La necessité de delaisser les opinions al albani

282 Aufrufe

Veröffentlicht am

0 Kommentare
1 Gefällt mir
Statistik
Notizen
  • Als Erste(r) kommentieren

Keine Downloads
Aufrufe
Aufrufe insgesamt
282
Auf SlideShare
0
Aus Einbettungen
0
Anzahl an Einbettungen
3
Aktionen
Geteilt
0
Downloads
2
Kommentare
0
Gefällt mir
1
Einbettungen 0
Keine Einbettungen

Keine Notizen für die Folie

La necessité de delaisser les opinions al albani

  1. 1. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP $X1RPG·$OODKOHOpPHQWOH0LVpULFRUGLHX[ 'HODQpFHVVLWpGHVXLYUHOHV KDGvWKVDXWKHQWLTXHVHWGH GpODLVVHUOHVRSLQLRQVGHV VDYDQWVORUVTX·HOOHVVRQWHQ GpVDFFRUGDYHFOD6RXQQD ,QWURGXFWLRQDXOLYUH© 'HVFULSWLRQGHODSULqUHGX3URSKqWHVDZ
  2. 2. ª GXKHLNK0XKDPPDG1kVLUXGGvQ(O$OEkQv 7UDGXFWLRQ $EX7DOKD HGRFXPHQWHVWWpOpFKDUJHDEOHjO©DGUHVVH,QWHUQHWVXLYDQWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP 7RXWHXWLOLVDWLRQGHFHGRFXPHQWjGHVILQVFRPPHUFLDOHVHVWLQWHUGLWH
  3. 3. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP 1RWHGXWUDGXFWHXU HFL HVW O LQWURGXFWLRQ j O H[FHOOHQW RXYUDJH GX KHLNK(O$OEkQv LQWLWXOp © 6LIDW 6DODW (Q1DEv ª RX © 'HVFULSWLRQGHODSULqUHGX3URSKqWH6$:
  4. 4. ª,QWURGXFWLRQGDQVODTXHOOHLOH[SOLTXHODPpWKRGRORJLHTX LOD VXLYLHjVDYRLUVXLYUHOHVKDGLWKVDXWKHQWLTXHVHWGpODLVVHUOHVRSLQLRQVGHV,PDPVTXDQGHOOHVVRQWHQFRQWUDGLFWLRQ DYHFOD6RXQQDGX3URSKqWH6$:
  5. 5. ,ODVXGpPRQWUpGDQVFHVTXHOTXHVSDJHVTXHO LPLWDWLRQDYHXJOH GHV,PDPV HVWTXHOTXHFKRVHGHUpSURXYpSDUO ,VODPHWTXHOHV,PDPVHX[PrPHVRQWLQWHUGLWGHIDLUH 3RXUODWUDGXFWLRQMHPHVXLVEDVpVXUODVHFRQGHQRXYHOOHpGLWLRQGH©0DNWDEDWHO0D¶kULI ªTXLHVWODSOXV UpFHQWHjPDFRQQDLVVDQFH 4X $OODK UpFRPSHQVH GRQF OH YpQpUDEOH KHLNK SRXU OH WUDYDLO TX LO D IRXUQL SRXU OD UHYLYLILFDWLRQ HW OD SXULILFDWLRQGHOD6RXQQDGX3URSKqWH6$:
  6. 6. $PvQ ,7$7,216'(648$75(,0Ç06 9RLFLTXHOTXHVXQHVGHVSDUROHVGHVTXDWUH,PDPV$E€+DQvIDK0kOLN 6KkIL¶v HW$KPHG LEQ +DQEDO
  7. 7. j FH VXMHW 3HXWrWUH FHOD VHUDWLO XQ UDSSHO SRXU FHX[ TXL OHV LPLWHQW DYHXJOpPHQW FRPPHVLOHXUVSDUROHVGHVFHQGDLHQWGXFLHODORUVTX·$OODK6:7
  8. 8. GLWGDQVOHRUDQ© 6XLYH]FH TXLYRXVDpWpUpYpOpGHYRWUH6HLJQHXUHWQHVXLYH]SDVG·DXWUHVDOOLpVTXH/XL0DLVYRXV YRXVVRXYHQH]SHX ª6RXUDWHYHUVHW
  9. 9. /·,0$0$%Ô+$1Í)$+4X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  10. 10. /H SUHPLHU G·HQWUH HX[ HVW O·,PDP $EX +DQLID $Q1X·PDQ LEQ 7KDELW UD
  11. 11. 3OXVLHXUV GH VHV pOqYHV RQW UDSSRUWp GH OXL GLYHUVHV SDUROHV FKDFXQH G·HOOHV PHQDQW j XQH PrPH UpDOLWp O·REOLJDWLRQ G·DGRSWHU OH KDGLWK HW GH GpODLVVHU OHV RSLQLRQV GHV ,PDPV HQ GpVDFFRUG DYHF OD 6RXQQD ©6LOHKDGLWKHVWDXWKHQWLTXHDORUVF·HVWPRQRSLQLRQ ª ©,OQ·HVWSDVSHUPLVjXQHSHUVRQQHG·DGRSWHUQRWUHRSLQLRQ VDQV VDYRLU G·RQRXV O·DYRQVWLUpH ª'DQVXQHDXWUHYHUVLRQ©,OHVWLQWHUGLWjWRXWHSHUVRQQHQHFRQQDLVVDQW ·HVW FHW DYHXJOHPHQW TXH O·,PDP7DKDZL FLWH ORUVTX·LO GLW © 3HUVRQQH Q·LPLWH VL FH Q·HVW XQ IDQDWLTXH RX XQ LPEpFLOHª5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$ELGLQHGDQV5DVPXO0XIWL UpSRQVHS
  12. 12. 5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$ELGLQHGDQV(O+DFKLD 9 S
  13. 13. HWGDQVVRQOLYUH5DVPXO0XIWL 9 SGH0DGMPX·DWX UDVDLOLEQ$ELGLQH
  14. 14. 5DSSRUWp pJDOHPHQW SDU OHKHLNK6DOLK(O)XOODQL GDQV,TDGKXO+LPHP S
  15. 15. ,EQ$ELGLQH UDSSRUWHDXVVLFHVSDUROHVWLUpHVGH6KDUKXO+LGDDRXYUDJHpFULWSDU,EQ6KDKQDHO.DELUOHPDvWUHG·LEQ+DPPDP © 6LOHKDGLWKHVWDXWKHQWLTXHHVWTX·LOHVWHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFO·DYLVMXULGLTXHGHO·(FROHKDQDILWHLOIDXWDGRSWHUOH KDGLWKHWFHODQHUHQGSDVODSHUVRQQHQRQKDQDILWHFDULODpWpUDSSRUWpGHVRXUFHDXWKHQWLTXHTXH$EX+DQLIDDGLW © 6LOHKDGLWKHVWDXWKHQWLTXHDORUVF·HVWPRQRSLQLRQªª/·,PDP,EQ$EGLO%DUDDXVVLUDSSRUWpFHODG·$EX+DQLID DLQVLTXHG·DXWUHVJUDQGV,PDPV -·DMRXWH HOD HVW XQH SUHXYH GH OD SHUIHFWLRQ GH OHXU VFLHQFH HW GH OHXU FUDLQWH G·$OODK 6:7
  16. 16. FDU LOV RQW ELHQ VRXOLJQp LFL TXH OD6RXQQD GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  17. 17. QH OHXU pWDLW SDV SDUYHQXH LQWpJUDOHPHQW /·,PDP6KDIL·L O·D DXVVL UHFRQQXFRPPHRQOHYHUUDSOXVORLQ$LQVLLOVHSHXWTX·LOpPDQHGHFHV,PDPVGHVDYLVTXLQHVRLHQWSDVHQDFFRUG DYHFOD6RXQQDF·HVWSRXUTXRLLOVQRXVRQWRUGRQQpVGHQRXVDFFURFKHUjFHOOHFLHWTX·HOOHVRLWFRQVLGpUpHFRPPH OHXURSLQLRQ4X·$OODKOHVDFFHSWHWRXVGDQV6DFOpPHQFH
  18. 18. 5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$EGLO%DUGDQV(O,QWLTDILIDGKDLOLWKDODWKDWLOIXTDKDS
  19. 19. HW,EQXO4DLPGDQV,·ODPXO 0XZDTTL·LQ 9S
  20. 20. ,EQ$ELGLQHGDQV(O+DFKLD9S
  21. 21. HWGDQV5DVPXO0XIWL SHW
  22. 22. KD·UDQLGDQV (O0L]DQH 9 S
  23. 23. ¶$EEDV (O'RXUL GDQV G·LEQ 0X·LQH 9 K S
  24. 24. DYHF XQH FKDvQH GH WUDQVPLVVLRQ DXWKHQWLTXHG·DSUqV=DIDUHWWHSDUROHDDXVVLpWpUDSSRUWpHG·$EXXVXIHW¶$ILDLEQD]LG9RLU(O,TDGK S
  25. 25. HW ,EQXO4DLPDDIILUPpVRQDXWKHQWLFLWpG·DSUqV$EXXVXI9RLU(O,·ODP9S
  26. 26. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP SDVPHV SUHXYHV GDOLOV
  27. 27. GH MXJHU VHORQ PRQ RSLQLRQª ,O HVW DMRXWp GDQV XQH DXWUH YHUVLRQ © «@ FDU QRXV VRPPHV GHV rWUHV KXPDLQV QRXV pPHWWRQV XQ DYLV DXMRXUG·KXLHWQRXVFKDQJHRQVGHPDLQª(WGDQVXQHDXWUHYHUVLRQ©0DOKHXUjWRL{ D·NRXELOV·DJLWG·$EXXVXIXQGHVSOXVJUDQGVpOqYHVG·$EX+DQLID
  28. 28. 1·pFULVSDVGH PRL WRXW FH TXH WX HQWHQGV FDU MH SHX[ DYRLU XQ DYLV DXMRXUG·KXL HW OH GpODLVVHU GHPDLQGHPrPHTXHMHSHX[DYRLUXQHRSLQLRQGHPDLQHWODGpODLVVHUDSUqVGHPDLQ ª © 6L M·DL GLW XQH SDUROH HQ GpVDFFRUG DYHF OHRUDQ HW OD6RXQQD DORUVGpODLVVH]PD SDUROH ª -·DMRXWH9RLOjGRQFOHXUVGLUHVjSURSRVGHFHOXLTXLQHFRQQDvWSDVOHXUVSUHXYHVGDOLOV
  29. 29. 0DLVTX·DXUDLHQWLOVGLW DORUVjSURSRVGHFHX[TXLVDYHQWTXHOHKDGLWKHVWHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFO·RSLQLRQGHV,PDPVHWTXLPDOJUpFHODMXJHQW G·DSUqVOHXUVDYLVHWDUJXPHQWVXIILWjOXLVHXOSRXUGpWUXLUHO·LPLWDWLRQDYHXJOHF·HVWSRXUTXRLSOXVLHXUVKHLNKV KDQDILWHV RQW UHIXVp G·DWWULEXHU FHWWH SDUROH j $EX+DQLID FDU HOOH OHV HPSrFKDLW GH MXJHU VHORQ VRQ DYLV VDQV FRQQDvWUHVHVSUHXYHVGDOLOV
  30. 30. /·,PDP$EX+DQLIDIDLWFHWWHUHPDUTXHFDULOEDVHVRXYHQWVHVDYLVMXULGLTXHVVXUO·DQDORJLH4LkV
  31. 31. $LQVLLOSHXWOXL DUULYHU GH FRQVLGpUHU TXH WHOOH DQDORJLH HVW SOXV SXLVVDQWH RX TX·XQKDGLWK DXWKHQWLTXH GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  32. 32. OXL SDUYLHQQHFHTXLDSRXUFRQVpTXHQFHOHGpODLVVHPHQWGHVRQDYLVDQWpULHXU(OKD·UDQLDGLWGDQVVRQRXYUDJH(O 0L]DQH 9S
  33. 33. © 1RWUHFRQYLFWLRQHWODFRQYLFWLRQGHWRXWHSHUVRQQHMXVWHjO·pJDUGGHO·,PDP$EX+DQLIDHVW TXHV·LODYDLWYpFXMXVTX·jFHTXHOD6KDUL·D/RL,VODPLTXH
  34. 34. DLWpWpPLVHSDUpFULWHWDSUqVTXHOHV6DYDQWVGXKDGLWK HXUHQWUDVVHPEOpWRXWHVOHVSDUROHVGX3URSKqWH6$:
  35. 35. pSDUSLOOpHVGDQVOHVGLYHUVHVFRQWUpHVPXVXOPDQHVLODXUDLW VDQVDXFXQGRXWHDGRSWpOHVKDGLWKVHWGpODLVVpWRXWHVOHVDQDORJLHVTX·LODYDLWIDLWHVHWO·DQDORJLHDXUDLWpWpUDUHGDQV VHVMXJHPHQWVFRPPHHOOHO·DpWpGDQVFHX[GHVDXWUHV,PDPVHSHQGDQWHWpWDQWGRQQpTXHOHV pOpPHQWVHWOHV SUHXYHVGHOD6KDUL·DpWDLHQWpSDUSLOOpVHQVRQWHPSVFKH]OHV7DEL·LJpQpUDWLRQVXFFpGDQWDX[RPSDJQRQV
  36. 36. HWOHXUV VXFFHVVHXUVGDQVOHVGLYHUVHVFRQWUpHVHWYLOOHVO·,PDPVHYLWGDQVO·REOLJDWLRQG·XWLOLVHUO·DQDORJLHSOXVVRXYHQWTXHOHV DXWUHV,PDPVFDULOQ·DYDLWSDVHQWUHOHVPDLQVGHWH[WHVFRQFHUQDQWOHVSUREOqPHVTXLOXLpWDLHQWSRVpV(WFHQ·HVW TX·DSUqVOXLTX·DFRPPHQFpO·pSRSpHGXKDGLWKHWGHODUHFKHUFKHGHO·DXWKHQWLTXHFKH]OHV6DYDQWVGXKDGLWKFHTXL OHXUDSHUPLVG·DYRLUWRXVOHVWH[WHVHQPDLQSRXUUpSRQGUHDX[SUREOqPHVVDQVXWLOLVHUO·DQDORJLHª$ EXO+DVVDQDWD UDSSRUWpXQHJUDQGHSDUWLHGHFHVSDUROHVGDQVVRQOLYUH(O1DIL·XONDELU S
  37. 37. HWDDMRXWpGHVFRPPHQWDLUHVSRXU TXLYRXGUDLWVHSHQFKHUSOXVSURIRQGpPHQWVXUODTXHVWLRQ -·DMRXWH 6L FHOD HVW O·H[FXVH G·$EX+DQLID HQ FH TXL FRQFHUQH VHV DYLV HQ GpVDFFRUG LQYRORQWDLUHPHQW
  38. 38. DYHF OD 6RXQQD²HWF·HVWXQHH[FXVHYDODEOHVDQVO·RPEUHG·XQGRXWHFDU$OODK6:7
  39. 39. QHFKDUJHSDVXQHkPHSOXVTXHFH TX·HOOHQHSHXWVXSSRUWHU²LOHVWGRQFVWULFWHPHQWLQWHUGLWjWRXWHSHUVRQQHGHOHUDEDLVVHUFRPPHOHIRQWFHUWDLQHV SHUVRQQHVLJQRUDQWHV%LHQ DXFRQWUDLUH1RXVOXLGHYRQVWRXWQRWUHSOXVSURIRQGUHVSHFWFDUF·HVWXQGHVSOXV JUDQGV,PDPVGHO·,VODPSDUOHTXHO$OODKDSURWpJpFHWWHUHOLJLRQHWQRXVO·DWUDQVPLVHjWUDYHUVOHVJpQpUDWLRQV'H SOXVO·,PDP$EX+DQLIDVHUDUpFRPSHQVpTXHVRQRSLQLRQVRLWMXVWHRXIDXVVH'HODPrPHIDoRQLOHVWLQWHUGLWj WRXWHSHUVRQQHOHUHVSHFWDQWGHUHVWHUDFFURFKpDX[RSLQLRQVGHO·,PDPHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFOD 6RXQQDFDUHOOHQHIRQW SOXV SDUWLH GH FHV DYLV FRPPH LO OH GLW OXLPrPH (W OD YpULWp HVW HQWUH FHV GHX[ JURXSHV© 1RWUH 6HLJQHXU SDUGRQQHQRXVDLQVLTX·jQRVIUqUHVTXLQRXVRQWSUpFpGpVGDQVODIRLHWQHPHWVGDQVQRVF±XUDXFXQH UDQF±XUSRXUFHX[TXLRQW FUX1RWUH 6HLJQHXU7XHVRPSDWLVVDQW HW7UqV0LVpULFRUGLHX[ªVRXUDWH YHUVHW
