SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 15
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Informal sector support and Poverty Reduction1 
Niklaus Eggenberger-Argote 
Contents 
Introduction 
1. Causes of high business costs and informal sectors 
2. Approaches to promote the formalisation of the informal economy 
3. Approaches to support informal sector actors within the informal sector 
Conclusion 
Bibliography 
February 2005 
1 The following paper is a desk study of existing literature on behalf of the Swiss State Secretariat for 
Economic Affairs (seco).
2 
Executive Summary 
The recent trend towards democratisation and market-based systems has improved 
the live of millions worldwide. Many countries have increased political participation 
and achieved macroeconomic stabilisation and growth. However, there are also mil-lions 
of people in emerging democracies who are excluded from the political and 
economic system and are living in poverty. A glaring symptom is the growing number 
of entrepreneurs engaged in low-income and low-growth business activities in the 
informal sector. Roughly a third of the GDP of emerging markets is produced infor-mally. 
This paper will provide a deeper insight into the relevant causes of informal sectors, 
the macro-level interventions needed to promote the formalisation of the informal 
economy, and the steps required to assist informal sector entrepreneurs within the 
informal sector. 
High business costs and the informal economy are mainly caused by: ill-designed 
and unstable rules and regulations (particularly in relation to taxation, labour policy 
and business registration); a lack of well-defined and secure property rights; poor-quality 
or non-existent infrastructure and public services; deficient government ca-pacity 
and resources to enforce laws and regulations; a lack of transparency, ac-countability 
and autonomy of governmental institutions (e.g. the judiciary); as well as 
a high degree of macroeconomic instability, unemployment and corruption. 
The key to facilitating the informal sector’s participation in the formal economy, there-fore, 
is to establish transparent and inclusive mechanisms through which citizens can 
regularly voice their concerns, participate in policy and law making, monitor public 
and private sector activity and hold public and private sector actors accountable. Fur-ther 
interventions include: fostering macroeconomic stability and growth; clarifying 
and streamlining legal and regulatory codes; ensuring and enforcing property rights 
and legal security; simplifying business permits and licences and making them af-fordable 
to all; reforming tax and labour policies; instituting corporate governance 
legislation, conflict of interest laws, international government procurement codes and 
anti-bribery principles; reforming bureaucratic government institutions and strength-ening 
their administrative and enforcement capacities; making essential business-related 
information available to all; and providing high quality, cost-effective and well-maintained 
infrastructure and public services. 
Some of the macro-level interventions aimed at formalising the informal economy 
also facilitate entrepreneurship in the informal sector and therefore are useful instru-ments 
for supporting actors within the informal sector, too. Examples are: efforts to 
promote macroeconomic stability and growth; to guarantee and enforce property 
rights and legal security; and to provide a minimal, but functioning and well-maintained, 
infrastructure.
3 
Introduction 
An extensive informal economy is characteristic of the business sector of many de-veloping 
countries. Billions of dollars in potential profits are lost each year in emerg-ing 
democracies and economies because ill-designed, complex laws and regulations 
exclude millions of citizens from the political and economic system and unnecessarily 
raise the costs of doing business in the formal sector. A recent IMF study revealed 
that about nine trillion dollars – roughly a third of the GDP of emerging markets – was 
produced informally. Similarly, ILO figures indicate that, in 1999, 17% to 84% of the 
urban labour force in developing countries worked informally. 
The informal sector consists of entrepreneurs who produce legitimate products with-out 
proper permits and legal status because they lack the resources and/or the in-centives 
to comply with the burdensome and excessive rules and regulations neces-sary 
to become part of the formal economy. Informal sector activities are extra-legal 
in the regulatory, but not in the criminal, sense. Hence, the informal sector is a very 
heterogeneous and complex phenomenon: it includes urban poor people, who de-pend 
on informal subsistence activities for their livelihood, as well as higher-income 
people entering the informal economy as a way of supplementing declining formal 
sector incomes or of increasing profit margins. The understanding of the complexity 
and heterogeneity of the informal sector has significant implications for any strategy 
and policy interventions trying to alleviate poverty in this sector and to formalise the 
informal economy. 
A large informal sector has serious consequences for private sector activity, eco-nomic 
growth and the consolidation of democracy. It weakens democracy, hinders 
necessary reforms, and contributes to misguided policies due to the illegality of the 
’informals’ preventing them from voicing their concerns to government officials and 
holding them accountable. Therefore, reforms that would increase private sector ac-tivity 
and growth are not implemented. Because informal activities are not reported, 
policy makers do not have the necessary information to make adequate decisions. 
Furthermore, if the legal and regulatory framework does not encourage an efficient 
use of resources, the economy cannot achieving its production potential. Resource 
allocation is distorted, while productivity and competitiveness are lowered, giving rich, 
but not necessarily efficient, producers an unfair advantage. The informal sector 
places significant constraints particularly on smaller firms, limiting their access to fi-nancial 
resources, public services and utilities, and narrowing the kind of contracts or 
investments they can make. Job creation and chances for upward social mobility are 
severely restrained. 
Additionally, the failure to attract firms to formal market activities results in foregone 
tax revenues, which reduces government’s ability to finance essential business-related 
goods and services – and in turn discourages even more entrepreneurs from
4 
paying taxes and business-related fees. High business costs and a lack of informa-tion 
and transparency also invite corruption. ‘Informals’ are illegal and therefore do 
not benefit from law enforcement services. They, therefore, have to resort to bribery 
in order to avoid costly punishment or to obtain certain services and protection. In 
short, high business costs and the informal sector are closely linked with low growth, 
poverty, reinforced inequality and the weakening of political and economic institu-tions. 
What can be done to lower business costs? How can policymakers reform key politi-cal 
and economic institutions so that informal sector entrepreneurs in emerging de-mocracies 
will participate actively in the formal economy and in policymaking? What 
can be done to assist people in the informal sector? 
This paper will provide a deeper insight into the relevant causes of high business 
costs and informality, macro-level approaches and policy interventions to promote 
the formalisation of the informal economy, and action required to assist entrepre-neurs 
within the informal sector. Poverty Reduction Strategies (PRS) should reflect 
these concerns, since they are supposed to enhance the interests of the people living 
in poverty, many of whom depend on the informal economy for their livelihoods. 
1. Causes of high business costs and informal sectors 
Where do high business costs and large informal sectors come from? Identifying the 
obstacles to joining the formal economy and the sources of high business costs is the 
first step towards reducing barriers to entering the formal economy. 
The underlying reasons for many citizens in emerging democratic, market-based sys-tems 
not participating in the political and economic system are the ill-designed ‘rules 
of the game’, undemocratic decision-making, and poor quality government services. 
These contribute to prohibitively expensive costs of doing business, the removal of 
incentives to comply with burdensome rules and regulations, and the erection of bar-riers 
to participation. 
Among the most common examples of ill-designed rules and regulations are taxation 
and labour policies. High tax rates and poorly administered taxation systems reduce 
profit margins, which encourages tax evasion and recourse to the informal sector. 
Similarly, restrictive labour regulations impose substantial, fixed burdens on firms, 
particularly the low income-earning ones, and make the hiring of informal workers 
attractive. 
Setting up a business is often a troublesome and long-term adventure. Acquiring le-gal 
property titles for assets such as a piece of land is one of the first steps to regis-tering 
a business. The lack of well-defined and secure property rights lowers the in-centive 
to register property and hinders the obtaining of credit and the conversion of
5 
assets into productive capital. In his recent book, The Mystery of Capital, Hernando 
de Soto has argued that the developing world is sitting on some US$ 9,3 trillion in 
unreleased land value (’dead capital’), which is largely in the hands of poor people, 
because imperfect property rights do not allow their formalisation, capitalisation, and 
hence, conversion into working capital. De Soto illustrates how burdensome obtain-ing 
legal real estate titles can be in some countries: in the Philippines, for example, it 
requires 168 bureaucratic steps involving 53 public and private agencies and taking 
from 13 to 25 years. In Haiti it requires clearing 111 bureaucratic hurdles, and takes 
approximately 12 years. 
Business registration requires more than ’mere’ property titles in hand; entrepreneurs 
are confronted with further expensive and complicated licence and permit require-ments. 
The Harvard Institute of Economic Research recently published a survey of 
the official requirements to set up a business in 75 countries. The results indicate that 
the process entails, at best, two steps, two business days, and US$ 280 in Canada; 
at worst, 20 steps, 82 days, and US$ 2996 in Bolivia. 
Once registered, remaining formal is often made hazardous by unclear, unknown, 
conflicting, and frequently changing laws and regulations. In Perú, 73% of all costs of 
remaining formal came from following administrative rules. Complying with laws and 
regulations becomes even more overwhelming and costly if government agencies 
lack adequate financial, technical and human resources to administer and enforce 
them quickly and correctly. 
The degree of transparency, accountability, and political autonomy of government 
institutions and the extent of officials’ discretion in implementing and enforcing laws 
are other important factors influencing the costs of doing business. The judiciary is 
one of the most important government agencies in this regard: without an impartial, 
transparent, efficient and credible judicial system, business activity becomes very 
costly, thus encouraging recourse to the informal economy and weakening democ-racy 
and market-based transactions. 
