Soninké I Mandinga

883 Aufrufe

Veröffentlicht am

0 Kommentare
1 Gefällt mir
Statistik
Notizen
  • Als Erste(r) kommentieren

Keine Downloads
Aufrufe
Aufrufe insgesamt
883
Auf SlideShare
0
Aus Einbettungen
0
Anzahl an Einbettungen
11
Aktionen
Geteilt
0
Downloads
5
Kommentare
0
Gefällt mir
1
Einbettungen 0
Keine Einbettungen

Keine Notizen für die Folie

Soninké I Mandinga

  1. 1. &ROÂOH..Ly/OHQJXDLPPLJUD.LyLHQVHQDPHQWGHO.DWDOjQ~P (/621,1.e,(/0$1',1*$ (678',203$5$7,8 (175(/(6*5$0¬7,48(6'(/621,1.e,(/0$1',1*$, /$'(/$7$/¬ /OXwVD*Uj.LD -RDQ0LTXHORQWUHUDV *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D *DELQHWG¶$VVHVVRUDPHQW/LQJtVWL.SHUDOD,PPLJUD.Ly 8QLYHUVLWDWGH*LURQD *HQHUDOLWDWGHDWDOXQD 'HSDUWDPHQWGH%HQHVWDUL)DPÇOLD
  2. 2. *Uj.LDL6ROp/OXwVD (O6RQLQNpLHOPDQGLQJDHVWXGL.RPSDUDWLXHQWUHOHVJUDPjWLTXHVGHOVRQLQNpLHOPDQGLQJDLODGHO.DWDOj ±/OHQJXDLPPLJUD.LyLHQVHQDPHQWGHO.DWDOj
  3. 3. ,6%1 ,RQWUHUDV-RDQ0LTXHO,,DWDOXQD'HSDUWDPHQWGH%HQHVWDU6R.LDO,,,7tWRO,9ROÂOH..Ly/OHQJXD LPPLJUD.LyLHQVHQDPHQWGHO.DWDOjDWDOj±*UDPjWL.D.RPSDUDGD±6RQLQNp6RQLQNp±*UDPjWL.D .RPSDUDGD±DWDOjDWDOj±*UDPjWL.D.RPSDUDGD±0DQGLQJD0DQGLQJD±*UDPjWL.D.RPSDUDGD± DWDOjDWDOj±(QVHQDPHQW±(VWXGLDQWVHVWUDQJHUV (OSURMH.WH³/OHQJXDLPPLJUD.LyLHQVHQDPHQWGHO.DWDOj´KDHVWDWILQDQoDWSHO'HSDUWDPHQWGH%HQHVWDUL)DPtOLD GHOD*HQHUDOLWDWGHDWDOXQDDWUDYpVG¶XQ.RQYHQLGH.ROÂODERUD.LyDPEOD8QLYHUVLWDWGH*LURQD
  4. 4. (OVLQYHVWLJDGRUVTXHKDQWUHEDOODWHQODUHGD..LyGHOVUHVXOWDWVG¶DTXHVWSURMH.WHVyQ /OXwVD*Uj.LD6ROp.RRUGLQDGRUD
  5. 5. *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  6. 6. -RDQ0LTXHORQWUHUDV+HUDV *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  7. 7. -RUGL)DUUpV1LHUJD 6('(*LURQD );DYLHU/DPXHOD*DU.LD *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  8. 8. -XDQDUORV0RUHQRDEUHUD 8QLYHUVLGDG$XWyQRPDGH0DGULG 0DU.RV2UR].R3DLUHW %H.DULGHOSURMH.WH8G*
  9. 9. )UDQ.HV.5R.D8UJHOO *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  10. 10. 5DTXHO6iQ.KH]$YHQGDxR (VWXGLDQWGHPjVWHU8G*
  11. 11. -RVHS06HUUD%RQHW *UXSGHXOWXUDL(GX.D.Ly8G*
  12. 12. (OLVDEHW6HUUDW6HOODERQD *UXSGHXOWXUDL(GX.D.Ly8G*
  13. 13. +DQSDUWL.LSDWHQO¶HODERUD.LyLUHLPSUHVVLyG¶DTXHVWYROXP.RPDEH.DULV.ROÂODERUDGRUVRUHYLVRUV 5RVHU$JXVWt+HUHX %H.jULD8G*
  14. 14. 0XVDDPDUD (V.RODG¶$GXOWVGH6DOW³/HV%HUQDUGHV´
  15. 15. 'HQLVUHLVVHOV 8QLYHUVLWpGH/RQ,, %HUWDURXVDVWDxp %H.jULD8G*
  16. 16. 2OJD)XOODQD1RHOO *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*L,(
  17. 17. /L]]*DXYUHDX2¶+DJDQ %H.jULDGHOSURMH.WH8G*
  18. 18. ULVWLQD-XKHU%DUURW 8QLYHUVLWDWGH*LURQD 0HULW[HOO0DUt5RGUtJXH] %H.jULDGHOSURMH.WH8G*
  19. 19. 0DU.RV2UR].R3DLUHW %H.DULGHOSURMH.WH8G*
  20. 20. /DXUD5LHUDDVHOODV *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  21. 21. /tGLD7XURQ3ODQHOOD *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  22. 22. ‹*HQHUDOLWDWGHDWDOXQD 'HSDUWDPHQWGH%HQHVWDUL)DPtOLD 3ULPHUDHGL.LyDEULOGH 3ULPHUDUHLPSUHVVLyUHYLVDGDPDLJGH 7LUDWJHH[HPSODUV 'LSzVLWOHJDO% 'LVVHQLSURGX..LyJDPDVO
  23. 23. 35(6(17$,Ï eVXQDVDWLVID..LySHUDPLSUHVHQWDUYRVDTXHVWDQRYD.ROÂOH..LyTXHHO'HSDUWDPHQWGH %HQHVWDUL)DPtOLDKDLQL.LDWDPEODYROXQWDWG¶DMXGDUD.RQqL[HULLQWHJUDUHQODQRVWUD VR.LHWDWOHVSHUVRQHVTXHDUULEHQG¶DUUHXGHOPyQ/DYROXQWDW.UHL[HQWTXHPRVWUHQSHU DSUHQGUH HO .DWDOj KD SRVDW GH PDQLIHVW OD QH.HVVLWDW GH IDPLOLDULW]DU OD .RPXQLWDW HGX.DWLYD DPE OHV OOHQJHV GHOV LPPLJUDQWV D IL TXH DTXHVWD SXJXL HQWHQGUH HOV SUREOHPHV OLQJtVWL.V TXH KDQ G¶DIURQWDU HOV HVWXGLDQWV TXDQ GHVLWJHQ DSUHQGUH R DSUHQHQHO.DWDOj$TXHVWDQH.HVVLWDWHVIDHYLGHQWDPEO¶HV.RODULW]D.LyGHQHQVLQHQHV HQOHVHV.ROHV.DWDODQHVSHUzWDPEpDPEO¶LQ.UHPHQWGHSHUVRQHVLQV.ULWHVDOHVHV.ROHVL DXOHV GH IRUPD.Ly G¶DGXOWV L HQ HOV .XUVRV GH QRUPDOLW]D.Ly OLQJtVWL.D DGDV.XQ GHOV YROXPV G¶DTXHVWD .ROÂOH..Ly pV IUXLW G¶XQ HVWXGL GH OHV OOHQJHV HVWUDQJHUHV QR .RPXQLWjULHVPpVSDUODGHVDDWDOXQDLHVWjGHVWLQDWDIHUQRWDUHOVDVSH.WHVOLQJtVWL.V TXH SRGHQ DIDYRULU R HQWRUSLU O¶DSUHQHQWDWJH GHO .DWDOj RQWHQHQ XQD GHV.ULS.Ly JUDPDWL.DOGHODOOHQJXDLXQDSDUWDWGHOVHUURUVLSUREOHPHVOLQJtVWL.VPpVIUHTHQWVL DPpVYDQD.RPSDQDWVG¶XQVEUHXVHVWXGLV.RPSDUDWLXVGHOVLVWHPDJUDPDWL.DO.DWDOj DPEHOVVLVWHPHVJUDPDWL.DOVGHOHVDOWUHVOOHQJHV /D ILQDOLWDW SULQ.LSDO GHO *RYHUQ GH OD *HQHUDOLWDW GH DWDOXQD DVVHQDODGD HQ HO 3OD LQWHUGHSDUWDPHQWDO G¶LPPLJUD.Ly pV D.RQVHJXLU TXH OHV SHUVRQHV TXH KDQ HV.ROOLW DWDOXQDSHUYLXUHV¶KLLQWHJULQDPEODPj[LPDQDWXUDOLWDWLUDSLGHVDSRVVLEOH/DYLD SULQ.LSDOSHUD.RQVHJXLUDTXHVWDLQWHJUD.LypVHO.RQHL[HPHQWLO¶~VGHO.DWDOj6yQHOV SURIHVVLRQDOVGHO¶HQVHQDPHQWLODVR.LHWDW.DWDODQDHQJHQHUDOHOVTXHWHQHQHOGHXUHGH ID.LOLWDUORV O¶DSUHQHQWDWJH GH OD QRVWUD OOHQJXD RQqL[HU TXLQHV VyQ OHV GLIL.XOWDWV OLQJtVWLTXHV DPE TXq HV WUREHQ KD G¶DMXGDUQRV D ID.LOLWDU O¶HQVHQDPHQW GHO .DWDOj D SHUVRQHV DPE TXL LQL.LDOPHQW KL SRW KDYHU PpV GLIL.XOWDWV GH .RPSUHQVLy L GH UHOD.Ly YHUEDODWqVTXH.DSGHOVGRVLQWHUOR.XWRUV.RQHL[RSDUODODOOHQJXDGHO¶DOWUH (OVHJRQPRWLXGHVDWLVID..LySHUODSUHVHQWD.LyG¶DTXHVWD.ROÂOH..LyGHULYDGHOIHWTXH pV IUXLW G¶XQD .ROÂODERUD.Ly HQWUH HO PyQ D.DGqPL. UHSUHVHQWDW SHU OD 8QLYHUVLWDW GH *LURQDLDPEOD.RRUGLQD.LyGHOD'UD/OXwVD*Uj.LD ±DPEXQDOODUJDWUDMH.WzULDHQOD LQYHVWLJD.Ly OLQJtVWL.D OD TXDO JDUDQWHL[ OD TXDOLWDW GHOV PDWHULDOV HODERUDWV ± L O¶$GPLQLVWUD.Ly .DWDODQD UHSUHVHQWDGD SHO 'HSDUWDPHQW GH %HQHVWDU L )DPtOLD GH OD
  24. 24. *HQHUDOLWDWGHDWDOXQDUH.TXHpVER TXH OHV LQYHVWLJD.LRQV TXH HV IDQ HQ HO PyQ D.DGqPL. WLQJXLQ XQD DSOL.D.Ly GLUH.WD L UHYHUWHL[LQ HQ EHQHIL.L GH OD VR.LHWDW L GHOV .LXWDGDQVHQJHQHUDO$L[tPDWHL[.UH.TXHpVERTXHOHVDGPLQLVWUD.LRQVV¶DGUH.LQDO PyQ D.DGqPL. SHU VROÂOL.LWDUOL .RQHL[HPHQWV L PqWRGHV TXH HQV SHUPHWLQ PLOORUDU HO WUHEDOOGHOGLDDGLD $TXHVWVPDWHULDOVGRQ.VHODERUDWVHQO¶jPELWD.DGqPL.YDQGHVWLQDWVDOVSURIHVVLRQDOV GH O¶HQVHQDPHQW D IL TXH HOV VHUYHL[LQ SHU DSURSDUVH XQD PL.D D OHV OOHQJHV TXH SDUOHQ HOV VHXV DOXPQHV L HOV SHUPHWLQ LGHQWLIL.DU OHV GLIL.XOWDWV L HOV SURJUHVVRV HQ O¶DSUHQHQWDWJH GHO .DWDOj GHULYDWV GH OHV GLIHUqQ.LHV IRQqWLTXHV JUDPDWL.DOV L Oq[LTXHV DPEODVHYDOOHQJXDPDWHUQD ,5(1(5,*$8,2/,9(5 RQVHOOHUDGH%HQHVWDUL)DPtOLD
  25. 25. 7RQWHIDQD +DDGDPD UHQPH VX VDDUHHQ D DQ QD GXNLWWHQ xD DQ QWD VHUH NRPDD[XDQGRVRURQVXDQHNNDGRURQWDD[XGRWDTX+DTLOHQZD VHUHVXDGRVRURNXWWXQDQVLULWHUHQHGRRPHNDSSDOHQJDD[XNDQPD 6RQLQNp
  26. 26. $UWL.OH 7RWV HOV pVVHUV KXPDQV QHL[HQ OOLXUHV L LJXDOV HQ GLJQLWDW L HQ GUHWV 6yQ GRWDWV GH UDy L GH .RQV.LqQ.LD L KDQ GH .RPSRUWDUVH IUDWHUQDOPHQWHOVXQVDPEHOVDOWUHV 'H.ODUD.Ly8QLYHUVDOGHOV'UHWV+XPDQV