  40. 40. 5DSSRUWpSDU(O)XOODQLGDQV(O,TDGK S
  41. 41. SDUROHDWWULEXpHpJDOHPHQWjO·,PDP6KDIL·LRPPHQWDQWFHVSDUROHV (O)XOODQLDGLW© HVSDUROHVQHFRQFHUQHQWSDVOH6DYDQW0XGMWDKLG6DYDQWDDQWDWWHLQWXQQLYHDXGHVFLHQFHHW GHFRPSUpKHQVLRQWHOTX·LOVRLWGHYHQXLQGpSHQGDQWGHV(FROHVRX0DGKKDEGDQVODGpGXFWLRQGHVORLVLVODPLTXHV@ FDULOQ·DSDVEHVRLQGHVDYLVGHV,PDPV0DLVFHODFRQFHUQHSOXW{WO·LPLWDWHXUª -·DMRXWHKD·UDQLDGLWGDQV(O0L]DQH 9S
  42. 42. © 6LWXWHSRVHVODTXHVWLRQDSUqVODPRUWGHO·,PDPTXHM·LPLWH TXHIDLUH GHVKDGLWKVDXWKHQWLTXHVTX·LOQ·D SDV SXSUHQGUHHQFRPSWHGDQVVHVMXJHPHQWV/D UpSRQVH HVW WRQ GHYRLUHVWG·DGRSWHUFHVKDGLWKVFDUVLO·,PDPTXHWXLPLWHVHQDYDLWHQWHQGXSDUOpHWTX·LOVDYDLHQWpWpDXWKHQWLTXHVj FHV HX[ LO W·DXUDLW V€UHPHQW RUGRQQp GH OHV DGRSWHU FDU WRXV OHV ,PDPV VRQW SULVRQQLHUV HQWUH OHV PDLQV GH OD 6KDUL·DHWFHOXLTXLDGRSWHFHWWHDWWLWXGHDXUDUpFROWpOHELHQjSOHLQHVEUDVVpHV4XDQWjFHOXLTXLGLW©-HQ·DSSOLTXH SDVWHOKDGLWKWDQWTXHPRQ,PDPQHO·DSDVDSSOLTXpªTX·LOVDFKHTX·LOHVWSDVVpjF{WpG·XQJUDQGELHQFRPPHOH IRQWEHDXFRXSG·LPLWDWHXUVGDQVOHV0DGKKDEV(FROHVMXULGLTXHV
  43. 43. 0DLVLODXUDLWpWpSUpIpUDEOHSRXUHX[G·DSSOLTXHU WRXWKDGLWKDXWKHQWLTXHDSUqVOHGpFqVGHOHXU,PDPSDUREpLVVDQFHDX[RUGUHVGHFHGHUQLHUDUQRWUHFRQYLFWLRQj OHXUVXMHWHVWTXHV·LOVDYDLHQWYpFXOHWHPSVG·rWUHHQSUpVHQFHGHVKDGLWKVDXWKHQWLILpVDSUqVHX[LOVDXUDLHQWVDQV DXFXQGRXWHDGRSWpFHVKDGLWKVHWOHVDXUDLHQWDSSOLTXpVGHPrPHTX·LOVDXUDLHQWGpODLVVpWRXWHVOHXUVDQDORJLHVHW SDUROHVHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFFHVKDGLWKVª
  44. 44. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP /·,0$00$/,.,%1$1$64X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  45. 45. ©-HVXLVXQrWUHKXPDLQTXLSHXWVHWURPSHUFRPPHLOSHXWDYRLUMXVWH(WXGLH]GRQF PHVRSLQLRQVDGRSWH]WRXWFHTXLHVWHQDFFRUGDYHFOHRUDQHWOD6RXQQDHWUHMHWH] WRXWFHTXLHVWHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFHX[GHX[ © © ,O Q·H[LVWH SHUVRQQHDSUqV OH3URSKqWH 6$:
  46. 46. VDQVTXH VHV RSLQLRQV SXLVVHQW rWUH DFFHSWpHVRXUHMHWpHVVDXIOH3URSKqWH6$:
  47. 47. ª ,EQ:DKEDGLW© -·DLHQWHQGX0DOLNUpSRQGUHjXQHTXHVWLRQjSURSRVGXIDLWGHVH ODYHUO·HVSDFHHQWUHOHVGRLJWVGHSLHGVSHQGDQWOHVDEOXWLRQVHOXLFLUpSRQGLWFHOD Q·HVWSDVQpFHVVDLUH-·DWWHQGLVDORUVMXVTX·jFHTX·LOQHUHVWHSOXVJUDQGPRQGHDXWRXU GHOXLSXLVMHOXLGLVSRXUQRXVFHODHVWXQH6RXQQD,OPHUpSRQGLWHWTXHOOHHVW HOOH-HOXLGLV(O/DWKLEQ6D·GLEQ/XKD·DHW¶$PUXLEQ(O+DULWKP·RQWUDSSRUWp G·DSUqVD]LG LEQ ¶$PUX(O0D·DILUL G·DSUqV $EX$EGHUUDKPDQH(O+DODEL G·DSUqV (O0XVWDZULGLEQ6KDGGDG(O4RUDFKLTX·LODGLWM·DLYXOH3URSKqWH6$:
  48. 48. IURWWHU O·HVSDFHHQWUHVHVGRLJWVGHSLHGVDYHFVRQDXULFXODLUH/·,PDP0DOLNPHGLWDORUVFH KDGLWKDXQHERQQHFKDvQHGHWUDQVPLVVLRQHWMDPDLVMHQHO·DYDLVHQWHQGXDXSDUDYDQW VL FH Q·HVW DXMRXUG·KXL 3OXV WDUG M·HQWHQGLV0DOLN UpSRQGUH j FHWWH TXHVWLRQ HQ RUGRQQDQWGHVHODYHUHQWUHOHVGRLJWVGHSLHGV ª /·,0$06+$),·,4X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  49. 49. 4XDQWjO·,PDP6KDIL·LLODpWpUDSSRUWpGHOXLGHVSDUROHVSOXVQRPEUHXVHVHWSOXVEHOOHVHWFHV pOqYHVVRQWFHX[TXLOHVRQWOHSOXVPLVHVHQDSSOLFDWLRQHWVRQWGRQFSOXVIRUWXQpV3DUPLVHV SDUROHV 5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$EGLO%DUGDQV(O'MDPL· 9S
  50. 50. HW,EQ+D]PGDQV8VXOXO$KNDP 9S
  51. 51. DLQVLTXH (O)XOODQLGDQV(O,TDGKS
  52. 52. HWWHSDUROHHVWOHSOXVVRXYHQWDWWULEXpHjO·,PDP0DOLN(OOHDpWpDXWKHQWLILpHSDU$EGXO+DGLGDQV,UVKDGXV 6DOLN 9S
  53. 53. GHPrPHTX·HOOHDpWpUDSSRUWpHSDU,EQ$EGLO%DUGDQV(O'MDPL· 9S
  54. 54. ,EQ+D]PGDQV 8VXOXO$KNDP 9SHW
  55. 55. G·DSUqV(O+DNDPLEQ¶8WDEDHW0XGMDKLG7DNLXGGLQ(V6XENLO·DDXVVLUDSSRUWp GDQV(O)DWDZD 9S
  56. 56. G·DSUqV,EQ$EEDVHWHQV·pWRQQDQWGHODEHDXWpGHFHWWHSDUROHLODDMRXWp©0XGMDKLGD DSSULVFHWWHSKUDVHG·,EQ$EEDVTXH0DOLNDOXLPrPHUHSULVHGH0XGMDKLGIRUPXOHGHYHQXHFpOqEUHGHSXLV0DOLNª -·DMRXWH3XLVO·,PDP$KPDGO·DUHSULVHFRPPHO·DGLW$EX'DZXGGDQV0DVDLOXO,PDPL$KPDG S
  57. 57. © -·DL HQWHQGX$KPDGGLUHLOQ·HVWSDVXQHSHUVRQQHVDQVTXHVHVSDUROHVVRLHQWDGRSWpHVRXUHMHWpHVH[FHSWpOH3URSKqWH 6$:
  58. 58. ª 5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$EL+DWLPGDQVO·LQWURGXFWLRQGHVRQRXYUDJH(O'MDUKZDW7D·GLO S
  59. 59. ,EQ+D]PDGLW© /HVMXULVWHVHWVDYDQWVTXHO·RQLPLWHDXMRXUG·KXLLQWHUGLVHQWHX[PrPHVO·LPLWDWLRQ DYHXJOHHW O·RQWLQWHUGLWHjOHXUVpOqYHV(WOHSOXVVWULFWHjFHVXMHWHVWVDQVDXFXQGRXWHO·,PDP6KDIL·L5$
  60. 60. FDULODVpYqUHPHQW LQVLVWpVXUOHIDLWGHVXLYUHOHVKDGLWKVDXWKHQWLTXHVHWG·DFFHSWHUOHVSUHXYHVLQGXELWDEOHVLQVLVWDQFHTXHSHUVRQQH Q·DYDLWDWWHLQWHDYDQWOXL'HSOXVLOV·HVWGpVROLGDULVpGHWRXWHSHUVRQQHYRXODQWO·LPLWHUGDQVWRXWFHTX·LODGLWHWIDLW HW O·D GpFODUp SXEOLTXHPHQW4X·$OODK QRXV IDVVH SURILWHU GH OD VFLHQFH GH FHW KRPPH HWTX·,O OXL DXJPHQWH VD UpFRPSHQVHFDULODpWpODFDXVHG·XQJUDQGELHQª
  61. 61. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP ©,OQ·HVWSDVXQHSHUVRQQHVDQVTX·XQH6RXQQDGX3URSKqWHQHOXLpFKDSSHRXQHOXL SDUYLHQQH $ORUV TXHO TXH VRLW O·DYLV TXH M·pPHWV RX TXHOOH TXH VRLW OD UqJOH TXH M·pQRQFHV·LOH[LVWHXQH6RXQQDGX 3URSKqWH6$:
  62. 62. TXLFRQWUHGLWPDSDUROHLOIDXW DORUVUHYHQLUjODSDUROHGX3URSKqWH6$:
  63. 63. TXHM·DGRSWHPRLPrPH ª © /HVPXVXOPDQV VH VRQW WRXV PLV G·DFFRUG SRXU GLUH TXH WRXWH SHUVRQQH j TXL LO DSSDUDvW XQH 6RXQQD GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  64. 64. LO OXL HVW LQWHUGLW GH OD GpODLVVHU SRXU OD SDUROHG·DXWUXL ª © 6L YRXV WURXYH] GDQV PRQ OLYUH XQH FRQWUDGLFWLRQ DYHF OD6RXQQD GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  65. 65. DGRSWH]DORUVOD6RXQQDGX3URSKqWH6$:
  66. 66. HWDEDQGRQQH]PHVSDUROHV©(W GDQVXQHDXWUHYHUVLRQ©6XLYH]OD6RXQQDGX3URSKqWH6$:
  67. 67. HWQ·DFFRUGH]DSUqVHOOH DXFXQHLPSRUWDQFHDX[SDUROHVGHVKRPPHVTXHOVTX·LOVVRLHQW ª ©6LOHKDGLWKHVWDXWKHQWLTXHDORUVF·HVWPRQRSLQLRQ ª ©9RXVrWHVSOXVVDYDQWGDQVOHKDGLWKHWODFRQQDLVVDQFHGHVUDSSRUWHXUVGHKDGLWKV TXHPRL6LGRQFYRXVDYH]XQKDGLWKDXWKHQWLTXHIDLWHVOHPRLVDYRLUTXHOOHTXHVRLW 5DSSRUWpSDU(O+DNLPDYHFVDSURSUHFKDvQHGHWUDQVPLVVLRQMXVTX·jO·,PDP6KDIL·L9RLU7DULNK'LPDFKT GH,EQ $VVDNLU9KS
  68. 68. GHPrPHTXH,·ODPXO0XZDTTL·LQ G·,EQXO4DLP9S
  69. 69. (O,TDGK GH(O)XOODQL S
  70. 70. 5DSSRUWpSDU,EQXO4DLP9S
  71. 71. HW(O)XOODQLS
  72. 72. 5DSSRUWpSDU(O+DUDZLGDQV'KDPPXO.DODP 9KS
  73. 73. (O.KDWLEGDQV(O,KWLGMDGMEL6KDIL·L 9S
  74. 74. ,EQ$VVDNLU9KS
  75. 75. 1DZDZLGDQV(O0DGMPX· 9S
  76. 76. ,EQXO4DLP9S
  77. 77. (O)XOODQLS
  78. 78. /D VHFRQGHYHUVLRQHVWUDSSRUWpHSDU$EX1D·LPGDQV(O+XOLD 9S
  79. 79. 5DSSRUWpSDU1DZDZLGDQV(O0HGMPX· KD·UDQL9S
  80. 80. FLWDWLRQTX·LODHPSUXQWpj(O+DNLPHW(O%HKDTL 5DSSRUWpDXVVLSDU(O)XOODQLS
  81. 81. KD·UDQLDGLWHQFLWDQW,EQ+D]P © TXHOHKDGLWKVRLWDXWKHQWLTXHjVHVHX[ RXDX[HX[G·DXWUHVVDYDQWVª'DQVOHPrPHRUGUHG·LGpHV1DZDZLDGLW© %HDXFRXSSDUPLQRXVDXWUHV6KDIL·LWHV RQWDGRSWpFHFRPSRUWHPHQWFRPPHSRXUOHIDLWGHGLUH©ODSULqUHHVWPHLOOHXUHTXHOHVRPPHLOªORUVGXSUHPLHU DSSHOjODSULqUHGXPDWLQRXO·LQWHQWLRQFRQGLWLRQQHOOHGHSqOHULQDJHSRXUODSHUVRQQHPDODGHHWFHODHVWFRQQXGDQV OHV OLYUHV GHO·(FROH 6KDIL·LWH 3DUPL OHV VDYDQWV GH QRWUH (FROH TXL RQW GpODLVVp O·DYLV GH6KDIL·L SRXU XQKDGLWK DXWKHQWLTXHRQGpQRPEUH$EXD·NXE(O%XZDLWL$EXO4DVLP(G'DULNLHWO·,PDP(O%HKDTLVDYDQWGXKDGLWK DIILOLp j O·(FROH 6KDIL·LWH (Q RXWUH LO DYDLW XQ JURXSH SDUPL OHV SUHPLHUV DGHSWHV GH6KDIL·L TXL ORUVTX·LO pWDLW FRQIURQWp j XQ FDV MXULGLTXH j SURSRV GXTXHO LO H[LVWDLW XQKDGLWK DXWKHQWLTXH DORUV TXH O·DYLV GH6KDIL·L pWDLW HQ GpVDFFRUGDYHFFHKDGLWKDGRSWDLWOHKDGLWKHQGLVDQWO·DYLVGH6KDIL·LHVWFHTXLHVWHQDFFRUGDYHFOHKDGLWK/H KHLNK$EX¶$PUX DGLW© 6LXQ6KDIL·LWHWURXYH XQKDGLWK TXL FRQWUHGLW VRQ (FROH TX·LO YpULILH V·LO D DWWHLQW XQ QLYHDXG·,GMWLKDGWRWDORXSDUWLHOFRQFHUQDQWODTXHVWLRQ'DQVFHFDVLODOHGURLWG·DGRSWHUOHKDGLWKVDQVFRQVLGpUHU VLXQVDYDQWDYDQWOXLO·DGpMjDGRSWp3DUFRQWUHV·LOQ·DSDVDWWHLQWOHQLYHDXG·,GMWLKDGHWTX·LOQ·DUULYHSDVjWURXYHU XQHUDLVRQYDODEOHTXLOXLSHUPHWWHGHQHSDVDSSOLTXHUOHKDGLWKLODDORUVOHGURLWGHO·DSSOLTXHUVLXQVDYDQWDXWUH TXH6KDIL·LO·DDGRSWpDYDQWOXLHWFHODHVWXQHUDLVRQYDODEOHSRXUGpODLVVHUO·DYLVGHVRQ(FROHª1DZDZLFRQWLQXHHW GLW