Poor-quality or non-existent infrastructure (roads, transport, access to public service 
utilities such as electricity, water, etc.) further raises business costs and hampers 
market efficiency by discouraging mobility, lowering productivity, stimulating corrup-tion 
and further limiting access to markets. Moreover, entrepreneurs have little incen-tive 
to pay taxes or business-related fees for services that are poor or non-existent. 
Finally, a high degree of macroeconomic instability (lack of fiscal discipline, highly 
volatile prices and inflation, high levels of government interventionism) also creates 
greater incentives to operate informally and induces capital flight, foreign exchange 
purchases and barter. Further high unemployment rates in the formal economy are 
reasons to turn to the informal sector. A recent poll in Brazil revealed that one third of
6 
the respondents engaged in informal sector activities because of rising unemploy-ment 
rates and lower wages in the formal economy. 
In short, high business costs and the informal sector are mainly caused by ill-designed 
and unstable rules and regulations (particularly in relation to taxation, la-bour 
policy and business registration); the lack of well-defined and secure property 
rights; poor quality or non-existent public services; deficient capacities and resources 
of government agencies to administer and enforce laws and regulations; a lack of 
transparency, accountability and political autonomy of governmental institutions (par-ticularly 
the judiciary); as well as high degrees of macroeconomic instability, unem-ployment 
and corruption. 
A worldwide survey of 10,000 enterprises, carried out during 1999 and 2000 under 
the leadership of the World Bank, to document the leading obstacles to doing busi-ness 
identified by business managers and owners in developing countries confirms 
the relevance of the sources for high business costs and the informal sector men-tioned 
above. The list is topped by: taxes and regulations, financing difficulties, infla-tion, 
and political instability or uncertainty. Among other obstacles perceived as very 
serious are: corruption, exchange rate problems and street crime. 
2. Approaches to promote the formalisation of the informal economy 
The main sources for high business costs and the informal sector presented in the 
previous section give a general overview of what is needed to reduce barriers to par-ticipation 
in the formal economy. Here, several intervention approaches aimed at 
opening up participation processes, stimulating informal sector formalisation and tap-ping 
its growth potential will be examined. 
1. Fostering macroeconomic stability as a precondition for economic reform, growth 
and informal sector formalisation 
A sound and stable economic foundation is a prerequisite for economic reform, 
growth and the success of subsequent measures. Governments should institute 
fiscal discipline and a monetary policy geared towards low inflation in order to at-tain 
and maintain macroeconomic stability. Also, the degree of intervention in the 
economy should be limited: more liberal trade regimes, exchange rate and inter-est 
rate policies and reduced barriers to foreign investment enable economic 
growth and create important enabling conditions for the informal sector to become 
formalised. 
Interventions aimed at promoting broad-based growth and creating jobs in the 
formal economy generally improve the enabling conditions for a formalisation of 
the informal sector, unemployment in the formal sector being an important reason 
for becoming active in the informal sector.
7 
2. Increasing public participation and transparency in the policy making and legisla-tive 
process by instituting transparent, inclusive decision-making procedures and 
providing regular opportunities for the public to comment on existing and pro-posed 
laws and regulations 
Countries with representative governments and checks and balances have sig-nificantly 
fewer entry barriers for new firms. In addition, checks and balances be-tween 
government branches help minimise frequent, radical changes to the legal 
and regulatory framework. Hence, the business costs in the formal sector can be 
reduced through enhancing the degree of public participation in the policymaking 
and legislative processes by: 
¾ instituting transparent and inclusive decision-making procedures; 
¾ implementing legislative procedures that ensure public access to plenary and 
committee meetings; 
¾ holding public hearings on proposed legislation and regulations; 
¾ appointing independent ombudsmen to represent citizens’ interests to legisla-tors 
and government officials; and 
¾ empowering citizens to initiate legislation and referendums and to challenge 
existing laws and policies. 
Legislative advisory programmes, therefore, are an essential tool for reform, and 
policy dialogue is a valuable means of increasing its effectiveness. 
3. Clarifying and streamlining legal and regulatory codes by eliminating duplicative, 
superfluous laws that increase the costs of doing business and invite for corrup-tion 
Laws and regulations should be clarified so that rights and responsibilities are 
clearly defined, rules clearly specified, and administrative and enforcement pro-cedures 
simplified. Superfluous, complex and conflicting laws and regulations 
should be rescinded and the steps necessary to comply with laws should be 
streamlined in order to minimise the possibility of multiple interpretations and ap-plications 
of laws and regulations. Any viable short-term strategy to improve the 
business climate and to reduce business costs should first of all ensure that the 
appropriate legal and regulatory codes are in place and regularly enforced. 
4. Making private property rights accessible to all, clearly defined and strongly en-forced
8 
According to Hernando de Soto, prosperity cannot be broad-based until property 
rights are secure for all citizens. Property rights are the legal vehicle through 
which assets are converted into productive capital. They should, therefore, be re-formed 
and strengthened so that private assets serve as an engine of growth and 
productivity. Property rights need to establish straightforward standards to identify 
asset owners and to indicate how property can be combined, leased, bought, sold 
or exchanged securely for productive purposes. Additionally, property rights, in 
order to be secure, need to be strongly and consistently enforced by an effective 
and impartial legal system. 
A study by the World Bank and Princeton University showed that an initial invest-ment 
of US$ 15 million in legalising dwellings and small enterprises in Perú, be-tween 
1990 and 1996, provided US$ 9,4 billion in additional income to poor peo-ple. 
Further, there was a 28% increase in school enrolment in shanty towns 
where legal security had been established. 
5. Simplifying business permits and licenses and making them affordable so that 
becoming part of the formal economy is within reach for entrepreneurs of modest 
means 
Business costs can be lowered significantly if processes to obtain business per-mits 
and licences are facilitated. Requirements to get a permit have to be simple, 
straightforward, well-publicised and accessible to entrepreneurs of modest 
means. A one-step process that can be followed in different cities throughout a 
country would greatly reduce start-up costs. Additionally, it should be legally man-dated 
that, once these requirements are fulfilled, permits and licences are granted 
immediately and are automatically registered in a centralised business registry for 
public record. 
6. Reforming tax systems in order to encourage profitable economic activity and 
promote widespread compliance 
Taxation systems should be reformed by lowering the overall tax rate, by target-ing 
corporate and income taxes, and by making tax codes simple and straightfor-ward. 
Multi-step, complex procedures on fiscal reporting should be eliminated. 
Also, a consistent enforcement of taxation laws should be strengthened by in-creasing 
government’s administrative capacity and minimising officials’ discre-tionary 
powers. 
Such measures not only lower business costs, they also tend to increase reve-nues 
by broadening the taxation base in the long-term. Higher revenues, in turn, 
prepare the ground for better quality public services – although one has to ac-knowledge 
that there is no automatic positive relationship between higher reve-nues 
and better public services. 
Gelöscht: ¶
9 
7. Overhauling labour laws to allow for more flexibility 
Labour, as well as tax policies, are key to improving the business environment. In 
order to make hiring of formal workers more attractive, labour regulations have to 
allow for more flexible work contracts, such as part-time or short-term employ-ment 
or contract-based arrangements. Moreover, the right to associate freely 
should be vigorously protected. Individuals in any industry or sector should have 
the right to choose whether or not to join a trade or labour union. 
8. Opening markets and combating cronyism through improved corporate govern-ance 
legislation 
Introducing corporate governance measures greatly helps to improve a country’s 
business climate. There is a need for legislation to protect investors, sharehold-ers, 
and other stakeholders by adopting internationally accepted accounting prin-ciples, 
standards of disclosure, and anti-trust and anti-conflict of interest meas-ures, 
as well as prohibiting insider trading and overhauling bankruptcy laws. 
Clarifying conflict of interest laws, adopting Transparency International’s govern-ment 
procurement codes, and upholding OECD anti-bribery principles further help 
to combat cronyism and corruption: fewer funds will then line the pockets of gov-ernment 
cronies and their private sector pals. 
9. Reforming excessively bureaucratic government agencies and strengthening their 
administrative and enforcement capacities 
Government agencies that are excessively bureaucratic and inefficient need to be 
reformed. This can be achieved by streamlining and simplifying agencies’ internal 
operating procedures and by regularly evaluating their performance according to 
clear and well-defined standards. 
Furthermore, administrative and enforcement capacities of government agencies 
have to be strengthened. Successful means include: cultivating a staff of well-qualified 
civil servants, basing the hiring and promoting staff on verifiable profes-sional 
standards, offering civil servants vocational training, paying adequate sala-ries 
to attract well-qualified personal and to deter bribe-taking, and offering tenure 
based on performance (not on the election cycle). In addition, sufficient financial 
and technical resources to administer laws expediently should be provided. 
Particular emphasis should be given to reforming and strengthening the judiciary 
so that it enforces laws consistently, efficiently and fairly, thereby maintaining the 
rule of law.
10 
10. Making essential business-related information available to all 
Providing essential business information and training concerning how to obtain 
permits and licences, how to form legal commercial entities, how to invest, and 
how to understand and comply with business-related laws and regulations greatly 
increases transparency and facilitates complying with the requirements. 
11. Providing high quality, efficient, and cost-effective infrastructure essential for a 
democratic, market-based system so that entrepreneurs benefit from joining the 
formal sector 
The provision of a high quality, efficient, cost-effective and well-maintained infrastruc-ture 
of transport, telecommunications, water, and power is essential for economic 