  27. 27. ,1752'8,Ï /D LGHD GH IHU XQ HVWXGL VREUH OHV OOHQJHV GHOV LPPLJUDQWV TXH UHVLGHL[HQ D DWDOXQDYDVRUJLUGHOD.RQVWDWD.LyGHOVSUREOHPHVTXHVXSRVDYDHOIHWG¶LQWHJUDUDOHV DXOHVLDODVR.LHWDWXQHVSHUVRQHVTXHSDUODYHQXQDDOWUDOOHQJXDGHODTXDOOD.RPXQLWDW HGX.DWLYDGHOQRVWUHSDtVHQODPDMRULDGHOV.DVRVQRWHQLD.DS.RQHL[HPHQW/DVLWXD.Ly GRQ.VpVEHQGLIHUHQWGHODTXHHVGyQDDPEHOVLPPLJUDQWVTXHSDUOHQ.DVWHOOjSHUTXq HOV HGX.DGRUV Vt TXH SRGHQ HQWHQGUH L SDUODU OD VHYD OOHQJXD L SHU WDQW QR HV GyQD OD LPSRVVLELOLWDWGH.RPSUHQVLyLGHUHOD.LyYHUEDO /¶REMH.WLXG¶DTXHVWVWUHEDOOVpVSURSRU.LRQDUDOVPHVWUHVLDOVSURIHVVRUVTXHKDQ G¶HQVHQDU .DWDOj DOV QRVWUHV LPPLJUDQWV XQD HLQD TXH HOV VHUYHL[L SHU DSURSDUVH XQD PL.DDODOOHQJXDTXHSDUOHQHOVVHXVDOXPQHV1RHVWUD.WDHYLGHQWPHQWTXHDSUHQJXLQ jUDE[LQqVRPDQGLQJDSHUH[HPSOH1RPpVSUHWHQHPTXHWLQJXLQXQDLGHDJHQHUDOGHO IXQ.LRQDPHQWGHODJUDPjWL.DG¶DTXHVWHVOOHQJHVTXHHOVSHUPHWLYDORUDULHQWHQGUHOHV GLIL.XOWDWVLHOVSURJUHVVRVGHOVDSUHQHQWVeVREYLTXHQRWRWVHOVSUREOHPHVOLQJtVWL.V SURYHQHQGHODLQWHUIHUqQ.LDDPEODSULPHUDOOHQJXDDOJXQVVyQJHQHUDOVHQTXDOVHYRO DSUHQHQWDWJH G¶XQD VHJRQD R ILQV L WRW G¶XQD SULPHUD OOHQJXD 3HUz Vt TXH KL KD GHWHUPLQDWVHUURUVTXHV¶HQWHQHQPpVEpVLHV.RPSDUDODJUDPjWL.DGHO.DWDOjDPEODGH O¶DOWUD OOHQJXD 1RVDOWUHV QR SUHWHQHP HQ DTXHVWV HVWXGLV GRQDU VROX.LRQV QL PDWHULDO GLGj.WL.SHUDOVSUREOHPHV.RQ.UHWV$L[zHVSRGUjIHUHQXQDVHJRQDIDVHDUDTXHWHQLP LGHQWLIL.DGHVOHVGLIHUqQ.LHVHQWUHOHVGXHVOOHQJHVLTXHKHPSRJXWGHWH.WDUHOVHUURUV PpV IUHTHQWV (O WUHEDOO TXH SUHVHQWHP DUD KDXULD G¶DMXGDU O¶HQVHQDQW D GHGXLU G¶RQ YpQHQ R G¶RQ SRGHQ YHQLU HOV SUREOHPHV L KDXULD G¶HVWLPXODUOR D WUREDU HVWUDWqJLHV GLGj.WLTXHVDGHTXDGHVD.DGD.DV /D LGHD TXH KL KD DO GDUUHUH G¶DTXHVW SURMH.WH pV TXH SHUTXq HOV LPPLJUDQWV V¶LQWHJULQ.DOTXHODVR.LHWDWG¶D.ROOLGDWLQJXLDOJXQ.RQHL[HPHQWGHOD.XOWXUDGHOVTXH KLDUULEHQ,OD.XOWXUDHQWUHG¶DOWUHV.RVHVLQ.ORXODOOHQJXD,SRWVHUpVHOID.WRUPpV LPSRUWDQWSHUTXqpVHOTXHSHUPHWODWUDQVPLVVLyGH.RQHL[HPHQWVG¶H[SHULqQ.LHVLGH VHQWLPHQWV/DOOHQJXDLSHUUDRQVKLVWzULTXHVHOV.DWDODQVKRSRGHPHQWHQGUHPROWEp L
  28. 28. pVXQWUHWPROWOOLJDWDODSHUVRQDLDOD.RPXQLWDWTXHPHUHL[XQUHVSH.WHHVSH.LDOSHU SDUWGHOVDOWUHVLTXHHQ.DS.DVQRV¶KDGHPHQVWHQLURLJQRUDU 3RGHU GHPRVWUDU DOV LPPLJUDQWV TXH VDEHP DOJXQD .RVD GH OD VHYD OOHQJXD HQ.DUDTXHQRPpVVLJXLTXHHQ.RQHL[HPO¶H[LVWqQ.LDLHOQRPRODPDQHUDGHGLUERQ GLDRJUj.LHVPDQLIHVWDUTXHKLHVWHPLQWHUHVVDWVLHQVHQDUORVTXHWHQLPXQOOLEUHWTXH HQVSRWDMXGDUDVDEHUQHPpVVyQ.RVHVTXHHOOVDJUDLUDQ.RPKRDJUDLUtHPQRVDOWUHVVL HQVWUREpVVLPHQOHVVHYHV.LU.XPVWjQ.LHV(QPROWV.DVRVHVSH.LDOPHQWSHUDOVSDUODQWV G¶DOJXQHVOOHQJHVDIUL.DQHVDTXHVWLQWHUqVSRWWHQLUHQ.DUDXQDOWUH HIH.WH EHQHIL.LyV HYLWDUTXHHOOVV¶DYHUJRQHL[LQGHODVHYDSUzSLDOOHQJXDLSHUWDQWUHGXLUHOVHQWLPHQW G¶LQIHULRULWDWTXHGHYHJDGHVVHQWHQHQYHUVHOOVPDWHL[RVLODVHYD.XOWXUDTXDQVyQDTXt 1RPpVTXDQHQVD..HSWHPLHQVVHQWLPD..HSWDWVVRP.DSDoRVG¶D..HSWDUHOVDOWUHV8Q SUR.pVG¶LQWHJUD.LyQRSRWDQDU GHVYLQ.XODW GHO .RQHL[HPHQW PXWX ,QWHJUDU QR YRO GLU IDJR.LWDU,QWHJUDUVHQRSRWLPSOL.DUKDYHUGHUHQXQ.LDUDODSUzSLD.XOWXUD6LIRVDL[t VHULDXQHPSREULPHQWSHUDOHVGXHVSDUWV (VWUX.WXUDGHOOOLEUH $TXHVWOOLEUH.RQVWDGH.LQ.SDUWV(QODSULPHUD,GHQWLIL.D.LyGHOHVOOHQJHVHV GRQHQ XQHV QR.LRQV EjVLTXHV VREUH HO OOR. RQ HV SDUOHQ HO VRQLQNp L HO PDQGLQJD HO QRPEUH GH SDUODQWV OD VLWXD.Ly VR.LROLQJtVWL.D L OHV YDULDQWV GLDOH.WDOV L OHV VHYHV SULQ.LSDOV.DUD.WHUtVWLTXHVJUDPDWL.DOV$TXHVWHVGXHVOOHQJHVV¶KDQDJUXSDWHQXQVRO YROXP SHUTXq SHUWDQHQ DO PDWHL[ JUXS GH OD PDWHL[D IDPtOLD OHV OOHQJHV PDQGp L WHQHQSURSLHWDWVJUDPDWL.DOVIRUoDVHPEODQWV /D VHJRQD SDUW 'HV.ULS.Ly JUDPDWL.DO SUHVHQWD DOJXQHV THVWLRQV GH O¶HVWUX.WXUDGHODJUDPjWL.DGHOVRQLQNpLGHOPDQGLQJDHVSH.LDOPHQWG¶DTXHOOHVTXHVyQ PpV GLIHUHQWV GHO .DWDOj R TXH SRGHQ VHU OD IRQW G¶DOJXQV HUURUV (VWj RUJDQLW]DW LQWHUQDPHQW HQ TXDWUH VXEDSDUWDWV IRQRORJLD L IRQqWL.D PRUIRORJLD VLQWD[L L Oq[L. $TXHVW .DStWRO QR V¶KD GH YHXUH .RP XQD ³JUDPjWL.D GHO VRQLQNp L GHO PDQGLQJD´ pV QRPpVXQ.RQMXQWG¶LQIRUPD.LRQVJUDPDWL.DOVVREUHDTXHVWHVGXHVOOHQJHV.RPSDUDGHV DPE OHV HVWUX.WXUHV .RUUHVSRQHQWV GHO .DWDOj 6HPSUH TXH HQV KD HVWDW SRVVLEOH KHP UHOD.LRQDWOD.RPSDUD.LyJUDPDWL.DODPEHOVHUURUVTXHKHPGHWH.WDWHQODSDUOD.DWDODQD GH SHUVRQHV VRQLQNpV L PDQGLQJXHV +HP LQWHQWDW VHPSUH GHL[DU GH EDQGD HOV LL
  29. 29. WH.QL.LVPHV L KHP VLPSOLIL.DW HOV SUREOHPHV DO Pj[LP 3RVVLEOHPHQW XQ OLQJLVWD KL WUREDUjPDQ.DQ.HVSUREOHPHVLQWHUHVVDQWVSR.H[SOL.DWVLVHQVH.DSSURSRVWDGHVROX.Ly ,WLQGUjUDy3HUzHVWUD.WDG¶XQWUHEDOODPEXQDILQDOLWDWSUj.WL.DPROW.ODUDDMXGDUHOV HGX.DGRUV TXH QR QH.HVVjULDPHQW VyQ OLQJLVWHV
  30. 30. eV SHU DL[z TXH KHP .UHJXW .RQYHQLHQWGHL[DUGHEDQGDOHVGLVTXLVL.LRQVTXHSRGULHQVHUPROWLQWHUHVVDQWVSHUDXQ OLQJLVWDSHUzTXHQRDSRUWDULHQUHVVLJQLIL.DWLXD O¶REUDWDO.RPO¶KHP.RQ.HEXGDGHV GHO.RPHQoDPHQW /D WHU.HUD SDUW LQ.ORX XQD OOLVWD DPE HOV WLSXV G¶HUURUV JUDPDWL.DOV TXH KHP WUREDWDPEDOJXQVH[HPSOHVLODUHIHUqQ.LDDO¶DSDUWDWGHOVHJRQ.DStWROHQTXqHVWUD.WD ODTHVWLy(OVHUURUVSURYHQHQGHSDUODQWVVRQLQNpVL PDQGLQJXHVTXHKHPHQWUHYLVWDW TXDQSDUODYHQ.DWDOj(QDOJXQ.DVO¶LQIRUPDQWSDUODYD.DVWHOOjSHUTXqKDHVWDWGLIt.LO WUREDU DGXOWV TXH SDUOHVVLQ .DWDOj (Q TXDOVHYRO .DV HOV UHVXOWDWV QR YDULHQ GHOV TXH WLQGUtHPVLKDJXHVVLQSDUODWHQ.DWDOjHOVWLSXVG¶HUURUVVyQJDLUHEpHOVPDWHL[RVSHUTXq OHVGXHVOOHQJHVHO.DWDOjLHO.DVWHOOjVyQPROWVLPLODUV6¶KDGHWHQLUHQ.RPSWHTXH .DSGHOVQRVWUHVLQIRUPDQWVQRHUDHQHOVSULPHUVHVWDGLVG¶DSUHQHQWDWJHGHODOOHQJXD $L[zYROGLUTXHQRKHPSRJXWGHWH.WDUDOJXQVGHOVHUURUVTXHSUREDEOHPHQWHVGRQHQ HQHOVSULPHUVPRPHQWVLGHVSUpVGHVDSDUHL[HQ (OTXDUWDSDUWDW.RQVLVWHL[HQTXDWUHEUHXVYR.DEXODULV.DWDOjVRQLQNpVRQLQNp .DWDOjL.DWDOjPDQGLQJDPDQGLQJD.DWDOj/HVIRUPHVVRQLQNpVLPDQGLQJXHVHVWDQ HV.ULWHVHQO¶RUWRJUDILDGH.DGDXQDGHOHVOOHQJHV(QHOVHJRQ.DStWROHQSDUODUGHOD IRQRORJLDLODIRQqWL.DHVGRQHQOHVHTXLYDOqQ.LHVHQWUHDTXHVWHVJUDILHVLHOVVtPEROVGH O¶DOIDEHW IRQqWL. LQWHUQD.LRQDO $L[z SRW ID.LOLWDU ILQV D XQ .HUW SXQW OD SURQXQ.LD.Ly G¶DOJXQD SDUDXOD HQ VRQLQNp R HQ PDQGLQJD VL pV QH.HVVDUL 6¶KDQ WULDW HOV .RQ.HSWHV TXH HV .RQVLGHUHQ PpV R PHQV XQLYHUVDOV HQ OD ELEOLRJUDILD HVSH.LDOLW]DGD L V¶KL KDQ DIHJLWDTXHOOVTXHHQVVHPEODYDTXHSRGLHQVHUG¶~VPpVIUHTHQWHQODQRVWUDVR.LHWDWR HQODVHYD.XOWXUD )LQDOPHQW HO .LQTXq SXQW pV XQD EUHX ELEOLRJUDILD TXH LQ.ORX UHIHUqQ.LHV ELEOLRJUjILTXHV DVVHTXLEOHV GHV GH DWDOXQD L DGUH.HV GH SjJLQHV ZHE TXH SRGHQ VHU ~WLOVLHOVLVqDSDUWDW.RQWpHOVDSqQGL[VHOTXDGUHGHO¶DOIDEHWIRQqWL.LQWHUQD.LRQDOHO TXDGUH GH VRQV GHO .DWDOj L XQV PDSHV OLQJtVWL.V GH OHV ]RQHV RQ HV SDUOHQ DTXHVWHV OOHQJHV LLL
  31. 31. $JUDwPHQWV 7RW DTXHVW SURMH.WH QR KDXULD HVWDW SRVVLEOH VHQVH HO ILQDQoDPHQW GHO 'HSDUWDPHQW GH %HQHVWDU L )DPtOLD GH OD *HQHUDOLWDW GH DWDOXQD $JUDwP GRQ.V G¶XQDPDQHUDPROWHVSH.LDOOD.RQILDQoDTXHHQVKDGHPRVWUDWOD.RQVHOOHUD,UHQH5LJDX LOD.ROÂODERUD.LyGHOHVSHUVRQHVGHO'HSDUWDPHQWTXHSUHVLGHL[ La redacció d’aquest volum s’ha beneficiat de la col·laboració de diverses persones. En primer lloc, agraïm la feina que han fet els becaris i col·laboradors que han treballat directament o indirectament en aquest projecte, entrevistant informants, transcrivint els enregistraments i fent tot el que calia: L. Gauvreau, M. Marí, M. Orozco, L. Riera, R. Agustí i L. Turon. A O. .ullana devem les pautes i totes les indicacions QH.HVVjULHVSHUDO¶HVWUX.WXUD.LyGHOVYR.DEXODULVILQDOVLD-XKHUL%URXVODUHYLVLy GHO PDQXV.ULW Agraïm també a les escoles que ens han facilitat les entrevistes als informants: al CEIP La .arga de Salt i a l’Escola d’Adults de Salt (“Les Bernardes”). Expressem també el nostre agraïment a les persones que han acceptat de ser entrevistades. Donem les gràcies a la International Phonetic Association (c/o Department of Linguistics, University of Victoria, Victoria, British Columbia, Canadà) per permetre la reproducció del quadre de sons que apareix a la secció d’apèndixs. .inalment, volem donar les gràcies a Musa Camara, que ens ha aportat algunes informacions sobre les llengües, i, d’una manera molt especial, al professor D. Creissels, de la Universitat de Lió, que, amb una gran generositat, ens ha proporcionat material i dades sobre el mandinga que han estat imprescindibles per a la redacció del treball. $JUDwP SHU HQGDYDQW WRWV HOV VXJJHULPHQWV REVHUYD.LRQV L .RUUH..LRQV TXH HOV OH.WRUV HQV SXJXHX IHU DUULEDU D O DGUHoD GH .RUUHX HOH.WUzQL. JDOL#XGJHV /D YRVWUD .ROÂODERUD.LyHQVSRGUjVHUPROW~WLOSHUPLOORUDUHOQRVWUHWUHEDOO LY
