SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
Emerging Technologies and Moral Boundaries: Psychological, Philosophical and Neuroscientific Perspectives
Understanding Ethical cognition Not ethical decision making Not (directly) guiding ethical decision making e.g. seven horizons e.g. case studies What guides/motivates/generates ethical sentiments & related emotions (e.g. anger, abhorrence, disgust, forgiveness, beneficence, sacrifice)
Why care? Understand basis of own decisions E.g. May reveal and shed light on disconnects between ‘in principle’ ethical decisions, and ‘hot’ ethical responses to actual situations Ethical sentiments are very powerful, perhaps most powerful social force Shapes public opinion / response Motivates life and death decisions Dictates ease and ability to treat others in different ways (e.g. to kill, to treat inhumanely, to treat appropriately to a peacekeeping operation)
Why military might care Effectiveness of troops in war situation Effectiveness of troops in peacekeeping Moral of troops and effective use of technology Reintegration of troops after tour National / International public opinion How to present or ‘package’ use of enhancements, control perception, win ‘hearts and minds’
Slight change of focus Not about reaching consensus – about understanding multiple perspectives, what is common, what is different Not about dismissing ‘hysterical’ responses or putting aside ‘bad arguments’.  Cultural differences  (by nation, by sub-culture) Dependency on exposure (live it vs. hear about it) and on how communicated (propaganda) Interesting and important in its own right Encourage thinking ‘outside the box’ – stronger guide to how to build consensus (as opposed to ‘look, we reached a consensus, now that should dictate policy’). Better understand what guides our own ethical intuitions (rather than appeal to religion, rationality, ‘authority of educated philosopher’) Inform laws / how principles should be applied. Not replacement for activities outlined, but complement to them.
Stuart J. Youngner, MD Chair, Department of Bioethics, CWRU Susan E. Watson Professor of Bioethics Professor of Psychiatry Sara Waller Associate Professor of Philosophy, Montana State Philosophy of animal minds, neuroscience, ethics
Social vs physical/logical/scientific Push – pull relationship > sharp boundary Research under way New project
FFA and animate/inanimate 1997 2009
A Nonvisual Look at the Functional Organization of Visual Cortex Animals vs tools /inanimate objects
Faces - houses
Kids (e.g. 3-7yrs) - houses
Babies (0-2yrs) - houses
‘cute’ mammal - houses
Robot - houses
Babies (0-2yrs) - houses
Uncanny valley
When does emotional response turn into moral sentiment?

More Related Content

What's hot

social psychology
social psychologysocial psychology
social psychologykbolinsky
 
Lesson 1 introduction to personality
Lesson 1   introduction to personalityLesson 1   introduction to personality
Lesson 1 introduction to personalityJasmine Nadja Pinugu
 
1 TORS Psych
1 TORS Psych1 TORS Psych
1 TORS Psychpsych1SCT
 
Personality psychology
Personality psychologyPersonality psychology
Personality psychologyelmakrufi
 
Social psychology definition paper
Social psychology definition paperSocial psychology definition paper
Social psychology definition paperSnowPea Guh
 
Alternative Personality Psychology Theories
Alternative Personality Psychology TheoriesAlternative Personality Psychology Theories
Alternative Personality Psychology TheoriesLily Yuan
 
Social psychology introduction
Social psychology introductionSocial psychology introduction
Social psychology introductionsanchicreator
 
Theoretical Perspectives in Social Psychology
Theoretical Perspectives in Social PsychologyTheoretical Perspectives in Social Psychology
Theoretical Perspectives in Social PsychologyKates Grajales
 
Lifespan Chapter 1 Online Stud 1202019114528164 4
Lifespan Chapter 1 Online Stud 1202019114528164 4Lifespan Chapter 1 Online Stud 1202019114528164 4
Lifespan Chapter 1 Online Stud 1202019114528164 4ndehaven
 

What's hot (17)

1 Introduction To Social Psychology
1 Introduction To Social Psychology1 Introduction To Social Psychology
1 Introduction To Social Psychology
 