growth and the expansion of employment. Improved public services and infrastruc-ture 
increase productivity, facilitate access to markets and, hence, provide an incen-tive 
for entrepreneurs to remain in, or to join, the formal sector economy. A fair 
amount of competition in these domains, through privatisation or transparent subcon-tracting 
bids with the government, greatly increases the efficiency, cost-effectiveness 
and quality of infrastructure provision. 
The key to facilitating informal sector’s participation in the formal economy and in the 
policymaking and lawmaking processes is to institute democratic governance in the 
public and private sectors. This entails establishing mechanisms through which citi-zens 
can regularly voice their concerns and participate in policy and law making, 
monitor public and private sector activity and hold public and private sector actors 
accountable. Using such mechanisms, private sector associations and citizens can 
advocate for reforms that reduce business costs, and encourage and facilitate par-ticipation 
in the formal economy. Such measures help to make both the public and 
private sectors more responsive to citizen’s needs, increase efficiency, transparency, 
accountability and growth, and reduce corruption. 
3. Approaches to support informal sector actors within the informal sector 
Implementing only a few of the above-mentioned intervention approaches alone will 
not yet lead to a formalisation of the informal economy; the reasons for formal sector 
actors joining the informal sector are multi-faceted. However, some of the strategies 
that provide incentives for informal actors to join the formal sector also facilitate eco-nomic 
activity within the informal sector. This is particularly true for macro-level inter-ventions 
aimed at creating a stable macroeconomic environment and promoting 
growth, ensuring property rights and legal security, and providing public services and 
infrastructure. Micro-level interventions providing Business Development Services,
11 
micro-finance and skills training for informal sector actors or building capacities of 
grassroots self-help organisations will not be addressed further in this paper2. 
1. Fostering macroeconomic stability and promoting growth as a precondition for 
any economic activity 
A sound and stable macroeconomic environment that enables economic growth, 
prevents high volatilities and dampens external and internal shocks not only 
stimulates the formalisation of the informal sector, but also facilitates business ac-tivity 
in both the formal and the informal sectors. The dynamics of a sound and 
stable economic environment, and increasing demands due to economic growth, 
will also positively affect informal sector activities. The same is true of a stable po-litical 
environment and public safety, since high rates of crime and violence dis-proportionately 
affect informal sector actors such as street vendors. 
2. Ensuring private property rights for all citizens, clearly defined and strongly en-forced 
Ensuring private property rights and legal security not only prepares the ground 
for formalising the informal sector. Secured, clearly defined and effectively en-forced 
property rights greatly encourage any economic activity, also in the infor-mal 
sector, and facilitate the conversion of private assets (dead capital) into pro-ductive 
capital. Without legally protected private property rights, entrepreneurs 
constantly face the risks of confiscation, forced relocation and harassment. In ad-dition, 
they have few incentives to train personnel or purchase machines and 
other equipment in order to improve productivity and undertake larger-scale and 
longer-term investment. 
Insecure property rights also damage economic performance in other ways: ob-taining 
water, electricity and telephone services usually requires a property title. 
The same is true for access to finance and banking. In addition, as the World 
Bank and Princeton study showed, ensuring property rights and legal security for 
poor people also had a positive impact on school enrolment rates, thereby pro-moting 
human capital-building and skills acquisition. 
Informal sector activities can also be supported by authorities applying more real-istic 
land-use standards, and providing public land for enterprises and markets. 
3. Providing a minimal and well-maintained infrastructure essential for conducting 
any economic activity 
The provision of a minimal, well-maintained infrastructure of transport, telecom-munications, 
water and power is essential for economic growth and the expansion 
2 According to instruction by seco.
12 
of employment in both the formal and informal sectors. Besides adopting more 
realistic land-use standards and providing public land for enterprises and markets, 
authorities could actively support the informal sector by developing a basic infra-structure 
for informal enterprises. The installation of electricity or water, for exam-ple, 
spurs productivity. The same is true of transportation: a lack of access to 
transport discourages mobility, limits access to markets and to inputs for produc-tion 
and, therefore, affects productivity and profit margins in a negative way. 
In short, some of the measures for stimulating the informal sector’s formalisation, 
presented in Section 2, also facilitate business activities in the informal sector. This 
holds for interventions at the macro-level – e.g. promoting economic stability and 
growth, ensuring property rights and legal security, and providing a functioning basic 
infrastructure – as well as at the micro-level – e.g. providing Business Development 
Services, access to micro-finance and skills training programmes. The strengthening 
of self-help grassroots organisations and informal entrepreneurs’ associations both 
supports increasing public participation in the shaping of policy and lawmaking proc-esses, 
which is the first step towards a formalisation of the informal sector, and pro-vides 
an impetus for pursuing own interests and rights within the informal sector. 
Conclusion 
This paper has provided a deeper insight into the relevant causes of high business 
costs and the informal sector, into macro-level approaches and policy interventions to 
promote the formalisation of the informal economy, and into the action required to 
support informal sector entrepreneurs within the informal sector. 
Identifying the sources of high business costs and the informal sector is a first step 
towards reducing the barriers to entering the formal sector, while also supporting in-formal 
entrepreneurs within the informal sector. High business costs and widespread 
informal sector activity are mainly caused by: ill-designed and unstable rules and 
regulations; a lack of well-defined and secure property rights; poor quality and non-existent 
infrastructure and public services; deficient capacities and resources of gov-ernment 
agencies to administer and enforce laws and regulations; a lack of transpar-ency, 
accountability and political autonomy of governmental institutions; as well as a 
high degree of macroeconomic instability, unemployment and corruption. 
In this regard, concrete intervention to promote the formalisation of the informal sec-tor 
should focus on: promoting macroeconomic stability and growth; clarifying and 
streamlining legal and regulatory codes; ensuring and enforcing property rights and 
legal security; simplifying business permits and licences and making them affordable 
for all; reforming tax and labour policies; instituting corporate governance legislation, 
conflict of interest laws, international government procurement codes and anti-bribery 
principles; reforming bureaucratic government institutions and strengthening their
13 
administrative and enforcement capacities; making essential business-related infor-mation 
available to all; and providing high quality, cost-effective and well maintained 
infrastructure and public services. 
Some of the macro-level interventions aimed at formalising the informal economy 
also facilitate entrepreneurship within the informal sector. Cases in point are efforts to 
promote macroeconomic stability and growth, to guarantee and enforce property 
rights and legal security, and to provide a minimal, but well-maintained infrastructure. 
Interventions at the micro-level, such as the provision of Business Development Ser-vices, 
access to micro-finance and skills training programmes, which dominate most 
of the donor efforts in relation to the informal sector, have not been explicitly dis-cussed 
in this paper. 
The key to facilitating the informal sector’s participation in the formal economy is to 
establish transparent and inclusive mechanisms through which citizens can regularly 
voice their concerns and participate in policy and lawmaking, monitor public and pri-vate 
sector activity and hold public and private sector actors accountable. Private 
sector associations and citizens can use such mechanisms to advocate for reforms 
that reduce business costs, and encourage and facilitate the formal sector. This re-sults 
in an increase in efficiency, transparency, accountability and growth and a re-duction 
of corruption. Moreover, greater citizens’ participation in the shaping of re-form 
processes will create a sense of ownership, which is essential for the consolida-tion 
of any democratic and market-based reforms.
14 
Bibliography 
De Soto, Hernando: 
The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Eve-rywhere 
Else. London, Bantam Press. 2000. 
Center for International Private Enterprise: 
Barriers to Participation: The Informal Sector in Emerging Democracies. Ple-nary 
Session Workshop Report. Presented at the Second Global Assembly of 
the World Movement for Democracy. São Paolo, Brazil. November 13, 2000. 
URL: www.cipe.org/programs/informalsector/reducinginformality/initiatives.htm 
Center for International Private Enterprise: 
Country Focus: CIPE projects designed to identify and reduce barriers to for-mality 
and business costs. 
URL: www.cipe.org/programs/informalsector/country/index.htm 
International Labor Organization, Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific: 
The informal sector. Bangkok. 2000. 
URL: www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/feature/inf_sect.htm 
Kuchta-Helbling, Catherine: 
Background Paper. Barriers to Participation: The Informal Sector in Emerging 
Democracies. Presented at the World Movement for Democracy. Second 
Global Assembly: Confronting Challenges to Democracy in the 21st. century. 
The Center for International Enterprise. São Paolo, Brazil. November 13, 
2000. 
Kuchta-Helbling, Catherine: 
Tapping Hidden Fortunes. Center for International Enterprise. 2001. 
URL: www.cipe.org/programs/informalsector/tapping.htm 
Neue Zürcher Zeitung: 
Wirtschaften im Schatten. Grosses aber unausgeschöpftes Entwicklungspo-tential 
in Brasiliens informellem Sektor. 11./12. Dezember 2004, S. 29. 
Sethuraman, S.V.: 
Urban Poverty and the Informal Sector. A Critical Assessment of Current 
Strategies. United Nations Development Programme, New York. 1997. 
The World Bank Group: 
The Informal Economy and Local Development. Program and Project Options. 
Main Problems Faced by those in the Informal Economy. 
URL: www.worldbank.org/html/fpd/urban/led/main_problems.html
15 
Tokman, Víctor E.: 
El sector informal en América Latina. Dos décadas de análisis. Consejo Na-cional 
para la Cultura y las Artes. México. 1995. 
United Nations Human Settlements Programme: 
Urban Economy Livelihood. Trends in International Employment. 2000. Chap-ter 
4, pp. 80-89. . 
URL: www.unchs.org/Istanbul+5/84.pdf

