SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 2
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Say Something Substantial

What Constitutes a Substantial Posting?

Each posting should effectively drive conversation and motivate the other members of
the group to think more deeply about the topic being discussed. To accomplish this goal,
it is essential that teachers make their expectations for student responses clear before
initiating online conversations or activities. If students understand why they are being
asked to do something, they are more likely to do it.

Explain that this classroom site is a forum for them to engage in conversations, activities,
and collaboration. If they actively participate in the online forum, it will support and
strengthen their understanding of the curriculum.

It is important that the students feel that the online forum is their space and, as such, it
is crucial that each member of the class/group take an active role in ensuring a high
quality of discussion.

Review the following with your students prior to their first interactions in the online
classroom site.

A substantial posting will do the following:

      •  Present a new question for discussion to broaden, refine, or redirect the
         conversation.

      •  Discuss a personal experience (i.e. memory, interaction, person, class, book, etc.)
         that has influenced your perception of a given topic. Provide specific details about
         where your ideas, beliefs, opinions, etc. come from to support your statements.

      •  Think outside the box or play devil’s advocate (respectfully, of course). Providing
         another point of view on a topic being discussed can be both interesting and
         enlightening, effectively sparking further discussion.

      •  Ask your peers for clarification on ideas that you do not clearly understand. Your
         peers are your best resources.

      •  Make connections between the discussions taking place in the classroom forum to
         information learned in other classes and subject areas. Connecting what you are
         learning to past knowledge or experiences will strengthen your retention of that
         information.




                  Go to www.CollaborizeClassroom.com for more information
Say Something Substantial

        •  Share a resource that you have used that has been helpful for you. Use the
           attachment feature to share images, documents, and videos that will add to the
           conversation.

        •  Summarize the main ideas being discussed or presented in your own words to
           ensure you have a strong grasp of the central concepts. This will support your
           peers learning as well.

        •  Comment thoughtfully and respectfully on the ideas, experiences, and questions
           presented by your peers. The more you engage with your peers, the more
           meaningful the conversations will be for everyone involved.




Catlin Tucker is an English teacher at Windsor High School and has worked in Sonoma County for nine years. She
currently teaches 9th and 10th grade English and has previously taught 11th grade Advanced Placement English. She also
teaches online college research writing courses through Axia College.
Catlin earned her B.A. in English Literature from the University of California, Los Angeles and her Single Subject English
Credential and Education Masters from the University of California, Santa Barbara. Her Masters in Education focused on
creating and maintaining a safe space in the classroom to lower the affective filter and create a more supportive and
effective learning environment.
She is currently part of the Collaborize Team, designing resources for the education market.

                        Go to www.CollaborizeClassroom.com for more information

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Prince George Core Competencies
Prince George Core CompetenciesPrince George Core Competencies
Prince George Core CompetenciesFaye Brownlie
 
How to Create a Culture of Writing in the Classroom
How to Create a Culture of Writing in the ClassroomHow to Create a Culture of Writing in the Classroom
How to Create a Culture of Writing in the Classroomelis_singapore
 
Revving up writing instruction
Revving up writing instructionRevving up writing instruction
Revving up writing instructionHonor Moorman
 
Writing workshop: Writing instruction that WORKS
Writing workshop: Writing instruction that WORKSWriting workshop: Writing instruction that WORKS
Writing workshop: Writing instruction that WORKSHonor Moorman
 
Bc week 5 for lianne
Bc week 5 for lianneBc week 5 for lianne
Bc week 5 for lianneBeth Carey
 
Book clubs and beyond
Book clubs and beyondBook clubs and beyond
Book clubs and beyondIrina K
 
Burnaby4-7,3d session, jan.2019
Burnaby4-7,3d session, jan.2019Burnaby4-7,3d session, jan.2019
Burnaby4-7,3d session, jan.2019Faye Brownlie
 
Writing Groups in Language Teaching
Writing Groups in Language Teaching Writing Groups in Language Teaching
Writing Groups in Language Teaching Malu Sciamarelli
 
