This presentation was made to the BC Federation of Naturalists Fall General Meeting in Parksville, BC September 29th, 2012.
The talk title was provided at the invitation to speak and does not fit the talk well.
Please note that this presentation does not include notes (except for 1 slide) and most slides are simply to provide a visual while I talk (ramble) and as such do not provide the full story.
Thanks to the BC Naturalists for inviting me to speak. http://www.bcnature.ca/ and the warm welcome to a serious discussion.
It is a work in progress and comments welcome.
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Bc naturalist presentation 120929bk
1. Sustainable Harvesting in the Salish Sea
Brian Kingzett ,
Centre for Shellfish Research
Vancouver Island University
2. Presentation Notes
This presentation was made to the BC Federation of Naturalists Fall
General Meeting in Parksville, BC September 29th, 2012.
The talk title was provided at the invitation to speak and does not fit
the talk well.
Please note that this presentation does not include notes (except for
1 slide) and most slides are simply to provide a visual while I talk
(ramble) and as such do not provide the full story.
Thanks to the BC Naturalists for inviting me to speak.
http://www.bcnature.ca/ and the warm welcome to a serious
discussion.
It is a work in progress and comments welcome.
4. Presentation Objectives
• How the coast sustained us
• Role of Shellfish in the ecosystem
• Global Context – the future is not going
to be anything like we have seen before
• Where do we go from here?
Anthropology, ecology, math, chemistry,
economics, but no quiz…
9. Long history of Naturalists and Oysters!
• In 95 BC the Roman
naturalist Pliny wrote
about the great profit
from the oysters he
grew in his ostrearum
vivarium
10. Walking the talk – Green Research Facility
• One of Canada’s greenest buildings
• Platinum LEED certification anticipated 2012
• 2011 National Sustainable Architecture and Buildings
Award and more…
11. Thinking locally – drawing linkages
Healthy
Responsible
Marine
Coastal
Development Ecosystems
High
Quality Sustainable
Food Industry
12. Why do we care about shellfish?
The links between industry, academia and
conservation are obvious for shellfish; they
indicate sustainable coastal communities.
When we lose shellfish and shellfish
industries, it is a sure sign that
environmental degradation threatens the
very essence of coastal communities with
their strong sense of place and the
sustainable use of its resources.
Michael W. Beck, Ph.D. Senior Scientist, The Nature
Conservancy, Global Marine Initiative, Letter of Support to
CSR Deep Bay Oct .2008
14. ~ 5000 lived here before European contact
• Coast Salish peoples lived off the land and sea for 1000’s of years
here
• But less that 800 live here now
16. History of First Nations Shellfish Culture in BC
• Clam culture practiced by First Nations for
1000’s of years
• Traditional songs about building clam
gardens: lo xwi we
• Clam gardens (terraces) still evident in
Broughton Archipelago
Photo Credit: Royal BC Museum / Rowan Jacobsen, THE LIVING SHORE
17. History of First Nations Shellfish Culture in BC
Clam Garden
Photo Credit: John Harper
18. History of First Nations Shellfish Culture in BC
Clam Garden, Gulf Islands, BC
Photo Credit: John Harper
19. The productive value of Estuaries.….
• Where the land and fresh
water meets the sea
• Where the tides cover and
expose
• Area of immense ecological
value and productivity at all
trophic levels and human
activities
• Where shellfish play a critical
role
• Where humans impact.
Native Oyster Reef, Nootka Sound
20. Role of Shellfish as Ecosystem Engineers
Filtration
• Clear water allows light to penetrate
to bay bottom, powering sea grass
growth.
Stabilization
• Oysters and sea grass create a firm
bottom.
21. Role of Shellfish as Ecosystem Engineers
Infrastructure
• Oyster reefs and sea grass provide a
network of shelter for small and
juvenile organisms.
Food
• Oysters convert algae into food that
can be passed up the food chain.
Nitrogen, Phosphorous &
Carbon Sequestration
• Oyster shells are 12% carbon
23. Present Food Security on Vancouver Island
Many estimations are that in North America on
average food travels 4000km to consumer
More than 90% of Food consumed on Vancouver
Island comes from off-Island
At any given time 3 days supply in grocery stores
How is it we have lost the ability to feed
ourselves?