Chapter 5 Cst229
Chapter 5 Cst229Chapter 5 Cst229
Chapter 5 Cst229
 
social psychology
social psychologysocial psychology
social psychology
 
Perception
 Perception Perception
Perception
 
Social psychology
Social psychologySocial psychology
Social psychology
 
Lesson 1 introduction to personality
Lesson 1   introduction to personalityLesson 1   introduction to personality
Lesson 1 introduction to personality
 
1 TORS Psych
1 TORS Psych1 TORS Psych
1 TORS Psych
 
Personality psychology
Personality psychologyPersonality psychology
Personality psychology
 
Social psychology definition paper
Social psychology definition paperSocial psychology definition paper
Social psychology definition paper
 
Bailey
BaileyBailey
Bailey
 
Alternative Personality Psychology Theories
Alternative Personality Psychology TheoriesAlternative Personality Psychology Theories
Alternative Personality Psychology Theories
 
Basic concepts in socal psychology
Basic concepts in socal psychologyBasic concepts in socal psychology
Basic concepts in socal psychology
 
Social Psychology
Social PsychologySocial Psychology
Social Psychology
 
Social psychology introduction
Social psychology introductionSocial psychology introduction
Social psychology introduction
 
Theoretical Perspectives in Social Psychology
Theoretical Perspectives in Social PsychologyTheoretical Perspectives in Social Psychology
Theoretical Perspectives in Social Psychology
 
Lifespan Chapter 1 Online Stud 1202019114528164 4
Lifespan Chapter 1 Online Stud 1202019114528164 4Lifespan Chapter 1 Online Stud 1202019114528164 4
Lifespan Chapter 1 Online Stud 1202019114528164 4
 
Pw
PwPw
Pw
 

Similar to Emerging Technologies and Moral Boundaries: Psychological, Philosophical and Neuroscientific Perspectives on Understanding Ethical Cognition

Elements of Cultural EmotionsTheodoric Manley, Jr. PhD
Elements of Cultural EmotionsTheodoric Manley, Jr. PhDElements of Cultural EmotionsTheodoric Manley, Jr. PhD
Elements of Cultural EmotionsTheodoric Manley, Jr. PhDEvonCanales257
 
S. Sherrill - General Psychology - Chapter 1 (M1) Spring 2016
S. Sherrill - General Psychology - Chapter 1 (M1) Spring 2016S. Sherrill - General Psychology - Chapter 1 (M1) Spring 2016
S. Sherrill - General Psychology - Chapter 1 (M1) Spring 2016sjbrabham
 
Chapter1m1powerpointpresentation 160111151315
Chapter1m1powerpointpresentation 160111151315Chapter1m1powerpointpresentation 160111151315
Chapter1m1powerpointpresentation 160111151315Cleophas Rwemera
 
Chapter 1 introducing social psychology
Chapter 1 introducing social psychologyChapter 1 introducing social psychology
Chapter 1 introducing social psychologyFaizaKhalid50
 
PPT-U1-Definition.pptx
PPT-U1-Definition.pptxPPT-U1-Definition.pptx
PPT-U1-Definition.pptxAbebe90
 
Social Psychology: Review
Social Psychology: ReviewSocial Psychology: Review
Social Psychology: ReviewJames Neill
 
Awesome week 1 guidance ppt
Awesome week 1 guidance pptAwesome week 1 guidance ppt
Awesome week 1 guidance pptewhitelo
 
1Psychology’s Roots, Big Ideas, and Critical Thinking Tools.docx
1Psychology’s Roots, Big Ideas, and Critical Thinking Tools.docx1Psychology’s Roots, Big Ideas, and Critical Thinking Tools.docx
1Psychology’s Roots, Big Ideas, and Critical Thinking Tools.docxRAJU852744
 
History & Approaches
History & ApproachesHistory & Approaches
History & Approachesmeganmorrow79
 
