Women CEO’s in Family Business: Challenges & Differentiating Styles
1. Women CEO’s in Family Business:
Challenges
&
Differentiating Styles
A Survey Report
By Dale Carnegie Training® India
2. Relevance
80% of businesses all over the world are family owned
From traditional small businesses to a third of Fortune 500
companies
65% of top 500 BSE listed companies are family controlled,*
about 70% of all BSE listed companies are family controlled
54% market capitalization on BSE (2007-08)
contributed by the above family controlled companies
3. . . . Relevance
A vital force but . . .
Less than a third survive the transition from the first
generation to the second
Of these, about half do not survive the transition to the
third generation
Can a greater role for women in family businesses turn the
survival statistics???
4. Significance
No structured and published research done on
Owner-Promoter Women CEOs till date
This is the first survey, globally, giving an insight
into leadership aspects of women CEOs of family
businesses
5. Survey Objectives
Demographics
Entry in the family business
Initial challenges in the business
Gender related challenges
Growth corridor
Mentoring and grooming
Leadership styles
Advantages of being a woman leader
Disadvantages of being a woman leader
Critical skills for success as a CEO
6. Research Span
Number of respondents: 26
Average age: 40 years
Geographic span: Pan India
Status: Board level / CEO position
7. Personal Demographics
Designation 12% Chairperson level; 84% JMD/ED/VC/Dir /ED /Non-ED /
Whole Time Dir; 4% Other
Age 68% 25-45 years; 28% 46-55 years, 4% 65 years and above
Education 32% G; 52% PG/MBA; 12% Splzn (Ph.D./MBBS), 4% OPM
from USA
Marital status 68% married/with children; 28% single/with children, 4% Other
Prior experience 40% 1 - 3 yrs; 32% 4 - 9 yrs; 28% 10+ yrs
8. Business Characteristics
Age of Business: 76% companies were more than 20 years old
Industry Verticals: Construction, Consulting, Engineering,
FMCG, Infrastructure, IT, Logistics, Manufacturing.
Business Turnover: 32% < Rs. 100 Cr; 28% Rs. 100-500 Cr;
40% > Rs. 500 Cr
Company Type: 48% public limited; 52% privately held
9. Reasons for Joining Family
Business
48% - Felt it was a better career choice
40% - By chance
36% - Planned succession
28% - Because of business need
10. Initial Challenges Faced
72% - needed to juggle family and business demands
88% - received support from family for household
responsibilities
28% - had to put extra efforts to prove competence to
family members
8% - entry into the business created conflict among
management/employees
11. Gender - related Challenges
Agreed
52% disagreed having faced any gender bias at work
28% felt they faced gender bias from external business community
44% felt their performance was assessed more critically by all stakeholders
60% agreed they face more leadership challenges than the male counterparts
28% said they had to put extra effort to prove competence to other family members
36% said that their remuneration was not at par with the male counterparts
24% said that they have been given concessions/flexibility for work hours/travel / leave
20% said that being a woman have been given less critical responsibilities
20% said that their performance evaluation criteria different than other male family
members
12. Growth Corridor
24% joined at entry level, 20% at middle / supervisory level and
44% senior / managerial level and 12 % at top level
15% took less than 1 year to reach the top, while 39% took 2 to 4
years, 11% took 4 to 7 years and 35% took more than 7 years
52% agreed that their rise to the top was easier than in
professionally-managed companies
60% agreed that their hierarchical progress was faster than other
colleagues
44% agreed that one needs to have at least 10 years of experience to
get accepted as leader
13. Mentoring / Grooming
68% received specific grooming for their roles
68% had been coached for leadership responsibilities
Methods of Mentoring:
35% - Mentoring by a family member
12% - Early informal induction (16 to 17 years age) like office visits,
etc.
23% - On-the-job learning, experiential learning
12% - Observation of other business leaders
12% - One-to-one Mentoring by external consultant/Board members
14. Decision-making / Authority &
Attitude
Only 32% were final decision makers; 68% shared decision
making authority
68% had authority at all levels, 24% had only at strategic
level, and 8% had only at operational level
76% said they share accountability with other family members
84% said they are they are known to take tough / unpopular
decisions
92% agreed that they will do whatever it takes to achieve the
end results
15. Leadership Style
84% felt their strength was in Planning, Organizing and Execution
70% felt they were also strong in providing Strategic Direction for their
business
52% agreed that they were cautious and slow in taking business risks
Only 32% felt that they commanded more respect and trust being a woman
100% felt that they are amenable and friendly as a leader
52% felt that they are cautious and slow in taking business risk
16. Advantages of being a
Woman Owner-Promoter CEO
Agreed
Decision making authority 80%
Shared accountability 76%
Greater risk taking capability 68%
Flexibility of time 64%
Faster career progression 52%
17. Disadvantages of being a
Woman Owner-Promoter CEO
Agreed
Tough balancing business and family interests 60%
Restricted personal growth 20%
Lower acceptance of authority by male
family members 24%
18. Critical Skills for a Successful
CEO
Knowledge of external environment, trends, functional knowledge
and competence
Vision, foresight and planning, ability to see a bigger picture
Building strategic direction and clarity of purpose, leadership skills
Ability to articulate, communicate and inspire, people skills
Thinking out of the box, innovative thinking, taking risks
Dedication, Perseverance, Ambition, Drive, Passion, Hard Work
Emotional control, Empathy, cool head
Ability to execute, implement
Risk taking ability