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

National program for countering shadow economy in Serbia
National program for countering shadow economy in SerbiaNational program for countering shadow economy in Serbia
National program for countering shadow economy in SerbiaNALED Serbia
 
Determinants of tax compliance behavior in ethiopia the case of bahir dar cit...
Determinants of tax compliance behavior in ethiopia the case of bahir dar cit...Determinants of tax compliance behavior in ethiopia the case of bahir dar cit...
Determinants of tax compliance behavior in ethiopia the case of bahir dar cit...Alexander Decker
 
{721 cbbc9 5a7a-b960-0f33-54eecd7e973e}
{721 cbbc9 5a7a-b960-0f33-54eecd7e973e}{721 cbbc9 5a7a-b960-0f33-54eecd7e973e}
{721 cbbc9 5a7a-b960-0f33-54eecd7e973e}Dr Lendy Spires
 
Tax Morale and Its Effect on Taxpayers’ Compliance to Tax Policies of the Nig...
Tax Morale and Its Effect on Taxpayers’ Compliance to Tax Policies of the Nig...Tax Morale and Its Effect on Taxpayers’ Compliance to Tax Policies of the Nig...
Tax Morale and Its Effect on Taxpayers’ Compliance to Tax Policies of the Nig...IOSR Journals
 
Political Environment[1]
Political Environment[1]Political Environment[1]
Political Environment[1]pratiksjain
 
Political and legal environment of Business
Political  and  legal environment of BusinessPolitical  and  legal environment of Business
Political and legal environment of BusinessRucha Kularkar
 
3 political environment
3 political environment3 political environment
3 political environmentNasriyah Adnan
 
The Revolving Door and the Corporate Colonisation of UK Politics
The Revolving Door and the Corporate Colonisation of UK PoliticsThe Revolving Door and the Corporate Colonisation of UK Politics
The Revolving Door and the Corporate Colonisation of UK PoliticsMiqui Mel
 
Tortuga article-on-the-foundational-economy-and-the-italian-case
Tortuga article-on-the-foundational-economy-and-the-italian-caseTortuga article-on-the-foundational-economy-and-the-italian-case
Tortuga article-on-the-foundational-economy-and-the-italian-caseMatteo Gallone
 
The causes of success of the micro and small enterprises in Brazil presenta...
The causes of success of the micro and small enterprises in Brazil   presenta...The causes of success of the micro and small enterprises in Brazil   presenta...
The causes of success of the micro and small enterprises in Brazil presenta...Cristiano Machado
 
NATIONAL DIFF IN CULTURE CHAPTER 2 ITERNATIONAL BUSINESS 12130920-093
NATIONAL DIFF IN CULTURE CHAPTER 2 ITERNATIONAL BUSINESS 12130920-093NATIONAL DIFF IN CULTURE CHAPTER 2 ITERNATIONAL BUSINESS 12130920-093
NATIONAL DIFF IN CULTURE CHAPTER 2 ITERNATIONAL BUSINESS 12130920-093Rashid Gorsi
 
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...ECTIJ
 
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...ectijjournal
 
Political environment
Political environmentPolitical environment
Political environmentRajThakuri
 
Lurking in the Shadows: The informal sector and government policy
 Lurking in the Shadows: The informal sector and government policy  Lurking in the Shadows: The informal sector and government policy
Lurking in the Shadows: The informal sector and government policy Dr Lendy Spires
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Informalpaper
InformalpaperInformalpaper
Informalpaper
 
National program for countering shadow economy in Serbia
National program for countering shadow economy in SerbiaNational program for countering shadow economy in Serbia
National program for countering shadow economy in Serbia
 
Determinants of tax compliance behavior in ethiopia the case of bahir dar cit...
Determinants of tax compliance behavior in ethiopia the case of bahir dar cit...Determinants of tax compliance behavior in ethiopia the case of bahir dar cit...
Determinants of tax compliance behavior in ethiopia the case of bahir dar cit...
 
{721 cbbc9 5a7a-b960-0f33-54eecd7e973e}
{721 cbbc9 5a7a-b960-0f33-54eecd7e973e}{721 cbbc9 5a7a-b960-0f33-54eecd7e973e}
{721 cbbc9 5a7a-b960-0f33-54eecd7e973e}
 
Tax Morale and Its Effect on Taxpayers’ Compliance to Tax Policies of the Nig...
Tax Morale and Its Effect on Taxpayers’ Compliance to Tax Policies of the Nig...Tax Morale and Its Effect on Taxpayers’ Compliance to Tax Policies of the Nig...
Tax Morale and Its Effect on Taxpayers’ Compliance to Tax Policies of the Nig...
 
Political Environment[1]
Political Environment[1]Political Environment[1]
Political Environment[1]
 
Fair & Just Fiscal Policy
Fair & Just Fiscal Policy Fair & Just Fiscal Policy
Fair & Just Fiscal Policy
 
Political and legal environment of Business
Political  and  legal environment of BusinessPolitical  and  legal environment of Business
Political and legal environment of Business
 
3 political environment
3 political environment3 political environment
3 political environment
 
The Revolving Door and the Corporate Colonisation of UK Politics
The Revolving Door and the Corporate Colonisation of UK PoliticsThe Revolving Door and the Corporate Colonisation of UK Politics
The Revolving Door and the Corporate Colonisation of UK Politics
 
Tortuga article-on-the-foundational-economy-and-the-italian-case
Tortuga article-on-the-foundational-economy-and-the-italian-caseTortuga article-on-the-foundational-economy-and-the-italian-case
Tortuga article-on-the-foundational-economy-and-the-italian-case
 
The causes of success of the micro and small enterprises in Brazil presenta...
The causes of success of the micro and small enterprises in Brazil   presenta...The causes of success of the micro and small enterprises in Brazil   presenta...
The causes of success of the micro and small enterprises in Brazil presenta...
 
NATIONAL DIFF IN CULTURE CHAPTER 2 ITERNATIONAL BUSINESS 12130920-093
NATIONAL DIFF IN CULTURE CHAPTER 2 ITERNATIONAL BUSINESS 12130920-093NATIONAL DIFF IN CULTURE CHAPTER 2 ITERNATIONAL BUSINESS 12130920-093
NATIONAL DIFF IN CULTURE CHAPTER 2 ITERNATIONAL BUSINESS 12130920-093
 
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
 
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
TAX SYSTEM IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: A CASE STUDY OF HARARE INFORMAL SECTOR TAX...
 
Political environment
Political environmentPolitical environment
Political environment
 
Lurking in the Shadows: The informal sector and government policy
 Lurking in the Shadows: The informal sector and government policy  Lurking in the Shadows: The informal sector and government policy
Lurking in the Shadows: The informal sector and government policy
 
Tax knowledge, Tax Morale, and Tax Compliance : Taxpayers’ View
Tax knowledge, Tax Morale, and Tax Compliance : Taxpayers’ ViewTax knowledge, Tax Morale, and Tax Compliance : Taxpayers’ View
Tax knowledge, Tax Morale, and Tax Compliance : Taxpayers’ View
 
Political environment
Political environmentPolitical environment
Political environment
 
Huss0772
Huss0772Huss0772
Huss0772
 

Andere mochten auch

Decalogodelaamistad
DecalogodelaamistadDecalogodelaamistad
DecalogodelaamistadNathy1108
 
2012 13 seycove programming for current grade 8 &9
2012 13 seycove programming for current grade 8 &92012 13 seycove programming for current grade 8 &9
2012 13 seycove programming for current grade 8 &9Seycove
 
Low birthweight delivery prevalence and associated factors as seen at a terti...
Low birthweight delivery prevalence and associated factors as seen at a terti...Low birthweight delivery prevalence and associated factors as seen at a terti...
Low birthweight delivery prevalence and associated factors as seen at a terti...Michael Olafusi
 
Solar Resource Assessment - How to get bankable meteo data
Solar Resource Assessment - How to get bankable meteo dataSolar Resource Assessment - How to get bankable meteo data
Solar Resource Assessment - How to get bankable meteo dataSolarReference
 
Diari del 04 de desembre de 2012
Diari del 04 de desembre de 2012Diari del 04 de desembre de 2012
Diari del 04 de desembre de 2012diarimes
 
臺灣主題資料庫介紹Republic of China.R.O.C.
臺灣主題資料庫介紹Republic of China.R.O.C.臺灣主題資料庫介紹Republic of China.R.O.C.
臺灣主題資料庫介紹Republic of China.R.O.C.2018fidelity-1
 
215. pavimentación
215. pavimentación215. pavimentación
215. pavimentacióndec-admin3
 
Karannutta aikaa etsimässä_ohjelma_13.-14.6.2014
Karannutta aikaa etsimässä_ohjelma_13.-14.6.2014Karannutta aikaa etsimässä_ohjelma_13.-14.6.2014
Karannutta aikaa etsimässä_ohjelma_13.-14.6.2014Monkey Business®
 