We value our environment but we transfer our
environmental impact over the horizon
24. Our increasing global footprint – last 100 yrs
• Lost 50% of world wetlands
• Lost 50% of worlds forests
• 60% of Coral Reefs at risk
• Lost > 85% of shellfish reefs
• 6M tonnes/yr of debris to Oceans
25. Have we entered the Anthropocene? 2012
credits
NASA via http://e360.yale.edu
http://www.latimes.com
Flickr User Shotaku
Flickr User Fremont-Winema National Forest
26. Have we entered the Anthropocene? 2012
credits
NASA via http://e360.yale.edu
http://www.latimes.com
Flickr User Shotaku
Flickr User Fremont-Winema National Forest
27. Have we entered the Anthropocene? 2012
credits
NASA via http://e360.yale.edu
http://www.latimes.com
Flickr User Shotaku
Flickr User Fremont-Winema National Forest
28. Have we entered the Anthropocene? 2012
credits
NASA via http://e360.yale.edu
http://www.latimes.com
Flickr User Shotaku
Flickr User Fremont-Winema National Forest
29. Have we entered the Anthropocene? 2012
credits
NASA via http://e360.yale.edu
http://www.latimes.com
Flickr User Shotaku
Flickr User Fremont-Winema National Forest
30. “Dear future generations: Please
accept our apologies. We were
roaring drunk on petroleum”
Kurt Vonnegut, 2006
32. Ocean Acidification the “other” CO2 problem
http://www.interactiveoceans.washington.edu/file/Carbon+Cycle
33. Ocean Acidification
Feely, Bulletin of American Meteorological Society 2008
http://pmel.noaa.gov/co2/files/hitimeseries2.jpg
34. As the pH drops affects ability to make shells
Insert photo of diagram of impacts on shellfish
larvae
Veliger Larvae
Native Oyster, Ostrea lurida
35. How could we possibly affect an ocean so vast?
Because in proportion
really there is not that
much water on the
earth…..
Oceans = 1.34 Billion km3
Have absorbed estimated 525
billion tonnes CO2 in last
200 years
Current rate of 22 million
tonnes daily.
Image Source: USGS 2012
http://ga.water.usgs.gov/edu/earthhowmuch
.html
39. Is this the last century of wild seafood?
• More than 85% of global fish stocks
fully or over exploited
53%
32%
12%
3%
Underexploited
Underexploited or moderately exploited
Fully Exploited
Source: www.twooceanssportfishing.com
Overexploited, depleted or recovering
Source: FAO – State of World Fisheries
and Aquaculture 2010
41. How will we feed a world destined for 10B?
• World requires another 23 Million MT
of Seafood by 2020 - (8 Years)
• Total fisheries requirement expected
to exceed beef pork or chicken
• Aquaculture demand = 80-100 MMT
or another entire global ocean by
2030 for future population estimates.
53%
32% • FAO getting vague about what
12%
happens in 2050……
3%
42. Is farming the seas the solution?
“With earth's burgeoning human
populations to feed we must turn to
the sea with new understanding and
new technology. We must farm it as
we farm the land.”
Jacques Cousteau, 1973
43. The Blue Revolution?
• Fastest growing meat production sector
with an annual growth rate of 6.6%
expected to slow to 2.4%
• At present > 50% of all fish consumed by
humans from aquaculture
• Cultured Seafood and aquatic plants
$119 Billion/yr in 2010
• > 100 Million people globally derive
income from aquaculture
45. Shellfish Farming: Clean and Green (and blue)
• Shellfish farming requires clean water and
healthy marine ecosystems
• Being green is not an option but a necessity.
• Shellfish farming endorsed by all seafood
sustainability programs
46. Going beyond Sustainability
Oysters are not just
Sustainable Seafood,
they are
RESTORATIVE SEAFOOD
Barton Seaver; Chef, National Geographic
Fellow, Author
.
48. How do we do this sustainably? (NOTES)
This is a picture I took in China a few years of a scallop farm near the Korean border. It is a scallop farm that stretched to the horizon in three directions.
