SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 45
Examination of Environmental Education Initiatives in
Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages in Cambodia
Angela Hessenius
University of San Diego
San Diego, California, United States
Center for Mekong Studies, The School for Field Studies
Siem Reap, Cambodia
Research Advisor: Georgina Lloyd Rivera, Ph.D.
5 May 2015
Hessenius 2
Table of Contents
Tables...........................................................................................................................................................................................3
Figures .........................................................................................................................................................................................3
Abbreviationsand Terminology................................................................................................................................................3
Abbreviations.........................................................................................................................................................................3
Terminology...........................................................................................................................................................................4
Acknowledgements....................................................................................................................................................................4
Declaration..................................................................................................................................................................................5
Abstract.......................................................................................................................................................................................5
1. Introduction............................................................................................................................................................................5
1.1 Scope of Environmental Education...............................................................................................................................5
1.1.1. Global Context of Environmental Education.......................................................................................................5
1.1.2. Regional Scope of Environmental Education.......................................................................................................7
1.1.3. Environmental Educationin Cambodia................................................................................................................8
1.2 Environmental and Social Context of Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages.............................................................12
1.3 Aims and Objectives of Study.....................................................................................................................................13
2. Methods...............................................................................................................................................................................14
2.1 Study Period and Location...........................................................................................................................................14
2.2 Data Collection Methods.............................................................................................................................................14
2.3 Data Analysis Tools ......................................................................................................................................................16
2.4 Limitations of Study.....................................................................................................................................................16
3. Results ..................................................................................................................................................................................16
3.1 Osmose..........................................................................................................................................................................16
3.2 Public School.................................................................................................................................................................18
3.3 Ministry of Environment..............................................................................................................................................19
3.4 Community Fishery Committees ................................................................................................................................20
3.5 Other stakeholders ......................................................................................................................................................22
3.6 Community Environmental Awareness and Perceptions.........................................................................................24
4. Discussion.............................................................................................................................................................................26
4.1 Access to Education and Dissemination of Conservation Results Information......................................................27
4.2 Focus on Education for Children and Gap in Adult EE..............................................................................................29
4.3 Defermentof Responsibility to Other Stakeholders.................................................................................................30
4.4 Potential Benefits of Bottom-Up and Community-Based EE...................................................................................31
4.5 Shifting Focus from Awareness to Behavior Change................................................................................................32
4.6 Importance of IntegratingEducation with Livelihood Improvement......................................................................33
5. Conclusion............................................................................................................................................................................35
References................................................................................................................................................................................37
Appendix 1...............................................................................................................................................................................40
Appendix 2...............................................................................................................................................................................41
Hessenius 3
Tables
Table 1: Listof OpportunitiesandChallengesIdentifiedforEEStakeholdersinPrekToal andAnlong
Taor Villages, Cambodia, 2016..................................................................................................... 27
Table 2: Full List of Interviews Conducted During Data Collection Period,April 2016....................... 40
Figures
Figure 1: Map of Prek Toal Core Area, Osmose 2015..................................................................... 14
Figure 2: Pie Chart of StakeholderGroupsInterviewedduringDataCollectionPeriodinPrekToal and
Anlong Taor villages inApril 2016 ................................................................................................ 15
Figure 3: Picturesof ExteriorandInteriorof Osmose FloatingClassroominPrekToal village,
Cambodia, taken April 2016 ........................................................................................................ 17
Figure 4: ResponsesfromCommunityandOtherStakeholderGroups(includingMoERangers,
Osmose Teachers,PublicSchool Teachers,CommunityFisheryCommitteeMembers,andPublic
Officials) onLevelof KnowledgeandInterestinLearningaboutthe EnvironmentamongLocal
Community Members in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages, Cambodia, in 2016. ........................... 25
Abbreviations and Terminology
Abbreviations
ABE: Associationof Buddhistsforthe Environment
ADB: AsianDevelopmentBank
ASEAN:Associationof SoutheastAsianNations
CFi:CommunityFishery
DESD: Decade of EducationforSustainable Development
EE: EnvironmentalEducation
FCA:Fish ConservationArea
GEF: Global EnvironmentFund
JEEF: JapanEnvironmental EducationForum
MoE: Ministryof Environment
MOEYS: Ministryof Education,Youth,andSport
NGO: non-governmental organization
OHCHR: Office of HighCommissiononHumanRights
Hessenius 4
RSIS:Ramsar SitesInformationService
SSI:Semi-structuredinterview
TSCP: Tonle SapConservationProject
TSEMP: Tonle Sap Environmental ManagementProject
UN: UnitedNations
UNEP: UnitedNationsEnvironmentProgramme
UN FAO:UnitedNationsFoodandAgriculture Organization
UNESCO: UnitedNationsEducation,Social,andCultural Organization
USAID: UnitedStatesAgencyforInternationalDevelopment
WCS: WildlifeConservationSociety
Terminology
Mey kum:Commune chief
Mey phum:Village chief
Sangha:Communityof Buddhistmonksandnuns
Acknowledgements
There are several people withoutwhomitwouldnothave beenpossible tocomplete this
study,andI wouldlike tothankthemdeeplyandgenuinely. First,IwouldliketothankDr. Georgina
Lloyd-Rivera,forherindispensable guidance throughoutthe entire processof research,data
collection,andwriting,andherconfidence inme togatherand interpretourfindings.SamrithVichet
was alsoa vital part of my success,notonlyas an extremelyproficienttranslator,butalsoasthe
supportive teammate whowasalwaysbymyside.Iwouldalsolike tothankmyparents,fortheir
constantsupportand alsotheirconfidence andtrustinme,and forgivingme more opportunities
than I couldeverdeserve.Iwouldalsolike tothankmyhome school,the Universityof SanDiego,for
theirfinancial supportthroughthe AlcaláScholarshipthathashelpedmake byeducationpossible,
and alsofor the manymembersof the USD communitywhohave helpednurture mylove of
learning,mypassions,and helpedmake USDa place I not onlylearnatby where Ifeel a sense of
home and belonging. Iwouldlike toacknowledgeandthankthe Ministryof Environmentof the
Royal Governmentof Cambodiaforgrantinguspermissiontodoresearchandcollectthe data that
formedthe basisof thisstudy.Finally,Iwouldliketoexpressmydeepandsincere gratitude forall
the people whowere the subjectsof thisstudy,wholetme take the time tointerview them, who
oftengraciouslyandgenerouslyopenedtheirhomestome,andprovidedme withaninvaluable
glimpse intotheirlives.
Hessenius 5
Declaration
I, AngelaHessenius,acknowledgethatthe researchembodiedinthispaperisentirelymyownwork,
that where the ideasof othershave beenused,the sourceshave beenacknowledged,andthatno
portionof thisresearchhas beenpreviouslysubmittedforgradingatThe School forFieldStudiesor
the Universityof SanDiego.
Signed:__________________________________ Date: ___5 May 2015____
AngelaHessenius
Abstract
Environmental education(EE) isfundamental inachievingsustainable developmentand
environmental conservationgoals, andevaluationof EEinitiatives isnecessarytoimprove their
effectiveness.Thisstudyprovidesanexaminationof EE initiativesinPrekToal andAnlongTaor
villages, asfewformal evaluationshave beencompleted. Semi-structuredinterviews(SSIs) were
conductedwithkeyinformantsfromstakeholdergroups involvedinEEand local community
membersinPrekToal and AnlongTaorvillagesonthe Tonle SapinCambodia. Itwas foundthatEE
has had substantial positiveimpactsinthe community,yetalsofacessignificantchallengesandis
currentlylimitedbyanumberof factors.These includedlimitedaccesstoeducationforadults,alack
of disseminationof informationonsuccessfulconservationinitiatives,anda needforintegrationof
EE withimprovinglivelihoodsandbuildingcapacityforbehaviorchangesthatsupportconservation
and ecological sustainability.The explorationof these challengesisessential tobe able toreframe
such obstaclesasopportunities,becauseonce theyare recognized,suchimpedimentscan
transformedinto targetsforimprovement toEE inthe community.
Keywords:Environmentaleducation;Tonle Sap;Educationforsustainable development;
Conservation;Environment;Accesstoeducation;AdultEducation;Behaviorchange;Livelihood
Improvement
1. Introduction
1.1 Scope of Environmental Education
1.1.1. Global Context of Environmental Education
Environmental education(EE) isabroad conceptwithoutauniversallyaccepteddefinition
(Smith& Keat2006). The definitionincludedwithinthe TbilisiDeclaration,the productof the first
IntergovernmentalConferenceonEnvironmental Education in1977, may serve asa foundation:
Hessenius 6
Environmental educationisalearningprocessthatincreasespeople’sknowledgeand
awarenessaboutthe environmentandassociatedchallenges,developsthe necessaryskills
and expertisetoaddressthe challenges,andfostersattitudes,motivations,and
commitmentstomake informeddecisionsandtake responsibleaction(UNESCO-UNEP1977)
ThisdefinitionclearlyidentifiesthatEE entailsmore thanmerelyanincrease inknowledgeand
awarenessaboutthe environmentandglobal environmental issues.Italsomobilizespeople to
transformthisknowledgeintopractice andaction.Minimizingenvironmental harmcausedby
humanactivitiesandworkingtowardsthe creationof solutions andthe pathof sustainable
developmentare seenasessential componentsof EE (Smith&Keat2006). Springingfromthisbroad
scope of environmentaleducation,manyhave alsorecognizedthe linkbetweenpovertyreduction
and EE, and acknowledge thatpeople needtobe equippedwiththe capabilitiesandenvironmental
assetsto meettheirneedsinasustainable way,otherwise peoplewillcontinuetopursue livelihood
activitiesthatcause environmentaldegradation(Smith&Keat2006, Ardoin,Clark,&Kelsey2013,
Khieu2002, ADB 2011)
These loftyanddiverse goalsof EE have increasinglybeencitedasa necessarycomponentof
improvingglobal environmental managementandincorporatedintogoalsandobjectivesof
organizationsatmanydifferentscales (Smith&Keat2006, UNESCO 2006, ASEAN 2013). EE was first
codifiedasaninternational priorityin Principle 19of the Declarationof the UnitedNations
Conference on the HumanEnvironmentheldinStockholmin1972, whichdeclaredenvironmental
education asessential (UNEP1972). Recommendation96of the Declaration alsocalledforthe
establishmentof aninternational programonEE (UNEP 1972). In 1975, an International
Environmental WorkshopinBelgrade addressedthisrecommendationandoutlinedaglobal
frameworkforenvironmental education.The Belgrade Charterof 1975 identifiedthe goal of EE as
follows:
To developaworldpopulationthatisaware of,andconcernedabout,the environmentand
itsassociatedproblems,andwhichhasthe knowledge,skills,attitudes,motivationsand
commitmenttoworkindividuallyandcollectivelytowardsolutionsof currentproblemsand
the preventionof newones(UNESCO1975).
The Intergovernmental Conference onEnvironmental Education,heldin 1977, expandeduponthe
goals,objectives,andguidingprinciplesforEEexpressedinthe BelgradeCharter,andincludedthe
followinggoalsforEE:
Hessenius 7
1. to fosterclearawarenessof,andconcernabout,economic,social,political,andecological
interdependence inurbanandrural areas;
2. to provide everypersonwithopportunitiestoacquire the knowledge,values,attitudes,
commitment,andskillsneededtoprotectandimprove the environment;
3. to create newpatternsof behaviorof individuals,groups,andsocietyasa whole towards
the environment(UNESCO-UNEP1977).
The importance of educationforachievingsustainabledevelopmentandthe needtointegrate EE
intoeducationforall levelsof societywasalsorecognizedwithinChapter36 of Agenda21, the
productof the UN Conference onEnvironmentandDevelopmentin1992 (UNEP1992a). Most
recently,thislinkbetweenEEandsustainable developmentwaspromoted onthe international level
throughthe designationof 2005-2014 as the Decade of EducationforSustainable Development
(DESD) by the UnitedNationsGeneral Assemblyin2002 (Smith& Keat2006). The DESD wasa broad
and ambitiousplantoincorporate the inherentvaluesof sustainabilityinall formsof learningin
orderto encourage andempowerindividualsandsocietytoundergoatransformationtowardsthe
securityof a justand sustainable future (UNESCO2006).The DESD envisions“aworldwhere
everyone hasthe opportunitytobenefitfromeducationandlearnthe values,behaviourand
lifestylesrequiredforasustainable future andforpositivesocietal transformation”(UNESCO2006,
pg. 4). The goalsof the DESD thus situate EE withinthe broadersocial,cultural,economic,and
political contextof sustainabledevelopment,andacknowledgethe necessityof EEto continue
focusingonthe relationshipbetweenhumankindandthe natural worldandstrategiesforthe
preservationandsustainable use of itsresources(UNESCO2006).
1.1.2. Regional Scope of Environmental Education
In response tothispushfrominternational organizationssuchas UnitedNations
Educational,Scientific,andCultural Organization (UNESCO) andthe UnitedNationsEnvironment
Programme (UNEP) promotingEEand educationasa strategyfor sustainable development,regional
effortstoexpandEE have alsobeenformulated.The Associationof SoutheastAsianNations(ASEAN)
adoptedthe ASEAN Environmental EducationActionPlanfor2000-2005 andsuccessorplansfor
2008-2012 and 2014-2018, whichincorporatedthe goalsthe DESD.The ASEAN Environmental
EducationActionPlansarticulatedthe fundamental importance of EEfor the achievementof
sustainable developmentgoals:
EE iskeyto the overall ESDstrategysince humanity'svalue forandunderstandingof nature,
and itssustainable use andmanagementof natural resourcesformthe basisforsustainable
economies,harmonioussocietiesandhealthypeople (ASEAN 2006).
Hessenius 8
The ASEAN Environmental EducationActionPlans establishedastrategiccollaborativeframeworkto
“accelerate the developmentandadvancementof environmental education”withspecificobjectives
infour targetareas: formal education,non-formal education,humanresource capacitybuilding,and
networking,collaboration,andcommunication(ASEAN 2013).While the ASEAN membercountries
have made progressinactive engagementinEEacross multiple sectorsof society,substantial
challengesremain,includingthe needformore teacherswell-trainedandknowledgeable inEE,for
more instructional materials,andmore fundsallocatedfromthe governmenttosupportEE
initiatives (Smith&Keat2006).
1.1.3. Environmental Education in Cambodia
The impetusforthe developmentof EEfrominternational andregional policieshave
contributedtodevelopmentsof EEfrom a wide range of stakeholdersinCambodia,thoughthere
remainsignificantlimitationsandroomforgrowth. Due toCambodia’shistoryof more thantwenty
yearsof conflict,whichcoincided withthe developingawarenessof environmentalproblemsand
prioritizationof sustainable developmentandEEamong the internationalcommunity,EEhas hada
relativelyshorthistoryinCambodiacomparedtomanyothernations andisstill inan initial phase
(Smith& Keat2006). However,since the mid-1990s,EE has increasinglybeenadministeredbyboth
governmentandNGOstakeholders(Smith&Keat2006). The MoE has made importantprogressin
implementingEEon a national level,includingcollaborationwith the Ministryof Education,Youth
and Sport(MOEYS) to trainprimaryschool teachers,buildinghumanresource capacityby
conductingtrainingsforprovincial environmentdepartmentemployees,andpublicenvironmental
awareness-raisingcampaignsthroughmedia,suchas national televisionandradiobroadcasts, and
eventssuchas National andWorldEnvironmentDay(Smith&Keat2006). Despite these
accomplishments,the MoEstill facessignificantchallengestothe implementationof EE,including
limitedhuman resources,materials,financialsupport,planning,andcollaborationamong
stakeholders(Smith&Keat2006).
A representative,butnotexhaustive,listof NGOsfocusedonEE in Cambodiainclude Live
and LearnEnvironmental Education,MlupBaitong,the UN FoodandAgricultural Organization (FAO)
inSiemReap,Save Cambodia’sWildlife,Osmose, Wildlife Alliance,the Associationof Buddhistsfor
the Environment(ABE),the Culture andEnvironmentPreservationAssociation,andmore (Smith&
Keat2006, JapanEnvironmental EducationForum(JEEF) 2007, WildlifeAlliance 2015).Organizations
such as the WildlifeConservationSociety(WCS),SamVeasnaCenter,and ConservationInternational
are alsoinvolvedin projectstoimprove livelihoodsinlocal communitiesbygeneratingalternative
sourcesof income and to buildcapacityby providingtechnicaltrainingfor biodiversitymonitoring
and protectionof conservationareas,toachieve resultsinenhancingsustainablemanagementof
Hessenius 9
resourcesandprotectingkeyspeciesandtheirhabitats (WCS2016, ConservationInternational2016,
Sam VeasnaCentern.d.).
These NGOs and others have made significantprogressincollaborationwiththe
governmenttoextendEEinCambodiawithinavarietyof sectors.Inthe formal sector,activities
have mainlyfocusedonintegratingEEintoschool and universitycurriculums,includingthe
developmentof materialssuchastrainingmanualsandguidesforteachersandstudentclubs,and
technical trainingandcapacitybuildingin environmentallysoundpracticesforbothgovernment
employeesandcivil society(Smith&Keat2006). However,there isalack of assessmentof the
qualityof these trainingsandacritical needtoevaluate the qualityof environmental trainingbeing
administeredbymanydifferentproviderstoensure thataccurate informationandbestpracticesare
beingtaught(Smith&Keat 2006).
In spite of these pushesforEEdevelopmentinthe formal sector,the majorityof EEin
Cambodiaoccursin the non-formal sector.Activitiescarriedoutinthe non-formal sectorfall undera
verybroad range and include radioandtelevisionbroadcasts,speeches, posters,andspecial events
(Smith& Keat2006). Monks have alsoplayedanimportantrole inthe disseminationof EEin
Cambodiathroughactivitiessuchasspeechesandcommunity-basedenvironmental learning
activitiescarriedoutbypagodas(Smith&Keat 2006). For example,MlupBaitong,supportedbythe
WorldBank and Alliance of ReligionsandConservation,developedaprogramthat provided
educationandtrainingformonksin14 rural pagodas,whobecame able toprovide educationon
Buddhismandthe environmenttotheirlocal communitiesthrougheventsandactivitiessuchas
lectures,workshops,radioprogramsandevents onBuddhistholydays,andseedlingordination
ceremoniesattree nurseriesthatare now well-establishedatthese pagodas(Awoyemi etal 2012).
ABE isanotherorganizationthatworksto strengthenthe capacityof the sangha,the communityof
Buddhistmonksandnuns,inCambodiatopromote environmental educationandprotection (JEEF
2007, BerkleyCentern.d.).Examplesof theirmajorprojectscompletedsofarinclude the
developmentof a documentaryvideoonmonksandCommunityForestry,and providingtrainingin
environmental outreachtomonks anddisseminatingenvironmentaleducationmaterials,suchas
audiomaterialsthatare broadcastedat target pagodason Buddhistholydays inBokorNational Park
inKampotprovince andKampongLengdistrictin KampongChhnangprovice (JEEF2007). In
KampongLeng,ABE has alsoimplementedcommunitylivelihoodprojects,includingimprovinglocal
watersupplymanagement; establishingcompostheaps, vegetablegardens, andtree nurseries;and
organizingtree plantingevents andtree ordinationceremoniesatpagodas(JEEF2007, Berkley
Centern.d.). These initiativesare consistentwiththe globalmovementtobridge religionand
conservation,andspecificallyinBuddhistcountriestoutilize Buddhistprinciplesandteachings asa
Hessenius 10
base for establishinganenvironmental ethicandmotivatingpeople toprotectthe environment
(Awoyemi etal 2012, Chim2012).
1.1.4. Environmental Education in the Tonle Sap
Many EE projectswithinCambodiahave focusedspecificallyonthe regionof the Tonle Sap,
the great lake inthe centerof Cambodiaandthe largestfreshwaterlake inSoutheastAsia. Some of
the NGOs involvedinEE inthe Tonle Sap include Live andLearn EnvironmentalEducation,Mlup
Baitong,the UN FAOin SiemReap(whoestablishedthe GECKOcenterforEE ina floatingvillage on
the Tonle Sap in1999), Save Cambodia’sWildlife,andOsmose (Smith&Keat2006). EE projects
alongthe Tonle Sap have typicallybeenimplementedonasmall scale inlocal communities,witha
focuson primaryschool studentsandteachers(Smith&Keat2006). One major accomplishmentwas
the collaborative preparationof anEnvironmental EducationTrainingManual thatiscurrentlybeing
usedbythe Food& Agriculture Organisation(FAO),MlupBaitong,Save Cambodia’sWildlife &
Osmose andto aidin the integrationof EE intothe publicschool curriculum(Smith&Keat2006).
Due to the international recognitionof the environmental,social,andcultural significance of
the Tonle Sap, there have been internationallyandregionallydrivenEEeffortsinfocusedonthis
regionas well.AsaUNESCO Man and Biosphere Reserve,partof UNESCO’smissionistobuild
capacityand promote EE in the region(UNESCO 2016). One importantprojectthathas beencarried
out isthe Tonle Sap ConservationProject(TSCP).The TSCPwasdevelopedfromthe thirdcomponent
of the Tonle SapEnvironmental ManagementProject(TSEMP),the firstmajorprojectof the Asian
DevelopmentBank-fundedTonleSap Initiative (AsianDevelopmentBank(ADB) 2010, ADB 2011,
Global Environment Facility 2011). The ultimate objectiveof the TSEMP wasto improve “the
sustainable managementandconservationof natural resourcesandbiodiversityinthe Tonle Sap
Basin”(ADB 2011). To achieve thisgoal,Component3aimedto buildcapacityformanagementand
conservationof biodiversity,andspecificallyidentifiesthe promotionof “biodiversityconservation
awareness,education,andoutreach”asone of itsstrategiestoachieve thisobjective (ADB2010,
ADB 2011). The TSCPwas a separate projecttoimplementComponent3, fundedbythe Global
EnvironmentFacility andthe UNEP and implementedbythe CambodiaNational MekongCommittee
and the Ministryof Environment,andextendedfrom2004 to 2011 (ADB2011, GEF 2011).
The third expectedoutcomeof the TSCPwasto promote awareness,educationand
outreachon biodiversityconservationinthe Tonle SapBiosphere Reserve,throughthe development
and implementationof anenvironmentalawarenessandoutreachprogramto be deliveredthrough
the school systemandenvironmental educational centersinvillagesthroughoutthe Tonle Sap(GEF
2011). Trainingactivityforprovincial governmentstaff engagedinprotectedareasmanagementand
biodiversitymonitoringwasanotherimportanttargetof the TSCP(GEF 2011). Projectresults forthe
Hessenius 11
environmental awarenessandoutreachprogramincludedthe country’sfirstenvironmental
educationcurriculum, developmentof EEteachingmaterials forstudentsfromgrades4-9,training
of 255 teachers from65 schoolsaroundthe lake in usingthe environmentalmanual andteaching
materials,andthe initiationof eco-clubsinschoolswiththe establishment of nine eco-clubsintarget
schools (GEF2011). The environmental manual forteacherscontains14environmental themesand
isspecificallyfocusedonthe resourcesof the Tonle Sap,andwasdeveloped inpartnershipbythe
MOEYS andthe FAO,MlupBaitong,Save Cambodia’sWildlife,andOsmose,andreviewedin2004
basedon teacherfeedback(GEF2011, Smith& Keat2006). These are significantachievementsof the
project,andthe teacher’sguide forEE will have a lastingbenefitinCambodia(GEF2011). However,
one limitationof the EEand environmental awarenessandoutreachinitiativesof the TSCPisa lack
of sustainability,since the terminal evaluationof the TSCPconcludedthatalthoughindividual
teachersexpressedthe commitmenttocontinueduse of the educational materialsandskills
acquired,alack of fundingmeantthatsustainmentof the programwas unlikely(GEF2011).
A national environmental educationandawarenesscampaignwasalso planned asone of
the outputs underComponent1of the TSEMP inorderto strengthennatural resource management
coordinationandplanningthroughthe disseminationof informationaboutthe environment (ADB
2010). For thisobjective Live & Learnwas contractedto developand successfullycreatedavarietyof
useful educationtoolsincludingflipcharts,facilitationguides,andthe EE trainingmanual for
teachers,aswell asa publicationonthe Tonle Sap,EEstatus report,and national mediaincluding
theatre andradio (ADB2010, Live & Learn,Smith& Keat2006). However, completionreportsnoted
that at the conclusionof the project, the “‘national’educationandawarenesscampaignwasnotin
place as envisaged”at the projectoutset(ADB2010 pg. 24, ADB 2011).
In the case of the TSCP, a formal monitoringandevaluationwasconductedincompliance
withUnitedNationsDevelopmentProgrammeandGEF standards (GEF 2011). However,formanyof
the smaller-scaleEEinitiativescurrentlytakingplace onthe Tonle Sap,little ornoformal monitoring
and evaluationhasbeenconducted(Smith&Keat2006). Deficientmonitoringandevaluationof EE
projects isa seriousproblem,becauseitisimpossibletoassessthe variousstrategiesthathave been
employedandshare the knowledge of EEmethodsthatare effective atincreasingfostering
environmental awareness,values,andbehaviorchanges withincommunities,aswell astoaddress
and improve uponstrategiesthatare not successful inchangingpeople’sattitudesand actions
(Smith& Keat2006, Live & Learn2015). WithinPrekToal and AnlongTaor villages,avarietyof
differentstakeholdersare involvedinEE,yetfew examinationsorevaluationsof the impactof these
initiativeshave beenconducted.Forthisreason,these siteswereselectedasa case studyto gather
Hessenius 12
preliminarydataonthe influence thatdifferentstakeholders andEE projects have hadon the local
communities.
1.2 Environmental and Social Context of Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages
PrekToal isalsoan especiallyimportantsite toexamine the outcomesof EE initiativesinthe
local communitiesdue tothe extremeecological importance of the area.PrekToal Core Area isthe
largestof three core areasof the Tonle SapBiosphere Reserve,whichwasdesignatedin1997
(UNESCO2007). PrekToal wasselectedasa core area because itcontainssome of the Tonle Sap
floodplainsthatremaininthe mostpristine conditionandhasgreatbiodiversityvalue asahabitat
for a varietyof globallythreatenedspecies(RamsarSitesInformationService (RSIS) 2015).The site is
coveredmostlybyfreshwaterswampforesthabitatthatfloodsannuallywiththe seasonal
hydrological regimeof the Tonle Sap(RSIS2015). Nutrient-richsedimenttrappedbythe forests
supporthighlyproductive plantandfishhabitats(RSIS2015).Priorto the cancellationof fishinglots
in2011, the area was highlyexploitedasthe mostproductive fisheryonthe lake,Battambang
FishingLotNo.2 (Osmose 2015). In additiontobeingthe mostproductive fisheryareaonthe Tonle
Sap (itself one of the mostproductive freshwaterfisheriesinthe world),PrekToal core areais also
the most importantnestingsite onthe Tonle Sap—supporting210 species,including17 that are
globallythreatenedorendangered(Tonle SapConservationProject (TSCP) 2007).For its ecological
value,PrekToal wasalsodesignatedasa Ramsar Site in2015 (RSIS2015).
In additiontosuchhighbiodiversity, KohChiveangcommunealsosupportsfivevillagesand
approximately1300 familiesthatlive infloatinghousesorhouseboats(Osmose 2015, TSCP 2007).
The residentsof the local communityrepresent diverse ethnicbackgrounds,withamajorityof
Khmerpeople andminoritypopulationsof Chinese-Khmer,Vietnamese,andCham(Osmose 2014).
The economiesof these villagesare highlydependentuponfishingandassociatedactivities,withthe
majorityof fishingdone onasubsistence level(Osmose 2015).The site alsohassignificanteconomic
value foritsgreat potential asanecotourismsite,offeringthe abilitytoview ahighconcentrationof
large nestingwaterbirdswithineasyaccessof SiemReap(TSCP 2007). For itsbiological,economic,
social,andcultural value,PrekToal core area isa site of global significance thatrequiresdiligent
protectionof the natural resourcesthatsupportboth humanandnon-humanlife.
The recognitionof thisfacthas alreadyspurredmanyEE initiativesdesignedtoraise
awarenessof the importance of the PrekToal ecosystemandencourage andbuildthe capacityof
the local communitytosustainrich biodiversityof the core area.For example,the NGOOsmose was
establishedinPrekToal in1999 withan approachto conservationthatlinkscommunity-based
conservation,alternativelivelihoodsupportthroughthe developmentof ecotourism, andEE
Hessenius 13
(Osmose 2015). Osmose initiatedtheirEEprogramin 2000 withthe goal of educatingthe childrenof
the communitytoequipthemtoconserve the area’snatural resources(UNESCO 2007, Osmose
2015). Osmose purchasedafloatingschool toholdclassesin2001, and has heldbothindoorclasses
at theirfloatingcentertoteachchildrenaboutthe Tonle Sapecosystems,aswell asoutdoorclasses,
includingfieldtripstothe PrekToal birdsanctuaries,tosee the conceptstaughtin the classroomin
real life (UNESCO 2007, Osmose 2015). The EE program is also inthe processof beingintegratedinto
the curriculumof the local schoolsinPrekToal (Osmose 2015). An independentevaluationof
Osmose’sEEprogram was performedin2007 withpositiveresults(Osmose 2015). However,amore
currentevaluationisnecessarytodetermine if the resultsof thisprogramare still successful.
WCS alsohas an establishedpresence in the areathroughtheirPrekToal conservation
project(WCS2016). Through thisproject,WCShas workedclosely withthe MoEto monitorand
protectthe water birdcoloniesandfloodedforestinthe PrekToal Core Areasince 2001 (WCS2016).
As a partnerin the TSCP,WCS also contributedtocapacitybuildingforbiodiversitymanagement,
throughactions such as training52 rangerswhopatrol the conservationsite (WCS2016).
1.3 Aims and Objectives of Study
For the purposesof thisstudy,EE has beendefinedandinvestigatedspecificallyasit
pertainstoincreasingawarenessandknowledge of the environment,understandingof its
connectionstohumanlivelihoodsandwellbeing,andencouragingactionsthatcontribute to
environmental conservationandsustainabilityamonglocal communities.Whilesome stakeholders,
such as Osmose,alsoaimtoincorporate EE intotourisminitiatives,tonarrow the scope of this
study,the deliveryandreceptionof EEwithinlocal communitieswaschosenasthe central focus.
