Conducive and inhibiting factors to the development of women entrepreneurship
1. Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online)
Vol.3, No.8, 2013
28
Conducive and Inhibiting Factors to the Development of Women
Entrepreneurship
Pratima Pawar
Department of Sociology, Dr.Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University, Aurangabad,431004, Maharashtra
State, India.
*Pratimapawar2009@yahoo.com.
Abstract
In this dynamic world, women entrepreneurs are significant for the economic development of a country in
general and development of women in particular. Now a days a number of women are seeking professional
education to enter into an independent business/professional activities. They have entered in independent
business/professional activities such as manufacturing, trading and a number of professional activities such as
doctors, archictects, lawers, beauticians etc. The present empirical study has been carried out in Aurangabad city
of Marathwada region in Maharashtra, India. In the sphere of entrepreneurial development, women are
constrained by a variety of socio-economic factors. Therefore it is important to understand conducive and
inhibiting factors to the development of women entrepreneurship. The present study was conducted to
understand the factors, conducive as well as inhibiting, to the development of women entrepreneurship in
Aurangabad , one of the cities of Maharashtra State in India.
Key Words: Economic Growth, Conducive Factor, Inhibiting factor, Entrepreneurship.
1. Introduction:
A number of Social scientists have contended that entrepreneurship is a key variable that links the socio –cultural
milieu, with the rate of economic development (Deshpande 1982). Many economists now recognise the role of
social factors in economic growth and some have gone to the extent of including concepts developed in the
discipline of sociology and social psychology in to their overall analysis. Most sociological analysts, on the other
hand, following the tradition of Max Weber, have placed a major independent emphasis on the effect of values in
fostering economic development (Lipset 2000). Thus socio-cultural factors play a important role in the
development of any country.
Earlier women, almost one half of the total population, were, by and large, confined to household chores and
strictly to family affairs. Their skills, capabilities, abilities and potentialities were all confined to the four walls
of the house. With the opening up of the economy, the exposure to social and cultural practices of the modern
capitalist world, the influence of rapidly growing communication networks around the world, the growing
consumerism due to advanced techniques of salesmanship for the promotion of individually own ventures, and
the relaxed rules and restrictions besides various export promotion programmes have had a profound influence
on the Indian women particularly those belonging to the middle class (Begum 2006).
Today women are increasingly seeking entrepreneurship as an independent avenue for economic growth. In the
developing countries like India, the presence of women entrepreneurs is a vital necessity to achieve rapid all-
round and regionally and socially balanced economic growth through industrialisation (Ibid 13).
There are a number of factors that play an important role in determining women’s entry into and the further
development and promotion of women as entrepreneurs.
The present empirical study has been carried out in Aurangabad city of Marathwada region in Maharashtra,
India. Aurangabad is the divisional capital of Marathwada region. Therefore it is important to understand
conducive and inhibiting factors to the development of women entrepreneurship.
2. The Concept of Entrepreneur and Women Entrepreneurship:
The word 'Entrepreneur' comes from the French word 'entrepreneur' which means to do something. It was
originally used in the middle ages in the sense of a person who is active, who gets things done (Swedberg 2000).
During the early 16th
century, the Frenchmen who organized and led military expeditions were referred to as
'Entrepreneurs'. Around 1700 A.D. the term was used for Architects and Contractors of Public Works (Desai
2004).
Kamala Singh defined a woman entrepreneur as "Confident, innovative, and creative woman capable of
achieving self economic independence, individually or, in collaboration, who generates employment
opportunities for others through initiating, establishing and running an enterprise by keeping pace with her
personal, family and social life" (Singh 1992).
2. Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online)
Vol.3, No.8, 2013
29
In the present research work, the researcher defined a woman entrepreneur as," a woman who is innovative,
creative and who establishes her own business and provides some unique kind of services to the society,
individually or in collaboration by generating employment to others."