  32. 32. $%5(9,$785(686$'(6(1/$'(65,3,Ï*5$0$7,$/ $) DILUPDWLX 203 .RPSDUDWLX 21- .RQMXQ.Ly '() GHILQLW '(0 GHPRVWUDWLX (0) HPIjWL. ,17(55 LQWHUURJDWLX 025) PRUIHPD 1(* QHJDWLX 3$57 SDUWt.XOD 3/ SOXUDO 3266 SRVVHVVLX 3267 SRVWSRVL.Ly 327 SRWHQ.LDO 35(' SUHGL.DWLX 35(6 SUHVHQW 43 TXDVLSUHGL.DWLX 5() UHIOH[LX 5(/ UHODWLX 68% VXERUGLQDQW 68) VXIL[ $%5(9,$785(686$'(6(1(/92$%8/$5, DGM DGMH.WLX DGY DGYHUEL .RQM .RQMXQ.Ly LPSHUI LPSHUIH.WLX LQWU LQWUDQVLWLX Q QRP SHUI SHUIH.WLX SO SOXUDO SUHS SUHSRVL.Ly SURQ SURQRPSURQRPLQDO VJ VLQJXODU WU WUDQVLWLX Y YHUE Y
  33. 33. ,'(17,),$,Ï'(/(6//(1*h(6 /HVOOHQJHVPDQGpSHUWDQHQDODIDPtOLDQLJHUR.RQJROHVD(VSDUOHQDODSDUW RHVW GH O¶¬IUL.D 6XEVDKDULDQD D 0DOL 0DXULWjQLD *jPELD 6HQHJDO *XLQHD *XLQHD %LVVDX*KDQD6LHUUD/HRQH/LEqULDRVWDG¶,YRUL%XUNLQD)DVRHW.YJHOVPDSHV GH O¶DSDUWDW
  34. 34. $TXHVWHV OOHQJHV VyQ SDUODGHV SHU PpV GH GHX PLOLRQV GH SDUODQWV $OJXQHVGHOHVOOHQJHVG¶DTXHVWJUXSVyQHOEDPEDUDHOPDOLQNpHOGLXODHOPHQGHHO NSHOqVHOVXVXLOHVGXHVGHTXqHQVR.XSHPHQDTXHVWWUHEDOOHOVRQLQNpLHOPDQGLQJD 7DQWHOVRQLQNp.RPHOPDQGLQJDVyQOOHQJHVPDQGpGHOJUXS1RUGRHVW(OPDQGLQJD SHUWDQDOVXEJUXSPDQGLQJSHUzKLKDPROWD.RQIXVLyHQHOVWHUPHVTXHGHVLJQHQOHV GLIHUHQWVYDULHWDWVOLQJtVWLTXHVLHQODVHYDGHOLPLWD.Ly$UDQRDSURIXQGLUHPHQDTXHVWD THVWLySHUzUHPHWHPHOOH.WRULQWHUHVVDWDODELEOLRJUDILDTXHGRQHPDOILQDOGHOOOLEUH (OVRQLQNpWpDSUR[LPDGDPHQWXQPLOLyLPLJGHSDUODQWVLWDPEppVDQRPHQDW HQWUH G¶DOWUHV QRPV VDUDNROH VDUDKXOH VHUDKXOL L PDUND (V SDUOD IRQDPHQWDOPHQW D 0DOL 6HQHJDO 0DXULWjQLD L *jPELD (O PDQGLQJD Wp PpV G¶XQ PLOLy GH SDUODQWV L HV SDUODSULQ.LSDOPHQWD*jPELD*XLQHD%LVVDXLDXQDSDUWGHO6HQHJDO/DPDMRULDGHOHV YDULDQWVOLQJtVWLTXHVGHOVXEJUXSPDQGLQJVyQUHODWLYDPHQW.RPSUHQVLEOHVHQWUHVLHQ ERQDSDUWSHUTXq.RPSDUWHL[HQXQSHU.HQWDWJHPROWHOHYDWGHOOq[L.(QWUHPDQGLQJXHVL VRQLQNpV XQLOLQJHV HQ .DQYL HO JUDX G¶LQWHU.RPSUHQVLy pV PROW PpV EDL[ SHUz pV IUHTHQW WUREDU VRQLQNpV ELOLQJHV HQ OHV GXHV OOHQJHV L D PpV PROWV SDUODQWV GHO VRQLQNpWDPEpSDUOHQEDPEDUDXQDOOHQJXDGHOVXEJUXSPDQGLQJDOTXDOSHUWDQWDPEp HOPDQGLQJD ' UHLVVHOVHQVKDIHWVDEHUTXHDTXHVWD.RQIXVLyHVYHXDIDYRULGDHQWUHG¶DOWUHV.RVHVSHUO¶DPELJLWDW G¶DOJXQV GHO WHUPHV 0DUND SHU H[HPSOH pV HO WHUPH TXH IDQ VHUYLU HOV EDPEDUD SHU GHVLJQDU HOV VRQLQNpVSHUzDODIURQWHUDHQWUH0DOLL%XUNLQD)DVRKLKDXQJUXSqWQL.TXHV¶DXWRGHQRPLQD PDUNDL TXHHOVEDPEDUHVDQRPHQHQGDILQJ
  35. 35. SHUzTXHSDUOHQXQGLDOH.WHGHOVXEJUXSPDQGLQJLTXHSHUWDQWQRWp UHVDYHXUHDPEHOVRQLQNp$PpVD*jPELDLDO6HQHJDOHOVPDQGLQJXHVGHVLJQHQHOVVRQLQNpVDPEHO WHUPHVDUDKXOOHLHOWHUPHVRQLQNpO¶XWLOLW]HQHOVPDQGLQJXHVLVODPLW]DWVSHUUHIHULUVHDOVPDQGLQJXHVTXH QRV¶KDQ.RQYHUWLWDODUHOLJLyLVOjPL.D
  36. 36. (QODPDMRULDGHOVSDwVRVRQHVSDUOHQDTXHVWHVOOHQJHVODOOHQJXDRIL.LDORXQD GH OHV OOHQJHV QD.LRQDOV pV HO IUDQ.qV *XLQHD 0DOL 0DXULWjQLD 6HQHJDO %XUNLQD )DVR /LEqULD RVWD G¶,YRUL
  37. 37. O¶DQJOqV *KDQD 1LJqULD *jPELD 6LHUUD /HRQH
  38. 38. R HO SRUWXJXqV*XLQHD%LVVDX
  39. 39. (QDOJXQVG¶DTXHVWVSDwVRV.RPD*jPELD6HQHJDO0DOLR 0DXULWjQLDWDPEpHVSDUOHQDOWUHVOOHQJHVQLJHUR.RQJROHVHVGHOJUXS$WOjQWL..RPHO ZzORIRHOIXOD6¶KDGHWHQLUHQ.RPSWHTXHHQDTXHVWVSDwVRV.RQYLXHQPROWHVOOHQJHV L TXH OHV IURQWHUHV OLQJtVWLTXHV QR .RLQ.LGHL[HQ DPE OHV SROtWLTXHV 1RPpV SHU SRVDU XQVH[HPSOHVD6HQHJDOTXHD.WXDOPHQWWpXQVQRXPLOLRQVG¶KDELWDQWVV¶KLSDUOHQXQD TXDUDQWHQD GH OOHQJHV L D *jPELD DPE XQD SREOD.Ly GH SR. PpV G¶XQ PLOLy G¶KDELWDQWV XQD YLQWHQD GDGHV H[WUHWHV GH *ULPHV L GH 7KH 7LPHV $WODV RI WKH :RUOG
  40. 40. 3HOTXHIDDO¶HV.ULSWXUDD.WXDOHQWRWVGRV.DVRVKDHVWDWHVWDQGDUGLW]DGDSHUXQ GH.UHW GHO JRYHUQ VHQHJDOqV GHO WRW L TXH QR WRWHV OHV jUHHV GH SDUOD VRQLQNp D..HSWHQ DTXHVWD UHJXOD.Ly (V EDVD HQ O¶DOIDEHW OODWt DPE OD LQ.OXVLy G¶DOJXQV VLJQHV GLIHUHQWVGHOVTXHIHPVHUYLUQRVDOWUHV $OJXQHVGHOHV.DUD.WHUtVWLTXHVOLQJtVWLTXHVGHOJUXSPDQGpVyQOHVVHJHQWV D
  41. 41. HQJHQHUDOWHQHQVHWYR.DOVSHUzDOQRUGHVUHGXHL[HQD.LQ.LDOVXGWHQGHL[HQD WHQLUQHQRX E
  42. 42. QR WHQHQ .ODVVLIL.DGRUV QRPLQDOV SHUz VRYLQW GLVWLQJHL[HQ HQWUH QRPV OOLXUHV R GH SRVVHVVLy DOLHQDEOH OOLEUH WDXOD DUEUH
  43. 43. L QRPV GHSHQGHQWV R GH SRVVHVVLy LQDOLHQDEOHILOOPDUHXOOPj
  44. 44. .
  45. 45. OD .RQMXJD.Ly pV PROW OLPLWDGD SHO TXH ID D OD IRUPD YHUEDO SHUz V¶XVHQ HOV ³SUHGL.DWLXV´ XQV HOHPHQWV TXH UH.XOOHQ DOJXQHV .DWHJRULHV IOH[LYHV GHO YHUE WHPSVLDVSH.WH
  46. 46. G
  47. 47. HOSUR.pVGH.RPSRVL.LypVPROWSURGX.WLX H
  48. 48. WHQHQXQRUGUHGHPRWVPROWIL[DPEWHQGqQ.LDDVHJXLUO¶RUGUHVXEMH.WHREMH.WH YHUE629
  49. 49. I
  50. 50. OHVPDUTXHVGHGHILQLWXGDUWL.OHGHPRVWUDWLXV
  51. 51. LOHVPDUTXHVGHSOXUDOWHQGHL[HQ DDQDUGHVSUpVGHOQRPRGHOVLQWDJPDQRPLQDOSHUzHOVSRVVHVVLXVSUH.HGHL[HQ HOQRP J
  52. 52. SUHGRPLQHQOHVSRVWSRVL.LRQVSHUVREUHGHOHVSUHSRVL.LRQV
  53. 53. '(65,3,Ï*5$0$7,$/ )212/2*,$,)21Ê7,$ 92$/6 (OVVLVWHPHVYR.jOL.VGHOVRQLQNpLGHO PDQGLQJDWHQHQ.LQ.YR.DOVDHL RX$OJXQVDXWRUVSHUzGHIHQVHQTXHHOPDQGLQJDWpVHWYR.DOVSHUTXqGLVWLQJHL[ H(LRo$TXHVWHVYR.DOVSRGHQVHUOODUJXHVREUHXV(QODWUDQV.ULS.LyIRQqWL.DXQD YR.DOOODUJDHVUHSUHVHQWDSHOVtPEROYR.jOL..RUUHVSRQHQWVHJXLWGHGRVSXQWVD@
  54. 54. (Q ODVHYDHV.ULSWXUDOHVYR.DOVOODUJXHVHVWUDQV.ULXHQ.RPGXHVYR.DOVLGqQWLTXHVDD
  55. 55. /D GXUDGDGHOHVYR.DOVWpYDORUGLVWLQWLXpVDGLUSRWVHUYLUSHUGLIHUHQ.LDUPRWV*LULHU L3*
  56. 56. 6RQ NLQH µ.R.RGULO¶ NLLQH µPDULW¶ [DQD µDPL.¶ [DDQD µLJXDQD¶ 0DQ NH µHVGHYHQLU¶ NHH µKRPH¶ MH µYHXUH¶ MHH µDTXt¶ 21621$176 (O VLVWHPD .RQVRQjQWL. GHO VRQLQNp L GHO PDQGLQJD pV HO TXH UHSURGXwP HQ HO TXDGUH VHJHQW HQ TXq KHP IHW VHUYLU HOV VtPEROV GH O¶DOIDEHW IRQqWL. LQWHUQD.LRQDO +HPREVHUYDWTXHDOJXQVSDUODQWVGHYHJDGHVVXEVWLWXHL[HQOHVH(SHUL@ L
  57. 57. Wp@QHQoWt@QHQ MXJX(½@PoMXJXt@P G@VSUpVoGL@VSUpV 7DPEpHVGRQHQDOWUHV.DQYLVYR.jOL.VSHUzDTXHVWWLSXVG¶HUURUVQRVHPEODTXHHVSXJXLH[SOL.DUDSDUWLU GHOVLVWHPDYR.jOL.GHODOOHQJXDPDWHUQD
  58. 58. $),
  59. 59. YJ † L
  60. 60. +HP SRVDW HQWUH SDUqQWHVLV DTXHOOV TXH VyQ H[.OXVLXV GHO VRQLQNp ELODELDO ODELRGHQWDO GHQWRDOYHRODU SDODWDO YHODU XYXODU JORWDO VRUGDVRQRUD VRUGDVRQRUD VRUGDVRQRUD VRUGDVRQRUD VRUGDVRQRUD VRUGDVRQRUD VRUGDVRQRUD R.OXVLYD S E W G N J
  61. 61. T
  62. 62. IUL.DWLYD I V [
  63. 63. K DIUL.DGD W6 G= QDVDO P Q Ú 1 YLEUDQW U OtTXLGD O DSUR[LPDQW M Z 1LHQVRQLQNpQLHQPDQGLQJDDGLIHUqQ.LDGHOTXHSDVVDHQ.DWDOjQRH[LVWHL[HQ HOVVRQV]@=@6@5@QL–@7DPSR.QR.DQYLHQOHVR.OXVLYHVVRQRUHVEGLJHQ OHVIUL.DWLYHV%@'@L¦@QLODQDVDOHQODELRGHQWDO0@3HUDODPDMRULDGHOVSDUODQWV GHOPDQGLQJDHOVRJ@QRH[LVWHL[LQRPpVHVSRWWUREDUHQDOJXQVSUpVWH.V([LVWHL[HQ SHUzXQVDOWUHVVRQVTXHHO.DWDOjQRWpOD[@HQVRQLQNp
  64. 64. HTXLYDOHQWDODM.DVWHOODQD XQDR.OXVLYDXYXODUT@LXQDIUL.DWLYDJORWDOK@TXH.RUUHVSRQDODKDQJOHVDDKRWHO 3HOTXHIDDOVRQLQNpHQDOJXQHV]RQHVODIHVSURQXQ.LDK@7DPEpH[LVWHL[.RPD IRQHPD OD QDVDO YHODU 1 TXH pV HO VR TXH HQ .DWDOj QRPpV WUREHP TXDQ XQD Q YD VHJXLGDG¶XQD.RQVRQDQWYHODUHQ.DUD1Ni5@IDQJyVI1JyV@
  65. 65. /¶DSDUL.LyG¶DTXHVW VR QR HVWj .RQGL.LRQDGD D OD SUHVqQ.LD G¶XQD YHODU 6RQ WH1H@ µIURQW¶ 1DPH@ µLQXQGD.Ly¶0DQ1DOLWR@µIODXWD¶VL1R@µ.DPD¶ /HV GLIHUqQ.LHV HQWUH HO VLVWHPD .RQVRQjQWL. GHO .DWDOj L HOV GHO PDQGLQJD L HO VRQLQNp SRGHQ H[SOL.DU HUURUV .RP HOV TXH SUHVHQWHP D
  66. 66. D D
  67. 67. OD V VRQRUD V¶KD VXEVWLWXwW SHU OD VRUGD D E
  68. 68. HO VR SUHSDODWDO VRQRU =@ KD SDVVDW D O¶DSUR[LPDQW M@ WDPEpSDODWDORDODV@D.