Giventhe fundamental importance of EEin achievingsustainable developmentand
environmental conservationgoals,the necessityforevaluationof EE initiativestoimprove their
effectiveness,andthe lackof formal evaluation andevenacomprehensive collectionof basic
informationaboutthe currentstatusof environmental initiativesinPrekToal andAnlongTaor
villages,this studyaimstoaddressthisgapinknowledgebycollectingdatafromstakeholders
providingEEand local communitymembersreceivingEEto determine whichstakeholdersare active
inEE, whattechniquestheyare utilizingandwhattopicstheyare teaching,andhow these
educational initiativesare perceivedbythe local community.Thisinvestigationshouldserve asa
startingpointforfuture studiesanddata collectionthatcanallow fora formal monitoringand
evaluationprocess.The followingstate the objectivesof thisstudy:
1. Identifystakeholdersinvolvedindevelopmentandimplementationof environmental
educationprojectsandinitiativesinPrekToal andAnlongTaor
Hessenius 14
2. Determine whatmechanismsandactivitiesdifferentstakeholdersemployintheirEE
initiativesandwhatconceptsandtopicstheychoose tocover
3. Examine communityreception of pastandcurrentEE initiativesby exploringenvironmental
awarenessandknowledge amongthe local community
4. Analyze andcompare EE initiatives sharedbyrespondents
2. Methods
2.1 Study Period and Location
The study wasconductedduringthe periodfromApril 18, 2016 to April 27, 2016 inthe
villagesof PrekToal andAnlongTa OinrinKoh Chiveangcommune,EkPhnomdistrict,Battambang
province,inCambodia(Figure 1).
Figure 1: Map of Prek Toal Core Area, Osmose 2015
2.2 Data Collection Methods
To gather the data forthisstudy,semi-structuredinterviews(SSI) were conductedwithkey
informantsfromthe variousstakeholdergroupsinvolvedinEEinPrekToal and AnlongTaor.These
include rangersemployedbythe MoEwho patrol the Core Area,CommunityFisherycommittee
membersinPrekToal and AnlongTaor,and the mey phum (village chief) of PrekToal andAnlong
Taor and the mey kum (commune chief) of KohChiveangcommune.Interviewswere conductedwith
Hessenius 15
local schoolteachers,bothfromOsmose andthe publicschoolsinPrekToal andAnlongTaor,to
acquire informationaboutthe currentEE initiativesforchildreninthese villages.Representatives
fromNGOs witha presence inthe area,includingOSMOSE,the WildlifeConservationSociety(WCS),
and Live & Learn,were alsointerviewed.Inaddition,interviewswithmonksfromthe local
monasteryanda Catholicpriestwhoroutinelyvisitsthe Churchof St.JosephinPrekToal were
conductedinorderto ascertainwhetherthese religiousinstitutionsare activelyinvolvedin
environmental education.Toinvestigatethe experience of local communitymemberswithEEand
levelsof environmentalawarenessinthe community,SSIswerealsoconductedwithlocal
communitymembers.Nine interviewswere conductedinPrekToal villageandseveninterviews
were conductedinAnlongTaorvillage. Figure2,below,showsthe proportionsof the numberof
interviews conductedwithmembersof eachstakeholdergroupoutof the total numberof
interviews,andthe full listof interviewsconductedcanbe foundinAppendix1.
Figure 2: Pie Chart of Stakeholder Groups Interviewed during Data Collection Period in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor villages in
April 2016
Osmose Teachers
5% n=2 MoE Rangers
7% n=3
Catholic Priest
3% n=1
Village-level
Official
5% n=2
Monk
3% n=1
Community Members
42% n=17
Community Fishing
Committee Members
7%
Osmose
Representatives
5% n=2
WCS
Representative
2% n=1
MoE Official
2% n=1
Commune-level Official
2% n=1
Live & Learn
Representative
2% n=1
Public School
Teachers
15% n=6
Stakeholder Groups Interviewed Osmose Teachers
MoE Rangers
Catholic Priest
Village-level Official
Monk
Community Members
Community Fishing
Committee Members
Osmose Representatives
WCS Representative
MoE Official
Commune-level Official
Live & Learn
Representative
Public School Teachers
Hessenius 16
The topic guidesforboththe SSIsand focusgroupsuse botha seriesof yes/noquestions
followedbyprompts,aswell asopen-endedquestions.The fulltopicguidescanbe found in
Appendix 2.
2.3 Data Analysis Tools
The software Atlas.TIwasutilizedtomanage,analyze,andpresentthe datagathered.
MicrosoftExcel wasalso usedtocreate tablesinorderto presentthe dataresults.The datawas
analyzedusinggroundedtheory,todraw insightsandconclusionsbasedonthe interviewdata
collectedandcomparative analysisof the variousgroups examined(GlaserandStrauss1967).
2.4 Limitations of Study
Due to the limitedtimespentinthe field,yieldingamoderate sample size of interview
respondents,itisnotpossibletodrawgeneralizedconclusionsaboutthe full extentof EE initiatives
inPrekToal, or theireffectivenessandinfluence onthe community.FurtherresearchinPrekToal,as
well asotherlocationsonthe Tonle Sap,is necessarytobe able to conducta monitoringand
evaluationanalysisthatwill enable EEproviderstoimprove the effectivenessof theirapproachesto
EE.
Anotherlimitationof the studyisthatdue to the cross-cultural contextwhichrequireda
translator,there isthe inevitable possibilitythatsome questionsoranswerscouldhave been
misinterpretedorthatthe nuancesof responsescouldhave beenlost.Itisalsopossiblethat
interview respondentscouldhave modifiedtheiranswersinsome casesbasedontheirperceptions
of the researchersandan attempttogive answerstheythoughtwere desiredortoprotect their
owninnocence.
3. Results
3.1 Osmose
Osmose iscurrentlythe mostactive stakeholderinEEin PrekToal and AnlongTaor. Their
environmental education(EE) programfocusesonbuildingenvironmentalawarenessamong
primaryschool students(Grades1-6) througha combinationof indoorandoutdoorclassroom
activities.The Osmose teacherstransportthe studentstothe Osmose floatingclassroom, where EE
classesare taught complementarytothe publicschool schedule fourtimesperweek (if the public
school classesare inthe morning,the Osmose classeswill be inthe afternoon,andvice versa)
(Figure 3).Osmose alsostartedintegratingtheirEEcurriculumintothe local publicschools in2001.
Currently,Osmose hirestwostate teachersona part-time basis,whoteachbothat the Osmose
platformandthe local publicschools,one teacheratPrekToal and one teacherat KohChiveang
Hessenius 17
PublicSchool.The Osmose teachers andpublicschool teachersreportedthatthe Osmose teachers
visitthe publicschoolstoteachaboutthe environmenttwo orthree timespermonth. There usedto
be three teachershiredbyOsmose,butone teacherisnow resigned,sothere iscurrentlyno
Osmose teacheravailabletoteachclassesat the KampongPrahok PublicSchool.
Figure 3: Pictures of Exterior and Interior of Osmose Floating Classroom in Prek Toal village, Cambodia, taken April 2016
The outdoorclassroomactivitiesinclude fieldtripstothe PrekToal Core Areato see the
waterbirdcolonies,waste collectionatthe school ormonastery,andtripsinthe village toobserve
local plantlife andfloatinggardensthatOsmose helped20local familiesbuildin2002. The
birdwatchingtripsare a highpriority,because theywanttoencourage the childrentolove andwant
to protectthe endangeredbirdsthatare of greatconservationandecotourismvalue.Duringthe dry
season,whenthe birdpopulationsare attheirpeak(NovemberthroughMarch),Osmose
representativesexplainedthattheybringthe studentsonbirdwatchinguptofourtimespermonth,
while Osmose teachersreportedthattheytake studentsonoutdoorfieldtripstwotimespermonth.
The birdwatchingexcursionsalsorequirecollaborationbetweenOsmoseandthe Ministry of
Environment(MoE),since anMoE ranger alwaysaccompaniesthe teachersandstudentsinorderto
guide themtothe Core Areaand provide informationaboutthe birdstothe students.Duringthe
wetseason,whenthe birdshave migratedelsewhere,the teacherstake the studentstodothe local
outdooractivities.Asaresultof these activitiesandeducationontopicssuchasthe natural
environmentof the Tonle Sapandthe importance of conservingthose natural resourcesforthe
future,the Osmose teachers have notedchangesinbehavior,includingdisposal of waste inbins
rather thanthe lake and ceasingtohunt forbird eggs.Osmose isalsohopeful thatthe childrenwill
continue tolove andvalue the environmentinthe future andreflectthisthroughtheirbehaviorsby
protectingnatural resourcesandusingthemsustainably.
The EE program complementsthe othermaincomponentsof Osmose’sapproachto
environmental conservationandcommunitylivelihoodimprovement,whichare ecotourismand
Hessenius 18
local development.AnOsmose representative notedthat“all the componentsare linked,whichhas
beenone of theirsuccesses,”anddescribedhow environmental awarenessandprotectionof natural
resourcesare necessarytosupportand sustainthe ecotourismcomponent,whichalsohelpsto
provide alternative incometolocal families,incentivizingconservationbehaviors.
3.2 PublicSchool
The publicschool teachersalsoprovide the studentsinPrekToal andAnlongTaorwithEE as
part of the state curriculum.Theyteachaboutenvironmentaltopicsasoftenastheyare scheduled
to inthe curriculumandmaterialsfromthe Ministryof Education,Youth,andSport (MOEYS),which
one teacherreportedisaboutonce a month.Some of the mostcommon environmental topics
coveredbythe publicschool teachersinclude the natural environmentanditscomponents,suchas
the water,the animals,andespeciallythe floodedforestsandmangroves.The teachersemphasize
the importance of the forestsforprovidinglivelihoodbenefits now andin the future,including
supportingbiodiversityandbreedingfish,providingwoodtouse forfuel,protectionfromstorms,
and regulationof the weather.Multiple teachersalsoreportedthattheyhave discussedthe threat
of climate change,whichthe studentsunderstandbecause theyexperience the temperature getting
hotterand hotter,andhowclimate change can damage the forestsand the interrelated
environment.
One challenge identifiedbysome of the local publicschool teachersinterviewedisthatitis
difficulttoimprove students’habitsandbehaviorsbecause theyare more likelytofollowthe model
setby theirparentsandfamiliesthanbytheirteachers.Forexample,theytrytoteachthe students
not to throwtheirrubbishinthe waterand notto drinkthe lake water,but forstudents’whose
familiesdonotknownotto throwtheirrubbishthe wateror whocannot affordtobuy cleanwater
and do notknowto boil it,itis difficulttomake suchbehaviorchanges,thoughthe teachersdotry
to tell the studentstopassthese messagesontotheirparents.Similarly,thoughillegal fishinggearis
not a maincomponentof the curriculum, the teachersoftentalktotheirstudentsaboutwhich
fishingactivitiesandgearsare allowedandwhichare notallowed. However,theyexplainedthat
such educationwill notoverride the poorerfamilies’needstoperformillegal fishingactionsinorder
to feedtheirfamilies. One publicschool teachersaid,“Itisreallyhardforthe kidshere.Normally
theylistentotheirfamily,andthe life theylive dependsonfish.If theydon’tdoillegalactivity,then
theycan’t feedtheirfamily.”Whenaskedaboutwhetherthe studentshave changedtheirbehaviors
as a resultof learningaboutthe environment,the same teacherresponded,“Youcan hardlyblame
the kids;it dependsontheirfamilycondition.It’snotlike theydon’tknow andunderstand.They
knowand understand,butif theydon’tdoit,thentheycan’t feedtheirfamily.Forexample,some of
the kidscut downthe mangrovesforfirewood.Theyknow thatit’swrongbutit istheirlivelihood.”
Hessenius 19
Whensuch resource collectionpracticesare partof the livelihoodof child’sfamily,the childrenwill
continue suchbehaviorsdespite the factthattheyare aware that suchactions are illegal orwrong.
Despite thischallenge,teachershave reported some successesinalteringstudents’behaviors,
includingdisposingof rubbishinbins atthe school rather thanin the water.
3.3 Ministry of Environment
The MoE doesnot currentlyhave anEE programfor the adultsin the local community.Inthe
past theyhave hadan EE program foradults,buthave discontinuedthisprogramdue tolackof time.
Ratherthan educate the whole community,they onlyeducate theirrangers.There are currently30-
40 rangersemployedbythe MoE, includingbothvolunteerandfull-timerangers.The rangers
receive trainingincollectingdatatomonitorthe biodiversityandpatrollingthe Core Area;theyare
instructed bya teacherwhocomes from the MoE Ministry Office inPhnomPenhatleastonce a
year.The MoE also encouragesthe rangerstocare aboutprotectingthe environmentand
encouragingfellowcommunitymemberstoprotectthe environmentaswell,includingencouraging
community memberscaughtdoingminorillegal actions,suchasfishinginthe Core Area,tochange
theirbehaviorsandhelptake care of the environment.The rangersplayanimportantrole inEE as
disseminatorsof information.Theirmessagestendtofocusonclearprohibitionsof actions,suchas
tellingpeople nottoenterthe Core Area,notto cut downtreesinthe forest,andnotto use the
illegal fishinggears,andexplainingthatthese behaviorsare importantbecause protectingthe
forests,whichare where the fish breed,andleavingbehindthe small fishtoletthemgrow,are
necessarytomaintainthe fishstocksforthe future.
One challenge identifiedbysome of the MoE rangersinterviewedisthatthe MoE usedto
have rangerswhowere more active inEE inthe community,butthose rangershave now all retired,
and the newlyhiredrangersare toobusywithpatrollingtovisitthe communitymemberstoeducate
themaboutthe environment.One MoErangerinterviewedreportedthattheyhave requestedto
continue doingEElike the retiredrangersusedtodo,but that theyhave notreceivedfeedbackor
approval yetfromMoE seniorstaff.
Anotherwaythe MoE disseminatesinformationaboutthe environmentisthroughmeetings.
Theytypicallyholdmeetingstwotothree times ayear,especiallywhenanMoEofficial fromthe
MoE Ministry Office in PhnomPenhcomestovisitthe MoECore AreaManagementStationat Prek
Toal.In these official meetings,theyoftenutilize posterandslideshow presentationsanddiscuss
topicssuch as howto protectthe mangrove forestsandthe waterbird colonies.Normal attendance
at these meetingsisbetween40and 50 people.Official authoritiesandpublicfigures,suchasthe
mey kum andmey phums,are usuallyinvitedtoattend.AnMoE official reportedthattheydonot
Hessenius 20
announce these meetingstothe general communitybecause theydonothave the available space to
accommodate sucha large numberof people,sotheirstrategyistoinvite the people whoare heads
of the communityandentrustthemwithdisseminatingthe informationtothe restof the
population.
The communitymembersare aware thatthe MoE holdsthese meetings;however, they
reportedthatthey neverreceive invitationstothe meetingsorinformationaboutwhentheywillbe
held.Theyperceivethatonlycertainpeople are selectedtoattend. Forexample,when askedif
there are meetingsaboutthe environmentinthe community,avillage level official reportedthat
“normallywhentheysetupthe meetings,theydon’thave ageneral announcement,theyinvite
selecthouses,the oneswiththe goodlivingconditions.The poorpeople don’tgetinvited,”anda
communitymemberthatthey “know theyhave meetings,buttheydon’tinvite the poorpeople.”
Thisperceptionisone cause of frustrationbetweenthe MoEand the community.There were a
varietyof reasonscitedforthe poor relationshipbetweenthe MoEand the community.Some
communitymemberswhowere interviewedexpressedsignificantresentmentandsuspicionof the
MoE. There is a strong perceptionamongsome membersof the communitythatthe MoE iscorrupt
because theytake fishandotherresourcesoutof the protectedareathat theypreventthe
communityfromentering.Itwasalsoreportedthatwhenthe MoE catches people fordoingillegal
actions,theyonlymake thempaya fee and collectthatmoneyandletthe offendergo,sonothing
changesthe problemof decreasingresources:
Since the MoE tookoverthe protectedarea,there wasnothingleft,because the rangers
take the birdseggs to feedtheirfamilies.Whentheycatchpeople,theymake thempaythe
fine,andpeople don’thave thatmoneysotheydon’tdothe illegal action.
Otherstakeholdersreportedthatcollaboratingwiththe MoEis difficult.Forexample, one of
the Osmose teacherssaidthatsometimestheyhave plannedtohave anMoE rangertake their
groupof studentstosee the Core Area,but on the day theirtripwasplannedtheywere toldthatall
the MoE rangerswere busyso none couldaccompanythem, sotheyhad to change theirplansto a
local outdooractivity.
3.4 Community Fishery Committees
Like the MoE rangers,membersof the CommunityFishery(CFi) Committees of PrekToal and
AnlongTaor oftenteachpeople aboutthe environment,eitherwhentheyare onpatrol inthe CFi or
whentheyholdmeetingsforthe community.Meetingsheldbythe CFi Committee typicallyhappen
at leastonce a year.The CFi usesa poster andteachesaboutthe fishinglawsandregulations.For
example,theytell the communityaboutthe typesof fishinggearsthatare legal andillegal (including
Hessenius 21
electroshockandgill netsof asmall netsize). Theyalsoinformthe communityaboutwherethey are
allowedtofish,andespeciallytrytodeterthe communityfromfishinginthe Fish ConservationArea
(FCA),orformerFishingLot#2. There isalsoa protectedareawithinthe CFi (formerFishingLot#3)
where people are notallowedtofish.Theyexplaintothe communitythatpeople are notallowedto
fishinthe protectedareasor use the illegal gearsinorderto protectthe spawningfishtohave
resourcesforthe future.Anothermainfocusbesidesexplainingthe fisherylawsisteachingpeople
aboutthe connectionbetweenprotectingthe environmentandimprovingtheirlivingconditions,
since all relyonthe natural resourcesandhealthyenvironmentfortheirlivelihoods.The CFi
Committee alsorequeststhatcommunitymembershelptoprotectthe environment,especiallythe
forestthatsupportsthe breedingfish, bynotcuttingdowntreesandnot huntingthe wildlife.
The CFi Committee membersreportedthattheyoftencollaborate withotherNGOsfortheir
EE, such as the UnitedStatesAgencyforInternational Development(USAID) CambodiaHARVEST
program workedwiththe CFi Committeesandhelpedorganize andruntheirmeetingswith
communityuntil theirprojectconcluded thisyear.CFi committee membersdescribedhow HARVEST
helpedtraintheminmanagingthe CFi andtaught the communityaboutprotectingthe environment,
conservingnatural resources,andthe threatof climate change atthe meetings.Theyalsohelped
fundprojectstoimprove livelihoodsinthe community,includinga providingfishpondstoCFi
committee membersandtraininginaquaculture.
A CFi Committee memberinterviewedalsodiscussedhisownactivitiestoengage hislocal
communityinenvironmentaleducationandprotection.He reportedthatevenwhenfundsfrom
HARVESTran out for the communitymeetings,he continued toorganize meetingsforthe
communityonhisownabout three timesayear,usinghisownfundsto purchase snacksfor the
people whoattend. Three maingoals citedfordiscussioninthese meetingswere talkingaboutthe
environment,askingpeopletoprotectthe FCA and itsfishand birdpopulations,andrequestingthat
the whole communityunitesandworkstogethertoprotectthe environment.He discussedwaysin
whichhe is able tohelpthe communityunderstandtheseconceptseventhoughare nothighly
educated.Forexample,he avoidsusingtechnical language like the termecology,andinstead
explainshoweverythinginthe environmentisrelatedtoeachotherbyexplainingitasa “food
system.”Anotherwayhe helpsthe communityunderstandthe importance of the environmentisby
connectingthe environmenttothe economy,theirlivelihoods,andtheirdailyreality.He described
howhe explainsthateffectsof climate change,suchasincreasingtemperature,lowerwaterlevels
on the lake,andthe increasingincidencesof forestfireswillhave negative consequencesby
decreasingthe amountsof fishandtherefore the amountof foodforpeople toeat.The followingis
Hessenius 22
the reasoningreportedtoexplainthe conceptof conservingnatural resourcesandhow goodliving
conditionsare dependentonahealthyenvironment:
He usesthe realityof everyday,like the ecosystemandclimate changing,the temperature,
the lake dryingup,and the firesinthe forest—all of these problemsstarttomake you feel
worriedandmake yousick.Everyone startsto thinkthat if there isno waterthenthere will
be lessfishandthenthere will be nothingtoeatand thenpeople will getsick.Everytime he
has a meetingwiththe communityhe addsitwiththe economicsystemandhow itgoes
togetherwiththe environment.If youdestroythe environment,thenthere isnoflow of the
economy.
In additiontoholdingmeetingsinthe communityforadults,thisCFi Committee memberalsotalks
to studentsinthe publicschool forone houreach month.
Accordingto a CFi Committee member,the local communityisverywillingtoattend
communitymeetings,andtojointogetherincommunityactiontohelpprotectthe environment.As
an example,he reportedthathe organizedagroupof local communitymemberstoputouta fire
neartheirhouses.He alsoreportedbehaviorchangesamongthe majorityof the community
members,includingceasingtouse the electroshockgearforfishingandstoppingthe collectionof
birdeggsand nests.Despite these successes,he reportedfacingsignificantchallengesfrom
authorities,whodonotsupporthisprojects. A Committee memberexpressedthe belief that the
authorities,suchasthe MoE, shouldimprove theircollaborationwiththe local communityinorder
to be successful inconservingthe natural resourcesof the area,because if the communityisangry
withthe MoE, theywill notfollowthe rulesanditwill be impossible forthe MoE to enforce them:
Whateverproject,if youdon’thave helpfromthe communitythenitwon’thappen.You
needtokeepthe communityhappytocollaborate.If youmake the communityangryor hate
you,thenit iseasyfor themto destroythe environment.There are manymore of themthan
the 30-40 MoE rangers,sothere will be nowayto stop them.
3.5 Other stakeholders
While the mey phums of PrekToal and AnlongTaor andthe mey kumof KohChiveangare
involvedinthe meetingsheldbythe MoE on the environmentandingeneral meetingsforthe
commune heldbythe mey kumthat may coverenvironmental topics,theyare notextensivelyactive
inEE for the community.Theydotell communitymembersnottocut treesandonlyto take dead
woodfromthe forestforfuelwood,toobeythe fishinglawsbynotfishinginthe protectedareasor
Hessenius 23
usingthe illegal gearsinordertoprotectthe breedingfish,andtokeepthe environmentcleanand
collectingtheirrubbish.
The Wildlife ConservationSociety(WCS) isnotactivelyengagedinanyEE projectsforthe
local community,thoughtheycontinue tosupportthe MoE byprovidingannual technical trainingin
patrollingandwaterbirdmonitoringforthe MoE rangers.Thisis consistentwiththeircentral focus
on achievingconservationresultsforthe waterbirdcoloniesandtheirhabitatsinthe PrekToal Core
Area.WCS has collaboratedwithOsmoseinthe pastbyprovidingfundingfortheirEEprojects,and
there are opportunitiesforWCStoplaya more active role inEE inPrekToal inthe future.A WCS
representative mentionedsomeof these opportunities,includingcontinuingtheirpartnershipwith
Osmose orstandardizingeducationandawareness-raisingforadultsasa componentof their
conservationprograms.They stated“theywantthere tobe a dedicatedunitwithinWCSthat
suppliestrainingatall theirsites”andthat they“wantto raise awarenessamongadults.”
Currently,the monasteryatAnlongTaorisnot activelyinvolvedinanyenvironmental
education.Althoughthe space atthe monasteryisusedforactivitiessuchaswaste collectionevents
for schoolchildrenandcommunitymembers,the monksare nottypicallyconsultedorinvitedto
collaborate inthese events,andtheymayor maynot participate inthem.Accordingtothe monk
withthe mostauthorityat the monastery,thoughhe hastriedto engage the communityandasked
themto helpcollectrubbisharoundthe wat,the communitymembersare notinterestedandrefuse
to participate.Whenaskedif he everincorporatesteachingaboutthe environmentorBuddhist
storiesrelatedtothe environmentintoceremonies,he reportedthathe doesnot,because Osmose
and the MoE bothfill the role of teachingpeople inthe communityaboutthe environment.
The CatholicChurch inPrekToal (Churchof St. Joseph’s,asatellite churchof St.John’s
Church inSiemReap) isanotherreligiousinstitutionthatisnotcurrentlyengagedinEE,thoughthere
isthe possibilitythatEEbecomesa componentof the Church’ssocial outreachprogramsinthe
future.Atthe moment,the Churchis involvedinprogramsaimedatreducingpoverty,including
offeringfree Englishclassesforthe community.Whiletheyare notactivelyinvolvedEE,a
representative of St.John’sChurchwhoroutinelyvisitsthe churchinPrekToal reportedthathe
believesthere isthe potential forincorporatingEEintotheiractivitiesinthe future,andthatit
shouldbe a prioritygiventhe importance of the conservationareainPrekToal.Also,environmental
protectionhasbeenidentifiedasamainobjective of the CatholicDiocese inBattambang,based
uponthe understandingthatprotectingthe environmentisstrongly alignedwithCatholicvaluesto
respectandcare for Creation.Atthe moment,theydoencourage the childrennottothrow rubbish
inthe water,andbelieve the childrenare graduallychangingtheirbehaviors.
Hessenius 24
3.6 Community Environmental Awareness and Perceptions
Membersof the communityreportedavarietyof levelsof environmentalawareness,
behaviorspracticed,andreasonsforprotectingthe environment.One conceptthatisstrongly
understoodbythe communityisthe connectionbetweenthe forestsand the fish.Almostall
communitymembersknowandunderstandthatthe forestsare importanthabitatsforthe fishto
breed,soprotectingthe floodedforestsisof great importance tosustainingthe fishpopulations.
Thislinkshowsthatthe communityunderstandsthatthe elementsof the environment—the forests,
the water,and the wildlife—are all relatedtoeachother. Manycommunitymembersmade remarks
similartoa communitymemberwhostated,“If youprotectthe forest,itmeansyouprotectthe fish
too. When the fishbreedtheyneedthe forests.”
Some of the mostcommonlyreportedreasonsforprotectingthe environmentincludefor
supportingtheirfamilyandtheirlivelihoods,protectingnatural resourcesforthemselvesinthe
future andfor theirchildrenfuture generationstobe able toknow the environmentaswell ashave
the resourcestheyneedtosurvive.Anothercommonmotivationfortakingcare of the environment
isfor the healthandhygiene of themselvesandtheirfamilies,andthisisa majorreasonmany
communitymembersreportedtryingtokeepthe environmentaroundtheirhouse andthe lake
cleanby notthrowingtheirrubbishintothe waterandpracticingpropersanitationandnotdrinking
waterfrom the lake.Unfortunately,intervieweesalso notedthatmanypeople inthe communitystill
throwrubbishinthe waterand use the pollutedlakewaterfordrinking,washing,andbathing,which
has negative consequencesforpeople’shealth. However, frequentreporting of these motivationsto
protectthe environmentshows thatthe majorityof peopleunderstandthe connectionbetween
takingcare of the environmentandsupportingtheirownlivelihoodsandwellbeingforthemselves,
theirfamilies,andfuture generations.
In addition,almostall the communitymembersinterviewedindicatedthattheywouldbe
interestedinlearningmore aboutthe environment(seeFigure 4).However,manynotedthatwhile
theywouldbe interested,theydonothave the opportunitytoparticipate EE,eitherbecause there
are no groupsprovidinganyEE inthe community,thattheyare notinvitedtoparticipate,suchasin
the meetingsheldbythe MoE,or because theydonot have time because theyare busyfishingto
feedthemselvesandtheirfamilies.There isalsoadiscrepancyin the perceptionof the community’s
knowledge aboutandinterestinlearningaboutthe environment, whichisillustratedinFigure4,
showingthatcommunitymembersself-reporthigherlevelsandknowledgeandinterestthan
stakeholdersperceive the communitytohave.
Hessenius 25
Figure 4: Responses from Communityand Other Stakeholder Groups (including MoE Rangers, Osmose Teachers, Public
School Teachers, CommunityFisheryCommittee Members, and Public Officials) on Level of Knowledge and Interest in
Learning about the Environment among Local CommunityMembers in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages, Cambodia, in
2016.
Otherperceptionsreportedbythe communityinclude the threatof decreasingresources,
such as the forests, water,andwildlifesuchasbirdsand fish. One communitymemberstatedthe
followingcomparingthe amountof natural resourceshe perceivedtobe availabletothe community
nowcomparedto the past:
There wasso much wildlife thenandlesspeople.Now there are more people, more hunting,
and lesswildlife,andthe environmentisgettingdirtiereveryday.Fornatural resources,the
wildlife andbirdsare lessandless.Forfishing,sometimesthereisnotenoughtofeedhis
family.
One majorcause people commonly attributedtothisdecrease innatural resourcesisthe extremely
hot anddry weather,whichhascausedthe lake levelstobe abnormallylow andalsocausedforest
firesthatthe communityisdeeplyconcernedabout,since theyrecognize thatthe forestsare crucial
for the environmentandsustainingfishpopulations: “If theyprotectthe forest,thentheyprotect
the fishand the animalsandthe birds.But withthe fire,theyare notsure if theywill still be there.”
Increasingpressure onresourcesformpopulation growthandlackof watercausedby damsin other
countrieswere lesscommonlycitedasreasonsforthe decrease inresources.Some community
membersstatedthattheydonot knowwhythe natural resourcesare decreasing,theyonlyhave
Hessenius 26
noticedthatthere are lessfish,birds,andotherresourcesthanthere were inthe past.Multiple
communitymembersexpressedthe opinionthatasprotectionandstrict enforcementof regulations
inconservationareashasincreased,the amountof natural resourcesinthese areashave
paradoxicallydecreased.Relatedtothisperceptionisthe belief thatauthoritiesexcluding
communitymembersfromconservationareas,suchasthe MoE, are extractingresourcesfromthese
areas whichtheyare supposedtoprotect.Because of these observedtrendsindecreasing
resources,manycommunitymembersare facingdifficultiesnow andare veryworriedaboutthe
availabilityof resourcesandtheirabilitytofeedtheirfamiliesandsurviveinthe future.
It was alsoreportedoftenthat althoughmostpeople inthe communityare aware of the
importance of the environmentandwhatthe lawsand regulationsare,manypeoplestillbreakthose
laws,andthe mainreasonpeople breakthe rulesisbecause of povertyandneed.Because people in
the communityare dependentonfishingfortheirlivelihoods,people are oftenforcedtodoillegal
activityinorderto have enoughfoodtofeedtheirfamilies.AsaCFi memberremarked, “if people
don’tdo the illegal action,whatcantheydoto eat? The people here livebyfish.”Cuttingwoodto
use as firewoodwasalsocommonlycitedasanillegal actionmanyfamiliesmustdoto attainthis
resource thattheyneedbecause theyare poorand cannot affordtobuy it.Because thisyearhas
beenexceptionallydry,officialsnotedthatthere hasbeenanincrease inillegal activitiesandpeople
enteringthe Core Areabecause there isincreasedpressure onresourcessomore peopleare
strugglingtofeedtheirfamilies,pushingthemtobreakthe lawsmore oftenthaninpreviousyears.
4. Discussion
Interviewsconductedwith abroadrange of stakeholdergroupsinPrek Toal and AnlongTaor
villages(seeAppendix 1),servedtoinformasnapshotof the currentstate of environmental
education(EE) inPrekToal andAnlongTaor. Basedonthisexamination,itwasfoundthatEE has had
substantial positive impactsinthe community,yetalsofacessignificantchallengesandiscurrently
limitedbyanumberfactors(see Table 1). The explorationof these challengesisessentialtobe able
to reframe such obstaclesasopportunities,because once theyare recognized,suchimpediments
can be transformedinto targetsforimprovementtoEE inthe community.
Positive results and sources of opportunity Major obstacles or limitations
Many children in the community have received EE,
which can empower the next generation with the
capabilities and inspiration to be proper stewards of
nature in the future
There is currently a gap in EE for adultcommunity
members
Hessenius 27
Community-based education and action can be
supported with positiveconsequences in community
engagement in sustainablemanagement of natural
resources
There are challenges with access to education and a
lack of dissemination of information aboutpositive
results of conservation initiatives
Success has been shown in integrated approaches to EE
that link education with economic development
There is a tendency for stakeholders to choose not to
take ownership and responsibility for EE sincethey are
aware of other stakeholders already practicingEE
Illegal actions regardingresourceextraction and
unsustainablebehaviors continuefrompeople in the
community. Major causeof this challengeis thatpeople
are restricted in their behavior choices by the realities
of their daily lives,includingpoverty,need for resources
to feed their families and supporttheir livelihoods,and
lack of infrastructureand alternativelivelihood options.
Table 1: List of Opportunities and Challenges Identified for EE Stakeholders in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages,
Cambodia, 2016
4.1 Access to Education and Dissemination of Conservation Results Information
Despite the factthat conservationinitiativeshave demonstratedsignificantresultsinthe
protectionof biodiversityinPrekToal,local communitymembersare generallyunaware of these
successes,andmanyhave indicatedthatthey have anantagonisticrelationshipwithauthorities
engagedinprotectionof these conservationareas. There issubstantial datademonstratingthat
conservationeffortsbythe Ministryof Environment(MoE) andWildlife ConservationSociety(WCS)
have beeneffective,especiallyinpreservingthe endangeredbirdspeciesinthe PrekToal Core Area
(WCS2016, Sun & Mahood 2015). Both MoE and WCS representatives reportedduringthisstudy
that birdpopulationsinthe Core Areahave increaseddirectlyasaresultof theirpatrolling,which
has significantlyreducedillegalactivity,suchas collectionof eggs,althoughtheyalsoacknowledged
that thisyearis an exceptiontothese trendsdue tothe abnormallydryweatherandlow waterlevel
on the lake,increasingpressure onresourcesanddrivingmore communitymemberstoillegalenter
the Core Areaforfishing.WCSalsopridesthemselvesontheirconservation strategy,whichinvolves
hiringformerpoacherstobe rangers that protectand monitorthe birds(WCS2016). This approach
has proventobe effective,since the nestandpopulation countsforbirdspeciesrecordedbythe
rangers(includingthe globallyendangeredGreaterAdjutantStork,globallyvulnerable Lesser
AdjutantStork,globallynearthreatenedPaintedStork,AsianOpenbill,globallynearthreatened