  82. 82. FHFLHVWXQDYLVERQHWVDJHHW$OODKHVWSOXVVDYDQWª -·DMRXWHPDLVLOUHVWHXQWURLVLqPHFDVTXH,EQ6DODK$EX¶$PUX
  83. 83. Q·DSDVFLWpHWTXLHVWOHVXLYDQWVLDXFXQVDYDQW Q·DDGRSWpFHKDGLWKDYDQW OXL 7DNLXG'LQH(V6XENLDUpSRQGX jFHODGDQVVRQHVVDL([SOLFDWLRQ GXVHQV GHV SDUROHVGH6KDIL·LVLOHKDGLWKHVWDXWKHQWLTXHDORUVF·HVWPRQRSLQLRQ 9S
  84. 84. © $PHV HX[LOYDXW PLHX[ VXLYUHOHKDGLWK«HWTXHFKDFXQGHQRXVV·LPDJLQHrWUHHQIDFHGX3URSKqWH6$:
  85. 85. DXUDLWRQOHGURLWGHUHIXVHU G·DSSOLTXHU FHTX·LOQRXV GLW-HMXUH SDU$OODK TXH QRQ (W FKDFXQ GH QRXV HVW FRQWULEXDEOH HQ IRQFWLRQ GH VD FDSDFLWpª3RXUSOXVGHUHQVHLJQHPHQWVVXUODTXHVWLRQYRLU,·ODPXO0XZDTTL·LQH 9Sj
  86. 86. DLQVLTXHOHOLYUH G·(O)XOODQLQRPPp(O,TDGK WUDGXFWLRQLQWpJUDOHGXWLWUHGHFHOLYUH(YHLOGHODSHQVpHGHVJHQVFODLUYRDQWVGDQVOHIDLWGHVXLYUH OHPDvWUHFjGOH3URSKqWH6$:
  87. 87. GHV([LOpV0XKDGMLUXQ
  88. 88. HWGHV$OOLpV$QVDUV
  89. 89. HWPLVHHQJDUGHFRQWUHO·LQQRYDWLRQUpSDUWLHGDQV OHVYLOOHVHWFDPSDJQHVTXLFRQVLVWHHQO·LPLWDWLRQDYHXJOHGHV(FROHVHQFRXUDJpHSDUOHIDQDWLVPHHWODYpKpPHQFHHQWUHOHVMXULVWHVjWUDYHUV OHVJpQpUDWLRQV@FDUF·HVWXQOLYUHSUpFLHX[HWXQLTXHHQVRQJHQUHTXLGRLWrWUHpWXGLpSURIRQGpPHQWHWDYHFUpIOH[LRQ SDUWRXWHSHUVRQQHDLPDQWODYpULWp
  90. 90. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP VRQRULJLQHGH.RXIDGH%DVUDRXGX6KDPDILQTXHMHO·DGRSWHV·LOHVWDXWKHQWLTXH ª ©6·LOH[LVWHXQKDGLWKDXWKHQWLTXHFKH]OHVVDYDQWVGXKDGLWKjSURSRVG·XQHTXHVWLRQ MXULGLTXHHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFPRQDYLVDORUVM·DGRSWHOHKDGLWKGHPRQYLYDQWHWDSUqV PDPRUW ª © 6L YRXV PH YRH] GLUH XQH SDUROH DORUV TX·LO H[LVWH XQ KDGLWK DXWKHQWLTXH FRQWUHGLVDQWPDSDUROHVDFKH]TXHM·DLSHUGXODUDLVRQ ª ©6LGDQVWRXWFHTXHMHGLVLOH[LVWHXQKDGLWKDXWKHQWLTXHTXLPHFRQWUHGLWDORUVOH KDGLWKGX3URSKqWH6$:
  91. 91. HVWSOXVHQGURLWG·rWUHVXLYLQHP·LPLWH]GRQFSDV ª ©7RXWKDGLWKGX3URSKqWHHVWPRQDYLVPrPHVLYRXVQHO·DYH]SDVHQWHQGXGHPRL ª /·,0$0$+0$',%1+$1%$/4X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  92. 92. 4XDQWjO·,PDP$KPDGLOHVWFHOXLTXLDUDVVHPEOpOHSOXVGHKDGLWKVSDUPLOHVTXDWUHV,PDPVHW FHOXL TXL V· DFFURFKDLW OH SOXV j WHO SRLQW TX· © LO GpWHVWDLW TX·RQ pFULYH GHV OLYUHV EDVpV VXU OD GpGXFWLRQHWO·RSLQLRQ ª·HVWSRXUTXRLLODGLW ©1·LPLWHQLPRLQL0DOLNQL6KDIL·LQL(O$Z]D·LQL7KDZULPDLVSUHQGVG·RLOVRQW SULV ª'DQVXQHDXWUHYHUVLRQ©1·LPLWHSHUVRQQHGDQVODUHOLJLRQSDUPLFHVKRPPHV HTXLYLHQWGX3URSKqWH6$:
  93. 93. HWVHVRPSDJQRQVSUHQGVOHSXLVSUHQGVGHFHX[ TXLRQWVXLYLSDUPLOHVTXHOVWXDVOHFKRL[ª'DQVXQHDXWUHYHUVLRQ©/HVXLYLFRQVLVWH /H©YRXVªGpVLJQHLFL$KPDGLEQ+DQEDOTX·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  94. 94. pOqYHGH6KDIL·L5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$EL +DWLPGDQV$GDEX6KDIL·L S
  95. 95. $EX1D·LPGDQV(O+XOLD 9S
  96. 96. (O.KDWLE GDQV(O,KWLGMDGMEL6KDIL·L 9S
  97. 97. ,EQ$VVDNLU9KS
  98. 98. ,EQ$EGHO%DUGDQV(O,QWLTD S
  99. 99. ,EQXO'MDZ]LGDQV0DQDTLEXO,PDPL $KPDG S
  100. 100. (O+DUDZL9KS
  101. 101. G·DSUqV$EGXOODKLEQ$KPDGLEQ+DQEDOG·DSUqVVRQSqUHG·DSUqV6KDIL·L HWWHSDUROHHVWGRQFDXWKHQWLTXH·HVWSRXUTXRL,EQXO4DLPDpWpFDWpJRULTXHGDQVO·DWWULEXWLRQGHFHWWHSDUROHj O·,PDP6KDIL·LGDQV,·ODPXO0XZDTTL·LQH 9S
  102. 102. HW(O)XOODQLGDQV(O,TDGKS
  103. 103. HGHUQLHUDHQVXLWHGLWHQ FLWDQW(O%HKDTL© ·HVWSRXUFHWWHUDLVRQTXH6KDIL·LV·DSSXLHVRXYHQWVXUOHVKDGLWKVGDQVVHVDYLVMXULGLTXHVFDULO DUDVVHPEOpODVFLHQFHGHVJHQVGX+LGMD]GX6KDPGXHPHQGHO·,UDNHWDDGRSWpWRXWFHTXLpWDLWDXWKHQWLTXH VDQVDXFXQIDYRULWLVPHRXSHQFKDQWGHVDSDUWSRXUFHTXHOHVVDYDQWVGHVDUpJLRQDYDLHQWO·KDELWXGHGHGLUHWDQW TXHODYpULWpOXLDSSDUDLVVDLWDLOOHXUV$ORUVTXHG·DXWUHVDYDQWOXLDYDLHQWO·KDELWXGHGHVHOLPLWHUDX[DYLVGHVVDYDQWV GHOHXUUpJLRQVDQVFKHUFKHUjVDYRLUVLO·DYLVG·DXWUHVVDYDQWVpWDLWSHXWrWUHSOXVMXVWH4X·$OODKQRXVSDUGRQQHHW OHXUSDUGRQQHª 5DSSRUWp SDU $EX 1D·LP GDQV (O+XOLD 9 S
  104. 104. (O+DUDZL 9 S
  105. 105. ,EQXO4DLP GDQV ,·ODPXO 0XZDTTL·LQH 9S
  106. 106. (O)XOODQLS
  107. 107. 5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$EL+DWLPGDQV(O$GDE S
  108. 108. HW$EXO4DVLP(V6DPDUNDQGLGDQV(O$PDOLDLQVLTXH$EX +DIV(O0XDGGLEGDQV(O0XQWDTDPLQ(O$PDOL 9 S
  109. 109. $EX1D·LP 9 S
  110. 110. ,EQ$VVDNLU 9K S
  111. 111. DYHFXQHFKDvQHGHWUDQVPLVVLRQDXWKHQWLTXH 5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$EL+DWLP$EX1D·LPHW,EQ$VVDNLU9KS
  112. 112. 5DSSRUWpSDU,EQ$EL+DWLPS
  113. 113. ,EQXO'MDZ]LGDQV(O0DQDTLES
  114. 114. (O)XOODQLS
  115. 115. ,EQXO4DLPGDQV(O,·ODP 9S
  116. 116. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP jVXLYUHWRXWFHTXLYLHQWGX3URSKqWH6$:
  117. 117. HWVHVRPSDJQRQVDSUqVHX[RQDOH FKRL[SDUPLOHV6XLYDQWV ª ©/·RSLQLRQGH(O$Z]D·L O·RSLQLRQGH0DOLN O·RSLQLRQ GH$EX+DQLIDQH VRQW TXH GHVRSLQLRQVTXLVRQWpJDOHVjPHVHX[PDLVODSUHXYHUpVLGHGDQVOHVKDGLWKV ª ©HOXLTXLUHMHWWHXQKDGLWKGX3URSKqWH6$:
  118. 118. HVWDXERUGGHODSHUGLWLRQ ª 9RLOj GRQF OHV SDUROHV GHV TXDWUH,PDPV TX·$OODK OHV DJUpH
  119. 119. HQ FH TXL FRQFHUQH O·RUGUH TX·LOVRQWGRQQpGHV·DFFURFKHUDX[KDGLWKVHWOHXULQWHUGLFWLRQ GH OHV LPLWHU DYHXJOpPHQWVDQV UpIOpFKLUHVSDUROHVVRQWWHOOHPHQWFODLUHVTX·HOOHVQHSHXYHQWDFFHSWHUTXHOTXHFRQWHVWDWLRQRX LQWHUSUpWDWLRQ 3DUWDQWGHFHODXQHSHUVRQQHTXLV·DFFURFKHjWRXWFHTXLHVWDXWKHQWLTXHGDQVOD6RXQQD GX3URSKqWH6$:
  120. 120. PrPHVLF·HVWHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFOHVDYLVGHVTXDWUH,PDPVQHVHUDSDVVRUWL GH OHXU pFROH QL QH OHV DXUD FRQWUHGLW ELHQ DX FRQWUDLUH ,O VHUD FHOXL TXL OHV VXLW OH SOXV ILGqOHPHQWHWVHVHUDDFFURFKpjO·DQVHIHUPHHWLQGLVVRFLDEOH(O¶8UZDWXO:XWKTk@ 7DQGLVTXHFHOXLTXLGpODLVVHXQH6RXQQDDXWKHQWLTXHFDUHOOHHVWHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFOHVDYLV GHV ,PDPV FHOXLOj HQ IDLW OHXU D GpVREpL HW D FRQWUHGLW OHXUV SDUROHV FLWpHV SOXV KDXW DORUV TX·$OODK6:7
  121. 121. GLW©1RQ3DUWRQ6HLJQHXU,OVQHVHURQWSDVSDUIDLWHPHQWFURDQWWDQW TX·LOVQHWHSUHQGURQWSDVFRPPHMXJHGHOHXUVGLIIpUHQWVHWTX·HQVXLWHLOVQHUHVVHQWHQW DXFXQH GpFRQYHQXH HQ OHXU IRU LQWpULHXU j SURSRV GH WD GpFLVLRQ HW WDQW TX·LOV QH VH VRXPHWWURQW SDV WRWDOHPHQW ª 6RXUDWH YHUVHW
  122. 122. $OODK GLW DXVVL ©4XH SUHQQH JDUGH FHX[ TXL VRQW HQ GpVDFFRUG DYHF VHV RUGUHV SHXWrWUH $OODK OHXU IHUDWLO VXELU XQH pSUHXYHRXXQFKkWLPHQWGRXORXUHX[ª 6RXUDWHYHUVHW
  123. 123. (O+DILGKLEQ5DGMDEDGLW©,OHVWREOLJDWRLUHSRXUWRXWHSHUVRQQHjTXLHVWSDUYHQXXQ KDGLWKGX3URSKqWH6$:
  124. 124. GRQWLODFRPSULVOHVHQVGHOHIDLUHVDYRLUjODFRPPXQDXWpGHOD FRQVHLOOHUGHO·DSSOLTXHUHWGHOHXURUGRQQHUGHVXLYUHO·RUGUHGX3URSKqWH6$:
  125. 125. PrPHV·LOHVW HQGpVDFFRUGDYHFXQJUDQG,PDPUHVSHFWpGHFHWWHFRPPXQDXWpFDUO·RUGUHGX3URSKqWH6$:
  126. 126. HVW SOXV HQ GURLW G·rWUH UHVSHFWp HW VXLYL TXH O·RSLQLRQ GH WRXW JUDQG 6DYDQW HQ GpVDFFRUG LQYRORQWDLUHPHQW
  127. 127. DYHF O·RUGUH GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  128. 128. GDQV FHUWDLQHV FKRVHV ·HVW SRXUTXRL EHDXFRXS GH RPSDJQRQV DLQVL TXH OD JpQpUDWLRQ GHV 6XLYDQWV RQW UHMHWp WRXWH SHUVRQQH FRQWUHGLVDQW XQ KDGLWK DXWKHQWLTXH HW SDUIRLV PrPH RQW pWp GXUV GDQV OH UHMHW QRQ SDV SDU $EX'DZXGGDQV0DVDLOXO,PDPL$KPDG S
  129. 129. ,EQ$EGLO%DUGDQV(O'MDPL· 9S
  130. 130. ,EQXO'MDZ]LS
  131. 131. 0rPHVLFHODYDjO·HQFRQWUHGHOHXUSDUHQWVRXVDYDQWVFRPPHO·DUDSSRUWp7DKDZLGDQV6KDUKX0D·DQLO$WKDU 9S
  132. 132. HW$EXD·ODGDQVVRQ0XVQDG 9S
  133. 133. DYHFXQHFKDvQHGHWUDQVPLVVLRQGRQWOHVUDSSRUWHXUVVRQW GLJQHVGHFRQILDQFHG·DSUqV6DOLPLEQ$EGDOODKLEQ8PDUTX·LODGLW © -·pWDLVDVVLVDYHF,EQ8PDU4X·$OODKO·DJUpH
  134. 134. GDQVODPRVTXpHORUVTX·XQKRPPHRULJLQDLUHGX6KDPO·DTXHVWLRQQpjSURSRVGXUHSRVWDPDWWX·@HQWUHOD¶8PUDHWOH +DGM,EQ8PDUGLWDORUVF·HVWXQHERQQHHWEHOOHFKRVH/·KRPPHUpWRUTXDPDLVWRQSqUHFjG8PDULEQ(O .KDWWDE@LQWHUGLVDLWFHOD,EQ8PDUUpSRQGLW0DOKHXUjWRL6LPRQSqUHO·DLQWHUGLWHWTXHOH3URSKqWH6$:
  135. 135. O·DIDLW HW RUGRQQp SUHQGVWX O·RSLQLRQ GHPRQ SqUH RX O·RUGUH GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  136. 136. ,O UpSRQGLW O·RUGUH GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  137. 137. ,EQ8PDUOXLGLWDORUVDORUVYDWHQPDLQWHQDQWª5DSSRUWpSDU$KPDGKDGLWKQƒ
  138. 138. HW7LUPLGKL9 SDYHF6KDUKXW7XKID
  139. 139. HWLOO·DDXWKHQWLILp,EQ$VVDNLUDDXVVLUDSSRUWp9KS