Future Plants Presentation
Future Plants PresentationFuture Plants Presentation
Future Plants Presentationthatpho
 
Mafalda y su deseo de Felicidad!!!
Mafalda y su deseo de Felicidad!!!Mafalda y su deseo de Felicidad!!!
Mafalda y su deseo de Felicidad!!!blogkis Soni
 
Infographie JSF Nanterre 2014
Infographie JSF Nanterre 2014Infographie JSF Nanterre 2014
Infographie JSF Nanterre 2014Baptiste Derenne
 
LMdiscoveryprocess
LMdiscoveryprocessLMdiscoveryprocess
LMdiscoveryprocesssigfrids
 
Standing on chairs
Standing on chairsStanding on chairs
Standing on chairstwalker2
 

Andere mochten auch (19)

Decalogodelaamistad
DecalogodelaamistadDecalogodelaamistad
Decalogodelaamistad
 
MAE - Informe diario 13-03-2014
MAE - Informe diario 13-03-2014MAE - Informe diario 13-03-2014
MAE - Informe diario 13-03-2014
 
comparación de pc
comparación de pccomparación de pc
comparación de pc
 
2012 13 seycove programming for current grade 8 &9
2012 13 seycove programming for current grade 8 &92012 13 seycove programming for current grade 8 &9
2012 13 seycove programming for current grade 8 &9
 
Low birthweight delivery prevalence and associated factors as seen at a terti...
Low birthweight delivery prevalence and associated factors as seen at a terti...Low birthweight delivery prevalence and associated factors as seen at a terti...
Low birthweight delivery prevalence and associated factors as seen at a terti...
 
Solar Resource Assessment - How to get bankable meteo data
Solar Resource Assessment - How to get bankable meteo dataSolar Resource Assessment - How to get bankable meteo data
Solar Resource Assessment - How to get bankable meteo data
 
Diari del 04 de desembre de 2012
Diari del 04 de desembre de 2012Diari del 04 de desembre de 2012
Diari del 04 de desembre de 2012
 
SAK:n graafiset ohjeet
SAK:n graafiset ohjeetSAK:n graafiset ohjeet
SAK:n graafiset ohjeet
 
Product Work Log #5
Product Work Log #5Product Work Log #5
Product Work Log #5
 
臺灣主題資料庫介紹Republic of China.R.O.C.
臺灣主題資料庫介紹Republic of China.R.O.C.臺灣主題資料庫介紹Republic of China.R.O.C.
臺灣主題資料庫介紹Republic of China.R.O.C.
 
White rose template
White rose templateWhite rose template
White rose template
 
215. pavimentación
215. pavimentación215. pavimentación
215. pavimentación
 
Karannutta aikaa etsimässä_ohjelma_13.-14.6.2014
Karannutta aikaa etsimässä_ohjelma_13.-14.6.2014Karannutta aikaa etsimässä_ohjelma_13.-14.6.2014
Karannutta aikaa etsimässä_ohjelma_13.-14.6.2014
 
Future Plants Presentation
Future Plants PresentationFuture Plants Presentation
Future Plants Presentation
 
Mafalda y su deseo de Felicidad!!!
Mafalda y su deseo de Felicidad!!!Mafalda y su deseo de Felicidad!!!
Mafalda y su deseo de Felicidad!!!
 
Esc 2011
Esc 2011Esc 2011
Esc 2011
 
Infographie JSF Nanterre 2014
Infographie JSF Nanterre 2014Infographie JSF Nanterre 2014
Infographie JSF Nanterre 2014
 
LMdiscoveryprocess
LMdiscoveryprocessLMdiscoveryprocess
LMdiscoveryprocess
 
Standing on chairs
Standing on chairsStanding on chairs
Standing on chairs
 

Ähnlich wie Prsp psd informal_sector

Secteur informel emplois_et_transformation_structurelle_english_
Secteur informel emplois_et_transformation_structurelle_english_Secteur informel emplois_et_transformation_structurelle_english_
Secteur informel emplois_et_transformation_structurelle_english_Dr Lendy Spires
 
Powerpoint presentation of_business_globalisation
Powerpoint presentation of_business_globalisationPowerpoint presentation of_business_globalisation
Powerpoint presentation of_business_globalisationshub-singhania
 
The implications that the presence of a large informal sector has on business...
The implications that the presence of a large informal sector has on business...The implications that the presence of a large informal sector has on business...
The implications that the presence of a large informal sector has on business...Dr Lendy Spires
 
Ict access and usage among informal businesses in africa
Ict access and usage among informal businesses in africaIct access and usage among informal businesses in africa
Ict access and usage among informal businesses in africaDr Lendy Spires
 
Formal and Informal Economies - updated march 2020.pptx
Formal and Informal Economies - updated march 2020.pptxFormal and Informal Economies - updated march 2020.pptx
Formal and Informal Economies - updated march 2020.pptxMarChahin1
 
The fight against corruption in latin america and the caribbean…
The fight against corruption in latin america and the caribbean…The fight against corruption in latin america and the caribbean…
The fight against corruption in latin america and the caribbean…Homealoneagain
 
Harnessing the potentials of the informal sector for sustainable development
Harnessing the potentials of the informal sector for sustainable developmentHarnessing the potentials of the informal sector for sustainable development
Harnessing the potentials of the informal sector for sustainable developmentDr Lendy Spires
 
Business environment
Business environmentBusiness environment
Business environment11051992
 
Cso letter digital trade 2019 04-rev
Cso letter digital trade 2019 04-revCso letter digital trade 2019 04-rev
Cso letter digital trade 2019 04-revNGUYEN MINH QUOC
 
Government Tackles Tax Evasion
Government Tackles Tax EvasionGovernment Tackles Tax Evasion
Government Tackles Tax EvasionAngie Willis
 
Fnancial Transparency Glossary
Fnancial Transparency GlossaryFnancial Transparency Glossary
Fnancial Transparency GlossaryMiqui Mel
 
Aruba, Curacao, Dutch Antilles. Their island’s banking seems under a cloak of...
Aruba, Curacao, Dutch Antilles. Their island’s banking seems under a cloak of...Aruba, Curacao, Dutch Antilles. Their island’s banking seems under a cloak of...
Aruba, Curacao, Dutch Antilles. Their island’s banking seems under a cloak of...GhostofBetico
 
Taxing the informal economy challenges, possibiliites and remaining questions
Taxing the informal economy   challenges, possibiliites and remaining questionsTaxing the informal economy   challenges, possibiliites and remaining questions
Taxing the informal economy challenges, possibiliites and remaining questionsDr Lendy Spires
 
Administrative Amp Financial Corruption In Developing Countries ( Case Of S...
Administrative  Amp  Financial Corruption In Developing Countries ( Case Of S...Administrative  Amp  Financial Corruption In Developing Countries ( Case Of S...
Administrative Amp Financial Corruption In Developing Countries ( Case Of S...Dustin Pytko
 
Netherland Antilles, Dutch Antilles, these islands banking systems seem under...
Netherland Antilles, Dutch Antilles, these islands banking systems seem under...Netherland Antilles, Dutch Antilles, these islands banking systems seem under...
Netherland Antilles, Dutch Antilles, these islands banking systems seem under...SantaCruzSaint
 

Ähnlich wie Prsp psd informal_sector (20)

Secteur informel emplois_et_transformation_structurelle_english_
Secteur informel emplois_et_transformation_structurelle_english_Secteur informel emplois_et_transformation_structurelle_english_
Secteur informel emplois_et_transformation_structurelle_english_
 
111611
111611111611
111611
 
Powerpoint presentation of_business_globalisation
Powerpoint presentation of_business_globalisationPowerpoint presentation of_business_globalisation
Powerpoint presentation of_business_globalisation
 
Paper
PaperPaper
Paper
 
The implications that the presence of a large informal sector has on business...
The implications that the presence of a large informal sector has on business...The implications that the presence of a large informal sector has on business...
The implications that the presence of a large informal sector has on business...
 
Liberalization
LiberalizationLiberalization
Liberalization
 
Ict access and usage among informal businesses in africa
Ict access and usage among informal businesses in africaIct access and usage among informal businesses in africa
Ict access and usage among informal businesses in africa
 
Formal and Informal Economies - updated march 2020.pptx
Formal and Informal Economies - updated march 2020.pptxFormal and Informal Economies - updated march 2020.pptx
Formal and Informal Economies - updated march 2020.pptx
 
The fight against corruption in latin america and the caribbean…
The fight against corruption in latin america and the caribbean…The fight against corruption in latin america and the caribbean…
The fight against corruption in latin america and the caribbean…
 
Harnessing the potentials of the informal sector for sustainable development
Harnessing the potentials of the informal sector for sustainable developmentHarnessing the potentials of the informal sector for sustainable development
Harnessing the potentials of the informal sector for sustainable development
 
International conventions against corruption and draft-measures against corru...
International conventions against corruption and draft-measures against corru...International conventions against corruption and draft-measures against corru...
International conventions against corruption and draft-measures against corru...
 