Spot-billedPelican,andgloballynearthreatenedOriental Darter) show anoverall increasesince
WCS startedtheirconservationinitiativesinthe early2000s (WCS 2016, Sun& Mahood 2015).
However, itappearsthatthe communitydoesnot know thisinformation.Infact,their
perceptionisthe exactopposite:thatresourcesare severelyandrapidlydeclining.Inorderto
addressthisdisconnectbetweenstakeholdersinvolvedinbiodiversityconservationandthe
Hessenius 28
community,organizationssuchasWCS and the MoE shouldmake ita prioritytodisseminate
informationaboutthe successfulresultsof conservationinitiativestothe local community.If the
communitydoesnotsee anyresultsof conservationefforts,theyare likelytohave more negative
attitudestowardsmeasuresthatplace restrictionsandlimitationsontheirabilitytouse natural
resourcesfortheirlivelihoods.However,if the communityismade aware of the benefitsof such
conservationinitiativesforthe environmentandthemselves,theywillbe more likelytocooperate,
followthe regulations,andchange theiractionsthatcontribute towardshabitatdegradation. Case
studiesconductedinMarine ProtectedAreas (MPAs) inthe Philippinessupportthispotential
informationdisseminationtoleadto improvedattitudestowardsconservation initiatives (Knight,
Allegretti,&Vaske 2015). Knight,Allegretti,&Vaske’s(2015) findingsshowedthatfisherswho
receiveddirectgovernment-citizencommunication,environmental education,andoutreachabout
protectedareagovernance policies were more likelytosupportMPAsandtheirpoliciesandperceive
theirMPAsas benefittingtheirlivelihoods.
Anotherchallenge withaccessto educationisthe perceptionconveyedbystudy
respondents thatthe general communityisnotinvitedtothe meetingsorganizedbythe MoE. In
addition tocontributingtoa perceived poorrelationship betweenthe MoEand the community,this
practice limitsaccesstoeducationforgeneral communitymembers,sinceonlypeople occupying
official andpublicpositionsare consistentlyinvited,whichespeciallytendsto excludepoorer
communitymembers. Suchlimitationsof accesstoeducationandinformationabout the
environmentare problematicbecause theyare contraryto the humanrightsof accessto education
and informationthatare widelyrecognizedandupheldbythe internationalcommunity, including
Article 26 of the Universal Declarationof HumanRights,whichguaranteesthe righttoeducation,
and Principle 10of the Rio Declarationfromthe UN Conference onEnvironmentandDevelopment
in1992, whichcodifiesthe rightthat“eachindividual shall have appropriateaccesstoinformation
concerningthe environmentthatisheldbypublicauthorities”(OHCHR1948, UNEP 1992b). The
rightsof accessto information,participationindecision-making,andaccesstojustice in
environmental mattersare widelyrecognizedasbeingone of the three essential dimensionsof the
nexusbetweenhumanrightsandthe environmentandcritical forgoodenvironmental governance
(UNEP-OHCHR2009, UNEP 2003, UNEP 2004). Although MoE officialsexpressedthe expectation that
the people selectedtoattendthe meetingswill passalongthe information,thisisnothappening,
whichiscreatinga gap in knowledgeandfeelingof exclusioninthe community. A more directand
egalitarianapproachtoEE couldbe pursuedbyincreasingaccesstomeetingsinwhicheducation
and informationaboutthe environmentisdisseminated,whichwouldbetterfulfillthe rightsof
communitymembersof accesstoeducationandinformation.Evenif itisnotfeasibletoinvite all
Hessenius 29
communitymembers toasingle meeting,the MoEcould have more frequentmeetingsandrotate
the houseswhoare invited,orreinstate the practice of having MoE rangersvisitpeople’shousesto
provide educationaboutthe environment.
4.2 Focus on Education for Children and Gap in Adult EE
Because Osmose isthe mostactive stakeholderinEE inPrekToal andAnlongTaor, andtheir
EE focusesmainlyonchildren,the resultisthatthere iscurrentlyagap inEE for adults.While
increasingenvironmental awarenessamongchildrenisvital anditisgoodto encourage the students
to care aboutthe environmentandformgoodhabitstohelpprotectit,the limitation isthatittakes
a longtime to see resultsfromeducationforchildren.Multiple representativesfromOsmose
reportedthateducationforadultswouldbe more directthaneducationforchildren.The EE
programsfor childrenare veryimportantforlongterm conservation,because the childrenwill be
the usersof the natural resourcesinthe future andneedto know how to be able to do so
sustainably.However,currently,the adultsinthe communityare the usersof natural resources,and
theyare the oneswho are reportedly committingillegal actions.Inordertohave a directimpacton
the current situationandreduce illegal activity,itisnecessarytofocusonachievingresultsby
providingEEand facilitatingbehaviorchangesamongadults. The educationof adultshasbeen
recognizedasa priorityforthe future directionsof EE and necessaryformeetingglobal goals
towardsenvironmental sustainabilityandeducationforsustainabledevelopment,especiallygiven
the urgencyof the planet’senvironmental crisisandthe needtochange humanbehaviornow,
rather thanfocussolelyoneducationthroughschoolingforchildrenandwaitfortoday’syoung
people totake action(UNESCOInstitute forLifelongLearning2010, Monroe 2007). Otherstudies
have alsosuggestedthatEE can enhance itseffectivenessbyfocusingoninstigatingactions,
behaviors,andchoicesthatsupportsustainability,andthatthese aimstowardbehaviorchange and
decision-makingare mostappropriate intargetingadults(Monroe 2007).
Anotherconsiderationisthata challenge tothe educationinitiativesforchildrenisthatthey
oftentendtostill followtheirparents’andfamilies’habitsratherthanadoptthe behaviorchanges
encouragedbytheirteachersatOsmose or the publicschool.Therefore,teachingthe adultsinthe
communityaboutthe environmentandactionstheycantake to helpprotectthe environmentcould
alsobe importantinreinforcingandstrengtheningthe EEaimedtowardschildren.Althoughone
hope of educatingthe children isthattheywill passalongthe messagestotheirparentsand
educationforthe childrencanhave a positive impactbythe childrensharingtheirknowledgeand
learnedbehaviorswiththeirfamilies,thisisalot to expectfromthe children.While itmay still be
helpful toencourage studentstoshare whattheylearnwiththeirparentsandfamilies,adultsinthe
communityshouldalsoreceive EEdirectly,sothattheycan model betterhabitsandbehaviorsfor
Hessenius 30
the children,ratherthanonlythe childrenbeingexpectedtoserve asexamplesforthe restof the
community.
4.3 Deferment of Responsibility to Other Stakeholders
Multiple stakeholdersreportedthatone of the reasonstheydo notinitiate andconduct
more EE isbecause theyknowthatotherstakeholders,principallyOsmose, are alreadyengagedand
active inEE. The monkinterviewedatthe monasteryreportedthathe doesnotincorporate Buddhist
storiesorlessonsaboutthe environmentintohisteachingsorceremoniesbecause the community
alreadyhas Osmose andthe MoE to teach themaboutthe environment.However,he also
expressedthe opinionthatthe MoE is notactive in EE, so itis currentlyonlyOsmose thatisactive in
EE, and theymainlyfocusoneducationforchildren.Eventhoughthe monkrecognizedthatthere is
a gap in educationforadultsinthe community,he believeditwasthe MoE’sresponsibilitytodo
more EE and encourage peopleinthe communitytoknow andcare aboutthe environment.Other
NGOs,such as WCS and Live & LearnCambodia, alsoreportedthattheyhave notfocusedonEE in
PrekToal because Osmose alreadyhasanestablishedpresenceandfocusonEE inthe community
(WCSinsteadfocusesontrainingMoE rangersto buildcapacityforconservationof Core Areaandits
waterbird colonies,andLive &Learn CambodiafocusestheirEEinitiativesinotherlocationsinthe
Tonle Sapregion).
Thisphenomenoninwhichstakeholdersperceive the responsibilityforEE as the
responsibilityof someoneelseisproblematicbecauseitpreventsthe benefitsthatcouldpotentially
come from multiplestakeholdersengaginginEEfrom varioussectorsinsociety.Forexample,were
boththe MoE and the monasteryto playa more active role inEE, the amountof people inthe
communitywithaccesstoEE couldincrease,since some communitymembersnotreachedbyone
stakeholdergroupcouldbe reachedbyanother.If communitymembersreceive EEfrommultiple
stakeholders,thiscouldalsohave importantbenefits.People couldgainamore comprehensive
understandingbylearningdifferentinformationindifferentcontexts.Continuityof EEisalso
extremelyimportanttoreinforcethe conceptspeople have learned,because otherwise peoplewill
mostlikelyforget,asmultiple communitymembersreportedthattheyhadbeentaughtaboutthe
environmentinthe pastbut nowdidnot rememberclearlywhattheyhadlearned. Ratherthan
perceivingengaginginEEas unnecessaryorrepetitiveif otherstakeholdersare alreadyinvolvedin
EE, stakeholdersshouldbe made of aware of the benefits of suchconsistentandcontinuedlearning
and encouragedtotake responsibilityforEEas part of theirownactivities.
Anotherreasonthistransferof responsibilityforEEisproblematicisbecause eventhough
Osmose hasbeenactive andsuccessful inEE,theyare still limitedintheircapacitytoreachthe
Hessenius 31
entire community.BecauseOsmose focusesonEEfor children,if theyare the sole providerof EE in
the community,thenthatcreatesa gap ineducationforadults inthe community.Inaddition,
Osmose islimitedinthe extentof theirEEprogram basedonthe amountof fundingtheyhave from
theirdonorsand revenue fromtheirecotourismprogram.Thislackof fundingwascitedasthe main
reasonOsmose nolongerhas an EE program foradults,whichtheydidwhentheyhadmore funding
sevenoreightyearsago. Theyalsono longerhave enoughfundingtoprovide the childrenwho
come to school at Osmose withsnacks(whichcanlimitthe abilityof studentstocome toschool
because if the boatarrivesand theyhave noteatenbreakfast,theycannotcome to school because
theywouldhave togo the whole morningwithoutfood)orto take the studentsonas manyfield
tripsas theyusedto whenthe EE program firststarted.One of the main challengesreportedfrom
Osmose representativesistheirdependence onsmall,timedgrants,andthe fact that theydonot
have any expertsingrantproposal writing,sotheyhave beenunsuccessful inacquiringlargergrants
to expandtheirprojects. Limitedfinances isacommonchallenge,bothforgovernment departments
and NGOs, for sustainingEEprogramsin Cambodiaandmanydevelopingcountries(Khieu2002,
Smith& Keat2006, ADB 2011).
4.4 Potential Benefits of Bottom-Up and Community-Based EE
While NGOand governmentstakeholdersare mostcommonlyperceivedasthe major
providers of EE inthe community, there alsoexiststhe basisandpotential foraburgeoning
movementof community-basedEEandconservationaction.Forexample,the independently
organizedactivitiesof aCFi Committee memberdemonstrate how passionate individualsinthe
communitycandraw upontheirownresourcesandutilize partnershipswithotherorganizationsto
galvanize the communitytounite togetherandprotecttheircommonenvironmentandresources.
Such bottom-upapproachestoEE can have many potential benefits. Educatorsfromwithinthe
community maybe more effective teachersthroughthe ability toexplaincomplex conceptsinways
that are easilyunderstoodby people,overcomingcultural, language,andliteracy barriersthatmight
hinderthe transferof knowledgefromNGOsorgovernmentofficials.Projectsinitiatedby
communitymembersare also likelymore sustainable thaninvolvementof outside NGOsthatusually
stay inthe communityonlyona short-termbasis.Suchcommunity-drivenprogramscouldalsobe
more empoweringandcontribute toastrongersense of ownershipoversustainable management
and conservation of natural resourcesif initiatedfromwithincommunityandledbylocal community
members.Giventhesepotential advantagesof bottom-upapproachestoEE, one recommended
strategywouldbe to trainand equip specificcommunity memberstobecome leaders intheir
communities whocaninstructand engage the local communityin conservingtheirenvironment.
Previousstudiesalsoattesttothe benefitsof community-based;forexample,Harris(2014)
Hessenius 32
concludedina case studyon the communicationonclimate change impactsandadaptation
strategiesinPacificislandsthatbottom-upapproacheswere effective inenablingcitizensto
participate,share knowledge,buildenvironmental awarenessandunderstandingof climate change
risksto theircommunitiesinaway that wasengagingandempoweringforcommunities.Ardoin,
Clark,& Kelsey(2013) alsoidentifythe needtodevelopmethodsof collaboratingwithpractitioners,
involvingwidercommunitymembersinparticipatinginEE,understandingthe effectsof collective
and social learningandhoweducational outcomesforindividualsandcommunitiesare linked,and
supportingcommunity-basedEEas one of the mostimportanttrendstoexplore inthe future forEE.
4.5 Shifting Focus fromAwareness to Behavior Change
Interviewswithlocal communitymembersrevealedthat general environmentalawareness
inthe communityisveryhigh.While communitymembersmaynotbe educatedinenvironmental
concepts,the realityof theirdailylivesandconstantinteractionwiththe environmentfortheir
livelihoods,since nearlyeveryoneinthe communityisinvolvedinfishing,meanthatthe community
membersare extremelyintune withtheirenvironment.Theyknow how the environmentis
interconnectedandare sensitivetoanychangesinthe environmentandthe resourcesthatare
crucial for theirlivelihoods. Althoughenvironmental awarenessishighamonglocal community
members,EEcan still be beneficial forthe community,butthere needstobe a shiftfromfocusing on
environmental awarenesstoemphasizingspecificandactionablebehaviorchangesthatcanyield
resultsforconservation. Trendsinthe EEresearchreflectthisshiftfromawareness-focusedto
action-orientedEEandbehaviorchange forconservation(Smith&Keat2006). Ardoin,Clark, &
Kelsey (2013) and Monroe (2007) acknowledge the highpriorityondevelopingeffective educational
and communicationstrategiesthatcansuccessfullyelicitindividual behaviorchange anddecision-
makingthat supportssustainability.
Aimingtoincrease environmental awarenessamongthe local communitymaybe misguided
and unproductive if itamountstosimplytryingtotell communitymemberswhattheyalreadyknow.
Instead,EE shouldaimtoprovide specificandviable alternativestocurrentpracticesthatcontribute
to degradationof the environmentanddeliverupdatesontangible outcomesandachievementsof
existingconservationprograms,inordertounderstandanddemonstrate the directlinkbetween
behaviorchange andconservationresults.
Some projectsinthe community have alreadyhad suchoutcomes.Forexample,one of
Osmose’scommunitydevelopmentprojects backin2002 whentheyhad the available funding was
to assist20 familiesinbuildingfloatinggardens.Thisprojecthadsignificantandlastingbenefits,as
one communitymemberwhostill usedherfloatinggardenreported,because she wasable togrow
Hessenius 33
mostof herown vegetablestofeedherfamily,reducingthe amountof income she neededtospend
and improvingnutritionforherfamily. Equippingpeople withthesekindsof toolsandskillsare
essential forimprovingpeople’slivelihoodsanddecreasingtheir dependence onnatural resources
to alleviate pressure onthose resources.Live &LearnEnvironmental Education have beenactive in
otherfloatingvillagesonthe Tonle Saptoachieve goalssuchas improving sanitation, water
management,andnutrition,andarepresentativeof the NGOemphasize thatthese projectsare
selectedbecausetheylinkeducationandimprovedqualityof life.Thisrepresentativeelucidated
that itis necessarytoprovide viable alternative optionsalongwithEEinorderto achieve behavior
outcomes,andthat EE that focusesonawarenesswithoutconnectingittospecificactionsand
alternative optionsisnotonlyineffectual,butweakensEEthroughitsunrealism.
In PrekToal and AnlongTaor,an example of the challengesinvolvedinmotivatingbehavior
changesisthe case of waste management. Despite the factthatimproperwaste disposal(i.e.
throwingrubbishintothe water) was the mostcommon behaviorchange encouraged by almost
everystakeholder,eventhose thatwere notactivelyengagedinEE, andmany communitymembers
didreportthat theyhave changedtheirwaste managementpractices, rubbishremainsamajor
environmental probleminthe community. Inthese floatingvillages,thereisnoinfrastructure for
waste collection,socommunitymembers’realisticoptionsare tokeeptheirrubbishintheirhouses,
burn it,or throwit inthe lake.Eventhoughcollectingandburningtheirrubbishisthe encouraged
practice,thismethodstill hasnegative healthconsequences.Unlessthere are socially,culturally,and
economicallyviablealternatives,implementingbehaviorchangesisunlikelytobe successful.
4.6 Importance of Integrating Education with Livelihood Improvement
One of the mostconsistent themesfrominterviewswithlocal communitymembersisthat
people knowwhatpractices are allowedandnotallowed,buttheycommitillegal actions anyway
because theyare poor andneedto feedtheirfamilies. Multiplecommunity membersalsostated
that local communitymembersuse resourcesforsubsistence,nottosell fora profit,sotheir
resource extractionisdrivenbyneedratherbygreedordesire toselfishlybenefitoveruse of
communityresources.Giventhisreality,itispossiblethatEE on itsownmay not be enoughto
achieve resultsinimprovingconservationandcontributingtobehaviorchangesamonglocal
communitymembers.Evenif peopleare educatedaboutthe environment,meetingtheirneedsin
the presenttosurvive will alwaysoutweighthe imperativetoconserve natural resourcesforthe
future.
An abundance of literature supportsthislinkbetweenlivelihoodsandsocioeconomicfactors
and EE and conservationbehavior(Ardoin,Clark,&Kelsey 2013,Masud etal.2014). Increasingly,in
Hessenius 34
the fieldof EE research,the purpose of educationisseennotonlyasto inspire behaviorchange,but
alsoto promote enhancedwell-beingandqualitylife andbuildthe capacityamongpeopletomake
sustainable choicesandlead sustainable lives(Ardoin,Clark,Kelsey2013). Withthe risinginterestin
the role of educationinsustainable development,EEwill likelycontinue toplayanimportantrole in
addressinginterconnectedsocial andecological issues,suchashealthandjustice (Ardoin,Clark,
Kelsey&2013). Thisrecognitionof EE’sbroadeningscope andthe impossibilityof separating
environmental andsocioeconomicissuesalsorevealsthe same themedemonstratedbythisstudy’s
findingsthatpoverty isamajor challenge toEE andenvironmentalsustainabilitybecause people will
alwaysprioritize theirimmediatesurvival needsoverconcernsforthe long-termpreservationof the
environment(Ardoin,Clark,Kelsey&2013, Khieu2002).
If it is true that educationnotpairedwithviable alternative solutionsisineffectual,than
improvinglivelihoodsmustbe akeycomponent toany EE initiative.If people’slivingconditionsare
too poorto be able toaffordto change theiractionslike illegal fishingandcuttingtrees,thenthere
will be norealisticalternative optionsthatcanfacilitate resultsinbehaviorchanges.Forthisreason,
Osmose’smodel thatintegrateslivelihoodimprovementthroughgenerationof alternative income
withEE is verypractical and successful.Still,overall livingconditionsinPrekToal remaingenerally
low,sothere are still significantchangesthatcanand shouldbe made toallow local community
memberstoincrease theirincome generationanddecrease theirdependence onillegal resource
use.
AnotherexampleinCambodiaof amodel thatsuccessfullyintegrateslivelihood
improvement,conservation,andeducationisthe SamVeasnaCenter’scommunityecotourism
projectinTmatboey that aimsto protecta critical habitatfor globallythreatenedlarge waterbirds in
the Northernplainsof Cambodia(Clementsetal.2008). Throughthe community-basedtourism
model,the local communityhasbecome apartnerinconservation,whose attitude towardsand
value of the birdspecieshaschangedsince theynow recognize the birdsasa valuable source of
revenue throughdirectpaymentforservicesanddonationtoacommunitydevelopmentfundfrom
the touristswhocome to see them (Clementsetal.2008). It wasreportedthatthe birdseven
became a source of pride tothe community,andthiscombinedwiththe financialincentivesfrom
tourismcausedthemto change theirbehaviorsandbecome active protectorsof the birds (Clements
et al.2008). The projecthashad substantial outcomesforbothreducingpovertyamongcommunity
membersandconservingthe birdspecies,whose populationsrose dramaticallyfollowing
implementationof the projectdue toa significantreductioninhuntingactivityfromlocal
communitymembers (Clementsetal.2008). More projectslike thiscancreativelyfindwaysto
incentivize conservationbehaviorsandintegrate benefitstolivelihoodsandthe environment,while
Hessenius 35
simultaneouslyengagingandeducatingthe communitybyempoweringthemtobecome partnersin
environmental preservationandsustainable resource use.
5. Conclusion
Thisstudy acknowledges the internationallyrecognizedandessential role thatEEplaysin
promotingsustainabledevelopment,benefittinglocal communities’livelihoods,andstrengthening
conservationof biodiversity.The studyalsorecognizesthatinCambodia, despite the prevalence of a
wide varietyof EE initiativesimplementedbymanystakeholders, there hasbeenlimitedformal
monitoringandevaluationof EE initiativesandassessmentof theirsuccess. Inresponse,thisstudy
aimedtoinvestigate the currentstatusof environmentaleducationinthe villagesof PrekToal and
AnlongTaor villages onthe Tonle Sap.
The findingsof thisstudy yield insightsintothe importance of EEfor improvingconservation
of natural resourcesandlivelihoodsinlocal communitiesonthe Tonle Sap, aswell assome ways
that approachestoEE in the regioncan be developedinthe future toincrease theireffectiveness
and abilitytocreate substantial change inbehaviorsandactions. Itwasfoundthat while stakeholder
such as Osmose andthe publicschoolshave focusedonprovidingchildreninthe communitywith
EE, there isa gap inEE foradults.Anotherfactorinthisoversightisthataccess to educationfor
adultsinthe communityis limited,asmanycommunitymembersreportedthattheywere not
invitedtomeetingsheldbythe MoE inwhichenvironmental informationisdiscussedand
disseminated.Targetingadultsasrecipientsof EEis especiallyimportantbecause theyare the
membersof the communitywhoare currentlyengagedincollectionof natural resources,which
sometimesincludesillegalextractionof those resources. A keyfindingwasthe perceptionamong
communitymembersthatincreasedconservationmeasureshave ledtoadecline innatural
resourcesinthe PrekToal Core Area,incontrast to the data frombiodiversitymonitoringthat
indicatessuccessesinprotectingnatural resourcesasaresultof conservation.Itispossible thatthis
lack of confidence amongcommunitymembersinthe effectivenessof conservationapproachesmay
be contributingtocontinuedillegal activity.RegularandcontinuedEEanddisseminationof
informationonconservationmayresultingreatercommunitysupportforthese initiatives. EEneeds
to focusmore on motivatingpeopletoaltertheiractionsandbehaviorsinordertobe successful in
achievingconservationresults,andthatEE initiativesshouldalsobe coupledwithstrategiesto
alleviate povertyandimprove local livelihoods,suchasbyofferingalternative optionsforincome
generation,since the mostcommonlyreportedreasonthatpeople violate restrictionsonresource
use isthat theyand theirfamiliesare dependentonthese resourcesfortheirsurvival.
Hessenius 36
Furtherstudiesshouldcontinue collectingdataonEE inlocal communitiesonthe Tonle Sap
and identifyingopportunitiesforimprovementanddevelopment.Asmore evidence isaccruedon
the methodsandapproachesemployedbyvarious stakeholdersand theirresultsandimpactinthe
local community ingeneratingpositiveactionsandbehaviorsthatsupportconservationof the
environmentandsustainableuse of resources, itwillbecome possible todeterminethe best
practicesand applythe mostsuccessful modelsinmore communitiesinCambodiaandthe region,
while adjustingimplementationtocomplywiththe local social,cultural,economic,and
environmental context.Bydevelopingsucheducational strategieswithanaimto equipindividuals
and communitieswiththe knowledge,skills,andvaluesnecessarytomake environmentally
consciousdecisions,change theiractions,andgenerate innovativesolutionstoenvironmental
problems,EEcan ideally be elevatedtoplaythe role envisionedbythe global communitytoadvance
sustainable development goals,promotingprotectionof the planet’sbiodiversityandimprovement
qualityof life.
Hessenius 37
References
ADB 2010, Cambodia:TonleSap EnvironmentalManagementProjectCompletion Report,ADB,
viewedMay1 2016 http://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/project-document/63385/33418-01-
cam-pcr.pdf
ADB 2011, Cambodia:Tonle SapEnvironmental ManagementProjectValidationReport,ADB,viewed
May 1 2016, http://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/evaluation-document/35547/files/in216-11.pdf
Ardoin,N,Clark,C,& Kelsey,E2013 ‘Anexplorationof future trendsinenvironmentaleducation
research’, EnvironmentalEducation Research,vol.19,no. 4, pp. 499–520
ASEAN 2006, ASEAN EnvironmentalEducation Action Plan 2008-2012, ASEAN,Yangon,viewed1May
2016, http://environment.asean.org/wp-
content/uploads/2015/06/ASEAN_Environmental_Education_Action_Plan_2008-2012.pdf
ASEAN 2013, ASEAN EnvironmentalEducation Action Plan 2014-2018, ASEAN,Surabaya,viewed1
May 2016, http://environment.asean.org/wp-
content/uploads/2015/06/ASEAN_Environmental_Education_Action_Plan_2014-2018.pdf
Awoyemi,SM,Gambrill,A,Ormsby,A,&VyasD 2012, ‘Global EffortstoBridge Religionand
Conservation:Are TheyReallyWorking?’inPovilitisT(ed.) Topicsin Conservation Biology,InTech,
Rijeka,Croatia,viewed1May 2016, http://library.umac.mo/ebooks/b28110031.pdf
BerkleyCenterforReligion,Peace &WorldAffairs n.d., Association of BuddhistsfortheEnvironment,
GeorgetownUniversity,WashingtonD.C.,
http://berkleycenter.georgetown.edu/organizations/association-of-buddhists-for-the-environment
Chim,P2012, ‘AnImplementationof BuddhistEnvironmentalEthicsforSustainableDevelopmentin
Cambodia’,Prajna Vihara Journalof Philosophy and Religion, vol.13,no. 1-2, pp.137-144, viewed1
May 2016, http://www.assumptionjournal.au.edu/index.php/PrajnaVihara/article/view/752/668
Clements,T,John,A,Nielsen,K,Chea,V,Sokha,E& Meas, P2008, CaseStudy Tmatboey
Community-based EcotourismProject,Cambodia,SamVeasnaCenter,SiemReap,viewed1May
2016, http://www.samveasna.org/userfiles/file/WCSCaseStudy-Cambodia-ecotourism-Final.pdf
ConservationInternational 2016, Tonle SapLake: ConservingCambodia’sFish Factory,CI,
http://www.conservation.org/projects/Pages/tonle-sap-lake-conserving-cambodia-fish-factory-
mekong.aspx
Glaser,B & Strauss,A 1967, The Discovery of Grounded Theory:StrategiesforQualitativeResearch,
Chicago,Adine PublishingCompany
Global EnvironmentFacility2011, Terminal Evaluation of TonleSap Conservation Project,GEF,
http://www.thegef.org/gef/sites/thegef.org/files/gef_prj_docs/GEFProjectDocuments/M&E/TER/FY
2011/UNDP/1183/962_BD_Cambodia_TE.pdf
Harris,U 2014, ‘Communicatingclimate change inthe Pacificusingabottom-upapproach’, Pacific
JournalismReview,vol.20, no. 2, pp. 77-95
JapanEnvironmental EducationForum 2007, Database of Environmental EducationRelated
OrganizationsinAsianCountries,JEEF,viewed1May 2016,
http://www.jeef.or.jp/EAST_ASIA/?job_cat=cambodia
Hessenius 38
Khieu,M 2002, The PathTo Success''Some Pioneering ExamplesOf EE'', Institute forGlobal
Environmental Strategies,viewed1May 2016
http://enviroscope.iges.or.jp/modules/envirolib/view.php?docid=1520
Knight, D,Allegretti, A, Vaske,J2015, ‘Informationdissemination-diffusionandmarine protected
area approval inthe Philippines’, Ocean &CoastalManagement, vol.113, pp.38-46
Live & Learn 2015, Building a SustainableFutureA StrategicApproach to EnvironmentalEducation in
the Tonle Sap Region – Cambodia,Live &LearnEnvironmental Education,viewed1May 2016
http://www.livelearn.org/sites/default/files/images/Mini%20Strategy.pdf
Masud, M, Kari,F, Yahaya, S,Al-Amin,A 2014, ‘Impactof residents’livelihoodsonattitudestowards
environmental conservationbehaviour:Anempirical investigationof TiomanIslandMarine Park
area,Malaysia’, Ocean & CoastalManagement,vol.93,pp. 7-14
Monroe,M 2007, ‘A PriorityforESD Research:InfluencingAdultCitizens’, Journalof Education for
SustainableDevelopment,vol.1,no.1, pp. 107-113
Office of the HighCommissiononHumanRights1948, UniversalDeclaration of Human Rights,
OHCHR, viewed1May 2016
http://www.ohchr.org/EN/UDHR/Documents/UDHR_Translations/eng.pdf
Osmose 2014, Social AssessmentPeakKanteilFloating Village,Tonle Sap BiophereReserve,Critical
EcosystemPartnershipFund,viewed1May 2016
http://www.cepf.net/SiteCollectionDocuments/indo_burma_ii/63482_Safeguard_OSMOSE_SocialAs
sessment.pdf
Osmose 2015, Osmose Conservation,Education,Ecotourism, PrekToal,viewed1May 2016
http://www.osmosetonlesap.net/english/accueil.php
Ramsar SitesInformationService 2015, PrekToal RamsarSite, RSIS,viewed1May 2016,
https://rsis.ramsar.org/ris/2245
Sam VeasnaCentern.d., Conservation,SVC,SiemReap,viewed1May 2016
http://www.samveasna.org/conservation.html
Smith,J& Keat,B 2006, Cambodia’sEnvironmentalEducation StatusReport2005, Live andLearn
Environmental Education,PhnomPenh,viewed1May 2016,
http://www.livelearn.org/sites/default/files/docs/LLEE%20Cam%20Status%20Rpt.pdf
Sun,V & Mahood, S 2015, Wildlife Monitoring atPrek Toal RamsarSite,Tonle Sap Great Lake, 2013
and 2014, Wildlife ConservationSocietyCambodia,PhnomPenh
Tonle SapConservationProject2007, Prek ToalCore Area Tonle Sap BiosphereReserve Management
Plan 2007-2011, Ramsar, viewed1May 2016
https://rsis.ramsar.org/RISapp/files/31383985/documents/KH_mgt1511.pdf
UNEP 1972, Stockholm1972 Reportof the UnitedNationsConference onthe HumanEnvironment,
UNEP, viewed1May 2016,
http://www.unep.org/Documents.Multilingual/Default.asp?DocumentID=97&ArticleID=1511).%20In
UNEP 1992, Rio Declaration on Environmentand Development,UNEP,viewed1May 2016
http://www.unep.org/documents.multilingual/default.asp?documentid=78&articleid=1163
Hessenius 39
UNEP 1992, Promoting Education,PublicAwareness,and Training,UNEPviewed1May 2016
http://www.unep.org/documents.multilingual/default.asp?DocumentID=52&ArticleID=4415&l=en
UNEP 2003, UNEP - Principle 10 and the Bali Guideline, UNEP, viewed1May 2016
http://www.unep.org/civil-society/Implementation/Principle10
UNEP 2004, Human Rightsand theEnvironmentProceedingsof a Geneva EnvironmentNetwork
roundtable,UNEP,viewed1May 2016
http://www.genevaenvironmentnetwork.org/?q=en/system/files/human_rights_env_report.pdf
UNEP-OHCHR2009, High Level Expert Meeting on the New Futureof Human Rights and
Environment:Moving theGlobalAgenda Forward,GenevaEnvironmentNetwork,viewed1May
2016,
http://www.genevaenvironmentnetwork.org/?q=en/system/files/human_rights_env_report.pdf
UNESCO 1975, Belgrade Charter,Global DevelopmentResearchCenter,viewed1May 2016,
http://www.gdrc.org/uem/ee/belgrade.html
UNESCO-UNEP1977, Tbilisi Declaration,Global DevelopmentResearchCenter,viewed1May 2016,
http://www.gdrc.org/uem/ee/tbilisi.html
UNESCO 2006, FrameworkfortheUNDESD InternationalImplementation Scheme,UNESCO, Paris,
viewed1May 2016, http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0014/001486/148650E.pdf
UNESCO 2007, UNESCO - MAB BiosphereReservesDirectory, UNESCO,viewed1May 2016,
http://www.unesco.org/mabdb/br/brdir/directory/biores.asp?mode=all&code=CAM+01
UNESCO 2016, World Networkof BiosphereReserves(WNBR),UNESCO,viewed1May 2016,
http://www.unesco.org/new/en/natural-sciences/environment/ecological-sciences/biosphere-
reserves/world-network-wnbr/
WildlifeAlliance2015, Wildlife Alliance,New York,viewedMay1 2016,
http://www.wildlifealliance.org/education
Wildife ConservationSociety2016, WCS Cambodia,PhnomPenh,viewed1May 2016,
http://cambodia.wcs.org/
Hessenius 40
Appendix 1
Interview Date Location Stakeholder Sex and Age
1 15-Apr St. John's Church, Siem Reap Catholic Priest M
2 19-Apr MoE Station, Prek Toal MoE Ranger M-35
3 19-Apr Anlong Taor Village-level Official M-57
4 19-Apr Osmose Platform,Prek Toal Osmose Teacher F-54
5 19-Apr Monastery, Anlong Taor Monk M
6 19-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-63
7 19-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-31
8 20-Apr Osmose Platform,Prek Toal Osmose Representative M-40
9 20-Apr Osmose Platform, Prek Toal Osmose Teacher F-58
10 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community M-37, F-31
11 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-43, M-47
12 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community M-49, F-47
13 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-59, F-30
14 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-47
15 21-Apr Anlong Taor MoE Ranger M-53
16 21-Apr Anlong Taor Community FishingCommittee Member M-52
17 21-Apr Prek Toal Village-level Official M-78
18 21-Apr Prek Toal Community F-49
19 21-Apr Prek Toal Community F-70
20 22-Apr Prek Toal Community M-42
21 22-Apr Prek Toal Community M-55, M-29
22 22-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-51
23 22-Apr Anlong Taor Community FishingCommittee Member M-66
24 22-Apr Anlong Taor MoE Ranger M-33
25 22-Apr MoE Station, Prek Toal MoE Official M
26 22-Apr Phone WCS Representative M
27 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-70
28 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-55, F-22
29 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-57
30 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-39
31 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-59
32 25-Apr Prek Toal Public School Teacher M-31
33 25-Apr Anlong Taor Public School Teacher M-42
34 25-Apr Anlong Taor Public School Teacher F-20
35 26-Apr Prek Toal Public School Teacher F-26
36 26-Apr Anlong Taor Public School Teacher F-27
37 26-Apr Prek Toal Commune-level Official M
38 27-Apr Anlong Taor Public School Teacher F-24
39 27-Apr Prek Toal Community FishingCommittee Member M-50
40 29-Apr Osmose Headquarters,Siem Reap Osmose Representative M
41 29-Apr Siem Reap Live & Learn Cambodia Representative M
Table 2:Full List of Interviews Conducted During Data Collection Period, April 2016
Directed Research: Examination of Environmental Education
Directed Research: Examination of Environmental Education
Directed Research: Examination of Environmental Education
Directed Research: Examination of Environmental Education
Directed Research: Examination of Environmental Education