  69. 69. ODEDWHJDQWGHO.DWDOjV¶KD.RQYHUWLWHQXQDYLEUDQWL ILQDOPHQWDG
  70. 70. WHQLP.DVRVHQTXqODSDODWDOODWHUDO–@WDPEpV¶KD.RQYHUWLWHQM@LGH YHJDGHVGREOH
  71. 71. D .R]@D o .RV@D PX]@XOPj o PXV@XOPj ]@RR o V@RR E =@HUPj o M@HUPj UHOL=@Ly o UHOLV@Ly . PD5@H o PDU@H G YHUPH–@HV o YHUPHM@HV X–@V o XM@V –@HJLU o MM@HJLU 8QDOWUHWUHWLPSRUWDQWGHODIRQRORJLDVRQLQNppVTXHH[.HSWHD.RPHQoDPHQW GHPRWOHV.RQVRQDQWVSRGHQVHUGREOHVSW6LTKRVyQVHPSUHNOLWKRVyQ PROWVRYLQWEGJLG=UDUDPHQWVyQGREOHVLOHVDOWUHV[VUKIMLZ QR KR VyQ PDL 7DO .RP SDVVDYD DPE OHV YR.DOV HO YDORU GREOH GH OD .RQVRQDQW pV GLVWLQWLX*LULHU
  72. 72. IXOH µIODXWD¶ IXOOH µIXOD¶ NXWX µWDOODU¶ NXWWX µODUHVWD¶ (QWRWHVGXHVOOHQJHVHOVRPpVSDUWL.XODUpVODQ@(QSULPHUOOR.SHUTXqSRW WHQLUXQDUHDOLW]D.LyTXDVLYR.jOL.D 6RQ Q@ µMR¶ 7DPEp pV O¶~QL.D .RQVRQDQW TXH HV SRW .RPELQDU DPE XQD DOWUD HO TXH V¶DQRPHQD µSUHQDVDOLW]D.Ly¶
  73. 73. *LULHU L 3*
  74. 74. 6RQ IXQ.H µJUD¶ IDQNH µYHQW¶ VDQJH µMR.¶ 0DQ WHQNXQGL µGHL[DUVRO¶ PXQNRR µIDULQD¶ OXQWD1R µHVWUDQJHU¶
  75. 75. 4XDQODQSUH.HGHL[XQD.RQVRQDQWODELDOWDQWDGLQWUHGHODSDUDXOD.RPHQWUH GXHVSDUDXOHVGLIHUHQWVHVSURQXQ.LD.RPXQDP@.RPHQ.DWDOj(QPDQGLQJDODQ GDYDQWIWDPEpHVSURQXQ.LDP@DGLIHUqQ.LDGHO.DWDOjHQTXqHVSURQXQ.LD0@(Q PDQGLQJDODSURQXQ.LD.LyELODELDOMDTXHGDUHIOH.WLGDHQODJUDILDP*LULHU L3*
  76. 76. 6RQ D NRQSH µKDELWD.Ly¶ NRPSH@ NDQEH µGHQW¶ NDPEH@ NDQPH µSOXMD¶ NDPPH@ E QPD µODPHYDPDUH¶ PPD@ QSDDND µHOPHXSXQDO¶ PSDND@ QEDDL µODPHYDWLD¶ PEDML@ 0DQ NDPEDDQRR µHOQRL¶ NDPEDQR@ NXPIDD µODERWLJD¶ NXPID@ ODPSRR µHOOOXP¶ ODPSR@ 4XDQ OD Q SUH.HGHL[ XQD .RQVRQDQW TXH QR SRW SUHQDVDOLW]DU HV SURGXHL[HQ GLYHUVRV .DQYLVIRQqWL.V$
  77. 77. HQSRGHPYHXUHDOJXQVGHOVRQLQNp*LULHU
  78. 78. Q o Qx QDTTH µODPHYDGRQD¶ QÚDTTH@ QZ o Q1 QZDWWH µODPHYDPDODOWLD¶ Q1DWWH@ Q[ o QT Q[R[RQH µHOPHXJHUPjSHWLW¶ QTR[RQH@ QO o OO QODER µHOPHXJDQLYHW¶ OODER@ QU o OO QUHQPH µHOPHXQHQ¶ OOHPPH@ (QPDQGLQJDODOSRW.DQYLDUDQ@VLODSDUDXODTXHHOSUH.HGHL[D.DEDHQQDVDO3*
  79. 79. QOD o QQD IH1OH o IH1QH
  80. 80. $.RQWLQXD.LyGRQHPH[HPSOHVGHSDUDXOHVTXH.RQWHQHQHOVGLIHUHQWVVRQVSHU YHXUHODUHOD.LyHQWUHODJUDILDLHOVR*LULHUL3*
  81. 81. 6RQLQNp 0DQGLQJD S SRROH µHOjVWL.¶ SRRVHH µDUUHJODU¶ E EXOD µEODX¶ EDDPRODD µSHL[DWHU¶ W WD µ.DPD¶ WRSRWRRURR µWHQLU.XUD¶ G GDDUX µDKLU¶ GRURQ µVRO¶ N ND µ.DVD¶ NDDILULDD µLQILGHO¶ J JLGH µJHUPj¶ ± T UDTTH µER.D¶ ± I IR µ.RVD¶ IRURDD µOOLEHUWDW¶ V VL µ.DYDOO¶ VDQMRR µSOXMD¶ G= ML µDLJXD¶ MXXUD µ.HOHEUDU¶ [ [DVH µYHOO¶ ± K KDTTH µQRPEUH¶ KDEXWD µJRODIUH¶ W6 .DDNX µVD.¶ .DIDUL µERLJ¶ P PD µPDUH¶ PDDUL µSURSLHWDUL¶ Q QHHQH µOOHQJXD¶ QXNXQGLQR µR.XOW¶ Ú xD µIHU¶ xDD µXOO¶ 1 1DDPH µLQXQGD.Ly¶ 1DxDD µUDV.DU¶ U UHJH µEDOODU¶ UDQR µILOD¶ M XJR µKRPH¶ LWDQGL µLQIRUPDU¶ Z ZX µSORUDU¶ ZDUDULQ µJURV¶ O OHQNL µDYXL¶ ORQGL µLQIRUPDU¶ /$6Ë/Â/$%$ /¶HVTXHPDVLOÂOjEL.GHOVRQLQNpLGHOPDQGLQJDpVIRUoDUtJLGL.RLQ.LGHL[DPEOD VHTqQ.LD.RQVRQDQWYR.DOTXHpVODPpV.RPXQDHQWUHOHVOOHQJHVGHOPyQ99 9 ([.HSWH HQ SR.V .DVRV OHV SDUDXOHV .RPHQ.HQ HQ .RQVRQDQW L D.DEHQ HQ YR.DO *LULHUL3'
  82. 82. 6RQ NDPH µ.HQW¶ WR1H µIURQW¶ D[DUH µGRQD¶ 0DQ .DIDULWD µERLJ¶ NXWX µYqQ.HU¶ VLODWD µHVSDQWDW¶ 1R KL SRW KDYHU GXHV .RQVRQDQWV VHJXLGHV H[.HSWH VL OD SULPHUD pV XQD Q SUHQDVDOLW]D.Ly
  83. 83. UH.RUGHP TXH HQ O¶HV.ULSWXUD GXHV .RQVRQDQWV VHJXLGHV LGqQWLTXHV HTXLYDOHQDXQD.RQVRQDQWOODUJDQRDGXHV.RQVRQDQWV
  84. 84. *LULHUL3'
  85. 85. 6RQ UHQPH µQHQ¶ OHQNL µDYXL¶ WXQVL µD.RPSDQDU¶ 0DQ ORQNRR µJDUIL¶ VDQND µLPLWDU¶ PDQVDNH µUHL¶ 7DPSR. QR KL SRW KDYHU GXHV YR.DOV VHJXLGHV UH.RUGHP TXH OHV JUDILHV GH YR.DOV VHJXLGHVLJXDOVLQGLTXHQYR.DOVOODUJXHVQRGXHVYR.DOV
  86. 86. +LKDDOJXQV.DVRVH[.HS.LRQDOVGHPRWVTXH.RPHQ.HQSHUYR.DOLTXHSRGHQ D.DEDU HQ .RQVRQDQW
  87. 87. (V WUD.WD JHQHUDOPHQW GH SURQRPV SHUVRQDOV L GH SUpVWH.V *LULHUL3'
  88. 88. 6RQ D D µHOOHOOD¶ R µQRVDOWUHV¶ L µHOOVHOOHV¶ DQ µWX¶ LQ µPL¶
  89. 89. E $OD µ$OÂOj¶ DOLPDDPL µLPDP¶ DOLMXPD µGLYHQGUHV¶ 0DQ D D µHOO¶ L µWX¶ E $GDPD µ$GDP¶ RNXWRRED µR.WXEUH¶ DODKDGRR µGLXPHQJH¶ HNLVDDPRR µH[DPHQ¶ 7DPEpKLKDDOJXQVPRWVTXH.RPHQ.HQSHUXQD.RQVRQDQWSUHQDVDOLW]DGD*LULHU L3'
  90. 90. 6RQ QWD SDUWt.XODGH.RQMXJD.Ly
  91. 91. QGD SDUWt.XODGH.RQMXJD.Ly
  92. 92. QED VDOXWD.Ly
  93. 93. 0DQ QGHPRR µyV¶ QWHOX µQRVDOWUHV¶ QQD µPHX¶ /¶HVWUX.WXUD VLOÂOjEL.D GHO VRQLQNp L OD GHO PDQGLQJD TXH EjVL.DPHQW VHJXHL[ O¶HVTXHPD99.RQWUDVWHQ.ODUDPHQWDPEOHVSRVVLELOWDWVGHODVtOÂODED.DWDODQD.RP HVSRWYHXUHHQO¶H[HPSOHVHJHQW
  94. 94. EUDo E5iV@ VHUSV VpUSV@ 3HS S(qS@ SODWV SOiWV@ IRV. IyVN@ SUH.V S5pNV@ SOD SOi@
  95. 95. DSGHOHVVHTqQ.LHVGH
  96. 96. QRVHULDSRVVLEOHHQVRQLQNpQLHQPDQGLQJDeVSHUDL[z TXH DTXHVWV SDUODQWV VRYLQW VLPSOLILTXHQ OHV VtOÂODEHV GH OHV SDUDXOHV .DWDODQHV R Ep HOLGLQW.RQVRQDQWVREpLQVHULQWXQDYR.DOHQWUHGXHV.RQVRQDQWV
  97. 97. D PD±GULG o PD±Gt SD±OD±EURWHV o SD±OD±ER±WHV GLV±IUH±VVDW o GL±IH±VVDW GHV±SUpV o GH±Sp E P¶D±JUD±GD o PD±JD±UD±GD VyQ o VR±QR (/(0(1766835$6(*0(17$/6(/72,/¶$(17 (Q OD ELEOLRJUDILD TXH KHP SRJXW .RQVXOWDU VREUH DTXHVWHV OOHQJHV WUREHP LQIRUPD.Ly .RQWUDGL.WzULD VREUH O¶H[LVWqQ.LD GHO WR (Q OHV OOHQJHV .ODUDPHQW WRQDOV .RP HO [LQqV .DGD VtOÂODED Wp XQD HQWRQD.Ly SDUWL.XODU $OJXQV DXWRUV .RP UHLVVHOV .RPXQL.D.LySHUVRQDO
  98. 98. VRVWHQHQTXHWRWHVOHVOOHQJHVPDQGpVyQOOHQJHVWRQDOVSHUz HQVRQLQNpLHQPDQGLQJDHOWRWpXQSDSHUXQDPL.DGLIHUHQWGHOTXHWpHQOOHQJHV.RP HO [LQqV 6L Ep HQ [LQqV HO WR Wp YDORU .RQWUDVWLX GXHV SDUDXOHV HV SRGHQ GLIHUHQ.LDU QRPpV SHO WR GH OHV VHYHV VtOÂODEHV
  99. 99. HQ DTXHVWHV OOHQJHV PDQGp HO WR JHQHUDOPHQW QR DIH.WD HO VLJQLIL.DW GH OHV SDUDXOHV SUHVHV DwOODGDPHQW (Q DTXHVW SHWLW HVWXGL QR $TXHVWHV PDWHL[HV UHVWUL..LRQV HQ O¶HVWUX.WXUD VLOÂOjEL.D GHO VRQLQNp L GHO PDQGLQJD H[SOLTXHQ OHV DGDSWD.LRQVGHOVSUpVWH.VDJDIDWVG¶DOWUHVOOHQJHV.RPHOIUDQ.qV 6RQ JR±IH±UH±QD±PD µJR±YHU±QH±PHQW¶ µJRYHUQ¶
  100. 100. SH±UH±VL±GD µSUH±VL±GHQW¶ ¶SUHVLGHQW¶
  101. 101. PL±QL±VL±WLL±UL µPL±QLV±WUH¶ µPLQLVWUH¶
  102. 102. EX±OD µEOHX¶ µEODX¶
  103. 103. 0DQ SH±UH±VL±GD±1R µSUH±VL±GHQW¶ µSUHVLGHQW¶
  104. 104. PD±UL±VHH µPDU±.Kp¶ µPHU.DW¶
  105. 105. WD±EX±ORR µWD±EOH¶ µWDXOD¶
  106. 106. EX±OXX µEOHX¶ µEODX¶
  107. 107. 'UHLVVHOVHQVKDSURSRU.LRQDWDOJXQVH[HPSOHVGHOPDQGLQJDHQTXqHOWRWpYDORU.RQWUDVWLXWRWLTXH QRSDVVDJDLUHVYHJDGHV 0DQ EDD WRDOW
  108. 108. µULX¶ EDD WREDL[
  109. 109. µ.DEUD¶ VLL WRDOW
  110. 110. µDUULEDU¶ VLL WREDL[
  111. 111. µDVVHXUH¶V¶
  112. 112. HQWUDUHPHQDTXHVWDTHVWLyLQRPDU.DUHPHOVWRQV3HOTXHIDDO¶D..HQWV¶KDGLWTXHHO PDQGLQJDVROWHQLUXQD..HQWGqELODO¶~OWLPDVtOÂODEDGHOPRW 025)2/2*,$ /(63$576'(/¶25$,Ï /HVSDUWVGHO¶RUD.LyHQVRQLQNpLHQPDQGLQJDQRVyQVXEVWDQ.LDOPHQWGLIHUHQWV GHOHVTXHWUREHPHQ.DWDOjQRPVYHUEVDGMH.WLXVSURQRPVDGYHUELV.RQMXQ.LRQVL LQWHUMH..LRQVSHUzQRH[LVWHL[O¶DUWL.OHRPYHXUHPDO¶DSDUWDWGHODPRUIRORJLDYHUEDO HO YHUE Wp XQHV .DUD.WHUtVWLTXHV GLIHUHQWV GH OHV GHOV YHUEV .DWDODQV JDLUHEp QR WHQHQ IOH[Ly L DTXHVWD HV UHDOLW]D D WUDYpV G¶XQHV SDUWt.XOHV DQRPHQDGHV SUHGL.DWLXV 7DPEp H[LVWHL[HQSDUWt.XOHVLQWHUURJDWLYHV3HOTXHIDDOHVSUHSRVL.LRQVVLEpHOVRQLQNpHQWp DOJXQHVHQWRWHVGXHVOOHQJHVVyQPROW PpVIUHTHQWVOHVSRVWSRVL.LRQVTXHVyQXQV HOHPHQWV HTXLYDOHQWV D OHV QRVWUHV SUHSRVL.LRQV SHUz TXH HV .ROÂORTXHQ GHVSUpV GHO VLQWDJPDQRPLQDOHQOOR.GHVLWXDUVHDEDQVeV.RPVLHQ.DWDOjGLJXpVVLPDTXHOODPL. DPE HQ OOR. GH GLU DPE DTXHOO DPL. 3DUODUHP G¶DTXHVWV WLSXV GH PRWV D O¶DSDUWDW GH VLQWD[L 5HPDUTXHPTXHHQPDQGLQJDHOVDGMH.WLXVTXDOLIL.DWLXVVyQGLIt.LOVGHGHOLPLWDULGHGLVWLQJLUG¶DOWUHV .DWHJRULHV.RPHOVQRPVLHOVYHUEV+LKDSRTXHVDUUHOVTXHVLJXLQ.ODUDPHQWDGMH.WLYHVHQODPDMRULD GHOV.DVRVHVQH.HVVLWHQPRUIHPHVGHGHULYD.LySHU.RQVWUXLUXQDGMH.WLXYJUHLVVHOV
  113. 113. $PpV VROHQWHQLUGLYHUVHVIRUPHVGHSHQHQWGHODSRVL.LyHQTXqDSDUHL[HQ3*
  114. 114. L
  115. 115. fL1PXEHWHPDDOHWL µ$TXHVWpVXQGHER¶ LL
  116. 116. fL1EXNRRPD1EHWHDD µ$TXHVWOOLEUHQRpVER¶ LLL
  117. 117. fL1EXNRREHEHWHDDUL1QH µ$TXHVWOOLEUHpVERHQDTXHVWPRPHQW
  118. 118. ¶ LY
  119. 119. fL1EXNRRPXEHWHDDULÚROHWL µ$TXHVWOOLEUHpVXQGHER¶ Y
  120. 120. fL1EXNRREHWHDDWDOH µ$TXHVWOOLEUHpVER¶ YL
  121. 121. fL1PXEXNXEHWRROHWL µ$TXHVWpVXQOOLEUHER¶
  122. 122. /$)/(;,Ï /DIOH[LyQRPLQDO /DIOH[LyQRPLQDOHQVRQLQNpLHQPDQGLQJD.RPHQ.DWDOjDIH.WDHOVQRPVLHOV DGMH.WLXV *qQHUH (Q VRQLQNp L HQ PDQGLQJD QR KL KD GLVWLQ.Ly GH JqQHUH 7DPSR. QR KL KD PDUTXHVTXHLQGLTXLQ.ODVVHGHQRPDGLIHUqQ.LDGHOTXHSDVVDDPROWHVOOHQJHVYHwQHV TXHQRVyQGHOJUXSPDQGpIXODZzORI
  123. 123. $TXHVWD.DUD.WHUtVWL.DH[SOL.DSDU.LDOPHQWOHV GLIL.XOWDWV G¶DTXHVWV SDUODQWV D O¶KRUD G¶DVVLJQDU JqQHUH DOV QRPV .DWDODQV L GH IHU OD .RQ.RUGDQoDDPEHOVGHWHUPLQDQWVLHOVDGMH.WLXV
  124. 124. D HOPj IHPoPDV. HOVRUHOOHV HO.DSXW[HWDYHUPHOOD HOPHX.RVLQD HOQRVWUHUHOLJLy XQUHJDGRUD DTXHVW
  125. 125. pVOD-DZD .DPLVHWDEODX IHPSOjVWL.µSOjVWL.D¶
  126. 126. E ODWLPEUH PDV.oIHP OD.DVDPHQW ODPHYDLGLRPD ODPHXVDPL.V XQD.RW[H ODPHYDSDUH DTXHVWDQHQ
  127. 127. $OJXQV G¶DTXHVWV HUURUV GHQRWHQ TXH HO SDUODQW MD KD .RPHQoDW D DGTXLULU OD UHJOD PRUIROzJL.DGHIRUPD.LyGHOIHPHQtpVDGLUUH.RQHL[XQDYR.DOQHXWUDILQDO.RPXQD PDU.DGHIHPHQtLUHOD.LRQDXQILQDOHQR@DPEXQPDV.XOtSRWVHUSHU.RQWD.WHDPEHO .DVWHOOj
  128. 128. eVSHUDL[zTXHDOJXQV.RQVLGHUHQLGLRPDWLPEUH.RW[H.RPDQRPVIHPHQLQV LUHOLJLy.RPDPDV.XOt 1RPEUH 7DQW HQ VRQLQNp .RP HQ PDQGLQJD H[LVWHL[ OD GLVWLQ.Ly VLQJXODU SOXUDO (Q VRQLQNpKLKDWUHVVLVWHPHVSHUIRUPDUHOSOXUDOSHUzQRKLKD.DSUHJODSUH.LVDSHUVDEHU GHTXLQDPDQHUDHVIRUPDHOSOXUDOG¶XQDSDUDXOD*LULHU
  129. 129. D
  130. 130. .DQYLGHODYR.DOILQDOSHUX
  131. 131. VXJR µ.DEUD¶ VXJX µ.DEUHV¶ D[DUH µGRQD¶ D[DUX µGRQHV¶ UHQPH µQHQ¶ UHQPX µQHQV¶ E
  132. 132. .DQYLGHODYR.DOILQDOSHUR
  133. 133. MD[H µ[DL¶ MD[R µ[DLV¶ PDOOD µVHUS¶ PDOOR µVHUSV¶ UD[H µOOR.¶ UD[R µOOR.V¶ .
