This document discusses opportunities for a smart grid to aid a low-carbon future in the UK. It summarizes that by 2020, 35% of UK energy demand will be supplied by renewables and by 2030 the electricity system will be decarbonized while incorporating heat and transport sectors. A smart grid uses demand response and network technologies to provide flexibility instead of building redundant generation assets. The document outlines various transmission, distribution and demand-related issues that a smart grid could help address to enable high renewable penetration at lowest cost.
2. UK Energy Future
2020: 35% of energy demand to be supplied by renewable generation
2030: Decarbonisation of electricity system ....
.... while incorporating heat and transport sectors into electricity system
A major change to generation mix and demand growth.
• Cessation of (non-abated) coal and gas and existing nuclear
• 30% Wind; 30% New Nuclear; 30% New Carbon Capture Coal/Gas
Demand growth and wind integration is technically feasible
with a traditional network.
The problem would be the cost of a “dumb” approach.
So, what do we need to be “smart” about?
3. Providing for the New Generation Patterns
Energy v. Capacity
• Wind farms provide low carbon energy and
displace fuel-burn from conventional coal and
gas
• Most coal and gas stations are not closed
because their capacity is needed occasionally to
cover peak demand which coincides with times of
no wind
• Utilisation of generation assets falls
Transmission Constraints
• Wind is in the north, demand in the south
• Constraining-off wind (in north) and constraining-
on coal (in south) is very expensive
• But, how is new transmission capacity best
provided
4. Can we afford “predict and provide”?
55%
2010
Asset
Utilisation
BaU
Smart
Smart Grid= paradigm shift in
providing flexibility: from
redundancy in assets to
more intelligent operation
through incorporation of
demand side and advanced
network technologies in
support of real time grid
management
2020 2030
35%
25%
5. Transmission System Issues
Issue Present Solution Changes Foreseen
Wind farm
connection
Medium voltage cable Longer cable distance and
higher power
Greater north-south flows
Frequency
Control
Part-loaded gas and
coal stations
CO2 emitting stations retired
Greater variability introduced
by wind
Operating
Reserve
Part-loaded and
warmed thermal
stations
Retired thermal stations
Greater variability introduced
by wind
Security of
Generation
20% plant margin Stochastic availability of wind
Low utilisation of thermal
stations
Security of
Transmission
Redundant lines (N-1
planning etc.)
Difficulty building new lines
Low value of interrupted wind
6. Distribution System Issues
Issue Present Solution Changes Foreseen
Consumer
voltage
regulation
System planning
margins
On-load tap-change
transformer
Distributed/Micro generation
cause voltage rise
Demand growth through
electric vehicles and heat
pumps
Line loading limit System planning
margins
(Design for low loss)
Distributed generation cause
back-feed
Demand growth through
electric vehicles and heat
pumps
Fault current
limit
System planning
margins
City-centre load growth (short
distribution system, high
interconnection, distributed
generation)
7. Offshore Wind Farm Expansion in the UK
1.25 GW capacity installed
3.2 GW being added in 2010/11
New offshore wind farm zones recently
announce total about 32 GW
Some new wind farms are 200 km from shore
EHV AC cable connection has a