Uvalde writing workshop day 6
Uvalde writing workshop day 6Uvalde writing workshop day 6
Uvalde writing workshop day 6Honor Moorman
 
Coquitlambootcamp.literacy
Coquitlambootcamp.literacyCoquitlambootcamp.literacy
Coquitlambootcamp.literacyFaye Brownlie
 
Extensive Reading in the CLIL Class
Extensive Reading in the CLIL ClassExtensive Reading in the CLIL Class
Extensive Reading in the CLIL ClassMalu Sciamarelli
 
Coquitlam School Teams.Jan2020
Coquitlam School Teams.Jan2020Coquitlam School Teams.Jan2020
Coquitlam School Teams.Jan2020Faye Brownlie
 
Conferring with students
Conferring with studentsConferring with students
Conferring with studentsjbigsby
 
MRLC Evidence Based Literacy, Oct
MRLC Evidence Based Literacy, Oct MRLC Evidence Based Literacy, Oct
MRLC Evidence Based Literacy, Oct Faye Brownlie
 
Literature circles
Literature circlesLiterature circles
Literature circlestuckerl06
 
Writer's Workshop - Archdiocese, 8.14
Writer's Workshop - Archdiocese, 8.14Writer's Workshop - Archdiocese, 8.14
Writer's Workshop - Archdiocese, 8.14Winnie Huebsch
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Prince George Core Competencies
Prince George Core CompetenciesPrince George Core Competencies
Prince George Core Competencies
 
How to Create a Culture of Writing in the Classroom
How to Create a Culture of Writing in the ClassroomHow to Create a Culture of Writing in the Classroom
How to Create a Culture of Writing in the Classroom
 
Revving up writing instruction
Revving up writing instructionRevving up writing instruction
Revving up writing instruction
 
Writing workshop: Writing instruction that WORKS
Writing workshop: Writing instruction that WORKSWriting workshop: Writing instruction that WORKS
Writing workshop: Writing instruction that WORKS
 
Bc week 5 for lianne
Bc week 5 for lianneBc week 5 for lianne
Bc week 5 for lianne
 
Book clubs and beyond
Book clubs and beyondBook clubs and beyond
Book clubs and beyond
 
Facilitating the discussion forum workshop
Facilitating the discussion forum workshopFacilitating the discussion forum workshop
Facilitating the discussion forum workshop
 
Burnaby4-7,3d session, jan.2019
Burnaby4-7,3d session, jan.2019Burnaby4-7,3d session, jan.2019
Burnaby4-7,3d session, jan.2019
 
BCTELA 2019
BCTELA 2019BCTELA 2019
BCTELA 2019
 
Writing Groups in Language Teaching
Writing Groups in Language Teaching Writing Groups in Language Teaching
Writing Groups in Language Teaching
 
3.6.12pppres.
3.6.12pppres.3.6.12pppres.
3.6.12pppres.
 
Uvalde writing workshop day 6
Uvalde writing workshop day 6Uvalde writing workshop day 6
Uvalde writing workshop day 6
 
Coquitlambootcamp.literacy
Coquitlambootcamp.literacyCoquitlambootcamp.literacy
Coquitlambootcamp.literacy
 
Extensive Reading in the CLIL Class
Extensive Reading in the CLIL ClassExtensive Reading in the CLIL Class
Extensive Reading in the CLIL Class
 
Coquitlam School Teams.Jan2020
Coquitlam School Teams.Jan2020Coquitlam School Teams.Jan2020
Coquitlam School Teams.Jan2020
 
Conferring with students
Conferring with studentsConferring with students
Conferring with students
 
MRLC Evidence Based Literacy, Oct
MRLC Evidence Based Literacy, Oct MRLC Evidence Based Literacy, Oct
MRLC Evidence Based Literacy, Oct
 
Literature circles
Literature circlesLiterature circles
Literature circles
 
Richmond Feb 2020
Richmond Feb 2020Richmond Feb 2020
Richmond Feb 2020
 
Writer's Workshop - Archdiocese, 8.14
Writer's Workshop - Archdiocese, 8.14Writer's Workshop - Archdiocese, 8.14
Writer's Workshop - Archdiocese, 8.14
 

