Berber

713 Aufrufe

Veröffentlicht am

0 Kommentare
0 Gefällt mir
Statistik
Notizen
  • Als Erste(r) kommentieren

  • Gehören Sie zu den Ersten, denen das gefällt!

Keine Downloads
Aufrufe
Aufrufe insgesamt
713
Auf SlideShare
0
Aus Einbettungen
0
Anzahl an Einbettungen
8
Aktionen
Geteilt
0
Downloads
4
Kommentare
0
Gefällt mir
0
Einbettungen 0
Keine Einbettungen

Keine Notizen für die Folie

Berber

  1. 1. &ROÂOH..Ly/OHQJXDLPPLJUD.LyLHQVHQDPHQWGHO.DWDOjQ~P (/%(5%(5 (678',203$5$7,8 (175(/$*5$0¬7,$'(/$7$/¬ ,/$'(/%(5%(52$0$=,* ;DYLHU/DPXHOD *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D *DELQHWG¶$VVHVVRUDPHQW/LQJtVWL.SHUDOD,PPLJUD.Ly 8QLYHUVLWDWGH*LURQD *HQHUDOLWDWGHDWDOXQD 'HSDUWDPHQWGH%HQHVWDUL)DPÇOLD
  2. 2. /DPXHOD;DYLHU (O%HUEHUHVWXGL.RPSDUDWLXHQWUHODJUDPjWL.DGHO.DWDOjLODGHOEHUEHURDPD]LJ±/OHQJXDLPPLJUD.Ly LHQVHQDPHQWGHO.DWDOj
  3. 3. ,6%1 ,DWDOXQD'HSDUWDPHQWGH%HQHVWDU6R.LDO,,7tWRO,,,ROÂOH..Ly/OHQJXDLPPLJUD.LyLHQVHQDPHQWGHO .DWDOjDWDOj±*UDPjWL.D.RPSDUDGD±5LIHQ5LIHQ±*UDPjWL.D.RPSDUDGD±DWDOjDWDOj± (QVHQDPHQW±(VWXGLDQWVHVWUDQJHUV (OSURMH.WH³/OHQJXDLPPLJUD.LyLHQVHQDPHQWGHO.DWDOj´KDHVWDWILQDQoDWSHO'HSDUWDPHQWGH%HQHVWDUL)DPtOLD GHOD*HQHUDOLWDWGHDWDOXQDDWUDYpVG¶XQ.RQYHQLGH.ROÂODERUD.LyDPEOD8QLYHUVLWDWGH*LURQD
  4. 4. (OVLQYHVWLJDGRUVTXHKDQWUHEDOODWHQODUHGD..LyGHOVUHVXOWDWVG¶DTXHVWSURMH.WHVyQ /OXwVD*Uj.LD6ROp.RRUGLQDGRUD
  5. 5. *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  6. 6. -RDQ0LTXHORQWUHUDV+HUDV *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  7. 7. -RUGL)DUUpV1LHUJD 6('(*LURQD );DYLHU/DPXHOD*DU.LD *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  8. 8. -XDQDUORV0RUHQRDEUHUD 8QLYHUVLGDG$XWyQRPDGH0DGULG 0DU.RV2UR].R3DLUHW %H.DULGHOSURMH.WH8G*
  9. 9. )UDQ.HV.5R.D8UJHOO *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  10. 10. 5DTXHO6iQ.KH]$YHQGDxR (VWXGLDQWGHPjVWHU8G*
  11. 11. -RVHS06HUUD%RQHW *UXSGHXOWXUDL(GX.D.Ly8G*
  12. 12. (OLVDEHW6HUUDW6HOODERQD *UXSGHXOWXUDL(GX.D.Ly8G*
  13. 13. +DQSDUWL.LSDWHQO¶HODERUD.LyLUHLPSUHVVLyG¶DTXHVWYROXP.RPDEH.DULV.ROÂODERUDGRUVRUHYLVRUV +DVVDQ$EDUNDQ 6HUYHLV6R.LDOV$MXQWDPHQWGH3DODIUXJHOO 5RVHU$JXVWt+HUHX %H.jULD8G*
  14. 14. DUOHVDVWHOODQRV/ORUHQV 8QLYHUVLWDW$XWzQRPDGH%DU.HORQD %HUWDURXVDVWDxp %H.jULD8G*
  15. 15. 2OJD)XOODQD1RHOO *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*L,(
  16. 16. /L]]*DXYUHDX2¶+DJDQ %H.jULDGHOSURMH.WH8G*
  17. 17. 0HULW[HOO0DUt5RGUtJXH] %H.jULDGHOSURMH.WH8G*
  18. 18. 0DU.RV2UR].R3DLUHW %H.DULGHOSURMH.WH8G*
  19. 19. /DXUD5LHUDDVHOODV *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  20. 20. /tGLD7XURQ3ODQHOOD *UXSGH/q[L.L*UDPjWL.D8G*
  21. 21. ‹*HQHUDOLWDWGHDWDOXQD 'HSDUWDPHQWGH%HQHVWDUL)DPtOLD 3ULPHUDHGL.LyDEULOGH 3ULPHUDUHLPSUHVVLyUHYLVDGDPDLJGH 7LUDWJHH[HPSODUV 'LSzVLWOHJDO% 'LVVHQLSURGX..LyJDPDVO
  22. 22. 35(6(17$,Ï eVXQDVDWLVID..LySHUDPLSUHVHQWDUYRVDTXHVWDQRYD.ROÂOH..LyTXHHO'HSDUWDPHQWGH %HQHVWDUL)DPtOLDKDLQL.LDWDPEODYROXQWDWG¶DMXGDUD.RQqL[HULLQWHJUDUHQODQRVWUD VR.LHWDWOHVSHUVRQHVTXHDUULEHQG¶DUUHXGHOPyQ/DYROXQWDW.UHL[HQWTXHPRVWUHQSHU DSUHQGUH HO .DWDOj KD SRVDW GH PDQLIHVW OD QH.HVVLWDW GH IDPLOLDULW]DU OD .RPXQLWDW HGX.DWLYD DPE OHV OOHQJHV GHOV LPPLJUDQWV D IL TXH DTXHVWD SXJXL HQWHQGUH HOV SUREOHPHV OLQJtVWL.V TXH KDQ G¶DIURQWDU HOV HVWXGLDQWV TXDQ GHVLWJHQ DSUHQGUH R DSUHQHQHO.DWDOj$TXHVWDQH.HVVLWDWHVIDHYLGHQWDPEO¶HV.RODULW]D.LyGHQHQVLQHQHV HQOHVHV.ROHV.DWDODQHVSHUzWDPEpDPEO¶LQ.UHPHQWGHSHUVRQHVLQV.ULWHVDOHVHV.ROHVL DXOHV GH IRUPD.Ly G¶DGXOWV L HQ HOV .XUVRV GH QRUPDOLW]D.Ly OLQJtVWL.D DGDV.XQ GHOV YROXPV G¶DTXHVWD .ROÂOH..Ly pV IUXLW G¶XQ HVWXGL GH OHV OOHQJHV HVWUDQJHUHV QR .RPXQLWjULHVPpVSDUODGHVDDWDOXQDLHVWjGHVWLQDWDIHUQRWDUHOVDVSH.WHVOLQJtVWL.V TXH SRGHQ DIDYRULU R HQWRUSLU O¶DSUHQHQWDWJH GHO .DWDOj RQWHQHQ XQD GHV.ULS.Ly JUDPDWL.DOGHODOOHQJXDLXQDSDUWDWGHOVHUURUVLSUREOHPHVOLQJtVWL.VPpVIUHTHQWVL DPpVYDQD.RPSDQDWVG¶XQVEUHXVHVWXGLV.RPSDUDWLXVGHOVLVWHPDJUDPDWL.DO.DWDOj DPEHOVVLVWHPHVJUDPDWL.DOVGHOHVDOWUHVOOHQJHV /D ILQDOLWDW SULQ.LSDO GHO *RYHUQ GH OD *HQHUDOLWDW GH DWDOXQD DVVHQDODGD HQ HO 3OD LQWHUGHSDUWDPHQWDO G¶LPPLJUD.Ly pV D.RQVHJXLU TXH OHV SHUVRQHV TXH KDQ HV.ROOLW DWDOXQDSHUYLXUHV¶KLLQWHJULQDPEODPj[LPDQDWXUDOLWDWLUDSLGHVDSRVVLEOH/DYLD SULQ.LSDOSHUD.RQVHJXLUDTXHVWDLQWHJUD.LypVHO.RQHL[HPHQWLO¶~VGHO.DWDOj6yQHOV SURIHVVLRQDOVGHO¶HQVHQDPHQWLODVR.LHWDW.DWDODQDHQJHQHUDOHOVTXHWHQHQHOGHXUHGH ID.LOLWDUORV O¶DSUHQHQWDWJH GH OD QRVWUD OOHQJXD RQqL[HU TXLQHV VyQ OHV GLIL.XOWDWV OLQJtVWLTXHV DPE TXq HV WUREHQ KD G¶DMXGDUQRV D ID.LOLWDU O¶HQVHQDPHQW GHO .DWDOj D SHUVRQHV DPE TXL LQL.LDOPHQW KL SRW KDYHU PpV GLIL.XOWDWV GH .RPSUHQVLy L GH UHOD.Ly YHUEDODWqVTXH.DSGHOVGRVLQWHUOR.XWRUV.RQHL[RSDUODODOOHQJXDGHO¶DOWUH (OVHJRQPRWLXGHVDWLVID..LySHUODSUHVHQWD.LyG¶DTXHVWD.ROÂOH..LyGHULYDGHOIHWTXH pV IUXLW G¶XQD .ROÂODERUD.Ly HQWUH HO PyQ D.DGqPL. UHSUHVHQWDW SHU OD 8QLYHUVLWDW GH *LURQDLDPEOD.RRUGLQD.LyGHOD'UD/OXwVD*Uj.LD±DPEXQDOODUJDWUDMH.WzULDHQOD LQYHVWLJD.Ly OLQJtVWL.D OD TXDO JDUDQWHL[ OD TXDOLWDW GHOV PDWHULDOV HODERUDWV± L O¶$GPLQLVWUD.Ly .DWDODQD UHSUHVHQWDGD SHO 'HSDUWDPHQW GH %HQHVWDU L )DPtOLD GH OD
  23. 23. *HQHUDOLWDWGHDWDOXQDUH.TXHpVER TXH OHV LQYHVWLJD.LRQV TXH HV IDQ HQ HO PyQ D.DGqPL. WLQJXLQ XQD DSOL.D.Ly GLUH.WD L UHYHUWHL[LQ HQ EHQHIL.L GH OD VR.LHWDW L GHOV .LXWDGDQVHQJHQHUDO$L[t PDWHL[.UH.TXHpVERTXHOHVDGPLQLVWUD.LRQVV¶DGUH.LQ DO PyQ D.DGqPL. SHU VROÂOL.LWDUOL .RQHL[HPHQWV L PqWRGHV TXH HQV SHUPHWLQ PLOORUDU HO WUHEDOOGHOGLDDGLD $TXHVWVPDWHULDOVGRQ.VHODERUDWVHQO¶jPELWD.DGqPL.YDQGHVWLQDWVDOVSURIHVVLRQDOV GH O¶HQVHQDPHQW D IL TXH HOV VHUYHL[LQ SHU DSURSDUVH XQD PL.D D OHV OOHQJHV TXH SDUOHQ HOV VHXV DOXPQHV L HOV SHUPHWLQ LGHQWLIL.DU OHV GLIL.XOWDWV L HOV SURJUHVVRV HQ O¶DSUHQHQWDWJH GHO .DWDOj GHULYDWV GH OHV GLIHUqQ.LHV IRQqWLTXHV JUDPDWL.DOV L Oq[LTXHV DPEODVHYDOOHQJXDPDWHUQD ,5(1(5,*$8,2/,9(5 RQVHOOHUDGH%HQHVWDUL)DPtOLD
  24. 24. 7DPDGGD 0DUUD LZGDQ [HOOHTHQ G VHUUHKŽHQ PTXGGDQ GH OKŽZHUPD G OKŽDTT DUVHQWLLWGODTHOLW[HVŽVŽLWHQDGWLOLWDZPDWWMDUDVHQ $UWL.OH 7RWV HOV pVVHUV KXPDQV QHL[HQ OOLXUHV L LJXDOV HQ GLJQLWDW L HQ GUHWV 6yQ GRWDWV GH UDy L GH .RQV.LqQ.LD L KDQ GH .RPSRUWDUVH IUDWHUQDOPHQWHOVXQVDPEHOVDOWUHV 'H.ODUD.Ly8QLYHUVDOGHOV'UHWV+XPDQV
  25. 25. ,1752'8,Ï /D LGHD GH IHU XQ HVWXGL VREUH OHV OOHQJHV GHOV LPPLJUDQWV TXH UHVLGHL[HQ D DWDOXQDYDVRUJLUGHOD.RQVWDWD.LyGHOVSUREOHPHVTXHVXSRVDYDHOIHWG¶LQWHJUDUDOHV DXOHVLDODVR.LHWDWXQHVSHUVRQHVTXHSDUODYHQXQDDOWUDOOHQJXDGHODTXDOOD.RPXQLWDW HGX.DWLYD GHO QRVWUH SDtV HQ OD PDMRULD GHOV .DVRV QR WHQLD .DS .RQHL[HPHQW /D VLWXD.Ly GRQ.V pV EHQ GLIHUHQW GH OD TXH HV GyQD DPE HOV LPPLJUDQWV TXH SDUOHQ .DVWHOOjSHUTXqHOVHGX.DGRUVVtTXHSRGHQHQWHQGUHLSDUODUODVHYDOOHQJXDLSHUWDQW QRHVGyQDODLPSRVVLELOLWDWGH.RPSUHQVLyLGHUHOD.LyYHUEDO /¶REMH.WLXG¶DTXHVWVWUHEDOOVpVSURSRU.LRQDUDOVPHVWUHVLDOVSURIHVVRUVTXHKDQ G¶HQVHQDU.DWDOjDOVQRVWUHVLPPLJUDQWVXQDHLQDTXHHOVVHUYHL[LSHUDDSURSDUVHXQD PL.DDODOOHQJXDTXHSDUOHQHOVVHXVDOXPQHV1RHVWUD.WDHYLGHQWPHQWTXHDSUHQJXLQ jUDE[LQqVRPDQGLQJDSHUH[HPSOH1RPpVSUHWHQHPTXHWLQJXLQXQDLGHDJHQHUDOGHO IXQ.LRQDPHQWGHODJUDPjWL.DG¶DTXHVWHVOOHQJHVTXHHOVSHUPHWLYDORUDULHQWHQGUHOHV GLIL.XOWDWVLHOVSURJUHVVRVGHOVDSUHQHQWVeVREYLTXHQRWRWVHOVSUREOHPHVOLQJtVWL.V SURYHQHQGHODLQWHUIHUqQ.LDDPEODSULPHUDOOHQJXDDOJXQVVyQJHQHUDOVHQTXDOVHYRO DSUHQHQWDWJH G¶XQD VHJRQD R ILQV L WRW G¶XQD SULPHUD OOHQJXD 3HUz Vt TXH KL KD GHWHUPLQDWVHUURUVTXHV¶HQWHQHQPpVEpVLHV.RPSDUDODJUDPjWL.DGHO.DWDOjDPEODGH O¶DOWUD OOHQJXD 1RVDOWUHV QR SUHWHQHP HQ DTXHVWV HVWXGLV GRQDU VROX.LRQV QL PDWHULDO GLGj.WL.SHUDOVSUREOHPHV.RQ.UHWV$L[zHVSRGUjIHUHQXQDVHJRQDIDVHDUDTXHWHQLP LGHQWLIL.DGHVOHVGLIHUqQ.LHVHQWUHOHVGXHVOOHQJHVLTXHKHPSRJXWGHWH.WDUHOVHUURUV PpV IUHTHQWV (O WUHEDOO TXH SUHVHQWHP DUD KDXULD G¶DMXGDU O¶HQVHQDQW D GHGXLU G¶RQ YpQHQ R G¶RQ SRGHQ YHQLU HOV SUREOHPHV L KDXULD G¶HVWLPXODUOR D WUREDU HVWUDWqJLHV GLGj.WLTXHVDGHTXDGHVD.DGD.DV /D LGHD TXH KL KD DO GDUUHUH G¶DTXHVW SURMH.WH pV TXH SHUTXq HOV LPPLJUDQWV V¶LQWHJULQ.DOTXHODVR.LHWDWG¶D.ROOLGDWLQJXLDOJXQ.RQHL[HPHQWGHOD.XOWXUDGHOVTXH KLDUULEHQ,OD.XOWXUDHQWUHG¶DOWUHV.RVHVLQ.ORXODOOHQJXD,SRWVHUpVHOID.WRUPpV LPSRUWDQWSHUTXqpVHOTXHSHUPHWODWUDQVPLVVLyGH.RQHL[HPHQWVG¶H[SHULqQ.LHVLGH VHQWLPHQWV/DOOHQJXDLSHUUDRQVKLVWzULTXHVHOV.DWDODQVKRSRGHPHQWHQGUHPROWEp L
