1. Learning Management Systems Open Source versus Proprietary software Danit Isaacs Department of Technologically-Enhanced learning May 6 2009 Ariel, Israel Mathematical Olympiad; Mathematical Competitions Workshop
2. Learning Management System (LMS) Black Board WebCT SharePointLMSJoomlaLMS High Learn Moodle Sakai A-Tutor
3.
4. Learning Management System (LMS) Black Board WebCT SharePointLMSJoomlaLMS High Learn Moodle Sakai A-Tutor Proprietary software Open Source
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Hinweis der Redaktion
Proprietary software is computer software which is the legal property of one party. The terms of use for other parties is defined by contracts or licensing agreements. These terms may include various privileges to share, alter, dissemble, and use the software and its code. In the free software movement the term is used for software that may not be used, modified and distributed according to the definitions of free software or for which the source code is not available. GNU General Public License
prominent A-Tutor is unique for its accessibility features, (useful to visually-impaired and disabled learners- complies completely with the accessibility specifications of W3C WCAG 1.0 at the AA+ level Standards association stamp
Differ by Learner Tools Communication Tools Discussion Forums File Exchange Internal Email Online Journal/Notes Real-time Chat Video Services Whiteboard Productivity Tools Bookmarks Orientation/Help Searching Within Course Calendar/Progress Review Work Offline/Synchronize Student Involvement Tools Groupwork Self-assessment Student Community Building Student Portfolios Support Tools Administration Tools Authentication Course Authorization Registration Integration Hosted Services Course Delivery Tools Course Management Instructor Helpdesk Online Grading Tools Student Tracking Automated Testing and Scoring Curriculum Design Accessibility Compliance Course Templates Curriculum Management Customized Look and Feel Instructional Standards Compliance Instructional Design Tools Content Sharing/Reuse Technical Specifications Hardware/Software Client Browser Required Database Requirements Server Software UNIX Server Windows Server Pricing/Licensing Company Profile Costs Open Source Optional Extras Software Version
perception and policy yearly cost of licensing license restriction against customizing While the product is free, the overall cost of running an Open Source product is not zero
we cannot interface directly to the backend database of Blackboard without breaking terms and conditions of purchase. We wish to do this to reduce the administration overhead of maintaining student accounts on blackboard. There is no technical reason why this cannot be done, the database is able to be queried and modified. However, as Moodle is Open Source, we were able to apply a middle-tier system to load students directly from our SMS (Student Management System) into the MySQL database of Moodle. This is huge time saving for the eLearning administration staff. Interface between the Student Management System and the LMS
flexibility
Moodle is designed to help educators create online courses with opportunities for rich interaction. Its open source license and modular design means that people can develop additional functionality. Development is undertaken by a globally diffused network of commercial and non-commercial users, streamlined by the Moodle company based in Perth, Western Australia.
The problem resolution procedures between the systems are quite different. With a closed system like Blackboard usually, the problem is logged or ticketed and then someone is assigned to your problem. With an Open Source system such as Moodle you need to search the user forums and if no one else has had the same problem, you then submit your problem to the forum hoping that someone can help. This can sometimes be problematic; more so if the problem is critical