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

cops-w0753-pub
cops-w0753-pubcops-w0753-pub
cops-w0753-pubSam Wood
 
The crypton laser:Description,Specificities and Applications
The crypton laser:Description,Specificities and ApplicationsThe crypton laser:Description,Specificities and Applications
The crypton laser:Description,Specificities and ApplicationsMuhire Kean
 
Adaptive Networking Protocol for Rapid Mobility
Adaptive Networking Protocol for Rapid MobilityAdaptive Networking Protocol for Rapid Mobility
Adaptive Networking Protocol for Rapid MobilityDr. Edwin Hernandez
 
Arizona schools reopening
Arizona schools reopeningArizona schools reopening
Arizona schools reopeningEducationNC
 
Closing The Loop: the benefits of Circular Economy for developing countries a...
Closing The Loop: the benefits of Circular Economy for developing countries a...Closing The Loop: the benefits of Circular Economy for developing countries a...
Closing The Loop: the benefits of Circular Economy for developing countries a...Alexandre Fernandes
 
Deller rpl thesis
Deller rpl thesisDeller rpl thesis
Deller rpl thesisLinda Meyer
 
Lesser Slave Lake Sustainable Development Study_Ganna Samoylenko
Lesser Slave Lake Sustainable Development Study_Ganna SamoylenkoLesser Slave Lake Sustainable Development Study_Ganna Samoylenko
Lesser Slave Lake Sustainable Development Study_Ganna SamoylenkoGanna Samoylenko
 
Community Health Assessment WMHD
Community Health Assessment WMHDCommunity Health Assessment WMHD
Community Health Assessment WMHDJacob Matthews, MPA
 
Hhs national survey on drug use and health 2011 report
Hhs national survey on drug use and health 2011 reportHhs national survey on drug use and health 2011 report
Hhs national survey on drug use and health 2011 reportDrJYelderMDPhD
 
Pakistan Rural Factor Markets Study :Policy Reforms for Growth and Equity
Pakistan Rural Factor Markets Study :Policy Reforms for Growth and EquityPakistan Rural Factor Markets Study :Policy Reforms for Growth and Equity
Pakistan Rural Factor Markets Study :Policy Reforms for Growth and Equityidspak
 
Sanitation Personnel. Capacity Development Strategy.
Sanitation Personnel. Capacity Development Strategy.Sanitation Personnel. Capacity Development Strategy.
Sanitation Personnel. Capacity Development Strategy.Oswar Mungkasa
 
Global Export Forecast 2012
Global Export Forecast 2012Global Export Forecast 2012
Global Export Forecast 2012Colin McKillop
 
Our Land, Our Water: Case Studies in Local Success
Our Land, Our Water: Case Studies in Local SuccessOur Land, Our Water: Case Studies in Local Success
Our Land, Our Water: Case Studies in Local SuccessSotirakou964
 
Hcad mass appraisal report 2016
Hcad mass appraisal report 2016Hcad mass appraisal report 2016
Hcad mass appraisal report 2016cutmytaxes
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

The Thin Months Revisited
The Thin Months RevisitedThe Thin Months Revisited
The Thin Months Revisited
 
cops-w0753-pub
cops-w0753-pubcops-w0753-pub
cops-w0753-pub
 
The crypton laser:Description,Specificities and Applications
The crypton laser:Description,Specificities and ApplicationsThe crypton laser:Description,Specificities and Applications
The crypton laser:Description,Specificities and Applications
 
Adaptive Networking Protocol for Rapid Mobility
Adaptive Networking Protocol for Rapid MobilityAdaptive Networking Protocol for Rapid Mobility
Adaptive Networking Protocol for Rapid Mobility
 
Arizona schools reopening
Arizona schools reopeningArizona schools reopening
Arizona schools reopening
 
Closing The Loop: the benefits of Circular Economy for developing countries a...
Closing The Loop: the benefits of Circular Economy for developing countries a...Closing The Loop: the benefits of Circular Economy for developing countries a...
Closing The Loop: the benefits of Circular Economy for developing countries a...
 
Deller rpl thesis
Deller rpl thesisDeller rpl thesis
Deller rpl thesis
 
Lesser Slave Lake Sustainable Development Study_Ganna Samoylenko
Lesser Slave Lake Sustainable Development Study_Ganna SamoylenkoLesser Slave Lake Sustainable Development Study_Ganna Samoylenko
Lesser Slave Lake Sustainable Development Study_Ganna Samoylenko
 
Compressed CHA
Compressed CHACompressed CHA
Compressed CHA
 
Community Health Assessment WMHD
Community Health Assessment WMHDCommunity Health Assessment WMHD
Community Health Assessment WMHD
 
Hhs national survey on drug use and health 2011 report
Hhs national survey on drug use and health 2011 reportHhs national survey on drug use and health 2011 report
Hhs national survey on drug use and health 2011 report
 
Pakistan Rural Factor Markets Study :Policy Reforms for Growth and Equity
Pakistan Rural Factor Markets Study :Policy Reforms for Growth and EquityPakistan Rural Factor Markets Study :Policy Reforms for Growth and Equity
Pakistan Rural Factor Markets Study :Policy Reforms for Growth and Equity
 
Volunteer Manual
Volunteer ManualVolunteer Manual
Volunteer Manual
 
Sanitation Personnel. Capacity Development Strategy.
Sanitation Personnel. Capacity Development Strategy.Sanitation Personnel. Capacity Development Strategy.
Sanitation Personnel. Capacity Development Strategy.
 
Global Export Forecast 2012
Global Export Forecast 2012Global Export Forecast 2012
Global Export Forecast 2012
 
iswpp_03-2010
iswpp_03-2010iswpp_03-2010
iswpp_03-2010
 
Tap21
Tap21Tap21
Tap21
 
Our Land, Our Water: Case Studies in Local Success
Our Land, Our Water: Case Studies in Local SuccessOur Land, Our Water: Case Studies in Local Success
Our Land, Our Water: Case Studies in Local Success
 
Hcad mass appraisal report 2016
Hcad mass appraisal report 2016Hcad mass appraisal report 2016
Hcad mass appraisal report 2016
 
Vaccine Logistics and Supply Chain | National Cold Chain Assessment India
Vaccine Logistics and Supply Chain | National Cold Chain Assessment IndiaVaccine Logistics and Supply Chain | National Cold Chain Assessment India
Vaccine Logistics and Supply Chain | National Cold Chain Assessment India
 

Andere mochten auch

Pourquoi un programme de formation des employés est important pour votre tran...
Pourquoi un programme de formation des employés est important pour votre tran...Pourquoi un programme de formation des employés est important pour votre tran...
Pourquoi un programme de formation des employés est important pour votre tran...IAMCP Canada
 
Transformation numérique 5 juillet 2016 Quimper
Transformation numérique 5 juillet 2016 QuimperTransformation numérique 5 juillet 2016 Quimper
Transformation numérique 5 juillet 2016 QuimperCantine numérique Quimper
 
20151118 Transformation numerique et reseaux sociaux
20151118 Transformation numerique et reseaux sociaux20151118 Transformation numerique et reseaux sociaux
20151118 Transformation numerique et reseaux sociauxGaston Guéna
 
La dématérialisation des processus métiers
La dématérialisation des processus métiersLa dématérialisation des processus métiers
La dématérialisation des processus métiersOurouk
 
60min pour l'Innovation dans la Transformation Numérique par Antoine Chotard ...
60min pour l'Innovation dans la Transformation Numérique par Antoine Chotard ...60min pour l'Innovation dans la Transformation Numérique par Antoine Chotard ...
60min pour l'Innovation dans la Transformation Numérique par Antoine Chotard ...Antoine Chotard
 
Les ECNi : une transformation numérique réussie
Les ECNi : une transformation numérique réussieLes ECNi : une transformation numérique réussie
Les ECNi : une transformation numérique réussieAntoine Vigneron
 
Talk sur la Gestion de projet informatique
Talk sur la Gestion de projet informatiqueTalk sur la Gestion de projet informatique
Talk sur la Gestion de projet informatiqueKader KANE
 
Relever le défi SI de la transformation numérique en Europe
Relever le défi SI de la transformation numérique en EuropeRelever le défi SI de la transformation numérique en Europe
Relever le défi SI de la transformation numérique en EuropeAntoine Vigneron
 

Andere mochten auch (11)

Le cloud computing
Le cloud computingLe cloud computing
Le cloud computing
 
Le Cloud computing c'est quoi ?
Le Cloud computing c'est quoi ?Le Cloud computing c'est quoi ?
Le Cloud computing c'est quoi ?
 
Pourquoi un programme de formation des employés est important pour votre tran...
Pourquoi un programme de formation des employés est important pour votre tran...Pourquoi un programme de formation des employés est important pour votre tran...
Pourquoi un programme de formation des employés est important pour votre tran...
 
Transformation numérique 5 juillet 2016 Quimper
Transformation numérique 5 juillet 2016 QuimperTransformation numérique 5 juillet 2016 Quimper
Transformation numérique 5 juillet 2016 Quimper
 
20151118 Transformation numerique et reseaux sociaux
20151118 Transformation numerique et reseaux sociaux20151118 Transformation numerique et reseaux sociaux
20151118 Transformation numerique et reseaux sociaux
 
La dématérialisation des processus métiers
La dématérialisation des processus métiersLa dématérialisation des processus métiers
La dématérialisation des processus métiers
 
60min pour l'Innovation dans la Transformation Numérique par Antoine Chotard ...
60min pour l'Innovation dans la Transformation Numérique par Antoine Chotard ...60min pour l'Innovation dans la Transformation Numérique par Antoine Chotard ...
60min pour l'Innovation dans la Transformation Numérique par Antoine Chotard ...
 