Business environment
Business environmentBusiness environment
Business environment
 
Exploring Tax Morale Essay
Exploring Tax Morale EssayExploring Tax Morale Essay
Exploring Tax Morale Essay
 
Cso letter digital trade 2019 04-rev
Cso letter digital trade 2019 04-revCso letter digital trade 2019 04-rev
Cso letter digital trade 2019 04-rev
 
Government Tackles Tax Evasion
Government Tackles Tax EvasionGovernment Tackles Tax Evasion
Government Tackles Tax Evasion
 
Fnancial Transparency Glossary
Fnancial Transparency GlossaryFnancial Transparency Glossary
Fnancial Transparency Glossary
 
Aruba, Curacao, Dutch Antilles. Their island’s banking seems under a cloak of...
Aruba, Curacao, Dutch Antilles. Their island’s banking seems under a cloak of...Aruba, Curacao, Dutch Antilles. Their island’s banking seems under a cloak of...
Aruba, Curacao, Dutch Antilles. Their island’s banking seems under a cloak of...
 
Taxing the informal economy challenges, possibiliites and remaining questions
Taxing the informal economy   challenges, possibiliites and remaining questionsTaxing the informal economy   challenges, possibiliites and remaining questions
Taxing the informal economy challenges, possibiliites and remaining questions
 
Administrative Amp Financial Corruption In Developing Countries ( Case Of S...
Administrative  Amp  Financial Corruption In Developing Countries ( Case Of S...Administrative  Amp  Financial Corruption In Developing Countries ( Case Of S...
Administrative Amp Financial Corruption In Developing Countries ( Case Of S...
 
Netherland Antilles, Dutch Antilles, these islands banking systems seem under...
Netherland Antilles, Dutch Antilles, these islands banking systems seem under...Netherland Antilles, Dutch Antilles, these islands banking systems seem under...
Netherland Antilles, Dutch Antilles, these islands banking systems seem under...
 