  26. 26. pVXQWUHWPROWOOLJDWDODSHUVRQDLDOD.RPXQLWDWTXHPHUHL[XQUHVSH.WHHVSH.LDOSHU SDUWGHOVDOWUHVLTXHHQ.DS.DVQRV¶KDGHPHQVWHQLURLJQRUDU 3RGHU GHPRVWUDU DOV LPPLJUDQWV TXH VDEHP DOJXQD .RVD GH OD VHYD OOHQJXD HQ.DUDTXHQRPpVVLJXLTXHHQ.RQHL[HPO¶H[LVWqQ.LDLHOQRPRODPDQHUDGHGLUERQ GLDRJUj.LHVPDQLIHVWDUTXHKLHVWHPLQWHUHVVDWVLHQVHQDUORVTXHWHQLPXQOOLEUHWTXH HQVSRWDMXGDUDVDEHUQHPpVVyQ.RVHVTXHHOOVDJUDLUDQ.RPKRDJUDLUtHPQRVDOWUHVVL HQVWUREpVVLPHQOHVVHYHV.LU.XPVWjQ.LHV(QPROWV.DVRVHVSH.LDOPHQWSHUDOVSDUODQWV G¶DOJXQHVOOHQJHVDIUL.DQHVDTXHVWLQWHUqVSRWWHQLUHQ.DUDXQDOWUH HIH.WH EHQHIL.LyV HYLWDUTXHHOOVV¶DYHUJRQHL[LQGHODVHYDSUzSLDOOHQJXDLSHUWDQWUHGXLUHOVHQWLPHQW G¶LQIHULRULWDWTXHGHYHJDGHVVHQWHQHQYHUVHOOVPDWHL[RVLODVHYD.XOWXUDTXDQVyQDTXt 1RPpVTXDQHQVD..HSWHPLHQVVHQWLPD..HSWDWVVRP.DSDoRVG¶D..HSWDUHOVDOWUHV8Q SUR.pVG¶LQWHJUD.LyQRSRWHVWDUGHVYLQ.XODWGHO.RQHL[HPHQWPXWX,QWHJUDUQRYROGLU IDJR.LWDU,QWHJUDUVHQRSRWLPSOL.DUKDYHUGHUHQXQ.LDUDODSUzSLD.XOWXUD6LIRVDL[t VHULDXQHPSREULPHQWSHUDOHVGXHVSDUWV (VWUX.WXUDGHOOOLEUH $TXHVWOOLEUH.RQVWDGHTXDWUHSDUWV(QODSULPHUD,GHQWLIL.D.LyGHODOOHQJXDHV GRQHQXQHVQR.LRQVEjVLTXHVVREUHHOOOR.RQHVSDUODHOQRPEUHGHSDUODQWVODVLWXD.Ly VR.LROLQJtVWL.D L OHV YDULDQWV GLDOH.WDOV O¶DOIDEHW L OHV SULQ.LSDOV .DUD.WHUtVWLTXHV JUDPDWL.DOVGHOEHUEHU /D VHJRQD SDUW 'HV.ULS.Ly JUDPDWL.DO SUHVHQWD DOJXQHV THVWLRQV GH O¶HVWUX.WXUDGHODJUDPjWL.DGHOEHUEHUHVSH.LDOPHQWDTXHOOHVTXHVyQPpVGLIHUHQWVGHO .DWDOjRTXHSRGHQVHUOD IRQWG¶DOJXQV HUURUV (VWj RUJDQLW]DGD LQWHUQDPHQW HQ TXDWUH VXEDSDUWDWVIRQqWL.DLIRQRORJLDPRUIRORJLDVLQWD[LLOq[L.$TXHVW.DStWROQRV¶KDGH YHXUH .RP XQD ³JUDPjWL.D EHUEHU´ pV QRPpV XQ .RQMXQW G¶LQIRUPD.LRQV JUDPDWL.DOV VREUH HO EHUEHU .RPSDUDGHV DPE OHV HVWUX.WXUHV .RUUHVSRQHQWV GHO .DWDOj 6HPSUH TXH HQVKDHVWDWSRVVLEOHKHPUHOD.LRQDWOD.RPSDUD.LyJUDPDWL.DODPEHOVHUURUVTXHKHP GHWH.WDWHQODSDUOD.DWDODQDGHSHUVRQHVEHUEHUV+HPLQWHQWDWVHPSUHGHL[DUGHEDQGD HOVWH.QL.LVPHVLKHPVLPSOLIL.DWHOVSUREOHPHVDOPj[LP3RVVLEOHPHQWXQOLQJLVWDKL WUREDUjPDQ.DQ.HVSUREOHPHVLQWHUHVVDQWVSR.H[SOL.DWVLVHQVH.DSSURSRVWDGHVROX.Ly ,WLQGUjUDy3HUzHVWUD.WDG¶XQWUHEDOODPEXQDILQDOLWDWSUj.WL.DPROW.ODUDDMXGDUHOV LL
  27. 27. HGX.DGRUV TXH QR QH.HVVjULDPHQW VyQ OLQJLVWHV
  28. 28. eV SHU DL[z TXH KHP .UHJXW .RQYHQLHQWGHL[DUGHEDQGDOHVGLVTXLVL.LRQVTXHSRGULHQVHUPROWLQWHUHVVDQWVSHUDXQ OLQJLVWDSHUzTXHQRDSRUWDULHQUHVVLJQLIL.DWLXDO¶REUDWDOL.RPO¶KHP.RQ.HEXGDGHV GHO.RPHQoDPHQW /D WHU.HUD SDUW LQ.ORX XQD OOLVWD DPE HOV WLSXV G¶HUURUV TXH KHP WUREDW DPE H[HPSOHV L OD UHIHUqQ.LD D O¶DSDUWDW GHO VHJRQ .DStWRO HQ TXq HV WUD.WD OD THVWLy (OV HUURUVSURYHQHQGHSDUODQWVEHUEHUVTXHKHPHQWUHYLVWDWTXDQSDUODYHQ.DWDOj (OTXDUWDSDUWDW.RUUHVSRQDGRVEUHXVYR.DEXODULVXQGH.DWDOjEHUEHULXQDOWUH GHEHUEHU.DWDOj/HVIRUPHVEHUEHUVHVWDQHV.ULWHVDPEO RUWRJUDILDG DTXHVWDOOHQJXD (QHOVHJRQ.DStWROHQSDUODUGHODIRQqWL.DLGHODIRQRORJLDHVGRQHQOHVHTXLYDOqQ.LHV HQWUHDTXHVWHVJUDILHVLHOVVtPEROVGHO DOIDEHWIRQqWL.LQWHUQD.LRQDO$L[zSRWID.LOLWDU ILQV D XQ .HUW SXQW OD SURQXQ.LD.Ly G DOJXQD SDUDXOD HQ EHUEHU VL pV QH.HVVDUL 6¶KDQ WULDW HOV .RQ.HSWHV TXH HV .RQVLGHUHQ PpV R PHQV XQLYHUVDOV HQ OD ELEOLRJUDILD HVSH.LDOLW]DGD L V¶KL KDQ DIHJLW DTXHOOV TXH HQV VHPEODYD TXH SRGLHQ VHU G¶~V PpV IUHTHQWHQODQRVWUDVR.LHWDWRHQOD.XOWXUDEHUEHU )LQDOPHQW HO .LQTXq SXQW pV XQD EUHX ELEOLRJUDILD TXH LQ.ORX HOV PDWHULDOV XWLOLW]DWV UHIHUqQ.LHV DVVHTXLEOHV GHV GH DWDOXQD L DGUH.HV GH SjJLQHV ZHE UHOD.LRQDGHV DPE HO WHPD L HO VLVq DSDUWDW .RQWp HOV DSqQGL[V HO TXDGUH GH O¶DOIDEHW IRQqWL.LQWHUQD.LRQDOHOTXDGUHGHVRQVGHO.DWDOjLXQPDSDGHO¶H[WHQVLyJHRJUjIL.DGH ODOOHQJXDEHUEHU $JUDwPHQWV 7RW DTXHVW SURMH.WH QR KDXULD HVWDW SRVVLEOH VHQVH HO ILQDQoDPHQW GHO 'HSDUWDPHQW GH %HQHVWDU L )DPtOLD GH OD *HQHUDOLWDW GH DWDOXQD $JUDwP GRQ.V G¶XQDPDQHUDPROWHVSH.LDOOD.RQILDQoDTXHHQVKDGHPRVWUDWOD.RQVHOOHUD,UHQH5LJDX LOD.R
  29. 29. ODERUD.LyGHOHVSHUVRQHVGHO'HSDUWDPHQWTXHSUHVLGHL[ /D UHGD..Ly G¶DTXHVW YROXP V¶KD EHQHIL.LDW GH OD .R
  30. 30. ODERUD.Ly GH GLYHUVHV SHUVRQHV(QSULPHUOOR.DJUDwPODIHLQDTXHKDQIHWHOVEH.DULVL.R
  31. 31. ODERUDGRUVTXHKDQ WUHEDOODW GLUH.WDPHQW R LQGLUH.WDPHQW HQ DTXHVW SURMH.WH HQWUHYLVWDQW LQIRUPDQWV LLL
  32. 32. WUDQV.ULYLQWHOVHQUHJLVWUDPHQWVLIHQWWRWHOTXH.DOLD/*DXYUHDX00DUt02UR].R / 5LHUD % URXV 5 $JXVWt L / 7XURQ $ 2 )XOODQD GHYHP OHV SDXWHV L WRWHV OHV LQGL.D.LRQV QH.HVVjULHV SHU D O¶HVWUX.WXUD.Ly GHO YR.DEXODUL ILQDO $JUDwP WDPEp D OHV HV.ROHVTXHHQVKDQID.LOLWDWOHVHQWUHYLVWHVDOVLQIRUPDQWVHO(,3/D)DUJDGH6DOWHO (,3(O3RUWLW[ROGH/ (VWDUWLWHOHQWUHGH)RUPD.LyG $GXOWV/HV%HUQDUGHVGH6DOWL OD3DUUzTXLDGH6DQW*HQtVGH7RUURHOODGH0RQWJUt([SUHVVHPHOQRVWUHDJUDwPHQWDOHV SHUVRQHV TXH KDQ D..HSWDW GH VHU HQWUHYLVWDGHV L D OD VHYD GLVSRQLELOLWDW 'RQHP OHV JUj.LHV D OD ,QWHUQDWLRQDO 3KRQHWL. $VVR.LDWLRQ .R 'HSDUWPHQW RI /LQJXLVWL.V 8QLYHUVLWRI9L.WRULD9L.WRULD%ULWLVKROXPELDDQDGj
  33. 33. SHUSHUPHWUHODUHSURGX..Ly GHOTXDGUHGHVRQVTXHDSDUHL[DODVH..LyG¶DSqQGL[V)LQDOPHQWYROHPDJUDLUO H[WUHPD GLVSRQLELOLWDWGH+DVVDQ$EDUNDQLGHDUOHVDVWHOODQRVTXHKDQUHVSRVWDOHVQRVWUHV .RQVXOWHV KDQ OOHJLW O¶RULJLQDO L KL KDQ IHW DSRUWD.LRQV YDOXRVHV L XQHV TXDQWHV .RUUH..LRQV D PpV D PpV HO GDUUHU HQV KD SUHVWDW PDWHULDOV LQGLVSHQVDEOHV SHU D OD UHDOLW]D.Ly GHO WUHEDOO 2PDU 2XDNULP HQV KD IHW DOJXQHV REVHUYD.LRQV SDUWL.XODUPHQW ~WLOV(QHOQRVWUH.DVSHUzpVHVSH.LDOPHQW.HUWTXHHOVGHIH.WHVTXHSHUVLVWHL[HQVyQ H[.OXVLYDPHQWGHODUHVSRQVDELOLWDWGHO¶DXWRU $JUDwP SHU HQGDYDQW WRWV HOV VXJJHULPHQWV REVHUYD.LRQV L .RUUH..LRQV TXH HOV OH.WRUV HQV SXJXHX IHU DUULEDU D O¶DGUHoD GH .RUUHX HOH.WUzQL. JDOL#XGJHV /D YRVWUD .R
  34. 34. ODERUD.LyHQVSRGUjVHUPROW~WLOSHUDPLOORUDUHOQRVWUHWUHEDOO LY
  35. 35. $%5(9,$785(686$'(6(1/$'(65,3,Ï*5$0$7,$/ $11(; HVWDWG¶DQQH[Ly $8; DX[LOLDU '(0 GHPRVWUDWLX )(0 IHPHQt +$% KDELWXDO ,03(5 LPSHUDWLX ,03(5) LPSHUIH.WLX ,17(55 SDUWt.XODLQWHUURJDWLYD 0$6 PDV.XOt 25,(17 SDUWt.XODG RULHQWD.Ly 3$57 SDUWt.XOD 3(5) SHUIH.WLX 3/ SOXUDO 3521 SURQRP 5$' UDGL.DO 6* VLQJXODU $%5(9,$785(686$'(6(1(/92$%8/$5, DGM DGMH.WLX DGY DGYHUEL DUW DUWL.OH .RQM .RQMXQ.Ly Q QRP QXP QXPHUDO SUHS SUHSRVL.Ly SURQ SURQRP Y YHUE Y
  36. 36. ,'(17,),$,Ï'(/$//(1*8$ ),/,$,Ï,'(120,1$,Ï /¶DPD]LJ SHUWDQ D OD IDPtOLD DIURDVLjWL.D /D GLVWjQ.LD OLQJtVWL.D HQWUH HOV GLIHUHQWVPHPEUHVG¶DTXHVWDIDPtOLDpVPROWJUDQDL[zIDTXHPDOJUDWDOJXQHVDILQLWDWV HQ OD IRQqWL.D L HQ OHV HVWUX.WXUHV JUDPDWL.DOV HO EHUEHU L O¶jUDE TXH .RP D OOHQJXD VHPtWL.DSHUWDQWDPEpDOJUXSDIURDVLjWL.VyQOOHQJHVPROWGLIHUHQWV$L[zQRSULYD TXH HO .RQWD.WH VH.XODU HQWUH OHV GXHV KD SURGXwW LQIOXqQ.LHV P~WXHV PROW LPSRUWDQWV '¶XQD EDQGD O¶jUDE GLDOH.WDO GHO 0DJULE pV SDUODW HQ XQD SURSRU.Ly LPSRUWDQW SHU GHV.HQGHQWVG¶DQWL.VEHUEHUzIRQVWDOPHQWTXHHVSRWGLUTXHWpXQVXEVWUDWDPD]LJDPE HOTXHDL[z.RPSRUWDG¶DGDSWD.LyIRQqWL.DJUDPDWL.DOLVHPjQWL.D'¶DOWUDEDQGDO¶jUDE pVODOOHQJXDVR.LDOPHQWGRPLQDQWSHUDODPDMRULDGHOVEHUEHUVLODOOHQJXDGHODUHOLJLy SHU D TXDVL WRWV .RP D .RQVHTqQ.LD G¶DL[z XQD SDUW VLJQLIL.DWLYD GHO Oq[L. DPD]LJ D.WXDO pV G¶RULJHQ jUDE L DTXHVW YR.DEXODUL KD SHQHWUDW HQ OD OOHQJXD DPE IRQHPHV HVSH.tIL.VTXHV¶KDQLQ.RUSRUDWDO¶LQYHQWDULGHOVVRQVGHOEHUEHU 3HOTXHIDDOQRPGHODOOHQJXDDO.RVWDWGHOWHUPHEHUEHU.RQVDJUDWSHUXQ~V JHQHUDOLW]DW HQ HO TXDO SDUWL.LSHQ GHVWD.DWV PLOLWDQWV SROtWL.V L .XOWXUDOV YHJHX SHU H[HPSOH HOV WtWROV GH 6DOHP KDNHU D OD ELEOLRJUDILD
  37. 37. XWLOLW]HP WDPEp XQD DGDSWD.Ly G¶XQ WHUPH DXWz.WRQ VHJXLQW OD SURSRVWD GH 7LOPDWLQH HW DO
  38. 38. L GH DVWHOODQRV
  39. 39. $TXHVWWHUPHpVHQEHUEHUDPD]LSOXUDOLPD]LHQ
  40. 40. UHIHULWDOHVSHUVRQHVLHO IHPHQt WDPD]LW UHIHULW D OD OOHQJXD TXH pV HPSUDW DO .RVWDW G¶XQ DOWUH WHUPH WDPEp KDELWXDO.HOKŽD7DO.RPV¶KDIHWHQ.DWDOjHQHO.DVGHOQRPGHO¶DOIDEHWHQ~VHQWUHHOV WXDUHJVDQRPHQDWWLILQDDGDSWHPODGHOEHUEHUWUDQV.ULWDGHYHJDGHVJK.RPDJ$ GLIHUqQ.LD GHOV DXWRUV .LWDWV HQV VHPEOD XQD PL.D IRUoDW .UHDU G¶HQWUDGD XQD IRUPD IHPHQLQD HQ .DWDOj SRWVHU O¶~V OD GHPDQDUj L OD LPSRVDUj PpV HQGDYDQW 8VHP GRQ.V .RP D VLQzQLPV EHUEHU EHUEHUV L DPD]LJ DPD]LJV WRWV GRV LQYDULDEOHV SHO TXH ID DO JqQHUH
  41. 41. ',675,%8,Ï*(2*5¬),$,120%5('(3$5/$176 /DOOHQJXDDPD]LJpVSUHVHQWDWRWHOQRUGG¶¬IUL.DGHVGHOHVSULPHUHVQRWt.LHV KLVWzULTXHVTXHWHQLPG¶DTXHVWWHUULWRUL7RWLTXHHQ.DUDQRV¶KDQSRJXW.RPSUHQGUHVH VXSRVD TXH OHV LQV.ULS.LRQV G¶qSR.D URPDQD DQRPHQDGHV OtELTXHV VyQ HV.ULWHV HQ XQD OOHQJXDTXHKDYLDGHVHUHOEHUEHUDQWL.RDOPHQVXQDIRUPDOLQJtVWL.DSUz[LPD(Q WRW.DVO¶DPD]LJKDVXEVLVWLWDPEOHV.RQTXHVWHVURPDQDLjUDE$.WXDOPHQWpVSDUODWSHU XQVYLQWPLOLRQVGHSHUVRQHVGLQVGHWHUULWRULVTXHR.XSHQG¶XQDPDQHUDGLV.RQWtQXDHO 0DJULE L XQD ERQD SDUW GHO 6jKDUD L GHO 6DKHO KDNHU
  42. 42. (OV JUXSV PpV LPSRUWDQWVGHEHUEHUzIRQVHVWUREHQ D
  43. 43. $O0DUUR.XQVPLOLRQVPpVGHOGHODSREOD.Ly
  44. 44. HOVSDUODQWVGH 5LIHQ WDULILW
  45. 45. DO QRUG /D .LXWDW GH 0HOLOOD G¶DGPLQLVWUD.Ly HVSDQROD HV WUREDHQWHUULWRULULIHQ %HUjEHURWDPD]LJKWHQVHQWLWHVWUL.WH±HVWUD.WDWDPEpGHOQRPJOREDOGHOD OOHQJXD±DO.HQWUHHVW 7DL[HOKLWDOVXGRHVW E
  46. 46. $$OJqULDXQVPLOLRQVHQWRUQGHOGHODSREOD.Ly
  47. 47. HOVSDUODQWVGH DELOHQ.WDTEDOLW
  48. 48. DOQRUGHVWDODDEtOLD 7DL[DZLWHQXQWHUULWRULVHSWHQWULRQDOVLWXDWXQDPL.DDOVXGHVWGHODDEtOLD 7DP]DELWDO0]DEVLWXDWDO.HQWUHQRUG .