Ähnlich wie Say Something Substantial

Cps conflict resolution #1
Cps conflict resolution #1Cps conflict resolution #1
Cps conflict resolution #1gnonewleaders
 
CPS Conflict Resolution #1
CPS Conflict Resolution #1CPS Conflict Resolution #1
CPS Conflict Resolution #1GNOCommunityInfo
 
International Undergraduate Student Folder
International Undergraduate Student FolderInternational Undergraduate Student Folder
International Undergraduate Student FolderIsela Pena-Rager
 
Creating a pln cape town
Creating a pln cape townCreating a pln cape town
Creating a pln cape townAnn Michaelsen
 
Activities in teaching speaking
Activities in teaching speakingActivities in teaching speaking
Activities in teaching speakingDraizelle Sexon
 
Engaged Learning
Engaged LearningEngaged Learning
Engaged Learningssorden
 
Rupert Middle-UDK & Backwards Design, Jan 2014
Rupert Middle-UDK & Backwards Design, Jan 2014Rupert Middle-UDK & Backwards Design, Jan 2014
Rupert Middle-UDK & Backwards Design, Jan 2014Faye Brownlie
 
Vocabulary and Literature Circles for CPS August 2014
Vocabulary and Literature Circles for CPS August 2014Vocabulary and Literature Circles for CPS August 2014
Vocabulary and Literature Circles for CPS August 2014Elizabeth Swaggerty
 
Making online discussions fun and engaging
Making online discussions fun and engagingMaking online discussions fun and engaging
Making online discussions fun and engagingSusan Bastian
 
Accountable talk for secondary
Accountable talk for secondaryAccountable talk for secondary
Accountable talk for secondarysdebru1
 
Discussion toolkit
Discussion toolkitDiscussion toolkit
Discussion toolkitjorawlings
 
Akhavan comprehension matters ideas slideshare
Akhavan  comprehension matters ideas slideshareAkhavan  comprehension matters ideas slideshare
Akhavan comprehension matters ideas slideshareNancy Akhavan
 
The Anatomy of an Asynchronous Course
The Anatomy of an Asynchronous CourseThe Anatomy of an Asynchronous Course
The Anatomy of an Asynchronous CourseAmy Jauman
 
Promoting literacy through conversation
Promoting literacy through conversationPromoting literacy through conversation
Promoting literacy through conversationsdebru1
 
Engaging Students in Online Discussion & Collaboration
Engaging Students in Online Discussion & CollaborationEngaging Students in Online Discussion & Collaboration
Engaging Students in Online Discussion & CollaborationDerrick Mears
 

Ähnlich wie Say Something Substantial (20)

Cps conflict resolution #1
Cps conflict resolution #1Cps conflict resolution #1
Cps conflict resolution #1
 
CPS Conflict Resolution #1
CPS Conflict Resolution #1CPS Conflict Resolution #1
CPS Conflict Resolution #1
 
Community of Inquiry
Community of InquiryCommunity of Inquiry
Community of Inquiry
 
International Undergraduate Student Folder
International Undergraduate Student FolderInternational Undergraduate Student Folder
International Undergraduate Student Folder
 
Creating a pln cape town
Creating a pln cape townCreating a pln cape town
Creating a pln cape town
 
Rethinking Your Role
Rethinking Your RoleRethinking Your Role
Rethinking Your Role
 
Citi april13
Citi april13Citi april13
Citi april13
 
Activities in teaching speaking
Activities in teaching speakingActivities in teaching speaking
Activities in teaching speaking
 
Active learning
Active learningActive learning
Active learning
 
Engaged Learning
Engaged LearningEngaged Learning
Engaged Learning
 
Rupert Middle-UDK & Backwards Design, Jan 2014
Rupert Middle-UDK & Backwards Design, Jan 2014Rupert Middle-UDK & Backwards Design, Jan 2014
Rupert Middle-UDK & Backwards Design, Jan 2014
 