  134. 134. DIHJLQWQXDOILQDOPRQRVtOÂODEVSUpVWH.VQRPVGHIDPtOLDLDOWUHV
  135. 135. 4XDQHVWUD.WD GHPRWVPRQRVtOÂODEVODYR.DOHVIDOODUJD
  136. 136. D WH µ.DPS¶ WHHQX µ.DPSV¶ IR µ.RVD¶ IRRQX µ.RVHV¶ VL µ.DYDOO¶ VLLQX µ.DYDOOV¶ 8Q.DV.XULyVTXHHVUHOD.LRQDDPEO¶DVVLJQD.LyGHJqQHUHDOVQRPVpVHOGHOSDUODQWTXHGLX .DVWHOOyHQ OOR.GH.DVWHOOjSHUIHUUHIHUqQ.LDDODOOHQJXD.DVWHOODQDVLpVXQQRPPDV.XOtKDG¶D.DEDUHQR@LQRHQ D@
  137. 137. E ODQSD µOjPSDUD¶ ODQSDQX µOjPSDUHV¶ 7XXUH µ7XUH¶ 7XXUHQX µHOV7XUH¶ EDDL µWLD¶ EDDLQX µWLHV¶ (QPDQGLQJDODPDU.DGHSOXUDOpVOX*HQHUDOPHQWDSDUHL[TXDQHOQRPHVWj HQ IRUPD GHILQLGD YJ O¶DSDUWDW VHJHQW
  138. 138. L VHJXHL[ HO PRUIHPD GH GHILQLWXG 3*
  139. 139. NDODD µHOOODSLV¶ NDODDOX µHOVOODSLV¶ PRWRR µHOYHKL.OH¶ PRWRROX µHOVYHKL.OHV¶ 4XDQ HOV SDUODQWV GHO VRQLQNp L HOV GHO PDQGLQJD SDUOHQ .DWDOj VRYLQW WHQHQ SUREOHPHV SHU DIHJLU HO PRUIHPD GH SOXUDO D WRWV HOV HOHPHQWV TXH O¶KDXULHQ GH WHQLU $TXHVW HUURU VHPEOD PpV IUHTHQW HQ HOV SDUODQWV VRQLQNpV TXH HQ HOV PDQGLQJXHV SRWVHUSHUTXqHQPDQGLQJDVHPSUHV¶DIHJHL[XQVXIL[LHQVRQLQNpJHQHUDOPHQWHOSOXUDO HVPDU.DQRPpVDPEXQ.DQYLGHYR.DO
  140. 140. 6RQ XQ.RQ.XUV@GHSDVWtV OHVSDWDWD HOVPXVXOPDQ XQHV.RVDYHUPHOOHV VXUWHQGHODSDWDWHV OHVPHYDDPLJXHV@ XQDQLPDOV PROWSROL.LHV IDPROWHVEDUDOOD 0DQ QHQSHWLWV HOPHXVDEDWHV
  141. 141. 'HILQLWXG 7DQWHQVRQLQNp.RPHQPDQGLQJDH[LVWHL[ODGLVWLQ.LyGHILQLWLQGHILQLWHQHOV QRPV/DIRUPDLQGHILQLGDWpXQDLQWHUSUHWD.LyQRUHIHUHQ.LDOL.RUUHVSRQDXQSDUWLWLX PHQMD IRUPDWJH
  142. 142. OD GHILQLGD HQ .DQYL pV UHIHUHQ.LDO L .RUUHVSRQ DO QRVWUH GHILQLW R LQGHILQLW PHQMD HOXQ IRUPDWJH
  143. 143. /D IRUPD GHILQLGD pV PROW PpV IUHTHQW TXH OD LQGHILQLGDLHQPDQGLQJDpVODIRUPDTXHHVIDVHUYLUSHUUHIHULUVHDODSDUDXOD (QVRQLQNpODIRUPDGHILQLGDHVIRUPDDIHJLQWQDOILQDO6LHOQRPpVSOXUDOHO PRUIHPDGHGHILQLWXGDSDUHL[GHVSUpVGHOPRUIHPDGHQRPEUH*LULHU
  144. 144. 1GD PDDUR LJD MR35(' DUUzV PHQMDU µ+HPHQMDWDUUzV¶ 1GDPDDURQ LJD MR35('DUUzV'() PHQMDU µ+HPHQMDWO¶DUUzV¶
  145. 145. D VXJR µ.DEUD¶ VXJRQ µODXQD.DEUD¶ VXJX µ.DEUHV¶ VXJXQ µOHVXQHV.DEUHV¶ E QRTTX µOOR.¶ QRTTXQ µHOXQOOR.¶ QRTTXQX µOOR.V¶ QRTTXQXQ µHOVXQVOOR.V¶ (QPDQGLQJDODQR.LyGHGHILQLWXGV¶H[SUHVVDDPEHOVXIL[RDIHJLWDODIRUPD LQGHILQLGD6RYLQWDTXHVWPRUIHPDRHVIRQDPEODYR.DODQWHULRULGyQDXQDROODUJD RRHQODJUDILDKDELWXDO
  146. 146. UHLVVHOV
  147. 147. PXVX µGRQD¶ PXVRR µODXQDGRQD¶ NXOX1 µYDL[HOO¶ NXOX1R µHOXQYDL[HOO¶ $
  148. 148. H[HPSOLILTXHP OD GLIHUqQ.LD HQWUH HO YDORU GH OD IRUPD GHILQLGD L HO GH OD LQGHILQLGDTXHVRODSDUqL[HUHQ.RQVWUX..LRQVQHJDWLYHVUHLVVHOV
  149. 149. D 0XURRWHMD1 JDQLYHW'()35('1(*DTXt µ$TXtQRKLKDHOJDQLYHW(OJDQLYHWQRpVDTXt¶ E 0XUXWHMD1 JDQLYHW35('1(*DTXt µ$TXtQRKLKD.DSJDQLYHW¶ 4XDQ HO QRP pV SOXUDO D GLIHUqQ.LD GHO TXH SDVVD HQ VRQLQNp HO PRUIHPD GH SOXUDODSDUHL[GHVSUpVGHOGHGHILQLWXGUHLVVHOV
  150. 150. PXVRR µODGRQD¶ PXVRROX µOHVGRQHV¶ OXQWD1R µO¶HVWUDQJHU¶ OXQWD1ROX µHOVHVWUDQJHUV¶ (OIHWTXHODGHILQLWXGHVPDUTXLDPEXQVXIL[DIHJLWDOQRPLQR.RUUHVSRQJXLD XQDSHoDOq[L.DLQGHSHQGHQWXQDUWL.OH
  151. 151. HVSRWUHOD.LRQDUDPEHOIHWTXHVRYLQWDTXHVWV SDUODQWVHOLGHL[LQO¶DUWL.OHTXDQSDUOHQHQ.DWDOj
  152. 152. P¶DJUDGD‡KDPEOXJXHVDDPESDWDWD DPLQRP¶DJUDGD‡SRU. RQVyQ@D‡SDWL DL[zYDD‡.DUSHWD ‡PHXSDUHWDPEpWpXQ.DYDOO /DIRUPDUHGXwGD (QVRQLQNpKLKDXQDIRUPDHVSH.tIL.DLLQYDULDEOHGHOVQRPVTXHHVIDVHUYLUHQ OD.RPSRVL.LyLTXDQHOQRPYDVHJXLWG¶XQDGMH.WLX(QJHQHUDOSUHVHQWDXQDDOWHUD.LyD O¶~OWLPDVtOÂODEDUHVSH.WHGHODIRUPDQRUHGXwGDD
  153. 153. HQSUHVHQWHPDOJXQVH[HPSOHV *LULHU
  154. 154. (QPDQGLQJDQRKLKDXQPRWHTXLYDOHQWDO¶LQGHILQLW.DS(OVHQWLWV¶REWp.RPELQDQWODIRUPDLQGHILQLGD GHOQRPDPEXQSUHGL.DWLXQHJDWLX
  155. 155. GHEHµSREOH¶JXPHµUHSRQVDEOH¶ GHELJXPH µ.DSGHOSREOH¶ VDUHµSHUVRQD¶[XOOH µEODQ.¶ VDUD[XOOH µSHUVRQDEODQ.D¶ UHQPH µQHQ¶XJRµPDV.OH¶ UHQXJR µILOO¶ XJRµKRPH¶[DVHµYHOO¶ XJX[DVH µDQ.Lj¶ (Q PDQGLQJDHQ.DQYL HOQRPDSDUHL[VLPSOHPHQW HQODIRUPDLQGHILQLGDQR HQ XQD IRUPDUHGXwGDHVSH.LDO3*
  156. 156. VDORRµHOSRQW¶NRWRRµYHOO¶ VDODNRWRR µHOSRQWYHOO¶ EXNRRµHOOOLEUH¶NXWRRµQRX¶ EXNXNXWRR µHOOOLEUHQRX¶ (Q DTXHVWHV .RQVWUX..LRQV OHV PDUTXHV GH GHILQLWXG L GH QRPEUH QRPpV DSDUHL[HQDOILQDODGMXQWDGHVDO¶DGMH.WLX /DIOH[LyG¶DOJXQHVIRUPHVSURQRPLQDOVLDGMH.WLYHV 3URQRPVSHUVRQDOVLSRVVHVVLXV (OV SURQRPV SHUVRQDOV GHO PDQGLQJD L HOV GHO VRQLQNp JHQHUDOPHQW QR YDULHQ VHJRQVODIXQ.LyVLQWj.WL.DTXHID.LQGLQWUHGHODIUDVH.I7XPLUHVODQHQDYV/DQHQD HWPLUD
  157. 157. /DGLIHUqQ.LDGHIXQ.LyHVGHGXHL[GHODSRVL.LyTXHR.XSHQ$L[tHOVXEMH.WH DSDUHL[GDYDQWGHWRWGHODIUDVHLO¶REMH.WHLPPHGLDWDPHQWDEDQVGHOYHUE(QVRQLQNp SHUzVtTXHKLKDXQHVIRUPHVHVSH.tILTXHVSHUDOVXEMH.WHLXQHVSHUDO¶REMH.WHGHOD SULPHUD SHUVRQD GHO VLQJXODU L SHU D OD WHU.HUD SHUVRQD GHO VLQJXODU UHIOH[LYD *LULHU L3*
  158. 158. (O PDQGLQJD D GLIHUqQ.LD GHO VRQLQNp Wp XQ SDUDGLJPD GH SURQRPV SHUVRQDOV HPIjWL.V
  159. 159. 6RQ 0DQ 0DQHPI
  160. 160. DVJ QLQREMH.WH
  161. 161. Q QWH DVJ DQ L LWH DVJ DLREMUHIOH[LX
  162. 162. D DWH DSO R 1 QWHOX DSO [D DOL DOLWHOX DSO L L LWHOX /HV IRUPHV HPIjWLTXHV GHO VRQLQNp HV IRUPHQ DIHJLQW HO GHPRVWUDWLX NHNX GDUUHUHGHOSURQRPSHUVRQDO*LULHU
  163. 163. QNH µMRPDWHL[¶ RNX µQRVDOWUHVPDWHL[RV¶ (OIHWTXHDTXHVWHVOOHQJHVQRWLQJXLQXQVHOHPHQWVSURQRPLQDOV.RUUHVSRQHQWV DOV QRVWUHV SURQRPV IHEOHV DPE IRUPHV GLIHUHQWV VHJRQV OD IXQ.Ly VLQWj.WL.D HV SRW UHOD.LRQDUDPEDOJXQVGHOVHUURUVTXHHVWUREHQHQHOVHX.DWDOj3HOTXHIDDOVSURQRPV SHUVRQDOVGH.RPSOHPHQWGLUH.WHLGH.RPSOHPHQWLQGLUH.WHGHYHJDGHVQRDSDUHL[HQL GHYHJDGHVDSDUHL[HQHQXQDIRUPDLQ.RUUH.WD
  164. 164. P¶DJUDGDYDGRQDU‡IXOOHV OLo‡ VLQSRVDU‡DO¶ROODHOVPD.DUURQV@ ORVo‡ O¶KHWLUDWXQDSHGUD OLoHO LDSpVO¶DOWUHOLWR.D HOoOL (OVSURQRPVHQLKLWHQGHL[HQDGHVDSDUqL[HU
  165. 165. MRQR‡WLQ. HQo‡ ‡KLKDXQPpVJUDQ HQo‡ ODPHYDJHUPDQDVtTXH‡KDDQDW KLo‡ GHVSUpVVH‡SRVD.RPXQDDLJXD KLo‡
  166. 166. (QDTXHVWHVGXHVOOHQJHVH[LVWHL[HQXQHVIRUPHVSURQRPLQDOVUHIOH[LYHVLQL SHU D OD SULPHUD L OD WHU.HUD SHUVRQD VLQJXODU HQ VRQLQNp L Q L SHU D OD SULPHUD GHO VLQJXODULSHUDWRWHVOHVDOWUHVHQPDQGLQJD1RREVWDQWO¶H[LVWqQ.LDG¶DTXHVWHVIRUPHV HOVSDUODQWVG¶DTXHVWHVOOHQJHVVRYLQWXVHQLQ.RUUH.WDPHQWHOVSURQRPV.DWDODQVSHUTXq QRVHPSUHKLKD.RUUHVSRQGqQ.LDHQWUHHOVYHUEVTXHVyQSURQRPLQDOVHQ.DWDOjLHOVTXH KR VyQ HQ VRQLQNp R HQ PDQGLQJD $L[t HQ PDQGLQJD SHU H[HPSOH YHUEV .RP MXUDU GHL[DU GH
  167. 167. R UHIXVDU V¶XVHQ SURQRPLQDOPHQW .RP HV YHX HQ HOV H[HPSOHV GH
  168. 168. UHLVVHOV
  169. 169. D .DPEDDQRRHLNDOLLNDWRRxDDIRQH QRL(0)5()MXUDU35('YHULWDWGLUMRD µ(OQRLKDMXUDW³V¶KDMXUDW´
  170. 170. GHGLUPHODYHULWDW¶ E -DPPRROXHLGDKDDxRRVHQRROD G¶DTXtJHQW(0)5()D.DEDUPLOO.RQUHDU'()35(' µ/DJHQWG¶DTXtKDGHL[DW³V¶KDGHL[DW´
  171. 171. GH.RQUHDUPLOO¶ . $HLED1 xL1GRRNXR NHOD HOO(0)5()UHIXVDUDTXHVWWUHEDOOIHU35(' µ+DUHIXVDW³V¶KDUHIXVDW´
  172. 172. GHIHUDTXHVWWUHEDOO¶ /D IRUPD SURQRPLQDO GHO PDQGLQJD WDPEp VHUYHL[ SHU LQWUDQVLWLYLW]DU YHUEV WUDQVLWLXV.RPHVYHXD
  173. 173. UHLVVHOV