  49. 49. (OV WXDUHJV SDUODQWV GH WDPDKDT WXDUHJ VHSWHQWULRQDO L GH WDPDL[HT WXDUHJ PHULGLRQDOHQXQDjUHDH[WHQVDVLWXDGDD.DYDOOG¶$OJqULD/tELD1LJqULD%XUNLQD)DVR LVREUHWRW1tJHUXQVEHUEHUzIRQV
  50. 50. L0DOLHQWUHL
  51. 51. RQO¶DPD]LJpV UH.RQHJXW.RPXQDGHOHVOOHQJHVQD.LRQDOV $PpVDPpVKLKDQRPEURVHVDOWUHVLOOHVOLQJtVWLTXHVSREODGHVSHUEHUEHUzIRQV D$OJqULDLDOJXQHVWDPEpD0DXULWjQLD7XQtVLD/tELDL(JLSWHDOWHQLUHQ.RPSWHDL[t PDWHL[OHVSREOD.LRQVDPD]LJVGHVSODoDGHVPpVRPHQVUH.HQWPHQWGLQVGHOVHVWDWVRQ ODOOHQJXDpVDXWz.WRQDLWDPEpHQG¶DOWUHVSDwVRVHQWUHHOVTXDOVGHVWD.D)UDQoDRQD SDUW GH OD VHYD LPSRUWjQ.LD VR.LDO OD SUHVqQ.LD EHUEHU HV PDQLIHVWD HQ XQD QRWDEOH D.WLYLWDW.XOWXUDO
  52. 52. RPHVSRWLPDJLQDUODYDULD.LyGLDOH.WDOGHODOOHQJXDEHUEHUpVPROWJUDQLOD LQWHU.RPSUHQVLy HQWUH SDUODQWV GH YDULHWDWV H[WUHPHV QR HVWj SDV DVVHJXUDGD OD IDOWD G¶KjELW G¶DTXHVWD PHQD G¶H[SHULqQ.LD UHIRUoD OHV GLIL.XOWDWV GHULYDGHV GH OD GLVWjQ.LD OLQJtVWL.D MD SURX LPSRUWDQWV 7RW L TXH XQD GHV.ULS.Ly XQLWjULD GH OD OOHQJXD pV SRVVLEOHHQDTXHVWOOLEUHKHPWULDWGHSUHVHQWDUODYDULHWDWULIHQDDILGHGRQDUOLXQD XWLOLWDW PpV LPPHGLDWD MD TXH OD JUDQ PDMRULD GHOV EHUEHUzIRQV HVWDEOHUWV D DWDOXQD SURYHQHQGHODUHJLyGHO5LI (65,3785$ ([LVWHL[XQDOIDEHWHVSH.tIL.DPHQWEHUEHUTXHKDHVWDWPDQWLQJXWSHOVWXDUHJVHO WLILQDJeVG¶RULJHQPROWDQWL.L.RQVHUYDVLJQHVTXHMDHUHQHPSUDWVHQOHVLQV.ULS.LRQV OtELTXHV$.WXDOPHQWHOEHUEHUpVVREUHWRWXQDOOHQJXDG¶~VRUDOSHUzO¶~VHV.ULWHVGLIRQ GH PDQHUD SURJUHVVLYD 'DYDQW OHV WUHV RS.LRQV SRVVLEOHV ±WLILQDJ HV.ULSWXUD jUDE L DOIDEHW OODWt± VHPEOD TXH O¶~V GH O¶HV.ULSWXUD OODWLQD pV HO TXH Wp PpV SRVVLELOLWDWV G¶LPSRVDUVH SRWVHU DO .RVWDW G¶XQ ~V HPEOHPjWL. GHO WLILQDJ 1DWXUDOPHQW O¶~OWLPD SDUDXOD OD WLQGUj XQ GHVLWMDEOH ~V HV.RODU L PHGLjWL. JHQHUDOLW]DW GHO EHUEHU SDUWL.XODUPHQW DO 0DUUR. L D $OJqULD (Q DTXHVW OOLEUH XWLOLW]HP OHV .RQYHQ.LRQV JUjILTXHV GH EDVH OODWLQD SURSRVDGHV SHU KDNHU YHJHX OD WDXOD GHO SDUjJUDI
  53. 53. $5$7(5,7=$,Ï7,32/Ñ*,$680¬5,$ 3HO TXH ID D OD SURQXQ.LD.Ly O¶DPD]LJ HV .DUD.WHULW]D SHU XQ VLVWHPD YR.jOL. UHGXwW GHV GHO SXQW GH YLVWD IRQROzJL. D a L a X
  54. 54. SHUz DPE XQD JUDQ GLYHUVLWDW GH UHDOLW]D.LRQV IRQqWLTXHV SHU OD .RPSOH[LWDW GHOV JUXSV .RQVRQjQWL.V SRVVLEOHV L SHU OD SUHVqQ.LDGH.RQVRQDQWVWHQVHVJHQHUDOPHQWPpVOODUJXHVHQRSRVL.LyIRQROzJL.DDPE OHV.RUUHVSRQHQWVOD[HV
  55. 55. LNHU] µKDOODXUDW¶ LNHUUH] µOODXUDHVWjOODXUDQW¶ HU]X µKDEXV.DW¶ LUH]]X µEXV.DHVWjEXV.DQW¶ /D SULQ.LSDO .DUD.WHUtVWL.D PRUIROzJL.D TXH HO EHUEHU .RPSDUWHL[ DPE OHV OOHQJHV VHPtWLTXHV pV TXH XWLOLW]D D PpV GH O¶DGMXQ.Ly GH SUHIL[RV L VXIL[RV OD SRVVLELOLWDWGHPRGLIL.DUODGRWD.LyYR.jOL.DLODTXDOLWDWGHOHV.RQVRQDQWVGHOVPRWVSHU D SURGXLU GHULYDWV L IRUPHV GH IOH[Ly $L[t SHU D REWHQLU HO SOXUDO GH OD SDUDXOD D]ŽUX µSHGUD¶HV.DQYLDHOSUHIL[SURSLGHOVLQJXODUDHQLLODYR.DOILQDOXHQDL]ŽUDD SDUWLU GH OD IRUPD EjVL.D GHO YHUE VH µ.RPSUDU¶ ±HV WUD.WD GH O¶LPSHUDWLX VLQJXODU± DIHJLQWKL XQ SUHIL[ L
  56. 56. GH SHUVRQD L OD YR.DO LQWHUQD D L IHQW WHQVD OD SULPHUD .RQVRQDQWV¶REWpHVVDWHU.HUDSHUVRQDGHOVLQJXODUPDV.XOtGHO¶KDELWXDOGXUDWLXTXH H[SUHVVD O¶D..Ly KDELWXDO R .RQWLQXDGD .RPSUD HVWj .RPSUDQW (V.ULYLQW SHU XQD .RQVRQDQWLSHUXQD.RQVRQDQWWHQVDSRGHPUHSUHVHQWDUDL[tHOV.DQYLV
  57. 57. D]ŽUXµSHGUD¶ o L]ŽUD µSHGUHV¶ DXoLD
  58. 58. VHµ.RPSUD¶ o HVVD µ.RPSUDHVWj.RPSUDQW¶ oD
  59. 59. 8Q DOWUH WUHW SURSL GHO EHUEHU pV O¶HVWDW G¶DQQH[Ly GHOV QRPV TXH DGRSWHQ XQD IRUPD SDUWL.XODU GDUUHUH GH GHWHUPLQDGHV SDUWt.XOHV .RP OD .RQMXQ.Ly G µL¶ L HQ GHWHUPLQDGHV IXQ.LRQV .RP OD GH .RPSOHPHQW QRPLQDO R OD GH VXEMH.WH HQ OD VHYD SRVL.LyQRPDU.DGDGDUUHUHGHOYHUE
  60. 60. D DIXQDVGXXO ERXLDVH$11(; µHOERXLO¶DVH¶ E DXOGXIXQDV DVHLERX$11(; µO¶DVHLHOERX¶ (Q DTXHVWV H[HPSOHV V¶REVHUYD O¶DOWHUQDQoD GH L L DPE XQ PDWHL[ YDORU GH WHU.HUD SHUVRQD GHO VLQJXODUPDV.XOt1RV¶KDGHWHQLUHQ.RPSWHODYR.DO HTXHUHSUHVHQWDXQDYR.DOQHXWUDGHVXSRUWTXH QRPpVV¶DIHJHL[SHUDID.LOLWDUODSURQXQ.LD.LyGHOVJUXSV.RQVRQjQWL.V
  61. 61. /D PRUIRORJLD YHUEDO V¶RUJDQLW]D D SDUWLU GH O¶H[SUHVVLy GH O¶DVSH.WH ±RSRVL.Ly SHUIH.WLXaLPSHUIH.WLXaKDELWXDOGXUDWLX±LQRSDVGHODGHOWHPSV
  62. 62. D X]]HOH µKH.RUUHJXWYDLJ.yUUHU¶ SHUIH.WLX
  63. 63. E DGD]]HOH µTXH.RUULMR
  64. 64. D.yUUHUMR
  65. 65. .RUUHUp¶ LPSHUIH.WLX
  66. 66. . WWD]]HOH µ.RUURHVWL..RUUHQW¶ KDELWXDOGXUDWLX
  67. 67. /¶RUGUH RUD.LRQDO GH O¶DPD]LJ pV YHUE VXEMH.WH .RPSOHPHQWV 962
  68. 68. .RP D D
  69. 69. WRWLTXHHOVXEMH.WHTXDQpVSUHVHQWDW.RPDUHIHUqQ.LDGHOTXHHVGLUjSUH.HGHL[ PROWVRYLQWHOYHUE.RPDE
  70. 70. 6DUULRQDQGLDDGDSWDW
  71. 71. D :DUWHTTDUWZHVVDUW.DLKŽDG QRGLU+$%YHOOD$11(;TXHO.RPDDOJ~ µ/DYHOODQRGLXUHVDQLQJ~¶ E 7DZHVVDUWZDUWHTTDU.DLKŽDG YHOOD QR GLU+$%TXHO.RPDDOJ~ µ/DYHOODQRGLXUHVDQLQJ~¶ (OVDGMH.WLXVTXDOLIL.DWLXVLHOV.RPSOHPHQWVQRPLQDOVVHJXHL[HQKDELWXDOPHQWHO QRP.RPSOHPHQWDW6DUULRQDQGLD
  72. 72. D DGL DPH]ŽDQ JRV0$66* SHWLW0$66* µHOJRVSHWLW¶ E D.XZDI Q WHPDUW DEHOO GH GRQD$11(; µHO.DEHOOGHODGRQD¶ (VWUD.WDGHOTXHV¶DQRPHQDWHPDWLW]D.LyXQH[HPSOHGHWHPDWLW]D.LyGHO.RPSOHPHQWGLUH.WHHQ.DWDOj HOWLQGUtHPDODIUDVHµHQ-RDQQRO¶KHYLVW¶HQTXqHQ-RDQpVSUHVHQWDW.RPDUHIHUqQ.LDGHOTXHHVGLUjD .RQWLQXD.LyYJ†
  73. 73. '(65,3,Ï*5$0$7,$/ )21Ê7,$,)212/2*,$ /¶,19(17$5,'(/(621621$176%(5%(56 (O.RQMXQWGHOHV.RQVRQDQWVGHOHVYDULHWDWVEHUEHUV /DOOHQJXDDPD]LJGHVWD.DSHUODULTXHVDGHOVHX.RQVRQDQWLVPH6L.RPSDUHPHO .RQMXQWGHOHV.RQVRQDQWVGHOEHUEHUDPEOHVGHO.DWDOjDSUH.LDUHPTXHKDGHWHQLUPpV GLIL.XOWDWV XQ .DWDODQzIRQ SHU D DSUHQGUH D SURQXQ.LDU HO EHUEHU TXH QR SDV XQ EHUEHUzIRQSHUDGRPLQDUODSURQXQ.LD.LyGHOHV.RQVRQDQWV.DWDODQHV9HXUHPTXHHQ HO.DVGHOHVYR.DOVODGLIL.XOWDWKDGHVHU PpVR PHQV VLPqWUL.D RPHQ.HP GRQDQW O¶LQYHQWDULGHOVVRQV.RQVRQjQWL.VGHO.DWDOjDILG¶HVWDEOLUXQD.RPSDUD.LyDPEHOVGH O¶DPD]LJ KL LQ.ORHP WDPEp VRQV TXH DSDUHL[HQ HQ GHWHUPLQDWV .RQWH[WRV VHQVH TXH WLQJXLQYDORUIRQROzJL..RPpVHO.DVGHODVqULHGHOVDSUR[LPDQWV3UHVHQWHPHOVVRQV DPEODVHYDJUDILD.DWDODQD.DUD.WHUtVWL.DD.RPSDQDGDGHODWUDQV.ULS.Ly.RUUHVSRQHQW HQDOIDEHWIRQqWL.LQWHUQD.LRQDO$),
  74. 74. RQVRQDQWVGHO.DWDOj R.OXVLYHV DIUL.DGHV IUL.DWLYHV DSUR[LPL QDVDOV ODWHUDOV YLEUDQW EDWHJDQW VHPLYR.DOV $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD ELODELDOV S S % E P P E E ODELRGHQWDOV I I 0 PI
  75. 75. Y
  76. 76. Y
  77. 77. GHQWDOVL W W WV WV V V G G Q Q O O U UUU 5 U DOYHRODUV G G G] W] ] ] DOYHRODUVL W6 W[ 6 L[ M L Ú Q – OO SDODWDOV G= WM = M YHODUV N .T ¦ J 1 QJ J J YHODU Z X DUURGRQLGD $PEDTXHVWYDORUV¶XVDVRYLQWHOVLJQH'@TXH.RUUHVSRQGULDPpVSUH.LVDPHQWDOVRGHODJUDILDWKHQOD SDUDXODDQJOHVDWKDW (Q.DWDOjODUSRWVHUEDWHJDQW.DUD
  78. 78. YLEUDQWSRUWD
  79. 79. LYLEUDQWOODUJDSRUURU@
  80. 80. $.RQWLQXD.LyGRQHPOHV.RQVRQDQWVTXHHVWUREHQHQOHVGLYHUVHVYDULHWDWVGHOD OOHQJXDDPD]LJSUHV.LQGLQWG¶DOJXQHVUHDOLW]D.LRQVTXHGHWDOODUHPPpVHQGDYDQWG¶XQD PDQHUDSDUWL.XODUSHUDOULIHQ(QDTXHVW.DVGRQHPWDPEpODUHSUHVHQWD.LyHQODJUDILD OODWLQDDGRSWDGDLOHV.RUUHVSRQGqQ.LHVHQO¶DOIDEHWIRQqWL.LQWHUQD.LRQDO RQVRQDQWVGHO¶DPD]LJ R.OXVLYHV DIUL.DGHV IUL.DWLYHV QDVDOV VHPLYR.DOV ODWHUDO YLEUDQWV $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD $),JUDILD ELODELDOV S