Below each float is nets of scallops and between the floats cultured kelp. This is to the ocean what monoculture of corn is the prairie. And Ironically in the
background that is not marine fog, It is a steady haze of air pollution from an emerging Chinese middle class and massive fossil fuel use.
And what I saw there was an ecosystem at the point of collapse and when we talked with our Chinese hosts about sustainability I realized we were talking
two different languages and I don’t mean Chinese and English,
While I was talking about the Environment I realized our hosts were talking about feeding a population. And this fundamental difference really affected me.
I have made two overwhelming trips to China and after this last one I really reconsidered the way I considered myself an environmentalist. At the time we
were in Design of the Field Station and I returned extremely and profoundly discouraged, it seemed that all the good we were trying to do here was really
just pissing in the wind with what was happening over the horizon.
But what really got me was how much of this activity was about satisfying our North American market demands and the emerging demands of a population
that just wants to be like us and who can blame them?
And so while I blithely imagine I am trying to up my sustainability game at home most of my true environmental footprint lies over the horizon in the hands
of others who do not recognize the value of the ecosystem as we do. I remain troubled by this and as a result have the desire to move more of my
environmental footprint home where I can at least have a bigger role in overseeing it, and this includes the resources that I use. In some ways this has
made me more pro development at home and put me at odds with some traditional exclusionary environmentalism.
But this picture is not all bad, when we actually got talking to the watermen who were out there working on the ocean, all they could do is complain about
all the pollution that was coming out the rivers from upland terrestrial agriculture and I realized that the shellfish guys who were maintaining tens of millions
of individual scallop shaped swimming pool filters and growing kelp that was flourishing in a high CO2 environment , that slowly they were getting it.
49. Aquaculture, the blue revolution?
• Sustainable Aquaculture –
the Green, Blue Revolution
Sustainable aquaculture can:
1. Green the planet
2. Feed the planet and meet the seafood
necessity
3. Healthier citizens – omega 3’s, etc.
(improve quality of life, save billions in
health care)
4. Help restore healthy marine ecosystems
51. A Call to Action
Eat less protein & more green stuff
(Michael Pollan)
Eat more sustainable seafood
Eat more farmed seafood
Eat lower on the seafood chain
Try to localize your global footprint
53. Questions regarding this presentation
Brian Kingzett, M.Sc.
Deep Bay Marine Field Station Manager,
Center for Shellfish Research,
Vancouver Island University
Mail: 900 5th St, Nanaimo. BC V9R 5S5
Field Station: 370 Crome Pt. Rd. , Bowser. BC VOR 1G0
Tel: 250 740-6399
Email: brian.kingzett@viu.ca
Twitter: @VIUDeepBay
Website: www.viu.ca/deepbay
Blog: www.viudeepbay.com
Hinweis der Redaktion
So we are located about 30 minutes north in Deep Bay at the Southern end of Baynes Sound defined by the waters between Vancouver Island and Denman Island.Important ecological areaWhere half of all the cultured shellfish in BC occursAn area where many are choosing to move to and Increasingly under environmental stress from human pressures but actually recovering from more than a century of resource exploitation.AS I began to learn more about this system and its history I was struck by a paradox.
A paradox – archaeologists have informed us that communities of as much as 5000 people continually habitated this area for 1000’s of years.Living locally and tied to the land and sea.Put that in context today were less than 800 people live around Deep Bay unsustainably
So while large seasonal resources like salmon, herring and migratory wildfowl contributed to First Nations diet – shellfish provided the year round staple that maintained populations. While working in many coastal First Nations communities I have heard the expression “when the tide is out the table is set”Look at any kitchen midden or waste heap on the West Coast coast of North America you will find primarily clam and sometimes native oyster shells for that was the staple diet that could hold everyone over between seasonal bounties.
A 3 inch oyster filters up to 50 gallons of water a day,
And historically for us…
CO2 highest in 15 million yearsThis year more americans reported that they were beginning to believ in Climate Change – record sea ice minimums, barges stuck in the mighty mississippi river, record droughts that put 50% of US counties in “crisis: designation and of course major wildfires.Climate change is already costing $1.2-trillion (U.S.) a year and is reducing global GDP by 1.6 per cent. It is contributing to the deaths of almost 400,000 people a year. TA new report published this week titled “Climate Vulnerability Monitor: A Guide to the Cold Calculus of a Hot Planet,” is one of the first studies that delves into climate change’s effect on global gross domestic product. It was commissioned by DARA, a non-profit group that monitors aid programs, and the Climate Vulnerable Forum, and was written by more than 50 scientists, economists and policy strategists commissioned by 20 governments.