difficult/expensive reactive power problem
Connection will have to be DC
Voltage source DC required to run wind
turbines
8. Smarter Transmission Infrastructure
Sizewell
Pembroke
Osbaldwick
Rowdown
Beddington
Chessington
West
Landulph
Abham
Exeter
Axminster
Chickerell
Mannington
Taunton
Alverdiscott
Hinkley Point
Bridgwater
Aberthaw
Cowbridge
Pyle
Margam
Swansea
North
Cardiff
East
Tremorfa
Alpha Steel
UskmouthUpper Boat
Cilfynydd
Imperial
Park
Rassau
Whitson
Seabank
Iron Acton
Walham
Melksham
Minety Didcot
Culham
Cowley
Bramley
Fleet
Nursling
Fawley Botley Wood
Lovedean
Bolney
Ninfield
Dungeness
Sellindge
Canterbury
E de F
Kemsley
Grain
Kingsnorth
Rayleigh Main
Littlebrook
Tilbury
Warley
Barking
W.HamCity Rd
Brimsdown
Waltham
Ealing
Mill Hill
Willesden
Watford
St Johns
Wimbledon
New Hurst
Elstree
Rye House
N.Hyde
Sundon
Laleham
Iver
Amersham Main
Wymondley
Pelham
Braintree
Burwell
Main
Bramford
Eaton
Socon
Grendon
East
Claydon
Enderby
Walpole
Norwich
Main
Coventry
Berkswell
Rugeley
Cellarhead
Ironbridge
Bushbury
Penn
Willenhall
Ocker
Hill
Kitwell
Oldbury
Bustleholm
Nechells
Hams
Hall
Bishops
Wood
Feckenham
Legacy
Trawsfynydd
Ffestiniog
Dinorwig
Pentir
Wylfa
Deeside
Capenhurst Frodsham
Fiddlers
Rainhill
Kirkby
Lister
Drive
Birkenhead
Washway
Farm
Penwortham
Carrington
South
Manchester
Daines
Macclesfield
Bredbury
Stalybridge
Rochdale
WhitegateKearsley
Elland
Stocksbridge
West
Melton
Aldwarke
Thurcroft
BrinsworthJordanthorpe
Chesterfield
Sheffield City
Neepsend
Pitsmoor
Templeborough Thorpe
Marsh
Keadby
West
Burton
Cottam
High
Marnham
Staythorpe
Stanah
Heysham
Padiham
Hutton
Bradford
West Kirkstall
Skelton
Poppleton
Thornton
Quernmore
Monk
Eggborough
Ferrybridge
Killingholme
South
Humber
Bank Grimsby
West
Drax
Lackenby
Greystones
Grangetown
Saltholme
Norton
Spennymoor
Tod Point
Hartlepool
Hart Moor
Hawthorne Pit
Offerton
West Boldon
South Shields
Tynemouth
Stella
West
Harker
Eccles
Blyth
Indian
Queens
Coryton
Ratcliffe
Willington
Drakelow
Shrewsbury
Cross
Weybridge
Cross
Wood
North
Fryston
Grange
Ferry
Winco Bank
Norton Lees
Creyke Beck
Saltend North
Saltend South
Hackney
Baglan
Bay
Leighton
Buzzard
Patford
Bridge
Northfleet East
Singlewell
Fourstones
Humber Refinery
Spalding
North
West Thurrock
ISSUE B 12-02-09 41/177619 C Collins Bartholomew Ltd 1999
Dingwall
Dounreay
Newarthill
Cumbernauld
Kincardine
Wishaw
Strathaven
Kilmarnock
South
Ayr
Coylton
Inveraray
HelensburghDunoon
Inverkip
Devol
Moor
Hunterston
Sloy
Fort William
Bonnybridge
Neilston
Ceannacroc
Conon
Fort Augustus
Foyers
Inverness
Stornoway
Elvanfoot
Kaimes
Glenrothes
Westfield
Grangemouth
Longannet
Linmill
Bathgate
Errochty Power Station
Torness
Cockenzie
Keith
Thurso
Fasnakyle
Beauly
Deanie
Lairg
Shin
Nairn
Kintore
Blackhillock
Elgin
Keith
Peterhead
Persley
Fraserburgh
Invergarry
Quoich
Culligran
Aigas
Kilmorack
Grudie
Bridge
Mossford
Orrin
Luichart
Alness
Brora
Cassley
Dunbeath
Mybster
St. Fergus
Strichen
Macduff
Boat of
Garten
Redmoss
Willowdale
Clayhills
Dyce
Craigiebuckler
Woodhill
Tarland
Dalmally
Killin
Errochty
Tealing
Glenagnes
Dudhope
Milton of Craigie
Dudhope
Lyndhurst
Charleston
Burghmuir
Arbroath
Fiddes
Bridge of Dun
Lunanhead
St. Fillans
Finlarig
Lochay
Cashlie
Rannoch
Tummel
Bridge
Clunie
Taynuilt
Nant
Cruachan
Port
Ann
Carradale
Auchencrosh
Lambhill
Clydes
Mill
Glenluce
Newton
Stewart
Maybole
Dumfries Ecclefechan
Berwick
Hawick
Galashiels
Dunbar
Meadowhead
Saltcoats
Hunterston
Farm
SP TRANSMISSION LTD.