  81. 81. S
  82. 82. E E P P ELODELDOV DUURGRQLGHV EZ E Z ODELRGHQWDO I I GHQWDOVL W W WV V V DOYHRODUV G G G] zX ] ] Q Q O O U U GHQW L DOYHRO W¸ WŽ V¸ VŽ IDULQJDOLW]DGHV G¸ GŽ ]¸ ]Ž U¸ UŽ DOYHRSDODWDOV W6 þ 6 . G= ÷ = M M YHODUV N N J J YHODUV NZ NZ DUURGRQLGHV JZ JZ Z Z XYXODUV T T [ ´ XYXODUV TZ TZ Z [Z DUURGRQLGHV ´Z Z IDULQJDOV Ò KŽ ¸ ODULQJDO Ü /DSULPHUD.RVDTXHGHVWD.DGHOD.RPSDUD.LyGHOVGRVTXDGUHVpVTXHHOEHUEHU WpUHSUHVHQWDQWVGHWUHVVqULHVGH.RQVRQDQWVTXHIDOWHQ.RPSOHWDPHQWHQ.DWDOjHVWUD.WD GH OHV XYXODUV OHV IDULQJDOV L OHV ODULQJDOV $ PpV D PpV DOJXQHV VqULHV HV GREOHQ DOPHQVSDU.LDOPHQWGH.RQVRQDQWV.DUD.WHULW]DGHVSHUXQDDUWL.XOD.Ly.RPSOHPHQWjULD ODELDO OHV DUURGRQLGHV R IDULQJDO OHV IDULQJDOLW]DGHV (Q .DWDOj QRPpV OD VHPLYR.DOZ .RQHL[DOKRUDXQDDUWL.XOD.LyYHODULODELDO$OTXDGUHGHOEHUEHUIDOWHQHQ.RQWUDSDUWLGD HOV VRQV GH Q L GH OO SHUz .DO DGYHUWLU TXH GHWHUPLQDGHV .RPELQD.LRQV GH IRQqWL.D VLQWj.WL.DIDQDSDUqL[HUHOGHQTXHVHQVHVHUXQIRQHPDpVSUHVHQWHQWRW.DVHQ OD SURQXQ.LD.Ly
  83. 83. 7RW VHJXLW .RQ.UHWHP DOJXQV GHWDOOV L GRQHP DOJXQHV QR.LRQV VREUH OD SURQXQ.LD.LyGHOHV.RQVRQDQWVDEVHQWVHQ.DWDOjRTXHWHQHQXQDSURQXQ.LD.LyGLIHUHQW GH OD GH OHV VHYHV HTXLYDOHQWV .DWDODQHV (Q D.DEDW .RPHQWDUHP G¶XQD PDQHUD PpV SUH.LVDOHV.DUD.WHUtVWLTXHVGHODIRQRORJLDLGHODIRQqWL.DGHOULIHQ /DSH[LVWHL[QRPpVHQPDQOOHXVG¶DOWUHVOOHQJHVpVDEVHQWGHOVLVWHPDEHUEHU WUDGL.LRQDO /HV .RQVRQDQWV DUURGRQLGHV HV SURQXQ.LHQ SRVDQW HOV OODYLV .RP VL KDJXHVVLQ G¶DQDUVHJXLGHVG¶XQDXeVHOTXHHVIDHQ.DWDOjTXDQHVSURQXQ.LHQHOVJUXSVTXLJX GHOHVSDUDXOHVTXDWUHLJXDQWKRSRGHPREVHUYDUDWXUDQWODSURQXQ.LD.LyHQHOPRPHQW HQTXqHVWHPDSXQWGHGHVIHUO¶R.OXVLyGHOD.RQVRQDQW/DGLIHUqQ.LDHQWUHTXLJXGHO .DWDOj L OHV .RQVRQDQWV DUURGRQLGHV EHUEHUV pV TXH HQ DTXHVWHV HO WHPSV GH Z pV PpV EUHX.RPVLHVSURQXQ.LpVSUj.WL.DPHQWDOPDWHL[WHPSVTXHOD.RQVRQDQWR.OXVLYD(Q ULIHQQRPpVKLKD.RQVRQDQWVDUURGRQLGHVGHODVqULHYHODU
  84. 84. VVHNNZDU µVX.UH¶ Z JJ HG µWHQLUSRU¶ (Q G¶DOWUHV YDULHWDWV .RP HO .DELOHQ. HQ WUREHP WDPEp GH OHV VqULHV ELODELDO L XYXODU $O .RVWDW GH OD IRUPD .DELOHQ.D GRQHP OD IRUPD ULIHQD .RUUHVSRQHQW DL[t .RQVWDWHP TXH D OD ELODELDO GHO .DELOHQ. KL .RUUHVSRQ XQD YHODU L TXH D OHV XYXODUV ODELDOLW]DGHVKL.RUUHVSRQHQXYXODUVVHQVHODELDOLW]DU
  85. 85. HEEZJZXZ@ µ.RXUH¶YHUE
  86. 86. Z DPHTT UDQDPHTTUDQ µJUDQ¶ Z WD[ ]DQWWD[]DQW µDUPDUL¶ Z DO HPDOHP µ.DPHOO¶ /HV.RQVRQDQWVIDULQJDOLW]DGHVHVSURQXQ.LHQD.RPSDQDQWO¶DUWL.XOD.LyGHQWDOR DOYHRODUG¶XQD.RVWDPHQWGHO¶DUUHOGHODOOHQJXDDOYHOGHOSDODGDUDOSXQWG¶DUWL.XOD.Ly GHODNLHVWUHQHQWDOPDWHL[WHPSVODIDULQJHpVDGLUHO.RQGX.WHSHURQSDVVDO¶DLUHDO IRQV GH OD ER.D (O SUR.pV GH YHODULW]D.Ly TXH V¶REWp D.RVWDQW OD OOHQJXD DO SXQW
  87. 87. G¶DUWL.XOD.Ly GH OD N pV HO .RPSRQHQW IRQDPHQWDO G¶DTXHVWD DUWL.XOD.Ly L WDQW DTXHVW SUR.pV.RPO¶HIH.WHTXHSURGXHL[GHVRPpVJUHXTXHO¶KDELWXDOVyQGHODPDWHL[DPHQD TXHHOVTXH.DUD.WHULW]HQODO.DWDODQDSHUzWRWSOHJDWpVPpVPDU.DW7DPEp.RPHQHO .DVGHODOYHODULW]DGDDTXHVWDSURQXQ.LD.LyHVIDSDUWL.XODUPHQWVHQVLEOHHQOHVYR.DOV LPPHGLDWHVTXHUHVXOWHQDPEXQVR.DUD.WHUtVWL.PpVJUHXPpVWDQ.DWHQHO.DVGHODD± SHQVHX HQ OD D GH OD SDUDXOD LJXDO± PpV REHUW HQ HO .DV GH OD L L GH OD X TXH GRQHQ YHUVLRQVSDUWL.XODUVGHHLGHR
  88. 88. DWŽWŽDV µPROW¶ TGŽD µD.DEDU¶ QTHVŽ µIDOWDU¶ ]ŽHU µYHXUH¶ UŽUŽX] µDUUzV¶ /DVLOD]VyQDQWHULRUVUHVSH.WHDOHVGHO.DWDOj R OHV GHO .DVWHOOj HVWUL.WH VyQ PpVDYLDW.RPOHVGHOIUDQ.qVROHVGHOHVYDULHWDWVDWOjQWLTXHVGHO¶HVSDQRO
  89. 89. VHUV µSRVDU¶ L]L µPRV.D¶ /HVDIUL.DGHVWˆ L]X VyQSURQXQ.LDGHVWV@LG]@DPEODPDWHL[DDUWL.XOD.LyGHVL GH ] TXH D.DEHP GH YHXUH 6yQ DEVHQWV GH OD PDMRU SDUW GH OHV YDULHWDWV EHUEHUV L QR WRUQDUDQDDSDUqL[HUHQODQRVWUDGHV.ULS.Ly /DOpV.RPODGHO.DVWHOOjSHUzHQDOJXQV.DVRVSHUH[HPSOHTXDQpVWHQVDHV IDULQJDOLW]DLWDO.RPKHPYLVWDGTXLUHL[XQVRGHODPHQDGHOGHODO.DWDODQDSHUzPpV PDU.DW9HXUHPTXHHQULIHQODOpVJHQHUDOPHQWSURQXQ.LDGD.RPXQDU /HVDOYHRSDODWDOV.LM.RUUHVSRQHQDOVVRQVHV.ULWVHQ.DWDOjL[6@LM=@
  90. 90. PX. µJDW¶ UDMD µHVSHUDU¶
  91. 91. /HVDIUL.DGHV.RUUHVSRQHQWVþW6@L÷G=@WDPEpH[LVWHL[HQHQ.DWDOjHQEHUEHU QR VyQ SDV JHQHUDOV SHUz VyQ SURX PpV HVWHVHV TXH OHV DIUL.DGHV GHQWDOV 7DO .RP YHXUHP PpV HQGDYDQW HQ ULIHQ SRGHQ .RUUHVSRQGUH D OD SURQXQ.LD.Ly GH OW L GH OO JUDILHVTXHVyQVRYLQWVXEVWLWXwGHVSHUþL÷YJ7LOPDWLQHHWDO
  92. 92. (O.DELOHQ.Wp DIUL.DGHVDOYHRSDODWDOVTXHHV.RUUHVSRQHQUHJXODUPHQWDPEIUL.DWLYHVWHQVHVGHOULIHQ
  93. 93. HþH.. µPHQMDU¶ L÷LMM µXQ¶ /D T T@ pV XQD R.OXVLYD XYXODU SURQXQ.LDGD IHQW UH.XODU OD OOHQJXD ILQV D OD .DPSDQHWD SXQW G¶DUWL.XOD.Ly GH OD U IUDQ.HVD /D IUL.DWLYD XYXODU VRQRUD ´@ .RUUHVSRQDODSURQXQ.LD.LyD.WXDOGHODUGHOIUDQ.qV.RPXQDJIUL.DWLYDSURQXQ.LDGD HQGDUUHUH/DIUL.DWLYDXYXODUVRUGD[@WpXQDDUWL.XOD.LyPpVDYDQoDGDTXHODGHOD VRQRUDLGHVGHOSXQWGHYLVWDIRQqWL.HVSRW.RQVLGHUDUYHODUYHDVHUODMGHO.DVWHOOj
  94. 94. DTQHQQL µ.RQLOO¶ DHPEXE µ.DUD¶ D[[DP µKDELWD.Ly¶ /DIUL.DWLYDIDULQJDOVRUGDKŽ Ò@HVSURGXHL[IHQWIUHJDUO¶DLUHHQWUHO¶DUUHOGHOD OOHQJXD L OD IDULQJH TXH V¶HVWUHQ WDO .RP KHP GHV.ULW SHU D OHV IDULQJDOLW]DGHV ID O¶HIH.WH G¶XQD DVSLUD.Ly DPE XQ VR GH IUL..Ly PDU.DW L D.RPSDQDW G¶XQD UHVVRQjQ.LD JUHX/DIDULQJDOVRQRUD¸@pVPpVDYLDWXQDVHPLYR.DOLHVSURQXQ.LDD.RVWDQWO¶DUUHO GHODOOHQJXDDODIDULQJHTXHV¶HVWUHQHVWUD.WDG¶XQVROOHXJHUSR.SHU.HSWLEOH
  95. 95. KŽPD µSURWHJLU¶ VVDG µIHOL.LWDW¶ /D IUL.DWLYD ODULQJDO K Ü@ pV XQD DVSLUD.Ly SURGXwGD SHO SDV GH O¶DLUH SHU OD ODULQJH(QEHUEHU.RPHQjUDEpVJHQHUDOPHQWVRQRUD.RPO¶DVSLUD.LyGHO¶DQGDO~VD ODSDUDXODSDMD
  96. 96. ZDK µVt¶
  97. 97. /¶DPD]LJWpOHVGXHVVHPLYR.DOVTXHWUREHPHQ.DWDOjM@LZZ@
  98. 98. GHD µDYLDW¶ DGL µJRV¶ EDZ µIDYD¶ DZDO µSDUDXOD¶ 6HJRQV HOV .RQWH[WRV DOWHUQHQ DPE OHV YR.DOV L L X SHUz YHXUHP TXH WDPEp SRGHQHQWUDUHQDOWHUQDQ.HVDPE.RQVRQDQWV RPMDKHPDSXQWDWHOEHUEHUGREODJDLUHEpWRWVHOVVHXVVRQV.RQVRQjQWL.VDPE .RQVRQDQWV WHQVHV TXH V¶KL RSRVHQ IRQROzJL.DPHQW GH YHJDGHV DPE IXQ.LRQV PRUIROzJLTXHVHVSH.tILTXHVHVSDUODG¶XQDRSRVL.LyHQWUH.RQVRQDQWVOD[HVLWHQVHV'HV G¶XQ SXQW GH YLVWD IRQqWL. OHV .RQVRQDQWV WHQVHV VROHQ VHU PpV OODUJXHV TXH OHV OD[HV SHUzODGLVWLQ.LyHVPDQLIHVWDGHYHJDGHVSHUG¶DOWUHVPLWMDQV.RPDUDO¶RSRVL.LyHQWUH .RQVRQDQWVR.OXVLYHVLIUL.DWLYHVDOGHVWD.DUTXHODQRWpXQDSDUHOODWHQVDLTXHHQ HOV.DVRVHQTXqSRGUtHPHVSHUDUWUREDUODGLQVGHOMR.GHOHVRSRVL.LRQVPRUIROzJLTXHV DSDUHL[ XQD T WHQVD /D GŽ HQWUD HQ RSRVL.Ly DPE OD VRUGD WŽWŽ /HV VHPLYR.DOV L Z V¶RSRVHQDJJLJJZUHVSH.WLYDPHQW
  99. 99. DPHQ µ.UHXUH¶ PPHW µPRULU¶ QH µPDWDU¶ LQHTT µPDWDHVWjPDWDQW¶ UDMD µHVSHUDU¶ HMM µGHL[DU¶ VHTVD µSUHJXQWDU¶ TTHG µ.UHPDU¶ GŽHZ µYRODU¶ LWŽWŽDZ µYRODHVWjYRODQW¶ ]ZD µWUDYHVVDU¶ L]HJJZD µWUDYHVVDHVWjWUDYHVVDQW¶ (Q PROWHV YDULHWDWV VREUHWRW GHO QRUG OHV .RQVRQDQWV R.OXVLYHV OD[HV .RQHL[HQ UHDOLW]D.LRQVIUL.DWLYHVVHJRQVXQIHQRPHQVHPEODQWDOGHO¶DUWL.XOD.LyGHEGLJGHO .DWDOjLGHO¶HVSDQROHQSDUDXOHV.RPD.DEDUSRGHULSDJDU/DGLIHUqQ.LDpVTXHHQ EHUEHU OD IUL.DWLYLW]D.Ly DIH.WD WDPEp OHV .RQVRQDQWV VRUGHV $L[t XQD W HV SRW SURQXQ.LDU .RP XQD ] GHO .DVWHOOj R XQD N DPE VRQV LQWHUPHGLV HQWUH HO GH OD M GHO .DVWHOOjLHOGHODL[GHO.DWDOjWDOpVHO.DVGHOULIHQ