3. Review of Literature:
Rao, Harinarayana (1991) has carried out a study to assess the factors which inhibit and slow down the
process of entrepreneurial development among women in Anantapur district of Andhra Pradesh. The study was
conducted on 81 rural women entrepreneurs. It is revealed in the study that poor financial status, lack of co-
operation from the family and society, widespread illiteracy and ignorance were some of the hindrances in the
way of development of women entrepreneurship.
Das Mallika (1999) has carried out an exploratory study of women entrepreneurs from two Southern
Indian States of Tamilnadu and Kerala. The study examines their reasons for starting a business and compares
women who started their own business for different reasons. It also looks at operational problems being faced by
women entrepreneurs and the work-family conflicts experienced by women entrepreneurs. This exploratory
study indicated that there are both similarities and differences between the experiences of women from the
developing and developed worlds.Cash flow problem was the most frequently stated bottleneck, followed by
‘inadequate working capital’, ‘product quality’, lack of managerial experience and lack of time were some of the
problems faced by women in the study.
Manimekala and Rajeshwari (2000) analysed the nature of entrepreneurial activities at the micro level
and their problems in successfully running the enterprise by studying a sample of 30 women entrepreneurs in
Tiruchirapalli district. The study reveals that the majority of the entrepreneurs were Hindus and the remaining
were Muslims and Christians. Majority of the entrepreneurs came from business and industrial backgrounds and
most of them were married to business families. It was also revealed in the study that majority of them did not
face any problems severely by virtue of being women. Non-availability of quality raw material, non-sanctioning
of the loan by banks and lack of co-operation from family members were some of the problems faced by the
women entrepreneurs.
Kalyani and Chandralekha (2002) have conducted an exploratory survey of a sample of 300 women
entrepreneurs in two districts namely Cuddaph and Tirupati of Andhra Pradesh. This study dwells upon factors
that motivate women to initiate the launching of enterprises and also tries to understand the factors which act as
constraints and support their effective association in managing the enterprises. This study brings forth the
observation that socio-economic and demographic characteristics have a significant impact on the involvement
of women entrepreneurs particularly when it comes to enterprise management. Many of them do receive help
from their family members particularly the male members in carrying out various kinds of work.
Kumar Anil (2005) has conducted a study on women entrepreneurs in Delhi city. A sample of 75
women entrepreneurs had been selected for the purpose of the study. The study focused on the profile of women
entrepreneurs, constraints, that a woman entrepreneur normally faces both at the time of commencement of
business and during the course of business and also income, investment and sources of finance used by women
entrepreneurs. The study pointed out that, Most of the women entrepreneurs are facing the problem of finance
and marketing. Moreover, the present schemes for making finance available have a lot of bottlenecks and gaps.
4. Methodology:
The present empirical Study in Aurangabad city intends to understand conducive as well as inhibiting factors to
the development of women entrepreneurship. The study is descriptive in nature. The universe for the present
study constituted all the women entrepreneurs working in Aurangabad city from two sectors: manufacturing and
trading.
No organized efforts were made earlier on the part of the government or on the part of the non government
organization to prepare an exhaustive list of entrepreneurs in manufacturing and trading sectors from
Aurangabad city.
By using snow ball technique the researcher herself had to prepare a list of women entrepreneurs to be
used as a sampling frames for the present study. Out of total ninety three respondents (45 from manufacturing
and 48 from Trading sector) in Aurangabad city fifty six women entrepreneurs (26 from manufacturing and 30
from trading sector) were purposively selected as sample entrepreneurs.
5. Objectives of the Study: The major two-fold objectives of the present study were:
1) To understand the conducive factors to the development of women entrepreneurship.
2) To understand the inhibiting factors to the development of women entrepreneurship.
3. Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online)
Vol.3, No.8, 2013
30
6. Factors Conducive to the Development of Women Entrepreneurship
A number of factors play an important role in determining women's entry into and the further development and
promotion of women as entrepreneurship. The factors which are considered to be conducive by the respondents
for women's entry into and further development of entrepreneurship have been discussed in this paper.
