establishing an effective criminal justice system with emphasis on Under-trial prisoners TEAM Group Coordinator: Arpita Mitra Members: Quratulain Mushtaque, Aishwarya Khanna, Deepali Dutta, Navdeep Kaur
  • 2. It is a matter of deep concern that the bulk of cases pending (nearly 60 to 65 percent), relate to criminal matters, with a staggering proportion of 64.7 percent of under-trials cases, resultant issue of overcrowded prisons and human rights violation at multiple levels. As per prison statistics of National Crime Bureau, total capacity of Jails in the country: 3,32,782; Total Number of Jail Inmates as on 31.12.2011 : 3,72,926. The number of under-trial prisoners has increased by 0.5% in 2011 (2,41,200) over 2010 (2,40,098). However, a staggering number of under-trials are imprisoned for a longer term than even the most rigorous sentence would have ever been. Source: http://ncrb.gov.in/PSI-2011/Graphs-2011.pdf
  • 3. In our attempt to hypothesize, these crucial issues within the ambit of criminal justice finds focus and emphasis of the subsequent analysis Ineffective identification and lack of adequate institutional arrangement of/for under-trial prisoners: Pertaining to classification of under-trial prisoners from previously existing hardened criminals, especially in the case of juvenile delinquents and other categories of prisoners to appropriate channelize prison reforms. Infrastructural inadequacy and lack of institutionalization to promote demarcation of various categories of prisoners, considering a backlog of 35,000 cases with the Supreme Court of India, 350,000 with the high courts and over 25 million with the subordinate courts. 2. Inapplicability of archaic provisions as part of Prison Manuals without adequate revisions as per the subject to present circumstances - Understanding the context in which the crime takes place, the larger sociological parameters and trends of nature of crime to be recognized before law can be formulated and implemented. Concept of Human rights violation and lack of recognition of the inalienable rights of prisoners; in relation to implementation to various welfare schemes pertaining to them (such as pre-natal, post- natal care for pregnant prisoners), together with denial of Acts and Constitutional Provisions. For instance Section 437(6) is to be enacted to prevent this and makes it mandatory for a person to be released on bail where the trial has not concluded within 60 days from the first date fixed for taking evidence. Section 436-A20 which spells out the right of an under-trial prisoner to apply for bail once she/he has served one half of the maximum term of sentence she/he would have served had she/he been convicted.
  • 4. 4. Inadequacies and underutilization in/of Bail Provisions: Inaccessibility due to monetary-financial crisis. they are found to rot in prisons due to exorbitantly high bail amount. The hierarchy of courts and with appeals after appeal have led to a situation where the poor cannot reach the temple of justice due to heavy cost of its access. In other words one can state that granting justice at a higher cost indirectly means the denial of justice. Such circumstances lead to a clear violation of the Supreme Court judgment which held, legal aid to a poor is a constitutional mandate not only by virtue of Article 39A but also Articles 14, 19, 21 which cannot be denied by the government 5. Lack of Accountability and Objective criteria for Prison Management In terms of the debate between concern of Prison and Prisoners as a State subject vs the prerogative of the Centre to ensure accountability on a larger level. In terms of Prison administration: Prison authorities and their responsibility to ensure decentralization of work and responsibility to ensure justice even inside the prisons, undermining which promote physical abuse and custodial violence and death for the under-trial prisoners- who are subjected to a form of brutality that the law doesn’t recognize as ‘being deserved’. 6. Objective/ Outlook of Prison and Judicial provisions in criminal cases Faulty understanding of emphasis on ‘punitive’ aspect, and not the concept of rehabilitation and reformation of the prisoner Denies existence of a prisoner as a human being “A huge majority of under-trial prisoners are poor, who have no lawyers, access to adequate medical care and thereby subjected to torture and exploitation”
  • 5. Proposed suggestions •Pertaining to involvement of the prisoner in her/his concerned case •Suggestive element as to how to ensure speedy justice procedurally Logistical and Procedural • Awareness/Knowledge of the prisoner about the welfare schemes s/he is eligible to avail, specially pertaining to women prisoners and juvenile delinquents • Rights of the Prisoner, for the contestation and deliberation happens over her/his crime, which should be delinked with the person’s individualistic identity in relation to the social- as a human being having the right to access their inalienable rights- especially right to Life. • Clarity in institutional structures dealing directly with under-trial pending cases. • Resolving debate concerning Prisons as a State subject vs Centre’s concern. Ultimately these indivuals can determine both favourable and unfavourable situations for the community as a whole. • Proper registration and record-keeping in regard to under-trial prisoners: seek transparency • Ensuring legal rights of prisoners and Right to Plea Bargaining. • Court proceedings, video- conferencing facility to be introduced. •Community awareness and community involvement •Understanding context of crime •Under-trial prisoners be offered with stimulating activities and vocational training- role of NGOs have been crucial. Administration and accountability Identification and Access to Legal-social rights Coping mechanism and change in outlook