Program Management
Program ManagementProgram Management
Program Management
 
Les ECNi : une transformation numérique réussie
Les ECNi : une transformation numérique réussieLes ECNi : une transformation numérique réussie
Les ECNi : une transformation numérique réussie
 
Talk sur la Gestion de projet informatique
Talk sur la Gestion de projet informatiqueTalk sur la Gestion de projet informatique
Talk sur la Gestion de projet informatique
 
Relever le défi SI de la transformation numérique en Europe
Relever le défi SI de la transformation numérique en EuropeRelever le défi SI de la transformation numérique en Europe
Relever le défi SI de la transformation numérique en Europe
 

Ähnlich wie Directed Research: Examination of Environmental Education

PNABZufykuyfluiyflyufliuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulhcmhgcht...
PNABZufykuyfluiyflyufliuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulhcmhgcht...PNABZufykuyfluiyflyufliuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulhcmhgcht...
PNABZufykuyfluiyflyufliuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulhcmhgcht...SirajudinAkmel1
 
Day Stay Program - Research and Evaluation - Tweddle Child and Family Health ...
Day Stay Program - Research and Evaluation - Tweddle Child and Family Health ...Day Stay Program - Research and Evaluation - Tweddle Child and Family Health ...
Day Stay Program - Research and Evaluation - Tweddle Child and Family Health ...Tweddle Australia
 
Situation analysis rupandehi1
Situation analysis rupandehi1Situation analysis rupandehi1
Situation analysis rupandehi1Biplop Pokharel
 
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENTFINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENTLaura Peltonen
 
Rat Lab Manual
Rat Lab ManualRat Lab Manual
Rat Lab Manualk3stone
 
Social Vulnerability Assessment Tools for Climate Change and DRR Programming
Social Vulnerability Assessment Tools for Climate Change and DRR ProgrammingSocial Vulnerability Assessment Tools for Climate Change and DRR Programming
Social Vulnerability Assessment Tools for Climate Change and DRR ProgrammingUNDP Climate
 
Research & Analysis Report for Elderly and Health-related Information
Research & Analysis Report for Elderly and Health-related InformationResearch & Analysis Report for Elderly and Health-related Information
Research & Analysis Report for Elderly and Health-related InformationCHEN DI
 
Baseline Survey Report for the Radio School Project-Final
Baseline Survey Report for the Radio School Project-FinalBaseline Survey Report for the Radio School Project-Final
Baseline Survey Report for the Radio School Project-FinalGerald Ogoko
 
Is psychotherapy effective for reducing suicide attempt and non suicidal sel...
Is psychotherapy effective for reducing suicide attempt and non  suicidal sel...Is psychotherapy effective for reducing suicide attempt and non  suicidal sel...
Is psychotherapy effective for reducing suicide attempt and non suicidal sel...Daryl Chow
 
LEA AL ASSAD.docx
LEA AL ASSAD.docxLEA AL ASSAD.docx
LEA AL ASSAD.docxLALune12
 
College America Grant Reports- Final Evaluation
College America Grant Reports- Final EvaluationCollege America Grant Reports- Final Evaluation
College America Grant Reports- Final EvaluationCOCommunityCollegeSystem
 
ICTs_for_Child_Protection_Case_Management_Research_HealthEnabled
ICTs_for_Child_Protection_Case_Management_Research_HealthEnabledICTs_for_Child_Protection_Case_Management_Research_HealthEnabled
ICTs_for_Child_Protection_Case_Management_Research_HealthEnabledwcphilbrick
 
Promente Seeyn Voluntarism Research Results
Promente Seeyn Voluntarism Research ResultsPromente Seeyn Voluntarism Research Results
Promente Seeyn Voluntarism Research ResultsproMENTE social research
 
Healthy Families Healthy Forests_CI's PHE end of project report article
Healthy Families Healthy Forests_CI's PHE end of project report articleHealthy Families Healthy Forests_CI's PHE end of project report article
Healthy Families Healthy Forests_CI's PHE end of project report articleMarcelino Jr. Viernes
 
Pisa test
Pisa testPisa test
Pisa testhome
 
Northfield Township Master Plan (final_6_17_13)
Northfield Township Master Plan (final_6_17_13)Northfield Township Master Plan (final_6_17_13)
Northfield Township Master Plan (final_6_17_13)JGNelson
 

Ähnlich wie Directed Research: Examination of Environmental Education (20)

PNABZufykuyfluiyflyufliuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulhcmhgcht...
PNABZufykuyfluiyflyufliuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulhcmhgcht...PNABZufykuyfluiyflyufliuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulhcmhgcht...
PNABZufykuyfluiyflyufliuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuulhcmhgcht...
 
wfp268240
wfp268240wfp268240
wfp268240
 
Day Stay Program - Research and Evaluation - Tweddle Child and Family Health ...
Day Stay Program - Research and Evaluation - Tweddle Child and Family Health ...Day Stay Program - Research and Evaluation - Tweddle Child and Family Health ...
Day Stay Program - Research and Evaluation - Tweddle Child and Family Health ...
 
Suero hipertónico en bronquiolitis
Suero hipertónico en bronquiolitisSuero hipertónico en bronquiolitis
Suero hipertónico en bronquiolitis
 
Situation analysis rupandehi1
Situation analysis rupandehi1Situation analysis rupandehi1
Situation analysis rupandehi1
 
DNevels_USC_Thesis
DNevels_USC_ThesisDNevels_USC_Thesis
DNevels_USC_Thesis
 
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENTFINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
 
Rat Lab Manual
Rat Lab ManualRat Lab Manual
Rat Lab Manual
 
Rat Lab Manual
Rat Lab ManualRat Lab Manual
Rat Lab Manual
 
Social Vulnerability Assessment Tools for Climate Change and DRR Programming
Social Vulnerability Assessment Tools for Climate Change and DRR ProgrammingSocial Vulnerability Assessment Tools for Climate Change and DRR Programming
Social Vulnerability Assessment Tools for Climate Change and DRR Programming
 
Research & Analysis Report for Elderly and Health-related Information
Research & Analysis Report for Elderly and Health-related InformationResearch & Analysis Report for Elderly and Health-related Information
Research & Analysis Report for Elderly and Health-related Information
 
Baseline Survey Report for the Radio School Project-Final
Baseline Survey Report for the Radio School Project-FinalBaseline Survey Report for the Radio School Project-Final
Baseline Survey Report for the Radio School Project-Final
 
Is psychotherapy effective for reducing suicide attempt and non suicidal sel...
Is psychotherapy effective for reducing suicide attempt and non  suicidal sel...Is psychotherapy effective for reducing suicide attempt and non  suicidal sel...
Is psychotherapy effective for reducing suicide attempt and non suicidal sel...
 
LEA AL ASSAD.docx
LEA AL ASSAD.docxLEA AL ASSAD.docx
LEA AL ASSAD.docx
 
College America Grant Reports- Final Evaluation
College America Grant Reports- Final EvaluationCollege America Grant Reports- Final Evaluation
College America Grant Reports- Final Evaluation
 
ICTs_for_Child_Protection_Case_Management_Research_HealthEnabled
ICTs_for_Child_Protection_Case_Management_Research_HealthEnabledICTs_for_Child_Protection_Case_Management_Research_HealthEnabled
ICTs_for_Child_Protection_Case_Management_Research_HealthEnabled
 
Promente Seeyn Voluntarism Research Results
Promente Seeyn Voluntarism Research ResultsPromente Seeyn Voluntarism Research Results
Promente Seeyn Voluntarism Research Results
 
Healthy Families Healthy Forests_CI's PHE end of project report article
Healthy Families Healthy Forests_CI's PHE end of project report articleHealthy Families Healthy Forests_CI's PHE end of project report article
Healthy Families Healthy Forests_CI's PHE end of project report article
 
Pisa test
Pisa testPisa test
Pisa test
 
Northfield Township Master Plan (final_6_17_13)
Northfield Township Master Plan (final_6_17_13)Northfield Township Master Plan (final_6_17_13)
Northfield Township Master Plan (final_6_17_13)
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Spiders by Slidesgo - an introduction to arachnids
Spiders by Slidesgo - an introduction to arachnidsSpiders by Slidesgo - an introduction to arachnids
Spiders by Slidesgo - an introduction to arachnidsprasan26
 
Determination of antibacterial activity of various broad spectrum antibiotics...
Determination of antibacterial activity of various broad spectrum antibiotics...Determination of antibacterial activity of various broad spectrum antibiotics...
Determination of antibacterial activity of various broad spectrum antibiotics...Open Access Research Paper
 
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call GirlsHi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girlsssuser7cb4ff
 
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...Delhi Escorts
 
办理La Trobe学位证(文凭证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证成绩单原版一模一样
办理La Trobe学位证(文凭证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证成绩单原版一模一样办理La Trobe学位证(文凭证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证成绩单原版一模一样
办理La Trobe学位证(文凭证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证成绩单原版一模一样umasea
 
See How do animals kill their prey for food
See How do animals kill their prey for foodSee How do animals kill their prey for food
See How do animals kill their prey for fooddrsk203
 
earthquake drill seminar for schools.pptx
earthquake drill  seminar for schools.pptxearthquake drill  seminar for schools.pptx
earthquake drill seminar for schools.pptxBfpSiniloanFSLaguna
 
Philippines-Native-Chicken.pptx file copy
Philippines-Native-Chicken.pptx file copyPhilippines-Native-Chicken.pptx file copy
Philippines-Native-Chicken.pptx file copyKristineRoseCorrales
 
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesGwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Servicesnajka9823
 
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Educationz xss
 
Delivering nature-based solution outcomes by addressing policy, institutiona...
Delivering nature-based solution outcomes by addressing  policy, institutiona...Delivering nature-based solution outcomes by addressing  policy, institutiona...
Delivering nature-based solution outcomes by addressing policy, institutiona...CIFOR-ICRAF
 
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full NightCall Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Nightssuser7cb4ff
 
Poly-film-Prefab cover agricultural greenhouse-polyhouse structure.pptx
Poly-film-Prefab cover agricultural greenhouse-polyhouse structure.pptxPoly-film-Prefab cover agricultural greenhouse-polyhouse structure.pptx
Poly-film-Prefab cover agricultural greenhouse-polyhouse structure.pptxAgrodome projects LLP
 
Abu Dhabi Sea Beach Visitor Community pp
Abu Dhabi Sea Beach Visitor Community ppAbu Dhabi Sea Beach Visitor Community pp
Abu Dhabi Sea Beach Visitor Community pp202215407
 
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一z xss
 
AI and Ecology - The H4rmony Project.pptx
AI and Ecology - The H4rmony Project.pptxAI and Ecology - The H4rmony Project.pptx
AI and Ecology - The H4rmony Project.pptxNeoV2
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Spiders by Slidesgo - an introduction to arachnids
Spiders by Slidesgo - an introduction to arachnidsSpiders by Slidesgo - an introduction to arachnids
Spiders by Slidesgo - an introduction to arachnids
 
Determination of antibacterial activity of various broad spectrum antibiotics...
Determination of antibacterial activity of various broad spectrum antibiotics...Determination of antibacterial activity of various broad spectrum antibiotics...
Determination of antibacterial activity of various broad spectrum antibiotics...
 
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call GirlsHi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
 
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
 
办理La Trobe学位证(文凭证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证成绩单原版一模一样
办理La Trobe学位证(文凭证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证成绩单原版一模一样办理La Trobe学位证(文凭证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证成绩单原版一模一样
办理La Trobe学位证(文凭证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证成绩单原版一模一样
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In kashmiri gate (Delhi) Call Us 9953056974
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In  kashmiri gate (Delhi) Call Us 9953056974FULL ENJOY Call Girls In  kashmiri gate (Delhi) Call Us 9953056974
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In kashmiri gate (Delhi) Call Us 9953056974
 
young call girls in Janakpuri🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
young call girls in Janakpuri🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Serviceyoung call girls in Janakpuri🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
young call girls in Janakpuri🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
 
Hot Sexy call girls in Nehru Place, 🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
Hot Sexy call girls in Nehru Place, 🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort ServiceHot Sexy call girls in Nehru Place, 🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
Hot Sexy call girls in Nehru Place, 🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
 
See How do animals kill their prey for food
See How do animals kill their prey for foodSee How do animals kill their prey for food
See How do animals kill their prey for food
 
earthquake drill seminar for schools.pptx
earthquake drill  seminar for schools.pptxearthquake drill  seminar for schools.pptx
earthquake drill seminar for schools.pptx
 
Philippines-Native-Chicken.pptx file copy
Philippines-Native-Chicken.pptx file copyPhilippines-Native-Chicken.pptx file copy
Philippines-Native-Chicken.pptx file copy
 
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesGwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
 
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
 
Delivering nature-based solution outcomes by addressing policy, institutiona...
Delivering nature-based solution outcomes by addressing  policy, institutiona...Delivering nature-based solution outcomes by addressing  policy, institutiona...
Delivering nature-based solution outcomes by addressing policy, institutiona...
 
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full NightCall Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
 
Poly-film-Prefab cover agricultural greenhouse-polyhouse structure.pptx
Poly-film-Prefab cover agricultural greenhouse-polyhouse structure.pptxPoly-film-Prefab cover agricultural greenhouse-polyhouse structure.pptx
Poly-film-Prefab cover agricultural greenhouse-polyhouse structure.pptx
 
Model Call Girl in Rajiv Chowk Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Rajiv Chowk Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Rajiv Chowk Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Rajiv Chowk Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
Abu Dhabi Sea Beach Visitor Community pp
Abu Dhabi Sea Beach Visitor Community ppAbu Dhabi Sea Beach Visitor Community pp
Abu Dhabi Sea Beach Visitor Community pp
 
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 
AI and Ecology - The H4rmony Project.pptx
AI and Ecology - The H4rmony Project.pptxAI and Ecology - The H4rmony Project.pptx
AI and Ecology - The H4rmony Project.pptx
 