Cultural Emotions Pain, Hate, Fear, Disgust, Shame, Love
Cultural Emotions Pain, Hate, Fear, Disgust, Shame, Love Cultural Emotions Pain, Hate, Fear, Disgust, Shame, Love
Cultural Emotions Pain, Hate, Fear, Disgust, Shame, Love OllieShoresna
 
Module 1 the history and scope of psychology
Module 1 the history and scope of psychologyModule 1 the history and scope of psychology
Module 1 the history and scope of psychologyTina Medley
 
43306261-A-Case-Study-on-Schizophrenia.doc
43306261-A-Case-Study-on-Schizophrenia.doc43306261-A-Case-Study-on-Schizophrenia.doc
43306261-A-Case-Study-on-Schizophrenia.docRanushaAnusha2
 
What is Psychology?
What is Psychology?What is Psychology?
What is Psychology?Don Thompson
 
Cognitive biases without borders (Me)
Cognitive biases without borders (Me)Cognitive biases without borders (Me)
Cognitive biases without borders (Me)José Arizaga
 
1 Running head THE ETHICS OF ELEPHANTS IN CIRCUSES .docx
1 Running head THE ETHICS OF ELEPHANTS IN CIRCUSES    .docx1 Running head THE ETHICS OF ELEPHANTS IN CIRCUSES    .docx
1 Running head THE ETHICS OF ELEPHANTS IN CIRCUSES .docxhoney725342
 
Introduction to Moral Injury, Theory & Practice
Introduction to Moral Injury, Theory & PracticeIntroduction to Moral Injury, Theory & Practice
Introduction to Moral Injury, Theory & PracticeJohn Gavazzi
 

Similar to Emerging Technologies and Moral Boundaries: Psychological, Philosophical and Neuroscientific Perspectives on Understanding Ethical Cognition (20)

Elements of Cultural EmotionsTheodoric Manley, Jr. PhD
Elements of Cultural EmotionsTheodoric Manley, Jr. PhDElements of Cultural EmotionsTheodoric Manley, Jr. PhD
Elements of Cultural EmotionsTheodoric Manley, Jr. PhD
 
S. Sherrill - General Psychology - Chapter 1 (M1) Spring 2016
S. Sherrill - General Psychology - Chapter 1 (M1) Spring 2016S. Sherrill - General Psychology - Chapter 1 (M1) Spring 2016
S. Sherrill - General Psychology - Chapter 1 (M1) Spring 2016
 
Chapter1m1powerpointpresentation 160111151315
Chapter1m1powerpointpresentation 160111151315Chapter1m1powerpointpresentation 160111151315
Chapter1m1powerpointpresentation 160111151315
 
Chapter 1 introducing social psychology
Chapter 1 introducing social psychologyChapter 1 introducing social psychology
Chapter 1 introducing social psychology
 
PPT-U1-Definition.pptx
PPT-U1-Definition.pptxPPT-U1-Definition.pptx
PPT-U1-Definition.pptx
 
From Neuroscience to 'Neuroart'
From Neuroscience to 'Neuroart' From Neuroscience to 'Neuroart'
From Neuroscience to 'Neuroart'
 
Unit 1
Unit 1Unit 1
Unit 1
 
Social Psychology: Review
Social Psychology: ReviewSocial Psychology: Review
Social Psychology: Review
 
Awesome week 1 guidance ppt
Awesome week 1 guidance pptAwesome week 1 guidance ppt
Awesome week 1 guidance ppt
 
1Psychology’s Roots, Big Ideas, and Critical Thinking Tools.docx
1Psychology’s Roots, Big Ideas, and Critical Thinking Tools.docx1Psychology’s Roots, Big Ideas, and Critical Thinking Tools.docx
1Psychology’s Roots, Big Ideas, and Critical Thinking Tools.docx
 
History & Approaches
History & ApproachesHistory & Approaches
History & Approaches
 
Cultural Emotions Pain, Hate, Fear, Disgust, Shame, Love
Cultural Emotions Pain, Hate, Fear, Disgust, Shame, Love Cultural Emotions Pain, Hate, Fear, Disgust, Shame, Love
Cultural Emotions Pain, Hate, Fear, Disgust, Shame, Love
 