6.1 Proper Age to start the Business / Profession to Achieve Success:
Age is an important criterion to be considered for one's entry into a business / profession. Respondents’ opinions
with regard to the proper age- group to enter into business / profession were collected. The respondents’ opinions
regarding the proper age- group to start business / profession are presented in table no.6.1.
The respondents’ responses presented in the table no.6.1 indicate that an overwhelming majority (82 percent) of
the respondents were of the opinion that the proper age to start the business / profession was between 21 to 30
years, and (12 percent) saying that it was between 31 to 40 years.
Thus it is clearly revealed in the study that an overwhelming majority of the respondents were found to have
expressed their opinion that proper age to enter the business was between 21 to 30 years. Because this is the age-
group in which women feel relatively young and energetic. And to run any business/profession one must require
good physical stamina, courage which one can possess comparatively in the younger age. Thus, entry in the
enterprise at a relatively young age is considered as conducive factor by the respondents in this study.
6.2 Professional Education:
Professional education is considered to be an important facilitating factor for the development of women
entrepreneurship. It is very difficult to enter and succeed in business/ profession without the achievement of
professional education. Respondents’ opinions regarding the importance of professional education to run the
business were collected and they are presented in the table no.6.2.
The table no.6.2 clearly reveals that, an overwhelming majority of the respondents (73 Percent) were found to
consider professional education as the most important whereas 11 percent were found to consider professional
education as of medium importance. Among the remaining, 8 percent were found to consider professional
education as the least important and another 8 percent were found to consider professional education as not
important at all. Thus, the overall majority of the respondents considered professional education to be the most
important conducive factor to enter into an independent entrepreneurial activity.
Free education policy of government for a girl child, various programmes of women’s empowerment in the last
quarter of the 20th century has increased the educational awareness among the women. Due to it many women
have started taking various kind of professional education to enter into different kinds of business/professional
activity. Because education helps individual to think and act the way individual wants to do.
6.3 Family Professional Background:
Family business/Professional background influences one's entry into the independent business/ profession.
Therefore, respondents’ opinions regarding the relationship between the family professional background and the
level of success in the business/profession were collected.
The data regarding the relationship between these two variables as perceived by the respondents are presented in
the table no.6.3.
It is seen from the data presented in the table no.6.3 that, a majority (39 percent) of the respondents were found
to be in a agreement that there is a close relationship between the family professional background and the
professional success, 32 percent of the respondents said that there is no relationship between family professional
background and success in the business, where as 29 percent of the respondents said that there is a relationship
between these variables to some extent.
It is relatively easy for a person to enter into and achieve success in a business/profession, who is having
business/professional background than the person who does not have such background. On the whole, as
reflected in the respondents’ opinions, it appears that the family professional background is a conducive factor
for the success in the entrepreneurship activity.
6.4 Relationship between Birth in a particular Caste and success in entrepreneurial Activity.
In India social stratification is based on Caste. It means Caste influences almost all aspects of social life.
Therefore, a question was asked to the respondents seeking their opinions about the relationship between the
birth in a particular caste and the success in the business / profession. The responses given by the respondents are
presented in the table no.6.4.
It can be seen from the data presented in the table no.6.4 that 45 percent of the respondents think that there is a
positive relationship between one's caste, and success in one's business / profession to great extent and another
24 percent think that there is a relationship between the two to a certain extent only.
4. Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online)
Vol.3, No.8, 2013
31
Thus, a majority of the respondents (45+24=69 Percent) opined that there is some degree of positive relationship
between caste and success in an entrepreneurial activity. As against this, 31 percent of the respondents think that
there is no relationship between them.