  140. 140. OHUpFLWVXLYDQWG·DSUqV ,EQ$EL'KL·ETX·LODGLW © 8QMRXU6D·GLEQ,EUDKLPOHILOVGH$EGHUUDKDPDQHLEQ¶$ZI
  141. 141. jUpSRQGXjODTXHVWLRQ G·XQ KRPPH VHORQ O·DYLV GH5DEL·DLEQ$EGHUUDKPDQH -H FjGLEQ$EL'KL·E
  142. 142. O·LQIRUPDL DORUV G·XQKDGLWK GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  143. 143. FRQWUHGLVDQW FHWWH RSLQLRQ6D·G GLW DORUV j5DEL·D YRLFLLEQ$EL'KL·E TXL HVW jPHV HX[ XQ KRPPHGHFRQILDQFHTXLYLHQWGHP·LQIRUPHUG·XQKDGLWKGX3URSKqWH6$:
  144. 144. TXLFRQWUHGLWWRQRSLQLRQ5DEL·DOXL GLWDORUVWXDVIDLVWRQ,GMWLKDGHWWRQMXJHPHQWHVWSDVVp6D·GV·pFULD·HVWLQFURDEOH-·DSSOLTXHOHMXJHPHQWGH 6D·GVDQVDSSOLTXHUFHOXLGX3URSKqWH6$:
  145. 145. (WELHQQRQ-HUHMHWWHSOXW{WOHMXJHPHQWGH 6D·GHWM·DSSOLTXHFHOXLGX
  146. 146. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP KDLQH FRQWUH OD SHUVRQQH ELHQ DX FRQWUDLUH HWWH SHUVRQQH SHXW rWUH FKqUH j OHXU F±XU HW UHVSHFWpHGDQVOHXUFRQVFLHQFHPDLVOH3URSKqWH6$:
  147. 147. HVWSOXVFKHUjOHXUF±XUHWVRQRUGUHHVW DXGHVVXVGHO·RUGUHGHWRXWHFUpDWXUH6LGRQFO·RUGUHGX3URSKqWH6$:
  148. 148. HWO·RUGUHG·8QWHOVH FRQWUHGLVHQW O·RUGUHGX3URSKqWH 6$:
  149. 149. HVW SOXV jPrPH G·rWUH PLV HQ DYDQWHW VXLYL HW FHOD Q·HPSrFKHSDVGHUHVSHFWHUFHOXLTXLDpPLVXQDYLVLQYRORQWDLUHPHQWHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFO·RUGUH GX3URSKqWH6$:
  150. 150. FDUFHOD OXLHVWSDUGRQQp0LHX[ HQFRUH FH VDYDQWHQ GpVDFFRUGDYHF OH KDGLWKSDUHUUHXUQ·DXUDLWHXDXFXQHUDQF±XUTX·RQ QHOXLVXLYH SDV V·LO OXL pWDLW DSSDUX TXH OH KDGLWKGX3URSKqWH6$:
  151. 151. OHFRQWUHGLVDLW© -·DMRXWH FRPPHQW OHV ,PDPV SRXUUDLHQWLOV HQ DYRLU TXHOTXH UDQF±XU DORUV TX·LOV O·RQW RUGRQQpjOHXUVpOqYHVFRPPHYXSOXVKDXWHWOHVRQWREOLJpVjGpODLVVHUOHXUVGLUHVV·LOVVRQWHQ GpVDFFRUG DYHF OD 6RXQQD /·,PDP 6KDIL·L HVW PrPH DOOp MXVTX·j RUGRQQHU j VHV pOqYHV HW GLVFLSOHV GH FRQVLGpUHU OHV SDUROHV GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  152. 152. FRPPH VHV DYLV MXULGLTXHV PrPH V·LO 6KDIL·L
  153. 153. QHOHVDYDLHQWSDVGLWVRXTX·LODYDLWMXJpGHIDoRQGLIIpUHQWH·HVWODUDLVRQSRXUODTXHOOH OH6DYDQW,EQ'DTLT(O,GORUVTX·LODUDVVHPEOpWRXWHVOHVTXHVWLRQVVXUOHVTXHOOHVFKDFXQHGHV TXDWUHpFROHVpWDLWHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFOHVKDGLWKVDXWKHQWLTXHVGDQVXQVHXOJURVYROXPHGLW©/H IDLW G·DWWULEXHU VHV MXJHPHQWV DX[ ,PDPV HVW LQWHUGLW KDUDP
  154. 154. LO HVW GRQF REOLJDWRLUH SRXU OHV MXULVWHVLPLWDWHXUVGHOHVFRQQDvWUHDILQGHQHSDVOHVOHXUDWWULEXHUFDUFHVHUDLWXQPHQVRQJHj OHXUVXMHW ª 48(/48(6(;(03/(6'(6$9$176$$17 '(/$,66(/ $9,6'(/(85(2/(328568,95( /$62811$ 3RXUWRXWHVOHVUDLVRQVFLWpHVSOXVKDXWGHVVDYDQWVGHGLIIpUHQWHVpFROHV³©8QJUDQG QRPEUHSDUPLOHVSUHPLHUVXQSHWLWQRPEUHSDUPLOHVGHUQLHUVªVRXUDWHYHUVHW
  155. 155. ³QHVXLYDLHQWSDVOHXUV,PDPVGDQVWRXWFHTX·LOVpPHWWDLHQWFRPPHRSLQLRQVLOVHQRQWPrPH GpODLVVpEHDXFRXSORUVTX·LOOHXUDSSDUDLVVDLWTX·HOOHVpWDLHQWHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFOD6RXQQD$WHO SRLQWTXHOHVGHX[JUDQGVVDYDQWV+DQDILWHVpOqYHVGH$EX+DQLID0XKDPPDGLEQXO+DVVDQHW $EXXVVXI4X·$OODKOHXUIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  156. 156. RQWpWpHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFOHXUKHLNKVXUHQYLURQ XQWLHUVGHWRXWHVVHVRSLQLRQVMXULGLTXHVHWOHVOLYUHVGHMXULVSUXGHQFHKDQDILWHVRQWDXWDQWGH SUHXYHVVXUODYpUDFLWpGHFHVSURSRV,OSHXWrWUHGLWODPrPHFKRVHGHO·,PDP(O0X]QL HWELHQ G·DXWUHVSDUPLOHVpOqYHVGH6KDIL·LRXG·DXWUHV ,PDPV HW V·LO IDOODLW GRQQHU GHV H[HPSOHV SRXU 3URSKqWH6$:
  157. 157. 6D·GGHPDQGDDORUVOHPDQXVFULWVXUOHTXHOVRQRSLQLRQDYDLWpWppFULWHOHGpFKLUDHWMXJHDVHORQOH KDGLWKª 1RQVHXOHPHQWHVWLOSDUGRQQpPDLVHQSOXVLOHVWUpFRPSHQVpVHORQOHKDGLWKDXWKHQWLTXHUDSSRUWpSDU%XNKDULHW 0XVOLPHWG·DXWUHV © /RUVTX·XQHSHUVRQQHG·DXWRULWp6DYDQWRXJRXYHUQHXU
  158. 158. IDLWXQHIIRUWGHUHFKHUFKHpPHWXQDYLVHWTX·LOWURXYH MXVWHLODXUDGHX[UpFRPSHQVHV6·LOVHWURPSHLOQ·HQDXUDTX·XQHª (FULWSDU,EQ5DGMDEGDQVO·H[SOLFDWLRQGXOLYUHG·(O)XOODQL,TDGKXO+LPHPS
  159. 159. (O)XOODQLS
  160. 160. ,EQ$ELGLQHGDQV(O+DFKLD 9 S
  161. 161. DWWULEXp j(O.DQDZL GDQV(Q1DIL·XO.DELU S
  162. 162. GH$EX+DPLG(O *KD]DOL /·,PDP(O0X]QLDGLWDXGpEXWGHVRQUpVXPpGHMXULVSUXGHQFH6KDIL·LWH²TXLVHWURXYHHQPDUJHGH.LWDEXO 8PP GH6KDIL·L²ODFKRVHVXLYDQWH©-·DLUpVXPpFHOLYUHWLUpGHODVFLHQFHGHO·,PDP0XKDPPDG,EQ,GULVV6KDIL·L 4X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  163. 163. HWGXVHQVGHVHVSURSRVDILQGHOHIDFLOLWHUjTXLYHXWO·DSSUHQGUHV·LOYHXWO·pWXGLHU SRXUVDUHOLJLRQHWVHSURWpJHUGHVHUUHXUVWRXWHQVDFKDQWTXHO·,PDP6KDIL·LDLQWHUGLWGHO·LPLWHURXG·LPLWHUXQ DXWUHTXHOXLª
  164. 164. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP FKDFXQG·HX[FHVHUDLW G·XQHORQJXHXUH[FHVVLYHHWQRXVVRUWLULRQVDORUVGHQRWUHEXWTXLHVW G·rWUH EUHI GDQV FHWWH UHFKHUFKH ·HVW SRXUTXRL QRXV QRXV FRQWHQWHURQV GH GHX[ H[HPSOHV VHXOHPHQW /·,PDP0XKDPPDG LEQXO+DVVDQ D GLW GDQV VRQ0XZDWWD S
  165. 165. © 4XDQW j $EX +DQLID4X·$OODKO·DJUpH
  166. 166. LOMXJHDLWTX·LOQ·DYDLWSDVGHSULqUHORUVTXHO·RQLQYRTXDLW$OODKSRXU TX·LOIDVVHGHVFHQGUHODSOXLH4XDQWjQRXVQRXVMXJHRQVTXHO·,PDPGRLWGLULJHUXQHSULqUHGH GHX[LQFOLQDLVRQVSXLVLQYRTXH$OODKHQUHWRXUQDQWVRQPDQWHDXª ¶,VDPLEQXVXI(O%DODNKLpWDLWSDUPLOHVSURFKHVGHO·,PDP0XKDPPDGLEQXO+DVVDQ HW SDUPL OHV ILGqOHV GH O·,PDP $EX XVXI © ,O OXL DUULYDLW VRXYHQW GH MXJHU VHORQ XQ DYLV FRQWUDLUHj$EX+DQLIDFDUFHGHUQLHUQHFRQQDLVVDLWSDVODSUHXYHGDOLO
  167. 167. 4XDQWj¶,VDPLOMXJHDLW GLIIpUHPPHQWORUVTX·XQHSUHXYHSXLVVDQWHG·XQDXWUH,PDPOXLSDUYHQDLW ª·HVWSRXUTXRL©LO OHYDLW OHV PDLQV DYDQW O·LQFOLQDLVRQ HW ORUVTX·LO V·HQ UHOHYDLW ª FRPPH FHOD HVW FRQQX GDQV OD 6RXQQDVHORQGHVGL]DLQHVGHFKDvQHVGHWUDQVPLVVLRQGLIIpUHQWHVDXWKHQWLTXHVMXVTX·DX3URSKqWH 6$:
  168. 168. (WOHIDLWTXHVHVWURLV0DvWUHV$EX+DQLID0XKDPPDGLEQXO+DVVDQ$EXXVXI
  169. 169. DLHQW MXJp GLIIpUHPPHQW GH OD 6RXQQD QH O·D SDV HPSrFKp GH O·DSSOLTXpH« HW F·HVW DLQVL TXH WRXW PXVXOPDQGRLWrWUHDSSXpSDUOHVSDUROHVGHVTXDWUH,PDPVHWG·DXWUHVFRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVYX )$8;$5*80(176(75(3216(6 9RLOjGRQFFHTXHM·DYDLVpFULWLODGHFHODGL[DQVHQLQWURGXFWLRQjFHOLYUH6LIDW6DODW(Q 1DEL@,OQRXVHVWDSSDUXGDQVFHODSVGHWHPSVTXHFHWWHLQWURGXFWLRQDHXGHV FRQVpTXHQFHV EpQpILTXHV GDQV OHV UDQJV GH OD MHXQHVVHPXVXOPDQH FDU HOOH OHV D GLULJpV YHUV OD QpFHVVLWp GH UHWRXUQHUjODVRXUFHSXUHGHO·,VODPTXHVRQWOHRUDQHWOD6RXQQDGDQVWRXWFHTXLFRQFHUQH OHXUUHOLJLRQHWOHXUDGRUDWLRQDUOHQRPEUHGHMHXQHVDSSOLTXDQWOD6RXQQDHWDGRUDQW$OODKj WUDYHUVHOOHQ·DFHVVpG·DXJPHQWHU²/DORXDQJHHVWj$OODK²jWHOSRLQWTX·LOVVRQWDXMRXUG·KXL UHFRQQXVSRXUFHOD ,OHVWFODLUHPHQWPRQWUpGDQVFHWRXYUDJHTXHO·,PDP0XKDPPDGDpWpHQGpVDFFRUGDYHF$EX+DQLIDVXUSOXVGH YLQJWTXHVWLRQVTXHQRXVpQXPpURQVLFL 9RLU(W7D·OLTXO0XILG TXLHVWO·H[SOLFDWLRQGX0XZDWWDGHO·,PDP0XKDPPDG ,EQ¶$ELGLQHGDQV(O+DFKLD 9 S
  170. 170. HW5DVPXO0XIWL 9 S
  171. 171. (O.XUDFKL GDQV(O'MDZDKLUXO0XGLD IL 7DEDTDWLO+DQDILD S
  172. 172. HQGLVDQW©·pWDLWXQKRPPHGHFRQILDQFHFRQQDLVVDQWODVFLHQFHGXKDGLWK/XLHWVRQ IUqUH,EUDKLPpWDLHQWOHVGHX[SOXVJUDQGVKHLNKVGH%DONKHQOHXUWHPSVª 9RLU(O)DZD·LGXO%DKLDIL7DUDGMXPLO+DQDILD S
  173. 173. 9RLU(O%DKUX5DwT 9S
  174. 174. HW5DVPXO0XIWL 9S
  175. 175. 9RLU(O)DZDLG S
  176. 176. GRQWO·DXWHXUDGLWWUqVMXVWHPHQW©3DUWDQWGHFHODLODSSDUDvWFODLUHPHQWODIDXVVHWpGHOD SDUROHGH0DNKXO TX·LODWWULEXH j$EX+DQLID ©HOXLTXLOqYHOHVPDLQV SHQGDQW OD SULqUH VD SULqUH HVW DQQXOpHª SDUROHSDUODTXHOOH(O$PLU.DWLE(O$WTDQLV·HVWODLVVpDEXVpFRPPHRQOHYRLWGDQVVDELRJUDSKLH(QHIIHW,¶VDP LEQXVXI IDLVDLW SDUWLH GHV GLVFLSOHV DVVLGXV GH$EXXVXI GHYDQW OHTXHO LO OHYDLW OHV PDLQV SHQGDQW OD SULqUH 6L HIIHFWLYHPHQWODSDUROHDWWULEXpHj$EX+DQLIDV·DYpUDLWDYRLUHXTXHOTXHDXWKHQWLFLWp$EXXVXIHW¶,VDPO·DXUDLHQW VX2QSHXWHQGpGXLUHDXVVLTXHVLXQ+DQDILWHGpODLVVHO·RSLQLRQGHO·,PDPjFDXVHGHODSXLVVDQFHGHODSUHXYHG·XQ DXWUH,PDPFHODQHOHIDLWSDVVRUWLUGHO·(FROH+DQDILWHELHQDXFRQWUDLUH/HIDLWGHGpODLVVHUO·LPLWDWLRQSRXUXQH SUHXYHSXLVVDQWHQ·HVWTXHILGpOLWpjO·,PDP«QHYRLVWXSDVTXH¶,VDPLEQXVXIDGpODLVVpO·DYLVGH$EX+DQLID GDQVOHIDLWGHQHSDVOHYHUOHVPDLQVSHQGDQWODSULqUHHWTXHPDOJUpFHODLOHVWTXDQGPrPHFRQVLGpUpFRPPHXQ KDQDILWH (W MHPH SODLQV DXSUqV G·$OODK FRQWUH OHV LJQRUDQWV GH QRWUH pSRTXH TXL FULWLTXHQW FHOXL TXL GpODLVVH O·LPLWDWLRQGHVRQ,PDPVXUXQHTXHVWLRQHQUDLVRQG·XQHSUHXYHSXLVVDQWHMXVTX·jOHIDLUHVRUWLUGH O·(FROHjODTXHOOH LODSSDUWLHQW0DLVFHODQ·HVWSDVpWRQQDQWGHOHXUSDUWFDULOVIRQWSDUWLHGHODSRSXODFH«OHSOXVpWRQQDQWHVWTXDQG FHODpPDQHGHSHUVRQQHVYRXODQWUHVVHPEOHUDX[VDYDQWVPDLVTXLHQIDLWOHVLPLWHQWFRPPHGXEpWDLOª