Module 1 the history and scope of psychology
Module 1 the history and scope of psychologyModule 1 the history and scope of psychology
Module 1 the history and scope of psychology
 
Pppp
PpppPppp
Pppp
 
43306261-A-Case-Study-on-Schizophrenia.doc
43306261-A-Case-Study-on-Schizophrenia.doc43306261-A-Case-Study-on-Schizophrenia.doc
43306261-A-Case-Study-on-Schizophrenia.doc
 
What is Psychology?
What is Psychology?What is Psychology?
What is Psychology?
 
How science and religion are more like theology and commonsense explanations ...
How science and religion are more like theology and commonsense explanations ...How science and religion are more like theology and commonsense explanations ...
How science and religion are more like theology and commonsense explanations ...
 
Cognitive biases without borders (Me)
Cognitive biases without borders (Me)Cognitive biases without borders (Me)
Cognitive biases without borders (Me)
 
1 Running head THE ETHICS OF ELEPHANTS IN CIRCUSES .docx
1 Running head THE ETHICS OF ELEPHANTS IN CIRCUSES    .docx1 Running head THE ETHICS OF ELEPHANTS IN CIRCUSES    .docx
1 Running head THE ETHICS OF ELEPHANTS IN CIRCUSES .docx
 
Introduction to Moral Injury, Theory & Practice
Introduction to Moral Injury, Theory & PracticeIntroduction to Moral Injury, Theory & Practice
Introduction to Moral Injury, Theory & Practice
 

More from HeatherOlsen1

Fse -military_stakeholder_exercise_optimized
Fse  -military_stakeholder_exercise_optimizedFse  -military_stakeholder_exercise_optimized
Fse -military_stakeholder_exercise_optimizedHeatherOlsen1
 
Sponsor tth spring2010
Sponsor tth spring2010Sponsor tth spring2010
Sponsor tth spring2010HeatherOlsen1
 
Cetmons moral judgments and cognitive confusion
Cetmons moral judgments and cognitive confusionCetmons moral judgments and cognitive confusion
Cetmons moral judgments and cognitive confusionHeatherOlsen1
 
Cetmons boundaries in bioethics
Cetmons boundaries in bioethicsCetmons boundaries in bioethics
Cetmons boundaries in bioethicsHeatherOlsen1
 
Thrust group2 presention 020510
Thrust group2 presention 020510Thrust group2 presention 020510
Thrust group2 presention 020510HeatherOlsen1
 
Centerprg Appeel Brochure
Centerprg Appeel BrochureCenterprg Appeel Brochure
Centerprg Appeel BrochureHeatherOlsen1
 
Pub Humantotranshuman
Pub HumantotranshumanPub Humantotranshuman
Pub HumantotranshumanHeatherOlsen1
 
Pub Lincolncenter Brochure
Pub Lincolncenter BrochurePub Lincolncenter Brochure
Pub Lincolncenter BrochureHeatherOlsen1
 
Board Member Packet For Video
Board Member Packet For VideoBoard Member Packet For Video
Board Member Packet For VideoHeatherOlsen1
 
Cetmons Cyberwarfare
Cetmons CyberwarfareCetmons Cyberwarfare
Cetmons CyberwarfareHeatherOlsen1
 
Kosal Nanotechnology & Defense 5 Feb10
Kosal Nanotechnology & Defense 5 Feb10Kosal Nanotechnology & Defense 5 Feb10
Kosal Nanotechnology & Defense 5 Feb10HeatherOlsen1
 
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And DemocracyEmerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And DemocracyHeatherOlsen1
 

More from HeatherOlsen1 (13)

Fse -military_stakeholder_exercise_optimized
Fse  -military_stakeholder_exercise_optimizedFse  -military_stakeholder_exercise_optimized
Fse -military_stakeholder_exercise_optimized
 
Sponsor tth spring2010
Sponsor tth spring2010Sponsor tth spring2010
Sponsor tth spring2010
 