  100. 100. (O.RQVRQDQWLVPHGHOULIHQ $.DEHP GH YHXUH TXH HQ ULIHQ OHV R.OXVLYHV OD[HV VyQ GH IHW IUL.DWLYHV $ GLIHUqQ.LDGHOTXHIDQDOJXQVDXWRUVKHPSUR.XUDWHV.ULXUHDTXHVWVVRQVDPEODJUDILDGH OHV R.OXVLYHV HQWHQHQW TXH HQ JHQHUDO HV SRW GHL[DU D UHJOHV GH OH.WXUD OD UHDOLW]D.Ly IUL.DWLYD L TXH pV VHPSUH PLOORU XWLOLW]DU XQD IRUPD HV.ULWD TXH YDJL HQ HO VHQWLW GH OD LQWHU.RPSUHQVLy HQWUH HOV EHUEHUzIRQV GH GLYHUVRV RUtJHQV $L[t GRQ.V .DOGUj WHQLU SUHVHQW TXH OD E HV OOHJHL[ .RP OD GHO .DWDOj TXDQ pV HQWUH YR.DOV OD W L OD G UHVSH.WLYDPHQWDPEHOVVRQVGHOD]GHO.DVWHOOjLGHODWKGHO¶DQJOqVHQODSDUDXODWKDW ODNDPEXQVR.RPHOGHL[GHO.DWDOjSHUzVHQVHHOVHX.DUj.WHUVLELODQWo@ODNZV¶KL .RQIRQODJVRQD.RPODLODJZHVSURQXQ.LD.RPXQDZDOODUJDGD
  101. 101. E %@ LEDZHQ µIDYHV¶ EDHO µ.RUE¶ W 7@ WDQDUW µIURQW¶ WDPDUW µGRQD¶ G è@ DGHI µHQWUDU¶ IXG µJHQROO¶ N o@ VNHQ µHQVHQDU¶ DPNDQ µOOR.¶ J M@ DUJD] µKRPH¶ XJXU µ.DPLQDU¶ Z Z N o@ DN HUDNHU µUREDU¶ Z J Z@ WDJZXUW µSRUWD¶ /DWLODGPDQWHQHQO¶DUWL.XOD.LyR.OXVLYDTXDQHQWUHQHQ.RQWD.WHHQWUHHOOHVR GDUUHUHG¶XQDQ/DPGDYDQWGHWRGHGHVSURQXQ.LD.RPXQDQ
  102. 102. DGWDVHG DWDVè@ µYLQGUjV¶ WDQGLQW 7DQGLQW@ µ.LXWDW¶ DPWL ¸DQWL@ µWLDSDWHUQD¶ /HV.RQVRQDQWVR.OXVLYHVWHQVHVVHQVHYHULWDEOHRSRVL.LyDPEOHV.RUUHVSRQHQWV OD[HVHVSURQXQ.LHQVRYLQWVHQVHDOODUJDUOHVSDUWL.XODUPHQW(VSRGHQHV.ULXUHGREOHV SHUDDGYHUWLUTXHQRV¶KDQGHSURQXQ.LDUIUL.DWLYHV
  103. 103. LWWD]]HO µ.RUUHHVWj.RUUHQW¶ WLGHWW µYHULWDW¶
  104. 104. +L KD HQVRUGLPHQW GH .RQVRQDQWV TXDQ SUH.HGHL[HQ XQD VRUGD eV HO PDWHL[ IHQRPHQTXHWUREHPUHJXODUPHQWHQ.DWDOjGLVVDEWHSW@(QEHUEHUSRWDIH.WDUWDPEp OHVVHPLYR.DOVZL
  105. 105. WDTVHEW I7@ µ.DVWHOO¶ DGWDVHG W@ µYLQGUjV¶ WDZUDW 7@ µJURJD¶ WDIHTTDW Ò7@ µSHQD¶ WDHQMDW o7@ µ.XOOHUD¶ WIDZW Å7@ µOOXP¶ RQYpGHGHVWD.DUXQDVqULHGHSURQXQ.LD.LRQVGHOULIHQTXHDIH.WHQODO D
  106. 106. /DOVLPSOHpVSURQXQ.LDGDJHQHUDOPHQW.RPXQDU
  107. 107. DZDO µSDUDXOD¶ WZDOD µYHJDGD¶ E
  108. 108. $ODOOGREOHGHODJUDILDKL.RUUHVSRQXQVRDOODUJDW.RPHOGHOJUXSWMGHO.DWDOjHQOD SURQ~Q.LDQRUPDWLYD
  109. 109. HOOL µILOOD¶ WDPHOODOW µRX¶ .
  110. 110. (QDOJXQHV]RQHVHOJUXSOWHVSRWSURQXQ.LDUDPEXQVR.RPHOGH OD JUDILD W[ GHO .DWDOj
  111. 111. WDPHOODOW µRX¶ ZHOWPD µJHUPDQD¶ /DZHQVRUGLGDVRQDD.RPSDQDGDG¶XQOOHXJHUVRGHIUL..LyYHODUHQWUDQV.ULS.LyIRQqWL.DHVUHSUHVHQWD SHOVLJQHÅ@
  112. 112. /DUSHUODVHYDEDQGDWHQGHL[DHPPXGLUVHDILQDOGHVt
  113. 113. ODEDLSURGXHL[GDYDQW VHXXQVRSURSHUDOGHODDLXQDPDU.DGDREHUWXUDGHODLLGHODXUHVSH.WLYDPHQW.DSD HLR
  114. 114. DMHU µVXSHUDUpVVHUPpVJUDQ¶ DKŽHQMLU µQHQ¶ WDPXUW µWHUUD¶ $OJXQHV .DUD.WHUtVWLTXHV GHO .RQVRQDQWLVPH ULIHQ SRGHQ LQIOXHQ.LDU OD SURQXQ.LD.LyGHO.DWDOjeVHO.DVGHO¶DEVqQ.LDRGHODGLVWULEX.LyOLPLWDGDGHOVVRQVGH OO L GH Q 3HO TXH ID DO SULPHU HO IHW TXH QR KL VLJXL HQ EHUEHU HV .RPELQD DPE OD LQIOXqQ.LD GH O¶HVSDQRO SHUTXq SXJXL IDOWDU HQ OD SURQXQ.LD.Ly .DWDODQD GHOV ULIHQV G¶DOWUDEDQGDWRWVGRVVRQVSDODWDOVSRGHQVHUSURQXQ.LDWVDPEGLIL.XOWDWHQGHWHUPLQDWV .RQWH[WRVSHUH[HPSOHGDYDQWGHV
  115. 115. DQVXOOV /¶DUWL.XOD.LyGLIHUHQWGHODVLGHOD]HQEHUEHULHQ.DWDOjSRWVHUOD.DXVDGHOD .RQIXVLyG¶DOJXQVG¶DTXHVWVVRQVLTXHHVSURQXQ.LwXQD]@.RPVLIRVXQDM
  116. 116. SRVDU /DSURQXQ.LD.LyULIHQDGHODOHVIDQRWDUGHYHJDGHVHQILQDOGHVt
  117. 117. ODEDGHWDO PDQHUDTXHVHVHQWXQDU
  118. 118. EDO.yIDOGLOOHV ,19(17$5,'(/(692$/6'(/%(5%(5,326,,Ï'(/¶$(17 (O VLVWHPD YR.jOL. GHO EHUEHU .RPSWD QRPpV DPE WUHV IRQHPHV D L X 6L HO .RPSDUHP DPE HO GHO .DWDOj WLQGUHP OD LPSUHVVLy TXH DTXHVW GDUUHU pV PROW PpV .RPSOH[
  119. 119. )RQHPHVYR.jOL.VGHO¶DPD]LJ DQWHULRU .HQWUDO SRVWHULRUDUURGRQLW
  120. 120. WDQ.DWV L X EDL[ D )RQHPHVYR.jOL.VGHO.DWDOj DQWHULRUV .HQWUDO SRVWHULRUV DUURGRQLWV
  121. 121. WDQ.DWV L X VHPLWDQ.DWV H R VHPLREHUWV ( o EDL[ D 3HU D .RPSOHWDU HO .RQMXQW GH OHV YR.DOV GHO .DWDOj KL DIHJLUtHP O¶DQRPHQDGD YR.DOQHXWUD@TXHQRpVXQIRQHPDDXWzQRP 6LHVWpHQ.RPSWHHOQRPEUHGHVRQVHIH.WLXVUHVXOWDTXHODSURQXQ.LD.LyGHOHV YR.DOV GHO EHUEHU pV G¶XQD .RQVLGHUDEOH .RPSOH[LWDW /HV UHDOLW]D.LRQV TXH SRGHP .RQVLGHUDU EjVLTXHV VyQ O¶DQWHULRU  @ SHU D D L O¶REHUWD SHU D L ,@ L X 8@ DTXHVWD GDUUHUD SURX VRYLQW pV WDPEp DYDQoDGD (Q WRW .DV V¶KD GH WHQLU SUHVHQW TXH OD SURQXQ.LD.Ly GH OHV YR.DOV GH O¶DPD]LJ YDULD .RQVLGHUDEOHPHQW VHJRQV HOV .RQWH[WRV L TXH XQ LQYHQWDUL GHOV VRQV UHDOPHQW SURQXQ.LDWV SUREDEOHPHQW VXSHUDULD HO GHOV TXH H[LVWHL[HQHQ.DWDOj (OEHUEHU.RQHL[WDPEpXQDYR.DOQHXWUDH@TXHQRWpYDORUIRQROzJL.SHUz TXH DSDUHL[ DPE HQWLWDW L DPE WLPEUH PROW YDULDEOHV SHU D ID.LOLWDU OD SURQXQ.LD.Ly GH JUXSV.RQVRQjQWL.VH[.HVVLYDPHQW.RPSOH[RV
  122. 122. /¶DPSOLWXG GH UHDOLW]D.LRQV GH OHV YR.DOV GH O¶DPD]LJ TXH QR .RUUHVSRQ D RSRVL.LRQV IRQROzJLTXHV HIH.WLYHV VXSRVD XQD GLIL.XOWDW DIHJLGD HQ O¶DGTXLVL.Ly GH OD SURQXQ.LD.LyGHOOHQJHV.RPHO.DWDOjHQTXq.DOIL[DU.RPDSHUWLQHQWVOHVGLVWLQ.LRQV TXHHQODOOHQJXDG¶RULJHQQRKRVyQDL[tOHV.RQIXVLRQVGHYR.DOVSDUWL.XODUPHQWGHH LGHLVyQ.DUD.WHUtVWLTXHVGHODSURQXQ.LD.Ly.DWDODQDGHOVEHUEHUzIRQV
  123. 123. H@R(@o L@ IL@U µIH@U¶ HVWL@P µHVW(@P¶ @ o L@ SL@
  124. 124. Ot.XOD µS@
  125. 125. Ot.XOD¶ KHPTXL@GDW µKHPTX@GDW¶ GLYL@UWLGD µGLY@UWLGD¶ D@ o L@ PH.L@QL. µPH.D@QL.¶ L@ o H@ EH@JRWL µEL@JRWL¶ GH@QWUH µGL@QWUH¶ H@R(@o D@ PD@QMR µPH@QMR¶ SDUD@OOD µSDU(@OOD¶ /¶DPD]LJWpXQD..HQWG¶LQWHQVLWDWHQTXqHOWUHWUHOOHYDQWpVO¶DOWXUDPXVL.DOSHU VREUH GH OD IRUoD GH OD YHX L GH OD GXUDGD VL
  126. 126. OjEL.D DTXHVWD .DUD.WHUtVWL.D HO OOLJD IRUWDPHQWDO¶HQWRQD.LyGHODIUDVHILQVDOSXQWTXHpVDTXHVWDODTXHGH.LGHL[ODSRVL.Ly GHILQLWLYD GHOV D..HQWV HQ HO GLV.XUV L TXH VL HV SRW SDUODU G¶D..HQW HQ OHV SDUDXOHV DwOODGHV pV QRPpV HQ OD PHVXUD HQ TXq VyQ SURQXQ.LDGHV DGDSWDQWKL OHV UHJOHV G¶HQWRQD.LyLG¶D..HQWXD.LyGHODIUDVHKDNHU
  127. 127. 7$8/$'(/66216,'(/(6*5$),(6'(/%(5%(5 (Q OD WDXOD VHJHQW ILJXUHQ
  128. 128. OD JUDILD HQ DOIDEHW OODWt
  129. 129. HO VHX YDORU HQ DOIDEHW IRQqWL. LQWHUQD.LRQDO DPE OHV YDULD.LRQV SULQ.LSDOV
  130. 130. HO QRP GH OD OOHWUD HQ
  131. 131. EHUEHU
  132. 132. OD JUDILD HQ WLILQDJ VHJRQV O¶~V PDUURTXt UHYLVWD 7LILQDJK GHV
  133. 133. DPE HOV VLJQHV GLIHUHQWV TXH ILJXUHQ D 7LOPDWLQH HW DO
  134. 134. SRVDWV HQWUH SDUqQWHVLV
  135. 135. OD OOHWUD jUDE TXH .RUUHVSRQ DO VR EHUEHU L
  136. 136. XQ H[HPSOH GH PRW DPE DTXHVWVRD.RPSDQDWGHODVHYDWUDGX..Ly.DWDODQD/DEDUUD
  137. 137. HQHOQRPGHOHVYR.DOV VLJQLIL.D TXH KL KD GXHV GHQRPLQD.LRQV SRVVLEOHV (Q HO .DV GH OHV .RQVRQDQWV DUURGRQLGHVEZZTZL[ZQRKHPWUREDW.DSQRPSHUzHVSRGULDIRUPDUSDUD
  138. 138. OHODPHQW DOVGHJZHPLNZHPYJWDPEp0DPPHUL
  139. 139. (OVH[HPSOHVVyQHQJHQHUDO ULIHQV TXDQ QR SRGHP L
  140. 140. OXVWUDU HO VR .RUUHVSRQHQW HQ DTXHVWD YDULHWDW GRQHP XQ H[HPSOH .DELOHQ. VHJXLW GH OD VROX.Ly ULIHQD TXH VH Q¶DSDUWD QRPpV SHU DOJXQ GHWDOO IRQqWL. JUDILD YDORU QRP WLILQDJ DOLIDW H[HPSOH D 4@ DDUD D  WDUZDµILOOV¶ E E@%@ ED E  LEDZHQµIDYHV¶ EZ E:@ HEEZJZµ.RXUHY¶ . 6@ .D . µ PX.µJDW¶ þ W6@ Hþ É HþH..µPHQMDU¶ G G@è@ GD G © GDµDTXt¶ GŽ G•@è•@ GŽDUŽ U'
  141. 141. ½ TGŽDµD.DEDU¶ H @ LOHP H DTHPPXPµER.D¶ I I@ ID -I
  142. 142. Ñ IXVµPj¶ J J@M@ JD J HJJµIHU¶ JZ J:@Z@ JZHP JJZHGµWHQLUSRU¶ ÷ G=@ H÷ R  L÷LMMµXQ¶ ´@ DUŽ Í DHPEXEµ.DUD¶ Z ´:@ DOZHP DOHPµ.DPHOO¶ K Ü@ KD EK