Prsp psd informal_sector

  • 1. Informal sector support and Poverty Reduction1 Niklaus Eggenberger-Argote Contents Introduction 1. Causes of high business costs and informal sectors 2. Approaches to promote the formalisation of the informal economy 3. Approaches to support informal sector actors within the informal sector Conclusion Bibliography February 2005 1 The following paper is a desk study of existing literature on behalf of the Swiss State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (seco).
  • 2. 2 Executive Summary The recent trend towards democratisation and market-based systems has improved the live of millions worldwide. Many countries have increased political participation and achieved macroeconomic stabilisation and growth. However, there are also mil-lions of people in emerging democracies who are excluded from the political and economic system and are living in poverty. A glaring symptom is the growing number of entrepreneurs engaged in low-income and low-growth business activities in the informal sector. Roughly a third of the GDP of emerging markets is produced infor-mally. This paper will provide a deeper insight into the relevant causes of informal sectors, the macro-level interventions needed to promote the formalisation of the informal economy, and the steps required to assist informal sector entrepreneurs within the informal sector. High business costs and the informal economy are mainly caused by: ill-designed and unstable rules and regulations (particularly in relation to taxation, labour policy and business registration); a lack of well-defined and secure property rights; poor-quality or non-existent infrastructure and public services; deficient government ca-pacity and resources to enforce laws and regulations; a lack of transparency, ac-countability and autonomy of governmental institutions (e.g. the judiciary); as well as a high degree of macroeconomic instability, unemployment and corruption. The key to facilitating the informal sector’s participation in the formal economy, there-fore, is to establish transparent and inclusive mechanisms through which citizens can regularly voice their concerns, participate in policy and law making, monitor public and private sector activity and hold public and private sector actors accountable. Fur-ther interventions include: fostering macroeconomic stability and growth; clarifying and streamlining legal and regulatory codes; ensuring and enforcing property rights and legal security; simplifying business permits and licences and making them af-fordable to all; reforming tax and labour policies; instituting corporate governance legislation, conflict of interest laws, international government procurement codes and anti-bribery principles; reforming bureaucratic government institutions and strength-ening their administrative and enforcement capacities; making essential business-related information available to all; and providing high quality, cost-effective and well-maintained infrastructure and public services. Some of the macro-level interventions aimed at formalising the informal economy also facilitate entrepreneurship in the informal sector and therefore are useful instru-ments for supporting actors within the informal sector, too. Examples are: efforts to promote macroeconomic stability and growth; to guarantee and enforce property rights and legal security; and to provide a minimal, but functioning and well-maintained, infrastructure.
  • 3. 3 Introduction An extensive informal economy is characteristic of the business sector of many de-veloping countries. Billions of dollars in potential profits are lost each year in emerg-ing democracies and economies because ill-designed, complex laws and regulations exclude millions of citizens from the political and economic system and unnecessarily raise the costs of doing business in the formal sector. A recent IMF study revealed that about nine trillion dollars – roughly a third of the GDP of emerging markets – was produced informally. Similarly, ILO figures indicate that, in 1999, 17% to 84% of the urban labour force in developing countries worked informally. The informal sector consists of entrepreneurs who produce legitimate products with-out proper permits and legal status because they lack the resources and/or the in-centives to comply with the burdensome and excessive rules and regulations neces-sary to become part of the formal economy. Informal sector activities are extra-legal in the regulatory, but not in the criminal, sense. Hence, the informal sector is a very heterogeneous and complex phenomenon: it includes urban poor people, who de-pend on informal subsistence activities for their livelihood, as well as higher-income people entering the informal economy as a way of supplementing declining formal sector incomes or of increasing profit margins. The understanding of the complexity and heterogeneity of the informal sector has significant implications for any strategy and policy interventions trying to alleviate poverty in this sector and to formalise the informal economy. A large informal sector has serious consequences for private sector activity, eco-nomic growth and the consolidation of democracy. It weakens democracy, hinders necessary reforms, and contributes to misguided policies due to the illegality of the ’informals’ preventing them from voicing their concerns to government officials and holding them accountable. Therefore, reforms that would increase private sector ac-tivity and growth are not implemented. Because informal activities are not reported, policy makers do not have the necessary information to make adequate decisions. Furthermore, if the legal and regulatory framework does not encourage an efficient use of resources, the economy cannot achieving its production potential. Resource allocation is distorted, while productivity and competitiveness are lowered, giving rich, but not necessarily efficient, producers an unfair advantage. The informal sector places significant constraints particularly on smaller firms, limiting their access to fi-nancial resources, public services and utilities, and narrowing the kind of contracts or investments they can make. Job creation and chances for upward social mobility are severely restrained. Additionally, the failure to attract firms to formal market activities results in foregone tax revenues, which reduces government’s ability to finance essential business-related goods and services – and in turn discourages even more entrepreneurs from
  • 4. 4 paying taxes and business-related fees. High business costs and a lack of informa-tion and transparency also invite corruption. ‘Informals’ are illegal and therefore do not benefit from law enforcement services. They, therefore, have to resort to bribery in order to avoid costly punishment or to obtain certain services and protection. In short, high business costs and the informal sector are closely linked with low growth, poverty, reinforced inequality and the weakening of political and economic institu-tions. What can be done to lower business costs? How can policymakers reform key politi-cal and economic institutions so that informal sector entrepreneurs in emerging de-mocracies will participate actively in the formal economy and in policymaking? What can be done to assist people in the informal sector? This paper will provide a deeper insight into the relevant causes of high business costs and informality, macro-level approaches and policy interventions to promote the formalisation of the informal economy, and action required to assist entrepre-neurs within the informal sector. Poverty Reduction Strategies (PRS) should reflect these concerns, since they are supposed to enhance the interests of the people living in poverty, many of whom depend on the informal economy for their livelihoods. 1. Causes of high business costs and informal sectors Where do high business costs and large informal sectors come from? Identifying the obstacles to joining the formal economy and the sources of high business costs is the first step towards reducing barriers to entering the formal economy. The underlying reasons for many citizens in emerging democratic, market-based sys-tems not participating in the political and economic system are the ill-designed ‘rules of the game’, undemocratic decision-making, and poor quality government services. These contribute to prohibitively expensive costs of doing business, the removal of incentives to comply with burdensome rules and regulations, and the erection of bar-riers to participation. Among the most common examples of ill-designed rules and regulations are taxation and labour policies. High tax rates and poorly administered taxation systems reduce profit margins, which encourages tax evasion and recourse to the informal sector. Similarly, restrictive labour regulations impose substantial, fixed burdens on firms, particularly the low income-earning ones, and make the hiring of informal workers attractive. Setting up a business is often a troublesome and long-term adventure. Acquiring le-gal property titles for assets such as a piece of land is one of the first steps to regis-tering a business. The lack of well-defined and secure property rights lowers the in-centive to register property and hinders the obtaining of credit and the conversion of
  • 5. 5 assets into productive capital. In his recent book, The Mystery of Capital, Hernando de Soto has argued that the developing world is sitting on some US$ 9,3 trillion in unreleased land value (’dead capital’), which is largely in the hands of poor people, because imperfect property rights do not allow their formalisation, capitalisation, and hence, conversion into working capital. De Soto illustrates how burdensome obtain-ing legal real estate titles can be in some countries: in the Philippines, for example, it requires 168 bureaucratic steps involving 53 public and private agencies and taking from 13 to 25 years. In Haiti it requires clearing 111 bureaucratic hurdles, and takes approximately 12 years. Business registration requires more than ’mere’ property titles in hand; entrepreneurs are confronted with further expensive and complicated licence and permit require-ments. The Harvard Institute of Economic Research recently published a survey of the official requirements to set up a business in 75 countries. The results indicate that the process entails, at best, two steps, two business days, and US$ 280 in Canada; at worst, 20 steps, 82 days, and US$ 2996 in Bolivia. Once registered, remaining formal is often made hazardous by unclear, unknown, conflicting, and frequently changing laws and regulations. In Perú, 73% of all costs of remaining formal came from following administrative rules. Complying with laws and regulations becomes even more overwhelming and costly if government agencies lack adequate financial, technical and human resources to administer and enforce them quickly and correctly. The degree of transparency, accountability, and political autonomy of government institutions and the extent of officials’ discretion in implementing and enforcing laws are other important factors influencing the costs of doing business. The judiciary is one of the most important government agencies in this regard: without an impartial, transparent, efficient and credible judicial system, business activity becomes very costly, thus encouraging recourse to the informal economy and weakening democ-racy and market-based transactions. Poor-quality or non-existent infrastructure (roads, transport, access to public service utilities such as electricity, water, etc.) further raises business costs and hampers market efficiency by discouraging mobility, lowering productivity, stimulating corrup-tion and further limiting access to markets. Moreover, entrepreneurs have little incen-tive to pay taxes or business-related fees for services that are poor or non-existent. Finally, a high degree of macroeconomic instability (lack of fiscal discipline, highly volatile prices and inflation, high levels of government interventionism) also creates greater incentives to operate informally and induces capital flight, foreign exchange purchases and barter. Further high unemployment rates in the formal economy are reasons to turn to the informal sector. A recent poll in Brazil revealed that one third of
  • 6. 6 the respondents engaged in informal sector activities because of rising unemploy-ment rates and lower wages in the formal economy. In short, high business costs and the informal sector are mainly caused by ill-designed and unstable rules and regulations (particularly in relation to taxation, la-bour policy and business registration); the lack of well-defined and secure property rights; poor quality or non-existent public services; deficient capacities and resources of government agencies to administer and enforce laws and regulations; a lack of transparency, accountability and political autonomy of governmental institutions (par-ticularly the judiciary); as well as high degrees of macroeconomic instability, unem-ployment and corruption. A worldwide survey of 10,000 enterprises, carried out during 1999 and 2000 under the leadership of the World Bank, to document the leading obstacles to doing busi-ness identified by business managers and owners in developing countries confirms the relevance of the sources for high business costs and the informal sector men-tioned above. The list is topped by: taxes and regulations, financing difficulties, infla-tion, and political instability or uncertainty. Among other obstacles perceived as very serious are: corruption, exchange rate problems and street crime. 2. Approaches to promote the formalisation of the informal economy The main sources for high business costs and the informal sector presented in the previous section give a general overview of what is needed to reduce barriers to par-ticipation in the formal economy. Here, several intervention approaches aimed at opening up participation processes, stimulating informal sector formalisation and tap-ping its growth potential will be examined. 1. Fostering macroeconomic stability as a precondition for economic reform, growth and informal sector formalisation A sound and stable economic foundation is a prerequisite for economic reform, growth and the success of subsequent measures. Governments should institute fiscal discipline and a monetary policy geared towards low inflation in order to at-tain and maintain macroeconomic stability. Also, the degree of intervention in the economy should be limited: more liberal trade regimes, exchange rate and inter-est rate policies and reduced barriers to foreign investment enable economic growth and create important enabling conditions for the informal sector to become formalised. Interventions aimed at promoting broad-based growth and creating jobs in the formal economy generally improve the enabling conditions for a formalisation of the informal sector, unemployment in the formal sector being an important reason for becoming active in the informal sector.
  • 7. 7 2. Increasing public participation and transparency in the policy making and legisla-tive process by instituting transparent, inclusive decision-making procedures and providing regular opportunities for the public to comment on existing and pro-posed laws and regulations Countries with representative governments and checks and balances have sig-nificantly fewer entry barriers for new firms. In addition, checks and balances be-tween government branches help minimise frequent, radical changes to the legal and regulatory framework. Hence, the business costs in the formal sector can be reduced through enhancing the degree of public participation in the policymaking and legislative processes by: ¾ instituting transparent and inclusive decision-making procedures; ¾ implementing legislative procedures that ensure public access to plenary and committee meetings; ¾ holding public hearings on proposed legislation and regulations; ¾ appointing independent ombudsmen to represent citizens’ interests to legisla-tors and government officials; and ¾ empowering citizens to initiate legislation and referendums and to challenge existing laws and policies. Legislative advisory programmes, therefore, are an essential tool for reform, and policy dialogue is a valuable means of increasing its effectiveness. 3. Clarifying and streamlining legal and regulatory codes by eliminating duplicative, superfluous laws that increase the costs of doing business and invite for corrup-tion Laws and regulations should be clarified so that rights and responsibilities are clearly defined, rules clearly specified, and administrative and enforcement pro-cedures simplified. Superfluous, complex and conflicting laws and regulations should be rescinded and the steps necessary to comply with laws should be streamlined in order to minimise the possibility of multiple interpretations and ap-plications of laws and regulations. Any viable short-term strategy to improve the business climate and to reduce business costs should first of all ensure that the appropriate legal and regulatory codes are in place and regularly enforced. 4. Making private property rights accessible to all, clearly defined and strongly en-forced