Vocabulary and Literature Circles for CPS August 2014
Vocabulary and Literature Circles for CPS August 2014Vocabulary and Literature Circles for CPS August 2014
Vocabulary and Literature Circles for CPS August 2014
 
Making online discussions fun and engaging
Making online discussions fun and engagingMaking online discussions fun and engaging
Making online discussions fun and engaging
 
Accountable talk for secondary
Accountable talk for secondaryAccountable talk for secondary
Accountable talk for secondary
 
Discussion toolkit
Discussion toolkitDiscussion toolkit
Discussion toolkit
 
Discussion toolkit
Discussion toolkitDiscussion toolkit
Discussion toolkit
 
Akhavan comprehension matters ideas slideshare
Akhavan  comprehension matters ideas slideshareAkhavan  comprehension matters ideas slideshare
Akhavan comprehension matters ideas slideshare
 
The Anatomy of an Asynchronous Course
The Anatomy of an Asynchronous CourseThe Anatomy of an Asynchronous Course
The Anatomy of an Asynchronous Course
 
Promoting literacy through conversation
Promoting literacy through conversationPromoting literacy through conversation
Promoting literacy through conversation
 
Engaging Students in Online Discussion & Collaboration
Engaging Students in Online Discussion & CollaborationEngaging Students in Online Discussion & Collaboration
Engaging Students in Online Discussion & Collaboration
 

Say Something Substantial

  • 1. Say Something Substantial What Constitutes a Substantial Posting? Each posting should effectively drive conversation and motivate the other members of the group to think more deeply about the topic being discussed. To accomplish this goal, it is essential that teachers make their expectations for student responses clear before initiating online conversations or activities. If students understand why they are being asked to do something, they are more likely to do it. Explain that this classroom site is a forum for them to engage in conversations, activities, and collaboration. If they actively participate in the online forum, it will support and strengthen their understanding of the curriculum. It is important that the students feel that the online forum is their space and, as such, it is crucial that each member of the class/group take an active role in ensuring a high quality of discussion. Review the following with your students prior to their first interactions in the online classroom site. A substantial posting will do the following: •  Present a new question for discussion to broaden, refine, or redirect the conversation. •  Discuss a personal experience (i.e. memory, interaction, person, class, book, etc.) that has influenced your perception of a given topic. Provide specific details about where your ideas, beliefs, opinions, etc. come from to support your statements. •  Think outside the box or play devil’s advocate (respectfully, of course). Providing another point of view on a topic being discussed can be both interesting and enlightening, effectively sparking further discussion. •  Ask your peers for clarification on ideas that you do not clearly understand. Your peers are your best resources. •  Make connections between the discussions taking place in the classroom forum to information learned in other classes and subject areas. Connecting what you are learning to past knowledge or experiences will strengthen your retention of that information. Go to www.CollaborizeClassroom.com for more information
  • 2. Say Something Substantial •  Share a resource that you have used that has been helpful for you. Use the attachment feature to share images, documents, and videos that will add to the conversation. •  Summarize the main ideas being discussed or presented in your own words to ensure you have a strong grasp of the central concepts. This will support your peers learning as well. •  Comment thoughtfully and respectfully on the ideas, experiences, and questions presented by your peers. The more you engage with your peers, the more meaningful the conversations will be for everyone involved. Catlin Tucker is an English teacher at Windsor High School and has worked in Sonoma County for nine years. She currently teaches 9th and 10th grade English and has previously taught 11th grade Advanced Placement English. She also teaches online college research writing courses through Axia College. Catlin earned her B.A. in English Literature from the University of California, Los Angeles and her Single Subject English Credential and Education Masters from the University of California, Santa Barbara. Her Masters in Education focused on creating and maintaining a safe space in the classroom to lower the affective filter and create a more supportive and effective learning environment. She is currently part of the Collaborize Team, designing resources for the education market. Go to www.CollaborizeClassroom.com for more information