  174. 174. D 6XQNXWRROXHOHQMH1RGR1 QRLHV(0)OHQMHQJ EDOODU µ/HVQRLHVKDQEDOODWHOOHQMHQJ¶ E 6XQNXWRROXHLGR1 QRLHV(0)5()EDOODU µ/HVQRLHVKDQEDOODW³V¶KDQEDOODW´
  175. 175. ¶ $
  176. 176. SUHVHQWHPDOJXQVH[HPSOHVG¶XVRVLQ.RUUH.WHVGHIRUPHVSURQRPLQDOVHQ ODSDUOD.DWDODQDRHQOD.DVWHOODQDGHSHUVRQHVGHOHV.RPXQLWDWVVRQLQNpRPDQGLQJD
  177. 177. D V¶KDSRUDWµKDSORUDW¶
  178. 178. ‡oVH ±LDPEO¶HVSDVDTXqID@ ±HVIDDL[zµIDDL[z¶
  179. 179. ‡oVH E ‡HVWDQDPDJDQWGHODVHQRUHWD VHo‡ ‡LEDQD.DVDU.DVW
  180. 180. VHo‡ (Q VRQLQNp HOV SURQRPV SHUVRQDOV VyQ HOV TXH VHUYHL[HQ SHU IHU OHV .RQVWUX..LRQVHQTXqQRVDOWUHVXVHPXQDGMH.WLXSRVVHVVLXTXHHQVRQLQNpQRH[LVWHL[HQ *LULHU
  181. 181. DDTTH HOOGRQD µODVHYDGRQD¶ QUHQPH MRQHQ µHOPHXQHQ¶ $O.RQWUDULGHOVRQLQNpHOPDQGLQJDWpXQSDUDGLJPDGHSURQRPVLG¶DGMH.WLXV SRVVHVVLXVTXHHVIRUPHQDIHJLQWHOVPRUIHPHVWDDRODDOSURQRPSHUVRQDO7DPEpKL KDODIRUPDHPIjWL.DTXH.RPHVSRWYHXUHHVIRUPDDIHJLQWODLWDDUHVSH.WLYDPHQWD OHV IRUPHV GHOV SURQRPV SHUVRQDOV HPIjWL.V WDD L OD VyQ PDUTXHV GH JHQLWLX .RPSOHPHQWGHOQRP
  182. 182. 3*
  183. 183. SURQRPV DGMH.WLXV QRHPI HPIjWL. QRHPI HPIjWL. QWDD QWHOD QQD QWHWDD µPHX¶ LWDD LWHOD LOD LWHWDD µWHX¶ DWDD DWHOD DOD DWHWDD µVHXG¶HOO
  184. 184. ¶ QWDD QWHOXOD xQD QWHOXWDD µQRVWUH¶ DOLWDD DOLWHOXOD DOLOD DOLWHOXWDD µYRVWUH¶ LWDD LWHOXOD LOD LWHOXWDD µVHXG¶HOOV
  185. 185.
  186. 186. D fL1PXVXZDDURR PXQWDDOHWL DTXHVWPR.DGRU'()35('32663$57 µ$TXHVWPR.DGRUpVPHX¶
  187. 187. E fL1PXQQDNDODDOHWL DTXHVW35('3266OODSLV 3$57 µ$TXHVWpVHOPHXOODSLV¶ (Q PDQGLQJD HV ID VHUYLU XQD .RQVWUX..Ly HTXLYDOHQW D OD GHO VRQLQNp DPE HO SURQRP SHUVRQDO HQ OOR. GHO SRVVHVVLX TXDQ DTXHVW HOHPHQW PRGLIL.D XQ QRP TXH GHQRWDXQDSDUWGHO.RVRXQDUHOD.LyHVWUHWDGHSDUHQWLX3*
  188. 188. QNXQVXxRR MR.DEHOO µHOPHX.DEHOO¶ QGL1R MRILOO µHOPHXILOO¶ 7RUQDUHPDSDUODUG¶DTXHVWDTHVWLyDO¶DSDUWDW 'HPRVWUDWLXV (OVRQLQNpWpWUHVIRUPHVGLIHUHQWVSHUDOVGHPRVWUDWLXVTXHSRGUtHP.RPSDUDUD DTXHVWDTXHL[DTXHOOGHOVGLDOH.WHVGHO.DWDOjTXHPDQWHQHQODVHJRQDIRUPDRDHVWH HVHDTXHOGHO.DVWHOOjWRWLTXHHOVVHXVXVRVQRVyQLGqQWL.V/HVIRUPHVGHOVRQLQNp VyQOHVVHJHQWV'LDJDQD
  189. 189. VLQJXODU NH NHQ NLWHHUH SOXUDO NX NXQ NLWXXUX (Q PDQGLQJD QRPpV HV GLVWLQJHL[HQ GXHV IRUPHV OD SULPHUD HV ID VHUYLU SHU LQGL.DU XQ HOHPHQW SURSHU HQ XQD VLWXD.Ly DTXHVW QHQ G¶DTXt
  190. 190. L OD VHJRQD Wp HO VHX UHIHUHQWHQHOGLV.XUVDTXHVWHOQHQGHTXLD.DEHPGHSDUODU
  191. 191. UHLVVHOV
  192. 192. (Q VRQLQNp pV IUHTHQW TXH HO GHPRVWUDWLX NH DSDUHJXL GDUUHUH GHO QRP IRUoDQW XQD LQWHUSUHWD.Ly GHILQLGDHQ.DUDTXHHOQRPQRWLQJXLPRUIHPDGHGHILQLWXG'LDJDQD
  193. 193. L
  194. 194. /HPXQXQVXULxD[DNH QHQV'() WRWV YHQLUIHVWD'(0 µ7RWVHOVQHQVKDQYLQJXWDODIHVWDDTXHVWD
  195. 195.
  196. 196. xL1 µDTXHVW¶ xLQQX µDTXHVWV¶ ZRZRR µDTXHOO¶ ZROX µDTXHOOV¶ 4XDQDTXHVWVGHPRVWUDWLXVIXQ.LRQHQ.RPDDGMH.WLXVTXHGHWHUPLQHQXQQRPHQ SOXUDOHQPDQGLQJDODPDU.DGHSOXUDOQRPpVDSDUHL[HQHOQRPDOILQDOGHOVLQWDJPD HQ .DQYL HQ VRQLQNp WHQHQ IRUPD SOXUDO WDQW HO QRP .RP HO GHPRVWUDWLX 3* L *LULHU
  197. 197. 0DQ ZRR PRR ZRRPRROX DTXHOOSHUVRQD DTXHOOSHUVRQHV µDTXHOODSHUVRQD¶ µDTXHOOHVSHUVRQHV¶ 6RQ NHXJR NXXJX DTXHOOKRPH DTXHOOVKRPHV µDTXHOOKRPH¶ µDTXHOOVKRPHV¶ (Q VRQLQNp HOV QRPV QR HV IDQ VHUYLU HQ OD IRUPD GHILQLGD TXDQ YDQ D.RPSDQDWVG¶XQGHPRVWUDWLX*LULHU
  198. 198. .HXJR XJRQEDJX DTXHVWKRPHKRPH'()VRUWLU µ$TXHVWKRPHKDVRUWLW¶ (QPDQGLQJDHQ.DQYLHOQRPDSDUHL[HQODIRUPDGHILQLGDUHLVVHOV
  199. 199. xL1PXURR xL1GLQGL1ROX DTXHVWJDQLYHW'() DTXHVWQHQ'()3/ µDTXHVWJDQLYHW¶ µDTXHVWVQHQV¶
  200. 200. 1XPHUDOV Els pronoms numerals són els que apareixen a (45) (Girier, 1996: 81-82 i PCG: 37):
  201. 201. 6RQ 0DQ 6RQ 0DQ EDDQH NLOL1 WDQILOOH PXZD1 ILOOR IXOD WDQMLNNH WD1VDED VLNNR VDED WDQQD[DWH WD1QDDQL QD[DWR QDDQL WDQNDUDJH WD1OXXOX NDUDJR OXXOX NDPH NHPHNLOL1
  202. 202. WXPX ZRRUR xHUX ZRURZXOD VHJX VHVDL NDEX NRQRQWR WDQPX WD1 WDQPXGREDDQHWD1QL1NLOL1 WDQPXGRILOOR WDQQL1IXOD (OV DGMH.WLXV QXPHUDOV YDQ GDUUHUH GHO QRP L VyQ .RP HOV SURQRPV SHUz HQ VRQLQNpSUHQHQODWHUPLQD.LyLH[.HSWHEDDQHµXQ¶TXHQRYDULD
  203. 203. (QPDQGLQJDQRV¶KL DIHJHL[.DSSDUWt.XOD*LULHUL3*
  204. 204. 6RQ VLNNR
  205. 205. QDDQXVLNNL YDTXHVWUHV µWUHVYDTXHV¶ WXPX
  206. 206. ZXOOXWXPL JRVVRVVLV µVLVJRVVRV¶ EDDQH
  207. 207. XJXEDDQH KRPHXQ µXQKRPH¶ 0DQ VDED
  208. 208. VXXVDED .DYDOOWUHV µWUHV.DYDOOV¶ OXXOX
  209. 209. PRROXXOX SHUVRQD.LQ. µ.LQ.SHUVRQHV¶ NLOL1
  210. 210. PRRNLOL1 SHUVRQDXQ µXQDSHUVRQD¶ RPHVSRWYHXUHD
  211. 211. HQVRQLQNpHOQRPWpPDU.DGHSOXUDOTXDQHOQXPHUDO QRpVXQ SHUz HQ PDQGLQJD HO QRP JHQHUDOPHQW.RQVHUYD OD IRUPD VLQJXODU WRW L TXH
  212. 212. WDPEpSRWDSDUqL[HUODPDU.DGHSOXUDODOILQDOGHVSUpVGHOQXPHUDORGDUUHUHGHOQRP YJ
  213. 213. 3HOTXHIDDODGHILQLWXGHOPDQGLQJDDIHJHL[HOVXIL[.RUUHVSRQHQWDOILQDO GHOVLQWDJPDLDEDQVGHTXDOVHYRO PDU.D GH SOXUDO SHUz VL HO QRP Wp PDU.D GH SOXUDO WDPEpHQWpGHGHILQLWXG(QVRQLQNpODPDU.DGHGHILQLWXGHV.ROÂOR.DDOILQDOGHOQRP GHVSUpV GHO PRUIHPD GH SOXUDO UHLVVHOV L 0 DPDUD .RPXQL.D.Ly SHUVRQDO
  214. 214. 0DQ GHQGLNDIXORR YHVWLWGRV'() µHOVGRVYHVWLWV¶ GHQGLNDIXORROX YHVWLWGRV'()3/ µHOVGRVYHVWLWV¶ GHQGLNRROXIXORR YHVWLW'()3/GRV'() µHOVGRVYHVWLWV¶ 6RQ QDQXQVLNNL YD.D3/'()WUHV µOHVWUHVYDTXHV¶ 3HO TXH ID DOV RUGLQDOV HQ VRQLQNp V¶DGMXQWD HO VXIL[ DQGL XQGL D OD IRUPD .DUGLQDOHQPDQGLQJDHOVXIL[pVQMDR*LULHUL3*
  215. 215. 6RQ ILOOR µGRV¶ ILOODQGL µVHJRQ¶ QD[DWR µTXDWUH¶ QD[DWDQGL µTXDUW¶ WXPX µVLV¶ WXPXQGL µVLVq¶ 0DQ IXOD µGRV¶ IXODQMD1R µVHJRQ¶ VDED µWUHV¶ VDEDQMD1R µWHU.HU¶ QDDQL µTXDWUH¶ QDDQQLQMD1R µTXDUW¶ 0RUIRORJLDYHUEDO (O YHUE WDO .RP O¶HQWHQHP QRVDOWUHV QR pV XQ HOHPHQW LPSUHV.LQGLEOH SHU D OD IUDVH HQ VRQLQNp L HQ PDQGLQJD +L KD IUDVHV VHQVH ³YHUE´ QRPLQDOV L DGMH.WLYDOV '¶DOWUDEDQGDOHVIRUPHVYHUEDOVPDQLIHVWHQPROWSRTXHVYDULD.LRQVIOH[LYHV/DIHLQD TXH HQ OHV QRVWUHV OOHQJHV IDQ HOV PRUIHPHV GH IOH[Ly DGMXQWDWV D O¶DUUHO YHUEDO HQ
  216. 216. VRQLQNpLHQPDQGLQJDODIDQXQHVSDUWt.XOHVJHQHUDOPHQWPRQRVLOÂOjELTXHVDQRPHQDGHV SUHGL.DWLXVTXHVyQLPSUHV.LQGLEOHVSHUDODIUDVH(QSDUODUHPPpVHQGDYDQW /HVIRUPHVYHUEDOVIRUPHVSHUIH.WLYHVLIRUPHVLPSHUIH.WLYHV (OV YHUEV GHO VRQLQNp WHQHQ GXHV IRUPHV YHUEDOV GLIHUHQWV XQD pV OD IRUPD SHUIH.WLYD TXH LQGL.D XQD D..Ly D.DEDGD L O¶DOWUD OD LPSHUIH.WLYD R GXUDWLYD TXH H[SUHVVD GXUD.Ly L LQGL.D XQD D..Ly LQD.DEDGD $TXHVWD HVWUDWqJLD QR V¶XWLOLW]D HQ PDQGLQJD HOV SUHGL.DWLXV PDWHL[RV D SDUW G¶LQGL.DU HO WHPSV DIHJHL[HQ OD QR.Ly G¶DVSH.WHSHUIH.WLXRD.DEDWLLPSHUIH.WLXRQRD.DEDW
  217. 217. DODIRUPDYHUEDO (Q VRQLQNp OD IRUPD LPSHUIH.WLYD HV GHULYD D SDUWLU GH OD SHUIH.WLYD GH GXHV PDQHUHVGLIHUHQWVGHSHQHQWGHOYHUE*LULHU
  218. 218. D
  219. 219. DIHJLQWKLXQDVtOÂODEDIRUPDGDSHUOD.RQVRQDQWQVHJXLGDGHODGDUUHUDYR.DOGH ODIRUPDSHUIH.WLYD
  220. 220. SHUIH.WLX LPSHUIH.WLX DQTD DQTDQD µEDL[DU¶ LJH LJHQH µPHQMDU¶ PLQL PLQLQL µEHXUH¶ E