In India some castes and communities are considered as business communities such as Guajarati’s, Marwari’s
and Punjabi. As McClelland supported n achievement as a major psychological dimension, which is important in
the development of entrepreneurship. Thomas Cochran has formulated a sociological theory of entrepreneurial
supply. The key elements in his system are cultural values, role expectations and social sanctions. According to
Weber Indians lacks entrepreneurial skills because of values antithetical to it. But as an exception some
castes/communities in India such as Guajarati’s, Marwari’s and Punjabi are considered as traditional business
communities. It is easier to them to enter into an independent business/professional activity because they possess
values required for it.
7. Factors Inhibiting to the Development of Women Entrepreneurship.
In our society a women still receives a secondary status in the family.Generally women does not enter the
business line or independent profession due to a number of obstacles in their way. Some such factors inhibiting
the development of women entrepreneurship were identified on the basis of responses of the respondents in the
present study.
7.1 Unfavourable Traditional Societal Attitude:
In general, societal attitude towards women’s entry in the entrepreneurial activity is still not so favourable; it is
because tradition bound persons in society question women’s independent abilities. However, recently women
have shown that they are not inferior to men. Women have started entering in all the fields including the
entrepreneurial activities.
Yet the situation is quite different in metropolitan cities in India and small towns and cities such as Aurangabad
where one finds elements of tradition along with that of modernity. Hence, an attempt was made in this study to
understand the respondents perception regarding the societal attitude towards women entrepreneurs.
The responses received to a question in this regard have been presented in the table no.7.1.
The table no.7.1 indicates that only 43 percent of the respondents have opined that the societal attitude towards
women is favourable to a great extent. As againt this majority (46 percent) of the respondents opined that the
societal attitude is favourable only to some extent and 11 percent of the respondents opined that the societal
attitude is not favourable at all
It is revealed from the data that a majority of the respondents opined that the societal attitude towards women
entrepreneurs is not very favourable. Despite constitutional equality, women are still discriminated by the male
dominated society. The data thus strongly indicate that in general, tradition bound unfavourable societal attitude
still prevails in smaller city such as Aurangabad. And this unfavourable societal attitude towards women
entrepreneurs could be regarded as the inhibiting factor in the context of the development of women
entrepreneurship in Aurangabad.
7.2 Problems Faced While Getting the Loan Sanctioned:
In setting up of an enterprise it is necessary to raise loan from some financial organisation. In case of women
entrepreneurs, they are likely to face a number of problems in raising loan from banks, because banks are not
ready to sanction the loan unless they are fully satisfied with the repayment ability of the party concerned. In this
case it is interesting to understand the experiences of the women entrepreneurs. To understand respondents’
experiences the question asked was, “Did you face any problem while getting the loan sanctioned from the
banks?” The responses thus collected are presented accordingly in the table no.7.2.
The data revealed in the above table no.7.2 that, in case of 32 percent of the respondents opined that they did not
face any problems while getting the loan sanctioned. Almost 29 percent of the respondents opined that the
procedure of loan sanctioning is tedious. To 27 percent of the respondents this question did not arise because
they were found to have started their units without financial assistance from the banks. 7 percent of the
respondents also opined that they have experienced negative attitude on the part of the bankers. 5 percent of the
respondents opined that their loan was sanctioned but not received on time. In brief, about the problems faced by
the respondents in raising loans from the banks, it can be summarised that in case of 41 percent of the
respondents who were found to have experienced a number of problems in getting the loans sanctioned.
In general it appears that the attitude of the bankers was not conducive towards women entrepreneurs. In Indian
society very few women have property on their names. Therefore, bank officers feel it risky to provide financial
assistance to women owned units. Bankers show distrust mainly because they suspect repayment ability of the
women. Thus the problems created by the banks appear to be the inhibiting or negative factor in starting their
business/professional units.
5. Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online)
Vol.3, No.8, 2013
32
7.3 Discouraging Attitude of Some Government Officers:
Doing a business/profession is a very difficult task. In case of women it becomes a more difficult because as
compared to men women have to face more difficulties while doing business/ profession. To seek information
regarding the respondents experiences in the Government offices, the question that was asked to the sample
respondents was: “What experiences have you faced in the Government offices?” The responses obtained are
presented in the table no.7.3.
The data in the table no.7.3 indicate that, 50 percent of the respondents opined that Government officers did help
them in case of their work. However, as many as 50 percent of the respondents had to face discouraging attitude
of the Government officials, 21 percent opined that the Government officers always help by taking some bribe,
17 percent respondents opined that they were not so willing to give information about various Government
schemes etc, and 12 percent opined that the Government officers neglected them and their attitude was found to
be negative towards business women.
It indicates that attitude towards business women in the Government offices was not found to be conducive for
the development of women entrepreneurship.
Conclusions:
It is revealed from the study that entry in the enterprise at a relatively young age, professional education, family
professional background, birth in a particular caste are found to be conducive for women’s entry into and further
development of entrepreneurship. It is also revealed in a study that a number of obstacles inhibit women’s entry
into entrepreneurship and these inhibiting factors are unfavorable traditional societal attitude towards women,
obstacles in the procedure of loan sanctioning, discouraging attitude of government officers. To some extent in
the present context some factors are conducive for women’s entry into an independent economic activity but still
many factors are inhibiting to women to enter into an independent business activity. A number of studies
indicate that although number of women are entering into a entrepreneurial activity they are still facing certain
problems. Despite efforts of Government and semi-Government organizations there are certain gaps. Therefore
there is a need to encourage women to take part in a various entrepreneurial activities.
References
Begum, Mustiary.(2006),Women Entrepreneurship in India: Challenges and Strategies.University News: A
Weekly Journal of Higher Education,44(15),13-16.
Das, Mallika.(1999). Women Entrepreneurs from Southern India. The Journal of Entrepreneurship,8(2),147-
163.
Desai, Vasant.(2004), Small-Scale Industries and Entrepreneurship, Mumbai, Himalaya Publishing House,356.
Deshpande,Manohar.(1982), Entrepreneurship of Small Scale Industries: Concepts,Growth,Management,New
Delhi,Deep and Deep Publications,34.
Kalyani, W., & Chandralekha, K.(2002).Association between Socio-Economic Demographic Profile and
Involvement of Women Entrepreneurs in Their Enterprise Management. The Journal of
Entrepreneurship,11(2),219-247.
Kumar, Anil. (2005).Entrepreneurship and Employment in Metropolitan Cities. New Delhi. Deep and Deep
Publications.
Manimekala & Rajeshwari,G.(2000). Nature of Women Entrepreneurship In Tiruchirapalli.Sedme,27(2),69-
86.
Lipset, Seymour, Martin.(2000),Values and Entrepreneurship In the Americas, Swedberg Richard,
Entrepreneurship: The Social Science View, New Delhi, Oxford University Press,110.
Rao, Harinarayana.(1991).Promotion of Women Entrepreneurship. Sedme . 18(2) 21-28.
Singh , Kamala.(1992), Women Entrepreneurs, New Delhi, Ashish Publishing House,12.
Swedberg, Richard.(2000),The Social Science View Of Entrepreneurship: Introduction and Practical
Applications. Richard Swedberg. Entrepreneurship: The Social Science View, New Delhi, Oxford University
Press, 11.
6. Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online)
Vol.3, No.8, 2013
33
Table 6.1
Proper Age- group to start the Business: Respondents’ Opinions
Sr. No. Age- Groups Frequency Percentage
1. 18-20 years 03 6.00
2. 21-30 years 46 82.14
3. 31-40 years 07 11.86
Total 56 100.00
Table 6.2
Importance of Professional Education: Respondents’ Opinions
Sr.