Kilwinning
Currie
Cupar
Leven
Redhouse
Glenniston
SCOTTISH HYDRO-ELECTRIC
TRANSMISSION
Telford Rd.
Gorgie
Kilmarnock
Town
Busby
Erskine
Strathleven
Mossmorran
Dunfermline
Broxburn
Livingston
Whitehouse
Shrubhill
Portobello
Devonside
StirlingWhistlefield
Spango
Valley
Ardmore
Broadford
Dunvegan
NGC
Easterhouse
East
Kilbride
South
Gretna
Chapelcross
THE SHETLAND ISLANDS
Tongland
Glen
Morrison
Clachan
400kV Substations
275kV Substations
400kV CIRCUITS
275kV CIRCUITS
Major Generating Sites Including Pumped Storage
Connected at 400kV
Connected at 275kV
Hydro Generation
TRANSMISSION SYSTEM REINFORCEMENTS
Langage
BlacklawWhitelee
Iverkeithing
Marchwood
Bicker
Fenn
Coalburn
REINFORCED NETWORK
Under Construction or ready to start
Construction subject to consents
Very strong need case
Series Capacitors
RedbridgeTottenham
Strong need case
Future requirement, but no strong
need case to commence
at present
• Build more lines to N-1
security standard
• Improve damping and raise
stability limit closer to
thermal limit
• Build offshore HVDC
9. Use of Transmission Capacity
• Full thermal capacity is 6.8 GW
• Capacity at N-1 is 5.1 GW
• Capacity at N-2 is 3.4 GW
• Stability Limit is 2.2 GW
England
Scotland
Four
1.7 GW
lines
Wind Farm
1 GW
Reserve
Gen 1 GW
Wind Farm
1 GW
Load
40 GW
Managed
Load 1GW
Export 4 GW
Import 4 GW
Transmission Capacity?
Smart releases capacity
and avoids reinforcement
10. European Super Grid
‘Roadmap 2050’, published 2010, ECF
Expanded network across Europe
would have a variety of
advantages:
• Increased diversity of wind
energy resource leading to
regional balancing of energy
generation
• Increased load diversity
(lower peak to average ratio)
• Greater energy trading
opportunities
• Increased security of supply
• Reduced dependency on fuel
imports
• But this is a DC network on an
unprecedented scale and
complexity
Iberia
France
UK &
Ireland
Nordic
Benelux &
Germany
Italy &
Malta
South East
Europe
Central Europe
Poland &
Baltic
4GW
21GW
41GW
5GW
10GW
4GW
19GW
10GW
10GW
3GW
2GW
3GW
4GW
11. Increased Electric Demand in a Low-Carbon Future
Traditional electrical demand may well (perhaps must) reduce
but ..
Two further demand sectors need to be met: heating and
vehicles
How does this demand affect
• Peak demand : average demand ratio
• Generation asset utilisation
• Loading on final LV distribution
12. Electric Vehicles in Commercial District
Significant opportunity to
optimise charging as EVs will
remain stationary for several
hours (e.g. 8h)
Significant correlation in arrivals to
work i.e. significant peak load
imposed by EV charging
BaU SMART
13. Generation asset utilisation with
Smart demand management
117 GW
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
00:00
01:00
02:00
03:00
04:00
05:00
06:00
07:00
08:00
09:00
10:00
11:00
12:00
13:00
14:00
15:00
16:00
17:00
18:00
19:00
20:00
21:00
22:00
23:00
Demand(GW)
Time
Non-optimised EV and HP operation
EV charging
HP demand
Originaldemand
78 GW
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
00:00
01:00
02:00
03:00
04:00
05:00
06:00
07:00
08:00
09:00
10:00
11:00
12:00
13:00
14:00
15:00
16:00
17:00
18:00
19:00
20:00
21:00
22:00
23:00
Demand(GW)
Time
Optimised EV and HP operation
Value of demand response: almost 40GW
less installed generation capacity required
GW
18:00
19:00
20:00
21:00
22:00
23:00
tion
EV charging
HP demand
Original demand
14. 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
0 1344 2688 4032 5376 6720 8064
Time (h)
But is a flat demand profile the best answer?