  143. 143. é ZDKµVt¶ KŽ Ò@ KŽLP + ¡ KŽPDµSURWHJLU¶ L ,@ LLUL WL[VLµRYHOOD¶ M =@ MD M UDMDµHVSHUDU¶ N N@o@ ND N Ù NNHVµWUHXUH¶ NZ N:@o@ NZHP VVHNNZDUµVX.UH¶ O O@U@ OD O Ý LOLµpVVHU¶ P P@ PD P á PDUUDµWRW¶ Q Q@ QD Q å LQLµGLU¶ S S@ HQPDQOOHXV
  144. 144. SLVXµSLV¶ T T@ TLO T Õ DTQHQQLµ.RQLOO¶
  145. 145. TZ T:@ DPHTTZUDQ DPHTTUDQµJUDQ¶ ¸@ LO ˆÂ É VVDGµIHOL.LWDW¶ U U@ UD U ­ LUDUµMXJDU¶ UŽ U•@ UŽDUŽ 6 UŽUŽX]µDUUzV¶ V V@ VD V ± VHUVµSRVDU¶ VŽ V•@ VŽDUŽ 6 ¹ QTHVŽµIDOWDU¶ W W@7@ WD W • WDEUDWWµ.DUWD¶ WŽ W•@ WŽDUŽ 7'
  146. 146. Á DWŽWŽDVµPROW¶ WV@ H 3 WLGHWLGHWWµYHULWDW¶ X 8@ XXUX X IXGµJHQROO¶ Z Z@ ZD í KZDµEDL[DU¶ [ @ [D [ ¥ D[[DPµKDELWD.Ly¶ [Z :@ WD[Z]DQW WD[]DQWµDUPDUL¶ M@ D ñ D]ŽLGŽµJDOO¶ ] ]@ ]D ] ¯ L]LµPRV.D¶ ]Ž ]•@ ]ŽDUŽ = ]ŽHUµYHXUH¶ ]ˆ G]@ H]ˆ DJH]ˆ]ˆDU DJH]]DUµ.DUQLVVHU¶ 025)2/2*,$ /¶(6758785$'(/60276 /DSULPHUD.DUD.WHUtVWL.DDGHVWD.DUGHODPRUIRORJLDGHODOOHQJXDEHUEHUpVHO .RQMXQWGHUH.XUVRVTXHXWLOLW]DSHUDODIOH[LyLODGHULYD.LyHOVGHULYDWVLOHVIRUPHVGH IOH[LyHVIRUPHQSHUSUHIL[D.LyLVXIL[D.LyLWDPEpPRGLIL.DQWODGRWD.LyYR.jOL.DGHOV PRWV L OD TXDOLWDW JDLUHEp VHPSUH OD WHQVLy GH OHV .RQVRQDQWV TXH .RQWHQHQ $L[t HO VXEVWDQWLXTXHVLJQLIL.DµPXOD¶DVHUGXQHQODIRUPDGHVLQJXODUTXHD.DEHPGHGRQDU HV SRW UHSUHVHQWDU DPE DTXHVWD IyUPXOD TXH UHIOH.WHL[ OHV YR.DOV L XVD .RQYHQ.LRQDOPHQW OD OOHWUD SHU D TXDOVHYRO .RQVRQDQW DX KL WUREHP OD YR.DO LQL.LDO D KDELWXDO SHU DOV QRPV PDV.XOLQV VLQJXODUV ±UH.RUGHP TXH OD H pV QRPpV XQD YR.DOGHVXSRUW(OSOXUDOLUUHJXODUHQ.DQYLWpODIRUPDLDLVHUGDQHQTXqODL LQL.LDOpVSUzSLDGHOVQRPVHQPDV.XOtSOXUDO
  147. 147. DX6*
  148. 148. o LD3/
  149. 149. DVHUGXQµPXOD¶ LVHUGDQµPXOHV¶ 3RGHP.RPSDUDUDTXHVW.RPSRUWDPHQWDPEHOGHQRPVUHJXODUVHQTXqHOSOXUDO HVIRUPDVLPSOHPHQW.DQYLDQWODDLQL.LDOHQLLDIHJLQWHOVXIL[H
  150. 150. QQDPEXQDYR.DO GHVXSRUW
  151. 151. D DD6*
  152. 152. o LDQ3/
  153. 153. DUJD]µKRPH¶ LUJD]HQµKRPHV¶ E DD6*
  154. 154. o LDQ3/
  155. 155. DQHJPDUµ.DoDGRU¶ LQHJPDUHQµ.DoDGRUV¶ $TXHVWGDUUHUH[HPSOHpVDOVHXWRUQXQQRPGHULYDWGHOYHUEJPHUµ.DoDU¶±HV WUD.WD GHO UDGL.DO VRO TXH .RLQ.LGHL[ DPE OD IRUPD GH O¶LPSHUDWLX VLQJXODU YJ †
  156. 156. ± IRUPDW SHU O¶DGMXQ.Ly GHO SUHIL[ DQ L OD LQVHU.Ly GH OD YR.DO D GDYDQW GH O¶~OWLPD .RQVRQDQW SHU XQ SUR.HGLPHQW VHPEODQW SRGHP IRUPDU XQ QRP G¶D..Ly DGMXQWDQWHOSUHIL[DLLQVHULQWODYR.DODWDPEpGDYDQWGHODGDUUHUD.RQVRQDQW
  157. 157. D 5$'
  158. 158. o DQDQRPG¶DJHQW
  159. 159. JPHUUDGL.DOGHµ.DoDU¶
  160. 160. DQHJPDUµ.DoDGRU¶ E 5$'
  161. 161. o DDQRPG¶D..Ly
  162. 162. JPHUUDGL.DOGHµ.DoDU¶
  163. 163. DJPDUµ.DoD¶ 6L SUHQHP HO YHUE TXH VLJQLIL.D µEXV.DU¶ U]X OD IRUPD GH OD WHU.HUD SHUVRQD PDV.XOLQDGHOSHUIH.WLXV¶REWpDPEHOSUHIL[LGDYDQWG¶XQD.RQVRQDQW~QL.DOD[D
  164. 164. TXHH[SUHVVDODSHUVRQDYHUEDOHU]XLODIRUPDKDELWXDOGXUDWLYD.RUUHVSRQHQW.DQYLDQW OD.RQVRQDQWOD[D]SHUXQDGHWHQVD]]LUH]]X
  165. 165. D X5$'
  166. 166. o X0$63(5)
  167. 167. U]XUDGL.DOGHµEXV.DU¶
  168. 168. HU]XµKDEXV.DW¶ E X5$'
  169. 169. o X0$6+$%
  170. 170. U]XUDGL.DOGHµEXV.DU¶
  171. 171. LUH]]XµEXV.DHVWjEXV.DQW¶
  172. 172. $%6Ê1,$'¶$57,/( (OEHUEHUQR.RQHL[XQHTXLYDOHQWGHO¶DUWL.OHGHOHVOOHQJHVURPjQLTXHVHOQRP DSDUHL[ .RP D GHILQLW R LQGHILQLW VHJRQV OD IXQ.Ly TXH ID HQ HO GLV.XUV 7UDGXLUHP OD IUDVHGHO¶H[HPSOHVHJHQW.RPXQDSDSDOORQDVH¶QYDYRODQWR.RPODSDSDOORQDVH¶Q YDYRODQWVHJRQVTXHODGLJXHPHQREVHUYDU.DVXDOPHQWXQDSDSDOORQDTXHVXUWYRODQWR TXH SDUOHP G¶XQD SDSDOORQD TXH KHP HVWDW REVHUYDQW R TXH MD KHP HVPHQWDW DQWHULRUPHQW4XLWRXWDGDSWDW
  173. 173. 7HGŽHZWKŽHULMDW YRODU3(5)SDSDOORQD$11(; µ/DXQDSDSDOORQDVH¶QYDYRODQW¶ 4XDQ O¶DUWL.OH GHO .DWDOj LQWURGXHL[ XQ DGMH.WLX O¶DPD]LJ UH.RUUH D XQ SURQRP GHPRVWUDWLXHVSH.tIL.YJ†
  174. 174. 5HSUHVHQWDXQDGLIL.XOWDWSHUDOVEHUEHUzIRQVGRPLQDUO¶~VGHO¶DUWL.OHGHO.DWDOj SDUWL.XODUPHQWTXDQKLKDH[SUHVVLRQVHQTXqQRV¶XWLOLW]DDOHVTXDOVpVIj.LOHVWHQGUH¶O DEXVLYDPHQW
  175. 175. D ±GHTXqW¶KDYLHVGLVIUHVVDW@±GHOPHWJH E DQDUpDPEHOEDU.R (/120 (OJqQHUHGHOVQRPV (OV QRPV DPD]LJV .RP HOV GHO .DWDOj SRGHQ VHU PDV.XOLQV R IHPHQLQV SHUz .RPHUDG¶HVSHUDUHOJqQHUHG¶XQQRPQRPpV.RLQ.LGHL[DPEHOGHODVHYDWUDGX..LyR SHU .DVXDOLWDW R TXDQ pV PRWLYDW SHO VH[H GH O¶pVVHU GHVLJQDW 6yQ PDV.XOLQV SHU H[HPSOH
  176. 176. DUJD] µKRPH¶ LOV µOOHQJXD¶ X]]DO µIHUUR¶ 6yQIHPHQLQV
  177. 177. WDPDUW µGRQD¶ WVD µIHWJH¶ WLOL µRPEUD¶ (OVJqQHUHVGLIHUHQWVGHOVQRPVHQEHUEHULHQ.DWDOjVyQO¶RULJHQG¶DOJXQHV.RQIXVLRQV HQHOGLV.XUV.DWDOjGHOVSDUODQWVG¶DPD]LJ
  178. 178. D VLQRVpOHVGHXUHV
  179. 179. PHSHJXHQ E WpXQD.RW[H 7DPEpSRWVHUXQDIRQWG¶HUURUVO¶~VIL[DWGHSOXUDOVDPEQRPVHVSH.tIL.V
  180. 180. WRWVHOVVHXVGLQHUVO¶KDYLDJDVWDWSHUDL[z /D IRUPD PpV IUHTHQW GHOV QRPV PDV.XOLQV pV OD GHOV TXH .RPHQ.HQ SHU OD YR.DODVyQSURXQRPEURVRVWDPEpHOVTXH.RPHQ.HQSHUOHVYR.DOVLLX
  181. 181. D DWELU µ.RORP¶ DVHUGXQ µPXOD¶ E LIUL µ.RYD¶ LJHU µ.DPS¶ . XGHP µ.DUD¶ X..HQ µ[D.DOOORS¶ 3HUzQ¶KLKDVHQVHYR.DOLQL.LDO.RPHOVVHJHQWV
  182. 182. OD]Ž µJDQD¶ IDG µVHW¶ (Q ULIHQ G¶DOWUD EDQGD IDOWD VRYLQW OD D LQL.LDO SUHVHQW HQ G¶DOWUHV YDULHWDWV EHUEHUV
  183. 183. GŽDU DGŽDU µSHX.DPD¶ EDZ DEDZ µIDYD¶ D]ŽLGŽ DD]ŽLGŽ µJDOO¶ (OV DUDELVPHV QR DGDSWDWV .RPSOHWDPHQW TXH SRUWHQ O¶DUWL.OH jUDE LQ.RUSRUDW .RPHQ.HQ SHU XQD O SURQXQ.LDGD HQ ULIHQ .RP XQD U YJ †
  184. 184. R SHU XQD .RQVRQDQW GHQWDO DOYHRODU R SDODWDO W WŽ G GŽ V VŽ ] ]Ž Q O . M
  185. 185. JHQHUDOPHQW WHQVD UHVXOWDWGHO¶DVVLPLOD.LyGHO¶DUWL.OHjUDEDDTXHVWHV.RQVRQDQWV
  186. 186. D OPXDOOLP µPHVWUH¶ O[HPLV µGLMRXV¶ ONXUVL µ.DGLUD¶ E VVXT µPHU.DW¶ WWDUL[ µGDWD¶ ..DUU µJXHUUD¶ (OVQRPVIHPHQLQV.RPHQ.HQSUj.WL.DPHQWVHPSUHSHUXQDWVHJXLGDG¶XQDDHQ ODPDMRULDGHOV.DVRVPROWVRYLQWD.DEHQWDPEpHQW
  187. 187. D WDEUDWW µ.DUWD¶ WDGGDUW µ.DVD¶ WDHQMDW µ.XOOHUD¶
  188. 188. E WLVLW µPLUDOO¶ WXGDUW µYLGD¶ W.XTTHW µWHOD¶ WLPHVVL µIR.¶ WLPHVQD µVDYLHVD¶ WDNH..D µ.X.¶ 7DO.RPR.RUUHDPEODDLQL.LDOGHOVPDV.XOLQVWDPEpODDGHOSUHIL[IHPHQtWD IDOWDVRYLQWHQULIHQGLQVGHSDUDXOHVTXHODWHQHQHQG¶DOWUHVYDULHWDWV
  189. 189. WPDUW WDPDUW µEDUED¶ WVD WDVD µIHWJH¶ WD]ŽLGŽWŽ WDD]ŽLGŽWŽ µJDOOLQD¶ ([LVWHL[ XQD .RUUHVSRQGqQ.LD UHJXODU HQWUH QRPV IHPHQLQV .RPHQoDWV L JHQHUDOPHQW D.DEDWV SHU W L HOV PDV.XOLQV SULYDWV G¶DTXHVWV DIL[RV HO PpV VRYLQW .RPHQoDWVSHUD
  190. 190. DPD]L µEHUEHU¶0$6
  191. 191. WDPD]LW µEHUEHU¶)(0
  192. 192. DPHQ]X µILOOJUDQ¶ WDPHQ]XW µILOODJUDQ¶ DMMDU µYHt¶ WDMMDUW µYHwQD¶ DIXQDV µERX¶ WDIXQDVW µYD.D¶ DOHP µ.DPHOO¶ WDOHPW µ.DPHOOD¶ D]ŽLGŽ µJDOO¶ WD]ŽLGŽWŽ µJDOOLQD¶ (VSRWXWLOLW]DUODIRUPD.LyGHOPDV.XOtG¶XQQRPKDELWXDOPHQWIHPHQtRODGHO IHPHQtG¶XQTXHpVKDELWXDOPHQWPDV.XOtSHUDSURGXLUXQDXJPHQWDWLXHQHOSULPHU.DV L XQ GLPLQXWLX HQ HO VHJRQ 'H YHJDGHV DPE OD UHIHUqQ.LD D XQ REMH.WH R D XQ pVVHU DQLPDWG¶XQDPLGDGLIHUHQW.DQYLDHOVHQWLWGHOVXEVWDQWLX.RPR.RUUHWDPEpHQ.DWDOj .XOOHUD.XOOHURW
  193. 193. D DTHPPXP µER.D¶ WDTHPPXPW µERTXHWD¶ DIHU µIXOOD¶ WDIHUW µIXOOHWD¶ L]L µPRV.D¶ WL]LW µPRVTXLW¶ E WDGGDUW µ.DVD¶ DGGDU µ.DVDVVD¶ WDHQMDW µ.XOOHUD¶ DHQMD µ.XOOHURW¶ WDNH..D µ.X.¶ DNH..DZ µ.X.JURV¶ RP HQ .DWDOj KL KD QRPV PDV.XOLQV L IHPHQLQV UHIHULWV D KRPHV L GRQHV R D PDV.OHVLIHPHOOHVG¶DQLPDOVTXHWHQHQDUUHOVGLIHUHQWV