Directed Research: Examination of Environmental Education

  • 1. Examination of Environmental Education Initiatives in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages in Cambodia Angela Hessenius University of San Diego San Diego, California, United States Center for Mekong Studies, The School for Field Studies Siem Reap, Cambodia Research Advisor: Georgina Lloyd Rivera, Ph.D. 5 May 2015
  • 2. Hessenius 2 Table of Contents Tables...........................................................................................................................................................................................3 Figures .........................................................................................................................................................................................3 Abbreviationsand Terminology................................................................................................................................................3 Abbreviations.........................................................................................................................................................................3 Terminology...........................................................................................................................................................................4 Acknowledgements....................................................................................................................................................................4 Declaration..................................................................................................................................................................................5 Abstract.......................................................................................................................................................................................5 1. Introduction............................................................................................................................................................................5 1.1 Scope of Environmental Education...............................................................................................................................5 1.1.1. Global Context of Environmental Education.......................................................................................................5 1.1.2. Regional Scope of Environmental Education.......................................................................................................7 1.1.3. Environmental Educationin Cambodia................................................................................................................8 1.2 Environmental and Social Context of Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages.............................................................12 1.3 Aims and Objectives of Study.....................................................................................................................................13 2. Methods...............................................................................................................................................................................14 2.1 Study Period and Location...........................................................................................................................................14 2.2 Data Collection Methods.............................................................................................................................................14 2.3 Data Analysis Tools ......................................................................................................................................................16 2.4 Limitations of Study.....................................................................................................................................................16 3. Results ..................................................................................................................................................................................16 3.1 Osmose..........................................................................................................................................................................16 3.2 Public School.................................................................................................................................................................18 3.3 Ministry of Environment..............................................................................................................................................19 3.4 Community Fishery Committees ................................................................................................................................20 3.5 Other stakeholders ......................................................................................................................................................22 3.6 Community Environmental Awareness and Perceptions.........................................................................................24 4. Discussion.............................................................................................................................................................................26 4.1 Access to Education and Dissemination of Conservation Results Information......................................................27 4.2 Focus on Education for Children and Gap in Adult EE..............................................................................................29 4.3 Defermentof Responsibility to Other Stakeholders.................................................................................................30 4.4 Potential Benefits of Bottom-Up and Community-Based EE...................................................................................31 4.5 Shifting Focus from Awareness to Behavior Change................................................................................................32 4.6 Importance of IntegratingEducation with Livelihood Improvement......................................................................33 5. Conclusion............................................................................................................................................................................35 References................................................................................................................................................................................37 Appendix 1...............................................................................................................................................................................40 Appendix 2...............................................................................................................................................................................41
  • 3. Hessenius 3 Tables Table 1: Listof OpportunitiesandChallengesIdentifiedforEEStakeholdersinPrekToal andAnlong Taor Villages, Cambodia, 2016..................................................................................................... 27 Table 2: Full List of Interviews Conducted During Data Collection Period,April 2016....................... 40 Figures Figure 1: Map of Prek Toal Core Area, Osmose 2015..................................................................... 14 Figure 2: Pie Chart of StakeholderGroupsInterviewedduringDataCollectionPeriodinPrekToal and Anlong Taor villages inApril 2016 ................................................................................................ 15 Figure 3: Picturesof ExteriorandInteriorof Osmose FloatingClassroominPrekToal village, Cambodia, taken April 2016 ........................................................................................................ 17 Figure 4: ResponsesfromCommunityandOtherStakeholderGroups(includingMoERangers, Osmose Teachers,PublicSchool Teachers,CommunityFisheryCommitteeMembers,andPublic Officials) onLevelof KnowledgeandInterestinLearningaboutthe EnvironmentamongLocal Community Members in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages, Cambodia, in 2016. ........................... 25 Abbreviations and Terminology Abbreviations ABE: Associationof Buddhistsforthe Environment ADB: AsianDevelopmentBank ASEAN:Associationof SoutheastAsianNations CFi:CommunityFishery DESD: Decade of EducationforSustainable Development EE: EnvironmentalEducation FCA:Fish ConservationArea GEF: Global EnvironmentFund JEEF: JapanEnvironmental EducationForum MoE: Ministryof Environment MOEYS: Ministryof Education,Youth,andSport NGO: non-governmental organization OHCHR: Office of HighCommissiononHumanRights
  • 4. Hessenius 4 RSIS:Ramsar SitesInformationService SSI:Semi-structuredinterview TSCP: Tonle SapConservationProject TSEMP: Tonle Sap Environmental ManagementProject UN: UnitedNations UNEP: UnitedNationsEnvironmentProgramme UN FAO:UnitedNationsFoodandAgriculture Organization UNESCO: UnitedNationsEducation,Social,andCultural Organization USAID: UnitedStatesAgencyforInternationalDevelopment WCS: WildlifeConservationSociety Terminology Mey kum:Commune chief Mey phum:Village chief Sangha:Communityof Buddhistmonksandnuns Acknowledgements There are several people withoutwhomitwouldnothave beenpossible tocomplete this study,andI wouldlike tothankthemdeeplyandgenuinely. First,IwouldliketothankDr. Georgina Lloyd-Rivera,forherindispensable guidance throughoutthe entire processof research,data collection,andwriting,andherconfidence inme togatherand interpretourfindings.SamrithVichet was alsoa vital part of my success,notonlyas an extremelyproficienttranslator,butalsoasthe supportive teammate whowasalwaysbymyside.Iwouldalsolike tothankmyparents,fortheir constantsupportand alsotheirconfidence andtrustinme,and forgivingme more opportunities than I couldeverdeserve.Iwouldalsolike tothankmyhome school,the Universityof SanDiego,for theirfinancial supportthroughthe AlcaláScholarshipthathashelpedmake byeducationpossible, and alsofor the manymembersof the USD communitywhohave helpednurture mylove of learning,mypassions,and helpedmake USDa place I not onlylearnatby where Ifeel a sense of home and belonging. Iwouldlike toacknowledgeandthankthe Ministryof Environmentof the Royal Governmentof Cambodiaforgrantinguspermissiontodoresearchandcollectthe data that formedthe basisof thisstudy.Finally,Iwouldliketoexpressmydeepandsincere gratitude forall the people whowere the subjectsof thisstudy,wholetme take the time tointerview them, who oftengraciouslyandgenerouslyopenedtheirhomestome,andprovidedme withaninvaluable glimpse intotheirlives.
  • 5. Hessenius 5 Declaration I, AngelaHessenius,acknowledgethatthe researchembodiedinthispaperisentirelymyownwork, that where the ideasof othershave beenused,the sourceshave beenacknowledged,andthatno portionof thisresearchhas beenpreviouslysubmittedforgradingatThe School forFieldStudiesor the Universityof SanDiego. Signed:__________________________________ Date: ___5 May 2015____ AngelaHessenius Abstract Environmental education(EE) isfundamental inachievingsustainable developmentand environmental conservationgoals, andevaluationof EEinitiatives isnecessarytoimprove their effectiveness.Thisstudyprovidesanexaminationof EE initiativesinPrekToal andAnlongTaor villages, asfewformal evaluationshave beencompleted. Semi-structuredinterviews(SSIs) were conductedwithkeyinformantsfromstakeholdergroups involvedinEEand local community membersinPrekToal and AnlongTaorvillagesonthe Tonle SapinCambodia. Itwas foundthatEE has had substantial positiveimpactsinthe community,yetalsofacessignificantchallengesandis currentlylimitedbyanumberof factors.These includedlimitedaccesstoeducationforadults,alack of disseminationof informationonsuccessfulconservationinitiatives,anda needforintegrationof EE withimprovinglivelihoodsandbuildingcapacityforbehaviorchangesthatsupportconservation and ecological sustainability.The explorationof these challengesisessential tobe able toreframe such obstaclesasopportunities,becauseonce theyare recognized,suchimpedimentscan transformedinto targetsforimprovement toEE inthe community. Keywords:Environmentaleducation;Tonle Sap;Educationforsustainable development; Conservation;Environment;Accesstoeducation;AdultEducation;Behaviorchange;Livelihood Improvement 1. Introduction 1.1 Scope of Environmental Education 1.1.1. Global Context of Environmental Education Environmental education(EE) isabroad conceptwithoutauniversallyaccepteddefinition (Smith& Keat2006). The definitionincludedwithinthe TbilisiDeclaration,the productof the first IntergovernmentalConferenceonEnvironmental Education in1977, may serve asa foundation:
  • 6. Hessenius 6 Environmental educationisalearningprocessthatincreasespeople’sknowledgeand awarenessaboutthe environmentandassociatedchallenges,developsthe necessaryskills and expertisetoaddressthe challenges,andfostersattitudes,motivations,and commitmentstomake informeddecisionsandtake responsibleaction(UNESCO-UNEP1977) ThisdefinitionclearlyidentifiesthatEE entailsmore thanmerelyanincrease inknowledgeand awarenessaboutthe environmentandglobal environmental issues.Italsomobilizespeople to transformthisknowledgeintopractice andaction.Minimizingenvironmental harmcausedby humanactivitiesandworkingtowardsthe creationof solutions andthe pathof sustainable developmentare seenasessential componentsof EE (Smith&Keat2006). Springingfromthisbroad scope of environmentaleducation,manyhave alsorecognizedthe linkbetweenpovertyreduction and EE, and acknowledge thatpeople needtobe equippedwiththe capabilitiesandenvironmental assetsto meettheirneedsinasustainable way,otherwise peoplewillcontinuetopursue livelihood activitiesthatcause environmentaldegradation(Smith&Keat2006, Ardoin,Clark,&Kelsey2013, Khieu2002, ADB 2011) These loftyanddiverse goalsof EE have increasinglybeencitedasa necessarycomponentof improvingglobal environmental managementandincorporatedintogoalsandobjectivesof organizationsatmanydifferentscales (Smith&Keat2006, UNESCO 2006, ASEAN 2013). EE was first codifiedasaninternational priorityin Principle 19of the Declarationof the UnitedNations Conference on the HumanEnvironmentheldinStockholmin1972, whichdeclaredenvironmental education asessential (UNEP1972). Recommendation96of the Declaration alsocalledforthe establishmentof aninternational programonEE (UNEP 1972). In 1975, an International Environmental WorkshopinBelgrade addressedthisrecommendationandoutlinedaglobal frameworkforenvironmental education.The Belgrade Charterof 1975 identifiedthe goal of EE as follows: To developaworldpopulationthatisaware of,andconcernedabout,the environmentand itsassociatedproblems,andwhichhasthe knowledge,skills,attitudes,motivationsand commitmenttoworkindividuallyandcollectivelytowardsolutionsof currentproblemsand the preventionof newones(UNESCO1975). The Intergovernmental Conference onEnvironmental Education,heldin 1977, expandeduponthe goals,objectives,andguidingprinciplesforEEexpressedinthe BelgradeCharter,andincludedthe followinggoalsforEE:
  • 7. Hessenius 7 1. to fosterclearawarenessof,andconcernabout,economic,social,political,andecological interdependence inurbanandrural areas; 2. to provide everypersonwithopportunitiestoacquire the knowledge,values,attitudes, commitment,andskillsneededtoprotectandimprove the environment; 3. to create newpatternsof behaviorof individuals,groups,andsocietyasa whole towards the environment(UNESCO-UNEP1977). The importance of educationforachievingsustainabledevelopmentandthe needtointegrate EE intoeducationforall levelsof societywasalsorecognizedwithinChapter36 of Agenda21, the productof the UN Conference onEnvironmentandDevelopmentin1992 (UNEP1992a). Most recently,thislinkbetweenEEandsustainable developmentwaspromoted onthe international level throughthe designationof 2005-2014 as the Decade of EducationforSustainable Development (DESD) by the UnitedNationsGeneral Assemblyin2002 (Smith& Keat2006). The DESD wasa broad and ambitiousplantoincorporate the inherentvaluesof sustainabilityinall formsof learningin orderto encourage andempowerindividualsandsocietytoundergoatransformationtowardsthe securityof a justand sustainable future (UNESCO2006).The DESD envisions“aworldwhere everyone hasthe opportunitytobenefitfromeducationandlearnthe values,behaviourand lifestylesrequiredforasustainable future andforpositivesocietal transformation”(UNESCO2006, pg. 4). The goalsof the DESD thus situate EE withinthe broadersocial,cultural,economic,and political contextof sustainabledevelopment,andacknowledgethe necessityof EEto continue focusingonthe relationshipbetweenhumankindandthe natural worldandstrategiesforthe preservationandsustainable use of itsresources(UNESCO2006). 1.1.2. Regional Scope of Environmental Education In response tothispushfrominternational organizationssuchas UnitedNations Educational,Scientific,andCultural Organization (UNESCO) andthe UnitedNationsEnvironment Programme (UNEP) promotingEEand educationasa strategyfor sustainable development,regional effortstoexpandEE have alsobeenformulated.The Associationof SoutheastAsianNations(ASEAN) adoptedthe ASEAN Environmental EducationActionPlanfor2000-2005 andsuccessorplansfor 2008-2012 and 2014-2018, whichincorporatedthe goalsthe DESD.The ASEAN Environmental EducationActionPlansarticulatedthe fundamental importance of EEfor the achievementof sustainable developmentgoals: EE iskeyto the overall ESDstrategysince humanity'svalue forandunderstandingof nature, and itssustainable use andmanagementof natural resourcesformthe basisforsustainable economies,harmonioussocietiesandhealthypeople (ASEAN 2006).
  • 8. Hessenius 8 The ASEAN Environmental EducationActionPlans establishedastrategiccollaborativeframeworkto “accelerate the developmentandadvancementof environmental education”withspecificobjectives infour targetareas: formal education,non-formal education,humanresource capacitybuilding,and networking,collaboration,andcommunication(ASEAN 2013).While the ASEAN membercountries have made progressinactive engagementinEEacross multiple sectorsof society,substantial challengesremain,includingthe needformore teacherswell-trainedandknowledgeable inEE,for more instructional materials,andmore fundsallocatedfromthe governmenttosupportEE initiatives (Smith&Keat2006). 1.1.3. Environmental Education in Cambodia The impetusforthe developmentof EEfrominternational andregional policieshave contributedtodevelopmentsof EEfrom a wide range of stakeholdersinCambodia,thoughthere remainsignificantlimitationsandroomforgrowth. Due toCambodia’shistoryof more thantwenty yearsof conflict,whichcoincided withthe developingawarenessof environmentalproblemsand prioritizationof sustainable developmentandEEamong the internationalcommunity,EEhas hada relativelyshorthistoryinCambodiacomparedtomanyothernations andisstill inan initial phase (Smith& Keat2006). However,since the mid-1990s,EE has increasinglybeenadministeredbyboth governmentandNGOstakeholders(Smith&Keat2006). The MoE has made importantprogressin implementingEEon a national level,includingcollaborationwith the Ministryof Education,Youth and Sport(MOEYS) to trainprimaryschool teachers,buildinghumanresource capacityby conductingtrainingsforprovincial environmentdepartmentemployees,andpublicenvironmental awareness-raisingcampaignsthroughmedia,suchas national televisionandradiobroadcasts, and eventssuchas National andWorldEnvironmentDay(Smith&Keat2006). Despite these accomplishments,the MoEstill facessignificantchallengestothe implementationof EE,including limitedhuman resources,materials,financialsupport,planning,andcollaborationamong stakeholders(Smith&Keat2006). A representative,butnotexhaustive,listof NGOsfocusedonEE in Cambodiainclude Live and LearnEnvironmental Education,MlupBaitong,the UN FoodandAgricultural Organization (FAO) inSiemReap,Save Cambodia’sWildlife,Osmose, Wildlife Alliance,the Associationof Buddhistsfor the Environment(ABE),the Culture andEnvironmentPreservationAssociation,andmore (Smith& Keat2006, JapanEnvironmental EducationForum(JEEF) 2007, WildlifeAlliance 2015).Organizations such as the WildlifeConservationSociety(WCS),SamVeasnaCenter,and ConservationInternational are alsoinvolvedin projectstoimprove livelihoodsinlocal communitiesbygeneratingalternative sourcesof income and to buildcapacityby providingtechnicaltrainingfor biodiversitymonitoring and protectionof conservationareas,toachieve resultsinenhancingsustainablemanagementof
  • 9. Hessenius 9 resourcesandprotectingkeyspeciesandtheirhabitats (WCS2016, ConservationInternational2016, Sam VeasnaCentern.d.). These NGOs and others have made significantprogressincollaborationwiththe governmenttoextendEEinCambodiawithinavarietyof sectors.Inthe formal sector,activities have mainlyfocusedonintegratingEEintoschool and universitycurriculums,includingthe developmentof materialssuchastrainingmanualsandguidesforteachersandstudentclubs,and technical trainingandcapacitybuildingin environmentallysoundpracticesforbothgovernment employeesandcivil society(Smith&Keat2006). However,there isalack of assessmentof the qualityof these trainingsandacritical needtoevaluate the qualityof environmental trainingbeing administeredbymanydifferentproviderstoensure thataccurate informationandbestpracticesare beingtaught(Smith&Keat 2006). In spite of these pushesforEEdevelopmentinthe formal sector,the majorityof EEin Cambodiaoccursin the non-formal sector.Activitiescarriedoutinthe non-formal sectorfall undera verybroad range and include radioandtelevisionbroadcasts,speeches, posters,andspecial events (Smith& Keat2006). Monks have alsoplayedanimportantrole inthe disseminationof EEin Cambodiathroughactivitiessuchasspeechesandcommunity-basedenvironmental learning activitiescarriedoutbypagodas(Smith&Keat 2006). For example,MlupBaitong,supportedbythe WorldBank and Alliance of ReligionsandConservation,developedaprogramthat provided educationandtrainingformonksin14 rural pagodas,whobecame able toprovide educationon Buddhismandthe environmenttotheirlocal communitiesthrougheventsandactivitiessuchas lectures,workshops,radioprogramsandevents onBuddhistholydays,andseedlingordination ceremoniesattree nurseriesthatare now well-establishedatthese pagodas(Awoyemi etal 2012). ABE isanotherorganizationthatworksto strengthenthe capacityof the sangha,the communityof Buddhistmonksandnuns,inCambodiatopromote environmental educationandprotection (JEEF 2007, BerkleyCentern.d.).Examplesof theirmajorprojectscompletedsofarinclude the developmentof a documentaryvideoonmonksandCommunityForestry,and providingtrainingin environmental outreachtomonks anddisseminatingenvironmentaleducationmaterials,suchas audiomaterialsthatare broadcastedat target pagodason Buddhistholydays inBokorNational Park inKampotprovince andKampongLengdistrictin KampongChhnangprovice (JEEF2007). In KampongLeng,ABE has alsoimplementedcommunitylivelihoodprojects,includingimprovinglocal watersupplymanagement; establishingcompostheaps, vegetablegardens, andtree nurseries;and organizingtree plantingevents andtree ordinationceremoniesatpagodas(JEEF2007, Berkley Centern.d.). These initiativesare consistentwiththe globalmovementtobridge religionand conservation,andspecificallyinBuddhistcountriestoutilize Buddhistprinciplesandteachings asa
  • 10. Hessenius 10 base for establishinganenvironmental ethicandmotivatingpeople toprotectthe environment (Awoyemi etal 2012, Chim2012). 1.1.4. Environmental Education in the Tonle Sap Many EE projectswithinCambodiahave focusedspecificallyonthe regionof the Tonle Sap, the great lake inthe centerof Cambodiaandthe largestfreshwaterlake inSoutheastAsia. Some of the NGOs involvedinEE inthe Tonle Sap include Live andLearn EnvironmentalEducation,Mlup Baitong,the UN FAOin SiemReap(whoestablishedthe GECKOcenterforEE ina floatingvillage on the Tonle Sap in1999), Save Cambodia’sWildlife,andOsmose (Smith&Keat2006). EE projects alongthe Tonle Sap have typicallybeenimplementedonasmall scale inlocal communities,witha focuson primaryschool studentsandteachers(Smith&Keat2006). One major accomplishmentwas the collaborative preparationof anEnvironmental EducationTrainingManual thatiscurrentlybeing usedbythe Food& Agriculture Organisation(FAO),MlupBaitong,Save Cambodia’sWildlife & Osmose andto aidin the integrationof EE intothe publicschool curriculum(Smith&Keat2006). Due to the international recognitionof the environmental,social,andcultural significance of the Tonle Sap, there have been internationallyandregionallydrivenEEeffortsinfocusedonthis regionas well.AsaUNESCO Man and Biosphere Reserve,partof UNESCO’smissionistobuild capacityand promote EE in the region(UNESCO 2016). One importantprojectthathas beencarried out isthe Tonle Sap ConservationProject(TSCP).The TSCPwasdevelopedfromthe thirdcomponent of the Tonle SapEnvironmental ManagementProject(TSEMP),the firstmajorprojectof the Asian DevelopmentBank-fundedTonleSap Initiative (AsianDevelopmentBank(ADB) 2010, ADB 2011, Global Environment Facility 2011). The ultimate objectiveof the TSEMP wasto improve “the sustainable managementandconservationof natural resourcesandbiodiversityinthe Tonle Sap Basin”(ADB 2011). To achieve thisgoal,Component3aimedto buildcapacityformanagementand conservationof biodiversity,andspecificallyidentifiesthe promotionof “biodiversityconservation awareness,education,andoutreach”asone of itsstrategiestoachieve thisobjective (ADB2010, ADB 2011). The TSCPwas a separate projecttoimplementComponent3, fundedbythe Global EnvironmentFacility andthe UNEP and implementedbythe CambodiaNational MekongCommittee and the Ministryof Environment,andextendedfrom2004 to 2011 (ADB2011, GEF 2011). The third expectedoutcomeof the TSCPwasto promote awareness,educationand outreachon biodiversityconservationinthe Tonle SapBiosphere Reserve,throughthe development and implementationof anenvironmentalawarenessandoutreachprogramto be deliveredthrough the school systemandenvironmental educational centersinvillagesthroughoutthe Tonle Sap(GEF 2011). Trainingactivityforprovincial governmentstaff engagedinprotectedareasmanagementand biodiversitymonitoringwasanotherimportanttargetof the TSCP(GEF 2011). Projectresults forthe
  • 11. Hessenius 11 environmental awarenessandoutreachprogramincludedthe country’sfirstenvironmental educationcurriculum, developmentof EEteachingmaterials forstudentsfromgrades4-9,training of 255 teachers from65 schoolsaroundthe lake in usingthe environmentalmanual andteaching materials,andthe initiationof eco-clubsinschoolswiththe establishment of nine eco-clubsintarget schools (GEF2011). The environmental manual forteacherscontains14environmental themesand isspecificallyfocusedonthe resourcesof the Tonle Sap,andwasdeveloped inpartnershipbythe MOEYS andthe FAO,MlupBaitong,Save Cambodia’sWildlife,andOsmose,andreviewedin2004 basedon teacherfeedback(GEF2011, Smith& Keat2006). These are significantachievementsof the project,andthe teacher’sguide forEE will have a lastingbenefitinCambodia(GEF2011). However, one limitationof the EEand environmental awarenessandoutreachinitiativesof the TSCPisa lack of sustainability,since the terminal evaluationof the TSCPconcludedthatalthoughindividual teachersexpressedthe commitmenttocontinueduse of the educational materialsandskills acquired,alack of fundingmeantthatsustainmentof the programwas unlikely(GEF2011). A national environmental educationandawarenesscampaignwasalso planned asone of the outputs underComponent1of the TSEMP inorderto strengthennatural resource management coordinationandplanningthroughthe disseminationof informationaboutthe environment (ADB 2010). For thisobjective Live & Learnwas contractedto developand successfullycreatedavarietyof useful educationtoolsincludingflipcharts,facilitationguides,andthe EE trainingmanual for teachers,aswell asa publicationonthe Tonle Sap,EEstatus report,and national mediaincluding theatre andradio (ADB2010, Live & Learn,Smith& Keat2006). However, completionreportsnoted that at the conclusionof the project, the “‘national’educationandawarenesscampaignwasnotin place as envisaged”at the projectoutset(ADB2010 pg. 24, ADB 2011). In the case of the TSCP, a formal monitoringandevaluationwasconductedincompliance withUnitedNationsDevelopmentProgrammeandGEF standards (GEF 2011). However,formanyof the smaller-scaleEEinitiativescurrentlytakingplace onthe Tonle Sap,little ornoformal monitoring and evaluationhasbeenconducted(Smith&Keat2006). Deficientmonitoringandevaluationof EE projects isa seriousproblem,becauseitisimpossibletoassessthe variousstrategiesthathave been employedandshare the knowledge of EEmethodsthatare effective atincreasingfostering environmental awareness,values,andbehaviorchanges withincommunities,aswell astoaddress and improve uponstrategiesthatare not successful inchangingpeople’sattitudesand actions (Smith& Keat2006, Live & Learn2015). WithinPrekToal and AnlongTaor villages,avarietyof differentstakeholdersare involvedinEE,yetfew examinationsorevaluationsof the impactof these initiativeshave beenconducted.Forthisreason,these siteswereselectedasa case studyto gather
  • 12. Hessenius 12 preliminarydataonthe influence thatdifferentstakeholders andEE projects have hadon the local communities. 1.2 Environmental and Social Context of Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages PrekToal isalsoan especiallyimportantsite toexamine the outcomesof EE initiativesinthe local communitiesdue tothe extremeecological importance of the area.PrekToal Core Area isthe largestof three core areasof the Tonle SapBiosphere Reserve,whichwasdesignatedin1997 (UNESCO2007). PrekToal wasselectedasa core area because itcontainssome of the Tonle Sap floodplainsthatremaininthe mostpristine conditionandhasgreatbiodiversityvalue asahabitat for a varietyof globallythreatenedspecies(RamsarSitesInformationService (RSIS) 2015).The site is coveredmostlybyfreshwaterswampforesthabitatthatfloodsannuallywiththe seasonal hydrological regimeof the Tonle Sap(RSIS2015). Nutrient-richsedimenttrappedbythe forests supporthighlyproductive plantandfishhabitats(RSIS2015).Priorto the cancellationof fishinglots in2011, the area was highlyexploitedasthe mostproductive fisheryonthe lake,Battambang FishingLotNo.2 (Osmose 2015). In additiontobeingthe mostproductive fisheryareaonthe Tonle Sap (itself one of the mostproductive freshwaterfisheriesinthe world),PrekToal core areais also the most importantnestingsite onthe Tonle Sap—supporting210 species,including17 that are globallythreatenedorendangered(Tonle SapConservationProject (TSCP) 2007).For its ecological value,PrekToal wasalsodesignatedasa Ramsar Site in2015 (RSIS2015). In additiontosuchhighbiodiversity, KohChiveangcommunealsosupportsfivevillagesand approximately1300 familiesthatlive infloatinghousesorhouseboats(Osmose 2015, TSCP 2007). The residentsof the local communityrepresent diverse ethnicbackgrounds,withamajorityof Khmerpeople andminoritypopulationsof Chinese-Khmer,Vietnamese,andCham(Osmose 2014). The economiesof these villagesare highlydependentuponfishingandassociatedactivities,withthe majorityof fishingdone onasubsistence level(Osmose 2015).The site alsohassignificanteconomic value foritsgreat potential asanecotourismsite,offeringthe abilitytoview ahighconcentrationof large nestingwaterbirdswithineasyaccessof SiemReap(TSCP 2007). For itsbiological,economic, social,andcultural value,PrekToal core area isa site of global significance thatrequiresdiligent protectionof the natural resourcesthatsupportboth humanandnon-humanlife. The recognitionof thisfacthas alreadyspurredmanyEE initiativesdesignedtoraise awarenessof the importance of the PrekToal ecosystemandencourage andbuildthe capacityof the local communitytosustainrich biodiversityof the core area.For example,the NGOOsmose was establishedinPrekToal in1999 withan approachto conservationthatlinkscommunity-based conservation,alternativelivelihoodsupportthroughthe developmentof ecotourism, andEE
  • 13. Hessenius 13 (Osmose 2015). Osmose initiatedtheirEEprogramin 2000 withthe goal of educatingthe childrenof the communitytoequipthemtoconserve the area’snatural resources(UNESCO 2007, Osmose 2015). Osmose purchasedafloatingschool toholdclassesin2001, and has heldbothindoorclasses at theirfloatingcentertoteachchildrenaboutthe Tonle Sapecosystems,aswell asoutdoorclasses, includingfieldtripstothe PrekToal birdsanctuaries,tosee the conceptstaughtin the classroomin real life (UNESCO 2007, Osmose 2015). The EE program is also inthe processof beingintegratedinto the curriculumof the local schoolsinPrekToal (Osmose 2015). An independentevaluationof Osmose’sEEprogram was performedin2007 withpositiveresults(Osmose 2015). However,amore currentevaluationisnecessarytodetermine if the resultsof thisprogramare still successful. WCS alsohas an establishedpresence in the areathroughtheirPrekToal conservation project(WCS2016). Through thisproject,WCShas workedclosely withthe MoEto monitorand protectthe water birdcoloniesandfloodedforestinthe PrekToal Core Areasince 2001 (WCS2016). As a partnerin the TSCP,WCS also contributedtocapacitybuildingforbiodiversitymanagement, throughactions such as training52 rangerswhopatrol the conservationsite (WCS2016). 1.3 Aims and Objectives of Study For the purposesof thisstudy,EE has beendefinedandinvestigatedspecificallyasit pertainstoincreasingawarenessandknowledge of the environment,understandingof its connectionstohumanlivelihoodsandwellbeing,andencouragingactionsthatcontribute to environmental conservationandsustainabilityamonglocal communities.Whilesome stakeholders, such as Osmose,alsoaimtoincorporate EE intotourisminitiatives,tonarrow the scope of this study,the deliveryandreceptionof EEwithinlocal communitieswaschosenasthe central focus. Giventhe fundamental importance of EEin achievingsustainable developmentand environmental conservationgoals,the necessityforevaluationof EE initiativestoimprove their effectiveness,andthe lackof formal evaluation andevenacomprehensive collectionof basic informationaboutthe currentstatusof environmental initiativesinPrekToal andAnlongTaor villages,this studyaimstoaddressthisgapinknowledgebycollectingdatafromstakeholders providingEEand local communitymembersreceivingEEto determine whichstakeholdersare active inEE, whattechniquestheyare utilizingandwhattopicstheyare teaching,andhow these educational initiativesare perceivedbythe local community.Thisinvestigationshouldserve asa startingpointforfuture studiesanddata collectionthatcanallow fora formal monitoringand evaluationprocess.The followingstate the objectivesof thisstudy: 1. Identifystakeholdersinvolvedindevelopmentandimplementationof environmental educationprojectsandinitiativesinPrekToal andAnlongTaor