  177. 177. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP HSHQGDQWM·DLUHVVHQWLFKH]TXHOTXHVXQVSDUPLHX[XQHFHUWDLQHUpWLFHQFHTXDQWDXIDLWGH V·pODQFHUGDQVVRQDSSOLFDWLRQ1RQSDUFHTX·LOVGRXWHQWGHODQpFHVVLWpGHO·DSSOLTXHUDSUqVWRXWHV OHVSUHXYHVFLWpHVWLUpHVGHVYHUVHWVGXRUDQHWGHVSDUROHVGHV,PDPVRUGRQQDQWGHUHYHQLUjOD 6RXQQD PDLV j FDXVH G·DUJXPHQWV VSpFLHX[ HW IDOODFLHX[ TX·LOV HQWHQGHQW GH FHUWDLQV KHLNKV LPLWDWHXUV·HVWSRXUTXRLM·DLUHVVHQWLODQpFHVVLWpGHFLWHUFHVDUJXPHQWVHWG·UpSRQGUHSHXW rWUH TXH FHWWH SDUWLH GH OD MHXQHVVH V·pODQFHUD GDQV O·DSSOLFDWLRQ GH OD 6RXQQD DYHF FHX[ TXL O·DSSOLTXHQWGpMjDILQG·DSSDUWHQLUDX*URXSH6DXYpVL$OODKOHYHXW 3UHPLHUIDX[DUJXPHQW HUWDLQVGLVHQW©LOQ·DDXFXQGRXWHVXUOHIDLWTXHUHYHQLUjOD7UDGLWLRQGX3URSKqWH 6$:
  178. 178. GDQVWRXWFHTXLFRQFHUQHQRWUHUHOLJLRQHVWXQHFKRVHREOLJDWRLUHVXUWRXWjSURSRVGHV DGRUDWLRQVSXUHVVXUOHVTXHOOHVODUDLVRQHWO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQQ·RQWSDVSULVHFDUFHVDGRUDWLRQVVRQW VRXVGpFUHWGLYLQ7DZTLILD
  179. 179. FRPPHODSULqUHSDUH[HPSOHHSHQGDQWQRXVQ·HQWHQGRQVDXFXQ GHV KHLNKV LPLWDWHXUV GHV TXDWUH (FROHV RUGRQQHU FHOD ELHQ DX FRQWUDLUH ,OV UHFRQQDLVVHQW SOXW{WODGLYHUJHQFHHWLOVSUpWHQGHQWTXHF·HVWXQHIDFLOLWpSRXUODFRPPXQDXWpHWLOVDSSXLHQW OHXUVGLUHVSDUXQKDGLWKTX·LOVQHFHVVHQWGHUpSpWHUGDQVFHJHQUHG·RFFDVLRQVHQUpSRQVHDX[ GpIHQVHXUVGHOD6RXQQD©/DGLYHUJHQFHGHPDFRPPXQDXWpHVWXQHPLVpULFRUGH©,OQRXVDSSDUDvWGRQF TXH FH KDGLWK FRQWUHGLW ODPpWKRGHj ODTXHOOH YRXV DSSHOH]PpWKRGHj SDUWLU GH ODTXHOOH YRXV DYH]SXEOLpYRVOLYUHVHWOD'HVFULSWLRQGHODSULqUHGX3URSKqWH6$:
  180. 180. HQSDUWLFXOLHU4XHOHVW GRQFYRWUHUpSRQVHjSURSRVGHFHKDGLWKª -HUpSRQGUDLjODTXHVWLRQHQGHX[pWDSHV /DSUHPLqUH HVWTXHOHKDGLWKQ·HVWSDVDXWKHQWLTXHLOHVWPrPHIDX[HWQ·DDXFXQHVRXUFH /·,PDP(V6XENL D GLW © -H QH OXL DL WURXYp DXFXQH FKDvQH GH WUDQVPLVVLRQ IDLEOH RX PrPH LQYHQWp©0DLVLODpWpUDSSRUWpVRXVODIRUPH©/DGLYHUJHQFHGHPHVRPSDJQRQVHVWSRXUYRXVXQH PLVpULFRUGH©©0HVRPSDJQRQVVRQWFRPPHGHVpWRLOHV6XLYH]Q·LPSRUWHOHTXHOG·HQWUHHX[HWYRXVVHUH]JXLGpV ©HSHQGDQWDXFXQHGHVGHX[YHUVLRQVQ·HVWDXWKHQWLTXH/DSUHPLqUHHVWWUqVIDLEOHO·DXWUHHVW IRUJpH GH WRXWHV SLqFHV -·DL GpYHORSSp FHOD GDQV 6LOVLODWXO$KDGLWK (G'D·LIDWL ZDO 0DZGX·D Qƒ
  181. 181. /DVHFRQGH HVWTXHOHKDGLWKHQSOXVGHVDIDLEOHVVH HVWHQ FRQWUDGLFWLRQ DYHFOH 6DLQW RUDQFDUOHVYHUVHWVFRQFHUQDQWO·LQWHUGLFWLRQGHGLYHUJHUGDQVODUHOLJLRQHWO·RUGUHGHVHPHWWUH G·DFFRUGjVRQVXMHWVRQWWHOOHPHQWFRQQXVTX·RQSRXUUDLWVHSDVVHUGHOHVFLWHU0DLVLOQ·DSDV GHPDOjHQUDSSHOHUTXHOTXHVXQVFRPPHH[HPSOHV$OODKGLW©(WQHGLYHUJH]SDVFDUYRXV SHUGULH]FRXUDJHHWYRWUHDUGHXUV·HQLUDLWjMDPDLV©6RXUDWHYHUVHW
  182. 182. (W,OGLWDXVVL© (WQHVRH]SDVSDUPLOHVDVVRFLDWHXUV3DUPLFHX[TXLVHVRQWGLYLVpVGDQVODUHOLJLRQ MXVTX·jrWUHSOXVLHXUVFODQVFKDTXHSDUWLpWDQWFRQWHQWGHFHTX·LOD©6RXUDWHYHUVHWV
  183. 183. 'DQV XQ DXWUH YHUVHW © (W LOV QH FHVVHURQW GH GLYHUJHU VDXI FHX[ j TXL $OODK DFFRUGHVD0LVpULFRUGH© 6RXUDWHYHUVHWV
  184. 184. 0DLVVLGRQF$OODKIDLWPLVpULFRUGHj FHX[TXLQHGLYHUJHQWSDV²FDUVHVRQWOHVJHQVGX)DX[TXLGLYHUJHQW²FRPPHQWSHXWLOrWUH UDLVRQQDEOHGHSHQVHUTXHODGLYHUJHQFHHVWXQHPLVpULFRUGH2QYRLWGRQFELHQTXHFHKDGLWK Q·HVWSDVDXWKHQWLTXHQLGDQVVDFKDvQHGHWUDQVPLVVLRQQLGDQVVRQWH[WHOXLPrPH$SDUWLUGH OjLOQ·HVWSDVSHUPLVGHOHSUHQGUHFRPPHDUJXPHQWSRXUQHSDVDSSOLTXHUOHRUDQHWOD6RXQQD FRPPHO·RQWRUGRQQpOHV,PDPV 9RLU6LOVLODWXO$KDGLWKL(G'D·LIDWLZDO0DZGX·D
  185. 185. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP 6HFRQGIDX[DUJXPHQW ' DXWUHVRQWGLWVLODGLYHUJHQFHGDQVODUHOLJLRQQ·HVWSDVSHUPLVHFRPPHQWH[SOLTXH] YRXVDORUVODGLYHUJHQFHGHVRPSDJQRQVHWGHV,PDPV DSUqV HX[(W DWLOXQH GLIIpUHQFH HQWUHOHXUGLYHUJHQFHHWFHOOHGHFHUWDLQVFRQWHPSRUDLQV 5pSRQVH RXL LO D XQH JUDQGH GLIIpUHQFH HQWUH OHV GHX[ GLYHUJHQFHV HW FH VXU GHX[ SRLQWV/HSUHPLHUODFDXVHOHVHFRQGODFRQVpTXHQFH 3RXUFHTXLHVWGHODGLYHUJHQFHGHVRPSDJQRQVHOOHpWDLWQpFHVVDLUHHWQDWXUHOOHGDQVOD FRPSUpKHQVLRQ QRQ SDV SDU LQWHQWLRQ YRORQWDLUH GH GLYHUJHQFH$MRXWRQV j FHOD TX·LO H[LVWDLW G·DXWUHV FRQGLWLRQV j OHXU pSRTXH TXL RQW HX SRXU FRQVpTXHQFH QpFHVVDLUH OHXU GLYHUJHQFH FRQGLWLRQVTXLRQWGLVSDUXHVSDUODVXLWH(QRXWUHRQQHSHXWVHGpEDUUDVVHUWRWDOHPHQWGHFH JHQUHGHGLYHUJHQFHHWOHVSHUVRQQHVGLYHUJHDQWGHODVRUWHQHIRQWSDVSDUWLHGHFHX[TX·$OODKD EOkPpVGDQVOHVYHUVHWVSUpFpGHQWVFDUODFRQGLWLRQGHEOkPHQ·DSDVpWpUHPSOLHjVDYRLUOHIDLW GHGLYHUJHUYRORQWDLUHPHQWHWFRQVFLHPPHQW4XDQWjODGLYHUJHQFHGHVLPLWDWHXUVHOOHQHSHXW rWUHH[FXVpHGDQVODSOXSDUWGHVFDVFDULOHQHVWFHUWDLQVSDUPLHX[jTXLLODSSDUDvWODSUHXYHGX RUDQ HW GH OD 6RXQQD PDLV FHWWH SUHXYH DSSXLH O·RSLQLRQ GH O·DXWUH (FROH j ODTXHOOH LOV Q·DSSDUWLHQQHQWSDV,OVGpODLVVHQWDORUVFHWWHSUHXYHSRXUODVHXOHUDLVRQTX·HOOHHVWHQGpVDFFRUG DYHF OHXU (FROH FRPPH VL O·(FROH pWDLW OH IRQGHPHQW RX OD UHOLJLRQ DYHF ODTXHOOH OH 3URSKqWH 6$:
  186. 186. DpWpHQYRpHWO·DXWUH(FROHXQHDXWUHUHOLJLRQDEURJpH« '·DXWUHV SDUPL HX[ VRQW j O·RSSRVp GH FHOD FDU LOV FRQVLGqUHQW FHV (FROHV ²PDOJUp OHV JUDQGHVGLIIpUHQFHVHQWUHHOOHV²FRPPHDXWDQWGHGRJPHVUpYpOpVGLIIpUHQWVFRPPHO·DGpFODUp XQGHOHXUVFRQWHPSRUDLQV© LOQ·DSDVGHPDOjFHTXHOHPXVXOPDQSUHQQHO·DYLVGHQ·LPSRUWH TXHOOH(FROHHWGpODLVVHO·DYLVGHQ·LPSRUWHTXHOOH(FROHFDUFKDFXQHG·HOOHIDLWSDUWLHGHODUHOLJLRQ UpYpOpH ª(WLOVHSHXWTX·LOVVHEDVHQWVXUOHKDGLWKIDX[©/DGLYHUJHQFHGHPDFRPPXQDXWpHVWXQH PLVpULFRUGH ª DILQ G·pWDHU OHXU DUJXPHQWDWLRQ HW FRPELHQ GH IRLV OHV DYRQV QRXV HQWHQGXV OH FODPHUKDXWHWIRUW« 3DUPL HX[ FHUWDLQV H[SOLTXHURQW FH KDGLWK SDU OH IDLW TXHPLVpULFRUGH VLJQLILH IDFLOLWp HW VRXSOHVVH SRXU OD FRPPXQDXWp (WPDOJUp OH IDLW TXH FHW DUJXPHQW HVW GDQV WRXV OHV FDV HQ FRQWUDGLFWLRQDYHFOHVYHUVHWVFODLUVFLWpVSUpFpGHPPHQWFHUWDLQVSDUPLOHVJUDQGV,PDPVO·RQW UpIXWp,EQXO4DVLPDGLW©-·DLHQWHQGX0DOLNHW(O/DWKGLUHjSURSRVGHODGLYHUJHQFHGHV RPSDJQRQVGX3URSKqWH6$:
  187. 187. ©FHQ·HVWSDVXQH©IDFLOLWpHWVRXSOHVVHªFRPPHOHGLVHQWOHV JHQVFHQ·HVWSDVGXWRXWFHODPDLVF·pWDLWSOXW{WMXVWHVVHRXHUUHXU ª ª (W$FKKDEDGLW©2QD SRVp OD TXHVWLRQ j 0DOLN j SURSRV G·XQH SHUVRQQH TXL HQWHQG GH OD SDUW G·XQH SHUVRQQH GH FRQILDQFHGHVSURSRVSRUWDQWVXUOHVMXJHPHQWVGHVRPSDJQRQVSHXWLOFKRLVLUjVRQDLVH@pWDQW GRQQpTXHF·HVWXQHIDFLOLWp,OUpSRQGLWQRQ3DU$OODK-XVTX·jFHTX·LOWURXYHODYpULWp/D YpULWp Q·HVW TX·XQH 'HX[ MXJHPHQWV RSSRVpV TXL VHUDLHQW MXVWHV WRXV GHX[ /D YpULWp HW OD MXVWHVVHVRQWXQLTXHV ª (O0X]QLGLVFLSOHGH6KDIL·LDGLW©/HVRPSDJQRQVGX3URSKqWHRQWGLYHUJpHWLODUULYDLW TX·LOVFRQVLGqUHQWTXHOHVDXWUHVV·pWDLHQWWURPSpV2UVLFKDFXQHGHOHXUVRSLQLRQVDYDLWpWpMXVWH 3RXUSOXVGHGpWDLOYRLU(O,KNDP IL8VRROLO$KNDP G·,EQ+D]P HW+XGMDWXOODKLO%DOLJKD GH'DKODZLRXVRQ HVVDLVXUFHVXMHW¶$TGXO'MLGIL$KNDPLO,GMWLKDGLZDW7DTOLG 9RLU)HLGKXO4DGLU GH(O0DQDZL9S
  188. 188. HW6LOVLODWXO$KDGLWKL(G'D·LIDWLZDO0DZGX·D 9S
  189. 189. ,EQ$EGLO%DUGDQV'MDPL·X%DDQLO¶,OP 9S
  190. 190. ,GHP9SHW
  191. 191. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP jOHXUVHX[LOVQHVHVHUDLHQWSDVFRPSRUWpVGHODVRUWH·HVWSRXUTXRL8PDU LEQXO.KDWWDE 4X·$OODKO·DJUpH
  192. 192. VHPLWHQFROqUHORUVTXH8EHLEQ.D·EHW,EQ0DV·XGGLYHUJqUHQWDXVXMHWGHOD SULqUHGDQVXQKDELWIDLWG·XQHVHXOHSLqFH8EHDIILUPDLWTXHF·pWDLWXQHEHOOHHWERQQHFKRVH DORUVTX·,EQ0DV·XGGLVDLWTXHFHODQ·pWDLWSHUPLVTXHORUVTXHOHVYrWHPHQWVPDQTXDLHQW8PDU VRUWLWDORUVHQFROqUHHQGLVDQWGHX[KRPPHVSDUPLOHVRPSDJQRQVGX3URSKqWH6$:
  193. 193. RQW GLYHUJpDORUVTXHF·HVWYHUVHX[TXHOHVUHJDUGVVHGLULJHQWHWG·HX[TXHOHVJHQVSUHQQHQWOHXU UHOLJLRQ« HSHQGDQW 8EH DYDLW UDLVRQ HW ,EQ 0DV·XG DYDLW WRUW 0DLV OD SURFKDLQH IRLV TXH M·HQWHQGVGHX[SHUVRQQHVGLYHUJHUjFHSURSRVTX·LOVV·DWWHQGHQWjFHTXHMHOHVFRUULJH ª /·,PDP (O0X]QL D DXVVL GLW © 1RXV GLVRQV j FHOXL TXL SHUPHW OD GLYHUJHQFH HW TXL SUpWHQGTXHVLGHX[VDYDQWVIRQWOHXUHIIRUWGHMXJHPHQWHWGHUHFKHUFKH,GMWLKDG
  194. 194. jSURSRVG·XQH TXHVWLRQTXHO·XQG·HX[GLVHF·HVWSHUPLVTXHO·DXWUHGLVHF·HVWLQWHUGLWDORUVFKDFXQG·HX[GDQV VRQ HIIRUW ,GMWLKDG
  195. 195. D WURXYp OD YpULWp QRXV OXL GLVRQV © 'LVWX FHOD HQ WH EDVDQW VXU XQ IRQGHPHQWGHODUHOLJLRQRXSDUDQDORJLH ª6·LOGLW© (QPHEDVDQWVXUXQIRQGHPHQWQRXVOXL UpSRQGRQV© RPPHQWWHEDVHVWXVXUXQIRQGHPHQWDORUVTXHFHOXLFLFjGOHRUDQ