  221. 221. DOWHUDQWODVtOÂODEDILQDOGHODIRUPDSHUIH.WLYDOD.RQVRQDQWHVGREODLODYR.DO ILQDOHV.DQYLDSHUODSHQ~OWLPDYR.DO
  222. 222. SHUIH.WLX LPSHUIH.WLX NDWX NDWWD µ.ROSLU¶ GHQL GHQQH µSRUWDU¶ 9HUEVWUDQVLWLXVLYHUEVLQWUDQVLWLXV (Q.DWDOjPROWHVYHJDGHVWHQLPODSRVVLELOLWDWGHIHUVHUYLUXQPDWHL[YHUE.RPD WUDQVLWLX L .RP D LQWUDQVLWLX DPE YDORU DEVROXW (O QHQ PHQMD SRPHV (O QHQ PHQMD
  223. 223. SHUz OD IRUPD YHUEDO QR YDULD (Q VRQLQNp HQ .DQYL DTXHVWHV GXHV SRVVLELOLWDWV .RUUHVSRQHQDGXHVIRUPHVYHUEDOVGLIHUHQWVTXHWDPEpHV.RQMXJXHQGHPDQHUDGLIHUHQW GRQHPODIRUPDSHUIH.WLYDLODLPSHUIH.WLYD
  224. 224. *LULHU
  225. 225. LQWUDQVLWLX WUDQVLWLX D LJHLJHQH LJDLJDQD µPHQMDU¶ GXJXQGLGXJXQGLQL GXJXGXNNX µHVSHUDU¶ VRUHVRUHQH VRURVRURQR µ.XLQDU¶ E PLQLPLQLQL PLQLPLQQL µEHXUH¶ WLILWLILQL WLILWLSSL µSODQWDU¶ 7RW L TXH D E
  226. 226. OD IRUPD SHUIH.WLYD WUDQVLWLYD L OD LQWUDQVLWLYD .RLQ.LGHL[HQ OHV LPSHUIH.WLYHVVyQGLIHUHQWV 3HO TXH ID DO PDQGLQJD HO VLVWHPD SHU LQWUDQVLWLYLW]DU XQ YHUE .RQVLVWHL[ D QRPLQDOLW]DUO¶DUUHOYHUEDODGMXQWDQWKLHOVXIL[ULPpVHOVPRUIHPHVGHIOH[LyQRPLQDO $TXHVW QRP GHULYDW GHO YHUE D.WXDUj .RP D .RPSOHPHQW GHO YHUE NH µIHU¶ UHLVVHOV
  227. 227. D .HRH PDDQRR GRPR KRPH35('DUUzVPHQMDU µ/¶KRPHPHQMDDUUzV¶ E .HRH GRPRURRNH KRPH35('PHQMDU68)'()IHU µ/¶KRPHKDPHQMDW³KDIHWXQDPHQMDGD´
  228. 228. ¶ $O¶DSDUWDWHQSDUODUGHOVUHIOH[LXVKHPIHWUHIHUqQ.LDDXQDDOWUDHVWUDWqJLD TXHIDVHUYLUHOPDQGLQJDSHULQWUDQVLWLYLW]DUYHUEV1RWHPTXHpVGLIt.LOWUREDUXQPRWLX TXH H[SOLTXL TXLQ GHOV GRV VLVWHPHV pV SURSL GH .DGD YHUE SHUTXq SHU D GRV YHUEV DSDUHQWPHQW WDQ VHPEODQWV .RP GRPR µPHQMDU¶ L PL µEHXUH¶ HV IDQ VHUYLU VLVWHPHV GLIHUHQWV6L.RPYqLHPD E
  229. 229. HOYHUEGRPRV¶LQWUDQVLWLYLW]DDPEOD IRUPDQRPLQDO GHOYHUESHUDPLHVIDVHUYLUOD.RQVWUX..LySURQRPLQDOUHLVVHOV
  230. 230. D .HRH MLRPL1 KRPH35('DLJXDEHXUH µ/¶KRPHKDEHJXWDLJXD¶ E .HRHLPL1 KRPH35('5()EHXUH µ/¶KRPHKDEHJXW³V¶KDEHJXW´
  231. 231. ¶ (OVSUHGL.DWLXV (O TXH V¶DQRPHQHQ SUHGL.DWLXV VyQ XQV HOHPHQWV TXH .RQWHQHQ LQIRUPD.Ly JUDPDWL.DO UHOD.LRQDGD DPE OD IOH[Ly GHO YHUE DVSH.WH WHPSV PRGH PRGDOLWDW HW.
  232. 232. SHUzTXHQRVyQDIL[RVTXHV¶DGMXQWHQDXQDDUUHOYHUEDO(VSRGULHQ.RPSDUDUDPEHOV DX[LOLDUVGHO¶DQJOqV
  233. 233. D ,ZLOOUHDG µMROOHJLUp¶ RXZLOOUHDG µWXOOHJLUjV¶ ZHZLOOUHDG µQRVDOWUHVOOHJLUHP¶ E ,ZRXOGUHDG µMROOHJLULD¶ RXZRXOGUHDG µWXOOHJLULHV¶ ZHZRXOGUHDG µQRVDOWUHVOOHJLUtHP¶ :LOOLZRXOGSHUH[HPSOHVyQPDUTXHVGHIXWXULGH.RQGL.LRQDOUHVSH.WLYDPHQWSHUz QR DSDUHL[HQ .RP D VXIL[RV XQLWV D O¶DUUHO .RP SDVVD HQ .DWDOj
  234. 234. VLQy .RP D IRUPHV LQGHSHQGHQWV RP YHXUHP TXH SDVVD HQ VRQLQNp L HQ PDQGLQJD DTXHVWV HOHPHQWV GH O¶DQJOqVWDPEpDGRSWHQIRUPHVGLIHUHQWVVLPpVQRHQODOOHQJXDRUDO
  235. 235. TXDQODIUDVHpV QHJDWLYDZRQ¶WZLOOQRW
  236. 236. LZRXOGQ¶WZRXOGQRW
  237. 237. RPKHPGLWDO.RPHQoDPHQWGHOOOLEUHKLKDXQD.HUWDLQWHU.RPSUHQVLyHQWUHOHV OOHQJHVGHOVXEJUXSPDQGLQJD.DXVDGHODVLPLOLWXGOq[L.D(OVHOHPHQWVTXHGLIL.XOWHQ PpV OD P~WXD .RPSUHQVLy HQWUH HOV SDUODQWV VyQ SUH.LVDPHQW HOV SUHGL.DWLXV TXH YDULHQ IRUoDGHOOHQJXDDOOHQJXDGHPDQHUDTXHXQDPDWHL[DIRUPDIRQqWL.DSRW.RUUHVSRQGUH DSUHGL.DWLXVTXHLQGLTXHQWHPSVLDVSH.WHGLIHUHQWVHQ.DGDXQDGHOHVGXHVOOHQJHV
  238. 238. 3UHGL.DWLXVGHIUDVHVQRPLQDOVLGHIUDVHVDGMH.WLYDOV 7DQWHQVRQLQNp.RPHQPDQGLQJDKLSRWKDYHUIUDVHVVHQVH.DSYHUE6yQIUDVHV TXHHQ.DWDOjHV.RQVWUXLULHQDPEHOVYHUEVVHURHVWDULXQDWULEXWQRPLQDORDGMH.WLYDOR XQ.RPSOHPHQWGHOOR.(QDTXHVWV.DVRVHQVRQLQNpLHQPDQGLQJDQRPpVKLDSDUHL[XQ SUHGL.DWLX VHQVH .DS IRUPD .RUUHVSRQHQW D XQ YHUE .RSXODWLX (OV SUHGL.DWLXV SRGHQ H[SUHVVDU WHPSV L PRGDOLWDW DILUPDWLYD QHJDWLYD L LQWHUURJDWLYD R HPIjWL.D
  239. 239. SHUz QR SHUVRQD (OV H[HPSOHV GH
  240. 240. L
  241. 241. .RUUHVSRQHQ D SUHGL.DWLXV GH IUDVHV QRPLQDOV LGHQWLIL.DWLYHVLOR.DWLYHVUHVSH.WLYDPHQW
  242. 242. LHOVGH
  243. 243. DIUDVHVDGMH.WLYDOV
  244. 244. )5$6(6120,1$/6,'(17,),$7,9(6*LULHULUHLVVHOV
  245. 245. 6RQ :XOOHQQL JRV 35('$) µeVXQJRV¶ :XOOHIH JRV 35('1(* µ1RpVXQJRV¶ 0DQQHQL TXq35('(0) µ4XqpV¶ 0DQ 1L1PRROXPXWLOLERQNRROXOHWL DTXHVWJHQW35('$)HVWJHQW(0)3267 µ$TXHVWDJHQWpVJHQWGHO¶HVW¶ :RWHVLLUD1RWL DTXHOO35('1(*YHULWDW3267 µ$L[zQRpVODYHULWDW¶
  246. 246. )5$6(6120,1$/6/2$7,9(626,78$,21$/6 *LULHULUHLVVHOV3*
  247. 247. 6RQ 1ZD %DPDNR MR35('$)%DPDNR µ-RVy.D%DPDNR¶ $QWD HUH HOO35('1(* DTXt µ(OOQRpVDTXt¶ 1QD%DPDNRD MR35('(0)%DPDNR(0) µ-RVy.D%DPDNR¶ 1xL 3DUL MRSUHG$) 3DUtV µ-RHUDD3DUtV¶ $PDxL GHEHQ1D HOO35('1(* SREOHD µ(OOQRHUDDOSREOH¶ $QxL PLQQD WX35('(0)RQ µ2QHUHVWX¶ 0DQ 'LQGL1ROXEHEX1RNRQR QHQV35('$).DVDD µ(OVQHQVVyQDOD.DVD¶ .DODDWH WDDEXORRND1 OODSLV35('1(*WDXODVREUH µ(OOODSLVQRpVVREUHODWDXOD¶
  248. 248. )5$6(6$'-(7,9$/6*LULHULUHLVVHOV.RPXQL.D.LySHUVRQDO
  249. 249. 6RQ XJRQJLOOHQQL KRPHJUDQ35('$) µ/¶KRPHpVJUDQ¶ 6DDMRJLOOHIH 6DGLRJUDQ35('1(* µ(Q6DGLRQRpVJUDQ¶ $JLOOHD QLED HOOJUDQ(0)35('(0),17 µeVJUDQHOO
  250. 250.
  251. 251. 0DQ fL1 VLQVL1RNRWRWD DTXHVW.LVWHOOYHOO35('$) µ$TXHVW.LVWHOOpVYHOO¶ fL1VLQVL1RPDQJNRWR DTXHVW.LVWHOO35('1(*YHOO µ$TXHVW.LVWHOOQRpVYHOO¶ 3UHGL.DWLXVGHYHUEV 4XDQ HQ VRQLQNp OD IUDVH .RQWp XQ YHUE HO SUHGL.DWLX D PpV GH OD PRGDOLWDW H[SUHVVD HO WHPSV L HO PRGH $OJXQV WHPSV GHPDQHQ OD IRUPD SHUIH.WLYD L G¶DOWUHV OD LPSHUIH.WLYD(OYHUEpVSUj.WL.DPHQW LQYDULDEOH HQ WRWHV OHV SHUVRQHV WHPSV L PRGHV (OV SUHGL.DWLXV VRYLQW WHQHQ IRUPHV GLIHUHQWV VHJRQV OD WUDQVLWLYLWDW GHO YHUE $ .RQWLQXD.Ly GRQHP DOJXQV H[HPSOHV GH SUHGL.DWLXV GH YHUEV LQWUDQVLWLXV L GH YHUEV WUDQVLWLXV
  252. 252. 9HUEVLQWUDQVLWLXVLQGL.DWLX
  253. 253. *LULHU
  254. 254. D $ZDULLQL SUHVHQWLPSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX HOO35('YHQLU µ(OOYH¶ $QWDULLQL SUHVHQWLPSHUIH.WLXQHJDWLX HOO35('YHQLU µ(OOQRYH¶ $WULLQLD SUHVHQWLPSHUIH.WLXHPIjWL. HOO35('YHQLU(0) µ(OOYH¶ E $WUL SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX HOO35('YHQLU µ(OOKDYLQJXW¶ $PDUL SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXQHJDWLX HOO35('YHQLU µ(OOQRKDYLQJXW¶
  255. 255. 'HQEDD Q UL SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXHPIjWL. 'HPED(0) 35(' YHQLU µ(Q'HPED KDYLQJXW¶ . $QDUL IXWXUSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX HOO35('YHQLU µ(OOYLQGUj¶ $QDULD IXWXUSHUIH.WLXHPIjWL. HOO35('YHQLU(0) µ(OOYLQGUjVHJXU¶
  256. 256. 9HUEVWUDQVLWLXVLQGL.DWLX
  257. 257. *LULHU
  258. 258. D $ZDPDDURQLJDQD SUHVHQWLPSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX HOO35('DUUzVPHQMDU µ(OOPHQMDO¶DUUzV¶ $QWDPDDURQLJDQD SUHVHQWLPSHUIH.WLXQHJDWLX HOO35('DUUzVPHQMDU µ(OOQRPHQMDO¶DUUzV¶ $QQDPDQQHGDEDULQL SUHVHQWLPSHUIH.WLXHPILQW WX35('TXqIHU µ4XqIDVWX
  259. 259. ¶ E 1GDLQIDDEDMDDEL SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX MR35('MRSDUHUHVSRQGUH µ-RKHUHVSRVWDOPHXSDUH¶ $PDWLHLJD SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXQHJDWLX HOO35('.DUQPHQMDU µ(OOQRKDPHQMDW.DUQ¶ $QGDPDQQHLJD SHUIHWSHUIH.WLXHPILQW WX35('TXq PHQMDU µ4XqKDVPHQMDWWX
  260. 260.