  194. 194. DUJD] µKRPH¶ WDPDUWWDPHWŽWŽXW µGRQD¶ EDED µSDUH¶ HPPD µPDUH¶ PPL µILOO¶ HOOL µILOOD¶ LNHUUL µPROWy¶ WL[VL µRYHOOD¶ DWUXV µER.¶ WDWŽ µ.DEUD¶ LV µ.DYDOO¶ WDJPDUW µHJXD¶ (OQRPEUHGHOVQRPV 0ROWVQRPVEHUEHUVWHQHQIRUPHVGHSOXUDOTXHV¶REWHQHQDSOL.DQWSUR.HGLPHQWV UHJXODUV SHUz VyQ WDPEp QRPEURVRV HOV TXH XWLOLW]HQ SUR.HGLPHQWV SDUWL.XODUV GH WDO PDQHUDTXHHOERQ~VGHODOOHQJXDUHTXHUHL[O¶DSUHQHQWDWJHVLVWHPjWL.GHOD IRUPDGH SOXUDOGH.DGDVXEVWDQWLX (OVLVWHPDPpVIUHTHQWGHIRUPD.LyGHOSOXUDOGHOVQRPVPDV.XOLQV.RQVLVWHL[D DIHJLU OD WHUPLQD.Ly H
  195. 195. Q Q DPE XQD YR.DO GH VXSRUW
  196. 196. 6L HO PRW .RPHQoD SHU D HV .DQYLD HQ L HQ ULIHQ DTXHVWD L LQL.LDO HV SRW DIHJLU SHUz QR VHPSUH HV ID D XQD .RQVRQDQWLQL.LDOHQPRWVTXH.RPHQ.HQSHUDHQG¶DOWUHVYDULHWDWVYJ†
  197. 197. DUJD] µKRPH¶ LUJD]HQ DIXQDVµERX¶ LIXQDVHQ D]HOOLI µ.DS¶ L]HOOLIHQ GŽDU µSHX.DPD¶ LGŽDUHQ EDZ µIDYD¶ LEDZHQ D]ŽLGŽ µJDOO¶ D]ŽLGŽHQ (OSOXUDOGHOVPRWVPDV.XOLQVHVSRWIRUPDUWDPEpSHOVSUR.HGLPHQWVKDELWXDOV GH OD PRUIRORJLD GH O¶DPD]LJ .DQYLDQW OHV YR.DOV L DOWHUDQW OD WHQVLy .RQVRQjQWL.D L DOODUJDQWHOVUDGL.DOVDPEHOVHOHPHQWVWD
  198. 198. ZDZRLZ$TXHVWVSUR.HGLPHQWVHV SRGHQ.RPELQDULGHYHJDGHVIDOWDHOVXIL[(QDOJXQ.DVHOVXIL[H
  199. 199. QV¶DIHJHL[VHQVH SUHIL[D.Ly
  200. 200. DMMDU µYHt¶ DMMDUHQ DDoDDQ
  201. 201. LLGŽ µ.DEULW¶ LDGŽHQ LLoLDQ
  202. 202. DLO µEUDo¶ LDOOHQ DLoLDQ
  203. 203. DQX µSRX¶ DQXWHQ DXoDXWQ
  204. 204. DGL µJRV¶ LGŽWŽDQ DLoLWDQ
  205. 205. NXUGX µSXoD¶ LNXUGDQ XXoLXDQ
  206. 206. D]ŽZDU µDUUHO¶ L]ŽXZUDQ DDoLXDQ
  207. 207. Z DGHJJ DO µVRJUH¶ LGHZODQ DDoLDQ
  208. 208. GŽDGŽ µGLW¶ LGŽXGŽDQ DoLXDQ
  209. 209. DVV µGLD¶ XVVDQ DoXDQ
  210. 210. PX. µJDW¶ LPX.ZHQ XoLXZQ
  211. 211. L.. µEDQD¶ D..DZHQ LoDDZQ
  212. 212. DIHU µIXOOD¶ DIULZHQ DoDLZQ
  213. 213. DMDUWLO µHVWRUD¶ LMDUWDO DDLoLDD
  214. 214. (OVLVWHPDPpVIUHTHQWGHIRUPD.LyGHOSOXUDOGHOVQRPVIHPHQLQV.RQVLVWHL[D DIHJLUODWHUPLQD.LyLQVLHOPRW.RPHQoDSHUWDDTXHVWSUHIL[HV.DQYLDHQWL+HP YLVWTXHHQULIHQODDGHOSUHIL[VLQJXODUSRWIDOWDUYJ†
  215. 215. OODYRUVDOSOXUDOKLVRO KDYHUODLSHUzQRSDVVHPSUH
  216. 216. WD[]DQW µWHQGD¶ WL[]DQLQ WDPDUW µGRQD¶ WLPDULQ WDEUDWW µ.DUWD¶ WLEUDWLQ WDQDUW µIURQW¶ WLQDULQ WDJPDUW µHJXD¶ WLJPDULQ WVD µIHWJH¶ WLVDZLQ WPDUW µEDUED¶ WLPDULQ WD]ŽLGŽWŽ µJDOOLQD¶ WD]ŽLGŽLQ (OSOXUDOGHOVPRWVIHPHQLQVHVSRWIRUPDUWDPEpDPEHOSUHIL[WLRW.DQYLDQW OHV YR.DOV L DOWHUDQW OD WHQVLy .RQVRQjQWL.D L DOODUJDQW HOV UDGL.DOV DPE HOV HOHPHQWV WD
  217. 217. W
  218. 218. ZW
  219. 219. DZRLZ$TXHVWVSUR.HGLPHQWVHVSRGHQ.RPELQDULHQDOJXQV.DVRV QRKLKDVXIL[
  220. 220. WDGGDUW µ.DVD¶ WXGULQ WDDWoWXLQ
  221. 221. Z WDGHJJ DOW µVRJUD¶ WLGHZOLQ WDDWoWLLQ
  222. 222. WLVLW µPLUDOO¶ WLVLWLQ WLLWoWLLWLQ
  223. 223. WDPHWŽWŽXW µGRQD¶ WLPHWŽWŽXWLQ WDXWoWLXWLQ
  224. 224. WDGLW µJRVVD¶ WLGŽWŽDWLQ WDLWoWLWDWLQ
  225. 225. WL[VL µRYHOOD¶ WL[HVZLQ WLLoWLZLQ
  226. 226. WLWŽWŽ µXOO¶ WLWŽWŽDZLQ WLWoWLWDZLQ
  227. 227. WNHU]D µKLYHUQ¶ WLNHU]LZLQ WDoWLLZLQ
  228. 228. WKŽDQW µERWLJD¶ WLKŽXQD WDWoWLXD
  229. 229. WLWL µ.RS¶ WLLWD WLLoWLLD
  230. 230. (OV PDQOOHXV GH O¶jUDE QR DGDSWDWV .RPSOHWDPHQW PDQWHQHQ HO SOXUDO RULJLQDUL HYHQWXDOPHQWDPEUHDSDUL.LyGHODOGHO¶DUWL.OHDVVLPLODGDDOD.RQVRQDQWLQL.LDOHQHO VLQJXODUREVHUYHXODSDUDXODVVXTGHOVH[HPSOHVVHJHQWV
  231. 231. OPXDOOLPD µPHVWUD¶ OPXDOOLPDW OPXDOOLP µPHVWUH¶ OPXDOODP VVXT µPHU.DW¶ OHVZDT ..DUU µJXHUUD¶ ..DUUDW ONXUVL µ.DGLUD¶ ONHUDVL $OJXQV PRWV G¶RULJHQ jUDE WHQHQ D PpV GH OD IRUPD GH SOXUDO XQ GXDO .RUUHVSRQHQWDGRVLQGLYLGXV
  232. 232. DP µDQ¶ DPDQ µGRV
  233. 233. DQV¶ ODPDWµDQVRPpV
  234. 234. ¶ .KDU µPHV¶ .HKUDQ µGRV
  235. 235. PHVRV¶ O.KXU µPHVRVRPpV
  236. 236. ¶ /DIOH[LyGHOVDGMH.WLXVTXDOLIL.DWLXV (Q DPD]LJ V¶XVHQ KDELWXDOPHQW IRUPHV YHUEDOV SHU D DWULEXLU TXDOLWDWV PpV HQGDYDQW†
  237. 237. KRH[SOL.DUHPDPEPpVGHWDOO$L[zQRSULYDTXHH[LVWHL[LQWDPEp DGMH.WLXV TXDOLIL.DWLXV SDUD
  238. 238. OHOV DOV GHO .DWDOj SHUz GHULYDWV GHOV YHUEV TXH SUHVHQWHQ TXDVLVHPSUHXQDIOH[LyQRPLQDOUHJXODU
  239. 239. PVJ PSO IVJ ISO DZUD LZUDHQ WDZUDW WLZUDLQ µJUR.¶ DPHTTUDQ LPHTTUDQHQ WDPHTTUDQW WLPHTTUDQLQ µJURV¶ DPH]ŽDQ LPH]ŽDQHQ WDPH]ŽDQW WLPH]ŽDQLQ µSHWLW¶ D]HJUDO L]HJUDOHQ WD]HJUDOW WL]HJUDOLQ µOODUJ¶ DVŽHPPDGŽ LVŽHPPDGŽHQ WDVŽHPPDGŽWŽ WLVŽHPPDGŽLQ µIUHG¶ (OVQRPVGHSDUHQWLX (Q.DWDOjTXDQGLHPHOSDUHYROHPGLUHOQRVWUHSDUHRHOPHXSDUHHQEHUEHU GH PDQHUD VHPEODQW WRWD XQD VqULH GH QRPV GH SDUHQWLX SDUWL.XODUPHQW HOV UHIHULWV DO SULPHUJUDXHV.DUD.WHULW]HQSHUTXqWHQHQLQ.RUSRUDWHOVHQWLWGHOSRVVHVVLXGHSULPHUD SHUVRQDGHOVLQJXODU(OVQRPVTXHVLJQLILTXHQSDUHPDUHDYLILOOVLQRSRUWHQ.DS SRVVHVVLXYROHQGLUHOPHXSDUHODPHYDPDUHHOPHXDYLHOPHXILOO$TXHVWVQRPV
  240. 240. DPpVDPpVSRGHQWHQLUIRUPHVGHIOH[LySDUWL.XODUVRVXEVWLWXLUOHVSHUWHUPHVG¶XQD DOWUDDUUHO.RPHQHO.DVGHODSDUDXODWDUZDTXHV¶XWLOLW]D.RPDSOXUDOGHPPLµILOO¶L TXHYROGLUµ.ULDGHV.HQGqQ.LD¶
  241. 241. EDED µSDUHPHX
  242. 242. ¶ HPPD µPDUHPHYD
  243. 243. ¶ MMHGGL µDYLPHX
  244. 244. ¶ KŽHQQD µjYLDPHYD
  245. 245. ¶ OMHGXG µDYLV¶ PPL µILOOPHX
  246. 246. ¶ WDUZD µILOOVPDLQDGD¶ HOOL µILOODPHYD
  247. 247. ¶ HVVL µILOOHVPHYHV
  248. 248. ¶ XPD µJHUPjPHX
  249. 249. ¶ DWPD µJHUPDQVPHXV
  250. 250. ¶ ZHOWPD µJHUPDQDPHYD
  251. 251. ¶ HVVPD µJHUPDQHVPHYHV
  252. 252. ¶ [DOL µRQ.OHPHX
  253. 253. PDWHUQ¶ [DOWL µWLDPHYD
  254. 254. PDWHUQD¶ ]L]LDPPL µRQ.OHPHX
  255. 255. SDWHUQ¶ DPWL µWLDPHYD
  256. 256. SDWHUQD¶ eV LQWHUHVVDQW G¶REVHUYDU OD IRUPD.Ly GHOV PRWV TXH VLJQLILTXHQ µJHUPj¶ L µJHUPDQD¶.RPSRVWRVGHXZHOWµILOOILOODGH¶LPDµPDUH¶YROHQGLUGRQ.VµILOOILOOD GH OD PHYD PDUH¶ $TXHVW .DUj.WHU .RPSRVW H[SOL.D TXH HO SOXUDO VLJXL DSDUHQWPHQW LQWHUQ SHUTXq pV HO SULPHU HOHPHQW GH OD .RPSRVL.Ly HO TXH .DQYLD HVV L VXW VyQ H[SRQHQWVGHODYDULD.LyGLDOH.WDO
  257. 257. X µILOOGH¶ DW µILOOVGH¶ ZHOW µILOODGH¶ HVVVXW µILOOHVGH¶ $TXHVWHVIRUPHVGHSOXUDOTXHVLJQLILTXHQµILOOVILOOHVGH¶V¶KDQJUDPDWL.DOLW]DW V¶XWLOLW]HQSHUDODIRUPD.LyGHGHULYDWVLDUULEHQDIXQ.LRQDU.RPXQDVLPSOHPDU.DGH QRPEUHDPE.HUWVQRPV6DUULRQDQGLD
  258. 258. D EDEQWDGGDUW µO¶DPRGHOD.DVD¶ DWEDEQWDGGDUW µHOVDPRVGHOD.DVD¶ E ODOWQWPHQDW µODUL.DODPHVWUHVVDGHOVGLQHUV
  259. 259. ¶ HVVODOWQWPHQDW µOHVULTXHV¶
  260. 260. (OQRPJHQqUL. (Q.DWDOjIRUDGHO.DVGHOVQRPVQR.RPSWDEOHV.RPODOOHQD HO SD OD OOHW R O¶DUUzVpVJDLUHEpVHPSUHHOSOXUDOGHOJqQHUHKDELWXDOG¶XQVXEVWDQWLXHOTXHV¶XWLOLW]D SHUDH[SUHVVDUHOVHQWLWJHQqUL.DL[tHOVJDWVSRWUHIHULUVHDDTXHVWHVEqVWLHVHQJHQHUDO HQIUDVHV.RPHOVJDWVVyQPROWPDQGURVRVLH[SUHVVLRQV.RPHOJDWpVXQDEqVWLDPROW PDQGURVD VyQ PDU.DGHV HVWLOtVWL.DPHQW 1RPpV DPE HO QRP GH SURGX.WHV YHJHWDOV VREUHWRW GH IUXLWHV pV SURX KDELWXDO G¶HPSUDU HO VLQJXODU DTXHVW DQ OD SUXQD VHUj ERQD8QDSDUWL.XODULWDWGHOEHUEHUpVTXHSHUDO¶H[SUHVVLyGHOJHQqUL.GH.DGDQRPV¶KL KDGHIHUVHUYLUXQDIRUPDSDUWL.XODUGHODVHYDIOH[Ly.RQGL.LRQDGDOq[L.DPHQW
  261. 261. D WDEHWWL[W DEHWWL[ PHOy)(06* PHOy0$66* µPHOy¶ µHOVPHORQV¶JHQqUL.
  262. 262. E LNH..XGŽHQ OOHQHV0$63/ µOOHQD¶µODOOHQD¶JHQqUL.
  263. 263. . WD[VDW .DUDEDVVD)(06* µ.DUDEDVVD¶µOHV.DUDEDVVHV¶JHQqUL.
  264. 264. G WL..LW WL..LLQ SROO)(06* SROOV)(03/ µSROO¶ µHOVSROOV¶JHQqUL.
