A diversified real return portfolio can be an important component to investor portfolios, given the potential long-term threat of inflation. Inflation erodes purchasing power cumulatively and exponentially by increasing the cost of future spending.
While many asset classes perform poorly in an inflationary environment, a portfolio of real assets provides a hedge for inflation-driven liabilities and protects against losses in rising or high inflation scenarios.
Defined benefit (DB), endowment, foundation, defined contribution (DC) and individual investors are exposed to substantially different types of inflation risk.
This infographic takes a closer look at real return strategies. It depicts risk levels, product availability and the configuration of each real asset strategy. The three pie charts shown here represent examples of real return structures that are appropriate for diversified portfolios. The size of the real asset allocation and the types of strategies employed will depend on the unique circumstances of each investor.
The portfolios can be further customized to achieve more conservative allocations that are fixed income heavy (e.g., by
adding more TIPS) and for more aggressive, equity-heavy portfolios (e.g., by adding private investments).
A wide variety of asset classes are used in real return portfolios displaying a range of public and private equity and fixed income-like characteristics. On the reverse side we offer greater detail on the benefits, risks, investable universes and benchmarks that accompany each real asset class.
212MTAMount Durham University Bachelor's Diploma in Technology
Real Return Strategies: A Closer Look
1. TOTAL PORTFOLIO SIZE
A diversified real return portfolio can be an
important component to investor portfo-
lios, given the potential long-term threat of
inflation. Inflation erodes purchasing
power cumulatively and exponentially by
increasing the cost of future spending.
While many asset classes perform poorly
in an inflationary environment, a portfolio
of real assets provides a hedge for infla-
tion-driven liabilities and protects against
losses in rising or high inflation scenarios.
Defined benefit (DB), endowment, founda-
tion, defined contribution (DC) and individ-
ual investors are exposed to substantially
different types of inflation risk.
This charticle takes a closer look at real re-
turn strategies. It depicts risk levels, prod-
uct availability and the configuration of
each real asset strategy. The three pie
charts shown here represent examples of
real return structures that are appropriate
for diversified portfolios. The size of the
real asset allocation and the types of
strategies employed will depend on the
unique circumstances of each investor.
The portfolios can be further customized
to achieve more conservative allocations
that are fixed income heavy (e.g., by
adding more TIPS) and for more aggres-
sive, equity-heavy portfolios (e.g., by
adding private investments).
A wide variety of asset classes are used in
real return portfolios displaying a range of
public and private equity and fixed
income-like characteristics. On the reverse
side we offer greater detail on the benefits,
risks, investable universes and bench-
marks that accompany each real asset
class.
Real RetuRn StRategieS: a CloSeR look
Customization required as no multi-asset real return product that
includes private real estate exists. Private real estate can be accessed
via separate accounts or commingled funds.
Individual asset class exposure is available for all assets, although
mutual fund exposure to commodities is difficult due to taxes on
commodity income.
Eight multi-asset real return strategies for DB real return mandates of
$1 million or greater, mostly in mutual fund vehicles. Six of these
strategies are available to DC plans.
Twelve multi-asset real return strategies in commingled or mutual funds
for real return mandates of $5 million or greater.
Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are available in each asset class to
construct more customized portfolios.
For real return mandates of $500 million or greater; customization
through individual asset class exposure is required.
Separate accounts are available, which can be customized to broaden or
limit exposures. Potential use of closed-end vehicles with longer lock-up
periods for capital. Open-end funds with some liquidity exist for private
real estate, agriculture and infrastructure.
Private energy, infrastructure, agriculture and timberland have more
limited availability due to a smaller universe of managers. Can substitute
infrastructure, timberland and agriculture if more exposure to one of the
asset classes is desired.
Callan Associates • Knowledge for Investors
MEDIUM PLANS ($100 million to $3 billion in plan assets)
• Multi-asset class real return fund or individual asset class exposure
through pooled funds.
• Private real estate represents the core of the portfolio, 65% to 75%
of total. REITs can comprise up to 20% of the real estate allocation for
liquidity and rebalancing.
• TIPS and commodities provide liquidity for portfolio rebalancing
to capture volatility premium.
SMALL PLANS (under $100 million in plan assets)
• Multi-asset class real return fund or stand-alone Treasury Inflation-
Protected Securities (TIPS) allocation.
• 50% TIPS allocation keeps portfolio liquid and less volatile.
LARGE PLANS (over $3 billion in plan assets)
• Multi-asset class real return fund or customized portfolios to access
individual asset class exposure.
• Provides greater diversification with the introduction
of a larger potential opportunity set—requires scale, additional
monitoring and a longer time frame due to limited liquidity
with real estate, infrastructure, agriculture,
timberland and private energy.
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
Private Real Estate
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
Commodities
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
TIPS
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
Timberland
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
Agriculture
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
Infrastructure
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
Private Energy
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
REITs
Expected Return
Expected Risk
Correlation with CPI
Short-Term Inflation Hedge
Long-Term Inflation Hedge
Liquidity
Availability of Product
Fees and Expenses
cash equity
cash equity
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
low high
poor excellent
poor excellent
Natural Resource Equities
REITs
Timberland
Agriculture
Infrastructure
Private Energy
Commodities
Private Real Estate
Private Real Estate
Commodities
Higher Liquidity Higher Complexity
TIPS TIPS
TIPS
Commodities
Natural
Resource
Equities
REITs REITs
PRODUCT AVAILABILITY