  • 14. Hessenius 14 2. Determine whatmechanismsandactivitiesdifferentstakeholdersemployintheirEE initiativesandwhatconceptsandtopicstheychoose tocover 3. Examine communityreception of pastandcurrentEE initiativesby exploringenvironmental awarenessandknowledge amongthe local community 4. Analyze andcompare EE initiatives sharedbyrespondents 2. Methods 2.1 Study Period and Location The study wasconductedduringthe periodfromApril 18, 2016 to April 27, 2016 inthe villagesof PrekToal andAnlongTa OinrinKoh Chiveangcommune,EkPhnomdistrict,Battambang province,inCambodia(Figure 1). Figure 1: Map of Prek Toal Core Area, Osmose 2015 2.2 Data Collection Methods To gather the data forthisstudy,semi-structuredinterviews(SSI) were conductedwithkey informantsfromthe variousstakeholdergroupsinvolvedinEEinPrekToal and AnlongTaor.These include rangersemployedbythe MoEwho patrol the Core Area,CommunityFisherycommittee membersinPrekToal and AnlongTaor,and the mey phum (village chief) of PrekToal andAnlong Taor and the mey kum (commune chief) of KohChiveangcommune.Interviewswere conductedwith
  • 15. Hessenius 15 local schoolteachers,bothfromOsmose andthe publicschoolsinPrekToal andAnlongTaor,to acquire informationaboutthe currentEE initiativesforchildreninthese villages.Representatives fromNGOs witha presence inthe area,includingOSMOSE,the WildlifeConservationSociety(WCS), and Live & Learn,were alsointerviewed.Inaddition,interviewswithmonksfromthe local monasteryanda Catholicpriestwhoroutinelyvisitsthe Churchof St.JosephinPrekToal were conductedinorderto ascertainwhetherthese religiousinstitutionsare activelyinvolvedin environmental education.Toinvestigatethe experience of local communitymemberswithEEand levelsof environmentalawarenessinthe community,SSIswerealsoconductedwithlocal communitymembers.Nine interviewswere conductedinPrekToal villageandseveninterviews were conductedinAnlongTaorvillage. Figure2,below,showsthe proportionsof the numberof interviews conductedwithmembersof eachstakeholdergroupoutof the total numberof interviews,andthe full listof interviewsconductedcanbe foundinAppendix1. Figure 2: Pie Chart of Stakeholder Groups Interviewed during Data Collection Period in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor villages in April 2016 Osmose Teachers 5% n=2 MoE Rangers 7% n=3 Catholic Priest 3% n=1 Village-level Official 5% n=2 Monk 3% n=1 Community Members 42% n=17 Community Fishing Committee Members 7% Osmose Representatives 5% n=2 WCS Representative 2% n=1 MoE Official 2% n=1 Commune-level Official 2% n=1 Live & Learn Representative 2% n=1 Public School Teachers 15% n=6 Stakeholder Groups Interviewed Osmose Teachers MoE Rangers Catholic Priest Village-level Official Monk Community Members Community Fishing Committee Members Osmose Representatives WCS Representative MoE Official Commune-level Official Live & Learn Representative Public School Teachers
  • 16. Hessenius 16 The topic guidesforboththe SSIsand focusgroupsuse botha seriesof yes/noquestions followedbyprompts,aswell asopen-endedquestions.The fulltopicguidescanbe found in Appendix 2. 2.3 Data Analysis Tools The software Atlas.TIwasutilizedtomanage,analyze,andpresentthe datagathered. MicrosoftExcel wasalso usedtocreate tablesinorderto presentthe dataresults.The datawas analyzedusinggroundedtheory,todraw insightsandconclusionsbasedonthe interviewdata collectedandcomparative analysisof the variousgroups examined(GlaserandStrauss1967). 2.4 Limitations of Study Due to the limitedtimespentinthe field,yieldingamoderate sample size of interview respondents,itisnotpossibletodrawgeneralizedconclusionsaboutthe full extentof EE initiatives inPrekToal, or theireffectivenessandinfluence onthe community.FurtherresearchinPrekToal,as well asotherlocationsonthe Tonle Sap,is necessarytobe able to conducta monitoringand evaluationanalysisthatwill enable EEproviderstoimprove the effectivenessof theirapproachesto EE. Anotherlimitationof the studyisthatdue to the cross-cultural contextwhichrequireda translator,there isthe inevitable possibilitythatsome questionsoranswerscouldhave been misinterpretedorthatthe nuancesof responsescouldhave beenlost.Itisalsopossiblethat interview respondentscouldhave modifiedtheiranswersinsome casesbasedontheirperceptions of the researchersandan attempttogive answerstheythoughtwere desiredortoprotect their owninnocence. 3. Results 3.1 Osmose Osmose iscurrentlythe mostactive stakeholderinEEin PrekToal and AnlongTaor. Their environmental education(EE) programfocusesonbuildingenvironmentalawarenessamong primaryschool students(Grades1-6) througha combinationof indoorandoutdoorclassroom activities.The Osmose teacherstransportthe studentstothe Osmose floatingclassroom, where EE classesare taught complementarytothe publicschool schedule fourtimesperweek (if the public school classesare inthe morning,the Osmose classeswill be inthe afternoon,andvice versa) (Figure 3).Osmose alsostartedintegratingtheirEEcurriculumintothe local publicschools in2001. Currently,Osmose hirestwostate teachersona part-time basis,whoteachbothat the Osmose platformandthe local publicschools,one teacheratPrekToal and one teacherat KohChiveang
  • 17. Hessenius 17 PublicSchool.The Osmose teachers andpublicschool teachersreportedthatthe Osmose teachers visitthe publicschoolstoteachaboutthe environmenttwo orthree timespermonth. There usedto be three teachershiredbyOsmose,butone teacherisnow resigned,sothere iscurrentlyno Osmose teacheravailabletoteachclassesat the KampongPrahok PublicSchool. Figure 3: Pictures of Exterior and Interior of Osmose Floating Classroom in Prek Toal village, Cambodia, taken April 2016 The outdoorclassroomactivitiesinclude fieldtripstothe PrekToal Core Areato see the waterbirdcolonies,waste collectionatthe school ormonastery,andtripsinthe village toobserve local plantlife andfloatinggardensthatOsmose helped20local familiesbuildin2002. The birdwatchingtripsare a highpriority,because theywanttoencourage the childrentolove andwant to protectthe endangeredbirdsthatare of greatconservationandecotourismvalue.Duringthe dry season,whenthe birdpopulationsare attheirpeak(NovemberthroughMarch),Osmose representativesexplainedthattheybringthe studentsonbirdwatchinguptofourtimespermonth, while Osmose teachersreportedthattheytake studentsonoutdoorfieldtripstwotimespermonth. The birdwatchingexcursionsalsorequirecollaborationbetweenOsmoseandthe Ministry of Environment(MoE),since anMoE ranger alwaysaccompaniesthe teachersandstudentsinorderto guide themtothe Core Areaand provide informationaboutthe birdstothe students.Duringthe wetseason,whenthe birdshave migratedelsewhere,the teacherstake the studentstodothe local outdooractivities.Asaresultof these activitiesandeducationontopicssuchasthe natural environmentof the Tonle Sapandthe importance of conservingthose natural resourcesforthe future,the Osmose teachers have notedchangesinbehavior,includingdisposal of waste inbins rather thanthe lake and ceasingtohunt forbird eggs.Osmose isalsohopeful thatthe childrenwill continue tolove andvalue the environmentinthe future andreflectthisthroughtheirbehaviorsby protectingnatural resourcesandusingthemsustainably. The EE program complementsthe othermaincomponentsof Osmose’sapproachto environmental conservationandcommunitylivelihoodimprovement,whichare ecotourismand
  • 18. Hessenius 18 local development.AnOsmose representative notedthat“all the componentsare linked,whichhas beenone of theirsuccesses,”anddescribedhow environmental awarenessandprotectionof natural resourcesare necessarytosupportand sustainthe ecotourismcomponent,whichalsohelpsto provide alternative incometolocal families,incentivizingconservationbehaviors. 3.2 PublicSchool The publicschool teachersalsoprovide the studentsinPrekToal andAnlongTaorwithEE as part of the state curriculum.Theyteachaboutenvironmentaltopicsasoftenastheyare scheduled to inthe curriculumandmaterialsfromthe Ministryof Education,Youth,andSport (MOEYS),which one teacherreportedisaboutonce a month.Some of the mostcommon environmental topics coveredbythe publicschool teachersinclude the natural environmentanditscomponents,suchas the water,the animals,andespeciallythe floodedforestsandmangroves.The teachersemphasize the importance of the forestsforprovidinglivelihoodbenefits now andin the future,including supportingbiodiversityandbreedingfish,providingwoodtouse forfuel,protectionfromstorms, and regulationof the weather.Multiple teachersalsoreportedthattheyhave discussedthe threat of climate change,whichthe studentsunderstandbecause theyexperience the temperature getting hotterand hotter,andhowclimate change can damage the forestsand the interrelated environment. One challenge identifiedbysome of the local publicschool teachersinterviewedisthatitis difficulttoimprove students’habitsandbehaviorsbecause theyare more likelytofollowthe model setby theirparentsandfamiliesthanbytheirteachers.Forexample,theytrytoteachthe students not to throwtheirrubbishinthe waterand notto drinkthe lake water,but forstudents’whose familiesdonotknownotto throwtheirrubbishthe wateror whocannot affordtobuy cleanwater and do notknowto boil it,itis difficulttomake suchbehaviorchanges,thoughthe teachersdotry to tell the studentstopassthese messagesontotheirparents.Similarly,thoughillegal fishinggearis not a maincomponentof the curriculum, the teachersoftentalktotheirstudentsaboutwhich fishingactivitiesandgearsare allowedandwhichare notallowed. However,theyexplainedthat such educationwill notoverride the poorerfamilies’needstoperformillegal fishingactionsinorder to feedtheirfamilies. One publicschool teachersaid,“Itisreallyhardforthe kidshere.Normally theylistentotheirfamily,andthe life theylive dependsonfish.If theydon’tdoillegalactivity,then theycan’t feedtheirfamily.”Whenaskedaboutwhetherthe studentshave changedtheirbehaviors as a resultof learningaboutthe environment,the same teacherresponded,“Youcan hardlyblame the kids;it dependsontheirfamilycondition.It’snotlike theydon’tknow andunderstand.They knowand understand,butif theydon’tdoit,thentheycan’t feedtheirfamily.Forexample,some of the kidscut downthe mangrovesforfirewood.Theyknow thatit’swrongbutit istheirlivelihood.”
  • 19. Hessenius 19 Whensuch resource collectionpracticesare partof the livelihoodof child’sfamily,the childrenwill continue suchbehaviorsdespite the factthattheyare aware that suchactions are illegal orwrong. Despite thischallenge,teachershave reported some successesinalteringstudents’behaviors, includingdisposingof rubbishinbins atthe school rather thanin the water. 3.3 Ministry of Environment The MoE doesnot currentlyhave anEE programfor the adultsin the local community.Inthe past theyhave hadan EE program foradults,buthave discontinuedthisprogramdue tolackof time. Ratherthan educate the whole community,they onlyeducate theirrangers.There are currently30- 40 rangersemployedbythe MoE, includingbothvolunteerandfull-timerangers.The rangers receive trainingincollectingdatatomonitorthe biodiversityandpatrollingthe Core Area;theyare instructed bya teacherwhocomes from the MoE Ministry Office inPhnomPenhatleastonce a year.The MoE also encouragesthe rangerstocare aboutprotectingthe environmentand encouragingfellowcommunitymemberstoprotectthe environmentaswell,includingencouraging community memberscaughtdoingminorillegal actions,suchasfishinginthe Core Area,tochange theirbehaviorsandhelptake care of the environment.The rangersplayanimportantrole inEE as disseminatorsof information.Theirmessagestendtofocusonclearprohibitionsof actions,suchas tellingpeople nottoenterthe Core Area,notto cut downtreesinthe forest,andnotto use the illegal fishinggears,andexplainingthatthese behaviorsare importantbecause protectingthe forests,whichare where the fish breed,andleavingbehindthe small fishtoletthemgrow,are necessarytomaintainthe fishstocksforthe future. One challenge identifiedbysome of the MoE rangersinterviewedisthatthe MoE usedto have rangerswhowere more active inEE inthe community,butthose rangershave now all retired, and the newlyhiredrangersare toobusywithpatrollingtovisitthe communitymemberstoeducate themaboutthe environment.One MoErangerinterviewedreportedthattheyhave requestedto continue doingEElike the retiredrangersusedtodo,but that theyhave notreceivedfeedbackor approval yetfromMoE seniorstaff. Anotherwaythe MoE disseminatesinformationaboutthe environmentisthroughmeetings. Theytypicallyholdmeetingstwotothree times ayear,especiallywhenanMoEofficial fromthe MoE Ministry Office in PhnomPenhcomestovisitthe MoECore AreaManagementStationat Prek Toal.In these official meetings,theyoftenutilize posterandslideshow presentationsanddiscuss topicssuch as howto protectthe mangrove forestsandthe waterbird colonies.Normal attendance at these meetingsisbetween40and 50 people.Official authoritiesandpublicfigures,suchasthe mey kum andmey phums,are usuallyinvitedtoattend.AnMoE official reportedthattheydonot
  • 20. Hessenius 20 announce these meetingstothe general communitybecause theydonothave the available space to accommodate sucha large numberof people,sotheirstrategyistoinvite the people whoare heads of the communityandentrustthemwithdisseminatingthe informationtothe restof the population. The communitymembersare aware thatthe MoE holdsthese meetings;however, they reportedthatthey neverreceive invitationstothe meetingsorinformationaboutwhentheywillbe held.Theyperceivethatonlycertainpeople are selectedtoattend. Forexample,when askedif there are meetingsaboutthe environmentinthe community,avillage level official reportedthat “normallywhentheysetupthe meetings,theydon’thave ageneral announcement,theyinvite selecthouses,the oneswiththe goodlivingconditions.The poorpeople don’tgetinvited,”anda communitymemberthatthey “know theyhave meetings,buttheydon’tinvite the poorpeople.” Thisperceptionisone cause of frustrationbetweenthe MoEand the community.There were a varietyof reasonscitedforthe poor relationshipbetweenthe MoEand the community.Some communitymemberswhowere interviewedexpressedsignificantresentmentandsuspicionof the MoE. There is a strong perceptionamongsome membersof the communitythatthe MoE iscorrupt because theytake fishandotherresourcesoutof the protectedareathat theypreventthe communityfromentering.Itwasalsoreportedthatwhenthe MoE catches people fordoingillegal actions,theyonlymake thempaya fee and collectthatmoneyandletthe offendergo,sonothing changesthe problemof decreasingresources: Since the MoE tookoverthe protectedarea,there wasnothingleft,because the rangers take the birdseggs to feedtheirfamilies.Whentheycatchpeople,theymake thempaythe fine,andpeople don’thave thatmoneysotheydon’tdothe illegal action. Otherstakeholdersreportedthatcollaboratingwiththe MoEis difficult.Forexample, one of the Osmose teacherssaidthatsometimestheyhave plannedtohave anMoE rangertake their groupof studentstosee the Core Area,but on the day theirtripwasplannedtheywere toldthatall the MoE rangerswere busyso none couldaccompanythem, sotheyhad to change theirplansto a local outdooractivity. 3.4 Community Fishery Committees Like the MoE rangers,membersof the CommunityFishery(CFi) Committees of PrekToal and AnlongTaor oftenteachpeople aboutthe environment,eitherwhentheyare onpatrol inthe CFi or whentheyholdmeetingsforthe community.Meetingsheldbythe CFi Committee typicallyhappen at leastonce a year.The CFi usesa poster andteachesaboutthe fishinglawsandregulations.For example,theytell the communityaboutthe typesof fishinggearsthatare legal andillegal (including
  • 21. Hessenius 21 electroshockandgill netsof asmall netsize). Theyalsoinformthe communityaboutwherethey are allowedtofish,andespeciallytrytodeterthe communityfromfishinginthe Fish ConservationArea (FCA),orformerFishingLot#2. There isalsoa protectedareawithinthe CFi (formerFishingLot#3) where people are notallowedtofish.Theyexplaintothe communitythatpeople are notallowedto fishinthe protectedareasor use the illegal gearsinorderto protectthe spawningfishtohave resourcesforthe future.Anothermainfocusbesidesexplainingthe fisherylawsisteachingpeople aboutthe connectionbetweenprotectingthe environmentandimprovingtheirlivingconditions, since all relyonthe natural resourcesandhealthyenvironmentfortheirlivelihoods.The CFi Committee alsorequeststhatcommunitymembershelptoprotectthe environment,especiallythe forestthatsupportsthe breedingfish, bynotcuttingdowntreesandnot huntingthe wildlife. The CFi Committee membersreportedthattheyoftencollaborate withotherNGOsfortheir EE, such as the UnitedStatesAgencyforInternational Development(USAID) CambodiaHARVEST program workedwiththe CFi Committeesandhelpedorganize andruntheirmeetingswith communityuntil theirprojectconcluded thisyear.CFi committee membersdescribedhow HARVEST helpedtraintheminmanagingthe CFi andtaught the communityaboutprotectingthe environment, conservingnatural resources,andthe threatof climate change atthe meetings.Theyalsohelped fundprojectstoimprove livelihoodsinthe community,includinga providingfishpondstoCFi committee membersandtraininginaquaculture. A CFi Committee memberinterviewedalsodiscussedhisownactivitiestoengage hislocal communityinenvironmentaleducationandprotection.He reportedthatevenwhenfundsfrom HARVESTran out for the communitymeetings,he continued toorganize meetingsforthe communityonhisownabout three timesayear,usinghisownfundsto purchase snacksfor the people whoattend. Three maingoals citedfordiscussioninthese meetingswere talkingaboutthe environment,askingpeopletoprotectthe FCA and itsfishand birdpopulations,andrequestingthat the whole communityunitesandworkstogethertoprotectthe environment.He discussedwaysin whichhe is able tohelpthe communityunderstandtheseconceptseventhoughare nothighly educated.Forexample,he avoidsusingtechnical language like the termecology,andinstead explainshoweverythinginthe environmentisrelatedtoeachotherbyexplainingitasa “food system.”Anotherwayhe helpsthe communityunderstandthe importance of the environmentisby connectingthe environmenttothe economy,theirlivelihoods,andtheirdailyreality.He described howhe explainsthateffectsof climate change,suchasincreasingtemperature,lowerwaterlevels on the lake,andthe increasingincidencesof forestfireswillhave negative consequencesby decreasingthe amountsof fishandtherefore the amountof foodforpeople toeat.The followingis
  • 22. Hessenius 22 the reasoningreportedtoexplainthe conceptof conservingnatural resourcesandhow goodliving conditionsare dependentonahealthyenvironment: He usesthe realityof everyday,like the ecosystemandclimate changing,the temperature, the lake dryingup,and the firesinthe forest—all of these problemsstarttomake you feel worriedandmake yousick.Everyone startsto thinkthat if there isno waterthenthere will be lessfishandthenthere will be nothingtoeatand thenpeople will getsick.Everytime he has a meetingwiththe communityhe addsitwiththe economicsystemandhow itgoes togetherwiththe environment.If youdestroythe environment,thenthere isnoflow of the economy. In additiontoholdingmeetingsinthe communityforadults,thisCFi Committee memberalsotalks to studentsinthe publicschool forone houreach month. Accordingto a CFi Committee member,the local communityisverywillingtoattend communitymeetings,andtojointogetherincommunityactiontohelpprotectthe environment.As an example,he reportedthathe organizedagroupof local communitymemberstoputouta fire neartheirhouses.He alsoreportedbehaviorchangesamongthe majorityof the community members,includingceasingtouse the electroshockgearforfishingandstoppingthe collectionof birdeggsand nests.Despite these successes,he reportedfacingsignificantchallengesfrom authorities,whodonotsupporthisprojects. A Committee memberexpressedthe belief that the authorities,suchasthe MoE, shouldimprove theircollaborationwiththe local communityinorder to be successful inconservingthe natural resourcesof the area,because if the communityisangry withthe MoE, theywill notfollowthe rulesanditwill be impossible forthe MoE to enforce them: Whateverproject,if youdon’thave helpfromthe communitythenitwon’thappen.You needtokeepthe communityhappytocollaborate.If youmake the communityangryor hate you,thenit iseasyfor themto destroythe environment.There are manymore of themthan the 30-40 MoE rangers,sothere will be nowayto stop them. 3.5 Other stakeholders While the mey phums of PrekToal and AnlongTaor andthe mey kumof KohChiveangare involvedinthe meetingsheldbythe MoE on the environmentandingeneral meetingsforthe commune heldbythe mey kumthat may coverenvironmental topics,theyare notextensivelyactive inEE for the community.Theydotell communitymembersnottocut treesandonlyto take dead woodfromthe forestforfuelwood,toobeythe fishinglawsbynotfishinginthe protectedareasor
  • 23. Hessenius 23 usingthe illegal gearsinordertoprotectthe breedingfish,andtokeepthe environmentcleanand collectingtheirrubbish. The Wildlife ConservationSociety(WCS) isnotactivelyengagedinanyEE projectsforthe local community,thoughtheycontinue tosupportthe MoE byprovidingannual technical trainingin patrollingandwaterbirdmonitoringforthe MoE rangers.Thisis consistentwiththeircentral focus on achievingconservationresultsforthe waterbirdcoloniesandtheirhabitatsinthe PrekToal Core Area.WCS has collaboratedwithOsmoseinthe pastbyprovidingfundingfortheirEEprojects,and there are opportunitiesforWCStoplaya more active role inEE inPrekToal inthe future.A WCS representative mentionedsomeof these opportunities,includingcontinuingtheirpartnershipwith Osmose orstandardizingeducationandawareness-raisingforadultsasa componentof their conservationprograms.They stated“theywantthere tobe a dedicatedunitwithinWCSthat suppliestrainingatall theirsites”andthat they“wantto raise awarenessamongadults.” Currently,the monasteryatAnlongTaorisnot activelyinvolvedinanyenvironmental education.Althoughthe space atthe monasteryisusedforactivitiessuchaswaste collectionevents for schoolchildrenandcommunitymembers,the monksare nottypicallyconsultedorinvitedto collaborate inthese events,andtheymayor maynot participate inthem.Accordingtothe monk withthe mostauthorityat the monastery,thoughhe hastriedto engage the communityandasked themto helpcollectrubbisharoundthe wat,the communitymembersare notinterestedandrefuse to participate.Whenaskedif he everincorporatesteachingaboutthe environmentorBuddhist storiesrelatedtothe environmentintoceremonies,he reportedthathe doesnot,because Osmose and the MoE bothfill the role of teachingpeople inthe communityaboutthe environment. The CatholicChurch inPrekToal (Churchof St. Joseph’s,asatellite churchof St.John’s Church inSiemReap) isanotherreligiousinstitutionthatisnotcurrentlyengagedinEE,thoughthere isthe possibilitythatEEbecomesa componentof the Church’ssocial outreachprogramsinthe future.Atthe moment,the Churchis involvedinprogramsaimedatreducingpoverty,including offeringfree Englishclassesforthe community.Whiletheyare notactivelyinvolvedEE,a representative of St.John’sChurchwhoroutinelyvisitsthe churchinPrekToal reportedthathe believesthere isthe potential forincorporatingEEintotheiractivitiesinthe future,andthatit shouldbe a prioritygiventhe importance of the conservationareainPrekToal.Also,environmental protectionhasbeenidentifiedasamainobjective of the CatholicDiocese inBattambang,based uponthe understandingthatprotectingthe environmentisstrongly alignedwithCatholicvaluesto respectandcare for Creation.Atthe moment,theydoencourage the childrennottothrow rubbish inthe water,andbelieve the childrenare graduallychangingtheirbehaviors.
  • 24. Hessenius 24 3.6 Community Environmental Awareness and Perceptions Membersof the communityreportedavarietyof levelsof environmentalawareness, behaviorspracticed,andreasonsforprotectingthe environment.One conceptthatisstrongly understoodbythe communityisthe connectionbetweenthe forestsand the fish.Almostall communitymembersknowandunderstandthatthe forestsare importanthabitatsforthe fishto breed,soprotectingthe floodedforestsisof great importance tosustainingthe fishpopulations. Thislinkshowsthatthe communityunderstandsthatthe elementsof the environment—the forests, the water,and the wildlife—are all relatedtoeachother. Manycommunitymembersmade remarks similartoa communitymemberwhostated,“If youprotectthe forest,itmeansyouprotectthe fish too. When the fishbreedtheyneedthe forests.” Some of the mostcommonlyreportedreasonsforprotectingthe environmentincludefor supportingtheirfamilyandtheirlivelihoods,protectingnatural resourcesforthemselvesinthe future andfor theirchildrenfuture generationstobe able toknow the environmentaswell ashave the resourcestheyneedtosurvive.Anothercommonmotivationfortakingcare of the environment isfor the healthandhygiene of themselvesandtheirfamilies,andthisisa majorreasonmany communitymembersreportedtryingtokeepthe environmentaroundtheirhouse andthe lake cleanby notthrowingtheirrubbishintothe waterandpracticingpropersanitationandnotdrinking waterfrom the lake.Unfortunately,intervieweesalso notedthatmanypeople inthe communitystill throwrubbishinthe waterand use the pollutedlakewaterfordrinking,washing,andbathing,which has negative consequencesforpeople’shealth. However, frequentreporting of these motivationsto protectthe environmentshows thatthe majorityof peopleunderstandthe connectionbetween takingcare of the environmentandsupportingtheirownlivelihoodsandwellbeingforthemselves, theirfamilies,andfuture generations. In addition,almostall the communitymembersinterviewedindicatedthattheywouldbe interestedinlearningmore aboutthe environment(seeFigure 4).However,manynotedthatwhile theywouldbe interested,theydonothave the opportunitytoparticipate EE,eitherbecause there are no groupsprovidinganyEE inthe community,thattheyare notinvitedtoparticipate,suchasin the meetingsheldbythe MoE,or because theydonot have time because theyare busyfishingto feedthemselvesandtheirfamilies.There isalsoadiscrepancyin the perceptionof the community’s knowledge aboutandinterestinlearningaboutthe environment, whichisillustratedinFigure4, showingthatcommunitymembersself-reporthigherlevelsandknowledgeandinterestthan stakeholdersperceive the communitytohave.
  • 25. Hessenius 25 Figure 4: Responses from Communityand Other Stakeholder Groups (including MoE Rangers, Osmose Teachers, Public School Teachers, CommunityFisheryCommittee Members, and Public Officials) on Level of Knowledge and Interest in Learning about the Environment among Local CommunityMembers in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages, Cambodia, in 2016. Otherperceptionsreportedbythe communityinclude the threatof decreasingresources, such as the forests, water,andwildlifesuchasbirdsand fish. One communitymemberstatedthe followingcomparingthe amountof natural resourceshe perceivedtobe availabletothe community nowcomparedto the past: There wasso much wildlife thenandlesspeople.Now there are more people, more hunting, and lesswildlife,andthe environmentisgettingdirtiereveryday.Fornatural resources,the wildlife andbirdsare lessandless.Forfishing,sometimesthereisnotenoughtofeedhis family. One majorcause people commonly attributedtothisdecrease innatural resourcesisthe extremely hot anddry weather,whichhascausedthe lake levelstobe abnormallylow andalsocausedforest firesthatthe communityisdeeplyconcernedabout,since theyrecognize thatthe forestsare crucial for the environmentandsustainingfishpopulations: “If theyprotectthe forest,thentheyprotect the fishand the animalsandthe birds.But withthe fire,theyare notsure if theywill still be there.” Increasingpressure onresourcesformpopulation growthandlackof watercausedby damsin other countrieswere lesscommonlycitedasreasonsforthe decrease inresources.Some community membersstatedthattheydonot knowwhythe natural resourcesare decreasing,theyonlyhave
  • 26. Hessenius 26 noticedthatthere are lessfish,birds,andotherresourcesthanthere were inthe past.Multiple communitymembersexpressedthe opinionthatasprotectionandstrict enforcementof regulations inconservationareashasincreased,the amountof natural resourcesinthese areashave paradoxicallydecreased.Relatedtothisperceptionisthe belief thatauthoritiesexcluding communitymembersfromconservationareas,suchasthe MoE, are extractingresourcesfromthese areas whichtheyare supposedtoprotect.Because of these observedtrendsindecreasing resources,manycommunitymembersare facingdifficultiesnow andare veryworriedaboutthe availabilityof resourcesandtheirabilitytofeedtheirfamiliesandsurviveinthe future. It was alsoreportedoftenthat althoughmostpeople inthe communityare aware of the importance of the environmentandwhatthe lawsand regulationsare,manypeoplestillbreakthose laws,andthe mainreasonpeople breakthe rulesisbecause of povertyandneed.Because people in the communityare dependentonfishingfortheirlivelihoods,people are oftenforcedtodoillegal activityinorderto have enoughfoodtofeedtheirfamilies.AsaCFi memberremarked, “if people don’tdo the illegal action,whatcantheydoto eat? The people here livebyfish.”Cuttingwoodto use as firewoodwasalsocommonlycitedasanillegal actionmanyfamiliesmustdoto attainthis resource thattheyneedbecause theyare poorand cannot affordtobuy it.Because thisyearhas beenexceptionallydry,officialsnotedthatthere hasbeenanincrease inillegal activitiesandpeople enteringthe Core Areabecause there isincreasedpressure onresourcessomore peopleare strugglingtofeedtheirfamilies,pushingthemtobreakthe lawsmore oftenthaninpreviousyears. 4. Discussion Interviewsconductedwith abroadrange of stakeholdergroupsinPrek Toal and AnlongTaor villages(seeAppendix 1),servedtoinformasnapshotof the currentstate of environmental education(EE) inPrekToal andAnlongTaor. Basedonthisexamination,itwasfoundthatEE has had substantial positive impactsinthe community,yetalsofacessignificantchallengesandiscurrently limitedbyanumberfactors(see Table 1). The explorationof these challengesisessentialtobe able to reframe such obstaclesasopportunities,because once theyare recognized,suchimpediments can be transformedinto targetsforimprovementtoEE inthe community. Positive results and sources of opportunity Major obstacles or limitations Many children in the community have received EE, which can empower the next generation with the capabilities and inspiration to be proper stewards of nature in the future There is currently a gap in EE for adultcommunity members
  • 27. Hessenius 27 Community-based education and action can be supported with positiveconsequences in community engagement in sustainablemanagement of natural resources There are challenges with access to education and a lack of dissemination of information aboutpositive results of conservation initiatives Success has been shown in integrated approaches to EE that link education with economic development There is a tendency for stakeholders to choose not to take ownership and responsibility for EE sincethey are aware of other stakeholders already practicingEE Illegal actions regardingresourceextraction and unsustainablebehaviors continuefrompeople in the community. Major causeof this challengeis thatpeople are restricted in their behavior choices by the realities of their daily lives,includingpoverty,need for resources to feed their families and supporttheir livelihoods,and lack of infrastructureand alternativelivelihood options. Table 1: List of Opportunities and Challenges Identified for EE Stakeholders in Prek Toal and Anlong Taor Villages, Cambodia, 2016 4.1 Access to Education and Dissemination of Conservation Results Information Despite the factthat conservationinitiativeshave demonstratedsignificantresultsinthe protectionof biodiversityinPrekToal,local communitymembersare generallyunaware of these successes,andmanyhave indicatedthatthey have anantagonisticrelationshipwithauthorities engagedinprotectionof these conservationareas. There issubstantial datademonstratingthat conservationeffortsbythe Ministryof Environment(MoE) andWildlife ConservationSociety(WCS) have beeneffective,especiallyinpreservingthe endangeredbirdspeciesinthe PrekToal Core Area (WCS2016, Sun & Mahood 2015). Both MoE and WCS representatives reportedduringthisstudy that birdpopulationsinthe Core Areahave increaseddirectlyasaresultof theirpatrolling,which has significantlyreducedillegalactivity,suchas collectionof eggs,althoughtheyalsoacknowledged that thisyearis an exceptiontothese trendsdue tothe abnormallydryweatherandlow waterlevel on the lake,increasingpressure onresourcesanddrivingmore communitymemberstoillegalenter the Core Areaforfishing.WCSalsopridesthemselvesontheirconservation strategy,whichinvolves hiringformerpoacherstobe rangers that protectand monitorthe birds(WCS2016). This approach has proventobe effective,since the nestandpopulation countsforbirdspeciesrecordedbythe rangers(includingthe globallyendangeredGreaterAdjutantStork,globallyvulnerable Lesser AdjutantStork,globallynearthreatenedPaintedStork,AsianOpenbill,globallynearthreatened Spot-billedPelican,andgloballynearthreatenedOriental Darter) show anoverall increasesince WCS startedtheirconservationinitiativesinthe early2000s (WCS 2016, Sun& Mahood 2015). However, itappearsthatthe communitydoesnot know thisinformation.Infact,their perceptionisthe exactopposite:thatresourcesare severelyandrapidlydeclining.Inorderto addressthisdisconnectbetweenstakeholdersinvolvedinbiodiversityconservationandthe