  265. 265. /¶~VGLIHUHQWGHQRPVJHQqUL.VHQDPD]LJLHQ.DWDOjSRWLQGXLUXVRVHUURQLV
  266. 266. D HOJDWLHOJRVP¶DJUDGHQ µHOVJDWVLHOVJRVVRVP¶DJUDGHQ¶ E PHIDSRUHOJRVTXHHOVJUDQVIDQSRU µHPIDQSRUHOVJRVVRVTXHHOVJURVVRVIDQSRU¶
  267. 267. (VWDWG¶DQQH[LyLHVWDWOOLXUHGHOVQRPV (QDPD]LJH[LVWHL[XQDYDULD.LyGHOVQRPVOOLJDGDDODVHYDSRVL.LyVLQWj.WL.DHQ GHWHUPLQDWV .RQWH[WRV GH GHSHQGqQ.LD G¶DOWUHV HOHPHQWV GH OD IUDVH HOV VXEVWDQWLXV EHUEHUVVRIUHL[HQXQDDOWHUD.LyLHVGLXTXHHVWUREHQHQHVWDWG¶DQQH[LyHOVQRPVTXH QRHVWDQVRWPHVRVDDTXHVW.DQYLHVGLXTXHHVWDQHQHVWDWOOLXUH /¶HVWDWG¶DQQH[LyGHOVQRPVPDV.XOLQVV¶REWp.DQYLDQW
  268. 268. D 8QDDLQL.LDOHQXVLQJXODU
  269. 269. DPDU µVRJUHGHODGRQD¶ o XPDU E 7DPEpKLKDXTXDQODDLQL.LDOIDOWDHQULIHQ D]ŽLGŽ µJDOO¶ o XD]ŽLGŽ . 8QDDLQL.LDOHQZDVLQJXODURSOXUDO
  270. 270. DQX µSRX¶ o ZDQX DNUDUHQ µPROWRQV¶ o ZDNUDUHQ G 8QDLLQL.LDOHQLVLQJXODURSOXUDO
  271. 271. LOHI µSRU.¶ o LOHI LOIDQ µSRU.V¶ o LOIDQ XQDLLQL.LDOSRWTXHGDULQDOWHUDGD
  272. 272. H 8QDXLQL.LDOHQZXVLQJXODURSOXUDO
  273. 273. XO µ.RU¶ o ZXO XODZHQ µ.RUV¶ o ZXODZHQ (QUHDOLWDWQRVyQQRPpVHOVQRPVHOVTXHDGRSWHQO¶HVWDWG¶DQQH[LyHOVLQGHILQLWVHOVSURQRPVLHOV DGYHUELVWDPEpSRGHQIHUKRHOVTXHWHQHQDLQL.LDOLDOJXQVGH.RPHQoDWVSHU.RQVRQDQW
  274. 274. L
  275. 275. D GOXV µSR.PHQV¶ o VXGOXV µDOPHQV¶ E DD µDL[z¶DLQµDOOz¶o DDGZDLQ µDL[zLDOOz¶ . DPPX µDL[t¶ o DPPXGZDPPX µDL[tLDL[t¶
  276. 276. /¶HVWDWG¶DQQH[LyGHOVQRPVIHPHQLQVV¶REWpHOLPLQDQWODYR.DOTXHVHJXHL[ODW LQL.LDO.RPDD
  277. 277. SHUzVRYLQWTXHGHQLQDOWHUDWV.RPDE
  278. 278. D WDPDUW µGRQD¶ o WHPDUW WLPDULQ µGRQHV¶ o WHPDULQ WDWHUELW µPLQRQD¶ o WWHUELW WDVHUGXQW µPXOD¶ o WVHUGXQW WL]JL µERV.¶ o WH]JL E WDGGDUW µ.DVD¶ o WDGGDUW WX..HQW µOORED¶ o WX..HQW WLVLW µPLUDOO¶ o WLVLW WDPPHQW µPHO¶ o WDPPHQW (OQRPYDHQHVWDWG¶DQQH[LyHQHOV.DVRVVHJHQWV D
  279. 279. (QIXQ.LyGHVXEMH.WHSRVSRVDWDOYHUEYJ†6DUULRQDQGLD
  280. 280. D 7WD]]HOHQZDPDQ .yUUHU+$%DLJHV$11(; µ/¶DLJXD.RUUH¶ E HPPXWXXO PRULU3(5)DVH$11(; µ6¶KDPRUWO¶DVH¶ . 8VDQWLGWHPDULQ YHQLU3(5)25,(17GRQHV$11(; µ9DQYHQLUOHVGRQHV¶ E
  281. 281. 'DUUHUH GH OD .RQMXQ.Ly G µL¶ 4XLWRXW DGDSWDWV 6DUULRQDQGLD
  282. 282. 5H.RUGHPTXHODHQRpVPpVTXHXQDYR.DOGHVXSRUWTXHV¶LQVHUHL[SHUDID.LOLWDUODSURQXQ.LD.LyGHOV JUXSV.RQVRQjQWL.V.RPSOH[RV
  283. 283. D X..HQGLQVL [D.DOLHULoy$11(; µHO[D.DOLO¶HULoy¶ E QH..LQGZDMMDUHQ QRVDOWUHVLYHwQV$11(; µHOVYHwQVLQRVDOWUHV¶ . DUJD]GWHPDUW KRPHLGRQD$11(; µO¶KRPHLODGRQD¶ .
  284. 284. 'DUUHUHGHOHVSUHSRVL.LRQVHQJHQHUDO6DUULRQDQGLD
  285. 285. D HUGŽDVDUUXGŽLXKŽHUPX. YHVWLU3521YHVWLWDQHQ$11(; µ3RVDOLHOYHVWLWDOQHQ¶ E 1VDZDO[XPHQL SDUODU+$%VREUHJXHUUD$11(; µ3DUOHPGHODJXHUUD¶ . 5XKŽDNHGWHPHWŽWŽXWD DQDUDPEGRQD$11(;'(0 µ9pVWH¶QDPEDTXHVWDGRQD¶ G
  286. 286. 3DUWL.XODUPHQW.RPD.RPSOHPHQWQRPLQDOGDUUHUHGHODSUHSRVL.Ly QµGH¶ TXHVRYLQWpVRPHVDGDYDQWGHOVQRPVPDV.XOLQV6DUULRQDQGLD
  287. 287. D DUUXGŽQWHPDUW YHVWLWGHGRQD$11(; µHOYHVWLWGHODGRQD¶ E DPDQQZDQX DLJHVGHSRX$11(; µO¶DLJXDGHOSRX¶
  288. 288. . D..DZHQQXIXQDV EDQHVGHERX$11(; µOHVEDQHVGHOERX¶ H
  289. 289. ,QWURGXwW SHU XQ QXPHUDO .DV HQ TXq HV .RPSRUWD .RP XQ .RPSOHPHQW QRPLQDO6DUULRQDQGLD
  290. 290. D WODWDQWXGULQ WUHVGH.DVHV$11(; µWUHV.DVHV¶ E D.UDQLNVDQ GHXGH.DYDOOV$11(; µGHX.DYDOOV¶ '(02675$7,86,35(6(17$7,86 (OVLVWHPDG¶RSRVL.LRQVGHOVGHPRVWUDWLXV (O VLVWHPD GH GHPRVWUDWLXV GH OD OOHQJXD EHUEHU pV IRQDPHQWDO GLQV GHOV VHXV PH.DQLVPHV GH IXQ.LRQDPHQW 3URSRU.LRQD SURQRPV TXH VHUYHL[HQ GH EDVH SHU D OD XWLOLW]D.Ly G¶DOWUHV HOHPHQWV JUDPDWL.DOV LSURGXHL[ XQD ERQD SDUW GH OHV .RQVWUX..LRQV TXH HTXLYDOHQ D OHV IUDVHV GHO .DWDOj DPE KDYHUKL R pVVHUKL '¶XQD PDQHUD PROW JHQHUDOHVSRGHQGLVWLQJLUWUHVSRVL.LRQVDTXqVROHQIHUUHIHUqQ.LDHOVGHPRVWUDWLXVLTXH SRGHP.DUD.WHULW]DUDPEOHVH[SUHVVLRQV.DWDODQHVVHJHQWV 326,,Ï'(/$$3(5621$ODTXHSDUOD
  291. 291. µDTXHVWTXHWLQ.DTXtRQVy.MR¶ 326,,Ï'(/$$3(5621$O¶LQWHUOR.XWRU
  292. 292. µDTXHVWTXHWHQVDTXtRQHWVWX¶
  293. 293. 326,,Ï'(/$$3(5621$TXHQRSDUWL.LSDHQODLQWHUD..LyOLQJtVWL.D
  294. 294. µDTXHOOTXHWpDOOjRQpVHOO¶ (O.DWDOjHVWUL.WHWpXQDVqULHGHGHPRVWUDWLXVLG¶DGYHUELVTXHHVUHIHUHL[DOKRUD DODSRVL.LyGHODDLGHODDSHUVRQHVDL[zDTXHVWDTXHVWDDTXt
  295. 295. LXQDDOWUDTXHHV UHIHUHL[DODSRVL.LyGHODDDOOzDTXHOODTXHOODDOOj
  296. 296. (QHOV DGYHUELVH[LVWHL[OD SRVVLELOLWDW G¶LQVLVWLU HQ O¶H[SUHVVLy GH OD OOXQDQLD XWLOLW]DQW DOOj EDL[ SHU D UHIRUoDU DOOj (OEHUEHUWpXQVLVWHPD.UHXDWDPEHOGHO.DWDOjWpXQDVqULHSHUDUHIHULUVHDOD SRVL.LyGHODDSHUVRQDLXQDDOWUDSHUDUHIHULUVHDOKRUDDODSRVL.LyGHODDLGHODD $PpVDPpVWpIRUPHVHVSH.tILTXHVSHUDUHIHULUVHDHOHPHQWVTXHVyQSUHVHQWVHQHO GLV.XUVRHQHO.RQWH[WDTXHVWDIXQ.LyDQRPHQDGDDQDIzUL.DHO.DWDOjODUHVROXWLOLW]DQW HOVDOWUHVGHPRVWUDWLXVWULDQWORVVHJRQVODSUR[LPLWDWHQHOGLV.XUVRHQHOWHPSVDTXHVW TXHHPGLXVDTXHOOTXHW¶KHGLWLDTXHVWTXHHWGL.DTXHOOTXHHWYDLJGLU $ PpV D PpV HQ HOV DGYHUELV Wp XQD IRUPD SHU D LQVLVWLU HQ O¶H[SUHVVLy GH OD OOXQDQLD .RP KHP YLVW TXH SRW IHU HO .DWDOj L IRUPHV HVSH.tILTXHV TXH LQGLTXHQ RULHQWD.Ly HQ O¶HVSDL G¶XQD IRUPD VHPEODQW D .RP KR IDQ HOV DGYHUELV .DWDODQV HQoj R HQOOj TXH H[SUHVVHQ XQD LGHD GH PRYLPHQW +L KD WDPEp DGYHUELV TXH HTXLYDOHQ D H[SUHVVLRQV .DWDODQHV .RP DUD YHW DTXt SHUz TXH WHQHQ XQ UHQGLPHQW JUDPDWL.DO PROW PpVJUDQSHUTXqV¶XWLOLW]HQHQ.DVRVHQTXqHO.DWDOjUH.RUUHDOVYHUEVKDYHULpVVHU (OVDGMH.WLXVGHPRVWUDWLXVVXIL[DWV (QEHUEHUODIXQ.LyGHOVDGMH.WLXVGHPRVWUDWLXVODIDQVXIL[RVLQYDULDEOHVTXDQW DOJqQHUHL DOQRPEUHTXHV¶DGMXQWHQDOQRP6yQ HOV VHJHQWV VHJXLQW OHV GLVWLQ.LRQV TXHKHPH[SOL.DW 326,,Ï'(/$$3(5621$
  297. 297. D 'DUUHUHGHQRPVD.DEDWVHQDKLKDXQDGDYDQWGHOVXIL[SHUDID.LOLWDUQHODSURQXQ.LD.LyWUD..DD µDTXHVWD[DU[D¶
  298. 298. DIXQDVD µDTXHVWERXTXHKLKDDTXtRQVy.MR
  299. 299. ¶ LIXQDVHQD µDTXHVWVERXV¶ WDIXQDVWD µDTXHVWDYD.D¶ WLIXQDVLQD µDTXHVWHVYDTXHV¶ 326,,Ï'(/$$,'(/$$3(5621(6 LQ
  300. 300. DIXQDVLQ µDTXHVWERXTXHKLKDDTXtRQHWVWX
  301. 301. DTXHOOERXTXHKLKDDOOj RQpVHOO
  302. 302. ¶ LIXQDVHQLQ µDTXHVWVDTXHOOVERXV¶ WDIXQDVWLQ µDTXHVWDDTXHOODYD.D¶ WLIXQDVLQLQ µDTXHVWHVDTXHOOHVYDTXHV¶ )81,Ï$1$)Ñ5,$ QQLQ
  303. 303. DIXQDVHQQL µDTXHVWERXGHTXqSDUOHP
  304. 304. DTXHOOERXGHTXqSDUOjYHP¶ LIXQDVHQHQQL µDTXHVWVDTXHOOVERXV¶ WDIXQDVWHQQL µDTXHVWDDTXHOODYD.D¶ WLIXQDVLQHQQL µDTXHVWHVDTXHOOHVYDTXHV¶ (Q .DWDOj IHP H[SOt.LWD OD UHIHUqQ.LD TXH .RPSRUWHQ HOV GHPRVWUDWLXV DQDIzUL.V XWLOLW]DQWSURQRPVUHODWLXVDTXHVWTXHDTXHOOTXH6DUULRQDQGLD
  305. 305. D DUJD]HQQL QH]ŽUDLGŽHQQDGŽ KRPH'(0 YHXUH3(5)DKLU µDTXHOOKRPHTXHYDPYHXUHDKLU¶ E WDGGDUWHQQL L]HQ]EDEDN .DVD'(0 YHQGUH3(5)SDUH3521 µDTXHOOD.DVDTXHYDYHQGUHHOWHXSDUH¶
  306. 306. (OVSURQRPVGHPRVWUDWLXV (OVSURQRPVGHPRVWUDWLXVGHOEHUEHUVyQHOVVHJHQWV 326,,Ï'(/$$3(5621$ QHXWUH DD µDL[zTXHWLQ.DTXt
  307. 307. ¶ VJP ZD µDTXHVW¶ VJI WD µDTXHVWD¶ SOP LQD µDTXHVWV¶ SOI WLQD µDTXHVWHV¶
  308. 308. 7LQD G HVVLV Q XMHOOLG 6DUULRQDQGLD
  309. 309. '(0)(03/ 3$57 ILOOHV3521 GH UHL$11(; µ$TXHVWHVVyQOHVILOOHVGHOUHL¶ 326,,Ï'(/$$,'(/$$3(5621(6 QHXWUH DLQ µDL[zTXHWHQVDTXt
  310. 310. DOOzTXHWpDOOj
  311. 311. ¶ VJP ZLQ µDTXHVWDTXHOO¶ VJI WLQ µDTXHVWDDTXHOOD¶ SOP LQLQ µDTXHVWVDTXHOOV¶ SOI WLQLQ µDTXHVWHVDTXHOOHV¶
  312. 312. 7LQGWDGGDUWQQH 6DUULRQDQGLD
  313. 313. '(0)(06*3$57.DVDGHQRVDOWUHV µ$TXHOODpVODQRVWUD.DVD¶
  314. 314. )81,Ï$1$)Ñ5,$ QHXWUH DHQQLDHQ µDL[zTXHGLHPDOOzTXHGqLHP¶ VJP ZHQQLZHQ µDTXHVWDTXHOO¶ VJI WHQQLWHQ µDTXHVWDDTXHOOD¶ SOP LQQLLQHQ µDTXHVWVDTXHOOV¶ SOI WLQQLWLQHQ µDTXHVWHVDTXHOOHV¶
  315. 315. $HQQLZDULKŽOL 6DUULRQDQGLD
  316. 316. '(0QRVHUYLU3(5) µ$L[zQRVHUYHL[¶ 7DPEpH[LVWHL[HQSURQRPVSHUDGHVLJQDUHOHPHQWVGHODUHDOLWDWTXHQRHVYROHQ HVPHQWDU G¶XQD PDQHUD SUH.LVD .RP HV ID HQ .DWDOj DPE O¶~V GH GDL[zV GDOOzV GDL[RQVHVLGDOORQVHV 5()(5Ê1,$,035(,6$ VJP ZLQDWLQDW µDTXHVWGDL[RQVHVDTXHOOGDOORQVHV¶ VJI WLQDW µDTXHVWDGDL[RQVHVDTXHOODGDOORQVHV¶ SOP LQDWHQ µDTXHVWHVGDL[RQVHVDTXHOOHVGDOORQVHV¶ SOI WLQDWLQ µDTXHVWVGDL[RQVHVDTXHOOVGDOORQVHV¶
  317. 317. 0DQDZLQDW 6DUULRQDQGLD
  318. 318. TXq'(00$66* µ4XqpVDTXHVWGDL[RQVHV¶ 4XDQ O¶DUWL.OH GHO .DWDOj LQWURGXHL[ XQ DGMH.WLX O€

×