CO2 highest in 15 million yearsThis year more americans reported that they were beginning to believ in Climate Change – record sea ice minimums, barges stuck in the mighty mississippi river, record droughts that put 50% of US counties in “crisis: designation and of course major wildfires.Climate change is already costing $1.2-trillion (U.S.) a year and is reducing global GDP by 1.6 per cent. It is contributing to the deaths of almost 400,000 people a year. TA new report published this week titled “Climate Vulnerability Monitor: A Guide to the Cold Calculus of a Hot Planet,” is one of the first studies that delves into climate change’s effect on global gross domestic product. It was commissioned by DARA, a non-profit group that monitors aid programs, and the Climate Vulnerable Forum, and was written by more than 50 scientists, economists and policy strategists commissioned by 20 governments.
CO2 highest in 15 million yearsThis year more americans reported that they were beginning to believ in Climate Change – record sea ice minimums, barges stuck in the mighty mississippi river, record droughts that put 50% of US counties in “crisis: designation and of course major wildfires.Climate change is already costing $1.2-trillion (U.S.) a year and is reducing global GDP by 1.6 per cent. It is contributing to the deaths of almost 400,000 people a year. TA new report published this week titled “Climate Vulnerability Monitor: A Guide to the Cold Calculus of a Hot Planet,” is one of the first studies that delves into climate change’s effect on global gross domestic product. It was commissioned by DARA, a non-profit group that monitors aid programs, and the Climate Vulnerable Forum, and was written by more than 50 scientists, economists and policy strategists commissioned by 20 governments.
CO2 highest in 15 million yearsThis year more americans reported that they were beginning to believ in Climate Change – record sea ice minimums, barges stuck in the mighty mississippi river, record droughts that put 50% of US counties in “crisis: designation and of course major wildfires.Climate change is already costing $1.2-trillion (U.S.) a year and is reducing global GDP by 1.6 per cent. It is contributing to the deaths of almost 400,000 people a year. TA new report published this week titled “Climate Vulnerability Monitor: A Guide to the Cold Calculus of a Hot Planet,” is one of the first studies that delves into climate change’s effect on global gross domestic product. It was commissioned by DARA, a non-profit group that monitors aid programs, and the Climate Vulnerable Forum, and was written by more than 50 scientists, economists and policy strategists commissioned by 20 governments.
CO2 highest in 15 million yearsThis year more americans reported that they were beginning to believ in Climate Change – record sea ice minimums, barges stuck in the mighty mississippi river, record droughts that put 50% of US counties in “crisis: designation and of course major wildfires.Climate change is already costing $1.2-trillion (U.S.) a year and is reducing global GDP by 1.6 per cent. It is contributing to the deaths of almost 400,000 people a year. TA new report published this week titled “Climate Vulnerability Monitor: A Guide to the Cold Calculus of a Hot Planet,” is one of the first studies that delves into climate change’s effect on global gross domestic product. It was commissioned by DARA, a non-profit group that monitors aid programs, and the Climate Vulnerable Forum, and was written by more than 50 scientists, economists and policy strategists commissioned by 20 governments.
But if you are in the shellfish game, these are not the things that have us worried.
A Larger Problem25% of the CO2 we emit is absorbed by the world’s oceansOcean acidification is the gradual decrease in pH due to rising CO2.Increased acidity leads to increased mortality in calcium dependent creatures – shellfish, plankton, corals, algaeA Larger ProblemCoastalupwellingWater upwelled off coast is loaded with more CO2 than anywhere else in the world (10% higher than Atlantic).The North Pacific is at the end of a deep circulation line.It’s full of old water (cold, salty, CO2-rich, low pH).8. A Larger Problem AragoniteIncreasing acidity from CO2 lowers saturation level of aragonite. Shelled organisms need high aragonite to grow.Bivalve juveniles experience significant mortality when aragonite values decrease and their aragonite shell dissolves.