Cetmons moral judgments and cognitive confusion
Cetmons moral judgments and cognitive confusionCetmons moral judgments and cognitive confusion
Cetmons moral judgments and cognitive confusion
 
Cetmons boundaries in bioethics
Cetmons boundaries in bioethicsCetmons boundaries in bioethics
Cetmons boundaries in bioethics
 
Thrust group2 presention 020510
Thrust group2 presention 020510Thrust group2 presention 020510
Thrust group2 presention 020510
 
Cetmons Brochure
Cetmons BrochureCetmons Brochure
Cetmons Brochure
 
Centerprg Appeel Brochure
Centerprg Appeel BrochureCenterprg Appeel Brochure
Centerprg Appeel Brochure
 
Pub Humantotranshuman
Pub HumantotranshumanPub Humantotranshuman
Pub Humantotranshuman
 
Pub Lincolncenter Brochure
Pub Lincolncenter BrochurePub Lincolncenter Brochure
Pub Lincolncenter Brochure
 
Board Member Packet For Video
Board Member Packet For VideoBoard Member Packet For Video
Board Member Packet For Video
 
Cetmons Cyberwarfare
Cetmons CyberwarfareCetmons Cyberwarfare
Cetmons Cyberwarfare
 
Kosal Nanotechnology & Defense 5 Feb10
Kosal Nanotechnology & Defense 5 Feb10Kosal Nanotechnology & Defense 5 Feb10
Kosal Nanotechnology & Defense 5 Feb10
 
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And DemocracyEmerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
 

Emerging Technologies and Moral Boundaries: Psychological, Philosophical and Neuroscientific Perspectives on Understanding Ethical Cognition

  • 1. Emerging Technologies and Moral Boundaries: Psychological, Philosophical and Neuroscientific Perspectives
  • 2. Understanding Ethical cognition Not ethical decision making Not (directly) guiding ethical decision making e.g. seven horizons e.g. case studies What guides/motivates/generates ethical sentiments & related emotions (e.g. anger, abhorrence, disgust, forgiveness, beneficence, sacrifice)
  • 3. Why care? Understand basis of own decisions E.g. May reveal and shed light on disconnects between ‘in principle’ ethical decisions, and ‘hot’ ethical responses to actual situations Ethical sentiments are very powerful, perhaps most powerful social force Shapes public opinion / response Motivates life and death decisions Dictates ease and ability to treat others in different ways (e.g. to kill, to treat inhumanely, to treat appropriately to a peacekeeping operation)
  • 4. Why military might care Effectiveness of troops in war situation Effectiveness of troops in peacekeeping Moral of troops and effective use of technology Reintegration of troops after tour National / International public opinion How to present or ‘package’ use of enhancements, control perception, win ‘hearts and minds’
  • 5. Slight change of focus Not about reaching consensus – about understanding multiple perspectives, what is common, what is different Not about dismissing ‘hysterical’ responses or putting aside ‘bad arguments’. Cultural differences (by nation, by sub-culture) Dependency on exposure (live it vs. hear about it) and on how communicated (propaganda) Interesting and important in its own right Encourage thinking ‘outside the box’ – stronger guide to how to build consensus (as opposed to ‘look, we reached a consensus, now that should dictate policy’). Better understand what guides our own ethical intuitions (rather than appeal to religion, rationality, ‘authority of educated philosopher’) Inform laws / how principles should be applied. Not replacement for activities outlined, but complement to them.
  • 6. Stuart J. Youngner, MD Chair, Department of Bioethics, CWRU Susan E. Watson Professor of Bioethics Professor of Psychiatry Sara Waller Associate Professor of Philosophy, Montana State Philosophy of animal minds, neuroscience, ethics
  • 7. Social vs physical/logical/scientific Push – pull relationship > sharp boundary Research under way New project
  • 9. A Nonvisual Look at the Functional Organization of Visual Cortex Animals vs tools /inanimate objects
  • 11. Kids (e.g. 3-7yrs) - houses
  • 17. When does emotional response turn into moral sentiment?