  261. 261. . 1QDDNDUL IXWXUSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX MR35('HOOPDWDU µ-RHOPDWDUp¶ $QQDPDQQHGDEDUL IXWXUSHUIH.WLXHPILQW WX35('TXqIHU µ4XqIDUjVWX
  262. 262. ¶ $.RQWLQXD.LyGRQHPDOJXQVH[HPSOHVGHSUHGL.DWLXVYHUEDOVHQPDQGLQJD
  263. 263. 9HUEVLQWUDQVLWLXV3*UHLVVHOV
  264. 264. D :LOONDWDD ELWLNRR SUHVHQWLPSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX :LOO35('DQDUERWLJD µ(Q:LOOYDDODERWLJD¶ :LOOEXNDWDDELWLNRR SUHVHQWLPSHUIH.WLXQHJDWLX :LOO35('DQDUERWLJD µ(Q:LOOQRYDDODERWLJD¶ E LURRERLWD SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX DUEUH.DXUH35(' µ/¶DUEUHKD.DLJXW¶ 0XVRROX PD1WDD SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXQHJDWLX GRQHV35(' PDU[DU µ/HVGRQHVQRKDQPDU[DW¶ (Q PDQGLQJD HO IXWXU LPPLQHQW V¶H[SUHVVD DPE HO SUHGL.DWLX GH VLWXD.Ly EH L HO PRUIHPD OD DGMXQWDW GDUUHUHO¶DUUHOYHUEDOUHLVVHOV
  265. 265. .RQVLGHUDTXH OD pVXQ VXIL[ ³WUDQVODWLX´ XQD PHQD GH PDU.D GH VXERUGLQD.Ly L HOV DXWRUV GH 3* KR WUD.WHQ .RP XQ SUHGL.DWLX HQ DTXHVW WUHEDOO HQ GLHP ³PRUIHPD´
  266. 266. L
  267. 267. 1EHxL1VXQNXWRRIXWXXOD MR35('DTXHVWQRLD.DVDUVHDPE 025) µ(P.DVDUpDPEDTXHVWDQRLD¶ HPYDLJD.DVDUHVWL.DSXQWGH.DVDUPH
  268. 268. 9HUEVWUDQVLWLXV3*UHLVVHOV
  269. 269. D )DDWX ND PDDQRR WXX SUHVHQWDILUPDWLX )DWX 35(' DUUzV PROGUH µ/D)DWXPRODUUzV¶ $ EXND PDDQRR WXX SUHVHQWQHJDWLX HOO 35(' DUUzV PROGUH µ(OOQRPRODUUzV¶ E .DPEDDQRROX H NXOX1R GDGDD SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXDILUPDWLX QRLV 35(' YDL[HOO IDEUL.DU µ(OVQRLVKDQIDEUL.DWXQYDL[HOO¶ 0XVRRPD1WDELURRNH SDVVDWSHUIH.WLXQHJDWLX GRQHV35('.XLQDIHU µ/HVGRQHVQRKDQ.XLQDW¶ RPV¶KDSRJXWREVHUYDUOHVIRUPHVYHUEDOVGHOVRQLQNpLOHVGHOPDQGLQJDQR PDQLIHVWHQ.DSPDU.DGHSHUVRQDQLDO¶DUUHOYHUEDOQLDOSUHGL.DWLX4XDQHOVSDUODQWV G¶DTXHVWHVOOHQJHVSDUOHQ.DWDOjPROWVRYLQWIDQHUURUVTXH.RQVLVWHL[HQDQRDGMXQWDU .DSPRUIHPDGHSHUVRQDDO¶DUUHOREpDDIHJLUKLXQPRUIHPDHTXLYR.DW
  270. 270. D SULPHU.XU‡QRVDOWUHV µ.RUUHP¶
  271. 271. HOVQHQVOLYDUH‡IHUPDO µYDUHQ¶
  272. 272. HOVQHQVHVWD‡MXJDQW µHVWDQ¶
  273. 273. MRHVWDYDPLUDQWOHVQHQHV.RP.DQWDYD‡ µ.DQWDYHQ¶
  274. 274. E O¶DOWUHTXHYDVQpL[HUDTXt µYDQpL[HU¶
  275. 275. DTXHVWDQHQDHVWDQ.RQWHQWHV µHVWj¶
  276. 276. HOQRVWUHUHOLJLyGLXHQ µGLX¶
  277. 277. ODVHQRUHWDGLJXHX µGLX¶
  278. 278. 3HO TXH ID DO WHPSV YHUEDO pV IUHTHQW O¶~V HUURQL GH OHV IRUPHV YHUEDOV .RPSRVWHVRSHULIUjVWLTXHVR Ep SHUTXq IDQ VHUYLU O¶DX[LOLDU HTXLYR.DW R Ep SHUTXq HO WHPSVYHUEDOTXHIDQVHUYLUQRpVO¶DGHTXDW
  279. 279. D GHVSpVTXDQYDYLQJXWXQDEUXL[D µKDYLQJXW¶
  280. 280. ODPHYDPDUHYD.UHL[XW µKD.UHV.XW¶
  281. 281. E HQXQDH[.XUVLyP¶KHSRUWDWPDODPHQW µHPYDLJSRUWDU¶
  282. 282. . ±TXqIHLHVDOOjDO¶HV.ROD@±HVWXGLDQW µHVWXGLDU¶µHVWXGLDYD¶ µHVWDYDHVWXGLDQW¶
  283. 283. 7RWLTXHOHVIRUPHVYHUEDOVXWLOLW]DGHVQRVyQOHV.RUUH.WHVpVLQWHUHVVDQWREVHUYDUTXH HV PDQWp HO YDORU DVSH.WXDO SHUIH.WLX R LPSHUIH.WLX
  284. 284. GHO YHUE $ D
  285. 285. HV ID VHUYLU O¶DX[LOLDUDQDUHQOOR.G¶KDYHUDPEHOSDUWL.LSLLDE
  286. 286. HVIDVHUYLUHOSUHWqULWLQGHILQLW HQOOR.GHOSHUIHWSHUzHQ WRWVHOV.DVRVHV IDVHUYLUXQDIRUPD TXH LQGL.D TXH O¶D..Ly V¶KDD.DEDWDVSH.WHSHUIH.WLX
  287. 287. /¶DVSH.WHLPSHUIH.WLXRGXUDWLXSURSLGHO¶LPSHUIHWLGH OD SHUtIUDVL HVWDU JHUXQGL TXHGD UHGXwW D O¶H[HPSOH GH .
  288. 288. DO JHUXQGL VHQVH .DS DX[LOLDUHQIRUPDSHUVRQDO 4XDVLSUHGL.DWLXV +L KD XQV HOHPHQWV TXH V¶DQRPHQHQ TXDVLSUHGL.DWLXV R SUHGL.DWLXV GH VXERUGLQD.Ly
  289. 289. TXH DSDUHL[HQ HQ OHV VXERUGLQDGHV L .RP HV SRW YHXUH HQ HOV H[HPSOHV VHJHQWVIXQ.LRQHQ.RPDSDUWt.XOHVTXHPDUTXHQODVXERUGLQD.Ly(QVRQLQNpDTXHVWV HOHPHQWVHV.ROÂORTXHQGDYDQWGHOSUHGL.DWLX*LULHU
  290. 290. D $JDUL WHPSRUDOSRWHQ.LDO HOO43YHQLU µ4XDQHOOKDYLQJXW«¶ $ JD QD UL HOO 43 35(' YHQLU µ4XDQHOOYLQJXL«¶µ6LHOOYH«¶ E $JDQUL .RQGL.LRQDOLUUHDO HOO43 YHQLU µ6LHOOKDJXpVYLQJXW«¶
  291. 291. $ JDQ QD UL HOO 43 35(' YHQLU µ6LPDLYLQJXpV«¶ . $ UD ZD WHUHQH PRGDOUDGL.DO.DSD.LWDW
  292. 292. HOO 43 35(' .DPLQDU µ(OOSRWVDS.DPLQDU¶ $ UD QWD[LQLQL HOO 43 35('QHGDU µ(OOQRVDSSRWQHGDU¶ $
  293. 293. WHQLPXQH[HPSOHGHOPDQGLQJDTXH.RUUHVSRQDOYDORUPRGDOG¶REOLJD.Ly 3*
  294. 294. 0 PD1 NHQGHDD IR Q VL WDD ORSLWDDQRR WR PRGDOREOLJD.Ly MR 35(' Ep 43 MR 43 DQDU KRVSLWDO D µ-RQRHPWUREREpKDXULDG¶DQDUDO¶KRVSLWDO¶ (O YHUE PRGDO TXH LQGL.D .DSD.LWDW PRGDO UDGL.DO
  295. 295. HQ .DQYL V¶H[SUHVVD DPE HO YHUE QRR TXH .RP HOV DOWUHV YHUEV Wp HO VHX SURSL SUHGL.DWLX GHVSUpV GHO VXEMH.WH L HO VHX .RPSOHPHQWDOGDYDQWODIRUPDYHUEDOTXHHQ.DWDOjpVXQLQILQLWLX
  296. 296. 3*
  297. 297. D 0PD1WDDQRR PRGDOUDGL.DO.DSD.LWDW
  298. 298. MR35('DQDUSRGHU µ-RQRKLYDLJSRGHUDQDU¶ E 1 VL WDD QRR PRGDOUDGL.DO.DSD.LWDW
  299. 299. MR 35(' DQDU SRGHU µ-RKLSX.DQDU¶ /DIRUPDSURJUHVVLYD (QPDQGLQJDODIRUPDSURJUHVVLYDV¶H[SUHVVDDPEHOSUHGL.DWLXGHVLWXD.LyEHL XQDDUUHOYHUEDOVHJXLGDGHODSRVWSRVL.LyND.RPDD
  300. 300. REpDPEXQDIRUPDYHUEDO
  301. 301. QRPLQDOLW]DGDPLWMDQoDQWODGHVLQqQ.LDQRPLQDOGHGHILQLWXGRHOVXIL[ULURRDPEOD PDU.DGHGHILQLWXG
  302. 302. VHJXLGDGHODSRVWSRVL.LyOD.RPDE.
  303. 303. UHLVVHOV
  304. 304. D 6D1REHIHWH1ND1 .HO 35('.ULGDU3267 µ(VWjWURQDQW³HO.HOHVWj.ULGDQW´
  305. 305. ¶ E LURREHERRWROD DUEUH35('.DXUH'()3267 µ/¶DUEUHHVWj.DLHQW¶ . 0XVRROXEHWDELURROD GRQHV35('.XLQDU68)'()3267 µ/HVGRQHVHVWDQ.XLQDQW¶ (Q VRQLQNp HV ID VHUYLU XQD .RQVWUX..Ly TXH WUDGXwGD HTXLYDOGULD D ³HOO L IHU DOJXQD.RVDHVWDQMXQWV´*LULHU
  306. 306. D $GRGDJDHQZDPHL HOOLPDU[DU35('MXQWV µ(OOHVWjPDU[DQW¶ E $GR[HQTRQZDPHL HOOLVRQ35('MXQWV µ(OOHVWjGRUPLQW¶ /$)250$,Ï'(0276 (OVSUR.HVVRVPpVXVXDOVGHIRUPD.LyGHPRWVHQDTXHVWHVGXHVOOHQJHVVyQOD .RPSRVL.LyLODGHULYD.LyVXIL[D.Ly
  307. 307. 'HULYD.LyVXIL[D.Ly
  308. 308. +LKDGLYHUVRVVXIL[RV$
  309. 309. L
  310. 310. HQGRQHPDOJXQVH[HPSOHVGHOVRQLQNpLGHO PDQGLQJDUHVSH.WLYDPHQW*LULHUL3*
  311. 311. D..LyUHVXOWDW UL µYHQLU¶ ULH µODYLQJXGD¶ LJD µPHQMDU¶ LJDQGH µO¶jSDW¶ JDMD µOOXLWDU¶ JDMD1H µODOOXLWD¶ LQVWUXPHQW WDD[X µVHXUH¶ WDD[DDGH µOD.DGLUD¶ ZXWX µDJDIDU¶ ZXWDDGH µODQDQVD¶ OOR. LJH µPHQMDU¶ LJLUD µHOPHQMDGRU¶ PLQL µEHXUH¶ PLQLUD µHOEDU¶ DJHQW VR[R µ.RQUHDU¶ VR[DDQD µHO.RQUHDGRU¶ WX µVDEHU¶ WXZDDQD µHOVDYL¶ SRVVHwGRUGHTXDOLWDW ZD[D µVHUERLJ¶ ZD[DQWH µXQERLJ¶ NDUL µPDWDU¶ NDULQWH µXQPRUW¶ QRSRVVGHTXDOLWDW VLQTL µVHUEDUEXW¶ VLQTXQEDOL µLPEHUEH¶ WX µVDEHU¶ WXZDQEDOL µLJQRUDQW¶ RULJHQJHRJUjIL. 3DUL µ3DUtV¶ SDULQNH µSDULVHQ.¶ HUH µDTXt¶ HUHQNH µLQGtJHQD¶ .DQYLG¶HVWDW JLOOH µJUDQ¶ JLOOR µHQJUDQGLUVH
  312. 312. ¶ [DVH µYHOO¶ [DVR µHQYHOOLUVH
  313. 313. ¶ GLPLQXWLX D[DUH µGRQD¶ D[DQQH µQRLD¶ EX..H µMRYH¶ EX..LQQH µSHWLW¶
  314. 314. QRSRVVGHTXDOLWDW NXOXX µGLV.LSOLQDU¶ NXOXXEDORR µLQGLV.LSOLQDW¶ OR1 µVDEHU¶ ORQEDORR µLJQRUDQW¶
  315. 315. QRPDEVWUD.WH NHH µKRPH¶ NHHDD µKXPDQLWDW¶ WRROHH µERLJ¶ WRROHHDD µERJHULD¶ DJHQW GRRNXX µWUHEDOODU¶ GRRNXODD µWUHEDOODGRU¶ VHQH µJUDQMD¶ VHQHODD µJUDQJHU¶ PDQHUD WDEL µ.XLQDU¶ WDELxDD µIRUPDGH .XLQDU¶ SULYD.Ly PXVR µGRQD¶ PXVXQWD1R µVROWHU¶ KDPH µDPEL.Ly¶ KDPHQWD1R µQRDPEL.LyV¶ GLPLQXWLX EXNRR µOOLEUH¶ EXNXQGL1R µOOLEUHW¶ VLLVHH µ.XLQD¶ VLLVHQGL1R µ.XLQHWD¶ DXJPHQWDWLX NHH µKRPH¶ NHHNDQD1R µKRPHJURV¶ VXQNXWRR µQRLD¶ VXQNXWXNDQD1R µQRLDJURVVD¶ RPSRVL.Ly (QWRWHVGXHVOOHQJHVOD.RPSRVL.LypVXQSUR.pVPROWSURGX.WLX$.RQWLQXD.Ly HQYHXUHPDOJXQVH[HPSOHV 11@1 eVHOWLSXVGH.RQVWUX..LyTXHHVIDVHUYLUTXDQXQQRPWpXQDOWUHQRPLQGHILQLW .RPD.RPSOHPHQW(OVHJRQQRPpVHOQX.OLLHOSULPHUTXHHQVRQLQNpDSDUHL[HQOD IRUPDUHGXwGDHO.RPSOHPHQWD*LULHULUHLVVHOV
  316. 316. 6RQ MD[DLQPH [DL.DS µ.DSGH[DL¶ LWWLUHQPH DUEUHILOO µIUXLW¶³ILOOG¶DUEUH´

×