Annual Wind Power Variation
Demand will need to respond to generation patterns
through price or other signals
Demand will also have to respond to local network
constraints
This may need to be resolved regionally
15. Responding to frequency excursions
49.2
Frequency (Hz)
10s
50. 0
10 mins
Frequency control
=
? +
16. 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
Time (min)
Loadp.f.(W)
Load per fridge (p.f) Demand 60Gw 100% Refigerators, step 1.320GW ramp 0
DDC
No DDC
...but the beer is getting warm!
fridges are supporting the system
Anything to worry about?
17. Thoughts on Demand-Action Research
• Utilising demand-side action is key to cost-effective
integration of variable low-carbon generation and vehicle &
heating demands
• Smart-Metering must be seen in this context
• Operational tools need to be developed
• Decentralised control structures and supporting
communications needs to be developed
• Distribution management takes on new tasks
• Public need to believe this is necessary and in their interest;
public acceptance is likely to be the key issue.
18. Active Network Management
• Distributed generation
actively managed
• Tap-changers
optimised for local
conditions
• Post-fault restoration
reacts in real-time
• Energy storage used
to mange congestion
• Control is devolved to
substation regions
• Regional controllers
report to control centre
• Some “peer-to-peer”
functions might be
needed
19. From Active to Smart Distribution
• “Active” distribution system discussion has been over integrating
distributed generation
• “Smart” distribution system discussion is around integrating active
consumers.
• “Smart” distribution may introduce a more complex hierarchy in system
control
• System balancing (of demand and supply) becomes local so that very
large number of consumers can be reached and so that local
congestion can be managed
20. Conclusion
• We seem to be at the beginning of a fascinating
phase of power system evolution
Hinweis der Redaktion
There are 10 offshore wind farms in operation in the UK - Total of 972MW installed capacity. Further 3.5GW being implemented in 2010/11. The majority of these wind farms are under 10 km to the nearest coast and in water depths of up to 20m.Successful bids for nine new offshore wind farm zone licences within UK waters have been announced early this year. Turbines in the nine zones could generate up to 32 gigawatts of power. The Dogger Bank zone is located off the east coast of Yorkshire between 125 and 195 kilometres offshore. It extends over approximately 8,660 km2. The water depth ranges from 18-63 metres.The Moray Firth Zone - Won by EDP Renovaveis and SeaEnergy Renewables. Potential yield: 1.3 gigawatts The Firth of Forth Zone - Won by SSE Renewables and Fluor. Potential yield: 3.5 gigawatts The Dogger Bank Zone - Won by SSE Renewables, RWE Npower Renewables, Statoil and Statkraft. Potential yield: 9 gigawatts The Hornsea Zone - Won by Mainstream Renewable Power and Siemens Project Ventures, and involving Hochtief Construction. Potential yield: 4 gigawatts The Norfolk Bank Zone - Won by Scottish Power Renewables and Vattenfall Vindkraft. Potential yield: 7.2 gigawatts The Hastings Zone - Won by E.On Climate and Renewables UK. Potential yield: 0.6 gigawatts The Isle of Wight Zone - Won by Eneco New Energy. Potential yield: 0.9 gigawatts The Bristol Channel Zone - Won by RWE Npower Renewables. Potential yield: 1.5 gigawatts The Irish Sea Zone - Won by Centrica Renewable Energy and involving RES Group. Potential yield: 4.2 gigawatts To date rule of thumb of €500m capex on offshore transmission for every 1000MW of offshore wind capacity (15-20% total capex)
The EWEA published ‘Oceans of Opportunity’ in September 2009. This sets out the EWEA’s target of 40GW of offshore wind in the EU by 2020 and 150GW by 2030.The key objectives of this report are to develop an offshore grid, which builds on the 11 offshore grids currently operating and 21 others being considered in the North and Baltic Seas. Some of the main issues to overcome include policy, supply chain and the development of HVDC VSC for multi-terminal operation.Link to document:http://ewea.org/fileadmin/ewea_documents/documents/publications/reports/Offshore_Report_2009.pdf
5000 cars/km2Another important point here is that local peaks may occur in the morning, so that a standard, location non-specific, ToU tariff that attempts to minimise evening peak will not be sufficient