  196. 196. UpIXWHOD GLYHUJHQFH ª 6L DORUV LO GLW © 3DU DQDORJLH QRXV OXL GLVRQV pWDQW GRQQp TXH OHV IRQGHPHQWV UpIXWHQW OD GLYHUJHQFH FRPPHQW WH VHUDLWLO SHUPLV G·XWLOLVHU XQH DQDORJLH SRXU DFFHSWHU OD GLYHUJHQFH ª$XFXQHSHUVRQQHGRXpHGHUDLVRQQHOHSHUPHWWUDLWTXHGLUHDORUVG·XQVDYDQW ª 0DLQWHQDQWVLXQHSHUVRQQHV·pFULHFHTXHWXDVGLWjSURSRVGHO·,PDP0DOLN²VXUOH IDLWTXHODYpULWpQ·HVWTX·XQHHWQHSHXWrWUHPXOWLSOH²FRQWUHGLWFHTXLHVWUHODWpGDQVOHOLYUH(O 0DGNKDOXO)LTKL 9 S
  197. 197. GX SURIHVVHXU =DUTD © /H FDOLIH $EX'MD·IDU(O0DQVXU HW VRQ VXFFHVVHXU +DUXQ (U5DFKLG HXUHQW OH JUDQG GpVLU GH FKRLVLU O·(FROH 0DOLNLWH HW OH OLYUH (O 0XZDWWD FRPPHORLMXULGLTXHGHODGQDVWLH$EEDVVLGH0DLV0DOLNOHOHXULQWHUGLWHQGLVDQW© /HV RPSDJQRQV GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  198. 198. RQW GLYHUJp j SURSRV GH OD MXULVSUXGHQFH HW VH VRQW pSDUSLOOpVGDQVOHVFRQWUpHVHWFKDFXQG·HX[DYDLWUDLVRQ ª ª -H UpSRQGV FHWWH KLVWRLUH HVW FRQQXH HW FpOqEUH j SURSRV GH O·,PDP 0DOLN TX·$OODK O·DJUpH
  199. 199. HSHQGDQWODGHUQLqUHSKUDVH©HWFKDFXQG·HX[DYDLWUDLVRQ ªIDLWSDUWLHGHVSDUROHV GRQWMHQ·DLMDPDLVWURXYpODVRXUFHGDQVDXFXQHGHV YHUVLRQV HW DXFXQ GHV OLYUHV TX·LO P·D pWp GRQQp GH UHQFRQWUHU VL FH Q·HVW XQH VHXOH YHUVLRQ UDSSRUWpH SDU$EX1X·DP GDQV(O+XOLD 9 S
  200. 200. DYHF XQH FKDvQH GH WUDQVPLVVLRQ FRPSRUWDQW (O0LTGDP LEQ 'DZXG TXH $GK 'KDKDELDFODVVpSDUPLOHVUDSSRUWHXUVIDLEOHV0DOJUpFHODFHWWHYHUVLRQFRPSRUWHODGHUQLqUH SKUDVHPDLVVRXVODIRUPH©HWFKDFXQG·HX[jVHV HX[DYDLWUDLVRQ ªHTXLSURXYHTXHOD YHUVLRQGH(O0DGNKDOXO)LTKL HVWYLFLpH(WFRPPHQWQHOHVHUDLWHOOHSDVDORUVTX·HOOHFRQWUHGLW FHTXLDpWpUDSSRUWpGHO·,PDP0DOLNSDUGHVUDSSRUWHXUVV€UVTXHODYpULWpQ·HVWTX·XQHHWQH SHXW rWUH PXOWLSOH FRPPH QRXV O·DYRQV PRQWUp DLQVL TXH OH GLVDLHQW OHV RPSDJQRQV OHV 6XLYDQWVOHVTXDWUH,PDPVHWOHVDXWUHV ,EQ $EGLO%DU D GLW 9 S
  201. 201. © 6L OD YpULWp SRXYDLW H[LVWHU GDQV GHX[ MXJHPHQWV FRQWUDGLFWRLUHV MDPDLV XQ RPSDJQRQ Q·DXUDLW FRQVLGpUp O·DXWUH FRPPH DDQW IDLW XQH HUUHXU GDQV VHV DYLV RX MXJHPHQWV(W OD UDLVRQ QRXV LQWHUGLW GH FURLUH TX·XQH FKRVH HW VRQ FRQWUDLUH SXLVVHQWrWUHMXVWHHQPrPHWHPSV(WTXHOOHMXVWHSDUROHTXHFHOOHGXSRqWHTXLV·pFULD $IILUPHUODFRH[LVWHQFHGHGHX[FRQWUDLUHVVRXVOHPrPHUDSSRUW ,GHP9S
  202. 202. ,GHP9S
  203. 203. 9RLU(O,QWLTD G ,EQ$EGLO%DUS
  204. 204. HW.DFKIXO0XJKHWWDIL6KDUKLO0XZDWWD S
  205. 205. G ,EQ$VDNLUHW7DGKNLUDW XO+XIIDGK GHO ,PDP'KDKDEL9S
  206. 206. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP (VWODFKRVHODSOXVVWXSLGHSDUPLOHVFKRVHVLPSRVVLEOHV© 0DLVTXHOTX·XQGLUDVLODSDUROHDWWULEXpHjO·,PDP0DOLNHVWHIIHFWLYHPHQWIDXVVHFRPPHQW H[SOLTXHU DORUV TX·LO DLW UHIXVp TXH OHV JHQV VH UDVVHPEOHQW GHUULqUH VRQ0XZDWWD SDU RUGUH GX FDOLIH(O0DQVXU -HUpSRQGVODPHLOOHXUHQDUUDWLRQTXHM·DLSXWURXYHUHVWFHOOHTX·,EQ.DWKLUDUDSSRUWpH GDQV6KDUKX.KWLVDUL¶8OXPLO+DGLWK S
  207. 207. QDUUDWLRQQRXVLQIRUPDQWTXHO·,PDP0DOLNDGRQQp ODUDLVRQVXLYDQWH©HUWDLQHVSHUVRQQHVRQWUDVVHPEOpHWSULVFRQQDLVVDQFHGHFKRVHVTXHQRXV Q·DYRQVSDVHXO·RFFDVLRQGHFRQQDvWUH ª(WFHODHVWXQHSUHXYHGHODSHUIHFWLRQGHVDVFLHQFHHW GHVDMXVWLFHFRPPHO·DGLW,EQ.DWKLU $LQVL GRQF WRXWH GLYHUJHQFH HVW XQ PDO HW QRQ XQHPLVpULFRUGH HSHQGDQW FHUWDLQHV GLYHUJHQFHV VRQW EOkPDEOHV FRPPH OD GLYHUJHQFH GHV IDQDWLTXHV GHV (FROHV HW G·DXWUHV VRQW SDUGRQQDEOHVFRPPHFHOOH GHVRPSDJQRQVHWGHV,PDPVDSUqV HX[«TX·$OODK QRXV DFFHSWH GDQV OHXUV UDQJV HW QRXV DLGH j OHV VXLYUH ,O DSSDUDvW GRQF FODLUHPHQW TXH OD GLYHUJHQFH GHV RPSDJQRQVHVWGLIIpUHQWHGHFHOOHGHVLPLWDWHXUVHWSRXUUpVXPHU /HVRPSDJQRQVRQWGLYHUJpSDUQpFHVVLWpPDLVLOVGpWHVWDLHQWODGLYHUJHQFHHWODIXDLHQW DXWDQWTXHSRVVLEOH4XDQWDX[LPLWDWHXUVPDOJUpODSRVVLELOLWpGHVHGpEDUUDVVHUGHVGLYHUJHQFHV GDQV XQH JUDQGHSDUWLH GHV TXHVWLRQV MXULGLTXHV LOV QH VHPHWWHQW SDV G·DFFRUG HW QH IRQW SDV O·HIIRUW SRXU HIIDFHU FHV GLYHUJHQFHV %LHQ SOXV LOV O·DSSURXYHQW 4XHO IRVVp HQWUH OHV GHX[ GLYHUJHQFHV« 9RLOjSRXUFHTXLHVWGHODFDXVH 'X SRLQW GH YXH GH OD FRQVpTXHQFH F·HVW HQFRUH SOXV FODLU DU OHV RPSDJQRQV PDOJUpOHXUVGLYHUJHQFHV FRQQXHV VXU OHV TXHVWLRQV MXULGLTXHVIDLVDLHQW WRXW OHXUSRVVLEOH SRXU VDXYHJDUGHUO·XQLRQHWO·HQWHQWHHWpWDLHQWWUqVpORLJQpVGHWRXWFHTXLSRXYDLWGLYLVHUOHVUDQJV $XVVLHQDYDLWLOSDUPLHX[TXLYRDLHQWOHFDUDFWqUHOpJLWLPHGHGLUHOD%HVPDOD·HVWOHIDLWGHGLUH %LVPLOOkKLU5DKPkQLU5DKvP@jYRL[KDXWHG·DXWUHVQHOHYRDLHQWSDVHUWDLQVG·HQWUHHX[pWDLHQW FRQYDLQFXV GX FDUDFWqUH UHFRPPDQGDEOH GH OHYHU OHV PDLQV SHQGDQW OD SULqUH G·DXWUHV QRQ HUWDLQVFURDLHQWHQO·DQQXODWLRQGHVDEOXWLRQVVLO·RQWRXFKHXQHIHPPHG·DXWUHVQHOHYRDLHQW SDVGHFHW±LO(WPDOJUpFHODLOVSULDLHQWWRXVGHUULqUHOHPrPH,PDPHWDXFXQG·HQWUHHX[QH UHIXVDLWGHSULHUGHUULqUH8QWHOFDULOQ·pWDLWSDVGHVRQDYLVVXUXQHTXHVWLRQMXULGLTXH 4XDQWDX[LPLWDWHXUVOHXUVGLYHUJHQFHVVRQWWRWDOHPHQWRSSRVpHVjFHOOHGHVRPSDJQRQV H TXL D HX SRXU FRQVpTXHQFH TXH OHV PXVXOPDQV RQW GLYHUJp VXU OH SOXV JUDQG SLOLHU DSUqV O·DWWHVWDWLRQGHIRLTX·HVWODSULqUH·HVWSRXUTXRLLOVUHIXVHQWGHSULHUWRXVHQVHPEOHGHUULqUHXQ VHXO,PDPjFDXVHGXIDLWTXHODSULqUHGHO·,PDPHVWDQQXOpHRXGpWHVWDEOHWRXWDXPRLQVDX[ HX[G·XQHSHUVRQQHG·XQHDXWUH(FROH«HWFHODQRXVO·DYRQVHQWHQGXHWYXFRPPHG·DXWUHVO·RQW YX0DLV FHOD Q·HVWSDV pWRQQDQW VDFKDQW TXH FHUWDLQV OLYUHV GH MXULVSUXGHQFH GHV (FROHV RQW PHQWLRQQpOHFDUDFWqUHQXORXGpWHVWDEOHGHODSULqUHGHUULqUHXQ,PDPG·XQHDXWUH(FROHFHTXLD HX SRXU FRQVpTXHQFH TXH WX WURXYHV TXDWUH 0LKUDEV GDQV XQH VHXOH PRVTXpH TXDWUH ,PDPV GLULJHDQWODPrPHSULqUHjWRXUGHU{OHHWTXHWXYRLHVGHVJHQVDWWHQGDQWOHXU,PDPSHQGDQWTXH O·DXWUHHVWGHERXWHQWUDLQGHSULHU 3LUHTXHFHODODGLYHUJHQFHHVWDUULYpHjXQGHJUpWHOFKH]FHUWDLQVLPLWDWHXUVTX·LOIXWXQ WHPSVROH+DQDILWHQHSRXYDLWVHPDULHUDYHFOD6KDIL·LWHMXVTX·jO·DUULYpHG·XQFpOqEUH+DQDILWH VXUQRPPp0XIWL7KDTDOHQ OH0XIWLGHV+RPPHVHWGHV'MLQQV
  208. 208. TXLDUHQGXOLFLWHOHGLWPDULDJH 9RLUOHFKDSLWUHGXOLYUH0D/DDGMX]X)LKLO.KLODI S
  209. 209. RSOXVLHXUVH[HPSOHVVRQWFLWpVTXHOTXHVXQV SDUPLHX[pPDQDQWGHFHUWDLQVVDYDQWVG (O$]KDU
  210. 210. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP FDUOD6KDIL·LWHSRXYDLWrWUH©FRPSDUpHjXQHIHPPHGHV*HQVGX/LYUH-XLIVHWKUpWLHQV
  211. 211. ª (W SDU FRQVpTXHQW LO Q·HVWSDV SHUPLV OH FRQWUDLUH j VDYRLU OHPDULDJH G·XQ 6KDIL·LWH DYHFXQH +DQDILWHGHODPrPHIDoRQTX·LOQ·HVWSDVSHUPLVjXQ-XLIRXKUpWLHQG·pSRXVHUXQHPXVXOPDQH HV GHX[ H[HPSOHV SDUPL WDQW G·DXWUHV FODULILHQW j WRXWH SHUVRQQH UDLVRQQDEOH OHV FRQVpTXHQFHV QpIDVWHV GH OD GLYHUJHQFH GHV FRQWHPSRUDLQV HW OHXU HQWrWHPHQW j VRQ VXMHW (Q UHYDQFKHFHOOHGHV$QFLHQV6DODI
  212. 212. Q·DYDLWDXFXQHPDXYDLVHLQIOXHQFHVXUODFRPPXQDXWp·HVW SRXUTXRLLOVVRQWORLQG·rWUHFRQFHUQpVSDUOHVYHUVHWVLQWHUGLVDQWODGLYHUJHQFHGDQVODUHOLJLRQj O·RSSRVpGHVFRQWHPSRUDLQVTX·$OODKQRXVJXLGHYHUVOHGURLWFKHPLQ 0DLVVLDXPRLQVOHPDOHQJHQGUpSDUOHXUGLYHUJHQFHV·pWDLWOLPLWpjOHXUPLOLHXHWQHV·pWDLW SDVWUDQVPLVDXGHOjGHODFRPPXQDXWpPXVXOPDQH«GDQVFHFDVOHSUREOqPHHQDXUDLWpWpDOOpJp HSHQGDQW²HWTXHOPDOKHXU²FHODV·HVWPrPHWUDQVPLVFKH]OHVPpFUpDQWVGDQVEHDXFRXSGH FRQWUpHVHWGHSDVFHTXLOHVDHPSrFKpVG·HQWUHUGDQVO·,VODP/·LOOXVWUHSURIHVVHXU0XKDPPDG (O*KD]DOLDGLWGDQVVRQOLYUH'KDODPXQPLQ(O*KHUE /·REVFXULWpGHO·2FFLGHQWS
  213. 213. © 8QHTXHVWLRQDpWpSRVpHORUVG·XQHFRQIpUHQFHRUJDQLVpHj%ULQVWRQDX[(WDWV8QLVTXHVWLRQTXL HVWVRXYHQWSRVpHGDQVOHPLOLHXGHVRULHQWDOLVWHVHWLVODPRORJXHVTXHOVVRQWOHVHQVHLJQHPHQWV TXHSURSRVHQWOHVPXVXOPDQVDXPRQGHDILQGHGpILQLUO·,VODPDXTXHOLOVDSSHOOHQW6RQWFHOHV HQVHLJQHPHQWVGHO·,VODPWHOVTXHOHVFRPSUHQQHQWOHV6XQQLWHV2XWHOVTXHOHVFRPSUHQQHQWOHV KLLWHV,PDPLWHVRX=HGLWHV7RXWHQVDFKDQWTXHFKDFXQGHFHVJURXSHVFRPSRUWHOXLPrPH GHV GLYLVLRQV (W LO VH SHXW TXH FHUWDLQV G·HQWUH HX[ DERUGHQW XQH TXHVWLRQ DYHF XQ HVSULW PRGHUQLVWH PDLV OLPLWp WDQGLV TXH G·DXWUHV O·DERUGHURQW DYHF XQ HVSULW WUDGLWLRQQHO HW VpYqUH 'DQVWRXVOHVFDVFHX[TXLDSSHOOHQWjO·,VODPODLVVHQWOHXUVDXGLWHXUVGDQVXQGpVDUURLWRWDOFDU LOVVRQWHX[PrPHVGDQVOHGpVDUURL ª 9RLU(O%DKUX5DLT 0DLV MH GLV DXMRXUG KXL OHV QRPEUHX[ GHUQLHUV pFULWV GH(O*KD]DOL ² FRPPH VRQ OLYUH TXL D pWp SXEOLp GHUQLqUHPHQWGRQWOHWLWUHHVW©/D7UDGLWLRQ3URSKpWLTXH6RXQQD