  • 28. Hessenius 28 community,organizationssuchasWCS and the MoE shouldmake ita prioritytodisseminate informationaboutthe successfulresultsof conservationinitiativestothe local community.If the communitydoesnotsee anyresultsof conservationefforts,theyare likelytohave more negative attitudestowardsmeasuresthatplace restrictionsandlimitationsontheirabilitytouse natural resourcesfortheirlivelihoods.However,if the communityismade aware of the benefitsof such conservationinitiativesforthe environmentandthemselves,theywillbe more likelytocooperate, followthe regulations,andchange theiractionsthatcontribute towardshabitatdegradation. Case studiesconductedinMarine ProtectedAreas (MPAs) inthe Philippinessupportthispotential informationdisseminationtoleadto improvedattitudestowardsconservation initiatives (Knight, Allegretti,&Vaske 2015). Knight,Allegretti,&Vaske’s(2015) findingsshowedthatfisherswho receiveddirectgovernment-citizencommunication,environmental education,andoutreachabout protectedareagovernance policies were more likelytosupportMPAsandtheirpoliciesandperceive theirMPAsas benefittingtheirlivelihoods. Anotherchallenge withaccessto educationisthe perceptionconveyedbystudy respondents thatthe general communityisnotinvitedtothe meetingsorganizedbythe MoE. In addition tocontributingtoa perceived poorrelationship betweenthe MoEand the community,this practice limitsaccesstoeducationforgeneral communitymembers,sinceonlypeople occupying official andpublicpositionsare consistentlyinvited,whichespeciallytendsto excludepoorer communitymembers. Suchlimitationsof accesstoeducationandinformationabout the environmentare problematicbecause theyare contraryto the humanrightsof accessto education and informationthatare widelyrecognizedandupheldbythe internationalcommunity, including Article 26 of the Universal Declarationof HumanRights,whichguaranteesthe righttoeducation, and Principle 10of the Rio Declarationfromthe UN Conference onEnvironmentandDevelopment in1992, whichcodifiesthe rightthat“eachindividual shall have appropriateaccesstoinformation concerningthe environmentthatisheldbypublicauthorities”(OHCHR1948, UNEP 1992b). The rightsof accessto information,participationindecision-making,andaccesstojustice in environmental mattersare widelyrecognizedasbeingone of the three essential dimensionsof the nexusbetweenhumanrightsandthe environmentandcritical forgoodenvironmental governance (UNEP-OHCHR2009, UNEP 2003, UNEP 2004). Although MoE officialsexpressedthe expectation that the people selectedtoattendthe meetingswill passalongthe information,thisisnothappening, whichiscreatinga gap in knowledgeandfeelingof exclusioninthe community. A more directand egalitarianapproachtoEE couldbe pursuedbyincreasingaccesstomeetingsinwhicheducation and informationaboutthe environmentisdisseminated,whichwouldbetterfulfillthe rightsof communitymembersof accesstoeducationandinformation.Evenif itisnotfeasibletoinvite all
  • 29. Hessenius 29 communitymembers toasingle meeting,the MoEcould have more frequentmeetingsandrotate the houseswhoare invited,orreinstate the practice of having MoE rangersvisitpeople’shousesto provide educationaboutthe environment. 4.2 Focus on Education for Children and Gap in Adult EE Because Osmose isthe mostactive stakeholderinEE inPrekToal andAnlongTaor, andtheir EE focusesmainlyonchildren,the resultisthatthere iscurrentlyagap inEE for adults.While increasingenvironmental awarenessamongchildrenisvital anditisgoodto encourage the students to care aboutthe environmentandformgoodhabitstohelpprotectit,the limitation isthatittakes a longtime to see resultsfromeducationforchildren.Multiple representativesfromOsmose reportedthateducationforadultswouldbe more directthaneducationforchildren.The EE programsfor childrenare veryimportantforlongterm conservation,because the childrenwill be the usersof the natural resourcesinthe future andneedto know how to be able to do so sustainably.However,currently,the adultsinthe communityare the usersof natural resources,and theyare the oneswho are reportedly committingillegal actions.Inordertohave a directimpacton the current situationandreduce illegal activity,itisnecessarytofocusonachievingresultsby providingEEand facilitatingbehaviorchangesamongadults. The educationof adultshasbeen recognizedasa priorityforthe future directionsof EE and necessaryformeetingglobal goals towardsenvironmental sustainabilityandeducationforsustainabledevelopment,especiallygiven the urgencyof the planet’senvironmental crisisandthe needtochange humanbehaviornow, rather thanfocussolelyoneducationthroughschoolingforchildrenandwaitfortoday’syoung people totake action(UNESCOInstitute forLifelongLearning2010, Monroe 2007). Otherstudies have alsosuggestedthatEE can enhance itseffectivenessbyfocusingoninstigatingactions, behaviors,andchoicesthatsupportsustainability,andthatthese aimstowardbehaviorchange and decision-makingare mostappropriate intargetingadults(Monroe 2007). Anotherconsiderationisthata challenge tothe educationinitiativesforchildrenisthatthey oftentendtostill followtheirparents’andfamilies’habitsratherthanadoptthe behaviorchanges encouragedbytheirteachersatOsmose or the publicschool.Therefore,teachingthe adultsinthe communityaboutthe environmentandactionstheycantake to helpprotectthe environmentcould alsobe importantinreinforcingandstrengtheningthe EEaimedtowardschildren.Althoughone hope of educatingthe children isthattheywill passalongthe messagestotheirparentsand educationforthe childrencanhave a positive impactbythe childrensharingtheirknowledgeand learnedbehaviorswiththeirfamilies,thisisalot to expectfromthe children.While itmay still be helpful toencourage studentstoshare whattheylearnwiththeirparentsandfamilies,adultsinthe communityshouldalsoreceive EEdirectly,sothattheycan model betterhabitsandbehaviorsfor
  • 30. Hessenius 30 the children,ratherthanonlythe childrenbeingexpectedtoserve asexamplesforthe restof the community. 4.3 Deferment of Responsibility to Other Stakeholders Multiple stakeholdersreportedthatone of the reasonstheydo notinitiate andconduct more EE isbecause theyknowthatotherstakeholders,principallyOsmose, are alreadyengagedand active inEE. The monkinterviewedatthe monasteryreportedthathe doesnotincorporate Buddhist storiesorlessonsaboutthe environmentintohisteachingsorceremoniesbecause the community alreadyhas Osmose andthe MoE to teach themaboutthe environment.However,he also expressedthe opinionthatthe MoE is notactive in EE, so itis currentlyonlyOsmose thatisactive in EE, and theymainlyfocusoneducationforchildren.Eventhoughthe monkrecognizedthatthere is a gap in educationforadultsinthe community,he believeditwasthe MoE’sresponsibilitytodo more EE and encourage peopleinthe communitytoknow andcare aboutthe environment.Other NGOs,such as WCS and Live & LearnCambodia, alsoreportedthattheyhave notfocusedonEE in PrekToal because Osmose alreadyhasanestablishedpresenceandfocusonEE inthe community (WCSinsteadfocusesontrainingMoE rangersto buildcapacityforconservationof Core Areaandits waterbird colonies,andLive &Learn CambodiafocusestheirEEinitiativesinotherlocationsinthe Tonle Sapregion). Thisphenomenoninwhichstakeholdersperceive the responsibilityforEE as the responsibilityof someoneelseisproblematicbecauseitpreventsthe benefitsthatcouldpotentially come from multiplestakeholdersengaginginEEfrom varioussectorsinsociety.Forexample,were boththe MoE and the monasteryto playa more active role inEE, the amountof people inthe communitywithaccesstoEE couldincrease,since some communitymembersnotreachedbyone stakeholdergroupcouldbe reachedbyanother.If communitymembersreceive EEfrommultiple stakeholders,thiscouldalsohave importantbenefits.People couldgainamore comprehensive understandingbylearningdifferentinformationindifferentcontexts.Continuityof EEisalso extremelyimportanttoreinforcethe conceptspeople have learned,because otherwise peoplewill mostlikelyforget,asmultiple communitymembersreportedthattheyhadbeentaughtaboutthe environmentinthe pastbut nowdidnot rememberclearlywhattheyhadlearned. Ratherthan perceivingengaginginEEas unnecessaryorrepetitiveif otherstakeholdersare alreadyinvolvedin EE, stakeholdersshouldbe made of aware of the benefits of suchconsistentandcontinuedlearning and encouragedtotake responsibilityforEEas part of theirownactivities. Anotherreasonthistransferof responsibilityforEEisproblematicisbecause eventhough Osmose hasbeenactive andsuccessful inEE,theyare still limitedintheircapacitytoreachthe
  • 31. Hessenius 31 entire community.BecauseOsmose focusesonEEfor children,if theyare the sole providerof EE in the community,thenthatcreatesa gap ineducationforadults inthe community.Inaddition, Osmose islimitedinthe extentof theirEEprogram basedonthe amountof fundingtheyhave from theirdonorsand revenue fromtheirecotourismprogram.Thislackof fundingwascitedasthe main reasonOsmose nolongerhas an EE program foradults,whichtheydidwhentheyhadmore funding sevenoreightyearsago. Theyalsono longerhave enoughfundingtoprovide the childrenwho come to school at Osmose withsnacks(whichcanlimitthe abilityof studentstocome toschool because if the boatarrivesand theyhave noteatenbreakfast,theycannotcome to school because theywouldhave togo the whole morningwithoutfood)orto take the studentsonas manyfield tripsas theyusedto whenthe EE program firststarted.One of the main challengesreportedfrom Osmose representativesistheirdependence onsmall,timedgrants,andthe fact that theydonot have any expertsingrantproposal writing,sotheyhave beenunsuccessful inacquiringlargergrants to expandtheirprojects. Limitedfinances isacommonchallenge,bothforgovernment departments and NGOs, for sustainingEEprogramsin Cambodiaandmanydevelopingcountries(Khieu2002, Smith& Keat2006, ADB 2011). 4.4 Potential Benefits of Bottom-Up and Community-Based EE While NGOand governmentstakeholdersare mostcommonlyperceivedasthe major providers of EE inthe community, there alsoexiststhe basisandpotential foraburgeoning movementof community-basedEEandconservationaction.Forexample,the independently organizedactivitiesof aCFi Committee memberdemonstrate how passionate individualsinthe communitycandraw upontheirownresourcesandutilize partnershipswithotherorganizationsto galvanize the communitytounite togetherandprotecttheircommonenvironmentandresources. Such bottom-upapproachestoEE can have many potential benefits. Educatorsfromwithinthe community maybe more effective teachersthroughthe ability toexplaincomplex conceptsinways that are easilyunderstoodby people,overcomingcultural, language,andliteracy barriersthatmight hinderthe transferof knowledgefromNGOsorgovernmentofficials.Projectsinitiatedby communitymembersare also likelymore sustainable thaninvolvementof outside NGOsthatusually stay inthe communityonlyona short-termbasis.Suchcommunity-drivenprogramscouldalsobe more empoweringandcontribute toastrongersense of ownershipoversustainable management and conservation of natural resourcesif initiatedfromwithincommunityandledbylocal community members.Giventhesepotential advantagesof bottom-upapproachestoEE, one recommended strategywouldbe to trainand equip specificcommunity memberstobecome leaders intheir communities whocaninstructand engage the local communityin conservingtheirenvironment. Previousstudiesalsoattesttothe benefitsof community-based;forexample,Harris(2014)
  • 32. Hessenius 32 concludedina case studyon the communicationonclimate change impactsandadaptation strategiesinPacificislandsthatbottom-upapproacheswere effective inenablingcitizensto participate,share knowledge,buildenvironmental awarenessandunderstandingof climate change risksto theircommunitiesinaway that wasengagingandempoweringforcommunities.Ardoin, Clark,& Kelsey(2013) alsoidentifythe needtodevelopmethodsof collaboratingwithpractitioners, involvingwidercommunitymembersinparticipatinginEE,understandingthe effectsof collective and social learningandhoweducational outcomesforindividualsandcommunitiesare linked,and supportingcommunity-basedEEas one of the mostimportanttrendstoexplore inthe future forEE. 4.5 Shifting Focus fromAwareness to Behavior Change Interviewswithlocal communitymembersrevealedthat general environmentalawareness inthe communityisveryhigh.While communitymembersmaynotbe educatedinenvironmental concepts,the realityof theirdailylivesandconstantinteractionwiththe environmentfortheir livelihoods,since nearlyeveryoneinthe communityisinvolvedinfishing,meanthatthe community membersare extremelyintune withtheirenvironment.Theyknow how the environmentis interconnectedandare sensitivetoanychangesinthe environmentandthe resourcesthatare crucial for theirlivelihoods. Althoughenvironmental awarenessishighamonglocal community members,EEcan still be beneficial forthe community,butthere needstobe a shiftfromfocusing on environmental awarenesstoemphasizingspecificandactionablebehaviorchangesthatcanyield resultsforconservation. Trendsinthe EEresearchreflectthisshiftfromawareness-focusedto action-orientedEEandbehaviorchange forconservation(Smith&Keat2006). Ardoin,Clark, & Kelsey (2013) and Monroe (2007) acknowledge the highpriorityondevelopingeffective educational and communicationstrategiesthatcansuccessfullyelicitindividual behaviorchange anddecision- makingthat supportssustainability. Aimingtoincrease environmental awarenessamongthe local communitymaybe misguided and unproductive if itamountstosimplytryingtotell communitymemberswhattheyalreadyknow. Instead,EE shouldaimtoprovide specificandviable alternativestocurrentpracticesthatcontribute to degradationof the environmentanddeliverupdatesontangible outcomesandachievementsof existingconservationprograms,inordertounderstandanddemonstrate the directlinkbetween behaviorchange andconservationresults. Some projectsinthe community have alreadyhad suchoutcomes.Forexample,one of Osmose’scommunitydevelopmentprojects backin2002 whentheyhad the available funding was to assist20 familiesinbuildingfloatinggardens.Thisprojecthadsignificantandlastingbenefits,as one communitymemberwhostill usedherfloatinggardenreported,because she wasable togrow
  • 33. Hessenius 33 mostof herown vegetablestofeedherfamily,reducingthe amountof income she neededtospend and improvingnutritionforherfamily. Equippingpeople withthesekindsof toolsandskillsare essential forimprovingpeople’slivelihoodsanddecreasingtheir dependence onnatural resources to alleviate pressure onthose resources.Live &LearnEnvironmental Education have beenactive in otherfloatingvillagesonthe Tonle Saptoachieve goalssuchas improving sanitation, water management,andnutrition,andarepresentativeof the NGOemphasize thatthese projectsare selectedbecausetheylinkeducationandimprovedqualityof life.Thisrepresentativeelucidated that itis necessarytoprovide viable alternative optionsalongwithEEinorderto achieve behavior outcomes,andthat EE that focusesonawarenesswithoutconnectingittospecificactionsand alternative optionsisnotonlyineffectual,butweakensEEthroughitsunrealism. In PrekToal and AnlongTaor,an example of the challengesinvolvedinmotivatingbehavior changesisthe case of waste management. Despite the factthatimproperwaste disposal(i.e. throwingrubbishintothe water) was the mostcommon behaviorchange encouraged by almost everystakeholder,eventhose thatwere notactivelyengagedinEE, andmany communitymembers didreportthat theyhave changedtheirwaste managementpractices, rubbishremainsamajor environmental probleminthe community. Inthese floatingvillages,thereisnoinfrastructure for waste collection,socommunitymembers’realisticoptionsare tokeeptheirrubbishintheirhouses, burn it,or throwit inthe lake.Eventhoughcollectingandburningtheirrubbishisthe encouraged practice,thismethodstill hasnegative healthconsequences.Unlessthere are socially,culturally,and economicallyviablealternatives,implementingbehaviorchangesisunlikelytobe successful. 4.6 Importance of Integrating Education with Livelihood Improvement One of the mostconsistent themesfrominterviewswithlocal communitymembersisthat people knowwhatpractices are allowedandnotallowed,buttheycommitillegal actions anyway because theyare poor andneedto feedtheirfamilies. Multiplecommunity membersalsostated that local communitymembersuse resourcesforsubsistence,nottosell fora profit,sotheir resource extractionisdrivenbyneedratherbygreedordesire toselfishlybenefitoveruse of communityresources.Giventhisreality,itispossiblethatEE on itsownmay not be enoughto achieve resultsinimprovingconservationandcontributingtobehaviorchangesamonglocal communitymembers.Evenif peopleare educatedaboutthe environment,meetingtheirneedsin the presenttosurvive will alwaysoutweighthe imperativetoconserve natural resourcesforthe future. An abundance of literature supportsthislinkbetweenlivelihoodsandsocioeconomicfactors and EE and conservationbehavior(Ardoin,Clark,&Kelsey 2013,Masud etal.2014). Increasingly,in
  • 34. Hessenius 34 the fieldof EE research,the purpose of educationisseennotonlyasto inspire behaviorchange,but alsoto promote enhancedwell-beingandqualitylife andbuildthe capacityamongpeopletomake sustainable choicesandlead sustainable lives(Ardoin,Clark,Kelsey2013). Withthe risinginterestin the role of educationinsustainable development,EEwill likelycontinue toplayanimportantrole in addressinginterconnectedsocial andecological issues,suchashealthandjustice (Ardoin,Clark, Kelsey&2013). Thisrecognitionof EE’sbroadeningscope andthe impossibilityof separating environmental andsocioeconomicissuesalsorevealsthe same themedemonstratedbythisstudy’s findingsthatpoverty isamajor challenge toEE andenvironmentalsustainabilitybecause people will alwaysprioritize theirimmediatesurvival needsoverconcernsforthe long-termpreservationof the environment(Ardoin,Clark,Kelsey&2013, Khieu2002). If it is true that educationnotpairedwithviable alternative solutionsisineffectual,than improvinglivelihoodsmustbe akeycomponent toany EE initiative.If people’slivingconditionsare too poorto be able toaffordto change theiractionslike illegal fishingandcuttingtrees,thenthere will be norealisticalternative optionsthatcanfacilitate resultsinbehaviorchanges.Forthisreason, Osmose’smodel thatintegrateslivelihoodimprovementthroughgenerationof alternative income withEE is verypractical and successful.Still,overall livingconditionsinPrekToal remaingenerally low,sothere are still significantchangesthatcanand shouldbe made toallow local community memberstoincrease theirincome generationanddecrease theirdependence onillegal resource use. AnotherexampleinCambodiaof amodel thatsuccessfullyintegrateslivelihood improvement,conservation,andeducationisthe SamVeasnaCenter’scommunityecotourism projectinTmatboey that aimsto protecta critical habitatfor globallythreatenedlarge waterbirds in the Northernplainsof Cambodia(Clementsetal.2008). Throughthe community-basedtourism model,the local communityhasbecome apartnerinconservation,whose attitude towardsand value of the birdspecieshaschangedsince theynow recognize the birdsasa valuable source of revenue throughdirectpaymentforservicesanddonationtoacommunitydevelopmentfundfrom the touristswhocome to see them (Clementsetal.2008). It wasreportedthatthe birdseven became a source of pride tothe community,andthiscombinedwiththe financialincentivesfrom tourismcausedthemto change theirbehaviorsandbecome active protectorsof the birds (Clements et al.2008). The projecthashad substantial outcomesforbothreducingpovertyamongcommunity membersandconservingthe birdspecies,whose populationsrose dramaticallyfollowing implementationof the projectdue toa significantreductioninhuntingactivityfromlocal communitymembers (Clementsetal.2008). More projectslike thiscancreativelyfindwaysto incentivize conservationbehaviorsandintegrate benefitstolivelihoodsandthe environment,while
  • 35. Hessenius 35 simultaneouslyengagingandeducatingthe communitybyempoweringthemtobecome partnersin environmental preservationandsustainable resource use. 5. Conclusion Thisstudy acknowledges the internationallyrecognizedandessential role thatEEplaysin promotingsustainabledevelopment,benefittinglocal communities’livelihoods,andstrengthening conservationof biodiversity.The studyalsorecognizesthatinCambodia, despite the prevalence of a wide varietyof EE initiativesimplementedbymanystakeholders, there hasbeenlimitedformal monitoringandevaluationof EE initiativesandassessmentof theirsuccess. Inresponse,thisstudy aimedtoinvestigate the currentstatusof environmentaleducationinthe villagesof PrekToal and AnlongTaor villages onthe Tonle Sap. The findingsof thisstudy yield insightsintothe importance of EEfor improvingconservation of natural resourcesandlivelihoodsinlocal communitiesonthe Tonle Sap, aswell assome ways that approachestoEE in the regioncan be developedinthe future toincrease theireffectiveness and abilitytocreate substantial change inbehaviorsandactions. Itwasfoundthat while stakeholder such as Osmose andthe publicschoolshave focusedonprovidingchildreninthe communitywith EE, there isa gap inEE foradults.Anotherfactorinthisoversightisthataccess to educationfor adultsinthe communityis limited,asmanycommunitymembersreportedthattheywere not invitedtomeetingsheldbythe MoE inwhichenvironmental informationisdiscussedand disseminated.Targetingadultsasrecipientsof EEis especiallyimportantbecause theyare the membersof the communitywhoare currentlyengagedincollectionof natural resources,which sometimesincludesillegalextractionof those resources. A keyfindingwasthe perceptionamong communitymembersthatincreasedconservationmeasureshave ledtoadecline innatural resourcesinthe PrekToal Core Area,incontrast to the data frombiodiversitymonitoringthat indicatessuccessesinprotectingnatural resourcesasaresultof conservation.Itispossible thatthis lack of confidence amongcommunitymembersinthe effectivenessof conservationapproachesmay be contributingtocontinuedillegal activity.RegularandcontinuedEEanddisseminationof informationonconservationmayresultingreatercommunitysupportforthese initiatives. EEneeds to focusmore on motivatingpeopletoaltertheiractionsandbehaviorsinordertobe successful in achievingconservationresults,andthatEE initiativesshouldalsobe coupledwithstrategiesto alleviate povertyandimprove local livelihoods,suchasbyofferingalternative optionsforincome generation,since the mostcommonlyreportedreasonthatpeople violate restrictionsonresource use isthat theyand theirfamiliesare dependentonthese resourcesfortheirsurvival.
  • 36. Hessenius 36 Furtherstudiesshouldcontinue collectingdataonEE inlocal communitiesonthe Tonle Sap and identifyingopportunitiesforimprovementanddevelopment.Asmore evidence isaccruedon the methodsandapproachesemployedbyvarious stakeholdersand theirresultsandimpactinthe local community ingeneratingpositiveactionsandbehaviorsthatsupportconservationof the environmentandsustainableuse of resources, itwillbecome possible todeterminethe best practicesand applythe mostsuccessful modelsinmore communitiesinCambodiaandthe region, while adjustingimplementationtocomplywiththe local social,cultural,economic,and environmental context.Bydevelopingsucheducational strategieswithanaimto equipindividuals and communitieswiththe knowledge,skills,andvaluesnecessarytomake environmentally consciousdecisions,change theiractions,andgenerate innovativesolutionstoenvironmental problems,EEcan ideally be elevatedtoplaythe role envisionedbythe global communitytoadvance sustainable development goals,promotingprotectionof the planet’sbiodiversityandimprovement qualityof life.
  • 37. Hessenius 37 References ADB 2010, Cambodia:TonleSap EnvironmentalManagementProjectCompletion Report,ADB, viewedMay1 2016 http://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/project-document/63385/33418-01- cam-pcr.pdf ADB 2011, Cambodia:Tonle SapEnvironmental ManagementProjectValidationReport,ADB,viewed May 1 2016, http://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/evaluation-document/35547/files/in216-11.pdf Ardoin,N,Clark,C,& Kelsey,E2013 ‘Anexplorationof future trendsinenvironmentaleducation research’, EnvironmentalEducation Research,vol.19,no. 4, pp. 499–520 ASEAN 2006, ASEAN EnvironmentalEducation Action Plan 2008-2012, ASEAN,Yangon,viewed1May 2016, http://environment.asean.org/wp- content/uploads/2015/06/ASEAN_Environmental_Education_Action_Plan_2008-2012.pdf ASEAN 2013, ASEAN EnvironmentalEducation Action Plan 2014-2018, ASEAN,Surabaya,viewed1 May 2016, http://environment.asean.org/wp- content/uploads/2015/06/ASEAN_Environmental_Education_Action_Plan_2014-2018.pdf Awoyemi,SM,Gambrill,A,Ormsby,A,&VyasD 2012, ‘Global EffortstoBridge Religionand Conservation:Are TheyReallyWorking?’inPovilitisT(ed.) Topicsin Conservation Biology,InTech, Rijeka,Croatia,viewed1May 2016, http://library.umac.mo/ebooks/b28110031.pdf BerkleyCenterforReligion,Peace &WorldAffairs n.d., Association of BuddhistsfortheEnvironment, GeorgetownUniversity,WashingtonD.C., http://berkleycenter.georgetown.edu/organizations/association-of-buddhists-for-the-environment Chim,P2012, ‘AnImplementationof BuddhistEnvironmentalEthicsforSustainableDevelopmentin Cambodia’,Prajna Vihara Journalof Philosophy and Religion, vol.13,no. 1-2, pp.137-144, viewed1 May 2016, http://www.assumptionjournal.au.edu/index.php/PrajnaVihara/article/view/752/668 Clements,T,John,A,Nielsen,K,Chea,V,Sokha,E& Meas, P2008, CaseStudy Tmatboey Community-based EcotourismProject,Cambodia,SamVeasnaCenter,SiemReap,viewed1May 2016, http://www.samveasna.org/userfiles/file/WCSCaseStudy-Cambodia-ecotourism-Final.pdf ConservationInternational 2016, Tonle SapLake: ConservingCambodia’sFish Factory,CI, http://www.conservation.org/projects/Pages/tonle-sap-lake-conserving-cambodia-fish-factory- mekong.aspx Glaser,B & Strauss,A 1967, The Discovery of Grounded Theory:StrategiesforQualitativeResearch, Chicago,Adine PublishingCompany Global EnvironmentFacility2011, Terminal Evaluation of TonleSap Conservation Project,GEF, http://www.thegef.org/gef/sites/thegef.org/files/gef_prj_docs/GEFProjectDocuments/M&E/TER/FY 2011/UNDP/1183/962_BD_Cambodia_TE.pdf Harris,U 2014, ‘Communicatingclimate change inthe Pacificusingabottom-upapproach’, Pacific JournalismReview,vol.20, no. 2, pp. 77-95 JapanEnvironmental EducationForum 2007, Database of Environmental EducationRelated OrganizationsinAsianCountries,JEEF,viewed1May 2016, http://www.jeef.or.jp/EAST_ASIA/?job_cat=cambodia
  • 38. Hessenius 38 Khieu,M 2002, The PathTo Success''Some Pioneering ExamplesOf EE'', Institute forGlobal Environmental Strategies,viewed1May 2016 http://enviroscope.iges.or.jp/modules/envirolib/view.php?docid=1520 Knight, D,Allegretti, A, Vaske,J2015, ‘Informationdissemination-diffusionandmarine protected area approval inthe Philippines’, Ocean &CoastalManagement, vol.113, pp.38-46 Live & Learn 2015, Building a SustainableFutureA StrategicApproach to EnvironmentalEducation in the Tonle Sap Region – Cambodia,Live &LearnEnvironmental Education,viewed1May 2016 http://www.livelearn.org/sites/default/files/images/Mini%20Strategy.pdf Masud, M, Kari,F, Yahaya, S,Al-Amin,A 2014, ‘Impactof residents’livelihoodsonattitudestowards environmental conservationbehaviour:Anempirical investigationof TiomanIslandMarine Park area,Malaysia’, Ocean & CoastalManagement,vol.93,pp. 7-14 Monroe,M 2007, ‘A PriorityforESD Research:InfluencingAdultCitizens’, Journalof Education for SustainableDevelopment,vol.1,no.1, pp. 107-113 Office of the HighCommissiononHumanRights1948, UniversalDeclaration of Human Rights, OHCHR, viewed1May 2016 http://www.ohchr.org/EN/UDHR/Documents/UDHR_Translations/eng.pdf Osmose 2014, Social AssessmentPeakKanteilFloating Village,Tonle Sap BiophereReserve,Critical EcosystemPartnershipFund,viewed1May 2016 http://www.cepf.net/SiteCollectionDocuments/indo_burma_ii/63482_Safeguard_OSMOSE_SocialAs sessment.pdf Osmose 2015, Osmose Conservation,Education,Ecotourism, PrekToal,viewed1May 2016 http://www.osmosetonlesap.net/english/accueil.php Ramsar SitesInformationService 2015, PrekToal RamsarSite, RSIS,viewed1May 2016, https://rsis.ramsar.org/ris/2245 Sam VeasnaCentern.d., Conservation,SVC,SiemReap,viewed1May 2016 http://www.samveasna.org/conservation.html Smith,J& Keat,B 2006, Cambodia’sEnvironmentalEducation StatusReport2005, Live andLearn Environmental Education,PhnomPenh,viewed1May 2016, http://www.livelearn.org/sites/default/files/docs/LLEE%20Cam%20Status%20Rpt.pdf Sun,V & Mahood, S 2015, Wildlife Monitoring atPrek Toal RamsarSite,Tonle Sap Great Lake, 2013 and 2014, Wildlife ConservationSocietyCambodia,PhnomPenh Tonle SapConservationProject2007, Prek ToalCore Area Tonle Sap BiosphereReserve Management Plan 2007-2011, Ramsar, viewed1May 2016 https://rsis.ramsar.org/RISapp/files/31383985/documents/KH_mgt1511.pdf UNEP 1972, Stockholm1972 Reportof the UnitedNationsConference onthe HumanEnvironment, UNEP, viewed1May 2016, http://www.unep.org/Documents.Multilingual/Default.asp?DocumentID=97&ArticleID=1511).%20In UNEP 1992, Rio Declaration on Environmentand Development,UNEP,viewed1May 2016 http://www.unep.org/documents.multilingual/default.asp?documentid=78&articleid=1163
  • 39. Hessenius 39 UNEP 1992, Promoting Education,PublicAwareness,and Training,UNEPviewed1May 2016 http://www.unep.org/documents.multilingual/default.asp?DocumentID=52&ArticleID=4415&l=en UNEP 2003, UNEP - Principle 10 and the Bali Guideline, UNEP, viewed1May 2016 http://www.unep.org/civil-society/Implementation/Principle10 UNEP 2004, Human Rightsand theEnvironmentProceedingsof a Geneva EnvironmentNetwork roundtable,UNEP,viewed1May 2016 http://www.genevaenvironmentnetwork.org/?q=en/system/files/human_rights_env_report.pdf UNEP-OHCHR2009, High Level Expert Meeting on the New Futureof Human Rights and Environment:Moving theGlobalAgenda Forward,GenevaEnvironmentNetwork,viewed1May 2016, http://www.genevaenvironmentnetwork.org/?q=en/system/files/human_rights_env_report.pdf UNESCO 1975, Belgrade Charter,Global DevelopmentResearchCenter,viewed1May 2016, http://www.gdrc.org/uem/ee/belgrade.html UNESCO-UNEP1977, Tbilisi Declaration,Global DevelopmentResearchCenter,viewed1May 2016, http://www.gdrc.org/uem/ee/tbilisi.html UNESCO 2006, FrameworkfortheUNDESD InternationalImplementation Scheme,UNESCO, Paris, viewed1May 2016, http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0014/001486/148650E.pdf UNESCO 2007, UNESCO - MAB BiosphereReservesDirectory, UNESCO,viewed1May 2016, http://www.unesco.org/mabdb/br/brdir/directory/biores.asp?mode=all&code=CAM+01 UNESCO 2016, World Networkof BiosphereReserves(WNBR),UNESCO,viewed1May 2016, http://www.unesco.org/new/en/natural-sciences/environment/ecological-sciences/biosphere- reserves/world-network-wnbr/ WildlifeAlliance2015, Wildlife Alliance,New York,viewedMay1 2016, http://www.wildlifealliance.org/education Wildife ConservationSociety2016, WCS Cambodia,PhnomPenh,viewed1May 2016, http://cambodia.wcs.org/
  • 40. Hessenius 40 Appendix 1 Interview Date Location Stakeholder Sex and Age 1 15-Apr St. John's Church, Siem Reap Catholic Priest M 2 19-Apr MoE Station, Prek Toal MoE Ranger M-35 3 19-Apr Anlong Taor Village-level Official M-57 4 19-Apr Osmose Platform,Prek Toal Osmose Teacher F-54 5 19-Apr Monastery, Anlong Taor Monk M 6 19-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-63 7 19-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-31 8 20-Apr Osmose Platform,Prek Toal Osmose Representative M-40 9 20-Apr Osmose Platform, Prek Toal Osmose Teacher F-58 10 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community M-37, F-31 11 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-43, M-47 12 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community M-49, F-47 13 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-59, F-30 14 20-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-47 15 21-Apr Anlong Taor MoE Ranger M-53 16 21-Apr Anlong Taor Community FishingCommittee Member M-52 17 21-Apr Prek Toal Village-level Official M-78 18 21-Apr Prek Toal Community F-49 19 21-Apr Prek Toal Community F-70 20 22-Apr Prek Toal Community M-42 21 22-Apr Prek Toal Community M-55, M-29 22 22-Apr Anlong Taor Community F-51 23 22-Apr Anlong Taor Community FishingCommittee Member M-66 24 22-Apr Anlong Taor MoE Ranger M-33 25 22-Apr MoE Station, Prek Toal MoE Official M 26 22-Apr Phone WCS Representative M 27 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-70 28 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-55, F-22 29 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-57 30 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-39 31 23-Apr Prek Toal Community F-59 32 25-Apr Prek Toal Public School Teacher M-31 33 25-Apr Anlong Taor Public School Teacher M-42 34 25-Apr Anlong Taor Public School Teacher F-20 35 26-Apr Prek Toal Public School Teacher F-26 36 26-Apr Anlong Taor Public School Teacher F-27 37 26-Apr Prek Toal Commune-level Official M 38 27-Apr Anlong Taor Public School Teacher F-24 39 27-Apr Prek Toal Community FishingCommittee Member M-50 40 29-Apr Osmose Headquarters,Siem Reap Osmose Representative M 41 29-Apr Siem Reap Live & Learn Cambodia Representative M Table 2:Full List of Interviews Conducted During Data Collection Period, April 2016