  • 8. 8 According to Hernando de Soto, prosperity cannot be broad-based until property rights are secure for all citizens. Property rights are the legal vehicle through which assets are converted into productive capital. They should, therefore, be re-formed and strengthened so that private assets serve as an engine of growth and productivity. Property rights need to establish straightforward standards to identify asset owners and to indicate how property can be combined, leased, bought, sold or exchanged securely for productive purposes. Additionally, property rights, in order to be secure, need to be strongly and consistently enforced by an effective and impartial legal system. A study by the World Bank and Princeton University showed that an initial invest-ment of US$ 15 million in legalising dwellings and small enterprises in Perú, be-tween 1990 and 1996, provided US$ 9,4 billion in additional income to poor peo-ple. Further, there was a 28% increase in school enrolment in shanty towns where legal security had been established. 5. Simplifying business permits and licenses and making them affordable so that becoming part of the formal economy is within reach for entrepreneurs of modest means Business costs can be lowered significantly if processes to obtain business per-mits and licences are facilitated. Requirements to get a permit have to be simple, straightforward, well-publicised and accessible to entrepreneurs of modest means. A one-step process that can be followed in different cities throughout a country would greatly reduce start-up costs. Additionally, it should be legally man-dated that, once these requirements are fulfilled, permits and licences are granted immediately and are automatically registered in a centralised business registry for public record. 6. Reforming tax systems in order to encourage profitable economic activity and promote widespread compliance Taxation systems should be reformed by lowering the overall tax rate, by target-ing corporate and income taxes, and by making tax codes simple and straightfor-ward. Multi-step, complex procedures on fiscal reporting should be eliminated. Also, a consistent enforcement of taxation laws should be strengthened by in-creasing government’s administrative capacity and minimising officials’ discre-tionary powers. Such measures not only lower business costs, they also tend to increase reve-nues by broadening the taxation base in the long-term. Higher revenues, in turn, prepare the ground for better quality public services – although one has to ac-knowledge that there is no automatic positive relationship between higher reve-nues and better public services. Gelöscht: ¶
  • 9. 9 7. Overhauling labour laws to allow for more flexibility Labour, as well as tax policies, are key to improving the business environment. In order to make hiring of formal workers more attractive, labour regulations have to allow for more flexible work contracts, such as part-time or short-term employ-ment or contract-based arrangements. Moreover, the right to associate freely should be vigorously protected. Individuals in any industry or sector should have the right to choose whether or not to join a trade or labour union. 8. Opening markets and combating cronyism through improved corporate govern-ance legislation Introducing corporate governance measures greatly helps to improve a country’s business climate. There is a need for legislation to protect investors, sharehold-ers, and other stakeholders by adopting internationally accepted accounting prin-ciples, standards of disclosure, and anti-trust and anti-conflict of interest meas-ures, as well as prohibiting insider trading and overhauling bankruptcy laws. Clarifying conflict of interest laws, adopting Transparency International’s govern-ment procurement codes, and upholding OECD anti-bribery principles further help to combat cronyism and corruption: fewer funds will then line the pockets of gov-ernment cronies and their private sector pals. 9. Reforming excessively bureaucratic government agencies and strengthening their administrative and enforcement capacities Government agencies that are excessively bureaucratic and inefficient need to be reformed. This can be achieved by streamlining and simplifying agencies’ internal operating procedures and by regularly evaluating their performance according to clear and well-defined standards. Furthermore, administrative and enforcement capacities of government agencies have to be strengthened. Successful means include: cultivating a staff of well-qualified civil servants, basing the hiring and promoting staff on verifiable profes-sional standards, offering civil servants vocational training, paying adequate sala-ries to attract well-qualified personal and to deter bribe-taking, and offering tenure based on performance (not on the election cycle). In addition, sufficient financial and technical resources to administer laws expediently should be provided. Particular emphasis should be given to reforming and strengthening the judiciary so that it enforces laws consistently, efficiently and fairly, thereby maintaining the rule of law.
  • 10. 10 10. Making essential business-related information available to all Providing essential business information and training concerning how to obtain permits and licences, how to form legal commercial entities, how to invest, and how to understand and comply with business-related laws and regulations greatly increases transparency and facilitates complying with the requirements. 11. Providing high quality, efficient, and cost-effective infrastructure essential for a democratic, market-based system so that entrepreneurs benefit from joining the formal sector The provision of a high quality, efficient, cost-effective and well-maintained infrastruc-ture of transport, telecommunications, water, and power is essential for economic growth and the expansion of employment. Improved public services and infrastruc-ture increase productivity, facilitate access to markets and, hence, provide an incen-tive for entrepreneurs to remain in, or to join, the formal sector economy. A fair amount of competition in these domains, through privatisation or transparent subcon-tracting bids with the government, greatly increases the efficiency, cost-effectiveness and quality of infrastructure provision. The key to facilitating informal sector’s participation in the formal economy and in the policymaking and lawmaking processes is to institute democratic governance in the public and private sectors. This entails establishing mechanisms through which citi-zens can regularly voice their concerns and participate in policy and law making, monitor public and private sector activity and hold public and private sector actors accountable. Using such mechanisms, private sector associations and citizens can advocate for reforms that reduce business costs, and encourage and facilitate par-ticipation in the formal economy. Such measures help to make both the public and private sectors more responsive to citizen’s needs, increase efficiency, transparency, accountability and growth, and reduce corruption. 3. Approaches to support informal sector actors within the informal sector Implementing only a few of the above-mentioned intervention approaches alone will not yet lead to a formalisation of the informal economy; the reasons for formal sector actors joining the informal sector are multi-faceted. However, some of the strategies that provide incentives for informal actors to join the formal sector also facilitate eco-nomic activity within the informal sector. This is particularly true for macro-level inter-ventions aimed at creating a stable macroeconomic environment and promoting growth, ensuring property rights and legal security, and providing public services and infrastructure. Micro-level interventions providing Business Development Services,
  • 11. 11 micro-finance and skills training for informal sector actors or building capacities of grassroots self-help organisations will not be addressed further in this paper2. 1. Fostering macroeconomic stability and promoting growth as a precondition for any economic activity A sound and stable macroeconomic environment that enables economic growth, prevents high volatilities and dampens external and internal shocks not only stimulates the formalisation of the informal sector, but also facilitates business ac-tivity in both the formal and the informal sectors. The dynamics of a sound and stable economic environment, and increasing demands due to economic growth, will also positively affect informal sector activities. The same is true of a stable po-litical environment and public safety, since high rates of crime and violence dis-proportionately affect informal sector actors such as street vendors. 2. Ensuring private property rights for all citizens, clearly defined and strongly en-forced Ensuring private property rights and legal security not only prepares the ground for formalising the informal sector. Secured, clearly defined and effectively en-forced property rights greatly encourage any economic activity, also in the infor-mal sector, and facilitate the conversion of private assets (dead capital) into pro-ductive capital. Without legally protected private property rights, entrepreneurs constantly face the risks of confiscation, forced relocation and harassment. In ad-dition, they have few incentives to train personnel or purchase machines and other equipment in order to improve productivity and undertake larger-scale and longer-term investment. Insecure property rights also damage economic performance in other ways: ob-taining water, electricity and telephone services usually requires a property title. The same is true for access to finance and banking. In addition, as the World Bank and Princeton study showed, ensuring property rights and legal security for poor people also had a positive impact on school enrolment rates, thereby pro-moting human capital-building and skills acquisition. Informal sector activities can also be supported by authorities applying more real-istic land-use standards, and providing public land for enterprises and markets. 3. Providing a minimal and well-maintained infrastructure essential for conducting any economic activity The provision of a minimal, well-maintained infrastructure of transport, telecom-munications, water and power is essential for economic growth and the expansion 2 According to instruction by seco.
  • 12. 12 of employment in both the formal and informal sectors. Besides adopting more realistic land-use standards and providing public land for enterprises and markets, authorities could actively support the informal sector by developing a basic infra-structure for informal enterprises. The installation of electricity or water, for exam-ple, spurs productivity. The same is true of transportation: a lack of access to transport discourages mobility, limits access to markets and to inputs for produc-tion and, therefore, affects productivity and profit margins in a negative way. In short, some of the measures for stimulating the informal sector’s formalisation, presented in Section 2, also facilitate business activities in the informal sector. This holds for interventions at the macro-level – e.g. promoting economic stability and growth, ensuring property rights and legal security, and providing a functioning basic infrastructure – as well as at the micro-level – e.g. providing Business Development Services, access to micro-finance and skills training programmes. The strengthening of self-help grassroots organisations and informal entrepreneurs’ associations both supports increasing public participation in the shaping of policy and lawmaking proc-esses, which is the first step towards a formalisation of the informal sector, and pro-vides an impetus for pursuing own interests and rights within the informal sector. Conclusion This paper has provided a deeper insight into the relevant causes of high business costs and the informal sector, into macro-level approaches and policy interventions to promote the formalisation of the informal economy, and into the action required to support informal sector entrepreneurs within the informal sector. Identifying the sources of high business costs and the informal sector is a first step towards reducing the barriers to entering the formal sector, while also supporting in-formal entrepreneurs within the informal sector. High business costs and widespread informal sector activity are mainly caused by: ill-designed and unstable rules and regulations; a lack of well-defined and secure property rights; poor quality and non-existent infrastructure and public services; deficient capacities and resources of gov-ernment agencies to administer and enforce laws and regulations; a lack of transpar-ency, accountability and political autonomy of governmental institutions; as well as a high degree of macroeconomic instability, unemployment and corruption. In this regard, concrete intervention to promote the formalisation of the informal sec-tor should focus on: promoting macroeconomic stability and growth; clarifying and streamlining legal and regulatory codes; ensuring and enforcing property rights and legal security; simplifying business permits and licences and making them affordable for all; reforming tax and labour policies; instituting corporate governance legislation, conflict of interest laws, international government procurement codes and anti-bribery principles; reforming bureaucratic government institutions and strengthening their
  • 13. 13 administrative and enforcement capacities; making essential business-related infor-mation available to all; and providing high quality, cost-effective and well maintained infrastructure and public services. Some of the macro-level interventions aimed at formalising the informal economy also facilitate entrepreneurship within the informal sector. Cases in point are efforts to promote macroeconomic stability and growth, to guarantee and enforce property rights and legal security, and to provide a minimal, but well-maintained infrastructure. Interventions at the micro-level, such as the provision of Business Development Ser-vices, access to micro-finance and skills training programmes, which dominate most of the donor efforts in relation to the informal sector, have not been explicitly dis-cussed in this paper. The key to facilitating the informal sector’s participation in the formal economy is to establish transparent and inclusive mechanisms through which citizens can regularly voice their concerns and participate in policy and lawmaking, monitor public and pri-vate sector activity and hold public and private sector actors accountable. Private sector associations and citizens can use such mechanisms to advocate for reforms that reduce business costs, and encourage and facilitate the formal sector. This re-sults in an increase in efficiency, transparency, accountability and growth and a re-duction of corruption. Moreover, greater citizens’ participation in the shaping of re-form processes will create a sense of ownership, which is essential for the consolida-tion of any democratic and market-based reforms.
  • 14. 14 Bibliography De Soto, Hernando: The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Eve-rywhere Else. London, Bantam Press. 2000. Center for International Private Enterprise: Barriers to Participation: The Informal Sector in Emerging Democracies. Ple-nary Session Workshop Report. Presented at the Second Global Assembly of the World Movement for Democracy. São Paolo, Brazil. November 13, 2000. URL: www.cipe.org/programs/informalsector/reducinginformality/initiatives.htm Center for International Private Enterprise: Country Focus: CIPE projects designed to identify and reduce barriers to for-mality and business costs. URL: www.cipe.org/programs/informalsector/country/index.htm International Labor Organization, Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific: The informal sector. Bangkok. 2000. URL: www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/feature/inf_sect.htm Kuchta-Helbling, Catherine: Background Paper. Barriers to Participation: The Informal Sector in Emerging Democracies. Presented at the World Movement for Democracy. Second Global Assembly: Confronting Challenges to Democracy in the 21st. century. The Center for International Enterprise. São Paolo, Brazil. November 13, 2000. Kuchta-Helbling, Catherine: Tapping Hidden Fortunes. Center for International Enterprise. 2001. URL: www.cipe.org/programs/informalsector/tapping.htm Neue Zürcher Zeitung: Wirtschaften im Schatten. Grosses aber unausgeschöpftes Entwicklungspo-tential in Brasiliens informellem Sektor. 11./12. Dezember 2004, S. 29. Sethuraman, S.V.: Urban Poverty and the Informal Sector. A Critical Assessment of Current Strategies. United Nations Development Programme, New York. 1997. The World Bank Group: The Informal Economy and Local Development. Program and Project Options. Main Problems Faced by those in the Informal Economy. URL: www.worldbank.org/html/fpd/urban/led/main_problems.html
  • 15. 15 Tokman, Víctor E.: El sector informal en América Latina. Dos décadas de análisis. Consejo Na-cional para la Cultura y las Artes. México. 1995. United Nations Human Settlements Programme: Urban Economy Livelihood. Trends in International Employment. 2000. Chap-ter 4, pp. 80-89. . URL: www.unchs.org/Istanbul+5/84.pdf