  214. 214. HQWUHOHV*HQVGX)LTKHWOHV*HQVGX+DGLWK ª RQUpYpOpTX LOIDLVDLWOXLDXVVLSDUWLHGHFHVJHQVTXLDSSHOOHQWjO ,VODPHW©TXLVRQWHX[PrPHGDQVOHGpVDUURL ª (WQRXVDYLRQVGpMjUHVVHQWLDXSDUDYDQW²jWUDYHUVTXHOTXHVXQHVGHVHVSDUROHVHWGHODGLVFXVVLRQTXHQRXVDYRQV HXGHFHUWDLQVGHVHVSRLQWVGHYXHGH)LTKDLQVLTX jWUDYHUVTXHOTXHVXQVGHVHVpFULWVHWRXYUDJHV²FHTXLUpYpODLW FHGpVDUURLVDGpYLDQFHGHOD6RXQQDVRQKDELWXGHGHSUHQGUHVDUDLVRQFRPPHMXJHjSURSRVGHO DXWKHQWLFLWpG XQ KDGLWKRXGHVDIDLEOHVVHFDUjFHVXMHWLOQHUHWRXUQHSDVjODVFLHQFHGXKDGLWKHWjVHVUqJOHVQLDX[FRQQDLVVHXUVHW VSpFLDOLVWHVGDQVFHGRPDLQHPDLVLODXWKHQWLILHSOXW{WFHTXLOXLSODvWPrPHVLOHKDGLWKHVWIDLEOH(WFHTXLQHOXL SODvWSDVLOOHFRQVLGqUHFRPPHIDLEOHPrPHV LOHVWDXWKHQWLTXHHWTXH%XNKDULHW0XVOLPVRQWXQDQLPHVOjGHVVXV RPPHWXYHUUDVFHODFODLUHPHQWGDQVVHVUHPDUTXHVjSURSRVGHO LQWURGXFWLRQTXHM DYDLVUpGLJpHHWLQWURGXLWHGDQV VRQOLYUH©RPSUpKHQVLRQGHOD9LHGX3URSKqWH)LTKXV6LUD
  215. 215. ªFRQFHUQDQWPRQDQDOVHGHVKDGLWKVTXHFHOLYUH FRQWLHQWGDQVVDTXDWULqPHpGLWLRQ(WFHODDpWpUpDOLVpjVDGHPDQGH²SDUO LQWHUPpGLDLUHG XQGHQRVIUqUHVGH( O $]KDU²FKRVHTXHMHPHVXLVHPSUHVVpG DFFRPSOLUFDUMHSHQVDLVHQFHWHPSVOjTXHFHODYHQDLWGHVRQLQWpUrWSRXU OD6RXQQD HW SRXU OD%LRJUDSKLH GX3URSKqWH HW GH VRQ HQJRXHPHQW SRXU VD SURWHFWLRQ GH WRXWH FKRVH OXL pWDQW pWUDQJqUH«(WELHQTX LODLWIDLWO pORJHGHPRQDQDOVHHWTX LODLWFODLUHPHQWGpFODUpVRQFRQWHQWHPHQWjFHSURSRV FRPPHRQOHYRLWGDQVVHVUHPDUTXHVGXOLYUHPHQWLRQQpFLGHVVXV²VRXVOHWLWUH©$SURSRVGHVKDGLWKVGHFHOLYUH ª LODWRXWGHPrPHFODULILpVDPpWKRGRORJLHTXDQWjVRQDFFHSWDWLRQGHVKDGLWKVIDLEOHVHWVRQUHMHW GHVKDGLWKV DXWKHQWLTXHV HQ VH FRQWHQWDQW G DQDOVHU SDU OD UDLVRQ VRQ FRQWHQX 3DU FHW DFWH LO IDLW UHVVHQWLU DX OHFWHXU TXH O DQDOVH VFLHQWLILTXH Q D DEVROXPHQW DXFXQH YDOHXU j VHV HX[ pWDQW GRQQp TXH FHWWH DQDOVH SHXW WRXMRXUV rWUH VXMHWWHjODFULWLTXHWKpRULTXHSHUVRQQHOOHTXLGLYHUJHJUDQGHPHQWG XQHSHUVRQQHjXQHDXWUHDUFHTXLSHXWrWUH DFFHSWpSDUO XQSHXWrWUHUHMHWpSDUO DXWUHHWYLFHYHUVD«(WF HVWDLQVLTXHODUHOLJLRQGHYLHQWVXLYLGHSDVVLRQVVDQV OLPLWHVHWVDQVUqJOHVVLFHQ HVWO REVHUYDWLRQSHUVRQQHOOH«FHTXLHVWFRQWUDGLFWRLUHDYHFODSRVLWLRQGHV6DYDQWVGH WRXW WHPSV VWLSXODQW OD FKDvQH GH WUDQVPLVVLRQ IDLW SDUWLH GH OD UHOLJLRQ KDvQH GH WUDQVPLVVLRQ VDQV ODTXHOOH Q LPSRUWHTXLDXUDLWSXGLUHFHTX LOYHXW«(WF HVWFHTXH(O*KD]DOL²TX $OODKOHJXLGH²DIDLWDYHFEHDXFRXSGHV KDGLWKVGHVD©%LRJUDSKLHGX3URSKqWHªDUELHQTX XQHJUDQGHSDUWLHGXFRQWHQXGHVRQOLYUHQHVRLW TXHGHV KDGLWKV0XUVDO KDvQH WURQTXpH DX QLYHDX GX7DEL L
  216. 216. HW0X GDO KDvQH GH WUDQVPLVVLRQ j ODTXHOOH LO PDQTXH PDLOORQVG DIILOp
  217. 217. HWTX XQHSDUWLHGHVKDGLWKVTXLRQWXQHFKDvQHGHWUDQVPLVVLRQFRQWLQXHVRQWIDLEOHV²FRPPHRQ YRLWFHODFODLUHPHQWjWUDYHUVPRQDQDOVH²PDOJUpWRXWFHODOHYRLFLTXLRVHV HQRUJXHLOOLUVRXV OHWLWUHSUpFLWpHQ GLVDQW
  218. 218. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP 'H PrPH RQ WURXYH GDQV O·LQWURGXFWLRQ DX OLYUH +DGLLDWXV6XOWDQH LOD PXVOLPL ELODGLO -DEDQH GXJUDQG6DYDQW0XKDPPDG6XOWDQH(O0D·VXPL4X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  219. 219. FHTXL VXLW © 8QH TXHVWLRQP·DYDLW pWp SRVpH SDU OHV PXVXOPDQV GX -DSRQ RULJLQDLUH GH 7RNR HW 2VDND TXL HVWOD VXLYDQWH TX·HVWFH TX·HQ UpDOLWpTXH OD UHOLJLRQPXVXOPDQH (W TXH VLJQLILH O·(FROH(VWLOQpFHVVDLUHSRXUXQHSHUVRQQHDDQWO·KRQQHXUGHGHYHQLUPXVXOPDQHGHVXLYUH XQHGHVTXDWUH(FROHV·HVWjGLUHG·rWUH0DOLNLWH+DQDILWH6KDIL·LWHRXDXWUHFKRVHRXQ·HVWFH SDV QpFHVVDLUH DU XQH JUDQGH GLVFRUGH HVW QpH DX -DSRQ HW XQH GLYLVLRQ DEMHFWH V·HVW GpYHORSSpHOHMRXURSOXVLHXUV-DSRQDLVjO·HVSULWRXYHUWRQWGpFLGpGHGHYHQLUPXVXOPDQVHWGH V·RUQHUGHODILHUWpGHODIRLGpFLVLRQTX·LOVRQWGpFODUpHjO·DVVRFLDWLRQPXVXOPDQHGH7RNRGRQW FHUWDLQV ,QGLHQV RQW GLW LO IDXW TX·LOV FKRLVLVVHQW O·(FROH GH O·,PDP $EX +DQLID FDU LO HVW OD OXPLqUHTXLJXLGHODFRPPXQDXWp0DLVGHV,QGRQpVLHQVUpWRUTXqUHQWLOIDXWTX·LOVVRLHQWWRXV 6KDIL·LWHV /RUVTXH FHV -DSRQDLV HQWHQGLUHQW FHV SDUROHV LOV V·HQ pWRQQqUHQW EHDXFRXS HW UHVWqUHQW GpVHPSDUpV«HWF·HVWDLQVLTXHODTXHVWLRQGHV(FROHVGHYLQWXQHEDUULqUHjOHXUFRQYHUVLRQ ª 7URLVLqPHIDX[DUJXPHQW HUWDLQVSUpWHQGHQWTXHQRWUHLQYLWDWLRQjVXLYUHOD6RXQQDHWjGpODLVVHUO·RSLQLRQ GHV ,PDPVHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFHOOHVLJQLILHOHGpODLVVHPHQWWRWDOGHOHXUVHQVHLJQHPHQWVHWGXSURILW TXHO·RQSHXWWLUHUGHOHXUVRSLQLRQVHWHIIRUWVG·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQ HjTXRLMHUpSRQGVULHQQHSHXWrWUHSOXVpORLJQpGHODGURLWXUHTXHFHWWHDOOpJDWLRQ (OOHHVWPrPHIDXVVH FODLUHPHQWIDXVVH FRPPH FHOD DSSDUDvW WUqV GLVWLQFWHPHQWGDQV OHV GLUHV SUpFpGHQWVTXLWpPRLJQHQWGXFRQWUDLUH (Q HIIHW QRWUH DSSHO FRQVLVWH VHXOHPHQW j QH SOXV FRQVLGpUHU OHV (FROHV FRPPH GHV UHOLJLRQVHWGHOHVpOHYHUDXQLYHDXGXRUDQHWGHOD6RXQQDjWHOSRLQWTXHF·HVWDX[RSLQLRQVGH FHV(FROHVTXHO·RQUHYLHQQHORUVTX·LODSSDUDvWXQSRLQWGHGpVDFFRUGRXSRXUGpGXLUHGHVUqJOHV LVVXHVGHVLWXDWLRQVQRXYHOOHVRXG·pYpQHPHQWVLPSUpYXVFRPPHOHIRQWOHVMXULVWHVDXMRXUG·KXL ·HVWDLQVLTX·LOVRQWLPSRVpGHQRXYHOOHVUqJOHVHQFHTXLFRQFHUQHODYLHVRFLDOHOHPDULDJHHWOH ©- DLIDLWPHVHIIRUWVSRXUVXLYUHODPpWKRGRORJLHFRUUHFWHHWSRXUPHEDVHUVXUOHVVRXUFHVUHVSHFWDEOHVHWMHSHQVH DYRLUHIIHFWXpjFHQLYHDXXQERQ WUDYDLO(WM DL UDVVHPEOpSDUPLOHVUpFLWVFHTXLSHUPHWWUDDXVDYDQWFODLUYRDQW G rWUHUDVVXUp ª 9RLOjFHTX LODGLW(WVLRQOXLDYDLWGHPDQGpVXUTXHOOHUqJOHW HVWXEDVpGDQVWHVHIIRUWV(VWFHOHVEDVHVGHOD VFLHQFHGXKDGLWK²TXLHVWODVHXOHYRLHSHUPHWWDQWGHFRQQDvWUHO DXWKHQWLTXHGHOD%LRJUDSKLHGX3URSKqWH²6D UpSRQVHQHSRXUUDLWrWUHTXHOHIDLWGHV rWUHDSSXpVXUVRQREVHUYDWLRQSHUVRQQHOOHPpWKRGHGRQWODIDXVVHWpDGpMj pWpGpPRQWUpH«(WODSUHXYHGHFHODHVWVRQDXWKHQWLILFDWLRQGHKDGLWKVGRQWODFKDvQHGHWUDQVPLVVLRQQ HVWSDV DXWKHQWLTXH HW VRQ UHMHW GHKDGLWKV GRQW OD FKDvQH GH WUDQVPLVVLRQ D pWp DXWKHQWLILpH SDU%XNKDUL HW0XVOLP HQ SHUVRQQH FKRVH TXH M DYDLV GpMjFODULILpH GDQV O LQWURGXFWLRQ FLWpH SOXV KDXW HW TX LO DYDLW LQVpUp DX GpEXW GH VRQ RXYUDJH©)LTKXV6LUD©4XDWULqPH(GLWLRQ
  220. 220. HWTX LODUHWLUp²KpODV²GHVpGLWLRQVVXLYDQWHVFRPPHO pGLWLRQGH 'DUXO4DODP j'DPDV HW G DXWUHV HQFRUH KRVH TXL D SRXVVpH FHUWDLQHV SHUVRQQHV j FURLUH TXH VD GHPDQGH SUpFLWpHQHYHQDLWSDVGHOXLVLFHQ HVWSRXUODGLIIXVLRQGHVRQOLYUHGDQVODPDVVHGHVOHFWHXUVTXLUHFRQQDLVVHQW O HIIRUWGHFHX[TXLVHUYHQWOD6RXQQDTXLODSURWqJHQWHWTXLGLIIpUHQFLHQWO DXWKHQWLTXHGXIDLEOHVHORQOHVUqJOHV VFLHQWLILTXHVHWQRQSDVVHORQOHVREVHUYDWLRQVSHUVRQQHOOHVHWOHVGLIIpUHQWHV SDVVLRQVFRPPHO D IDLW(O*KD]DOL TX $OODKOHJXLGHGDQVFHOLYUHHWGDQVVRQOLYUHSOXVUpFHQW©/D6RXQQD3URSKpWLTXHHQWUHOHVJHQVGX)LTKHWOHV JHQVGX+DGLWK ªjWUDYHUVOHTXHOLOHVWDSSDUXDX[JHQVFRPPHpWDQWGHPpWKRGRORJLHPX WD]LOLWHQ DDQWDXFXQ pJDUGHQYHUVOHVVDYDQWVGXKDGLWKVHWOHXUVHIIRUWVWLWDQHVTXHVWRXWDXORQJGHVDQQpHVSRXUVHUYLUOD6RXQQDHWSRXU GLIIpUHQFLHUO DXWKHQWLTXHGXIDLEOH'HODPrPHIDoRQLOQ DDXFXQpJDUGHQYHUVOHVHIIRUWVGHV-XULVWHV)XTDKD
  221. 221. SRXU PHWWUHHQSODFHFHVEDVHVHWOHXUVHPEUDQFKHPHQWVFDULOFKRLVLWFHOOHVTX LOYHXW HWGpODLVVHFHOOHV TX LOYHXW VDQV DXFXQOLHQDYHFXQHGHOHXUVEDVHVRXGHOHXUVHPEUDQFKHPHQWV(WEHDXFRXSSDUPLOHVJHQVGHOD6FLHQFHHWGX 0pULWHTX $OODKOHVUpFRPSHQVHOXLRQWUpSRQGXHWRQWFODLUHPHQWGpPRQWUpVRQGpVDUURLHWVDGpYLDWLRQHWSDUPL OHVPHLOOHXUHV UpSRQVHV TX LOP DLW pWp GRQQp GH OLUH VH WURXYH FHOOH GH QRWUH DPL OH'RFWHXU5DEL ,EQ +DGL (O 0DGNKDOLGDQVOHPDJD]LQHDIJKDQ©(O0XGMDKLG©Qƒj
  222. 222. DLQVLTXHOHSDPSKOHWGHQRWUHLOOXVWUHIUqUH6DOLK,EQ $EGHOD]L],EQ0XKDPPDGDDOL6KHLNKGRQWOHWLWUHHVW©(O0L LDU/L ,OPL(O*KD]DOL ª
  223. 223. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP GLYRUFH HW G·DXWUHV FKRVHV HQFRUH VDQV UHYHQLU SRXU FHOD DX RUDQ HW j OD 6RXQQD SRXU GLIIpUHQFLHUOHVUqJOHVMXVWHVGHVUqJOHVHUURQpHVHWOHYUDLGXIDX[«PDLVSOXW{WVHORQO·DGDJH© /D GLYHUJHQFH HVW XQH PLVpULFRUGHª (W DILQ GH UHFKHUFKHU OD IDFLOLWp HW OH ELHQIDLW FRPPH LOV OH SUpWHQGHQW0DLVTXHOOHEHOOHSDUROHTXHFHOOHGH6XOHPDQ(W7HwPLTX·$OODKO·DJUpH
  224. 224. ©6LWX UHFKHUFKHVOHVIDFLOLWpVGHFKDTXHVDYDQWWRXWOHPDOVHVHUDUDVVHPEOpHQWRL ªUDSSRUWpSDU,EQ $EGLO%DU9S
  225. 225. TXLDGLWjFHSURSRV©HFLHVWXQFRQVHQVXVjSURSRVGXTXHOMHQH FRQQDLVDXFXQHGLYHUJHQFH ª (WF·HVWFHODTXHQRXVGpQLJURQVHQDFFRUGDYHFOHFRQVHQVXVGHVVDYDQWVFRPPHWXSHX[ OHYRLU 3DUFRQWUHOHIDLWGHUHYHQLUjOHXUSDUROHVG·HQWLUHUSURILWGHV·HQDLGHUSRXUGpILQLUOD ERQQHRSLQLRQSDUPLOHVDYLVGDQVOHVTXHVWLRQVVXUOHVTXHOOHVLOQ·DSDVGHWH[WHGDQVOHRUDQ HWOD6RXQQDRXOHVSUREOqPHVFLWpVGDQVOHVWH[WHVPDLVTXLRQWEHVRLQG·pFODLUFLVVHPHQWFHODHVW XQHFKRVHTXHQRXVQHGpQLJURQVSDV$XFRQWUDLUHQRXVO·RUGRQQRQVHWLQFLWRQVjOHIDLUHFDUOH SURILWHQHVWHVSpUpSRXUWRXWHSHUVRQQHTXLSUHQGFRPPHPpWKRGHODYRLHGXRUDQHWGHOD 6RXQQD /·LOOXVWUHVDYDQW,EQ$EGLO%DUTX·$OODKO·DJUpH