No
Importance of Professional education Frequency Percentage
1. Most Important 41 73.2
2. Medium Important 6 10.8
3. Less Important 4 8.0
4. Not Important 5 8.0
Total 56 100.00
Table 6.3
Family Professional Background and success in Business
Sr.
No
Family Professional background and success Frequency Percentage
1. Close relationship between them 22 39.28
2. Relationship to some extent 16 28.57
3. No Relationship between them 18 32.15
Total 56 100.00
7. Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online)
Vol.3, No.8, 2013
34
Table 6.4
Relationship between Birth in a Particular Caste and success
Sr. No Relationship between caste and success in business Frequency Percentage
1. Relationship to a great extent 27 44.8
2. Relationship to some extent 13 24.0
3. No relationship between them 16 31.2
Total 56 100.00
Table 7.1
Societal Attitude towards Women Entrepreneur: Respondents’ Perception:
Sr.no Societal Attitude Frequency Percentage
1 Attitude favourable to a great extent 24 42.85
2 Attitude favourable only to a some extent 26 46.42
3 Attitude is not favourable. 06 10.73
Total 56 100.00
8. Developing Country Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online)
Vol.3, No.8, 2013
35
Table 7.2.
Problems Faced While Getting the Loan Sanctioned: Distribution of Respondents:
Sr.no. Problems faced while getting the
loan sanctioned
Frequency Percentage
1 Procedure of loan sanctioning is
tedious
16 28.57
2 Loan sanctioned but not received
on due time
3 5.35
3 Negative attitude of bankers and
they were not confident
4 7.14
4 Did not face any problems 18 32.16
5 Not applicable 15 26.78
Total 56 100.00
Table 7.3
Respondents experiences of Government Officials:
Sr.no Experiences In the government
Offices
Frequency Percentage
1 They neglected me and their
attitude was negative
07 12.50
2 They were reluctant to give desired
information
09 16.50
3 Government officers always help
us by taking bribe
12 21.00
4 They helped us 28 50.0
Total 56 100.00
Pratima Pawar ( AP’96-AP’10) became a Assistant Professor of Sociology in 1996 and Associate Professor of
Sociology in 2010.She was born in Kolhapur ( Maharashtra,India ) on 11th
May,1973. She has graduated in the
subject of Sociology from Shivaji University, Kolhapur, Maharashtra State, India, in 1993 and also post
graduated in the subject of Sociology from the same university in 1995. Her areas of specialization are Sociology
of Gender and Sociology of Development. At present, she is a Associate Professor and Head in the Department
of Sociology, Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University, Aurangabad, Maharashtra, India.
9. This academic article was published by The International Institute for Science,
Technology and Education (IISTE). The IISTE is a pioneer in the Open Access
Publishing service based in the U.S. and Europe. The aim of the institute is
Accelerating Global Knowledge Sharing.
More information about the publisher can be found in the IISTE’s homepage:
http://www.iiste.org
CALL FOR JOURNAL PAPERS
The IISTE is currently hosting more than 30 peer-reviewed academic journals and
collaborating with academic institutions around the world. There’s no deadline for
submission. Prospective authors of IISTE journals can find the submission
instruction on the following page: http://www.iiste.org/journals/ The IISTE
editorial team promises to the review and publish all the qualified submissions in a
fast manner. All the journals articles are available online to the readers all over the
world without financial, legal, or technical barriers other than those inseparable from
gaining access to the internet itself. Printed version of the journals is also available
upon request of readers and authors.
MORE RESOURCES
Book publication information: http://www.iiste.org/book/
Recent conferences: http://www.iiste.org/conference/
IISTE Knowledge Sharing Partners
EBSCO, Index Copernicus, Ulrich's Periodicals Directory, JournalTOCS, PKP Open
Archives Harvester, Bielefeld Academic Search Engine, Elektronische
Zeitschriftenbibliothek EZB, Open J-Gate, OCLC WorldCat, Universe Digtial
Library , NewJour, Google Scholar