  • 6. Logistical and Procedural Approach to modifying the present setup for under- trial prisoners (Identification) 1. •Ensure separation of the following categories of prisoners: a) Women (b) Young offenders (c) Under-trials (d) Convicts (e) Civil prisoners (f) Detenues (g) high security prisoners, for more systematic processes to avail welfare schemes. 2. •Use of Technology: For first time offenders especially, and under-trial prisoners who await their case to be deliberated in the continuous Court proceedings, video-conferencing facility to be introduced. Already experimented in Tihar/ Rohini Jails, it seeks to strengthen prison security, save manpower-equipment-and transportation. 3. •Recommending application and implementation of ‘Committee on Rationalization of Classification of Prisoners’ (1997), suggesting a set of categories by which prisoners should be segregated: Gender, Convicts, Under-trials, Age, Nature of Crime, Previous history, Prison term, Kind of sentence awarded and so on 4. •Instituting the Mulla Committee Report to avoid redundancy in existing Prison Manual provisions, and update provisions as per the change in context. Under-trial prisoners should be lodged in separate institutions away from convicted prisoners. There should be proper and classification even among under- trial prisoners to ensure that contamination of first time and petty offenders into full fledged and hardened criminals does not take place 5. • Bail Amount Management: Systematic implementation of Sections 107-10 of the Criminal Procedure Code, whereby it states how a prohibitive bail amount should be replaced by a token bail amount, accounting for poverty as an impediment to seek justice
  • 7. Prison Administrative System Prison Administrative System Examining people who administer prisons Need for implementation of an already existing law: to create a Board which is expected to meet a certain number of times a year, to facilitate inspection of a certain number of cases and ensure submission of report to the concerned Minister and the Parliament, which in effect fails to be implemented Need for adequate shelter homes and correctional institutions Inadequate provisions for juvenile delinquents, together with reflection on lack of adequate mechanisms to record details about the prisoner. A database is to be framed with specific focus on children, mentally-challenged prisoners with special provisions The executive personnel in prison i.e. the Superintendents, Additional Superintendents, Deputy Superintendents, Assistant Superintendents and the guards staff are entrusted with the primary responsibility to ensure that the human rights which the prisoners are entitled to are not impinged upon and restricted beyond the limit inherent in the process of incarceration itself.
  • 8. Administration and Accountability (Judiciary, Organizations and the Community) Alternatives to Imprisonment: Anger management and counseling strategies to be introduced by courts. Support from Community involvement in relation to organizations and NGOs is significant in devising coping mechanisms. Special emphasis also remain on non-custodial strategies to be implemented for women during pregnancy. Addressing Prisoner’s concerns and complaints through the Prison Grievance Box where they can write in their issues which must be systematically addressed, even if be on an anonymous level- due to sensitivity of the content shared. Change in Outlook- from focus on punitive aspects and punishment to prisoners to prisoner rehabilitation. This can be combined with incorporation of ideas from models of dealing with criminal justice, especially in Singapore- The Yellow Ribbon Project takes in account the social stigma faced by individuals in prisons and employing community involvement to deal with it Instituting the Mulla Committee Report. Also promoting implementation of some of the crucial clauses of the Model Prison Manual, with important guarantees essential for safeguarding the rights of the prisoners: Right to Bail, Institutionalized Mechanism to address Grievances, Right to living accommodation, hygiene, food-clothing. Emphasis on legal rights of prisoners and right to Plea Bargaining procedure.
  • 9. Possibilities and hindrances A major factor determining the potential of this framework is the establishment of a well-connected, well-networked system. Financial strains and technological efficiency can pose a risk to the effective implementation of these ideas. Also the systematic procedure to even debate upon the unanimous and obligatory implementation of some of the modules and Manuals can acquire a lot of time duration and resources. However, considering the Judicial system’s attempt to work on the prospects of increasing efficiency in the arena of Criminal Justice and Legal reform, the framework proposed is a plausible option. It takes 15 years on average to conduct disposition of one case, which is conceived to be reduced to 3 years by 2030.
  • 10. On an overall understanding, the attempt has been to weave a broader definition of Justice for the under-trial prisoners. This looks into timely justice and expeditious form of justice- which is routinely and systematically denied to the under-trial prisoners at multiple levels. The emphasis remains on not a fast-track court, but fast manner of conducting proceedings that do not exert pressure on existing institutional structures of the Judiciary, yet at the same time does not result in overcrowding of prisons with inadequate provisions together with an observance of denial and ignorance of human inalienable rights. The approach therefore attempts to identify the importance of a well-coordinated system and approach to deal with layers of hidden abuse /exploitation alongwith delayed investigation and delayed trials, Ultimately viewing the issue from multiple angle and dimensions , specially from the perspective of a prisoner and her/his experience assist us in the process of establishing an effective criminal system.