  226. 226. DGLW9S
  227. 227. ©-HWHFRQVHLOOH{PRQIUqUHG·DSSUHQGUHOHVEDVHVHWGHW·HQSUpRFFXSHU(WVDFKHTXH WRXWHSHUVRQQHTXLVHSUpRFFXSHGHOD6RXQQDHWGHVUqJOHVFLWpHVGDQVOHRUDQTXLVFUXWHOHV DYLVGHVMXULVWHVTXLV·HQIDLWXQHDLGHGDQVVHVHIIRUWVG·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQXQHFOpSRXUOHVYRLHVGH O·REVHUYDWLRQ XQH H[SOLFDWLRQ SRXU O·HQVHPEOH GHV 6RXQQDV TXL SHXYHQW DFFHSWHU SOXVLHXUV LQWHUSUpWDWLRQVVDQVLPLWHUFHVMXULVWHVFRPPHRQLPLWHOD6RXQQDGX3URSKqWH6$:
  228. 228. jODTXHOOH RQGRLWVHVRXPHWWUHGDQVWRXWHVOHVVLWXDWLRQVHWVDQVDXFXQHFRQGLWLRQTXLQHV·HVWSDVUHSRVp VXU FH TXH OHV VDYDQWV RQW GpSHQVp FRPPH HIIRUWV GDQV OH EXW GH SURWpJHU OD 6RXQQD HW OD FRPSUHQGUH TXL D SULV FHV GHUQLHUV FRPPH H[HPSOH GDQV OD UHFKHUFKH OD FRPSUpKHQVLRQ HW O·REVHUYDWLRQTXLDUHFRQQXOHXUVHIIRUWVHWOHVHQDUHPHUFLpVXUFHTX·LOVRQWDSSRUWpHWHQVHLJQp TXLDIDLWO·pORJHGHODMXVWHVVHGHOHXUVRSLQLRQVTXLHVWPDMRULWDLUHVDQVSRXUDXWDQWOHVFRQVLGpUHU FRPPHLQIDLOOLEOHVGHODPrPHIDoRQTX·LOVQ·RQWSDVSUpWHQGXO·rWUHF·HVWFHOXLOjOHYUDLpWXGLDQW TXLV·DFFURFKHjODYRLHGHQRV3LHX[$QFrWUHV6DODIXV6DOLK
  229. 229. HWF·HVWOXLTXLDWWHLQGUDOHSOXVJUDQG ELHQ TXL YLVH OD JXLGpH TXL VXLW OD 6RXQQD GX 3URSKqWH 6$:
  230. 230. HW OD YRLH GHV RPSDJQRQV TX·$OODKOHVDJUpH (QUHYDQFKHFHOXLTXLV·pORLJQHGHODUHFKHUFKHTXLGpODLVVHFHTXHQRXV DYRQV GLW SOXV KDXWTXLUHMHWWHOD6RXQQDSRXUVDUDLVRQTXLDEDQGRQQHODUHFKHUFKHSURIRQGHjVRQVXMHWOH YRLOjO·pJDUpHWO·pJDUHXU0DLVOHSLUHHVWHQFRUHFHOXLTXLLJQRUHWRXWFHODHWTXLRVHV·HQJDJHU GDQVODIDWZD«LOHVWFHUWHVHQFRUHSOXVDYHXJOHHWSOXVpJDUpHQFRUHª 9RLOjODYpULWpLOQ·DSDVGHGRXWH 1HSUHQGVSDVOHVVHQWLHUVPDLVSUHQGVSOXW{WODURXWH 4XDWULqPHIDX[DUJXPHQW ,ODXQHDXWUHDOOpJDWLRQFKH]FHUWDLQVLPLWDWHXUVTXLOHVHPSrFKHGH VXLYUH OD 6RXQQD ORUVTX·LOOHXUHVWDSSDUXTXHOHV(FROHV-XULGLTXHVOD FRQWUHGLVHQW LOV SUpWHQGHQW TXH VXLYUH OD 6RXQQDDSRXUFRQVpTXHQFHQpFHVVDLUHOHIDLWGHFRQVLGpUHUOHV,PDPVGDQVO·HUUHXUFHTXLHVW XQHJUDYHLQVXOWHjOHXUVHX[(WpWDQWGRQQpTX·LQVXOWHUXQPXVXOPDQRUGLQDLUHHVWLQWHUGLWTXH GLUHG·XQJUDQGVDYDQW
  231. 231. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP /D UpSRQVH HVW OD VXLYDQWH FHWWHDOOpJDWLRQ HVWIDXVVH HW HOOH HVW GXH DXPDQTXH GH FRQQDLVVDQFH HW GH FRPSUpKHQVLRQ UDLVRQQDEOH GH OD 6RXQQD 6LQRQ FRPPHQW XQ PXVXOPDQ SRXUUDLWLOGLUHFHOD$ORUVTXHOH3URSKqWH6$:
  232. 232. DGLW©/RUVTX·XQHSHUVRQQHG·DXWRULWp6DYDQWRX JRXYHUQHXU
  233. 233. IDLWXQHIIRUWGHUHFKHUFKHpPHWXQDYLVHWTX·LOWURXYHMXVWHLODXUDGHX[UpFRPSHQVHV6·LOVHWURPSHLO Q·HQDXUDTX·XQH ª HKDGLWKUHMHWWHGRQFO·DOOpJDWLRQSUpFpGHQWHHWQRXVPRQWUHFODLUHPHQWTXH ORUVTXHO·RQGLW©8QWHOV·HVWWURPSp ªFHODVLJQLILH©8QWHODpWpUpFRPSHQVpXQHIRLV ª6L GRQFDX[HX[GHFHOXLTXLOHVFRQVLGqUHV·rWUHWURPSpVFHV,PDPVVRQWUpFRPSHQVpVFRPPHQW SHXWRQFRQVLGpUHUTXHF·HVWXQHLQVXOWHjOHXUpJDUG,OQ·DSDVGHGRXWHTXHFHWWHSHQVpHHVW IDXVVHHWTXHWRXWHSHUVRQQHO·DDQWDFFHSWpHGRLWV·HQpORLJQHUDUVLQRQF·HVWOXLTXLLQVXOWHOHV PXVXOPDQV1RQSDVXQEDQDOPXVXOPDQPDLVOHVSOXVJUDQGV,PDPVSDUPLOHVRPSDJQRQVOHV 6XLYDQWVOHVTXDWUH,PDPVHWOHVDXWUHVDUQRXVVDYRQVDYHFFHUWLWXGHTXHFHUWDLQVSDUPLHX[ FRQVLGpUDLHQWOHVDXWUHVV·rWUHWURPSpVGDQVWHOOHRXWHOOHTXHVWLRQHWYLFHYHUVDGHPrPHTX·LOV UHMHWDLHQWO·RSLQLRQGHO·DXWUH8QHSHUVRQQHUDLVRQQDEOHSHXWHOOHVHSHUPHWWUHGHGLUHTXHFHV ,PDPVV·LQVXOWDLHQWPXWXHOOHPHQW,OHVWPrPHUDSSRUWpGHVRXUFHDXWKHQWLTXHTXHOH3URSKqWH 6$:
  234. 234. DYDLWFRQVLGpUp$EX%DNUrWUHGDQVO·HUUHXUTXDQGFHOXLFLWHQWDG·LQWHUSUpWHUOHUrYHG·XQ DXWUH/H3URSKqWH 6$:
  235. 235. OXL GLW DORUV ©7X DV YX MXVWH GDQV FHUWDLQHV FKRVHV PDLV W·HV WURPSp GDQV G·DXWUHV ª 'RLWRQDORUVFRQVLGpUHUTXHOH3URSKqWH6$:
  236. 236. DLQVXOWp$EX%DNU (WSDUPLOHVFRQVpTXHQFHVpWRQQDQWHVGHFHWWHSHQVpHVXUFHX[TXLO·DGRSWHQWOHVYRLOj TXLGpYLHQWGHO·DSSOLFDWLRQGHOD6RXQQDHQGpVDFFRUGDYHFOHXU(FROHDUOHIDLWGHVXLYUHFHWWH 6RXQQDVLJQLILHSRXUHX[LQVXOWHUO·,PDP3DUFRQWUHVXLYUHO·,PDPPrPHV·LOHVWHQGpVDFFRUG DYHFOD6RXQQDVLJQLILHVRQUHVSHFWHWVDYpQpUDWLRQ·HVWSRXUTXRLLOVLQVLVWHQWGDQVO·LPLWDWLRQ GHSHXUGHWRPEHUGDQVODGLIIDPDWLRQ 0DLVFHVSHUVRQQHVRQWRXEOLp²MHQHGLUDLVSDVRQWIDLWVHPEODQWG·RXEOLHU²TX·jFDXVH GHFHWWHSHQVpHLOVVRQWWRPEpVGDQVXQHFKRVHSOXVJUDYHHQFRUHTXHFHTX·LOVIXDLHQWDUVL TXHOTX·XQOHXUGLW© 6LOHIDLWGHVXLYUHHVWXQHSUHXYHGHUHVSHFWSRXUFHOXLTXHO·RQVXLWHWVLOH IDLWGHQHSDVOHVXLYUHHVWXQHLQVXOWHjVRQpJDUGFRPPHQWYRXVSHUPHWWH]YRXVGRQFGHQHSDV VXLYUHOH3URSKqWH6$:
  237. 237. SRXUVXLYUHO·,PDPGHYRWUH(FROH ORUVTXH VRQ RSLQLRQ FRQWUHGLW OD 6RXQQD$ORUVTXHFHW,PDPQ·HVWSDVLQIDLOOLEOHFRQWUDLUHPHQWDX3URSKqWH6$:
  238. 238. @HWTXHO·LQVXOWHU Q·HVWSDVXQHSUHXYHGHPpFUpDQFHFRQWUDLUHPHQWDXIDLWG·LQVXOWHUOH3URSKqWH6$:
  239. 239. @6LDORUVjYRV HX[QHSDVVXLYUHO·,PDPHVWXQHLQVXOWHSRXUOXLHWELHQOHIDLWGHQHSDVVXLYUHOH3URSKqWH 6$:
  240. 240. HVWXQHLQVXOWHHQFRUHSOXVJUDQGHjVRQpJDUG3LUHF·HVWODPpFUpDQFHPrPHTX·$OODK QRXVHQSURWqJH ª $LQVLVLTXHOTX·XQOHXUDYDQFHFHVDUJXPHQWVLOVQHSRXUURQWOXLUpSRQGUHVLFHQ·HVWSDU XQHSDUROHTXHQRXVQHFHVVRQVG·HQWHQGUHGHODSDUWGHFHUWDLQVG·HQWUHHX[TXLHVWODVXLYDQWH © 1RXVDYRQVGpODLVVpOD6RXQQDSDUFHTXHQRXVDYRQVWRWDOHPHQWFRQILDQFHHQO·,PDPGHQRWUH (FROHHWTX·LOFRQQDvWPLHX[OD6RXQQDTXHQRXV ª 1RWUH UpSRQVH j FHWWH SDUROH SHXW SUHQGUH GLIIpUHQWHV IRUPHV TXL VHUDLHQW ORQJXHV j H[SOLFLWHU GDQV FHWWH LQWURGXFWLRQ ·HVW SRXUTXRL MHPH FRQWHQWHUDL G·XQH VHXOH TXL VHUD XQH UpSRQVHVDQVDSSHOSDUODYRORQWpG·$OODK ,OQ·DSDVTXHO·,PDPGHYRWUH(FROHTXLFRQQDvWPLHX[OD6RXQQDTXHYRXV,OHQDGHV GL]DLQHVGHVFHQWDLQHVPrPH6LDORUVXQKDGLWKDXWKHQWLTXHYLHQWFRQWUHGLUHO·RSLQLRQGHYRWUH ,PDP HW TX·XQ DXWUH,PDP DLW DGRSWp FH KDGLWK YRXV rWHV GRQF REOLJp G·DSSOLTXHU OH KDGLWK VLQRQYRXVVHULH]HQFRQWUDGLFWLRQDYHFYRVSURSRV(QHIIHWODSHUVRQQHDSSDUWHQDQWjO·(FROH GRQWO·,PDPDDGRSWpOHKDGLWKYDYRXVGLUH©-·DLDSSOLTXpFHKDGLWKFDUM·DLFRQILDQFHHQO·,PDP TXLO·DDGRSWp,OHVWGRQFQpFHVVDLUHGHVXLYUHFHW,PDPSOXW{WTXHOHY{WUHTXLDFRQWUHGLWOH KDGLWK ª(WFHODHVWFODLUHWpYLGHQWSRXUWRXWOHPRQGHVL$OODKOHYHXW 5DSSRUWpSDU%XNKkUvHW0XVOLP %XNKDULHW0XVOLP9RLUOHFRQWH[WHGXKDGLWKHWVRQDQDOVHGDQV6LOVLODWXO$KDGLWKLV6DKLKD Qƒ
  241. 241. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP 21/86,21 ·HVWSRXUTXRLMHPHSHUPHWVGHGLUH 1RWUH OLYUH 6LIDW 6DODW (Q1DEL RX'HVFULSWLRQ GH OD SULqUH GX 3URSKqWH@ pWDQW GRQQp TX·LO UDVVHPEOHGHV6RXQQDVDXWKHQWLTXHVDXVXMHWGHODIDoRQGHSULHUGX3URSKqWH6$:
  242. 242. LOQHUHVWH GRQFSOXVG·H[FXVHjSHUVRQQHGDQVOHIDLWGHQHSDVOHVDSSOLTXHUFDULOQ·HQDLWDXFXQHSDUPL HOOHVVXUOHVTXHOOHVLODXQDQLPLWpGHVVDYDQWVTXDQWjOHXUGpODLVVHPHQWORLQG·HX[FHWWHSHQVpH (QRXWUHLOQ·DSDVXQpOpPHQWGHFHOLYUHVDQVTX·XQHSDUWLHGHVVDYDQWVQHO·DLHDGRSWp(WFHX[ SDUPLHX[TXLQHO·RQWSDVDGRSWpVRQWH[FXVpVDXSUqVG·$OODKHWJUDWLILpVG·XQHVHXOHUpFRPSHQVH FDU OH KDGLWK QH OHXU HVW SDV SDUYHQX RX ELHQ OHXU HVW SDUYHQX PDLV VHORQ XQH FKDvQH GH WUDQVPLVVLRQVXUODTXHOOHRQQHSHXWVHEDVHURXSRXUWRXWDXWUHH[FXVHFRQQXHFKH]OHVVDYDQWV 4XDQWjFHX[SRXUTXLOHKDGLWKHVWDSSDUXrWUHDXWKHQWLTXHDSUqVOHXU,PDPLOVQ·RQWDXFXQH UDLVRQGHO·LPLWHU,OHVWSOXW{WREOLJDWRLUHSRXUHX[GHVXLYUHOHWH[WHLQIDLOOLEOHEXWGHWRXWHFHWWH LQWURGXFWLRQ(W$OODK6:7
  243. 243. GLW©2YRXVTXLDYH]FUX5pSRQGH]jO·DSSHOG·$OODKHWGH 6RQ 0HVVDJHU ORUVTX·LOV YRXV LQYLWH j FH TXL YRXV IDLW UHYLYUH (W VDFKH] TX·$OODK V·LQWHUSRVHHQWUHO·KRPPHHWVRQF±XUHWTXHF·HVWYHUV/XLTXHYRXVVHUH]UDVVHPEOpVª 6RXUDWHYHUVHW
  244. 244. (W$OODKGLWODYpULWpHWF·HVW/XLTXLJXLGHYHUVOHGURLWFKHPLQTXHOERQ0DvWUHHWTXHO ERQ 6HFRXUHXU4X·$OODK EpQLVVH0XKDPPDG DLQVL TXH VD )DPLOOH HW VHV RPSDJQRQV(W OD ORXDQJHHVWj$OODK6HLJQHXUGHV0RQGHV '$0$6OHGHO·+pJLUH-DQYLHU
  245. 245. 08+$00$'1$6,58'',1(/$/%$1,
  246. 246. 'RFXPHQWLVVXGXVLWH KWWSZZZVRXQQDFRP 6200$,5( ,7$7,216 '(648$75(,0µ06 /·,0$0$%Ô+$1Í)$+4X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  247. 247. /·,0$00$/,.,%1$1$64X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  248. 248. /·,0$06+$),·,4X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  249. 249. /·,0$0$+0$',%1+$1%$/4X·$OODKOXLIDVVHPLVpULFRUGH
  250. 250. 48(/48(6(;(03/(6'(6$9$176$$17'(/$,66(/ $9,6'( /(85(2/(328568,95(/$62811$ )$8;$5*80(176(75(3216(6 3UHPLHUIDX[DUJXPHQW 6HFRQGIDX[DUJXPHQW 7URLVLqPHIDX[DUJXPHQW 4XDWULqPHIDX[DUJXPHQW 21/86,21 6200$,5(

×